Northeastern University et al v. Google, Inc.,

Filing 139

NOTICE of Disclosure by Jarg Corporation, Northeastern University OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT GOOGLE INC.'S PRE-TRIAL DISCLOSURES (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A - Objections to Google's Deposition Designations, # 2 Exhibit B - Objections to Google's Exhibit List)(Glauser, Nicole)

Northeastern University et al v. Google, Inc.,

Doc. 139 Att. 2

ATTACHMENT B: PLAINTIFFS' OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT'S EXHIBIT LIST

Dockets.Justia.com

LEGEND OF OBJECTIONS "A" "B" "C" "D" Lack of authenticity, FED. R. EVID. 901. Not the best evidence, FED. R. EVID. 1002-1004 & 1006. Cumulative, FED. R. EVID. 402 & 403. Subject to a filed/anticipated Daubert motion or motion to exclude. Duplicative. Hearsay, FED. R. EVID. 801-803. Incomplete (necessary additional testimony noted), FED. R. EVID. 106. Defendant has indicated it will provide a replacement copy to remedy blank pages contained within the document/exhibit served by Defendant, FED. R. EVID. 106. Improper opinion testimony from lay witness, FED. R. EVID. 701 & 702. Illegible. Lack of foundation or lack of personal knowledge, FED. R. EVID. 602. Lack scientific reliability, FED. R. EVID. 702 & 703. Multiple documents. Subject to a filed/anticipated Motion in Limine. Subject to a filed/anticipated Motion for (Partial) Summary Judgment. Not properly identified on Defendant's trial exhibit list. Not Relevant, FED. R. EVID. 402. Physical exhibit to which Plaintiffs reserve right to object following exchange of same in accordance with agreement among the parties. Privileged/attorney work-product. Probative value substantially outweighed by danger of unfair prejudice; confusion of issues; waste of time; considerations of undue delay; misleading nature of exhibit or testimony; needless presentation of cumulative evidence, FED. R. EVID. 402 & 403. Not timely produced. Offer of settlement/settlement negotiations, FED. R. EVID. 408.

"Dup." "H" "I" "I*" "IO" "Ill" -

"LF" "LS" "M" -

"ML" "MSJ" "NI" -

"NR" "P" -

"Priv." "PV" -

"T"

-

"408" -

- 2-

Defendant's Exhibit List GN005226-494 GN006340-879 JAR0285474-668 JAR0289215-24 JAR0002539-898 JAR0217059 JAR0027221-22 JAR0000443-48 JAR0063508-11 JAR0058355-406 JAR0000613-15 JAR0045039 JAR0194697-700 JAR0183608-13 JAR0183764-66 JAR0183512-13 JAR0183705-07 JAR0001284-86 GN015842-54 GN093053 GN007147-62 GN443965-4040 GN393392-95 GN345213-15 JAR0436807-08 JAR0368834-98 JAR0294277-332 JAR0556724-35 JAR0438038-40 JAR0295833-34 JAR0295854-55 JAR0294362-68 JAR0438163-64 JAR0292967-69 BL002250-51 JAR0330471-92 DR0019336-37 DR0022204-17

Plaintiffs' Objection(s) no obj. no obj. M no obj. no obj. no obj. no obj. no obj. no obj. no obj. no obj. no obj. NR, PV, ML NR, PV, ML NR, PV, ML NR, PV, ML, Dup. no obj. no obj. no obj. H, LF, Dup. NR, PV no obj. no obj. no obj. Dup. no obj. NR, PV no obj. no obj. no obj. no obj. no obj. NR, PV, ML no obj. NR, PV NR, PV NR, PV, H, MSJ NR, PV, H, MSJ

