Software Rights Archive, LLC v. Google Inc. et al

Filing 218

MOTION to Strike 198 Opposed MOTION Granting Defendants Leave to Amend and Supplement Invalidity Contentions by Software Rights Archive, LLC. Responses due by 2/2/2010 (Attachments: # 1 Affidavit Declaration of L Kaplan, # 2 Exhibit 1, # 3 Exhibit 2, # 4 Exhibit 3, # 5 Exhibit 4, # 6 Exhibit 5, # 7 Exhibit 6, # 8 Exhibit 7, # 9 Text of Proposed Order)(Kaplan, Lee)

Software Rights Archive, LLC v. Google Inc. et al

Doc. 218 Att. 5

Exhibit 4

Dockets.Justia.com

.

{

.

.INVALIDITYCLAIM CHART FOR U$.PATENT No. 5,544,352
O F CERTAIN EXEMPLARY COMBINATIONS

Each reference identified as anticipatory of any claim herein in Defendants' P. R. 3-3 Disclosure also renders such claim . obvious alone and in view of any of the one or more other references as identified in the chart below. In addition, combinations of two or more of the referepcesidentified in the chart below render the claims obvious.

Salton, 1971 ;Garfield. 1975;FoxJSmart, 1983;Fox Collections, 1983;Fox Thesis, 1983;Fox, 1984;Fox, 1985;Armstrong, 1988;Fox, 1988;Croft, 1989;Croft, Lucia, 1989;Frisse/Cousins, 1989;Thompson, 1989;Kommers, 1990;Nielsen, 1990b;Berk, 1991 ;Dunlop, 1991 ;Turtle, 1991 ;Turtle & Croft, 1991 ;Shaw Part I, 1991 ;Shaw Part II, 1991 ;Betrabet, 1993;Brunei, 1993;Bourne and Hahn, 2003;TIP;Frei & Steiger, 1992;Shimko, 1974;Blchteler & Eaton. 19n;Salton, 1970;Salton and McGill. 1983;Salton. 1968;Tapper, 1982;Frlsse, 1988;Salton, 1963;Kochtanek, 1982;Gelbart, 1991 ;Croft, 1993;Goffman, 1969;Pinski, 1976;Garner, 1967;Botafogo, 1992;Alaln, 1992;Shepherd, 1990;Schiminovich, 1971 ;Guinan. 1992;Salton, 1988;Nlelsen, 1990;Burt, 1991 ;Lucarella, 1990;U.S. Pat. No. 5,446,891 ;Rose, . 1989;UCINET, 1992;Belew, 1986;Salton, 1975;Rose. 1991 ;Plrolli, 19996;Bichteler & Parsons. 1974:Rada: 1991 :lnlermedia;Chen Thesis. 1992;Welss. 1996: ENVISION:SMARl Kessler, 1967;Salton, 1971 ;Garfield, 1979;FoxiSmart. 1983;Fox Collections, 1983;Fox [26aJ marking objects in the database so that each marked object may be individually identified by a Thesis, 1983;Fox, 1964;Fox, 1985;Armstrong, 1988;Fox, 1988;Croft. 1989;Croft, Lucia, 1989;Frisse/Cousins, 1989;Thompson, 1989;Kommers,1990;Nielsen~ 1990b;Berk, cornpl.lterized search; 1991 ;Dunlop, 1991 ;Turtle, 1991 ;Turtle & Croft, 1991 ;Shaw Part I, 1991 ;Shaw Part II, 1991 ;Betrabet, 1993;Brunei, 1993;Bourne and Hahn, 2003;TIP;Frei & Steiger, 1992;Shimko, 1974;Bichteler & Eaton, 19n;Salton. 1970;Salton and McGill. 1983;Salton. 1968;Tapper, 1982;Frisse, 1988;Salton, 1963;Kochtanek, 1982·;Gelbart, 1991 ;Croft, 1993;Goffman. 1969;Pinski, 1976;Garner. 1967;A1ain. 1992;Shepherd. 1990;Gliinan, 1992;Salton, .1988;Nielsen, 1990;Burt, 1991 ;Lucarella, 1990;U.S. Pat. No. 5,446,891 ;Rose, 1989;UCINET, 1992;Belew, 1986;Rose. 1991 ;Pirolli, 19996;Bichteler & Parsons. 1974;Rada, ·1991 ;lntermedia;Chen Thesis, 1992;ENVISION;SMART . Kessler, 1967;Salton, 1971;Garfield. 1979;FoxJSmart, 1983;Fox Collections, 1983;Fox .[26b] creating a first numerical representation for Thesis, 1983;Fox, 1984;Fox, 1985;Armstrong, 1988;Fox, 1988;Croft. 1989;Croft, Lucia, each. identified object in the database based upon ·1989;Frlsse/Cousins. 1989;Thompson, 1989;Kommers, 1990;Nielsen. 1990b;Berk. the object's direct relationship with other objects ·in 1991 ;Dunlop, 1991 ;Turtle, 1991 ;Turtle & Croft, 1991 ;Shaw Part 1,1991 ;Shaw Part II, the databa~e; 1991;Chen. 1992;Betrabet, 1993;Brunei, 1993;Bourne and Hahn. 2003;TIP;Frei & Steiger, 1992;Shimko, 1974;Bichteler & Eaton. 1 9 n ; s a l t o n , 1970;Salton and McGill, 1983;Salton,

