Rockstar Consortium US LP et al v. Google Inc

Filing 282

SUR-REPLY to Reply to Response to Motion re 220 MOTION to Amend/Correct Invalidity Contentions filed by NetStar Technologies LLC, Rockstar Consortium US LP. (Attachments: # 1 Affidavit of Meng Xi, # 2 Exhibit A, # 3 Exhibit B, # 4 Exhibit C, # 5 Exhibit D, # 6 Exhibit E)(Xi, Meng)

Download PDF
Exhibit A Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 1 of 24 PageID #: 7750 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS MARSHALL DIVISION FUNCTION MEDIA, L.L.C., Civil Case No. 2:07-cv-279 (CE) v. JURY TRIAL DEMANDED GOOGLE, INC. AND YAHOO!, INC. GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 Google Inc. hereby provides and/or confirms its written notice pursuant to 35 U.S.C. § 282 of the patents and publications that it may rely upon to anticipate, render obvious or show the state of the art with respect to United States Patent No. 6,446,045 (“the `045 patent”), United States Patent No. 7,240,025 (“the `025 patent”), and United States Patent No. 7,249,059 (“the `059 patent). Google Inc. may also rely on the person(s) listed below as being prior inventors or having prior knowledge of or as having previously used or offered for sale the invention of the patents-in-suit. In addition to the items expressly listed in this notice, Google Inc. also incorporates by reference, all information set forth in the expert reports which Google Inc. will be submitting in this matter, and the file histories and reexaminations for each of the asserted patents. GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 1 Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 2 of 24 PageID #: 7751 I. PATENTS AND PRINTED PUBLICATIONS ON WHICH GOOGLE INTENDS TO RELY ON AT TRIAL TO ANTICIPATE OR RENDER OBVIOUS THE ASSERTED PATENTS A. Patents TITLE COUNTRY DATE U.S. Patent No. 5,918,014 – Automated Collaborative Filtering in World Wide Web Advertising [G025074-G025086] U.S. Patent No. 5,948,061 – Method of Delivery, Targeting, and Measuring Advertising Over Networks [G000550G000561] U.S. Patent No. 6,026,368 – On-Line Interactive System and Method for Providing Content and Advertising Information to a Targeted Set of Viewers [G000597-G000623] U.S. Patent No. 6,401,075 – Methods of Placing, Purchasing and Monitoring Internet Advertising [G001011-G001017] U.S. Patent No. 6,985,882 – Method and System for Selling and Purchasing Media Advertising Over a Distributed Communication Network [G001178G001227] WO 97/21183 – Method and System for Placing Advertisements in a Computer Network [G000170-G00246] USA 06/29/1999 Gary B. Robinson USA 09/07/1999 Dwight Allen Merriman and Kevin Joseph O’Connor USA 02/15/2000 Yale Robert Brown and Matthew Brown Walker USA 06/04/2002 USA 01/10/2006 James C. Mason, John Grant, Arnold Behrman and Dennis Stillwell Justin Del Sesto Int’l 06/12/1997 B. INVENTOR(S) Sharmin Naqvi and Tomasz Imielinski Systems and Printed Publications PRINTED PUBLICATION/SYSTEM DATE AUTHOR(S) Advertising on the Internet, John Wiley & Sons [G018953-G019257] 1997 Zeff, Robbin and Aronson, Brad Advertising on the Internet, John Wiley & Sons [G018509-G018952] 1999 Zeff, Robbin and Aronson, Brad Unintrusive Customization Techniques for Web Advertising, 31 Computer Networks, pp. 1259–1272 [G016452-G016465] 05/1999 Langheinrich, et al. GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 2 Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 3 of 24 PageID #: 7752 PRINTED PUBLICATION/SYSTEM DATE AUTHOR(S) User Guide: A Complete Guide to AdForce, Version 2.6 [G005430G00714] 1998 AdForce, Inc. Passing and using multiple parameters in AdForce tags [G005733-G005740] November 17, 1998 AdForce, Inc. Guidelines for Creating and Submitting Creatives [G008119G008133] January 8, 1999 AdForce, Inc. Information Access Technologies, Inc., Aaddzz Brochure [G005296G005301] 1997 IAT, Inc. AdKnowledge, Campaign Manager: Reviewer's Inc., Guide [G014779-G014801] AdKnowledge System AdKnowledge, Inc. MarketMatch Planner: Reviewer's Guide [G014856-G014881] 1996 AdKnowledge 1996 AdKnowledge, Inc. NetGravity, Inc., AdServer System NetGravity AdServer v. 3.5, User Assistance Guide [G017154G017482] 1998 