Function Media, L.L.C. v. Google, Inc. et al

Filing 221

NOTICE by Function Media, L.L.C. Objections to Google's Trial Exhibits (Tribble, Max)

Function Media, L.L.C. v. Google, Inc. et al

Doc. 221

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS MARSHALL DIVISION FUNCTION MEDIA, L.L.C., Plaintiff, vs. GOOGLE, INC. AND YAHOO, INC., Defendants. § § § § § § § § §

Civil Action No. 2007-CV-279

JURY TRIAL DEMANDED

PLAINTIFF FUNCTION MEDIA, L.L.C.'S OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT GOOGLE, INC.'S TRIAL EXHIBITS Plaint iff Function Media, L.L.C. ("Function Media") hereby files its objections to Defendant Google, Inc.'s Trial Exhibits. Function Media reserves its right to amend and/or supplement its objections to the extent permitted by this Court's rules.

Exh. # 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18

Bates Begin

Bates End

Plaintiff's Objection FRE 403; MIL 36

Will Use

G000597 G026170 D017116 D017118 GGLFM0005064 D017496 D063196 D017393 D057094 D062063 D016832 D062095 D062093 D038097 D032938

G000623 G026171 D017117 D017119 GGLFM0005074 D017744 D063294 D017394 D057137 D062068 D016835 D062096 D062094 D038104 D032939 FRE 403; MIL 33 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 403; MIL 5; MIL 6; MIL 36 FRE 403; MIL 5; MIL 6; MIL 36 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46

May Use X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X

FRE 403; MIL 47 FRE 403; MIL 47 FRE 403 FRE 403; MIL 33 FRE 403; MIL 47 FRE 403; MIL 47 FRE 403; MIL 47 FRE 403; MIL 47 FRE 403; MIL 47 FRE 403; MIL 47

986880v1/010020

Dockets.Justia.com

19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65

G005358

G005359

G005378 G005379

G005378 G005379

G005380 G005373 G026172

G005381 G005374 G026189

G005362 G005360 G005365 G005370

G005364 G005361 G005369 G005372

G005375

G005377

G005380 G005382 G005383 G005384 G005387 G005390 G005391 G018954 G045837 G006053 G006227 G006233 G045838

G005381 G005382 G005383 G005386 G005389 G005390 G005393 G019071 G045837 G006061 GG00623 G006240 G045857

FRE 403, 802, 901 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 803, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901;MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 403, 802, 901 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 403, 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46

X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X

986880v1/010020

66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110

G045911 G045858 FIELDING 0001 FIELDING 0017 G005430 G068212 G026146 G002000372031 G068892 D017178 D017179 D017180 D017181 D017182 D058827 D058700 G002001080541

G045955 G045910 FIELDING 0016 FIELDING 0031 G005527 G068891 G026163 G002000372033 G069217 D017178 D017179 D017180 D017181 D017182 D058828 D058702 G002001080552

FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 403, 802 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 803, 901 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 803 FRE 803; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 403; MIL 42; MIL 43 FRE 403; MIL 42 FRE 403; MIL 42 FRE 403; MIL 42 FRE 403; MIL 42 FRE 403; MIL 42; MIL 44 FRE 403; MIL 42; MIL 44 FRE 802 FRE 403; MIL 5; MIL 6 X

X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X

G005296 G014946

G005301 G014963

G016551

G016753

G017488 G016760 D063234

G017488 G016760 D063235

FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 403; 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 403, 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 403; MIL 47 FRE 403; MIL 47

986880v1/010020

111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155

D063272 D061940 D016826 D062088 D059249 D054988 D059240

D063272 D061942 D016829 D062089 D059250 D054989 D059242

FRE 403; MIL 47 FRE 403; MIL 47 FRE 403; MIL 47 FRE 403; MIL 47

X X X X X X X X X

D017462 G001011 G026170 D005045 D069361 D032371 D039374 D036905 D036638

D017462 G001017 G026170 D005052 D069376 ? D039376 D036977 D036640

MIL 36 FRE 403, 802, 901; MIL 36; MIL 46

X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X

FRE 403; MIL 24; MIL 44 FRE 403, 802; MIL 36 FRE 802, 901; MIL 36

D032938 D055043 D063265

D032939 D055043 D063267

MIL 36 MIL 36 FRE 802, 901; MIL 36 FRE 403; MIL 47 FRE 403; MIL 47 FRE 403; 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 403; MIL 33 FRE 403; MIL 33 FRE 403; MIL 33 FRE 802 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46

