Davis v. Crescent Electric Supply Company et al

Filing 153

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER granting 141 Motion to Compel. Signed by U.S. District Judge Lawrence L. Piersol on 10/12/16. (DJP)

FILED
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF SOUTH DAKOTA

OCT 12

WESTERN DIVISION
CLERK
*

*

LISA A. DAVIS,

crv 12-5008

*
*

Plaintiff,

*

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

*

ON PLAINTIFF'S SUPPLEMENTAL

*

MOTION TO COMPEL

vs.
*

CRESCENT ELECTRIC COMPANY,

("CESCO")a Delaware Corporation;

*
*

JAMES M. SULLIVAN, CESCO 015

*

Branch Manager; MARTIN S.
BURBRIDGE,President/CEO; JAMES R.
ETHEREDGE, Sr. Vice Pres./CFO;

*

*

*

CHRISTOPHER P. BRESLIN,
Sr. Vice Pres./COO; DANIEL E.
PHILIPPI, Vice Pres.-Human Resources;

*

JAMES M.SWEENEY AND

*

*
*

ASSOCIATES,INC., an Iowa Corporation; *
LIBERTY MOTORS,INC.("LIBERTY"), *
*
a South Dakota Domestic Business;
*
LARRY L. PATNOE, Liberty President;
*
and DONALD E. PATNOE,Liberty
*
President/Treasurer,
*

Defendants.

*
*

Plaintiff, Lisa A. Davis ("Davis"), has filed a Supplemental Motion for an Order to

Compel pursuant to Rule 37(a) of the Federal Rules of Ciyil Procedure. Doc. 141. Specifically,
Davis requests: Julie Stienstra/Julie Skinner's emails from November 28, 2010 to July 6, 2011

and associated export logs from the Quest Software Archive Manager program. For the
following reasons, the motion will be granted.
BACKGROUND

The facts of this case have been thoroughly explained in this Court's prior memorandum

opinion and orders. See Docs. 121 and 122. As such, the Court will only recite the facts directly
pertinent to this pending motion.