MCCLATCHEY v. ASSOCIATED PRESS

Filing 40

NOTICE by VALENCIA M. MCCLATCHEY of Filing of Plaintiff's First Amended Trial Exhibit List (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A)(Hall, Douglas) Modified on 4/12/2007 (cen).

MCCLATCHEY v. ASSOCIATED PRESS

Doc. 40 Att. 1

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 1 of 24

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA VALENCIA M. MCCLATCHEY, ) ) Plaintiff, ) ) v. ) ) THE ASSOCIATED PRESS, ) ) Defendant. ) ________________________________)

Civil Action No. 05-00145J The Honorable Terence F. McVerry JURY TRIAL DEMANDED

PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST

EXHIBIT A

Dockets.Justia.com

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 2 of 24

Exhibit No. PTX 1 PTX 2 PTX 3 PTX 4 PTX 5 PTX 6 PTX 7 PTX 8 PTX 9 PTX 10 PTX 11 PTX 12 PTX 13 PTX 14 PTX 15 Complaint For Copyright Infringement

Description

Waiver of Service of Summons from Robert Penchina Defendant's Answer and Defenses Plaintiff's Rule 26(a)(1) Disclosures Rule 26(a)(1) Initial Disclosures of Defendant The Associated Press Fax Copy of Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's First Request for the Production of Documents Responses and Objections of Defendant The Associated Press to Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatories (Nos. 1-16) to Defendant Notice of Deposition of Individuals Charles Sheehan, George Galt, Gene Puskar, Jim Gerberich, David Ake Subpoena in a Civil case for Iphotoart Subpoena Served to the Washington Post Subpoena Served to America Online Subpoena Served to Chicago Tribune Responses and Objections of Defendant the Associated Press to the First Set of Requests for Admission by Plaintiff Valencia McClatchey Plaintiff's Response to Defendant's Requests for Admission Plaintiff's Objections and Responses to Defendant's Statement of Undisputed Material Facts

2

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 3 of 24

Exhibit No. PTX 16 PTX 17 PTX 18 PTX 19 PTX 20 PTX 21 PTX 22 PTX 23 PTX 24 PTX 25 PTX 26 PTX 27 PTX 28

Description Filed Copy of Plaintiff's Response to Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment and Declaration of Douglas M. Hall in Support Thereof Plaintiff's Statement of Undisputed Material Facts Memorandum Opinion and Order denying the Associated Press' Motion for summary Judgment Val McClathey's "Acquired Footage/Still Photograph License" Form (MC 00001 - MC 00002) January 14, 2005, Letter to Val McClatchey from Bruce (MC 00003 - MC 00004) June 19, 2002 Email from D. McCall to Val McClatchey re: End of Serenity photo (MC 00008) March 27, 2002 Email from Val McClatchey to John W. Harris re: "End of Serenity photo (MC 00009) November 26, 2001 Email from Val McClatchey to Kathy Jones re: Newsweek.com photo use confirmation (MC 00010) July 16, 2002 Email from Val McClatchey to Linda Carter re: Linda's request to use the photo (MC 00011) October 28, 2002 Email from Melissa Lata to Val McClatchey re: purchasing copies of the photo (MC 00012) October 27, 2002 Email from Dave and Paula to Val McClatchey re: photo questions (MC 00013) September 23, 2002 Email from Tom Miller to Val McClatchey re: requesting permission to use the photograph (MC 00014) September 11, 2002 Email from Val McClatchey to N. Nova re: use of photo (MC 00016 - MC 00017) 3

