AGRE et al v. WOLF et al

Filing 210

FINAL JUDGMENT IS ENTERED IN FAVOR OF ALL DEFENDANTS AND AGAINST PLAINTIFFS. JUDGE BAYLSON HAS FILED A DISSENTING OPINION. SIGNED BY HONORABLE D. BROOKS SMITH ON 1/10/18. 1/10/18 ENTERED AND COPIES E-MAILED. (va, )

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA
LOUIS AGRE, et al.

CIVIL ACTION

v.

NO. 17-4392

THOMAS W. WOLF, Governor of the
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, JONATHAN
MARKS, Commissioner of the Pennsylvania
Bureau of Commissions, Elections and
Legislation, ROBERT TORRES, Acting
Secretary of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania,
JOSEPH B. SCARNATI, III, President Pro
Tempore of the Pennsylvania Senate, and
MICHAEL C. TURZAI, Speaker of the
Pennsylvania House of Representatives, in their
official capacities.
JUDGMENT
BEFORE: Smith, Chief Circuit Judge; Shwartz, Circuit Judge; Baylson, District Judge:
AND NOW this 10th day of January, 2018, based on the opinions of Chief Circuit Judge
Smith and Circuit Judge Shwartz, filed today, it is ORDERED
That FINAL JUDGMENT is entered in favor of all Defendants and against Plaintiffs.
Judge Baylson has filed a dissenting opinion.
BY THE COURT:

D. Brooks Smith
Chief United States Circuit Judge

O:\CIVIL 17\17-4392 Agre v Wolf\17cv4392 Judgment.docx