NetGravity, Inc. DoubleClick, Inc., DART System DART User Manual [G003512G003587] 1998 DoubleClick, Inc. DoubleClick DART Brochure [G014967-G14989] 1998 DoubleClick, Inc. DoubleClick University: Essential DART Concepts Student Guide, Version 2 [GGL-FM0040181-GGLFM0040220] 1998 DoubleClick, Inc. Page 40 from DoubleClick University: Essential DART Concepts Student Guide, Version 2, and Exhibit 616 1998 DoubleClick, Inc. DART for Advertisers Quick Reference Cards [GGLFM0040221-GGL-FM0040239] 1998 DoubleClick, Inc. AdForce IAT, Inc., Aaddzz System GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 3 Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 4 of 24 PageID #: 7753 PRINTED PUBLICATION/SYSTEM DATE AUTHOR(S) DART for Advertisers Trafficking Training [GGL-FM0040240-GGLFM0040271]I DART for advertisers [G004607 – 97] DoubleClick from December 6, 1998, “Standard Ad Sizes" [G015162 – 63] DoubleClick from December 5, 1998, “DART FAQ” [G015095 – 97] Local Resellers Guide, February 1999 [G003851 – 3942] DoubleClick from December 6, 1998, “Ad Trafficking: Sending GIF/JPEG Files" [G015008 – 09] Local Resellers Manual [G003818 – 3843; Kdelfa00000397] 1998-1999 DoubleClick, Inc. 12/6/98 DoubleClick, Inc. DART for Advertisers (DFA5) Reports and User interface [G002-000710691 – 98] Training Manual [G004162 – 4293] FAQ [G004581 – 4603] Documentation Projects, Feb. 1999 [G004016 – 4700] DoubleClick, Inc. DoubleClick, Inc. 2/99 DoubleClick, Inc. 12/6/98 DoubleClick, Inc. 1999 DoubleClick, Inc. 1999 DoubleClick, Inc. 02/99 02/99 02/99 DoubleClick, Inc. DoubleClick, Inc. DoubleClick, Inc. “Welcome To DoubleClick" [G015018 – 94 ] Ad-Star, Inc., Ad-Star System 12/5/98 1996 DoubleClick, Inc. Ad-Star Orange County Register User's Manual [Depo Exh. 167] 1996 Ad-Star, Inc. Ad-Star.com website archive from www.archive.org [Depo Exh. 169] 04/12/1997 and 02/01/1997 06/1998 Ad-Star, Inc. Baseview Products, Inc. 06/1998 Baseview Products, Inc. AdManagerPro AdManagerPro Administrator's Manual, Version 2.0 [G068214G068440] AdManagerPro User Manual, v. 2.0 [G068441-G068566] GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 4 Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 5 of 24 PageID #: 7754 II. PATENTS AND PRINTED PUBLICATIONS ON WHICH GOOGLE MAY RELY AFTER THE COURT CONSTRUES THE LIMITATIONS OF THE ASSERTED CLAIMS OR TO SHOW STATE OF THE ART A. Patents TITLE COUNTRY DATE INVENTOR(S) U.S. Patent No. 5,347,632 – Reception System for an Interactive Computer Network and Method of Operation USA 09/13/1994 U.S. Patent No. 5,710,884 – System for Automatically Updating Personal Profile Server with Updates to Additional User Information Gathered from Monitoring User’s Electronic Consuming Habits Generated on Computer During Use[G025040-G025063] U.S. Patent No. 5,724,521 – Method and Apparatus for Providing Electronic Advertisements to End Users in a Consumer Best-Fit Pricing Manner [G000381-G000399] U.S. Patent No. 5,819,092 – Online Service Development Tool with Fee Setting Capabilities [G000424-G000471] U.S. Patent No. 5,848,396 – Method and Apparatus for Determining Behavioral Profile of a Computer User [G000472G000502] U.S. Patent No. 5,933,811 – System and Method for Delivering Customized Advertisements within Interactive Communication Systems [G000524G000549] U.S. Patent No. 5,937,392 – Banner Advertising Display System and Method with Frequency of Advertisement Control [G025087-G025097] U.S. Patent No. 5,999,912 – Dynamic Advertising Scheduling, Display, and Tracking [G025110-G025116] U.S. Patent No. 6,014,638 – System for USA 01/20/1998 Robert Filepp, Michael L. Gordon, Alexander Bidwell, Francis Young, Allan M. Wolf, Sam Meo, Duane Tiemann, Robert D. Cohen, Mel Bellar, Kenneth H. Appleman, Lawrence Abrahams, Michael J. Silfen Rick Dedrick USA 03/03/1998 Rick Dedrick USA 10/06/1998 Charles H. Ferguson and Randy J. Forgaard USA 12/08/1998 Thomas A. Gerace USA 08/03/1999 Paul D. Angles and Douglas O. Blattner USA 08/10/1999 Charles D. Alberts USA 12/07/1999 Dennis Wodarz, Donald L. Fairall and Douglas Hall USA 01/11/2000 Gary L. Burge and William GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 5 Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 6 of 24 PageID #: 7755 TITLE Customizing Computer Displays in Accordance with User Preferences [G025117-G025126] U.S. Patent No. 6,026,369 – Method for Distributing Advertising in a Distributed Web Modification System [G000624G000630] U.S. Patent No. 6,044,376 – Content Stream Analysis [G000631-G000640] U.S. Patent No. 6,047,310 – Information Disseminating Apparatus for Automatically Delivering Information to Suitable Distributees [G025161-G025194] U.S. Patent No. 6,112,192 – Method for Providing Indivudally Customized Content in a Network U.S. Patent No. 6,128,663 – Method and Apparatus for Customization of Information Content Provided to a Requestor Over a Network Using Demographic Information Yet the User Remains Anonymous to the Server [G025195-G025217] U.S. Patent No. 6,134,532 – System and Method for Optimal Adaptive Matching of Users to Most Relevant Entity and Information in Real-Time [G000676G000715] COUNTRY DATE INVENTOR(S) A. Luddy USA 02/15/2000 Peter George Capek USA 03/28/2000 Stephen J. Kurtzman, II USA 04/04/2000 Akira Kamakura, Hideo Oneda and Hideki Tanaka USA 08/29/2000 Peter George Capek USA 10/03/2000 C. Douglass Thomas USA 10/17/2000 U.S. Patent No. 6,144,944 – Computer System for Efficiently Selecting and Providing Information [G000716G000734] U.S. Patent No. 6,167,382 – Design and Production of Print Advertising and Commercial Display Materials Over the Internet [G000762-G000818 U.S. Patent No. 6,188,396 – Targeting Advertising Using Web Pages with Video [G000819-G000824] U.S. Patent No. 6,205,432 – Background Advertising System [G000825-G000853] USA 11/07/2000 Michael A. Lazarus, William R. Caid, Richard S. Pugh, Bradley D. Kindig, Gerald S. Russell, Kenneth B. Brown, Ted E. Dunning and Joel L. Carleton Stephen J. Kurtzman, II and Sandeep A. Nawathe USA 12/26/2000 Don R. Sparks, M. James Scott and Wally Tremel USA 02/13/2001 USA 03/20/2001 U.S. Patent No. 6,216,112 – Method for Software Distribution and Compensation with Replenishable Advertisements USA 04/10/2001 Mark Collins-Rector, Chad Shakley, James Sabo and Chris Fulton Chuck E. Gabbard, Bruce R. Chaffins and Everett B. Howerton, III William H. Fuller, Joel A. Pugh and Douglas E. Neel GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 6 Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 7 of 24 PageID #: 7756 TITLE COUNTRY DATE INVENTOR(S) USA 09/04/2001 USA 10/23/2001 U.S. Patent No. 6,385,592 – System and Method for Delivering Customized Advertisements within Interactive Communication Systems [G000985G001010] U.S. Patent No. 6,408,278 – System and Method for Delivering Out-of-Home Programming [G025291-G025306] U.S. Patent No. 6,415,270 – Multiple Auction Coordination Method and System [G025307-G025333] U.S. Patent No. 6,449,657 – Internet Hosting System [G001029-G001053] USA 05/07/2002 David William Roth and Dylan Salisbury Alan Cohn, John L. Adelus, Dean Blackketter, Samuel Thomas Scott, III and Stephen G. Perlman Paul D. Angles and Douglas O. Blattner USA 06/18/2002 USA 07/02/2002 USA 09/10/2002 U.S. Patent No. 6,633,850 – Background Advertising System [G001100-G001128] USA 10/14/2003 U.S. Patent No. 6,654,725 – System and Method for Providing Customized Advertising on the World Wide Web [G001129-G001144] U.S. Patent No. 6,810,527 – System and Method for Distribution and Delivery of Media Context and Other Data to Aircraft Passengers [G001157-G001177] U.S. Patent No. 6,907,566 – Method and System for Optimum Placement of Advertisements on a Webpage [G025334G025349] U.S. Patent No. 7,038,637 – System and Method for Selling Advertising Space on Electronic Billboards Over the Internet [G001424-G001435] U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2001/0042002 – Method and System for Communicating Targeted Information [G024996-G025039] WO 99/57660 – Content Enhancement USA 11/25/2003 USA 10/26/2004 USA 06/14/2005 USA 05/02/2006 Marc Eller and Zvi Yaniz USA 11/15/2001 Jeff Koopersmith Int’l 11/11/1999 Ja’acob Samboursky and [G000854-G000870] U.S. Patent No. 6,285,987 – Internet Advertising System [G000900-G000925] U.S. Patent No. 6,308,202 – System for Targeting Information to Specific Users on a Computer Network [G000947-G000960] GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 