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 4 of 24

Exhibit No. PTX 29 PTX 30 PTX 31 PTX 32 PTX 33 PTX 34 PTX 35 PTX 36 PTX 37 PTX 38 PTX 39 PTX 40

Description Augu st 14, 2002 Email from Val McClatchey to Michael Mercanti of the Philadelphia Daily News requesting use of the photo - MC 00018) August 17, 2002 Email from Val McClatchey to Paul Ruggieri re: permission to use photo (MC 00019) July 26, 2002 Email from Val McClatchey to Vannary Lim re: permission to use photo (MC 00020) July 16, 2002 Email from Val McClatchey to Linda Carter re: permission to use photo (MC 00021) July 13, 2002 Email from Val McClatchey to Beverly Brannan re: usage of photo (MC 00022) October 10, 2001 Letter to Jessica Cooper from Val McClatchey re: documentary (MC 00024) CBS News License Agreement dated 10/9/01 signed only by Val McClatchen (MC 00025) CNN Productions, Inc. License Agreement dated 6/11/02 (MC 00026) May 16, 2005 Email from Laura Alper to Val McClatchey re: Towers Productions, Inc. (MC 00027) July 6, 2005 Email from Lance Hori to Val McClatchey re: photo request - National Geographic Channel (MC 00028 - MC 00029) June 29, 2005 Email from Lance Hori to Val McClatchey re: Inside 9/11 - National Geographic Channel (MC 00030 - MC 00031) July 6, 2005 Email from Lance Hori to Val McClatchey re: photo request - National Geographic Channel (MC 00032 - MC 00033)

4

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 5 of 24

Exhibit No. PTX 41 PTX 42 PTX 43 PTX 44 PTX 45

Description Towers Productions Letter of Agreement for Use of Footage/Still Images dated May 16, 2005 (MC 00034 - MC 00035) License Agreement dated June 25, 2002 between National Museum of American History and Val McClatchey (MC 00036) March 8, 2002 Email from Val McClatchey to Emilie Sommer re: photo request (MC 00037) Agreement with Freelance Contributors dated March 11, 2002 (MC 00038) October 9, 2001 Letter to Val McClatchey from Jessica Cooper of CBS News enclosing License Agreement dated October 9, 2001 between CBS News and Val McClatchey (MC 00039 - MC 00040) June 6, 2002 Email from Donna Forte to Val McClatchey (MC 00041) May 14, 2002 Email from Jeffrey Kellogg to Val McClatchey (MC 00042) May 20, 2002 Email from Jeffrey Kellog to Val McClatchey (MC 00043 - MC 00044) October 11, 2001 from Val McClatchey to pti (MC 00045) September 21, 2001 Email from Val McClatchey to pas (MC 00046) September 29, 2001 Email from Val McClatchey to cxe6 (MC 00047) November 24, 1001 Email from Kathy Jones to Val McClatchey (MC 00048) November 28, 2001 Email from Andrea Croner to Val McClatchey (MC 00049) November 30, 2001 Email from Susan McNaughton to Val McClatchey (MC 00053) November 24, 2001 Email from Kathy Jones to Val McClatchey (MC 00054)

PTX 46 PTX 47 PTX 48 PTX 49 PTX 50 PTX 51 PTX 52 PTX 53 PTX 54 PTX 55

5

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 6 of 24

Exhibit No. PTX 56 PTX 57 PTX 58 PTX 59 PTX 60 PTX 61 PTX 62 PTX 63 PTX 64 PTX 65 PTX 66 PTX 67 PTX 68 PTX 69 PTX 70 PTX 71

