G.S. et al v. PFIZER, INC. et al

Filing 9

MEMORANDUM AND/OR OPINION ORDER THAT DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO EXCLUDE THE TESTIMONY OF PLAINTIFFS' STEERING COMMITTEE EXPERT WITNESS NICHOLAS JEWELL, PH.D. IS GRANTED. SIGNED BY HONORABLE CYNTHIA M. RUFE ON 12/2/2015. 12/3/2015 ENTERED AND COPIES E-MAILED TO LIAISON COUNSEL. (SEE PAPER # 1520 IN 12-MD-2342) (ems)

Download PDF
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA : : : : : : THIS DOCUMENT APPLIES TO: : : See Appendix A : _________________________________________ : IN RE: ZOLOFT (SERTRALINE HYDROCLORIDE) PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION _________________________________________ MDL No. 2342 12-md-2342 ORDER AND NOW, this 2nd day of December 2015, upon consideration upon consideration of Defendants’ Motion to Exclude the Testimony of Plaintiffs’ Steering Committee Expert Witness Nicholas Jewell, Ph.D., and the briefs of the parties, and after a Daubert hearing at which testimony and evidence were presented in support of each position, and for the reasons set forth in the accompanying memorandum opinion, it is hereby ORDERED that the Motion is GRANTED. It is so ORDERED. BY THE COURT: /s/ Cynthia M. Rufe ___________________________________ CYNTHIA M. RUFE, J. Appendix A ,i',i ':,:i' ,, i ,' ,::: i' i i ~,', , , ';;i;~;:l::::~'/i,ii , {,iii:'"{ '( i , , ,,',<',,)111, ,, i',~,,:,~h 1. Adams v. Pfizer, Inc. 14-2247 2. Aleshire et al v. Pfizer Inc. et al. 13-2734 3. Allen v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-7375 4. Amadio v. Pfizer, Inc. 11-3973 5. Amons v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 13-2737 6. Anderson v. Pfizer Inc. 12-2126 7. Asboe v. WKH, et al. 12-2686 8. Ascherman v. Pfizer, Inc. 15-530 9. Asphall v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-4091 10. Ball-Andrews v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5118 11. Beverly v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5118 12. Leffv. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5118 13. Pallaria v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5118 14. Putman v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5118 15. Retzer v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5118 16. Root v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5118 17. Sturdivant v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5118 18. Farugia v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-3234 19. Farugia v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-3234 20. Honn v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-3234 21. Pardo v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-3234 22. Schedlbauer v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-3234 23. Thompson v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-3234 24. Barnes v. WKH, et al 12-213 25. Barnette v. Pfizer, Inc. 14-147 26. Bassett et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 13-6296 27. Bell v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-6252 3 I 28. Bell v. WKH, et al. 12-2754 29. Bell v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-716 30. Bellemore et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-1427 31. Bell-Rumora v. Pfizer Inc. 12-2444 32. Bennett et al v. Pfizer Inc. et al 13-7129 33. Berg v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 13-724 34. Bertelson v. Pfizer Inc. 13-7511 35. Bishop v. Pfizer Inc. et al. 13-5945 36. Bolton v. Pfizer Inc. 13-4806 37. Booker v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 13-2740 38. Boyd et al v. Pfizer Inc. et al 14-850 39. Branscome et al v. Pfizer Inc. et al. 14-620 40. Brodt v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-1883 41. Brodt v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-1882 42. Brooks v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-872 43. Brown v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-1329 44. Brownback v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-3339 45. Bryan v. Pfizer Inc. et al. 13-5587 46. Bufford v. Greenstone LLC, et al. 12-2336 47. Buley v. Pfizer Inc. 13-63 48. Buneta v. Pfizer, Inc. 14-279 49. Burnett v. Pfizer, Inc et al 14-2519 50. Burton v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-6770 51. Butterworth v. Pfizer Inc. et al. 13-5690 52. Byington v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-5435 53. Cable v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 13-4025 54. Caldwell v. Pfizer 15-1678 55. Caldwell v. Pfizer, Inc., et al 12-2557 56. Carr v. Pfizer Inc. et al 15-2655 4 57. Case v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-6552 58. Casi v. WKH, et al. 12-247 59. Castello v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 13-2741 60. Castillo v. WKH, et al 12-243 61. Chapman et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-743 62. Chapman v. Pfizer Inc. 13-4807 63. Chatman v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-225 64. Chew v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 13-2723 65. Cho v. Pfizer Inc. 12-6664 66. Christianson v. WKH, et al. 12-216 67. Chumley et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 13-6240 68. Ciccone v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-5952 69. Cipher v. Pfizer Inc. et al 14-5818 70. Clarizio v. Pfizer, Inc., et al 13-4106 71. Clark v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-1709 72. Cloin v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-2337 73. Cochran v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-900 74. Cochran v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-1861 75. Coffey et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 13-6353 76. Cokeley v. Pfizer, Inc. et al. 13-1166 77. Collins