G015008 G014996 G015134 G004016 G004162 G004016 G003512

G015009 G014996 G015134 G004065 G004182 G004161 G003587

G002002737565

G002002737566

986880v1/010020

156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191

G014779 G014856 G014689 G014815 G014885 G014819

G014801 G014881 G014778 G014818 G014887 G014821

GGLFM0040572 GGLFM0039392

GGLFM0040621 GGLFM0039518

FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 403; MILS 5, 6, 36, 39, 41, 44, 47 FRE 403; MILS 5, 6, 28, 36, 39, 41, 44, 47 FRE 403; MILS 5, 6, 28, 36, 39, 41, 44, 47 FRE 403; MILS 39, 40, 42 FRE 403; MIL 47 FRE 403, MIL 5; MIL 6 FRE 802 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46

X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X

FRE 403; MIL 33 FRE 403; MIL 33 FRE 403, 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL33; MIL 46 FRE 403, 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL33; MIL 46 FRE 403, 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 33; MIL 46 FRE 403, 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 33; MIL 46 FRE 403, 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 33; MIL 46 FRE 403, 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 33; MIL 46 FRE 403, 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 33; MIL 46 FRE 403, 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 33; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46

G058633 G060169 G060889 G061407 G062943 G063663 G014990 G014996 G015001 G015011 G015018 G015095 G015134 G015166

G059466 G060888 G061035 G062240 G063662 G063809 G014995 G014998 G015001 G015015 G015094 G015097 G015134 G015167

986880v1/010020

192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 229 230 231 232 233 234 235 236

G173214 G036543 G035977 G005719 G014688.01 G014963.01 G015443.01 G015443.02 G015443.03 G015443.04 G017496.01 G046080 G065016 G065907 G064578 G026190 G177035 G068204 IV-FM 000009 IV-FM 000036 IV-FM 000045 IV-FM 000054 G000631

G173253 G036583 G036019 G005721 G014688.01 G014963.01 G015443.01 G015443.02 G015443.03 G015443.04 G017496.01 G046080 G065016 G065907 G064578 G027485 G177035 G068204 IV-FM 000009 IV-FM 000039 IV-FM 000048 IV-FM 000083 G000640

G000716 G000762 D065903 G017603 GGLFM0042833 G020792 GGLFM0039680 GGLFM0039682 G005715 G022202 G016001 G017767 G005308 GGLFM0039391 G005302 G005353 G005355 G014999 G015000 G015002

G000734 G000818 D065034 G017614 GGLFM0042934 G020792 GGLFM0039681 GGLFM000039684 G005718 G022202 G016001 G017767 G005308 GGLFM0039391 G005302 G005354 G005357 G014999 G015000 G015004

FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 403, 802 FRE 403, 802; MIL 28 FRE 403, 802; MIL 28 FRE 403, 802; MIL 28 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802; MIL 48 FRE 802; MIL 48 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46

X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X

986880v1/010020

237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 281 282 283

G015005 G015010 G015016 G015017 G015098 G015101 G015104 G015108 G015124 G015126 G015131 G015134 G015137 G015140 G015141 G015156 G015164 G003690 G003715 G003739 G003763 G003844 G003943 G003953 G003965 G003980 G024674 G024686 G024689 G024700 G024705 G024708 G024710 G024716 G024720 G024736 G024749 G024757 G024759 G024771 G024774 G024776 G024788 G024791 G024793 G024794 G024814

G015007 G015010 G015016 G015017 G015100 G015103 G015107 G015123 G015125 G015130 G015133 G015134 G015139 G015140 G015142 G015158 G015165 G003714 G003738 G003762 G003808 G003850 G003951 G003958 G003973 G004015 G024685 G024688 G024699 G024704 G024707 G024709 G024715 G024719 G024735 G024748 G024756 G024758 G024770 G024773 G024775 G024787 G024790 G024792 G024793 G024813 G024817

FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46

X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X

986880v1/010020

284 285 286 287 288 289 290 291 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 301 302 303 304 305 306 307 308 309 310 311 312 313 314 315 316 317 318 319 320 321 322 323 324 325 326

Deposition Exhibit 167 Deposition Exhibit 169 FIELDING0001 FIELDING0032 FIELDING0036 G000170 G000381 G000424 G000472 G000550 G000597 G000624 G000676 G000819 G000825 G000854 G000900 G000947 G000985 G001011 G001029 G001100 G001129 G001157 G001178 G001424 G001891 G001900 G001902 G001906 G001918 G001969 G002000710691 G002001618865 G002003483068 G002003734707 G002088 G002103 G002117 G002585 G002636 G002643 G002681

FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 403, 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17

X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X

FIELDING0016 FIELDING0035 FIELDING0065 G000246 G000399 G000471 G000502 G000561 G000623 G000630 G000715 G000824 G000853 G000870 G000925 G000960 G001010 G001017 G001053 G001128 G001144 G001177 G001227 G001435 G001894 G001901 G001904 G001916 G001927 G001976 G002000710698 G002001618892 G002003483079 G002003734738 G002092 G002107 G002124 G002593 G002642 G002652 G002690

MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802

986880v1/010020

327 328 329 330 331 332 333 334 335 336 337 338 339 340 341 342 343 344 345 346 347 348 349 350 351 352 353 354 355 356 357 358 359 360 361 362 363 364 365 366 367 368 369 370 371 372 373 374

G002691 G002924 G003-0000017 G003-0000065 G003-0000352 G003-0000356 G003-0000478 G003-0000546 G003-0000593 G003-0000622 G003-0000650 G003-0000671 G003-0000869 G003-0001043 G003-0001212 G003-0001246 G003-0001250 G003-0001252 G003-0001327 G003-0001402 G003-0001476 G003-0003130 G003-0003155 G003-0003252 G003-0003276 G003-0003305 G003-0003312 G003-0003394 G003-0003437 G003-0003527 G003-0003556 G003-0003563 G003-0003587 G003-0003668 G003016 G003018 G003081 G003115 G003467 G003512 G003588 G003818 G003851 G004016 G004162 G004581 G004607 G004709

G002698 G002935 G003-0000018 G003-0000066 G003-0000355 G003-0000356 G003-0000485 G003-0000546 G003-0000598 G003-0000631 G003-0000651 G003-0000722 G003-0000879 G003-0001053 G003-0001225 G003-0001247 G003-0001251 G003-0001264 G003-0001349 G003-0001433 G003-0001497 G003-0003154 G003-0003191 G003-0003255 G003-0003299 G003-0003311 G003-0003315 G003-0003425 G003-0003458 G003-0003540 G003-0003562 G003-0003586 G003-0003600 G003-0003677 G003017 G003020 G003083 G003134 G003467 G003587 G003689 G003843 G003942 G004144 G004293 G004603 G004697 G004714

FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802

X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X

986880v1/010020

375 376 377 378 379 380 381 382 383 384 385 386 387 388 389 390 391 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399 400 401 402 403 404 405 406 407 408 409 410 411 412 413 414 415 416 417

G004792 G004797 G004797 G004811 G004844 G004882 G004923 G004944 G004959 G004990 G004995 G004999 G005005 G005031 G005039 G005071 G005118 G005133 G005148 G005172 G005179 G005214 G005219 G005227 G005266 G005296 G005311 G005358 G005430 G005733 G008119 G014779 G014815 G014828 G014856 G014899 G014967 G015008 G015095 G015162 G015168 G015241 G015443.01 (native production) G015443.01 (native production) G015473

G004796 G004807 G004807 G004832 G004854 G003475 G004930 G004945 G004967 G004994 G004998 G005004 G005030 G005038 G005042 G005074 G005125 G005147 G005160 G005178 G005182 G005218 G005224 G005235 G005279 G005301 G005312 G005359 G005714 G005740 G008133 G014780 G014818 G014855 G014881 G014913 G014989 G015009 G015097 G015163 G015240 G015443 G015443.01 (native production) G015443.01 (native production) G015994

FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46

X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X

418

FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46

X

419

FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46

X

986880v1/010020

420 421 422 423 424 425 426 427 428 429 430 431 432 433 434 435 436 437 438 439 440 441 442 443 444 445 446 447 448 449 450 451 452 453 454 455 456 457 458 459 460 461 462 463 464 465 466

G016419 G016452 G017154 G017758 G018509 G018953 G024818 G024996 G025040 G025074 G025087 G025110 G025117 G025161 G025195 G025291 G025307 G025334 G025350 G025524 G025549 G025553 G025563 G025575 G025668 G025870 G025896 G025907 G025921 G025939 G025949 G026047 G026049 G026064 G026068 G026069 G026078 G026085 G026088 G026093 G026094 G026102 G026104 G026107 G026113 G026146 G026170

G016451 G016465 G017482 G017766 G018952 G019257 G024880 G025039 G025063 G025086 G025097 G025116 G025126 G025194 G025217 G025306 G025333 G025349 G025391 G025548 G025552 G025562 G025574 G025592 G025695 G025895 G025906 G025920 G025938 G025948 G026046 G026048 G026063 G026067 G026068 G026077 G026084 G026087 G026092 G026093 G026101 G026103 G026106 G026112 G026123 G026163 G026171

FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 36; MIL 46

X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X

986880v1/010020

467 468 469 470 471 472 473 474 475 476 477 478 479 480 481 482 483 484 485 486 487 488 489 490 491 492 493 494 495 496 497 498 499 500 501 502 503 504 505 506 507 508 509 510 511 512 513 514

G027532 G027810 G027812 G027834 G027902 G027933 G027941 G027948 G027964 G027967 G027975 G028305 G028509 G028962 G028974 G028991 G029001 G029020 G029030 G029042 G029053 G029125 G029125 G029134 G029135 G029137 G029212 G029283 G029338 G029349 G029364 G029369 G029371 G029373 G029883 G029886 G029918 G029920 G029925 G029926 G029947 G029951 G029959 G029972 G029977 G030277 G043058 G043060

G027535 G027811 G027833 G027851 G027903 G027939 G027946 G027963 G027966 G027968 G027975 G028337 G028535 G028966 G028990 G029000 G029019 G029021 G029041 G029047 G029053 G029133 G029133 G029134 G029136 G029143 G029228 G029305 G029348 G029363 G029368 G029370 G029372 G029378 G029885 G029887 G029919 G029924 G029925 G029946 G029950 G029952 G029960 G029976 G030034 G030277 G043059 G043060

FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46

X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X

986880v1/010020

515 516 517 518 519 520 521 522 523 524 525 526 527 528 529 530 531 532 533 534 535 536 537 538 539 540 541 542 543 544 545 546 547 548 549 550 551 552 553 554 555 556 557 558 559 560 561 562

G043062 G043063 G043064 G045772 G045822 G045823 G045827 G045970 G045994 G046050 G046050 G048446 G064500 G065911 G065912 G066037 G066038 G066042 G066044 G066046 G066049 G066051 G066053 G066056 G066058 G066068 G066102 G066105 G066115 G066124 G066127 G066133 G066135 G066139 G066145 G066167 G066175 G066260 G066261 G066263 G066274 G066278 G066280 G066282 G066284 G066300 G066303 G066305

G043062 G043063 G043064 G045791 G045822 G045823 G045830 G045993 G046016 G046079 G046079 G049183 G064501 G065911 G066036 G066037 G066041 G066043 G066045 G066048 G066050 G066052 G066055 G066057 G066067 G066101 G066104 G066114 G066123 G066126 G066132 G066134 G066138 G066144 G066166 G066174 G066259 G066260 G066262 G066273 G066277 G066279 G066281 G066283 G066299 G066302 G066304 G066332

FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802

X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X

986880v1/010020

563 564 565 566 567 568 569 570 571 572 573 574 575 576 577 578 579 580 581 582 583 584 585 586 587 588 589 590 592 593 594 595 596 597 598 599 600 601 602 603 604

G066333 G066341 G066343 G066365 G066369 G066373 G066380 G066385 G066387 G066391 G066402 G066405 G066406 G066408 G066410 G066413 G066415 G066420 G066529 G068214 G068441 G068892 G084303 G174743 G174744 G174809 G174822 G174838 GGLFM0000988 GGLFM0002126 GGLFM0040181 GGLFM0040221 GGLFM0040240 GGLFM0039575 G003-0299503 G002004025374 GGLFM0019128 G003-0299106 G003-0299282 G003-0299498 G003-0299501