Description July 26, 2002 Email from Vannary Lim to Val McClatchen (MC 00055) July 26, 2002 Email from Vannary Lim to Val McClatchey (MC 00056) December 29, 2003 Letter to Photosearch, Inc. From Val McClatchey (MC 00057) November 28, 2001 Email from Val McClatchey to Mike Morlacci (MC 00058) April 19, 2005 Email from Caryn Collier to Val McClatchey (MC 00060) Decemb er 5, 2001 Invoice in the amount of $200 from Val McClatchey to Spiegel Verlag (MC 00061) March 11, 2002 Note and Invoice in the amount of $300 from Val McClatchey to Emilie Sommer (MC 00062) Letter from Val McClatchey to Olivier Picard requesting remittance of $450 (MC 00063) June 6, 2002 Email from Arash Ghadishah to Val McClatchey (MC 00064) August 19, 2003 Email from Derek Mitchell to Val McClatchey (MC 00065) August 19, 2003 Email from Val McClatchey to Derek Mitchell (MC 00066) November 14, 2001 Email from Val McClatchey to Carol Tataleba (MC 00067) June 26, 2005 Email from Deborah Anderson to Val McClatchen (MC 00074 - MC 00077) November 27, 2001 Email from Val McClatchey to Dave LaBelle (MC 00078 - MC 00080) December 27, 2004 Email from David Kaplan to Val McClatchey (MC 00083 - MC 00085) Certificate of Registration effective January 29, 2002 (MC 00150)

6

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 7 of 24

Exhibit No. PTX 72 PTX 73 PTX 74 PTX 75 PTX 76 PTX 77 PTX 78 PTX 79 PTX 80 PTX 81 PTX 82 PTX 83

Description December 17, 2002 Invoice from Sebdo - Le Point to Val McClatchey in the amount of $500 (MC 00151 - MC 00153) July 26, 2002 Email from Vannary Lim to Val McClatchey (MC 00155 - MC 00156) Note enclosing check for $100 for photo use from Federal Aviation Administration (MC 00166 MC 00167) July 26, 2002 Check Stub from The Reader's Digest Association Inc. in the amount of $500 (MC 00157 - MC 00158) October 25, 2001 Check Stub from CBS in the amount of $300 (MC 00159) December 29, 2003 Check Stub from Photosearch, Inc. in the amount of $350 (MC 00160) March 18, 2002 Check Stub from The Washington Post in the amount $300 (MC 00161 MC 00162) January 14, 2002 Letter to Val McClatchey from John Harris of the U.S. Department of Transportation (MC 00168 -MC 00170) November 29, 2001 Check Stub from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette in the amount of $50.00 (MC 00171 - MC 00172) October 3, 2002 Check Stub to Val McClatchey in the amount of $250 (MC 00173) Letter from Stoystown Lions Club to Val McClatchey thanking her for the gift of the Flight 93 Picture (MC 00174 - MC 00175) 8/22/02 Check Stub in the amount of $250 and letter to Val McClatchey from Shonda Clark of Breezewood PTO (MC 00178 - MC 00179)

7

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 8 of 24

Exhibit No. PTX 84 PTX 85 PTX 86 PTX 87 PTX 88 PTX 89 PTX 90 PTX 91 PTX 92 PTX 93 PTX 94 PTX 95 PTX 96

Description Letter to Val McClatchey from the Todd M. Beamer Foundation thanking her for $400 donation (MC 00180 - MC 00181) Letter to Val McClatchey from the Todd M. Beamer Foundation thanking her for $1,195 donation (MC 00182 - MC 00183) Purchase Order in the amount of $250 from Bookspan dated 7/11/02 (MC 00184) Check Stub from Philadelphia Newspapers, Inc. in the amount of $200 (MC 00185) Check Stub from U.S. News & World Report in the amount of $450 (MC 00188 - MC 00189) July 5, 2005 Email from Scot Smith to Val McClatchey (MC 00191 - MC 00193) October 21, 2003 Email from David Oberdick to Val McClatchen (MC 00197) April 17, 2002 Letter from Beverly W. Brannan of The Library of Congress to Val McClatchey (MC 00201) June 9, 2003 Letter from Lawrence Hyman of the Smithsonian Institution Traveling Exhibition Service (MC 00202) September 15, 2005 Letter from Edward Rendell of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Office of the Governor to Val McClatchen (MC 00203) Photo of President Bush and End of Serenity Photo (MC 00206) Advertisement of 9-11 Remembered... The Shanksville Story (MC 00208) Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Responds to September 11, 2001 Attack on America (MC 00209)