v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-3113 78. Combs v. Pfizer, Inc. 14-179 79. Cook v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-1794 80. Coon v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 12-4711 81. Coronado v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 14-2490 82. Crabtree v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-365 83. Craghead v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-594 84. Crawford v. Pfizer, Inc et al 14-5591 85. Crozier et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-906 5 86. D'Ambrosio v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-341 87. Davis et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 13-6132 88. Demartini et al v. Pfizer, Inc. 14-2204 89. Demedio v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-482 90. Dennison v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-593 91. Derome v. Pfizer Inc. 14-5590 92. DeShields v. Pfizer Inc. 13-7515 93. DeSimone v. Pfizer Inc., et al 12-2435 94. Diaz v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-2620 95. Becker v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5119 96. Currier v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5119 97. Dorste v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5119 98. George v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5119 99. Hardy v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5119 100. Hill v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5119 101. Martynuik v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5119 102. Paris v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5119 103. Doyle v. Pfizer, Inc 12-5371 104. Dragon v. Pfizer, Inc. 14-3114 105. DuBois v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-1224 106. Greene v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-6162 107. Hudson v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-6162 108. Leffv. Pfizer, Inc. 13-6162 109. Leslie v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-6162 110. Madewell v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-6162 111. Parkinson v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-6162 112. Patterson v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-6162 113. Pittman v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-6162 114. Dundas v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-3818 6 115. Dyer et al v. Pfizer Inc. et al 14-2342 116. Easley v. Pfizer Inc. 14-4482 117. Ebright v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-5678 118. Emlen v. WKH, et al 12-226 119. Ero! et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 13-6915 120. Estock v. Pfizer Inc. 12-6520 121. Falk v. WKH, et al. 12-2750 122. Favata v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 12-5622 123. Ferris v. Pfizer Inc. 13-3963 124. Fitts v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-3094 125. Flores v. Pfizer Inc. 13-2733 126. Floyd v. Pfizer Inc., et al 13-54 127. Franklin v. Pfizer Inc. 13-2274 128. Gallegos v. Pfizer,Inc. 13-1019 129. Gardner v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-4090 130. Gearhart v. Pfizer Inc., et al 13-158 131. Gibbs v. Pfizer Inc et al 14-2521 132. Gilcrest v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-1282 133. Gillette v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-6772 134. Gilmore v. Pfizer Inc. 13-2270 135. Godwin v. Pfizer Inc. et al 13-4602 136. Goulet v. Pfizer Inc., et al 12-2441 137. Graves v. pfizer, Inc. 13-1072 138. Gregory v. Pfizer Inc., et al 12-2436 139. Griggs v. Pfizer Inc. 13-2276 140. Grotelueschen v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 14-2284 141. Gully v. WKH, et al 12-255 142. Haddad v. Pfizer Inc. 14-5331 143. Hagar v. Pfizer, Inc. 14-1949 7 144. Hammons v. Pfizer Inc., et al 12-6770 145. Harbin v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 14-4204 146. Beilke v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5122 147. Cox v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5122 148. Grube v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5122 149. Hardin v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5122 150. Havens v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5122 151. Markle v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5122 152. Hardy v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 13-4234 153. Haring v. Pfizer, Inc., et al 12-3485 154. Harrelson et al v. Pfizer Inc. et al 15-227 155. Harris et al. v. Pfizer Inc. et al. 14-685 156. Harrison v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-2750 157. Harrison v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-6448 158. Hart v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-1184 159. Hartley v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-2796 160. Hauguel et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-849 161. Hawkins et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-913 162. Hay v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-1379 163. Hayes v. Pfizer, Inc., et al 12-232 164. Hays v. WKH, et al. 12-233 165. Heronimus v. Wyeth, Inc et al. 12-2654 166. Hill v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-3186 167. Holley v. Pfizer Inc.,et al. 13-2738 168. Hopkins v. Pfizer et al 12-2218 169. Howard v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 13-7602 170. Howard v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-136 171. Hubbard et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-720 172. Hux v. Pfizer Inc. et al 15-2653 8 173. Iwasyszyn v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-4656 174. J.G. v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 12-2793 175. J.M. et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 15-875 176. Jackson v. Pfizer, Inc, et