G066340 G066342 G066364 G066368 G066372 G066379 G066384 G066386 G066390 G066401 G066404 G066405 G066407 G066409 G066412 G066414 G066419 G066428 G067818 G068440 G068566 G069217 G084333 G174743 G174744 G174814 G174824 G174841 GGLFM0001000 GGLFM0002133 GGLFM0040220 GGLFM0040239 GGLFM0040271 GGLFM0039604 G003-0299504 G002004025380 GGLFM0019139 G003-0299281 G003-0299497 G003-0299500 G003-0299502

FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802

X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X

986880v1/010020

605 606 607 608 609 610 611 612 613 614 615 616 617 618 619 620 621 622 623 624 625 626 627 628 629 630 631 632 633 634 635 636 637 638 639 640 641 642 643 644 645 646 647 648 649 650 651 652

G003-0299503 G003-0299505 G003-0299506 G003-0299508 G003-0299509 G003-0299510 G003-0299511 G003-0299515 G003-0299517 G003-0299518 G003-0299521 G003-0299523 G003-0299525 G003-0299527 G003-0299529 G003-0299531 G003-0299532 G003-0299535 G003-0299538 G003-0299541 G003-0299543 G003-0299545 G003-0299547 G003-0299549 G003-0299551 G003-0299552 G003-0299553 G003-0299555 G003-0299557 G003-0299559 G003-0299560 G003-0299562 G003-0299565 G003-0299567 G003-0299569 G003-0299571 G003-0299573 G003-0299577 G003-0299580 G003-0299582 G003-0299585 G003-0299587 G003-0299589 G003-0299591 G003-0299593 G003-0299594 G003-0299596 G003-0299598

G003-0299504 G003-0299505 G003-0299507 G003-0299508 G003-0299509 G003-0299510 G003-0299514 G003-0299516 G003-0299517 G003-0299520 G003-0299522 G003-0299524 G003-0299526 G003-0299528 G003-0299530 G003-0299531 G003-0299534 G003-0299537 G003-0299540 G003-0299542 G003-0299544 G003-0299546 G003-0299548 G003-0299550 G003-0299551 G003-0299552 G003-0299554 G003-0299556 G003-0299558 G003-0299559 G003-0299561 G003-0299564 G003-0299566 G003-0299568 G003-0299570 G003-0299572 G003-0299576 G003-0299579 G003-0299581 G003-0299584 G003-0299586 G003-0299588 G003-0299590 G003-0299592 G003-0299593 G003-0299595 G003-0299597 G003-0299599

FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802

X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X

986880v1/010020

653 654 655 656 657 658 659 660 661 662 663 664 665 666 667 668 669 670 671 672 673 674 675 676 677 678 679 680 681 682 683 684 685 686 687 688 689 690 691 692 693 694 695 696 697

G003-0299600 G003-0299602 G003-0299604 GGLFM0044113 GGLFM0007708 G005227 G002000243732

G003-0299601 G003-0299603 G003-0299604 GGLFM0044167 GGLFM0007720 G005235 G002000243750

FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46

X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X

G004797

G004807

G003-0131248 G003-0131342 G003-0131343 G003-0131350 G003-0131353 G003-0131362 G003-0131377 G003-0131387 G003-0131394 G003-0131403 G003-0131425 G003-0131455 G003-0131468 G003-0131481 G003-0131503 G003-0131345 G003-0131338 G003-0131539 G003-0131550 G003-0131802

G003-0131261 G003-0131344 G003-0131352 G003-0131361 G003-0131366 G003-0131386 G003-0131393 G003-0131402 G003-0131413 G003-0131439 G003-0131467 G003-0131480 G003-0131502 G003-0131516 G003-0131347 G003-0131339 G003-0131549 G003-0131565 G003-0131807

986880v1/010020

698 699 700 701 702 703 704 705 706 707 708 709 710 711 712 713 714 715 716 717 718 719 720 721 722 723 724 725 726 727 728 729 730 731 732 733 734 735 736 737 738 739 740

