Performance Pricing, Inc. v. Google Inc. et al
Filing
241
MOTION to Compel Production of Documents by Third Parties Neal Cohen and Vista IP Law Group, LLP by AOL LLC, Google Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Joint Stipulation Regarding Defendant Google Inc. and AOL LLC's Motion to Compel Production of Documents by Third Parties Neal Cohen and Vista IP Law Group, LLP, # 2 Declaration of Emily C. O'Brien in Support of Motion to Compel, # 3 Exhibit A, # 4 Exhibit B, # 5 Exhibit C, # 6 Exhibit D, # 7 Exhibit E, # 8 Exhibit F, # 9 Exhibit G, # 10 Exhibit H, # 11 Exhibit I, # 12 Exhibit J, # 13 Exhibit K, # 14 Exhibit L, # 15 Exhibit M, # 16 Exhibit N, # 17 Exhibit O, # 18 Exhibit P, # 19 Declaration of Christin Cho in Opposition to Motion to Compel, # 20 Errata 1, # 21 Exhibit 2, # 22 Exhibit 3, # 23 Proposed Order Granting Defendant Google Inc. and AOL LLC's Motion to Compel)(O'Brien, Emily) Modified on 9/25/2009 (sm, ). Modified on 9/25/2009 (sm, ).
<![CDATA[
y
Dockets.Justia.com
^..^
,..^...
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS Performance Pricing, inc. Plaintiff, v. Google , Ine. et al., 2:07-cv-432 (LED} REVISED PRIVILEGE LOG CORRESPONDING TO: 1) SUBPOENA COMMANDING NON-PARTY NEAL M. COHEN TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS; AND 2) SUBPOENA COMMANDING NON-PARTY VISTA 1P LAW GROUP LLP TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS
Defendants.
The Revised Privilege Log attached hereto as Exhibit A is being produced in
co 3nection with: 1} RESPONSE TO SUBPOENA COMMANDING NON-PARTY NEAL M. COHEN TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS; and 2} RESPONSE TO SUBPOENA COMMANDING NON-PARTY VISTA IP LAW GROUP LLP TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS. All documents identified in said Privilege Lag are being withheld on the bases identified, and are not being produced. Abbreviations used in the Privilege Log: "NMC" means Neai M. Cohen; "W L" means Wayne Lin;
"VLS" means Valerie L Sarigumba, who was at all relevant times an associate
attorney at Vista 1P Law Group; "JLL" means Jocelyn L. Lee, who was at al! relevant times a senior paralegal at Vista IP Law Group;
"HO" means Hidehiko Okada, who was at all relevant times an attorney at the law firm, Okada Patent & Trademark Office; "SS" means Samuel 8. Stone , who was at all relevant times a partner at Lyon & Lyon
LLP;
"JT" means Jeff Tekanic, who was at all relevant times an attorney at the law firm, Okada Patent & Trademark Office; "PJE" means Patricia J. English, who was at ali relevant times an employee at Cohen, Sakaguchi & English tLP;
"YPY" means Yeo-Pyo Yoon, wha was at all relevant times an attorney at Honesty &
Patent;
"A/C" means a claim of Attorney/Client Privilege; "W/P" means a claim of Work Product; "7PM" means a claim of Trial Preparation Material; "patent" means tJ5 Patent No. 6,978,253; "litigation" means Performance Pricing, inc. ^- Google, Inc., et al.; "licensing" means licensing of ll5 Patent No. 6,978,253; "trademark" means trademark of PricePlay;
"representation" means representation of Wayne Lin by Neal Cohen.
P^G^ _^_ a-o --
Ref 1-1
pate 8/2/2001 NMC
Authors} WL
Recipient ( s)
Description Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose o legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose o legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legs! advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legaE advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidentia! communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential comn·^unicatians between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client A/C
Privileges) Claimed
1-2
8/13/01
NMC
WL
A/C
1-3
3/24/01
NMC
WL
A/C
1-4
1/7.2/01
NMC
WL
A/C
1-5
2/20/01
NMC
WL
A/C
1-S
2/27/99
NMC
WL
A/C
1-7
1/3/01
NMC
WL
A/C
1-$
10/1/01
NMC
WL
A/C
^^ l^ ^ F'^^ C^
^^^ 1
Ref
Date
Author ( sy
Recipient(s)
Description " and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Leiter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning liatent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client A/C
Prlvllege(s)
Clairrted
1-9
12/13/00
NMC
WL
1-10
11/15/01
NMC
WL
A/C
1-11
4/2/01
NMC
WL
A/C
1-12
7/28/00
NMC
WL
A/C
_ A/C
1-13
5/10/01
NMC
WL
1-14
10/24/02
NMC
WL
A/C
1-15
8/2/01
NMC
WL
A/C
and attorney.