7 Patrick J. Carney, Joel B. Pina, James J. Boyle and Corey A. Perine Randall I. Rackson, Jonathan Adam Krane and Peter J. Trevisani Francis J. Stanbach, Jr., Daniel G. Hoffman and Bruce R. Keiser Chuck E. Gabbard, Bruce R. Chaffins and Everett B. Howerton, III Marc Langheinrich and Atsuyoshi Nakamura Adam P. Conrad, John L. Norin, Romulo Pontula, Peter W. Smith and Jeffrey M. Wales Charles McElfresh, Paul Minerio and Michael Radford Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 8 of 24 PageID #: 7757 TITLE COUNTRY System [G025350-G025391] WO 01/37119 – Apparatus and Method for Providing Advertising on Internet-enabled Channels [D065903-D065034] B. Int’l DATE 05/25/2001 INVENTOR(S) Alon Girmonsky John B. Ferber, Scott Ferber, Todd Walderman and Daniel Joensen Systems and Printed Publications TITLE DATE AUTHOR(S) A Consumption Model for Targeted Electronic Advertising," Intel Architecture Labs, IEEE [G017758-G017766] 1995 Dedrick, R. Interactive Electronic Advertising, IEEE [G017603-G017614] 1994 Dedrick, R. 8th World Wide Web Conference, AdWiz PowerPoint Presentation, in Toronto [G016419-G016451] 05/11-14/ 1999 Langheinrich, et al. Network Notebook [G003589-G003689, Kdelfa0000077] “Beyond Targeting: try on ‘MicroSegmentation’”[G014990 – 95] “DoubleClick Technical Specifications” [ G014996 – G014998] “DoubleClick: Lead Form” [G015001] Advertising Age, “Agencies Centralize Web Ad Serving,” s1, s18-s19 1998 DoubleClick, Inc. 2/19/98 DoubleClick, Inc. 1998 DoubleClick, Inc. 1998 3/8/99 DoubleClick, Inc. DoubleClick, Inc. Cross-network functionality File Name- X-10 Functionality – U.S. Version [G015443.01] 04/09/1998 DoubleClick, Inc. Cross-network FAQ File name: X-10 Functionality – FAQ [G015443.01] 04/09/1998 DoubleClick, Inc. “Terms of Agreement” [G015166 – 67 ] Glossary [G173214 – 53 ] Spreadsheet [G036543 – 83] Spreadsheet [G035977 - 36019 ] DART for Advertisers [G034339 – 34434] 1998 1998 1998 DoubleClick CDs [G015443.01, G015443.02, G015443.03, G015443.04, G017496.01, G046080] GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 8 DoubleClick, Inc. DoubleClick, Inc. DoubleClick, Inc. DoubleClick, Inc. DoubleClick, Inc. DoubleClick, Inc. Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 9 of 24 PageID #: 7758 TITLE DATE AUTHOR(S) AdForce, Inc. DoubleClick and NetGravity CD [G064578, G065907 G177035 ] various file dates various file dates various file dates various file dates various file dates NetGravity Source Code [G026190-27485] 1998 NetGravity, Inc. AdKnowledge Source Code [G065016, all.tar.gz] various AdKnowledge, Inc. Aaddzz.com website archive from www.archive.org [G005311-G005352] 01/30/1998 IAT, Inc. Accipiter.com website archive from www.archive.org [G005358-G005359] 02/01/1998 Accipiter, Inc. Campaign Manager: Quick Reference Card [G014815-G014818] 1996 AdKnowledge, Inc. NetGravity AdServer v. 2.0, User Assistance Guide [G015241-G015443] 1996 NetGravity, Inc. NetGravity AdServer v. 1.0.5, AdServer Help Contents [G015168-G015240] 1996 NetGravity, Inc. Ad-Star Windows User's Manual [G084303G084333] 1999 Ad-Star, Inc. AdManagerPro Brochure [G014899-G014913] 1999 Baseview Products, Inc. AdForce CD [G014688.01] NetGravity CD [G017496.01] AdStar CD [G014963.01] AdKnowledge CDs [G065016, G068204] Netgravity, Inc. Ad-Star, Inc. AdKnowledge, Inc. DoubleClick, Inc. and NetGravity, Inc. Baseview Products, Inc. AdManagerPro web site [GGL-FM0042833– GGL-FM0042934] Flycast Communications Corp. Form S-1 SEC Filing [G015473-G015994] 02/05/1999 Flycast, Inc. Flycast Network Competitive Overview [G029926-G029946] 12/31/1998 Flycast, Inc. Hyper System: Interactive Direct Marketing System, Presentation Materials [G029125G029133] 1996 Hyper Net, Inc. Hyper Net Presentation - What is Hyper Space? [G029125-G029133] 1996 Hyper Net, Inc. List of Targeting Criteria [G029134] 1996 Hyper Net, Inc. GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 9 Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 10 of 24 PageID #: 7759 TITLE DATE AUTHOR(S) The View Message System [G029135-G029136] 04/1996 HTML Explanation v. 1.0 [G029137-G029143] 04/12/1996 Hyper Net, Inc. Internet Advertising Federation Confidential Business