al. 13-2739 177. Jackson v. Pfizer, Inc., et al 12-1547 178. Jacobson et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 13-6318 179. James v. Pfizer, Inc .., et al. 13-2736 180. Janssen v. Pfizer Inc. et al. 13-5943 181. Jay v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-4580 182. Jensen v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-282 183. Jimena v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-2935 184. Johns v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-3815 185. Johnson v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-1652 186. Johnson v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5779 187. Johnson v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-4786 188. Johnson v. Pfizer Inc. 13-7514 189. Johnson v. Pfizer Inc. 15-314 190. Johnston v. WMH, et al. 12-2684 191. Jones-Hawkins v. Pfizer Inc., et al 13-3233 192. Jones v. Pfizer, Inc. 14-280 193. Jones v. Pfizer, Inc. 14-281 194. Juarez v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-5124 195. Karg v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-446 196. Kercher v. Pfizer Inc. 13-2282 197. Keyser v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 13-981 198. Khampeth v. Pfizer Inc. et al 14-3364 199. Kinslow v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 13-901 200. Knight v. WKH, et al. 12-222 201. Kyle v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-1663 9 202. Lands v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-0719 203. Lane v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-3644 204. Daronco v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-4366 205. Malouin v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-4366 206. Leaders v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-7535 207. Leal v. Greenst. & Pfizer Inc. 13-2278 208. Lee et al v. Pfizer Inc. et al 14-745 209. Lehew v. Pfizer Inc. 13-2284 210. Lentz v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5121 211. Silva v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5121 212. Stephens-Grega! v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5121 213. Tinsley v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5121 214. Watts v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5121 215. Williamson v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5121 216. Leos et al. v. Pfizer Inc. et al. 14-605 217. Letizia-Reichley v. Pfizer Inc. 13-7525 218. Levada v. Pfizer Inc. 13-2285 219. Levitt v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 13-2717 220. Lewis v. Pfizer Inc. 12-2127 221. Lewis v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-6871 222. Lexa v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-1735 223. Lietdke-Hoar v. Pfizer, et al 13-2926 224. Lilly v. Pfizer, Inc., et al 14-2157 225. Little v. Pfizer,Inc., et al. 13-880 226. Logan v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-3603 227. Long v. WKH, et al. 12-2595 228. Long et al v. Pfizer, Inc. 14-3061 229. Long v. Pfizer Inc. 11-3198 230. Lowes v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 12-2437 10 231. Lund v. Pfizer Inc. et al 12-6549 232. M.K.K. v. WKH, Inc., et al. 13-4653 233. Madison v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-3097 234. Malacara v. Pfizer Inc., et al 13-2716 235. Malek v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 13-2197 236. Mallory v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-2318 237. Mangine v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-2720 238. Mapp v. WKH, et al. 12-235 239. Martin v. Pfizer Inc et al 14-2520 240. Martin v. Pfizer Inc. 12-652 241. McClendon v. Pfizer, Inc. 15-569 242. McFarland v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-2978 243. McGoun v. WKH, et al. 12-2683 244. McKee v. Pfizer Inc. et al 13-137 245. McMonagle v. Pfzier, Inc., et al. 13-877 246. McMonagle v. Pfzier, Inc., et al. 13-878 247. Mercier v. Pfizer, Inc. et al. 12-3685 248. Metcalfv. Pfizer Inc. 13-7521 249. Miller v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-1729 250. Miller v. Pfizer, Inc. 14-2802 251. Mills v. Greenstone, LLC 14-1538 252. Minichini et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 13-6491 253. Mirones v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 13-4798 254. Mitchell v. WKH, et al. 12-2688 255. Mitchell et al v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-2446 256. Moore v. Greenstone LLC 13-4176 257. Moore v. WKH, et al. 12-239 258. Moore v. Pfizer. Inc., et al. 13-4112 259. Moore v. WKH, et al. 12-2711 11 260. Muhammad v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-1921 261. Myers et al v. Pfizer Inc. et al 14-2341 262. N.A. v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 13-4365 263. Natola v. Pfizer Inc et al 14-2620 264. Nixon v. Pfizer Inc. et al 13-138 265. Nolan v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 12-6665 266. Noriega v. Pfizer, Inc., et. Al 12-2798 267. Orellana et al. v. Pfizer Inc. 14-337 268. Otts et al. v. Pfizer Inc. et al. 14-658 269. Paglia v. Pfizer, Inc. 15-2018 270. Paprocki v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5315 271. Parker v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-2447 272. Parsley v. WKH, et al 12-240 273. Patti v. WKH, et al. 12-2751 274. Paylor v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-4646 275. Pazzo v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 13-1362 276. Peska v. Pfizer Inc. 12-2129 277. Peterlinz v. Pfizer Inc. 13-7512 278. Peterson v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 13-53 279. Petrosky v. Pfizer Inc. 13-2281 280. Phelps v. Pfizer Inc. 12-2128 281. Phillips v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-0715 282. Posey v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-2280 283. Potts