IP Innovation LLC et al v. Google, Inc.

Filing 74

Supplemental Joint CLAIM CONSTRUCTION and Prehearing Statement filed by IP Innovation LLC, Technology Licensing Corporation, Google, Inc.. (Beck, David)

IP Innovation LLC et al v. Google, Inc.

Doc. 74

T]NITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS

MARSHALL DIVISION
$ $ $ $

IP INNOVATION L.L.C. AND

TECHNOLOGYLICENSINGCORPORATION,
Plaintiffs,
v.

$ $ $
$ $ $ $

CASENO.2:07CV-503-LED

ruRY TzuAL REQUESTED

GOOGLE fNC.,
Defendant.

SUPPLEMENTAL JOINT CLAIM CONSTRUCTION AND PREHEARING STATEMENT
Pursuant to the Court's August 10, 2009 Order, Plaintiffs

IP Innovation L.L.C.

and

Technology Licensing Corporation and Defendant Google Inc. file this Supplemental Joint Claim Construction and Prehearing Statement concerning U.S. Patent Nos. 5,276,785 (the '785

patent). Pursuant to the Court's August 10,2009 Order, the deposition of named '785 patent
inventor Jock Mackinlay took place after the parties filed their initial Joint Claim Construction

and Prehearing Statement. The parties respectfully submit this supplemental statement to

identiff the portions of Dr. Mackinlay's testimony on which they will rely to support their
respective proposed constructions.

Google's Supplemental Statement Google

will rely on the following testimony of Dr. Mackinlay to support its proposed

constructions for the following disputed claim terms, phrases, or clauses of the '785 patent:

o

point of interest (claims 52 and 55): (Mackinlay Dep. 195:17-196:5.)

USIDOCS 7284752v1

Dockets.Justia.com

. . o o o .

viewpoint coordinate data (claims 1 and 52): (Mackinlay Dep. 195:17-196:5.)

user input means for providing signals (claim 52): (Mackinlay Dep. 195:17196:5.) the user can request viewpoint motion and point of interest motion independently

(claim 52) : (Mackinlay Dep.

143

:20-25, I 45

:7

-25, 1 461 I -l

47 :7)

viewpoint motion (claims 1,28, 42, 52 and 55): (Mackinlay Dep. 143:12-14,
143

:16-19, 195 :17 -196:5.)

point of interest motion (claim 52): (Mackinlay Dep. 195:17-196:5.)
ray (claim 55): (Mackinlay Dep. 195:17-196:5.)

Plaintiffs' Supplemental Statement
Plaintiffs may rely on the following testimony of Dr. Mackinlay

to

support Their

proposed constructions for the following disputed claim terms, phrases, or clauses of the '785 patent:

. o o .

user input means for providing signals (claim 52): Mackinlay Dep. at 52:2-24,
I 09 : l

-25, I I I :4 - 12,

21 4 :7 -21 6

:l l,

221 :8 -222 :2

motion requesting signal set (claim 52): Mackinlay Dep. at 52:2-24, 709:1-25,
III
:

4

-12,

21 4 :7 -21 6

:l l, 22t :8 -222:2

the user can request viewpoint motion and point of interest motion independently

(claim 52):56:2-16 viewpoint motion (claims I,28,42,52 and 55): Mackinlay Dep. at 46:6-24,56:2-

t6

USIDOCS 7284752v1

The parties expressly reserve the right to rely on any intrinsic and extrinsic evidence
identified by the other party, and any evidence obtained, or that may be obtained, through claim
construction discovery. The parties expressly reserve the right to amend, correct, or supplement

their claim construction positions and supporting evidence in response to any change of position

by the other party, in response to information received through claim construction discovery,

including inventor depositions and expert depositions concerning claim construction
declarations, or for other good cause.

Dated: September 4, 2009

Respectfully submitted, By: /s/ Dqvid J. Mahalek
Raymond P. Niro Joseph N. Hosteny Arthur A. Gasey Paul C. Gibbons Douglas M. Hall David J. Mahalek NIRO, SCAVONE, HALLER & NIRO 181 V/est Madison, Suite 4600 Chicago, Illinois 60602 Telephone: [phone] Facsimile: [phone]

T. John V/ard Ward & Smith I l1 V/. Tyler St. Longview, Texas 75601 Telephone: [phone] Toll Free [phone] Facsimile: (903) 7 57 -2323 Eric M. Albritton [e-mail] Attomey atLaw P.O. Box 2649 Longview, TX75606 Telephone: [phone] Facisimile: (903) 7 58-7397

ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFFS AND COUNTER.CLAIM DEFENDANTS IP INNOVATION L.L.C. AND TECHNOLOGY LICENSING CORPORATION

USIDOCS 7284752v1

Dated: September 4, 2009

Respectfu

lly submitted,

By: /s/ David J. Beck David J. Beck Texas Bar No. 00000070 [e-mail] Michael E. Richardson Texas Bar No. 24002838 mrichardson@brsfirm. com BECK, REDDEN & SECREST, L.L.P. One Houston Center l22lMcKinney St., Suite 4500 Houston, T){.. 77010 (713) 9st-3700 (713) 9sr-3720 (Fax)

Mark G. Matuschak (admittedpro hac vice) WILMER CUTLER PICKERING HALE AND DORR LLP
60 State Street Boston, MA 02109 (617) s26-6000 (617) s26-s000 (Fax)
John M. Híntz (admittedpro hac vice) Victor F. Souto (admittedpro hac vice) Ross E. Firsenbaum (admittedpro hac vice)

WILMER CUTLER PICKERING HALE AND DORR LLP 399 Park Avenue New York, NY 10022 (2r2)230-8800 (2r2)230-8888 (Fax)
ELizab efh Ro gers B rannen (admitted p r o
h øc v ic

e)

Anna T. Lee (admittedpro hac vice) WILMER CUTLER PICKERING HALE AND DORR LLP 1117 California Avenue Palo Alto, CA94304 (6s0) 8s8-6042 (6s0) 8s8-6100 (Fax)

ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT AND COUNTER.CLAIM PLAINTIFF GOOGLE INC.

4
USIDOCS 7284752v1

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
The undersigned hereby certifies that the foregoing document was filed electronically in compliance with Local Rule CV-5(a). As such, this motion was served on all counsel who have consented to electronic service. Local Rule CV-S(aX3XA).

/s/ Brad Co-{fe:t Brad Coffey

USlDOCS 7284752v1