Performance Pricing, Inc. v. Google Inc. et al
Filing
241
MOTION to Compel Production of Documents by Third Parties Neal Cohen and Vista IP Law Group, LLP by AOL LLC, Google Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Joint Stipulation Regarding Defendant Google Inc. and AOL LLC's Motion to Compel Production of Documents by Third Parties Neal Cohen and Vista IP Law Group, LLP, # 2 Declaration of Emily C. O'Brien in Support of Motion to Compel, # 3 Exhibit A, # 4 Exhibit B, # 5 Exhibit C, # 6 Exhibit D, # 7 Exhibit E, # 8 Exhibit F, # 9 Exhibit G, # 10 Exhibit H, # 11 Exhibit I, # 12 Exhibit J, # 13 Exhibit K, # 14 Exhibit L, # 15 Exhibit M, # 16 Exhibit N, # 17 Exhibit O, # 18 Exhibit P, # 19 Declaration of Christin Cho in Opposition to Motion to Compel, # 20 Errata 1, # 21 Exhibit 2, # 22 Exhibit 3, # 23 Proposed Order Granting Defendant Google Inc. and AOL LLC's Motion to Compel)(O'Brien, Emily) Modified on 9/25/2009 (sm, ). Modified on 9/25/2009 (sm, ).
x y
C^
Dockets.Justia.com
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS Performance Pricing, Inc. Plaintiff, v. Google, Inc. et a'.,
2:07--car-432 {LED)
PRIVILEGE LOG CORRESPONDING TO: 1) SUBPOENA COMMANDING NON-PARTY NEAL M. COHEN TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS; AND 2 ) SUBPOENA COMi^lANL1ING NON-PARTY VISTA IP LAW GROUP LLP TO PRODUCE nocvMENTs
Defendants.
The Privilege Log attached hereto as Exhibit A i.s being produced in connection with: NON-PARTY NEAL M . 1} RESPONSE TO SUBPOENA COMMANDING and 2) RESPONSE
COI^EN TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS;
TO SUBPOENA CON^iANDING NON-PARTY VISTA TP LAW GROUP LLP TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS. All documents identified in said Privilege
Log are being withheld on the bases identified, and are not being produced. The following abbreviations are used in the Privilege Log: "NMC" means Neal M. Cohen; "WL" means Wayne Lin; _.. _.._^_^^VLS" means Valerie L. Sarigumba, who was at all relevant times an associate attorney at Vista IP Law Group LLP; "J'LL" means Jocelyn L. Lee, who was at all relevant times a senz.or paralegal at Vista IP Law Group LLP;
"A/C" means a claim of Attorney / Client Privilege; "W/P" means a claim of Work Product; "TPM" means a claim of Trial
Prepazation Materials_
^^-^ ^^
Dated Neal M. open
'
/^'^"fig
Dated
^^^
Vista ZP Law Group LLP by Neal M, Cohen
Exhihif A
Date various Piuthor ( s) NMC WL Recipient ( s) Description 27 Word files (letters
Ref 1
Privilege(s)
Claimed A/C, W/P; TPM W/P, TPM A/C, W/P, TPM A/C, W/P, TPM A/C, W/P, TPM A/C, W/P, TPM
2
3 4 5 6
various
various various various various
NMC
NMC NMC NMC NMC
N/A
WL ^
re: D9/342,866} 50 Word files (drafts of legal documents)
40 Word files {letters
re: trademarks}
wz,
^ WZ, WL
^ Word files (letters re: PCT application} 9 Word files {letters
re: patent application}
6 Word files {letters
7
various
NMC
Japanese patent counsel WL
re: Japanese patent application} 7 Word files (letters re: Japanese patent application}
6 Word files (letters
A/C, W/P, TPM
8
various
NMC
A/C, W/P, TPM
9
various
NMC
Korean patent counsel N/A
30
various
NMG
11
various
NMC
W^
re: Korean patent application} 2 Word files (letters re: Korean patent application} 7 Word files (drafts of various legal documents, legal research notes} Z9 word files (letters to client re: various legal matters} Inventor notes / attorney notes
A/C, W/P, TPM
W/P, TPM
A/C, W/P, TPM
l2
06/07/1999
WL
NMC
A/C, W/P, TFM
^' i^
E ^l1
Page 1
Exhibit A
Authors}
WL, NMC, Sam Recipients} WL, NMC, Sam
Ref 13
Date
06/10/1999 -
Description
Attorney notes and
Privilege (s} Claimed
A/C, W/P, TPM
10/09/2002
Stone
Stone
correspondence file re: U.S. Patent application S/N 09/342,865, including 3.5" floppy disk dated 06/15/1999
email w1 attachment re: R/C, W/P, TPM
19
06/19/1999
Sam Stone,
NMC
counsel
patent application (includes email chain from D6/07/1999 06/13/1999 b/t Sam Stone NMC
WL i and WL} Inventor notes
,^
15
16
17
06/28/1999 11/10/1999 11/29/1999 05/07/2002
12/06/1999 -·
WL NMC
A/C, W/P, TPM
A/C, W/P, TPM R/C, W/P, TPM
NMC
WL
hardcopy email letters re: U.S. Trademark Application S/N. 75/695,119
letters re: U.S.