Plan [G045772-G045791] 09/25/1995 IAF (DoubleClick, Inc.) Rea1Media.com website archive from www.archive.org [G024818-G024880] 1997-1998 Competitive Analysis of RealMedia [G027948G027963] Prior to NetGravity, Inc. 01/19/2000 Competitive Analysis of RealMedia [G029972G029976] 08/1999 DoubleClick, Inc. Sabela Brochure [G028305-G028337] 1999 Sabela Media Competitive Analysis of DART and Sabela Media [G029947-G029950] 08/1999 DoubleClick, Inc. Sabela.com website archive from www.archive.org [G045970-G045993] 05/08/1999 Sabela Media Project Freud, Due Diligence Materials [G027532-G027535] 12/23/1999 DoubleClick, Inc. Sabela and AdKnowledge Presentation [G046050-G045079] Email from John Black, Sabela Media [G030277] 11/07/1999 Martin Wesley baseview.com website from www.archive.org (ClassManagerPro) [G026146-G026163] 01/16/1997 Baseview Products, Inc. Internet Advertising Network, "How Ads Are Placed" [G045822] 1995 Simple HTML Change [G045823] 1996 1996 Ian Advertising Rates [G045824G045830] 06/09/1998 Internet Advertising Network L90, Inc. Form S-1 SEC Filing [G029977G030034] 09/30/1999 L90, Inc. www.Spinbox.com website archive from www.archive.org [G029925] 11/11/1998 Spinbox Focalink Marketing Materials and Presentation Slides [G029283-G029305] Focalink MarketMatch UserGuide, Version 1.0 [G014828 – 55] 1996 Focalink 9/30/96 Focalink 8/17/99 GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 10 Hyper Net, Inc. RealMedia, Inc. Sabela Media The Ian System Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 11 of 24 PageID #: 7760 TITLE DATE AUTHOR(S) Direct Marketing Management, 2nd Edition, Prentice-Hall, Inc., Upper Saddle River, NJ [G020792] 1999 After the gold rush, The Economist, New York [GGL-FM0039680-GGL-FM0039681 04/20/2000 The Economist Chopping tech-stocks down to size, The Economist.com [GGL-FM0039682-GGLFM000039684] 12/05/2000 The Economist CMGI’s Web deal making hits big-time: Group preps two portals: AltaVista and MyWay.com, Advertising Age [G005715-5718] 10/04/1999 Jennifer Gilbert, Advertising Age The Internet Advertising Report, Harper Business [G022202] 1997 Mary Meeker, Morgan Stanley The Forrester Report – Media Technology – Ad Serving and Measurement [G029212G029228]] 05/1997 Susan Gertzis, et al. 2 Web Ad Firms Decide to Marry: Palo Alto’s Focalink, ClickOver merging,San Francisco Chronicle [G016001] 11/17/1997 Carol Emert Ad Management – Debunking the Turnkey Myth, Jupiter Strategic Planning Services [G017767] 07/1998 Small networks chase per-click ad business – Aaddzz, ValueClick compete [G005308] 09/08/1997 Advertising Age NetGravity Launches AdCenter Service Solution, ClickZ News [GGL-FM0039391] 08/12/1998 ClickZ Competitive Analysis of ATG Dynamo Ad Station (approx 1998) [G027902-G027903] 1998 Avenue A, FAQ, www.avenuea.comlcorpinfo/faq.html [G029920-G029924] 09/29/1999 Avenue A, Inc. Competitive Analysis of Avenue A (prior to November 14, 1999) [G029959-G029960] 11/14/1999 DoubleClick, Inc. Competitive Summary of the Infoseek Search Engine [G043058-G043059] 02/26/1997 Kevin O’Connor Competitive Summary of Lycos (2/26/1997) [G043060] 02/26/1997 Kevin O’Connor Competitive Analysis of Match Logic (prior to 1/14/1999) [G029918-G029919] 01/14/1999 DoubleClick, Inc. GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 11 Mary Lou Roberts and Paul D. Berger Evan Neufeld, Strategic Planning Services NetGravity, Inc. Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 12 of 24 PageID #: 7761 TITLE DATE AUTHOR(S) Competitive Analysis of MatchLogic (approximately 1998) [G027933-G027939] 1998 NetGravity, Inc. Competitive Analysis of Microsoft (approximately 1998) [G027941-G027946] 1998 NetGravity, Inc. Competitive Analysis (approximately 1998) [G027834-G027851] 1998 NetGravity, Inc. Competitive Analysis 2Q98 Presentation (7/9/1998) [G027812-G027833] 07/09/1998 NetGravity, Inc. Feature Comparison: DoubleClick DART vs. NetGravity AdServ(prior to 1/14/1999) [G029951-G029952] 01/14/1999 DoubleClick, Inc. Competitive Analysis of AdCenter [G029042G029047] 1/11/2000 NetGravity, Inc. Competition Coverage (approximately 1998) [G028962-G028966] 1998 NetGravity, Inc. Industry Perceptions of Net Gravity [G028974G028990] 12/01/1998 Blanc & Otus Competitive Positioning Brief, Approx. 