Doe v. Haley et al

Filing 203

ORDER granting 175 Motion to Approve Settlement as set out. Signed by Honorable G Ross Anderson, Jr on 3/10/14.(alew, )

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF SOUTH CAROLINA
ANDERSON/GREENWOOD DIVISION
John Doe, minor child, by and through
his Guardian, Jane Doe,
Plaintiff,
v.
Nikki Haley, et al.,
Defendants.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

C/A No.: 8:13-cv-01772-GRA

ORDER
(Written Opinion)

On February 2, 2014, Jane Doe filed a Petition to Approve a Minor Settlement,
asking this Court “to (1) appoint Jane Doe as John Doe’s guardian ad litem for
purposes of this settlement and (2) approve a settlement for John Doe, a minor child.”
ECF No. 175. This settlement would resolve all claims against Defendants Boys
Home of the South, Vernon Hayes, Nicole Lindsey, Cynthia Brock, Richelle Owens,
and Johnny Jones. Id. After carefully considering the filings and arguments by all
parties, this Court has concluded that Jane Doe should be appointed as John Doe’s
guardian ad litem for purposes of this settlement and the settlement should be
approved.
Standard of Review
S.C. Code Ann. § 62-5-433 provides the procedures for settlement of claims in
favor of minors. § 62-5-433(B)(1) states that settlement of any claim over twenty-five
thousand dollars in favor of a minor requires the petitioner to file with the court a
“verified petition setting forth all of the pertinent facts concerning the claim, payment,
attorney’s fees, and expenses, if any, and the reasons why, in the opinion of the

Page 1 of 4

petitioner, the proposed settlement should be approved.” S.C. Code Ann. § 62-5433(B)(1). The petitioner must also state in the verified petition that “in his opinion,
the proposed settlement is in the best interests of the minor.” Id. The court shall
issue an order approving the settlement if “the court concludes that the proposed
settlement is proper and in the best interests of the minor.” S.C. Code Ann. § 62-5433(B)(2). The court’s order “must require that payment or delivery of the money or
personal property be made through the conservator.”

S.C. Code Ann. § 62-5-

433(B)(3).
Appointment of Jane Doe as guardian ad litem for John Doe
The Petition to Approve a Minor Settlement seeks to appoint Jane Doe as
John Doe’s guardian ad litem for purposes of this settlement. ECF No. 175. Jane
Doe is John Doe’s maternal aunt and foster mother. Id. Jane Doe has had physical
custody of John Doe since March 28, 2012 pursuant to an Order by the Eighth
Judicial Circuit Family Court, stating that John Doe’s parents are not capable of
providing the requisite care and custody to the minor child. ECF Nos. 175 & 175-1.
In its Order, the Abbeville County Family Court found that Jane Doe should be
responsible for the care and custody of John Doe. ECF No. 175-1. This Court now
reaffirms that ruling for purposes of this settlement.
Approval of Settlement
The Petition to Approve a Minor Settlement seeks approval of a settlement for
John Doe, a minor child, against Defendants Boys Home of the South, Vernon
Hayes, Nicole Lindsey, Cynthia Brock, Richelle Owens, and Johnny Jones. ECF No.
175. Plaintiff and these six Defendants have reached an agreement to settle Count

Page 2 of 4

VI, gross negligence in failing to provide treatment under the South Carolina
Solicitation of Charitable Funds Act, and Count VIII, violation of Fourteenth
Amendment right to adequate care, and dismiss Count V, grossly negligent
supervision under the South Carolina Solicitation of Charitable Funds Act, and Count
VII, violation of Fourteenth Amendment right to a safe and secure placement. Id.
Plaintiff will also dismiss “any and all possible claims, suits, demands, or causes of
action against Defendants Boys Home of the South, Vernon Hayes, Nicole Lindsey,
Cynthia Brock, Richelle Owens, and Johnny Jones.” Id. “Plaintiff is proceeding,
however, on Counts I, II, III, and IV against [Defendants Department of Social
Service, Merry Eve Poole, Ursula Best, and Cassandra Daniels], under both state law
claims and federal 1983 claims.” Id.
This Court finds that the settlement of John Doe’s claims in the manner set
forth in the Petition to Approve a Minor Settlement is reasonable and appropriate and
in the best interests of the minor child. The set-off rights of non-settling parties are
not impacted by the terms and provisions of this Order. This Court will address the
issue of set-off after trial.
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Jane Doe is appointed as John Doe’s
guardian ad litem for purposes of this settlement, and the proposed settlement is
approved as being in the best interests of John Doe.
IT IS SO ORDERED.

Page 3 of 4

March 10 , 2014
Anderson, South Carolina

Page 4 of 4