JONES v. SEABOARD COSTLINE RAILROAD et al

Filing 24

ORDER ADOPTING REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS. CSX TRANSPORTATIONS MOTION TO STRIKE REBUTTAL EXPERT (DOC. 23)IS GRANTED, ETC.. SIGNED BY HONORABLE EDUARDO C. ROBRENO ON 2/28/12. 3/1/12 ENTERED AND COPIES MAILED, E-MAILED.(rf, )

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA
IN RE: ASBESTOS PRODUCTS
LIABILITY LITIGATION (No. N)

Consolidated Under
MDL DOCKET NO. 875

BENJAMIN HILL CARTER, JR.

E.D. PA Civil Action No.
09-cv-74351 *

()~-~8\.p\.D\~~

v.

Transferor Court:
S.D. Georgia
91-00164

FffiERBOARD CORP., et al.

l
AND NOW, this

'J6'

ORDER
day of

~~ 01 11.1 , 2012, upon considemtion of

the pleadings and the record herein, and after review of the Report and Recommendation of M.
Faith Angell, United States Magistrate Judge, it is hereby ORDERED that:j
Defendant CSX Transportation's Motion to Strike the Rebuttal Expert
Report of Dr. James Millette [See Docket #23] is GRANTED. This
expert report fails to directly rebut the Defendant's experts and Plaintiffs
have presented no justification for a delayed expert report.

~(~ ~~ ~cd- Ju~ ~~IJ ~ tt~ ~J
12-sLc.QV\\~ erta6'V'. ·,\ ~~etlvi:.D rAni A~~'It is

BY THE COURT:

~~~/(~.....rUARDO C. ROB~

J.

*This ruling applies to all of the cases in which Dr. Millette has been offered as a "rebuttal"
expert as identified in Exhibit "A."

EXHffiiT"A"

Benjamin Hill Carter, Jr.
Bobby R. Carter, Sr.
Jesse Ralph Carter,
Orville Carter,
Elmon L. Courson,
Walter Lee Easton,
Robert C. Ellis,
Jack B. Howell,
Eddie Lamorris Hyers,
Warren Johnston, Jr.,
Henry H. Jones,
Ronald K. Regulas, Sr.
Raymond L. Rosenblatt,
George A. Shuman,
John M. Taylor,
Thomas Wilson,
Roscoe Wolfe,

2:09-cv-74351-ER
2:09-cv-92628-ER
2:09-cv-74410-ER
2:09-cv-74246-ER
2:09-cv-74337-ER
2:09-cv-74467-ER
2:09-cv-74484-ER
2:09-cv-92610-ER
2:09-cv-74245-ER
2:09-cv-92657-ER
2:09-cv-92661-ER
2:09-cv-92660-ER
2:09-cv-92640-ER
2:09-cv-92636-ER
2:09-cv-92637-ER
2:09-cv-92607-ER
2: 10-cv-60978-ER