v. WKH, et al. 12-241 284. Prosser v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-3095 285. Puffer v. Pfizer Inc. et al 13-165 286. Pulcifer v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 13-2718 287. Ransdell v. Pfizer Inc. et al 14-5861 288. Ratliffv. Pfizer 13-4685 12 289. Rees v. Pfizer Inc. et al. 13-5944 290. Reese v. Pfizer, Inc 12-4215 291. Remsburg v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-5962 292. Richardson v. Pfizer Inc. et al 15-2654 293. Richburg-Rodriguez v. WKH et al. 12-245 294. Richmond v. Pfizer Inc. et al 15-1677 295. Ridler v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-3167 296. Riviera-Thuener v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-5010 297. Rogers v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-1651 298. Rogers v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 13-4490 299. Rorick v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-4089 300. Rosen v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-2794 301. Rosenberg v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-2288 302. Rosenkranz v. WKH, et al. 12-246 303. Rousseau v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 12-2440 304. Rowan v. WKH, et al. 12-248 305. Russo v. Pfizer Inc. et al 13-140 306. S.C.R. et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-2185 307. Saville v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 13-166 308. Schlomer et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-2798 309. Schroeder v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-342 310. Schulte v. WKH, et al. 12-2752 311. Schulze v. Pfizer, Inc. 14-284 312. Scordo v. Pfizer Inc. et al. 14-563 313. Seaton v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-4113 314. Sehorn v. Pfizer, Inc. 14-3702 315. Serrano v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-2909 316. Shannon et al v. Pfizer Inc. et al 14-1112 317. Silva v. Pfizer, Inc. et al. 13-2719 13 318. Simmons v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-817 319. Simpson v. WKH, et al. 12-2755 320. Slove v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-718 321. Smith v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-912 322. SRD et al v. Pfizer, Inc et al 15-1526 323. St. Pierre v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-6079 324. Starr v. Pfizer, In.c 13-1322 325. Stengrund v. Pfizer Inc. et al 14-2343 326. Stephens et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-1262 327. Stephens v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-2401 328. Stevens v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-2843 329. Stewart v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-2797 330. Stewart v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-4216 331. Stice v. Pfizer Inc. 13-7520 332. Sturman v. Pfizer Inc. 13-52 333. Swartz v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-308 334. Sweigart v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 15-261 335. Swift v. Pfizer Inc. 13-2976 336. Swindler v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 13-1287 337. Cameron v. Pfizer, Inc., et al 12-5123 338. Rutledge v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 12-5123 339. Teach v. Pfizer Inc., et a. 13-2724 340. Tebo v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-2292 341. Teed v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 13-139 342. Thomas v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-717 343. Thompson v. Pfizer Inc et al. 13-5727 344. Thompson et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-914 345. Thornton v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-4110 346. Tinsley v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-3953 14 347. Tipton et al v. Pfizer, Inc et al 14-3367 348. Tobben v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-2754 349. Torres et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 12-3484 350. Trejo v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-2730 351. Tunstall v. Pfizer, Inc. 14-3701 352. Turano v. Pfizer, Inc. 14-1907 353. Urban et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 13-6494 354. Vander Tuig v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 13-6238 355. Victor v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-3452 356. Victorian v. Pfizer Inc., et al 13-572 357. Villarreal v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-2747 358. Voeks, et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-1380 359. Walker v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 13-2732 360. Ward et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 13-6914 361. Wasiela et al v. Pfizer Inc. et al 14-811 362. Waters et al. v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-911 363. Weaver v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-3057 364. Webb-Dapron v. Pfizer, Inc. 14-5101 365. Webster v. Pfizer, Inc., et al. 13-2455 366. Weech v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 12-2439 367. Wellman v. Pfizer Inc. 13-2046 368. Wells v. WKH, et al. 12-2712 369. Wheeler v. Pfizer Inc. et al 13-141 370. Whiting v. Pfizer Inc. et al 14-2556 371. Wiebusch v. Pfizer Inc., et al 12-6712 372. Williams et al v. Pfizer, Inc. et al 14-910 373. Wills v. Pfizer Inc et al 15-391 374. Wilson v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-4088 375. Winningham v. WKH, et al 12-2710 15 376. Wolsey v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-5616 377. Wood v. Pfizer Inc., et al. 13-2729 378. Word v. Pfizer, Inc. 13-1270 379. Wurtz v. Pfizer Inc. et al 13-2727 380. Yocum v. Pfizer Inc. et al 13-2402 381. Young v. Pfizer Inc. et al 13-156 382. Young v. WKH, et al. 12-252 383. Zuwala v. Pfizer, Inc. 12-3096 16

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?