1-16 11/30/00 NMC WL Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client A/C
^
^ ^.-.^ ^^ ;'.^
.
e
Ref
Date
Author{ s)
Recipient ( s)
Description
and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including Confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter Concerning parent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential Communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between Client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client
Pri^llege(s^ Cfairned A/C
1-17
10/27/99
NMC
WL
1-18
6/1/OD
NMC
WL
A/C
5-19
4/18/02
NMC
WL
A/C
1-2D
10/16/01
NMC
WL
A/C
1-21
3/6/02
NMC
WL
A/C
1-22
10/9/D1
NMC
WL
A/C
1-23
7/5/00
NMC
WL
A/C
1-24
2/18/00
NMC
WL
A/C
^Z i^ W
i^ `^
Ref
Date
Author ( s)
Recipient{s)
Description and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legs[ advice and including confidential communications between client
Privilege(s)
Claimed 1-zS
8/13/0]. NMC WL A/C
and attorney.
1-26 4/17/02 NMC WL letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose o legal advice and including Confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and including Confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential comm^^nications between client and attorney. Letter Concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between Client A/C
1-27
7/31/02
NMC
WL
A/C
2-5
8/2/p1
NMC
WL
A/C
2-6
8/13/d1
NMC
WL
A/C
2-11
3/17/07
NMC
WL
A/C
3-1
5/7/02
NMC
WL
A/C
3-2
9/10/01
NMC
WL
A/C
^^ ^^ ^I^ N
N [`^
Ref
Date
Author ( s)
Reclplent ( sy
Descrlptlon and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecutian far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecutian for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecutian for the purpose of legal advice and including Confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client
Prlvllege(s)
CEaimed
3-3 9/10/01 NMC WL A/C
3-4
8/21/01
NMC
WL
A/C
3-5
NMC
WL
A/C
3-6
8/21/01
NMC
WL
A/C
3-7
5/2/01
NMC
WL
A/C
3-8
4/30/01
NMC
WL
A/C
3-9
4/23/01
NMC
WL
A/C .
3-10
4/6/01
NMC
WL
A/C
^' X ^^ I^ C^ :^
Nt
v'\
Ref
Date
Aathor(s}
Recipient ( s)
Description and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpase of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter Concerning patent prasecution for the purpose of legal advice and including Confidential Communications between Client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and 'including con#idential communications between client and attamey. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between ciient and attarney, Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpase of legal advice and including Confidential Communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prasecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client
Privileges]
Claimed
3-11 g/6/01 NMC WL A/C
3-12
4/6/01
NMC
WL
A/C
3-13
3/20/01
NMC
WL
A/C
3-14
1/29/01
NMC
WL
A/C
3-15
11/30/00
NMC
WL
A/C
3-16
11/13/04
NMC
WL
A/C ^^ J A/C
3-17
11/6/00
NMC
WL
3-18 `^ rd-- ^ ^^
3.1/6/00
NMC
WL
A/C
ilk
W :^
r
Ref
Date
Author{ s)
Recipient ( s)
Description and attorney, Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications t^etween client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential comm^^ications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including Confidential communications between client
privilege{s) Claimed A/C
3-19
10/16/00
NMC
WL
3-20
9/28/00
NMC
WL
A/C
3-21
9/12/00
NMC
WL
A/C
3-22
6/5/00
NMC
WL
A/C
3-23
S/S/00
NMC
WL
A/C
3-24
5/30/00
NMC
WL
A/C
3-25
1/26/00
NMC
WL
A/C
3-26
4/24/04
NMC
WL
A/C
^ ^ ^
^ ^ ^ -^--i
^ ^. ^
Ref
Date
Authors)
R clpient [ s) i
Deg^^iption
Privllege[s} Claimed A/C
i 3-27
3/23/00 NMC WL
and attorney.
Letter concerning patent prosecution or the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client
3-2$
3/9/00
NMC
WL
A/C
3-29
2/9/00
NMC
WL
A/C
and attorney.