- 3-

Defendant's Exhibit List JAR0294214-19 FIUR001805-09 JAR0293685-707 BL003034-42 SW00014-18 SW00020-21 SW00036-37 JAR0002624-28 JAR0002629-54 JAR0002685-96 JAR0002716-37 JAR0002697-715 JAR0002738-65 JAR0002766-84 GN003740-55 GN339859, GN482237-41 GN545262-66 GN545303-12 GN506003-17 GN386120-24 GN007468-93 12/13/10 Baclawski Deposition Exhibit 4 JAR0342249-61 12/13/10 Baclawski Deposition Exhibit 12 J. Belanger Deposition Exhibit 10 J. Belanger Deposition Exhibit 11 JAR0285548 JAR0285476-81 JAR0255629-33 JAR0285610-68 GN004029-61 GN004004-28 GN007537-46 TOM002071 GN003766-86 GN003787-96

Plaintiffs' Objection(s) H, ML NR, PV no obj. NR, PV NR, PV, H, MSJ, Dup. NR, PV, H, MSJ NR, PV, H, MSJ, Dup. no obj. no obj. no obj. no obj. no obj. no obj. no obj. NR, PV no obj. no obj. no obj. no obj. H, LF no obj. H, A Dup. no obj. NR, PV, H, ML NR, PV, H, ML no obj. no obj. NR, PV, MSJ, Dup. no obj. no obj. no obj. no obj. H no obj. no obj.

- 4-

Defendant's Exhibit List TOM004675-831 GN467293-307 GN545418-71 GN545493-97 GN546924-57 GN470254-71 GN470396-411 GN470301 GN471082-96 GN470034-95 GN470218-22 GN470223-27 GN471304-17 GN467242 BL000514-26 GN470552-72 GN470494-503 GN470533-51 GN555722-62 GN467420 GN467642-773 GN470034-96 GN470396-411 GN470494-503 GN470533-551 GN471082-96 GN471304-17 GN554282-300 GN000023-32 GN000430-38 GN001256-71 GN001376-91 GN003587-95 GN004029-61 GN004055-65 GN004326-37 GN007087-102 GN007124-32 GN007133-38

Plaintiffs' Objection(s) no obj. LS, NR, PV, ML, D, Dup. LS, NR, PV, ML, D LS, NR, PV, ML, D, Dup. LS, NR, PV, ML, D, NI, Dup. Dup. LS, NR, PV, ML, D, Dup. H LS, NR, PV, ML, D, NI, Dup. LS, NR, PV, ML, D, Dup. LS, NR, PV, ML, D, I, Dup. LS, NR, PV, ML, D, I, Dup. LS, NR, PV, ML, D, Dup. H, LF no obj. LS, NR, PV, ML, D LS, NR, PV, ML, D, Dup. LS, NR, PV, ML, D, Dup. LS, NR, PV, ML, D H, LF no obj. LS, NR, PV, ML, D, Dup. LS, NR, PV, ML, D, Dup. LS, NR, PV, ML, D, Dup. LS, NR, PV, ML, D, Dup. LS, NR, PV, ML, D, NI, Dup. LS, NR, PV, ML, D, NI, Dup. LS, NR, PV, ML, D, Dup. no obj. NR, PV H, NR, PV, MSJ H, NR, PV, ML NR, PV NI I, NI no obj. NI NR, PV NR, PV

- 5-

Defendant's Exhibit List GN007494-97 GN009126-64 GN009263-73 GN012368-72 GN013178-80 GN013181-87 GN014881-85 GN014881-85 GN015351-65 GN015727-44 GN019123-27 JAR0043595-99 GN093053 GN339405-06 GN339408-10 GN342249-61 GN434647-48 GN445423 GN454418-71 GN467213 GN467243-78 GN467279-92 GN467293-307 GN467419 GN467456-60 GN467467-76 GN467477 GN467478 GN467479 GN467480 GN467481-504 GN469963-93 GN469994-95 GN469996-700 GN470001-02 GN470003-05 GN470006-10 GN470011-13 GN470218-27