18
NMC
WL
A/C, W/P, TPM
09/10/2001
19 1.2/13/1999 NMC WL
Trademark Application S/N. 75/850,356
Attorney notes and A/C, W/P, TPM
01/17/2002
correspondence file re:
PCT Patent application
2D
21
22
12/7.3/1999 12/13/1999
12/14/1999
NMC NMC
NMC
N/A
N/A WL
S/N PCT/US99/30811 2 text files {drafts of legal documents) 2 Zip file (draft of legal documents)
letter with attached
W/P, TPM W/P, TPM
A/C, W/P, TPM A/C, W/P, TPM
3 ^^
01/26/2000 09/10/2001
NMC
WL
legal research memo letters re: U.S. `Trademark Application S/N. 75/910,fl68
k^} -.^ ^ 1 "
Page 2
Exhibit A
Ref 29 Date 02/05/2000 01/29/2001 Author ( s) NMC
WL
Recipient ( s)
Description hardcopy emails and letters re: U.S. Trademark Applicaticn S/N. 75/925,227 letters and hardcopy emails re: Japanese pat. app. S/N 2000-195293 correspondence re: Japanese pat. app. S/N 2000-195243 letters anct hardcopy emails re: U.S. Trademark Application S/N. 78/010,243 Attorney notes and correspondence file re:
U5 Pat. app. S/N
Privilege(sy Claimed
A/C, W/P, TPM
25
03/13/2000 09/26/2002 09/05/2000 09/27/2002 05/16/2000 09/26/2002
NMC
WL
A/C, W/P, TPM
26
NMC, Japanese patent counsel NMC, WL
NMC, Japanese patent counsel WL, NMC
A/C, W/P, TPM
27
A/C, W/P, TPM
28
05/31./2000 10/09/2002
NMC
WL (some attorney notes have na
recipient)
A/C, W/P, TPM
' 29
30
09/13/2000
11/01/2001 ^
NMC NMC, Korean patent counsel NMC, WL
N/A NMC,IKorean
09/585,902 2 Word files (drafts of
legal documents) correspondence re:
W1P, TPM A/C, W/P, TPM
10/13/2009 37. 11/16/2001 09/26/2002 10/29/2002
12/27/2002 06/12/2003
pateht counsel WL, NMC
32
33
NMC
NMC NNlC
WL
WL
Korean pat. app. S/N 10200J-7016629 letters and hardcopy emails re: Korean pat. app. S/N 10--2001-7016629 email
email email
A/C, W/P, TPM
A/C, W/P, TPM A/C, W/P, TPM A/C, W/P, TPM
34 35 36 3
^^^
.^ r:
07/22/2003 12/02/2009
12/03/2009
WL NMC
NMC, WL WL
WL NMC
WL
email email
email chain
A/C, W1P, TPM A/C, W/P, TPM
A/C, W/P, TPM A/C, W/P, TPM
12/03/2009
WL, NMC NMC
email
Page 3
r:
Exhibit A
Ref 39 Date 12/03/2009Author ( s) NMC, WL WL, Recipient(s) NMC Description Privilege(s) Claimed A/C, W/P, TPM A/C, W/P,
email chain email email chain email chain 1 PF7F file (draft patent drawings)
email
1z/a9/20o4
90 91
42
12/13/2009 09/17/200509/20/2005
09/7.7/200509/23/2005
NMC NMC,
NMC,
wL
WL
WL
WL,
WL, N/A NMC
NMC
NMC
A/C,
A/C, W/P, A/C, A/C, A/C, A/C, A/C, A/C, A/C, A/C, A/C, A/C, A/C, A/C, A/C, A/C,
W/P,
W/P,
TPM TPM
TPM
43 49 45 96 97 98 49 50 51
52
10/06/2005
12/20/2005
NMC
WL
TPM
W/P, W/P, W/P, W/P, W/P, W/P, TPM
12/20/200512/22/2005 02/02/2006 02/08/2006 02/26/2007