G003-0131817 G003-0131860 G003-0131871 G003-0131882 G003-0131930 G003-0131971 G003-131348 G061036 G064319 G064334 G064373 G064375 G065166 G065097 G067965 G067968 G067973 G067979 G067982 G067988 G068050 G068062 G068068 G068085 G068156 G068168 G068171 G068178 G068181 G068184 G068187 G068190 G068193 G068197 G068201 G068205 G068208 G172925 GGLFM0008543 GGLFM0008549 GGLFM0026509 GGLFM0026512 GGLFM0026513

G003-0131822 G003-0131870 G003-0131881 G003-0131893 G003-0131949 G003-0132009 G003-0131349 G061041 G064333 G064372 G064374 G064381 G065174 G065103 G067967 G067972 G067978 G067981 G067987 G068049 G068061 G068067 G068084 G068155 G068167 G068170 G068177 G068180 G068183 G068186 G068189 G068192 G068196 G068200 G068203 G068207 G068210 G172945 GGLFM0008548 GGLFM0010498 GGLFM0026511 GGLFM0026512 GGLFM0026514

X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X FRE 403, 802, 901 X FRE 403, 802, 901 X

986880v1/010020

741 742 743 744 745 746 747 748 749 750 751 752 753 754 755 756 757 758 759 760 761 762 763 764 765 766 767

GGLFM0026515 GGLFM0026521 GGLFM0026604 GGLFM0026677 GGLFM0026733 GGLFM0029215 GGLFM0037475 GGLFM0025620 GGLFM0025664 GGLFM0025713 G046471 G046592 G046166 G046294 G046418 GGLFM0004985 GGLFM0005005 GGLFM0005013 GGLFM0005029 GGLFM0005047 GGLFM0018822 GGLFM0019115 GGLFM0019202 GGLFM0019493 GGLFM0019876 GGLFM0019954 GGLFM0020032

GGLFM0026520 GGLFM0026603 GGLFM0026676 GGLFM0026732 GGLFM0029214 GGLFM0037474 GGLFM0039169 GGLFM0025663 GGLFM0025712 GGLFM0025776 G046591 G046723 G046293 G046417 G046470 GGLFM0005004 GGLFM0005012 GGLFM0005027 GGLFM0005045 GGLFM0005063 GGLFM0019114 GGLFM0019201 GGLFM0019492 GGLFM0019875 GGLFM0019953 GGLFM0020031 GGLFM0020487

X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X FRE 802 X FRE 802 X FRE 802 X FRE 802 X FRE 802 X FRE 802 X FRE 802 X FRE 802 X FRE 802 X FRE 802 X FRE 802 X FRE 802

986880v1/010020

768 769 770 771 777 778 779 780 781 782 783 784 785 786 787 788 789 790 791 792 793 794 795 796 797 798 799 800 801 802 803 804 805 806 807 808 809 810 811 812

G002002841893 GGLFM0040296 G002002745164 G002001102221 G050667 G050831 G051050

G002002842102 GGLFM0040309 G002002745221 G002001102253 G050795 G050897 G051107

X FRE 802 X FRE 802 X FRE 802 X FRE 802 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X FRE 802 X FRE 802 X FRE 802

MIL 17

MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17 MIL 17

MIL 17 MIL 17 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 G002001538575 G003-0015530 G002001084310 G002000682373 G002000941269 Ex. 3 MILLER Depo. G002001538585 G003-0015546 G002001084310.0016 G002000682452 G002000941373 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802

986880v1/010020

813 814 815 816 817 818 819 820 821 822 823 824 825 826 827 828 829 830 831 832 833 834 835 836 837 838 839 840 841 842 843 844 845 846 847 848 849 850 851 852 853 854 855 856

G014779 G014856 G014689 G014815 G014885 G014819

G014801 G014881 G014778 G014818 G014887 G014821

GGLFM004413 G003-0299106 D000009 D000697 D001120 D001994 D022334 D023605 D024053 D031545 D031739 D032298 D000218 CROSK 1299 G171095 G026170 G060169

GGLFM0044167 G003-0299605 D000695 D001118 D001993 D002386 D022851 D024050 D024773 D031735 D032297 D032830 D000290 CROSK 1355 G171101 G026171 G060888 G062967

FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 46 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802 FRE 802

X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X

FRE 403, 802; MIL 36 MIL 17 MIL 17 FRE 403, 802, 901; MIL 17; MIL 36; MIL 46 FRE 403, 802, 901; MILS 6, 17, 33, 46 FRE 403, 802, 901; MIL 17,MIL 33, MIL 46

857 G062950

986880v1/010020

858 859 860 861 862 863 G034339 864 G045824 865 866 867 868 869 870 871 872 873 874 875 876 877 878 G045830 G034434 G062968 Depo Exhibit 616 G002000710691 G000524 G003589 Kdelfa0000077 G063231

G002000710698 G000549 G003689

FRE 403, 802, 901; MIL 17,MIL 33, MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17,MIL 33, MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17,MIL 33, MIL 46 MIL 17 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17,MIL 33, MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17,MIL 33, MIL 46 FRE 802, 901; MIL 17,MIL 33, MIL 46

X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X

D017214 D038097 D040127 D019179 D016838 D060045 D066759 D062093 D017161 D017116 D017115

D017220 D038104 D040134 D019254 D016842 D060051 D066766 D062096 D017171 D017127 D017115

FRE 403; MIL 5; MIL 6 FRE 403; MIL 47 MIL 42; MIL 44 MIL 42; MIL 44 MIL 44 FRE 403; MIL 47 FRE 403, 408; MIL 27; MIL 28 FRE 403; MIL 47 FRE 403; MIL 5; MIL 6 FRE 403; MIL 5; MIL 6 FRE 403

Respect fully submitted,

/s/ Max L. Tribble, Jr._______________ Max L. Tribble, Jr. State Bar No. 20213950 Email: [e-mail] SUSMAN GODFREY L.L.P. 1000 Louisiana, Suite 5100 Houston, Texas, 77002 Telephone: [phone] Facsimile: [phone] Lead Attorney for Plaintiff OF COUNSEL: Joseph S. Grinstein State Bar No. 24002188
986880v1/010020

Aimée Robert State Bar No. 24046729 SUSMAN GODFREY L.L.P. 1000 Louisiana Street, Suite 5100 Houston, Texas 77002-5096 Telephone: [phone] Fax: [phone] [e-mail] m [e-mail] m Jeremy Brandon State Bar No. 24040563 Warren T. Burns State Bar No. 24053119 SUSMAN GODFREY L.L.P. 901 Main Street, Suite 5100 Dallas, Texas 75202-3775 Telephone: [phone] Fax: [phone] [e-mail] [e-mail] Just in A. Nelson State Bar No. 24034766 SUSMAN GODFREY L.L.P. 1201 Third Avenue, Suite 3800 Seattle, Washington 98101-3000 Telephone: [phone] Fax: [phone] [e-mail] Robert Christopher Bunt State Bar No. 00787165 Charles Ainsworth PARKER, BUNT & AINSWORTH, P.C. 100 East Ferguson, Suite 1114 Tyler, Texas 75702 Telephone: [phone] Fax: [phone] [e-mail] charley@pbat yler.com S. Calvin Capshaw State Bar No. 037839000

986880v1/010020

Elizabeth L. DeRieux State Bar No. 05770585 D. Jeffrey Rambin CAPSHAW DERIEUX, LLP Energy Centre 1127 Judson Road, Suite 220 P.O. Box 3999 (75606-3999) Longview, Texas 75601-5157 Telephone: [phone] Fax: [phone] [e-mail] [e-mail] m [e-mail] Otis Carroll State Bar No. 03895700 Collin Maloney State Bar No. 00794219 IRELAND, CARROLL & KELLEY, P.C. 6101 S. Broadway, Suite 500 Tyler, Texas 75703 Telephone: [phone] Fax: [phone] [e-mail] cmalo [e-mail] CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that on October 16, 2009, I electronically filed the foregoing document with the clerk of the court for the U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Texas, using the electronic filing system of the court. The electronic case filing system sent a "Notice of Electronic Filing" to the attorneys of record who have consented in writing to accept this Notice as service of this document by electronic means. /s/ Max L. Tribble, Jr._______________ Max L. Tribble, Jr.

986880v1/010020