1998 [G027810-G027811] 1998 Competitive Analysis of Double Click, MatchLogic, AdKnowledge, Avenue A, AdForce, 24/7, Flycast [G029030-G029041] 01/11/2000 NetGravity, Inc. Targeted Media: reality check on the road to one-to-one marketing Fig. 6: Ad Management Tools Overviews [G029020-G029021] 1998 Jupiter Research Server Software: Integrated Approaches will Drive Sophisticated Personalization [G045994G046016] 1998 Seamus McAteer, Jupiter Communications DART for Advertisers, Sabela and AdKnowledge Competitive Overview [G046050-G046079] 12/17/1999 DoubleClick, Inc. Competitive Analysis of Softbank's Foundation Buy Program [G043062] 02/26/1997 Kevin O’Connor Competitive Analysis of Soliant's Adapt/X Software (approximately 1998) [G027964G027966] 1998 NetGravity, Inc. www.anon.user.anonymizer.com, Switchboard Corporate Background [G029886-G029887] 9/13/1999 Switchboard, Inc. GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 12 NetGravity, Inc. Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 13 of 24 PageID #: 7762 TITLE DATE AUTHOR(S) Competitive Analysis of ThinkingMedia [G027967-G027968] 1998 NetGravity, Inc. Competitive Analysis of W3 (approximately 1998) [G027975] 1998 NetGravity, Inc. Competitive Analysis of the Web Connect Network [G043063] 2/26/1997 Web Connect Network Competitive Analysis of the Yahoo! Directory [G043064] 2/26/1997 Kevin O’Connor NetGravity Presentation [G028509-G028535] 1999 Stephen E. Recht Analyst Report Summary - Internet Marketing Management Solutions [G028991-G029000] 12/01/1998 Blanc & Otus NetGravity Analyst / Media audit, conducted by Blanc Ores [G029001-G029019] 12/1998 NetGravity, Inc. Press Release, NetGravity 'Announces Record Q2 Revenues [G029053] 7/13/1999 NetGravity, Inc. Patent's Net Result: Nothing? [G029883G029885] 09/13/1999 Chris Oaks, Wired News Web Ads Mark 2nd Birthday with Decisive Issues Ahead [G029338-G029348] 10/1996 Debra Aho Williamson, Advertising Age Randall Rothenberg, Advertising Age The Advertising Century [G029349-G029363] Online Advertising: On Target [G029364G029368] 12/17/1998 eMarketer Increase in Ad Spending Predicted [G029369G029370] 3/25/1999 Markets Advertising Internet Economy Looking Good [G029371G029372] 6/10/1999 CyberAtlas Publishers Thankful but Nervous About Boom [G029373-G029378] 11/1999 Adrienne W. Fawcett, Advertising Age Aaddzz Brochure reBrokers Web Ad Space Sales Between Advertisers and Publishers [G005302] 1997 IAT, Inc. Aaddzz Letter to all Customers re Aaddzz Services Suspended as of 10/01/2004 [G005353-G005354] 10/01/2004 IAT, Inc. New Online Ad Network Aaddzz to Launch, Western Div., Vol. XLVII No. 27 [G005355G005357] 07/07/1997 John Spooner, AdWeek.com GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 13 Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 14 of 24 PageID #: 7763 TITLE DATE AUTHOR(S) DoubleClick Case Study [G014999] 1998 DoubleClick Case Study re Client: Places to Stay (Hotel and Resort) [G015000] 1998 DoubleClick Lead Form re DART Technology [G015001] 1998 Rise of Infomediary [G015002-G015004] 06/24/1999 The Economist On the Internet, brand-building is out and straight selling is in…[G015005-G015007] 10/07/1999 The Economist DoubleClick joins ‘huge’ e-mail ad realm… [G015010] 11/29/1999 Patricia Riedman, Advertising Age, republished by Encylopedia.com Agencies centralize web ad serving [G015011G015015] 03/08/1999 Jennifer Gilbert, Advertising Age DoubleClick - Beyond the Banner [G015016] 01/27/1999 DoubleClick, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive 12/05/1998 DoubleClick, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Advertiser Solutions - Beyond the Banner [G015017] DoubleClick, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive DoubleClick, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive DoubleClick, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive DoubleClick fixes on bull’s-eye with Dart 5[G015098-G015100] 06/11/2001 Adrienne Mand, Advertising Age DoubleClick joins ‘huge’ e-mail ad realm [G015101-G015103] 11/29/1999 Patricia Riedman, Advertising Age DoubleClick shopping aids e-commerce, [G015104-G015107] 05/24/1999 Jennifer