Griffin v. Beard et al

Filing 114

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER: (1) Pltfs mtn to compel discovery 109 is GRANTEDIN PART as follow:(a) Dfts shall provide Pltf a photocopy of the single page that he requested of his medical records provided that Pltf pays the sum of $1.33;(b) Pltfs mtn to compel discovery is DENIED in all other respects.(2)Pltfs mtn for sanctions and expenses 111 is DENIED.(3) Pltf shall refrain from filing any addit'l discovery mtns in this case, discovery is closed. Any additional mtns filed by Pltf will be handled sua sponte by the court, and Dfts need not respond unless ordered to do so.Signed by Honorable Sylvia H. Rambo on 7/31/09 (ma, )

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA BRIAN EDWARD GRIFFIN, Plaintiff v. JEFFREY BEARD; RAYMOND LAWLER; C. WAKEFIELD; and TIMOTHY YUTZY, Defendants : : : : CIVIL ACTION NO: 1:08-CV-1120 : : : : JUDGE SYLVIA H. RAMBO : : : : :

M EM O R A N D U M and O R D E R On July 29, 2009, Plaintiff filed yet another motion to compel discovery, (Doc. 109), as well as a separate motion for sanctions and expenses, (Doc. 111). Defendants filed a brief in opposition to these motions on July 30, 2009. (Doc. 112.) The gist of Plaintiff's motions--his seventh and eighth discovery motions filed in this case-- is that Defendants refuse to provide him a copy of one page of his medical records unless he pays the fee of $21.13. In their brief, Defendants state that they have a policy which implements a flat fee structure designed to cover overhead resulting from searching for and retrieving medical records plus a price/per page. Defendants flat fee is $19.80, and their price per page for the first 20 pages requested is $1.33. The court does not believe that a flat fee almost 7 times higher than the price per page is reasonable, and will not require Plaintiff to pay it. A fee of $1.33 per page more than adequately compensates Defendants for the overhead associated with the retrieval of medical records. In fact, it is more than double what this court charges per page for photocopies made by the clerk's office. See 28 U.S.C. 1914 note 4 (setting a rate of 50 cents per page

for photocopies). It is unreasonable for Plaintiff to have to pay $21.13 for one photocopy. Accordingly, it is HEREBY ORDERED THAT: (1) Plaintiff's motion to compel discovery (Doc. 109) is GRANTED IN PART as follow: (a) Defendants shall provide Plaintiff a photocopy of the single page that he requested of his medical records provided that Plaintiff pays the sum of $1.33; (b) Plaintiff's motion to compel discovery is DENIED in all other respects. (2)Plaintiff's motion for sanctions and expenses (Doc. 111) is DENIED. (3) Plaintiff shall refrain from filing any additional discovery motions in this case, discovery is closed. Any additional motions filed by Plaintiff will be handled sua sponte by the court, and Defendants need not respond unless ordered to do so. s/Sylvia H. Rambo United States District Judge Dated: July 31, 2009.

2