Plaintiffs' Objection(s) NR, PV I H, LF no obj. H, LF H, LF H, LF, Dup. H, LF, Dup. no obj. no obj. no obj. LF, Dup. H, LF, Dup. NR, PV, H NR, PV, H NI, Dup. NR, PV H, NR, PV, NI LS, NR, PV, ML, D, I* no obj. H, LF LS, NR, PV, ML, D LS, NR, PV, ML, D, Dup. Ill, LF, H LS, NR, PV, ML, D LS, NR, PV, ML, D Ill, LF, H Ill, LF, H Ill, LF, H H, Ill., LF H, LF LS, NR, PV, ML, D LS, NR, PV, ML, D LS, NR, PV, ML, D LS, NR, PV, ML, D LS, NR, PV, ML, D LS, NR, PV, ML, D LS, NR, PV, ML, D LS, NR, PV, ML, D, Dup.

- 6-

Defendant's Exhibit List GN470254-71 GN470306 GN470308 GN470309 GN470315 GN516665-709 GN545493-97 GN546924-57 GN546958-65 GN551875-77 GN551886-89 GN551890-93 GN551909-15 GN551916-26 GN551927-37 GN554118-24 GN554282-99 Hoelzle Deposition Exhibit 100 ICA000031-34 JAR000114-18 JAR000822-27 JAR000828-45 JAR000902-04 JAR002252-67 JAR002800-13 JAR002814-20 JAR002828 JAR043595-99 JAR0118481-89 JAR0183512-13 JAR0205478 JAR0255635-38 JAR00280890 JAR00280892 JAR0280893 JAR0280894 JAR0312328-29 JAR0337521-24 JAR0385542

Plaintiffs' Objection(s) Dup. H, LF, Ill. H, LF, Ill. H, LF, Ill. H, LF, Ill. H, LF LS, NR, PV, ML, D, Dup. LS, NR, PV, ML, D, NI, I*, Dup. LS, NR, PV, ML, D LS, NR, PV, ML, D LS, NR, PV, ML, D LS, NR, PV, ML, D LS, NR, PV, ML, D LS, NR, PV, ML, D LS, NR, PV, ML, D no obj. LS, NR, PV, ML, D, NI, Dup. no obj. no obj. no obj. H, LF no obj. H, LF I* no obj. no obj. I LF, Dup. H, LF NR, PV, ML, Dup. no obj. NR, PV, MSJ, Dup. NR, PV, MSJ NR, PV, MSJ NR, PV, MSJ NR, PV, MSJ NR, PV , ML no obj. NR, PV, LF, ML

- 7-

Defendant's Exhibit List JAR0430227-29 JAR0443578-79 JAR0446841-42 JAR0568806-08 JAR0289691-747 Nicolaou Deposition Exhibit 71 Nicolaou Deposition Exhibit 72 Nicolaou Deposition Exhibit 73 Nicolaou Deposition Exhibit 74 Nicolaou Deposition Exhibit 75 Nicolaou Deposition Exhibit 76 GN443965-4040 GN305686-734 JAR0183073-76 JAR0000611-12 JAR0000259-61 DR003672-73 DR0020946-48 DR0020806-13 DR005702 DR005703-05 DR006559-69 DR006633-39 JAR0436807-08 DR009327-28 WSGH0013-18 TB000010-11 SW00014-18 SW00036-37 SW00035 WS000259 WS000896-97 GN012368-72 GN009168-91 GN009090-114 GN467774-901

Plaintiffs' Objection(s) NR, PV, LF, ML no obj. LF LF NR, PV no obj. no obj. no obj. no obj. no obj. no obj. no obj. no obj. NR, PV ML no obj. NR, PV no obj. no obj. H H no obj. no obj. Dup. no obj. no obj. NR, PV, 408 NR, PV, H, MSJ, Dup. NR, PV, H, MSJ, Dup. NR, PV, H, MSJ LF NR, PV, ML no obj. no obj. no obj. no obj.

- 8-