3-31 1/26/00 NMC WL Letter concerning foreign patent rights for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent rights for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent rights for the purpose of legal advice and including confidentia[ communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client A/C
3-33
1/Z6/00
NMC
WL
A/C
3-34
1/17/00
NMC
WL
A/C
3-35
12/6/99
NMC
WL
A/C
3-36
11/29/99
NMC
WL
A/C
^^ !^ ^ m N t W
Ref
Date
Author ( s)
Recipient ( s)
Description and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of Eegal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter Concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning toreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including con#idential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential Communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential corr7munications between client and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential Communications between client
Privilege(s) Claimed A/C
4-1
10/15/01
NMC
WL
4-2
S/14/01
NMC
WL ^ '
A/C
4-3
4/5/D1
NMC
WL
A/C
4-4
1/19/01
NMC
WL
A/C
4-5
6/26/00
NMG
WL
A/C
4-5
6/1/00
NMC
WL
A/C
4-7
2/15/00
NMC
WL
A/C
4-8
iZ/21/99
NMC
WL
A/C
^z r^ w ^ :^
9^
^ ^^
Ref
Date
Author { s)
Recipient(s^
Description and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between Client and attorney, Letter concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning Japanese patent application far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning Japanese patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning Japanese patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications
Pri^llege{s) Clamed A/C
4-9
12/7.3/99
NMC
WL
5-1
4/17/02
NMC
WL
A/C
5-2
8/13/01
NMC
WL
A/C
5-3
$/28/00
NMC
WL
A/C
5-4
6/5/00
NMC
WL
A/C
6-1
7/9/01
NMC
WL
A/C
6-2
3/2/01
NMC
WL
A/C
6-3 n--I 7C ^^ ^ ,.._"" ^ ^
3/2/01
NMC
WL
A/C
f^
Ref
Date
Authnr { s)
Recipient{s)
©e^^^ iptinn between client and attorney. Letter concerningJapanese patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. letter concerning Japanese patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning Japanese patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to Japanese patent application. Document related to Japanese patent application. Document related to Japanese patent application, Document related to Japanese patent application, Document related to Japanese patent application. Document related to Japanese patent application. Letter related to Japanese patent application. Letter concerning Korean patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning Korean patent application
pri^llege{s)
Claimed
6-4 7112/00 NMC WL A/C
6-S
Q/13/00
NMC
WL
A/C
b-5
4/11/04
NMC
WL
A/C
7-1 7-2 7-3 7-4
7-5
7-5 7-7 8-1 4/17/00 1/2/02
NMC(on behalf of WL) NMC(on behalf of WL) NMC[on behalf of WL) NMC(on behalf of WL) NMC(on behalf of WL} NMC[on behalf of WL) NMC(on behalf of WL) NMC
FiC1 HO HO j HO HO HO HC1 WL
A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C
8-2
i ^ ^ ^ ^
4/17/02
NMC
WL
A/C
W i^
7,
Ref
Date
Author { s)
Recipient ( s)
Description for the purpose o legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning Korean patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document concerning Korean patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning Korean patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential commui^sications between client and attorney. Letter concerning Korean patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidentiaE communications between client and attorney. Document related to Korean patent application. Document related to Korean patent application, Drafts of legal documents including confidential communications between client and attorney. Drafts of legal documents including confidential communications between client and attorney. Oacument concerning legal research far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client
Privilege{s) Claimed
8-3
^l/17/02
NMC
WL
A/C
8-4
NMC
WL
A/C
8-5
4/Z7/02
NMC
WL
A/C
&6
4/25/02
NMC
WL
A/C
9-1
9-2 10-1
12/14/01
3/21/00
NMC(on behalf of WL} NMC(on behalf of WL} NMC
YPY YPY ^ WL , ' WL
A/C A/C A/C
10-2
3/21/00
NMC
A/C
10-3 ^'} ^^ +^ ^ ^ ^ ·^ ^^ (
12/13/99
NMC
WL
A/C
Fief
t]ate
Authors}
Recipient ( sy
Description and attorney. Document concerning licensing for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document concerning licensing for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document concerning assignment for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Document concerning licensing for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning publication laws including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document concerning legal invoices including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document concerning legal invoices including confidential communications between client and attorney, Document concernin g patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter regarding a previous meeting including confidential communications
