Compression Labs Incorporated v. Dell, Inc et al

Filing 81

Minute Entry for proceedings held before Judge David Folsom : Motion Hearing held on 1/31/2005 re 63 MOTION to Dismiss Pursuant to Rule 12(b)(1) or, in the Alternative, to Transfer filed by Toshiba America Inc,, Toshiba America Electronic Components Inc,, Toshiba America Information Systems Inc,, Toshiba America Consumer Products Inc,, 64 MOTION to Change Venue filed by Toshiba America Inc,, Toshiba America Electronic Components Inc,, Toshiba America Information Systems Inc,, Toshiba America Consumer Products Inc,, 19 MOTION to Dismiss filed by International Business Machines Corporation,, Toshiba America Inc,, Dell, Inc,. (Court Reporter Libby Crawford.) (mrm, )

Compression Labs Incorporated v. Dell, Inc et al

Doc. 81

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS M A RSHA LL DIVISION

TIM E 10:00 (OPEN) J UDGE David Folsom COM PRESSION LABS V. § § § § § §

DATE 1/31/05 REPORTER Libby Craw f ord

A CER

CIVIL ACTION NO. 2:04CV294 2:04CV158 2:04CV159 MOTION HEARING

A TTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFF: Eric Buether; Carl Roth; Michael Smith; ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT: Eric Albritton; Lance Lee; Danny Williams; Jennifer Doan; David Hansen; David Weaver; LAW CLERK: Peter Corcoran and Trip Fussell THIS DAY CAME THE PARTIES BY THEIR ATTORNEYS AND THE FOLLOWING PROCEEDINGS WERE HAD: 9;27 ct opens; 9:30 Williams/ add ct, oral argument on 2:04cv158, 2:04cv159, and 2 : 0 4 cv 2 9 4 cases; 9:55 Buether/ responds; 10:12 Williams/ reply; 10:17 Hansen/ add ct re: Yahoo and Sun (2:04-cv-294) dismissal and transfers; 10:29 Smith/ responds; 10:31 ct/ w hat does that leave us w it h; 10:31 Lee/ w ould like to discuss scheduling issues; 10:32 ct/ 10 minute break; 10:32 recess; 10:48 ICC w it h Hansen, W illiams, Lee, Buet her, and Weaver; Buether/ has w it hdraw n bifurcation issue; ct/ Special Master or Technical Advisor; Buether/ responds; ct/ w ill not decide that until af t er MDL; 10:51 ct/ 400 hrs for deposition; Weaver/ 4/6th tutorial and 4/7th m ark m an; 10:52 ct/ schedule for next 60 days and early April is pushing it for M ark m an hrg; Weaver/ w ould like to pencil in something; ct/ w ill give 2 hrs 45 mins ea side for Markman hrg; ct/ sets tutorials for 4/27th 10:00 am 1.5 hrs each side and 4 / 2 8 t h 9:00 am Markman hrg 2 hrs 45 mins; 10:57 Lee/ experts issue; ct/ w ill not lim it at this time but be reasonable; 11:10 recess; 11:12 ct resumes; ct/ plfs not pursuing bifurcat ion claim; 4/27th for tutorial 1 ½ hrs ea side; 4/28th at 9:00 am M arkm an hrg 2 hrs 45 mins each side; Weaver/ w ill submit a revised scheduling order; Buet her/ housekeeping; protective order in 158 and one proposed in other 2 cases; ct/ can that protective order be extended to all the cases; Roth/ that protective order w as negot iat ed; Buether/ add ct; ct/ add ptys re: consolidation for discovery purposes and if ptys feel consolidation is needed for trial then notify ct as soon as possible; ct/ can Prot ect iv e order from 158 be extended to all cases; Weaver/ at a substantive level they are the same; ct/ if some modifications needed w e can address those at the appropriat e time; 11:18 recess;

Dockets.Justia.com

DAVID J. MALAND, CLERK BY: Mel Martin Courtroom Deputy TIM E: 11:18 (ADJOURN)