Barna v. Board of School Directors of the Panther Valley School District et al

Filing 96

ORDER 1. The Report and Recommendation (Doc. 66) is ADOPTED as modified in this Court's Memorandum Opinion; 2. The Motion for Summary Judgment of the Board of School Directors of the Panther Valley School District alkla Panther Valley Board of E ducation, Anthony DeMarco, David Hiles, William Hunsicker, Jeffrey Markovich, Koreen Nalesnik, Anthony Pondish and Donna Trimmel (Doc. 49) is GRANTED; 3. The Motion for Summary Judgment of Plaintiff, John Barna, (Doc. 77) is DENIED; 4. Judgment is HE REBY ENTERED IN FAVOR OF Defendants Board of School Directors of the Panther Valley School District a/k/a Panther Valley Board of Education, Anthony DeMarco, David Hiles, William Hunsicker, Jeffrey Markovich, Koreen Nalesnik, Anthony Pondish and Donna Trimmel, and AGAINST Plaintiff John Barna; and 5. The Clerk is directed to CLOSE this case.Signed by Honorable Robert D. Mariani on 11/6/15. (jfg)

THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA

JOHN BARNA,

Plaintiff,
v.

3:12·CV·638
(JUDGE MARIANI)

BOARD OF SCHOOL DIRECTORS
OF THE PANTHER VALLEY
SCHOOL DISTRICT, et al.,
Defendants.
ORDER

AND NOW, THIS

It~

DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2015, upon consideration of the

Motion for Summary Judgment of Defendants (Doc. 49), the Report and Recommendation
of Magistrate Judge Martin C. Carlson (Doc. 66), the objections thereto by Plaintiff John
Barna (Doc. 67), the Motion for Summary Judgment of Plaintiff (Doc. 77), and all
accompanying briefs and the oral argument of the parties, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED
THAT:
1. The Report and Recommendation (Doc. 66) is ADOPTED as modified in this Court's
Memorandum Opinion;
2. The Motion for Summary Judgment of the Board of School Directors of the Panther
Valley School District alkla Panther Valley Board of Education, Anthony DeMarco,
David Hiles, William Hunsicker, Jeffrey Markovich, Koreen Nalesnik, Anthony
Pondish and Donna Trimmel (Doc. 49) is GRANTED;

3. The Motion for Summary Judgment of Plaintiff, John Barna, (Doc. 77) is DENIED;
4. Judgment is HEREBY ENTERED IN FAVOR OF Defendants Board of School
Directors of the Panther Valley School District a/k/a Panther Valley Board of
Education, Anthony DeMarco, David Hiles, William Hunsicker, Jeffrey Markovich,
Koreen Nalesnik, Anthony Pondish and Donna Trimmel, and AGAINST Plaintiff John
Barna; and
5. The Clerk is directed to CLOSE this case.

2