Privileges} Claimed A/C
10-4
11/10/99
NMC
WL
10.,6
9/28/99
NMC
WL
A/C
10-6
9/26/99
NMC
WL
A/C
10-7
9/24/99
NMC
WL
A/C
11-1
3/17/07
NMC
WL
A/C
11-3
7/5/00
NMC
WL
A/C
11-Q
7/1/00
NMC
WL
A/C
11-5
5/4/00
NMC
WL ^
A/C
11-6 ^^
^^ i^ ^ ^ -.^.a
3/13/00
NMC
WL
A/C
I^
Ref
Date
Author ( s)
Recipient(s)
Description between client and attorney. Document concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related o Taiwanese patent application. Document concerting legal invoices including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning research for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning licensing for the purpose of legal advice and including canfidenial communications between client and attorney, Document concerning representation for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attomey. Letter concerning assignments for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications
Privilege(s) Claimed A/C
11-7
3/13/00
NMC
WL
11-8
2/16/00
NMC
WL
A/C
11-9
11-1Q
2/10/00 12/31/99
NMC(on behalf of WL) NMC
Taiwanese attorney WL
A/C
A/C
11-11
12/14/99
NMC
WL
A/C
11-12
11/10/99
NMC
WL
A/C
11-13
9/27/99
NMC
WL
A/C
11-14
9/28/99
NMC
WL
A/C
12
6/1.4/99
55
WL, NMC
A/C
^' ^^ !^ ^ :^
^ ^^
Ref
Date
Author { s)
Recipient(s)
Description between client and attorney. Document concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document concerning legal advice and including confiden^ial communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution or the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning patent prosecution for the
Privilege(s)
Claimed
13
06/10/1999 -
WL, NMC, 5S
WL, NMC, 55
A/C
10/04/2QOZ
14
05/14/1999
SS
NMC, WL
A/C
15
Q6/28/1999
WL
NMC
A/C
16
11/10/1999
NMC
WL
A/C
17-1
5/7/02
NMC
WL
A/C
17-2
9/19/01
NMC
WL
A/C
17-3
8/21/01
NMC
WL
A/C
^.7-4
4/30101
NMC
WL
A/C
17-5
^ ^ X ^
4/6/Q1
NMC
WL
A/C
^C^
^ I^
itef
Date
Author ( sy
Recipient ( s)
Description purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client
Privilege(s) Claimed
17-6
3/20/01
NMC
WL
A/C
17-7
9/Z8/00
NMC
WL
A/C
,,^ l
17-5-9
6/5/00
NMC
Wl.
A/C
17-10
4/24/00
NMC
WL
A/C
17-1112
3/13/00
NMC
WL
A/C
17-1315
2/16/00
NMC
WL
A/C
and attorney.
17-1519 1/17/DD NMC WL Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the A/C
17-20
11/29/99
NMC
WL
A/C
rn ^
^
^
Ref
Date
Author { s)
Recipient(s)
Description purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution #or the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution #or the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter cancerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and inciuding confidentiai communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution far the
Prkvikege(s^
Claimed
18-1
9/10/01
NMC
WL
A/C
18-z
^l/23/01
NMC
WL
A/C
1$-3
4/6/01
NMC
WL
A/C
18-4-5
11/6/00
NMC
WL
A/C
18-6-7
3/13/00
NMC
WL
A/C
18-811
2/16/00
NMC
WL
A/C
^'
18-12IA
i/26/00
NMC
WL
A/C
18-I5^ [3i; ^^
12/6/99
NMC
WL
A/C
^'^ ^^
Ref
Date
Author{s)
Reciplent ( sJ
l]escription purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. bocument concerning patent prosecution or the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning legal research for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including
Privilege(s) Claimed
17
19
12/13/1999 02/17/2002
NMC
WL
A/C
22
22/14/1999
NMC
WL
A/C
23-1
4/10/01
NMC
WL
A/C
23-2
4123/01
NMC
WL
A/C
23-3
4/6/01
NMC
WL
A/C
confidential communications between client
23-4-5 11/6/00 NMC WL and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. A/C
23-6-7
3/7.3/00
NMC
WL
Letter concerning foreign patent
application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and
A/C
.^' .^^. ^^ f^ ^ -tw t i i
Ref
Date
Author(s)
itecipient ( s}
pescription attorney, Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including
Privilege(s) Claimed A/C
23-8
3/9/00
NMC
WL
23-911
2/16/00
NMC
WL
A/C
23-1214
1/26/00
NMC
WL
A/C
24-1
1/29/01
NMC
WL
A/C
24-2
11/3Q/00
NMC
WL
A/C
24-3-4
6/5/00
NMC
WL
A/C
24-5
3/23/00
NMC
WL
A/C
24-fi-7
3/13/00
NMC
WL
A/C
^^ ::^
^-'
i
Ref
Pate
Author( s)
Recipient (s)
Description confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client 'and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning Japanese patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning Japanese patent application far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning Japanese patent application for the purpose of legal advice
Privilege(s) Claimer!