8

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 9 of 24

Exhibit No. PTX 97 PTX 98 PTX 99 PTX 100 PTX 101 PTX 102 PTX 103 PTX 104 PTX 105 PTX 106 PTX 107 PTX 108 PTX 109 PTX 110

Description August 27, 2002 Letter from Elizabeth A.C. Perry of the Smithsonian National Museum of American History to Val McClatchey (MC 00210) Article: Day to Remember from the Indiana Gazette showing picture of Val holding her photo (MC 00212) Article: Woman Receives Photo Award from the Daily America (MC 00213) Article: The Untold Story `Let's Roll' from Reader's Digest (MC 00219 - MC 00221) Photos: 2001: The Year in Photos showing President Bush, One of the Towers and Val's Photo (MC 00222) 12/9/02 Note to Val from Theresa Ambrose (MC 00226) Article: Three-Minute Discrepancy in Tape from the Philadelphia Daily News - September 16, 2002 (MC 00228) Article in German Publication showing Val's Picture (MC 00229) Smithsonian National Museum of American History Exhibit Brochure - September 11 Bearing Witness to History (MC 00230 - MC 00236) Copy of Val's Photo (MC 00237) Copy of Several Photo Credits including Val's Photo (MC 00238) Article published in Germany showing Val's Photo (MC 00240) Article published in German Magazine Focus showing Val's Photo (MC 00243 - MC 00245) Article: Photo Benefits Crash Victims published in Penn Lines January 2002 Magazine (MC 00248 - MC 00249) 9

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 10 of 24

Exhibit No. PTX 111 PTX 112 PTX 113 PTX 114 PTX 115 PTX 116 PTX 117 PTX 118 PTX 119 PTX 120 PTX 121 PTX 122 PTX 123 PTX 124

Description Article: The Story Behind the Photo published in Pennsylvania Township News January 2002 Magazine (MC 00250 - MC 00251) May 27, 2004 Letter from Anthony Laratonda to Val McClatchey (MC 00252 - MC 00254) Thank You Note from Der Spiegel The German News Magazine with article attached showing Val's Photo (MC 00257 - MC 00258) Article: Horror & Heros: What Really Happened on Flight 93 published in Newsweek (MC 00259 - MC 00269) Article published in a French Magazine (MC 00270 - MC 00273) Copy of Val's Photo published by the Washington Post Magazine (MC 00277) U.S. Department of Transportation Publication: 2001Criminal Acts Against Civil Aviation (MC 00282 - MC 00286) Article: At Pennsylvania's Ground Zero published by Time Magazine (MC 00287 - MC 00288) Certificate of Registration dated January 29, 2002 (MC 00289) January 22, 2004 Letter From Roxanne Esch of America Online to David G. Oberdick (MC 00291) December 12, 2003 Email from George Galt to David Oberdick (MC 00292) Associated Press Freelancer Agreement - unsigned (MC 00293 - MC ­294) Walk-In Photo Purchase Agreement - unsigned (MC 00295) March 8, 2002 Fax Cover Sheet from The Washington Post to Val McClatchey attaching Agreement With Freelance Contributors - signed by Val on 3/11/02 (MC 00296 - MC 00297) 10

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 11 of 24

Exhibit No. PTX 125

Description Screen Shot from the Associated Press Photo Services (MC 00302) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs (MC 00303) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - The Associated Press Collection (MC 00304) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - About the Photographs (MC 00305) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - iPhotoart (MC 00306) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - 60 images (MC 00307) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Ali Liston Photo (MC 00308) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - American League Poses Photo (MC 00309) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Armstrong and His Trumpet Photo (MC 00310) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Babe Ruth Photo (MC 00311) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Beatlemania Photo (MC 00312) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Beatlemania Photo (MC 00313) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Beatles Charity Show Rehearsal Photo (MC 00314) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Birmingham Protest Photo (MC 00315) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Bogart Becall London Photo (MC 00316) 11

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 12 of 24

Exhibit No.