02/26/2007
NMC, NMC NMC, NMC
WL WL
WL
WL, WL
NMC
email chain email email chain emails (3) emails (31 emails (3) email
email
TPM TPM TPM TPM
TPM
WL
WL, WL
NMC
NMC
02/27/2007 02/27/2007
03/02/2007
NMC
WL NMC
W/P,
W/P, W/P, W/P, W/P, W/P, W/P, W/P,
NMC
WL WL
TPM TPM
TPM
53 54 55 56
57
03/05/2007 03/06/2007 03/06/2007 03/07/2007
03/07/2007
WL NMC
WL NMC
NMC NMC
WL
NMC ^
WL WL, ^ VLS
58 59
60 61
03/11/2007 03/13/2007
03/13/2007 03/17/2007
NMC
WL NMC NMC WL WL
NMC,
WL WL,
VLS
VL5
email email email email email email emails emails
emails
TPM TPM TPM TPM
TPM
A/C, (21 (21
(21 AtC, A/C, A/C,
W/P, W/P,
W/P, W/P, W/P, w/P, W/P,
TPM TPM
TPM TPM
62 63 69
^"
03/17/2007 03/17/2007 03/17/2007
03/17/2007
NMC
NMC
NMC NMC, WL
WL
VLS
email email Wcrd file (letter)
POF file (letter)
A/C,
A/C, A/C,
TPM TPM TPM
TPM
f'"^-^
.^
03/20/2007 03/20/2007
WL NMC
NMC, WL
VLS
email email
A/C, A/C,
A/C,
W/P,
W/P, W/P,
TPM TPM
cS-' ^
^^
E
Page ^#
exhibit A
Red' Date 03/2]./2007 WL Author ( s)
Recipient ( s)
VLS WL, VL5 NMC, VLS NMC, VL5 NMC, email
Description
68 69
70
Privilege(s) Claimed A/C, W/P, TPM A/C, A/C, W/P, W/P, W/P,
03/26/2007
03/26/2007
NMC
WL WL
emails
emails
71 72 73
03/26/2D07 03/29/2007 03/17/2007 03/30/20D7 03/30/2007
03/30/2007
JLL NMC
NMC
N/A
79
75
NMC
NMC
WL
WL, VLS
emails email 8 Word files [drafts of documents related to patent applications} email
email
(2) {2) (2)
TPM
TPM TPM
A/C,
W/P,
W/P,
TPM TPM
76
77 78
03/30/2007
03/30/2007
WL
NMC WL
NMC,
VLS
emails
emails emails
79 80 81 62
83 89
03/30/2D07 03/30/2007 03/30/2007 03/30/2007 05/01/2007
05/01/2007
WL, VLS, JLL NMC, VLS, JLL WL
[2) (3)
A/C, A/C, A/C, A/C,
W/P,
W/P, W/P, W/P, W/P, W/P,
TPM
TPM
TPM
TPM TPM
(9)
(3}
NMC NMC NMC WL
NMC NMC
VLS,
N/A
JLL
emails email
A/C, A1C,
W/P, W/P, A/C, A/C,
TPM
2 PDE files related to patent applications
TPM TPM
W/P, W/P, W/P,
NMC
WL WL
emails
email email
(2)
TPM
TPM TPM
85
86 67
05/03/2007 05/D9/20D7
05/18/2007
WL
NMC NMC
NMC
WL WL
email email
email
88 89 90 91
92
93
99 5 .,:.. ( _ v ^6 97 ^x
^ ^
07/09/2D07 1D/02/2D07 10/02/2007 10/03/2007 10/05/2007 i0/OS/2007 12/17/2007 D6/11/2006
06/19/2008
A/C, A/C, W/P, A/C, W/P, A/C, W/P,
A/C, A/C, W/P,
TPM
TPM TPM
NMC WL WL NMC
WL
WL NMC NMC WL
NMC
email email email email
email
W/P,
W/P, W/P, W/P, W/P,
A/C,
A/C, A/C, A/C, A/C, A/C,
TPM TPM TPM TPM
'TPM
NMC WL
NMG
WL NMC
WL '.
email email
email
W/P,
W/P, W/P, W/P,
TPM TPM
TPM
10/26/2008 10/27/20D8
Christie Cho WL
NMC' NMC .
email email
A/C,
A/C,
TPM TPM
^' 1
ft f
Page S
i f
E .
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?