24-8-10
2/16/00
NMC
WL
A/C
2^3-11-13
2/9/QQ
NMC
WL
A/C
24-14-15
2/5/00
NMC
WL
A/C
24-15
2/5/00
NMC
WL
A/C
25-1
9/2b/Q2
NMC
WL
A/C
25-2
7/9/01
NMC
WL
A/C
25-3
3/2/01
NMC
WL
A/C
25-4
7/12/OQ
NMC
WL
A/C
^^ i^ ^ l^ ^ f^ , QQ ^^
i
P
Ref
Date
Author ( s)
Recipient ( s)
Description and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning Japanese patent application far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client
Privilege(s)
CEaimed
2S-S
4/11/00
NMC
WL
A/C
25-6-7
3/13/00
NMC
WL
A/C
and attorney,
25-8 10/8/02 NMC JT, WL Email concerning Japanese patent application for the Purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning Japanese patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning Japanese patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning Japanese patent application. Email concerning Japanese patent application, pocument concerning Japanese patent application, Document [oncerning Japanese patent application. pocument concerning Japanese patent application. A/C
26-1
9/27/02
NMC
JT, WL
A/C
25-2-3
9/26/02
NMC
JT, WL
A/C
26-4
26-5 26-6-7 26-8-9 Z6-1011 `^"C7 l^ i^ ^ l^°'i ^ -^# f ^ ,^
7/2/01 3/2/01 2/28/01 7/12/00 7/^l/00
HO JT NMC(on behalf of WL} NMC(on behalf of WL) Ha
NMC(on behalf of WL} NMC{on behalf of WL} HO HO NMC{on behalf of WL)
A/C A/C
A/C
A/C A/C
Ref 26-1214 26-15-
Date 7/5/00 6/22/00 6/21/00 4/21/00 4/2110© 4/21/00 4/17/00 4/11/00 4/7/00 4/11/00 4/11/00 4/7/00 x/7/00 ^/S/00 9/26/02 HO HO
Author ( s)
Recipient ( s) NMC(gn behalf of WL) NMC( n behalf of WL) HO HO NMC(on behalf of WL} NMC(on behalf of WL) HO HO NMC(on behalf of WL) NMC(on behalf of _ WL) NMC(on behalf of WL) HO NMC(on behalf of WL) HO WL
Description Document concerning Japanese patent application. Letter concerning Japanese patent application, Document concerning Japanese patent appfication. Letter concerning Japanese patent application. Document concerning Japanese patent application. Letter concerning Japanese patent appfication, Letter concerning Japanese patent appfication. Letter cancerning Japanese patent appfication. Letter concerning Japanese patent appfication. Letter concerning Japanese patent application. Letter cancerning Japanese patent application. Letter concerning Japanese patent application. Letter cancerning Japanese patent application. Letter concerning Japanese patent application. Letter concerning trademark application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C
Privilege(s) Claimed
16
26-17-
1$
26-19 26-20 26-21 26-22
NMC(on behalf of Wl.) NMC(on behalf of WL) HQ HO NMC(on behalf of WL) NMC(on behalf of WL) HO HO HO NMC(on behalf of
26-23z^l 26-25
26-26
26-27
26-2829 26-30 26-3 ].33 27-1 °-^ ^ ^^
WL)
HO NMC(an behalf of WL) NMC
^ »+ --^ ^`t C77
^'i^^ r
Ref 27-2
Date 8/21/01 NMC
Author(s) WL
Recipients}
Description Letter concerning trademark application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning trademark application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning trademark application for the purpose of legs ! advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning trademark application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning trademark application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential camrnunications between client and attorney. Letter concerning trademark application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client A/C
Privileges} Claimed
27-3-4
11,/14/01
WL
NMC
A/C
27-5
5/2/41
NMC
WL j
A/C
27-6
11/13/00
NMC
WL
A/C
27-7
10/16/00
NMC
WL
A/C
27-$
9/12/00
NMC
WL
A/C
and attorney,
27-9 5/34/00 NMC WL Letter concerning trademark application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning trademark application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, A/C
Z7-ZO
5/16/00
WL
NMG
A/C
"B l^ .^·-^T f"t""t ^ 0.a !J
Ref
Date 10/4/02 NMC
Author ( s) WL
Recipient ( s)