Description Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Chapline the Kid Photo (MC 00317) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Charles Lindbergh Photo (MC 00318) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Churchill Inspects Ruins Photo (MC 00319) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Clay and the Beatles Photo (MC 00320) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Clay and the Beatles Photo (MC 00321) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Clay Liston Photo (MC 00322) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - 69 Images (MC 00323) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Destruction of Warsaw Photo (MC 00324 Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Dewey Defeats Truman Photo (MC 00325 Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Dimaggio Gehrig Photo (MC 00326) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Einstein Vacation Photo (MC 00327) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Elvis Presley Photo ((MC 00328) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Ed of WW II Photo (MC 00329) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Editioni Photographs - World Trade Center Crash (MC 00380) 12

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 13 of 24

Exhibit No.

Description Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - U.S. Presidential Debate Photo (MC 00409) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs- Vietnam Child Killed Photo (MC 00410) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Vietnam Napalm Photo (MC 00411) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Vietnam Released POW Photo (MC 00412) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - 33 Images (MC 00413) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Vietnam War Photo (MC 00414) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Winecoff Hotel Death Photo (MC 00415) Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - WWII Japanese Casualties Photo (MC 00416)

PTX 126 PTX 127 PTX 128 PTX 129 PTX 130 PTX 131 PTX 132

Screen Shot from the Associated Press Collection Limited Edition Photographs - Old Glory Goes Up on Mt. Suribachi, Iwo Jima Photo (MC 00392) Video Tapes and DVDs Associated Press Facts & Figures (MC 00422) Associated Press Photo & Graphics Services (MC 00424 - MC 00425) Associated Press World Photo Feeds (MC 00426 - MC 00427) Associated Press Digital Products & Services (MC 00428) Associated Press Launches New Unit Called AP Digital (MC 00429 - MC 00430) 13

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 14 of 24

Exhibit No. PTX 133 PTX 134 PTX 135 PTX 136 PTX 137 PTX 138 PTX 139 PTX 140 PTX 141 PTX 142 PTX 143 PTX 144 PTX 145 PTX 146 PTX 147 PTX 148

Description Associated Press - Frequently Asked Questions (MC 00431 0 MC 00433) Color Copies of Val's Photo Color Copy of Val's Photo MC 00434 Handwritten Notes (Bates MC 00435 - MC 00796) September 11, 2001 Email from Val McClatchey to Lisa Tristano attaching phot(MC 0079700798) February 27, 2006 Email from Val McClatchey to Lisa Tristano (MC 00799 - MC 00800) Flight 93 National Memorial Capital Campaign Literature (MC 00801 - MC 00812) AP's Policy on Electronic Handling of Photos (AP00178 - AP00183) Val's Photo (AP00192) AP Stylebook 2005 - AP Caption and NAA/IPTC Header Reference Guide (AP00042-AP00110) AP 1848 - 2005 Charter and Bylaws (AP00244-AP00259) AP Wide World Photos - News Photos and Graphics from The Associated Press (AP00007AP00041) AP Image showing Metadata - Val's Photo and all Information - it says "Do Not Use" at the top (AP00193) Article published by The Associated Press (AP00186-AP00187) Article published by The Associated Press (AP00188-AP00189) Article published by The Associated Press (AP00190-AP00191) 14

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 15 of 24

Exhibit No. PTX 149 PTX 150 PTX 151 PTX 152 PTX 153 PTX 154 PTX 155 PTX 156 PTX 157 PTX 158 PTX 158 (A) PTX 159 PTX 160 PTX 161 PTX 162