26. A non-semantical method for numerically representing objects in a computer database and for computerized searching of the numerically represented objects in the database, wherein direct and indirect relationships exist between objects in the database, comprising:

1

1968;Tapper, 1982;Fi'isse, 1988;Salton, 1963;Kochtanek, 1982;Gelbart, 1991 ;Croft, 1993;Goffman, 1969;Plnskl, 1976;Gamer, 1967;Botafogo,1992;Shepherd, . 1990;Schlminovlch, 1971 ;Guinan, 1992;Salton, 1988;Nielsen, 1990;Burt, 1991 ;Lucarella. 1990;U.S. Pat. No. 5,446,891;Rose,1989;UCINET, 1992;Belew, 1986;Rose, 1991;Pirolli, 19996;Bichteler & Parsons. 1974;Rada, 1991 ;lntermedia;Chen Thesis, 1992; Weiss. 1996; ENVISION;SMART [26c] storing the frrst numerical representations for Salton, 1971 :Garfield, 1979;FoxlSmart, 1983;Fox Collections, 1983;Fox Thesis, 1985;Fox, 1984;Fox, 1985;Armstrong, i988;Fox, 1988;Croft, 1989;Croft, Lucia, 1989;Frisse/Couslns, use in computerized searching; 1989;Thompson. 1989;Kommers, 1990;Nielsen, 1990b;Berk, .1991 ;Dunlop, 1991 ;Turtle, 1991 ;Turtle & Croft, 1991 ; S M w Part I, 1991 ;Shaw Part II, 1991 ;Chen, 1992;Betrabet, 1993;Brunel, 1993;Bourne and Hahn. 2003;TIP;Frei & Steiger, 1992;Shimko, 1974;Bichteler & Eaton, 1977;Salton, 1970;Salton and McGill, 1983;Salton, 1968;Tapper, 1982;Frisse, 1988;Salton, f963;Kochtanek, 1982;Gelbart, 1991 ;Croft, 1993;Goffman, 1969;Pinski, 1976;Garner, 1967;Botafogo, 1992;Shepherd. 1990;SChlmlnovich, 1971 :Guinan, 1992;Salton, 1988;Nlelsen. 1990;Burt, 1991 ;Lucarella, 1990;U.S. Pat No. 5,446,891; Rose, 1989;UCINET,1992;Belew, 1986;Rose, 1991;Pirolli, 19996;Blchteler & Parsons. 1974;Rada, 1991 ;lntermedia;Chen Thesis, 1992; Weiss, 1996; ENVISION;SMART Salton, 1971 ;Garfield, 1979;FoxlSmart, 1983;Fox Collections, 1983;Fox Thesis, 1983;Fox, [26<1] analyzing the flfSt numerical representations for indirect relationships existing between or among 1984;Fox,' 1985;Armstrong, 1988;Fox, 1988;Croft, 1989;Croft, Lucia, 1989;Frisse/Cousins, 1989;Thompson, 1989;Kommers, 1990;Nielsen, 1990b;Berk, 1991;Dunlop, 1991;Turtle, objects in the database; 1991 ;Turtle & Crott, 1991 ;Shaw Part I; 1991;Shaw Part H, 1991 ;Chen,1992;Betrabet, 1993;arunel, 1993;Bourneand Hahn,2003;TIP;Frel & Steiger, 1992;Shimko, 1974;Bichteler & Eaton; 19n;Salton, 1970;salton and McGill, 1983;Salton, 1968;Tapper, 1982;Frlsse, 1988;Salton, 1963;Kochtanek, 1982;Gelbart. 1991 ;Croft, 1993;Goffman, 1969;Pinskl, 1976;Garner, 1967;Botafogo, 1992;Shepherd, 1990;Schiminovich, 1971 ;Guinan, 1992;salton, 1988;Nielsen, 1990;Burt, 1991 ;Lucarella, 1990;U.S. P a t No. 5,446,891 ;Rose, . 1989;UCINET, 1992;Belew, 1986;Salton, 1975;Rose, 1.991 ;Plrolli, 1999~;Blchteler & Parsons, 1974;Rada.1991 ;lntermedla;Chen Thesis, 1992;Weiss. 1996: ENVISION:SMART [26e] gen~rating a second numerical represenlation salton, 1971 ;Garfield,1979;FoXlSmart, 1983;FoxCollections, 1983;Fox Thesis, 1963;Fox, 1984;Fox, 1985;Armstrong, 1988;Fox, 1988;Croft, 1989;Croft, Lucia, 1989;Frlsse/Cousins, of each object based on the analysis of the fItst 1989;Thompson, 1989;Kommers, 1990;Nlelsen, 1990b;Berk, 1991 ;Dunlop, 1991 ;Turtle, numerical representation; . 1991;Turtle & Croft, 1991 ;Shaw Part 1,1991 ;Shaw Part II, 1991;Chen, 1992;Betrabet, 1993;Brunei, 1993;Bourne and Hahn, 2003;TIP;Frei & Steiger, 1992;Shimko, 1974;Bichteler & Eaton, 19n;salton, 1970;Salton and McGill,1983;Salton, 1968;Tapper. 1982;Frisse, 1988;Salton, 1963;Kochtanek, 1982;Croft. 1993;Goffman, 1969;Plnski, 1976;Garner, 1967;Botafogo, 1992;Shepherd, 1990;Schiminovich, 1971;Guinan, 1992;Salton, 1988;Burt, 1991;Lucarella, 1990;U.S. Pat. No. 5,446,891;Rose. 1989;UCINET, 1992;Belew, 1986;SaI10n, 1975;Rose, 1991;Pirolli, 19996;Bichteler & Parsons. 1974;Rada,