Description Email concerning trademark and patent applications for the purpose of legal advice and including can#idential communications between client and attorney, Email concerning trademark and patent applications far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attamey. Email concerning trademark and patent applications for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent application far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning patent application for the purpose of legal advice anti including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning pa#ent application far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. bacument concerning patent application including confidential communications between client and attorney. A/C
Privilege(s)
Claimed 28-1
28-2
9/30/02
NMC
WL
A/C
28-3
9/2S/02
NMC
WL
A/C
28-4
4/17/02
NMC
WL
A/C
28-5
8/13/01
NMC
WL
A/C
28-6
8 /28/00
NMC
WL
A/C
28-7
6/5/00
NMC
WL
A/C
28-8 "-C1 ^ ^ J -a-. i^ ^
5/31/00
NMC
WL
A/C
i
Ref 29-1
Date 9/13/40 NMC
Author { s} WL
Recipient { s)
Description Drafts of legal documents including confidentiai communications between client and attorney. Drafts of legal documents including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning Korean patent application. Email concerning Korean patent application. Email concerning Korean patent application, Letter concerning Korean patent application. A/C
Privilege(s) Gaimed
29-2
9/13/04
NMC
WL
A/C
30-1
30-2
30-3 30-4
10/13/04 10/11/04 10/13/04 10/6/04
30-5 30-6-7
10/19/02 10/18/02
Honesty & Patent Honesty & Patent P1E (on behalf of WL) 5e-Chang Kang , Korean patent counsel NMC (on behalf of WL) NMC
PJE (on behal# of WL) PJE {on behalf of WL) Honesty & Patent NMC (nn behalf of WL) YPY YPY, WL
A/C A/C A/C A/C
Email concerning Korean patent application. Email concerning Korean patent application for the purpose of legal advice and inciuding confidential communications between client and attorney, Email concerning Korean patent application far the purpose of legal advice and inciuding confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning Korean patent application. Email concerning Korean patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning Korean patent appiication. Letter concerning Korean patent appiication.
A/C A/C
30_g-9
10/17/02
NMC
YPY, Vti/L
A/C
30-1011
10/17/02 9/26/02
YPY NMC
30-1213
NMC(on behalf of WL) YPY, WL
A/C A/C
30-14
30-15
7/29/02 7/29/02
YPY YPY
NMC(on behalf of W L) NMC{on behalf of W L)
A/C A/C
^^ l^ ^ ^j
ITS
^E
,Ref 30-15 30-1719 30-20-
Date 4/17/02 12/29/01 12/26/41 YPY YPY
Author ( s)
Recplent{s}
NMC(on behalf of WL} NMC{on behalf of W L) NMC{on behalf of WL) NMC(vn behalf of W L} YPY YPY YPY YPY NMC{on behalf of W L} NMC(vn behalf of WL) NMC{on behalf of WL} hionest & Patent NMC(pn behalf of WL} . WL i ^'
Description Letter concerning Korean patent application. Letter concerning Korean patent application. Letter concerning Karean patent application. Letter concerning Korean patent appf'scation. Document concerning Korean patent application, Letter concerning Korean patent application. Letter concerning Karean patent application. Emai chain concerning Korean patent application, Letter concerning Korean patent application, Email concerning Korean patent application. Letter concerning Korean patent application. Email concerning Karean patent application. Letter concerning Korean patent application. Email concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and incuding confidential communications between client and attorney. Errfail concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of egal advice and including confidential communications between client A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C
Privilege(s) Claimed
Honest & Patent YPY NMC(on behalf of
30-21
30-22-
12/2S/O1
12/24/01 12/14/01 12/14/01 12/9/01 11/15/01 11/15/01 11/15/01 11/14/01 11/1/01 10/4/02
23
30-24 30-25-
WL}
NMC(on behalf of W L) NMC(on behalf of WL} NMC{on behalf of WL) YPY YPY YPY NMC Monest & Patent NMC
26
30-2732
30-3334
30-35 30-3b37 30-38 30-3940
31-1
31-2 ^ t^ .^^^
9/30/02