Description December 12, 2003 Email from George Galt to David Oberdick (AP00006) December 9, 2003 Email from David Oberdick to G. Galt (AP00005) AP Image Showing Metadata January 22, 2004 Letter from Roxanne Esch to David Oberdick (AP0001-AP0002) Photo Archive System - List of Users Who Downloaded the Image (AP00184-AP00185) Article: Woman Who Captured Flight 93 Image Struggles A Year Later published from The Progress dated September 12, 2002 (MC 00199) Article: Photo Brought Fame, Not Fortune For Woman published from The Tribune-Democrat, Johnstown, PA dated September 13, 2002 (MC 00198) October 21, 2003 Letter from David Oberdick to Jim Bramson (AP0002-A - AP0002-D) List of PhotoStream Users (AP00198-AP00225) AP PhotoStream Agreement (AP00226-AP00227) Media Liability Declarations (AP00433-AP00455) Media Liability Insurance Policy Declarations for Multimedia Companies (AP00456-AP00478) March 10, 2006 Letter from Robert Penchina to Kara Szpondowski re: AP's PhotoStream service December 1, 2005 Letter from Carmen Rivera to Douglas Hall enclosing documents produced in answer to our subpoena Deposition Transcript of James R. Gerberich - 1/19/06

15

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 16 of 24

Exhibit No. PTX 163 PTX 164 PTX 165 PTX 166 PTX 167 PTX 168 PTX 169 PTX 170 PTX 171 PTX 172

Description Exhibit 1 to James R. Gerberich Deposition 1/19/06 - Plaintiff's Notice of Deposition of Def. The Associated Press Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 30(b)(6) Exhibit 2 to James R. Gerberich Deposition 1/19/06 - AP00192 - End of Serenity Photo (AP00192) Exhibit 3 to James R. Gerberich Deposition 1/19/06 - Complaint for Copyright Infringement Exhibit 4 to James R. Gerberich Deposition 1/19/06 - Computer Print Out of Sept. 11 Flight 93 Image Exhibit 5 to James R. Gerberich Deposition 1/19/06 - Computer Print Out of Sept. 11 Flight 93 Image (AP00185) Exhibit 6 to James R. Gerberich Deposition 1/19/06 - Associated Press - Facts & Figures (MC 00417- MC 00428) Exhibit 7 to James R. Gerberich Deposition 1/19/06 - Associated Press - AP History/AP Corporate Archives (AP00111-AP00177) Exhibit 8 to James R. Gerberich Deposition 1/19/06 - Associated Press Limited Edition Photographic Prints (MC 00303 - MC 00416) Exhibit 9 to James R. Gerberich Deposition 1/19/06 - Responses and Objections of Def. The Associated Press to Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatories (Nos. 1-16) to Defendant Exhibit 10 to James R. Gerberich Deposition 1/19/06 - Article from: "Woman who captured Flight 93 image struggles a year later" published by The Progress in Pennsylvania on 9/12/02 (MC 00199) Exhibit 11 to James R. Gerberich Deposition 1/19/06 -Photo Archive System - List of Users Who Downloaded the Image: APA6430495 (AP00184) 16

PTX 173

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 17 of 24

Exhibit No. PTX 174 PTX 175 PTX 176 PTX 177 PTX 178 PTX 179 PTX 180 PTX 181 PTX 182 PTX 183 PTX 184 PTX 185 PTX 186

Description Exhibit 12 to James R. Gerberich Deposition 1/19/06 - List of Photo-Stream Users (AP00198AP225) Exhibit 13 to James R. Gerberich Deposition 1/19/06 - PhotoStream Subscribers Broadcast Department (AP00197) Exhibit 14 to James R. Gerberich Deposition 1/19/06 - Digital PhotoStream Subscribers (AP00194-AP00196) Exhibit 15 to James R. Gerberich Deposition 1/19/06 - AP PhotoStream Agreement (AP00226) Exhibit 16 to James R. Gerberich Deposition 1/19/06 - AP Stylebook 2005 - AP Staff Interface (AP00042-AP00110) Deposition Transcript of George Galt 1/19/06 Exhibit 17 to George Galt Deposition 1/19/06 - Rule 26(a)(1) Initial Disclosures of Defendant the Associated Press Exhibit 18 to George Galt Deposition 1/19/06 - Media Liability Declarations Exhibit 19 to George Galt Deposition 1/19/06 - Email From George Galt to David G. Oberdick dated 12/12/03 re: McClatchen - 9/11 Photo (MC 00292) Deposition Transcript of David Ake - 1/19/06 Exhibit 20 to David Ake Deposition 1/19/06 - Associated Press License to Distribute Photo For Publication (AP00090) Exhibit 21 to David Ake Deposition 1/19/06 - AP Photo Archive - Terms and Conditions of Use (AP00180 - AP00183) Exhibit 22 to David Ake Deposition 1/19/06 - AP Photo Archive (AP00059) 17