Gilbert, Advertising Age Dynamic Advertising Reporting and Targeting - 06/19/1998 Product Literature [G015108-G015123] 12/01/1998 DoubleClick - Enhanced Ad Banner Specs [G015124-G015125] Agencies centralize Web ad serving [G015126- 03/01/1999 G015130] DoubleClick clicks with NetGravity [G015131- 07/19/1999 G015133] 12/06/1998 How DART works [G015134] Advertising.com Serves Up Ad Delivery Software, Vol. 10, No. 28 [G015137-G015139] Imgis Becomes Ad Force; Receives Financing from AOL, ADWEEK, Vol. 39, No. 32, p. 34 [G015140] DoubleClick, Inc. DoubleClick, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Jennifer Gilbert, Advertising Age Jennifer Gilbert, Advertising Age DoubleClick, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive 07/10/2000 Ann M. Mack, Mediaweek.com 08/10/1998 Adrienne Mand, Adweek.com GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 14 Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 15 of 24 PageID #: 7764 TITLE DATE AUTHOR(S) DoubleClick Outsourcing Ad Sales FAQ [G015141-G015142] 12/06/1998 DoubleClick, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Real Media dives into competition [G015156G015158] 10/04/1999 Jennifer Gilbert, Advertising Age DoubleClick Targeting Filters [G015164G015165] 12/02/1998 DoubleClick, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive DoubleClick Terms of Agreement [G015166G015167] 12/06/1998 DoubleClick, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive DoubleClick Network Level Reports [G003690G003714] 1998 DoubleClick, Inc. DoubleClick Network Level Reports –DRAFT [G003715-G003738] 1998 DoubleClick, Inc. DoubleClick Network Level Reports –DRAFT [G003739-G003762] 1998 DoubleClick, Inc. DART Reporting Essentials – DRAFT [G003763-G003808] 02/17/1998 DoubleClick, Inc. Local Reseller Manual [G003818-G003843] 1998 DoubleClick, Inc. Show Availability - Managing Inventory [G003844-G003850] 1998 DoubleClick, Inc. Cross Network Functionality – A Step by Step Guide DRAFT [G003943-G003951] 04/11/1998 DoubleClick, Inc. DoubleClick DART Global Market/Hybrid DART? White Paper [G003953-G003958] 2/11/2000 DoubleClick Network Affiliations – Revenue Sharing Relationships [G003965-G003973] 12/09/2000 DoubleClick, Inc. DART for Advertising – The Power of Reporting [G003980-G004015] 09/6/2001 DoubleClick, Inc. DoubleClick Documentation Projects [G004016-G004701] 02/1999 DoubleClick, Inc. A framework for targeting banner advertising on the internet, IEEE System Sciences, Proceedings of the Thirtieth Hawaii Int’l Conference, pages 265-274, Vol. 4 [G024674G024685] 1997 K. Gallagher and J. Parsons Acquiring Customer Preferences for Information Filtering: a Heuristic-Statistical Approach [G024686-G024688] 1996 Bhavani Raskutti and Anthony Beitz GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 15 DoubleClick, Inc. Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 16 of 24 PageID #: 7765 TITLE DATE White Papers, Adding Value in the Digital Age, Bringing One-to-One Marketing to the Internet [G024689-G024699] 6/30/1998 Netperceptions.com AdForce Privacy Practices [G024700G024704] 6/30/1998 MGIS, Inc. AdForce Introduces AdForce EveryWhere: Advertising, Marketing & Promotions Wherever a Digital Signal Can Be Sent [G024705-G024707] 03/27/2000 Business Wire AdForce Strategic Partners [G024708G024709] 03/27/2000 AdForce, Inc. NetGravity Products – AdServer 3 [G024710G024715] 07/09/1998 NetGravity, Inc. Coupon Clippers, Save your Scissors [G024716-G024719] 06/20/1994 BusinessWeek DoubleClick DART Intro [G024720-G024735] 06/19/1998 DoubleClick, Inc. About Engage Technologies [G024736G024748] 07/09/1998 The CMG Internet Group Firefly Passport Office Overview [G024749G024756] 06/20/1998 Firefly.net Media Metrix FAQ [G024757-G024758] 06/30/1998 Media Metrix, The PC Meter Company “Goodies” in exchange for consumer information on the Internet: the economics and issues, IEEE System Sciences, Proceedings of the Thirty-First Hawaii Int’l Conference, pages 533-542, Vol. 4 [G024759-G024770] 01/1998 Learn Sesame [G024771-G024773] 07/09/1998 Open Sesame MatchLogic’s Services [G024774-G024775] 07/01/1998 MatchLogic, Inc. Netvertising: content-based subgeneric variations in a digital genre, IEEE System