2

1991 :lntermedla;Chen Thesis; 1992: Wels5. 1996: ENVISION:SMART ;Salton, 1971 ;Garfield. 1979;FoxlSmart, 1983;Fox Collections, 1983;Fox Thesis, 1983;Fox, [26f] storing the second numerical representation 1984;Fox, 19a5;Armstrong, 1988;Fox, 1988;Croft, 1ge9;Croft, Lucia, 1989;Frlsse/Cousins, for use i n computerized searching; and 1989;Thompson, 1989;Kommers, 1990;Nielsen, 1990b;Berk, 1991;Dunlop, 1991;Turtle, 1991 ;Turtle & Croft. 1991 ;Shaw Part I, 1991 ;Shaw Part II. 1991 ;Chen, 1992;Betrabet, 1993;Brunei, 1993;Boume and Hahn, 2003;T/P;Frei & Steiger, 1992;Shimko, 1974;Bichteler & Eaton, 19n;Salton, 1970;Salton and MCGill, 1983;Salton, 1968;Tapper, 1982;FriSS8, 1988;Salton, 1963;Kochtanek, 1982;Gelbart, 1991 ;Croft; 1993;Goffman, 1969;Pinski, 1976;Garner, 1967;Botafogo, 1992;5hepherd, 1990;S.chiminovich, 1971 ;Guinan, 1992;5alton, 1988;Nielsen, 1990;Burt, 1991 ;Lucarella, 199();U.S. Pat. No. 5,446,891 ;Rose, 1989;UCINET, 1992;Belew, 1966;5alton, 1975;Rose, 1991 ;Pirolli. 19996;Bichteler & Parsons, 1974;RM<:i, 1991 ;lntermedia;Chen Thesis. 1992: Weiss. 1996: ENVISrON:SMART [26g] searching the objCcts in the database using a Salton, 1971 ;Garfield, 1979;FoxlSmart. 1983;Fox Collections, 1983;Fox Thesis, 1983;Fox, computer and the stored second numerical .1984;Fox, 1985;Armstrong, 1986;Fox, 1988;Croft, 1989;Croft, Lucia, 1989;Frisse/Cousins, representations, wherein the search identifies one or 1989;Thompson, 1989;Kommers, 1990;Nielsen, 1990b;Berk, 1991 ;Dunlop, 1991 ;Turtle. more o f the objects in the database 1991 ;TurtJe & Croft, 1991 ;Shaw Part I, 1991 ;Shaw Part H, 1991 ;Chen, 1992;Betrabet, 1993;Brunei, 1993;Bourne and Hahn, 2003;TIP;Frei & Steiger, 1992;5hlmko. 1974;Bichteler . . & Eaton, 1977;Salton, 1970;5alton and McGill, 1983;Salton, 1968;Tapper. 1982;Frisse, 1988;Salto", 1963;Kochtanek, 1982;Gelb,art, 1991 ;Croft, 1993;Goffman,·1969;Plnski, 1976;Garner. 