NMC
WL
A/C
`^'
L
i i
1
Ref
Date
Author s}
Recipients}
Description and attorney, Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including
pri^ilege(s} Claimed A/C
31-3
9/26/D2
NMC
WL
confidential communications between Client
31-4 4/17/02 NMC WL and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential comm^Enications between client and attorney, Letter concerning patent prosecution For the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between cl'sent and attorney, Email chaln concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution including confidential communications between client and attorney, Email concerning patent prosecution and legal invoices including confidential A/C
31-5
8/13/01
NMC
WL
A/C
31-5
8/28/00
NMC
WL
A/C
31-7
5/5/02
NMC
WL
A/C
31-$
5/31/01
NMC
WL
A/C
32
10/29/2pD2
NMC
WL
A/C
33
12/27/2002
NMC
WL
A/C
^
^ ..._.. .^
"^ ^ ^
9
Ref
Date
Author ( s)
Recipient(s)
Description
communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution including confidentia[ communications between client and attorney, Email concerning legal invoices including con#idential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney.
Privilege(s)
Claimed
34
06/12/2003
NMC
WL
A/C
35
07/22/2003
WL
NMC
A/C
36
12/D2/2004
NMC
WL
A/C
37
12/03/2004
NMC, WL
WL, NMC
A/C
38
12/03/2004
WL
NMC
A/C
39
12/03/2004
NMC, WL
WL, NMC
A/C
40
12/13/2004
NMC
WL
A/C
41
09/17/200509/20/2005 ^ _^ _W ^^
NMC, WL
WL, NMC
A/C '
^ ^
I^ ,^ ^ i
Ref 42
Date 09/17/200509/23/2005
Author ( s)
NMC, WL
Recip ent(sa WL, NMC
Description Email chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between clien and attorney. Emaif concerning patent prosecution fpr the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning licensing for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between Client and attorney. Email chain concerning patent prosecution and licensing for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning legal invoices including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning legal invoices and patent prosecution including confidential communications between client and A/C
Prl^ilege(s) Claimed
43
1D/06/2DD5
NMC
WL
AC
44
12/20/2005
WL
NMC
A/C
45
12/22/2005
NMC, WL
WL, NMC
A/C
45
02/02/2006
NMC
WL
A/C
47
02/08/2006
NMC, WL
WL, NMC
A/C
48-1
3/3/07
NMC
WL
A/C
48-2
2/26/07
NMC
WL
A/C
`^7 ^
^^ l^ ^ I ,
P '^^ ^_
Ref
Date
Author ( s)
Recipients}
Description attorney. Email concerning legal invoices and patent prosecution including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning legal invoices and patent prosecution including confidential
Arivilege(s}
Claimed
4$-3
2/26/07
NMC
WL
A/C
49-1
2/26/07
WL
NMC
A/C ,^ r A/C
communications between client and
49-2 2/26/07 WL NMC attorney. Email concerning legal invoices and patent prosecution including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning legal invoices and patent prosecution including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning legal invoices and patent prosecution including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning legal invoices and patent prosecution including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning licensing and patent prosecution including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution and legal invoices including confidential communications between client and
49-3
2/26/07
WL
NMC
A/C
50-1
2/27/07
WL
NMC
A/C
50-2
2/27/07
WL
NMC
A/C
50-3
2/27/07
WL
NMC
A/C
51 ^ ^
02/27/2007 ^ ^ .,^..^
NMC
WL
A/C
_.
Ref
Date
Aut;,or(s^
Recipient ( s^
Description attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution and legal invoices including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legs! advice including confidential communications between client and at#orney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between
PriviEege(s) Clairrzed A/C
52
03/02/2007
WL
NMC
53
03/05/2007
WL
NMC
A/C
54
03/06/2007
WL
NMC
A/C
55
03/06/2007
NMC
WL
A/C
55
03/07/2007
WL
NMC
A/C
client and attorney.