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 18 of 24

Exhibit No. PTX 187 PTX 188

Description Deposition Transcript of Charles Sheehan - 3/9/06 Exhibit 23 to Charles Sheehan Deposition 3/9/06 - Article: "Photo Brought Fame, Not Fortune For Woman" 9/13/02 published by The Tribune-Democrat, Johnstown, PA with handwritten note to Val (MC 00198) Exhibit 24 to Charles Sheehan Deposition 3/9/06 - "End of Serenity" Photo 9/11/01 (Valencia McClatchey, copyright 2002) - (MC 00434) Deposition Transcript of Gene J. Puskar - 3/15/06 Exhibit 25 to Gene J. Puskar Deposition 3/15/06 - "End of Serenity" Photo 9/11/01 (Valencia McClatchey, copyright 2002 - (MC 00434) Deposition Transcript of Valencia M. McClatchey - 3/14/06 Exhibit 1 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Article: Woman who captured Flight 93 image struggles a year later" published by The Progress in Pennsylvania - 9/12/02 Exhibit 2 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - 9/11 Remembered - The Shanksville Story - How a small town was changed forever published by The Tribune Democrat - 9/11/02 (MC 00274 MC 00276) Exhibit 3 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Article: Lives changed in countless ways published by the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review 3/10/06 Exhibit 4 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Email from Val McClatchey to Kathy Jones dated November 26, 2001, re: Newsweek.com photo use confirmation (MC 00010) Exhibit 5 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Email from Val McClatchey to H. Nova2 dated 8/13/02 re: Use of Photo (MC 00016 - MC 00017)

PTX 189 PTX 190 PTX 191 PTX 192 PTX 193 PTX 194

PTX 195 PTX 196 PTX 197

18

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 19 of 24

Exhibit No. PTX 198 PTX 199 PTX 200 PTX 201 PTX 202 PTX 203 PTX 204 PTX 205 PTX 206 PTX 207 PTX 208

Description Exhibit 6 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Email from Val McClatchey to Paul Ruggieri dated 8/17/02 re: Email address from Paul Ruggieri (MC 00019) Exhibit 7 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Email from Val McClatchey to Emilie Sommer dated 3/8/02 re: End of Serenity (MC 00037) Exhibit 8 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - The Washington Post Agreement with Freelance Contributors (MC 00038) Exhibit 9 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - "End of Serenity" Photo 9/11/01 (Valencia McClatchey, copyright 2002 Exhibit 10 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Email from Val McClatchey to pto dated 10/11/01 re: Flight 93 Photo (MC 00045) Exhibit 11 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Letter from Valencia McClatchey to Olivier Picard requesting remittance of $450 (MC 00063) Exhibit 12 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Envelope and check stub from U.S. News & World in the amount of $450 (MC 00188 - MC 00189) Exhibit 13 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Email from Val McClatchey to Derek Mitchell dated 8/19/03 re: copyright for photo: complete 9/11 timeline (MC 00066) Exhibit 14 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Email from Val McClatchey to Martin dated 11/28/01 re: End of Serenity Photo (MC 00068) Exhib it 15 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Email from Val McClatchey to Dave LaBelle dated 11/27/01 (MC 00078 - MC 00080) Exhibit 16 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Email from Vannary Lim to Val McClatchey dated 7/26/02 re: Shanksville (MC 00056) 19