1967;A/a/n, 1992;Shepherd, 1990;Schiminovich; 1971;Guinan, 1992;Salton, 1988;Burt, 1991;Lucarella, 1990;U.S. Pat No. 5,446;891;Rose, 1989;UCINET. 1992;Belew, 1986;Salton, 1975;Rose, 1991 ;Pirolli, 19996;Blchteler & Parsons, 1974;Rada. 1991 :lntermedla:ChEm Thesis. 1992: Weiss. 1996: ENVISION:SMART Kessler, 1967;Salton;-197f;Gai'fleid,1979;FoX!Smart; 1983;Fox Collections, 1983;Fox 27; The non-semanticalmethod o f claim 26, Thesis, 1983;Fox, 1964;Fox, 1985;Armstrong,1988;Fox, 1968;Croft, 1989;Croft, Lucia, .wherein the objects i n the database include words, 1989;Frisse/Cousins, 1989;Thompson. 1989;Kommers, 1990;Nielsen, 1990b;Berk. and semantic indexing techniques are used i n . 1991 ;Dunlop, 1991 ;Turtle, 1991 ;Turtle & Croft. 1991 ;Shaw Part 1.1991 ;Shaw Part II, combination with the non-semantical method, the . 1991 ;Betrabet, 1993;Brunei, 1993;Bourneand Hahn, 2003;TIP;Shlmko, 1974;Salton, method further comprising the step o f creating and 1970;Salton and McGill, 1983;5alton, 1968;Tapper, 1982;Frlsse, 1988;Salton; storing a Boolean word index for the words o f the 1963;Kochtanek, 1982;Gelbart, 1991 ;Croft, 1993;Goffman, 1969;Alaln, 1992;Shepherd, objects in the database. 1990;Schlminovich. 1971 ;GlJinan, 1992;5alton, 1988;Lucarella, 1990;Rose, 1989;Belew, 1986;Rose, 1991 ;Pirolli. 19996;Blchteler & Parsons, 1974;Rada, 1991 ;lntermedla;Chen Thesis. 1992;Weiss, 1996; ENVISION:SMART . 28. The non-semantical method o f claim 26 wherein Salton, 1971 ;FoxlSmart, 1983;Fox Collections, 1983;Fox Thesis, 1983;Fox, 1984;Fox, 1985;Armstrong, 1988;Fox, 1988;Croft, Lucia, 1989;Frisse/Cousins, 1989;Thompson, the flrst and second numerical representationS are 1989;Kommers, 1990;Berk, 1991 ;Dunlop, 1991 ;TurtJe, 1991 ;Turtle & Croft, 1991 ;Shaw Part vectors that are arranged in fU'St and second I, 1991 ;Shaw Part II, 1991 ;Betrabet, 1993;Frei & Steiger, 1992;Shimko, 1974;Salton, mattices; 1970;Salton and McGIlI,1983;Salton. 1968;Tapper, 1982;Salton, 1963;Gelbart, 1991 ;Croft,

3