57 03/07/2007 NMC WL Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of iegal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidentiai communications between client and attorney. Email concerning prior art for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and A/C
58
03/11/2007
NMC
WL, VL5
A/C
59-1 `>^ r'r"1 ,,^ ..^ ^^ E°^ ^ ^^
3113/07
WL
NMC
A/C
'^ . _^
fief
Date
Author ( s)
Recipient ( s)
Description attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential cammunicatlans between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Emai concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for
Privilege(s)
Claimed
59-2 3/13/07 WL NMC A/C
60-1
3/13/07
NMC
WL
A/C
I
A/C
60-2
3/13/07
NMC
WL
61-1
3/17/07
NMC
WL, VLS
A/C
61-2
3/17/07
NMC
WL, VL5
A/C
67
03/17/2007
WL
NMC
A/C
the purpose of legal advice including
confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning representation including confidential communications between client and attorney.
63
03/17/2007
WL
NMC, VLS
A/C
b4 ,^
03/17/2007
NMC
WL
A/C
^ __^^^ ^ ^^ ^ !S
Ref 65
Date 03/7.7/2007 NMC
Author { s]
Recipient{s)
Description Letter concerning representation including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning representation and patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning representation and patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications ^4^ween client and attorney, Email chain concerning licensing and patent prosecution for the purpose of A/C
Privilege(s)
Gaimed WL
66
03/2fl/2007
WL
NMC, VL5
A/C
67
03/20/2007
NMC
WL
A/C
68
03/21/2007
WL
NMC, VL5
A/C
legal advice including confidential
communications between client and attorney. Email concerning infringement forthe purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning infringement for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning infringement for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution including confidential communications
69
03/26/2007
NMC
WL, VL5
A/C
7D
03/26/2007
WL
NMC, VLS
A/C
71
D3/28/20D7
WL
NMC, VLS
A/C
72--^ 03/29/2007 ^ L ^ r..l._ f "^^ l^_ I Q^ U^ 1^
.. E
!LL
NMC
A/C
Ref:
pate
Author ( sa
Recipient (s)
pescriptlon between client and attorney. Email chain concerning licensing for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between
Privilege(s) Claimed A/C
74
03/30/2007
NMC
WL
client and attorney, 75
03/30/2007 NMC WL, VLS Email chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney. 1=mail [ancerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including [onfidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution including confidentiaE communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between [lient A/C
76
03/30/2007
WL
NMC, VL5
A/C
77
03/30/2007
NMC
WL, VL5, JtL
A/C
7$
03/30/2007
WL
NMC, VLS, JLL
A/C
79
03/30/2007
NMC
WL
A/C
80
03/30/2007
NMC
VLS, JLL
A/C
82
f"T-! X ^
ra...,^ ^^. 7
05/01/2007
WL
NMC
A/C
^
Ref
bate
Author ( s)
recipient(s)
Description
Privilege=s) Claimed A/C
I
83 05/01/2007 NMC WL ^
and attorney.
Email chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney, Email chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attarney. Ernail chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney. Ernail chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attarney, Email chain concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attarney. Email chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning patent
84
05/03/2407
NMC
WL
A/C
85
OS/09/2007
W3.
NMC
A/C
$6
05/18/2007
NMC
WL
A/C
87
07/04/2007
NMC
WL
A/C
88
10/02/2007
NMC
WL
A/C
89
10/02/2007
WL
NMC
A/C
^
rn^ U,^ ^ `
i_
^
Re#
Date
Author ( s)
Recipient(s)
Description prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning patent prosecution for th ^ purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advlce including confidential communications between client and attorney, Emaii concerning representation and patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidenYsal communications between client and attorney. Email concerning representation and patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential
Privilege(s)
Claimed
90
10/03/2007
WL
NMC ^
A/C
91
10/05/2DD7
NMC
WL
A/C
92
10/05/2007
WL
NMC
A/C
93
12/17/2007
NMC
WL
AJC
94
06/il/2D08
WL
NMC
A/C
95
m
06/lA/2008
NMC
WL
A/C
^^ ^. ^.
Ref
Date
Author { s)
Recipient ( s)
Description communications between client and attorney, Email concerning discovery related to the litigation. Email chain concerning representation and patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney.
Pri^iiege(s) Claimed
96
97
10/Z6/Z008 10/27/x008
Christin Cho WL
^}MC NMC
W/P, TPM A/C
^
rn ^ ^ ^^
X ^
1
]]>
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
