Holbrook et al v. Jellen et al

Filing 69

ORDER (memorandum filed previously as separate docket entry). Upon consideration of the plaintiffs motion to compel discovery (Doc. 60) and after review of the parties submissions, it is hereby ORDERED as follows:1.The request of the defendant (Doc. 64) to vacate the order of May 5, 2015 is DENIED.2.The stay imposed on May 15, 2015 of the order dated May 5, 2015 (Doc. 62) is hereby LIFTED as to Request for Production Nos. 2, 8, 12, and 13; and Interrogatory Nos. 12, 28, and 37.3. The May 5, 201 5 order is STAYED as to Request for Production No. 10. The defendant shall provide the following documents to the court for an in camera review:a.November 17, 2009 email authored by former Assistant Counsel Dave Farney to Mailroom Supervisor at SCI- Laurel Highlands Gail Beers;b.May 19, 2010 email authored by former Assistant Counsel Dave Farney to Mailroom Supervisor SCI-Greensburg Kandace Gettins;c.April 22, 2011 email authored by former Assistant Counsel Dave Farney to Mailroom Supervisor Kim Ulisny and Institutional Business Manager Mike Spencer at SCI-Graterford;d.December 15, 2011 legal memorandum authored by Assistant Counsel Debra Sue Rand to the Dorina Varner at Central Office;e.January 19, 2012 email authored by Assistant Counsel Debra Sue Rand to Grievance Officer Leilani Sears (deceased) at Central Office;f.March 7, 2012 email authored by Deputy Chief Counsel Randall Sears to the Secretarys Office of Inmate Grievances and Appeals at Central Office; andg.July 26, 2012 legal memorandum authored by Assistant Counsel Debra Sue Rand to former Chief Counsel Suzanne N. Hueston on the subject of hate speech.4.In all other respects, the plaintiffs motion to compel discovery (Doc. 60) is GRANTED.5.All documents shall be inspecte d and/or produced and all answers to interrogatories shall be made within fourteen (14) days of the date of this order.6.The defendants shall provide those documents set forth in paragraph 3 of this order to the undersigned for an in camera review within fourteen (14) days of the date of this order.Signed by Magistrate Judge Joseph F. Saporito, Jr on 6/3/15. (ms)