HAYWOOD v. THE UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH

Filing 37

ORDER granting in part and denying in part plaintiff's 31 Motion to Compel. Defendant may contact the court for clarification of the redaction instructions contained in the court's order. Signed by Judge Joy Flowers Conti on 8/28/12. (kjm)

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA

MICHAEL A. HAYWOOD,
Plaintiff,

v.
THE UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH,
Defendant.

) CIVIL ACTION NO. 11-1200
)
) JUDGE JOY FLOWERS CONTI
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

ORDER
IT IS ORDERED that based on the court’s in camera review of the documents at issue in
the Motion to Compel Responsive Documents Generated or Received by Jerome Cochran (the
“motion”) filed by plaintiff, Michael Haywood (“Haywood” or “plaintiff”), the motion is granted
in part and denied in part. (ECF No. 31.) Except for the documents found to be entirely
privileged, documents at issue in plaintiff’s motion should be produced by defendant, The
University of Pittsburgh (“defendant”), to plaintiff subject to the following redactions:
Bates Number
UPPRIV 01

Document
Handwritten notes

UPPRIV 02
UPPRIV 03

Handwritten notes
Handwritten notes

UPPRIV 04-39

12/15/10 Email from Richard Holmes
(“Holmes”) to Jerome Cochran
(“Cochran”)
1/1/11 Email from Ted Fritz (“Fritz”)
to Cochran

UPPRIV 40

Redactions
Redact lines 4, 5, and 6 of the
handwritten note.
The entire document is privileged.
Redact lines 2, 11, and 12 of the
handwritten note.
The entire document and its
attachment are privileged.
Redact the entire email message from
Fritz to Cochran.
Redact the second full sentence of the
email forwarded on 12/31/10.

Bates Number
UPPRIV 41
UPPRIV 42

Document
1/1/11 Email from Timothy R.
Delaney (“Delaney”) to Cochran
1/1/11 Email from Cochran to Mark
Nordenberg (“Nordenberg”)

UPPRIV 43-44

1/1/11 Email from Cochran to
Nordenberg

UPPRIV 45

1/3/11 Email from Cochran to Ernest
Borghetti (“Borghetti”)
1/3/11 Email from Cochran to
Borghetti

UPPRIV 46

UPPRIV 47-48

1/4/11 Email to Cochran from Laurie
Sallows (“Sallows”)

UPPRIV 49-51

1/4/11 Email and attachment from
Nordenberg to Steve Pederson
(“Pederson”), Cochran
1/4/11 Email from Cochran to
Nordenberg

UPPRIV 52-53

UPPRIV 54
UPPRIV 55-56

UPPRIV 57-59
UPPRIV 60-61

UPPRIV 62
UPPRIV 63-64
UPPRIV 65-66
UPPRIV 67-68
UPPRIV 69

1/4/11 Email from Pederson to
Nordenberg, Cochran
1/4/11 Email from Nordenberg to
Pederson, Cochran
1/4/11 Email from Holmes to
Cochran
1/7/11 Email from Reynolds Clark
(“Clark”) to Robert Hill (“Hill”),
Cochran
1/9/11 Email from Holmes to
Cochran
1/10/11 Email from Holmes to
Wendy Meyers (“Meyers”), Cochran
1/10/11 Email from Cochran to
Holmes, Meyers
1/10/11 Email from Holmes to
Meyers, Cochran
1/11/11 Email from Ronald Frisch
2

Redactions
The entire document is privileged.
Redact the text of the email
forwarded to Cochran from Delaney
on 1/1/11.
Redact the first two lines of text
under the heading of the email from
Cochran to Nordenberg and the
following lines up to the original
message on UPPRIV 43.
Redact the text of the email from
Borghetti to Cochran.
Redact the text of the email from
Cochran to Borghetti up to the
original message.
Redact the text of the email up to the
original message from Micki Bosko
(“Bosko”) on UPPRIV 48.

Redact the text of the email up to the
original message from Pederson on
UPPRIV 49.
Redact the text of the email up to the
message from Pederson on UPPRIV
52.
Redact the text of the email up to the
email from Pederson.
Redact the text of the email up to the
original message from Pederson on
UPPRIV 56.
The entire document is privileged.
Redact the text of the email up to the
message from Fedele on UPPRIV 61.
The entire document and its
attachment are privileged.
The entire document is privileged.
The entire document is privileged.
No redactions. This document should
be produced in its entirety.
The entire document is privileged.

Bates Number
UPPRIV 70-71
UPPRIV 72-73

UPPRIV 74-77

Document
(“Frisch”) to Holmes
1/12/11 Email from Sallows to
Richard, Keafer, Cochran, Holmes
1/12/11 Email from Richard to
Sallows, Yvonne Keafer (“Keafer”),
Cochran, Holmes
1/15/11 Email from Cochran to Fritz

Redactions
The entire document is privileged.
The entire document is privileged.

Redact the text of the email from
Cochran to Fritz up to the original
message.

By the court:
/s/ Joy Flowers Conti
Joy Flowers Conti
United States District Judge

3