Vnuk v. Berwick Hospital Company, LLC et al

Filing 46

ORDER THAT, pursuant to this Court's accompanying Memorandum Opinion: 1.Counsel for Defendant Berwick Hospital SHALL BE ENTITLED to view the notes that Attorney Barry Dyller showed to Plaintiff Angela Vnuk during Ms. Vnuk's February 24, 201 6 deposition. 2. Counsel for Berwick Hospital SHALL BE ENTITLED to inquire as to subject matter of communications between Ms. Vnuk and her counsel during her deposition testimony and during the recesses in her deposition. 3. Any speaking objections t hrough which counsel attempt to suggest the answer of a question to adeponent are PROHIBITED in this or any future deposition. 4. Defendant Berwick Hospital's request for $370 in attorneys' fees is DENIED.Signed by Honorable Robert D. Mariani on 3/2/16. (jfg)

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA

ANGELA VNUK,

Plaintiff,

v.

3:14·CV·01432
(JUDGE MARIANI)

BERWICK HOSPITAL CO. and
MALlYAKKAL J. JOHN,
Defendants.
ORDER
AND NOW, THIS 2ND DAY OF MARCH, 2016, upon consideration of the matters
raised in Attorney Sidney Steinberg's Letter of February 25,2016 (Doc. 42), IT IS HEREBY

ORDERED THAT, pursuant to this Court's accompanying Memorandum Opinion:
1. Counsel for Defendant Berwick Hospital SHALL BE ENTITLED to view the notes
that Attorney Barry Dyller showed to Plaintiff Angela Vnuk during Ms. Vnuk's
February 24, 2016 deposition.
2. Counsel for Berwick Hospital SHALL BE ENTITLED to inquire as to subject matter
of communications between Ms. Vnuk and her counsel during her deposition
testimony and during the recesses in her deposition.
3. Any speaking objections through which counsel attempt to suggest the answer of a
question to a deponent are PROHIBITED in this or any future deposition.
4. Defendant Berwick Hospital's request for $370 in attorneys' fees is DENIED.

2