UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH OF THE COMMONWEALTH SYSTEM OF HIGHER EDUCTION v. VARIAN MEDICAL SYSTEMS, INC.

Filing 746

Verdict Form for Invalidity Portion of Trial. All Objections thereto shall be filed by noon on 3-26-12. Any and all Objections must contain 2 parts (1) new objections (2) previous objections with cites to record. Signed by Judge Arthur J. Schwab on 3-21-12. (Moschetta, Nicole)

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA
UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH OF
THE COMMONWEALTH SYSTEM OF
HIGHER EDUCATION d/b/a
UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH
Plaintiff,
v.

VARIAN MEDICAL SYSTEMS, INC.
Defendant.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

Civil Action No.: 2:08-cv-01307
Judge Arthur J. Schwab

FILED ELECTRONICALLY

VERDICT FORM
Based on the evidence admitted at trial and in accordance with the instructions as given
by the Court, we, the jury, unanimously agree to the answers to the following questions:
1.

Has Varian proven by clear and convincing evidence that claims of the '554 patent

are invalid because they are anticipated? Answer separately as to each claim.
Claim 20

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 21

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 22

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 25

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 26

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 28

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 30

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 31

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 38

Yes ____ No ____

2.

Has Varian proven by clear and convincing evidence that claims of the '554 patent

are invalid because they are obvious? Answer separately as to each claim.
Claim 20

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 21

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 22

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 23

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 24

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 25

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 26

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 28

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 29

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 30

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 31

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 32

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 36

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 37

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 38

Yes ____ No ____

3.

Has Varian proven by clear and convincing evidence that claims of the '554 patent

are invalid because they are not enabled? Answer separately as to each claim.
Claim 20

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 21

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 22

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 23

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 24

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 25

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 26

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 28

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 29

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 30

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 31

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 32

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 36

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 37

Yes ____ No ____

Claim 38

Yes ____ No ____

You have now reached the end of the verdict form and should review it to ensure it
accurately reflects your unanimous determinations.
All jurors should then sign and date the verdict form in the spaces below and notify the
bailiff that you have reached a verdict.
The Foreperson should retain possession of the verdict form and bring it when the jury is
brought back into the courtroom.
X__________________________ , Foreperson
X___________________________
X___________________________
X___________________________
DATED: ______________, 2012

X___________________________
X___________________________
X___________________________