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 20 of 24

Exhibit No. PTX 209 PTX 210 PTX 211 PTX 212 PTX 213 PTX 214

Description Exhibit 17 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Article from Monde (MC 00270 - MC 00273 Exhibit 18 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Article: Three-minute discrepancy in tape published by the Philadelphia Daily News - 9/16/02 (MC 00228) Exhibit 19 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Email from Key Stone Camaro Club re: Tri State Celebs Exhibit 20 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Email from Key Stone Camaro Club to Tri State Camaro dated 9/26/01 Exhibit 21 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Email from Key Stone Camaro Club to Tri State Camaro dated 10/10/01 Exhibit 22 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Letter from David G. Oberdick to Jim Bramson dated 10/21/03 re: Unauthorized Use of Copyrighted Work (AP 00002-A - AP 00002D) Exhibit 23 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Letter from Val McClatchey to Copyright Agent dated 1/ 8/05 (MC 00147) Exhibit 24 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Order screen for the "End of Serenity" Photo Exhibit 25 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Email from Val McClatchey to Mike Morlacci dated 11/28/01 re: End of Serenity Photo (MC 00058) Exhibit 26 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Email from R.G. Kozel to Stooge date: 3/26/05 re: AP Sued of Flight 93 Photo (MC 00194) Exhibit 27 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Screen Captures from Liberty Bound 20

PTX 215 PTX 216 PTX 217 PTX 218 PTX 219

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 21 of 24

Exhibit No. PTX 220 PTX 221 PTX 222 PTX 223 PTX 224 PTX 225 PTX 226 PTX 227 PTX 228 PTX 229 PTX 230 PTX 231 PTX 232 PTX 233 PTX 234 PTX 235

Description Exhibit 28 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Screen Captures - The Flight That Fought Back Exhibit 29 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Screen Captures from Windsor Park Stores - Shanksville Episodes Exhibit 30 to Valencia M. McClatchey Deposition 3/14/06 - Screen Capture Demonstrative re: Liability Demonstrative re: Liability Demonstrative re: Liability Demonstrative re: Liability Demonstrative re: Liability Demonstrative re: Liability Demonstrative re: Liability Demonstrative re: Liability Demonstrative re: Liability Demonstrative re: Liability Demonstrative re: Liability Demonstrative re: Liability Demonstrative re: Liability

21

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 22 of 24

Exhibit No. PTX 236 PTX 237 PTX 238 PTX 239 PTX 240 PTX 241 PTX 242 PTX 243 PTX 244 PTX 245 PTX 246 PTX 247 PTX 248 PTX 249 PTX 250 PTX 251 PTX 252 PTX 253 Demonstrative re: Liability Demonstrative re: Liability Demonstrative re: Liability Demonstrative re: Liability Demonstrative re: Liability Demonstrative re: Liability Demonstrative re: Liability Demonstrative re: Liability Demonstrative re: Damages Demonstrative re: Damages Demonstrative re: Damages Demonstrative re: Damages Demonstrative re: Damages Demonstrative re: Damages Demonstrative re: Damages Demonstrative re: Damages Demonstrative re: Damages Demonstrative re: Damages 22

Description

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 23 of 24

Exhibit No. PTX 254 PTX 255 PTX 256 PTX 257 PTX 258 PTX 259 PTX 260 PTX 261 PTX 262 Demonstrative re: Fair Use Demonstrative re: Fair Use Demonstrative re: Fair Use Demonstrative re: Fair Use Demonstrative re: Fair Use Demonstrative re: Fair Use Demonstrative re: Fair Use Demonstrative re: Fair Use Demonstrative re: Fair Use

Description

23

Case 3:05-cv-00145-TFM

Document 40-2

Filed 04/05/2007

Page 24 of 24

24