Sciences, Proceedings of the Thirty-First Hawaii Int’l Conference, pages 87-96, Vol.2 [G024776-G024787] 01/1998 The Power of Personalization [G024788G024790] 08/21/1998 BroadVision SelectCast for Ad Servers: The Only Ad Targeting System with Published Performance Results – Ask Us! [G024791-G024792] 06/30/1998 Aptex Software, Inc. GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 16 AUTHOR(S) A.M. Chang, P.K. Kannam, and A.B. Whinston I. Fortanet, J.C. Palmer and S. Posteguillo Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 17 of 24 PageID #: 7766 TITLE DATE AUTHOR(S) SelectCast for Commerce Servicers [G024793] 06/30/1998 Aptex Software, Inc. The Value of Purchase History Data in Target Marketing, Marketing Science, Vol. 15, No. 4 [G024794-G024813] 1996 Peter E. Rossi, Robert E. McCulloch and Greg M. Allenby Web advertising, IEEE Intelligent Systems, Vol. 13, Issue 3, pgs 8-9 [G024814-G024817] 1998 M. McCandless Eclipse Services, AdPro System Baseview Products Inc., ClassManagerPro System Accipiter, Inc., AdManager System 1997 1997 Eclipse Services Baseview Products, Inc. 1997-1998 Accipiter, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 288 1996 Deposition Exhibit 289 1997 Accipiter, Inc. republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 290 1997 Accipiter, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 291 1997 Deposition Exhibit 292 1997 Deposition Exhibit 294 1996 Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 295 1996 Accipiter, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 296 1998 Deposition Exhibit 297 1998 Deposition Exhibit 299 1996 Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 300 1996 Deposition Exhibit 301 1997 Deposition Exhibit 302 1997 Deposition Exhibit 303 1996 Deposition Exhibit 304 1998 Deposition Exhibit 305 1998 GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 17 Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 18 of 24 PageID #: 7767 TITLE DATE Deposition Exhibit 306 1998 Deposition Exhibit 307 1998 Deposition Exhibit 308 1998 Deposition Exhibit 309 1998 Deposition Exhibit 310 1998 Deposition Exhibit 311 1998 Deposition Exhibit 312 02/22/1999 Deposition Exhibit 313 1998 Deposition Exhibit 314 02/03/1999 Deposition Exhibit 315 1998 Deposition Exhibit 316 02/04/1999 Deposition Exhibit 317 1998 Deposition Exhibit 318 02/04/1999 Deposition Exhibit 319 1998 Deposition Exhibit 320 02/08/1999 Deposition Exhibit 321 02/09/1999 Deposition Exhibit 322 02/09/1999 Deposition Exhibit 323 1998 Deposition Exhibit 324 1998 Deposition Exhibit 325 02/09/1999 Deposition Exhibit 326 02/09/1999 GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 18 AUTHOR(S) Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Accipiter, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 19 of 24 PageID #: 7768 TITLE DATE AUTHOR(S) Deposition Exhibit 327 1998 Accipiter, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 328 1997 Robbin Zeff Deposition Exhibit 331 1998 AdForce, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 332 1998 AdForce, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 333 1998 AdForce, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 334 1998 AdForce, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 336 1999 AdForce, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 337 1999 AdForce, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 338 1998-1999 Deposition Exhibit 341 AdForce, Inc. employees and Roy T. Fielding 01/04/1999 AdForce, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 143 1997-1999 Baseview Products, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 144 1997 Baseview Products, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 145 1997 Deposition Exhibit 235 1998-1999 Baseview Products, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive Imgis, Inc. and AdForce, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 700 1999 AdKnowledge, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 701 1999 AdKnowledge, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 702 1999 AdKnowledge, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 704 1998 AdKnowledge, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 705 1998 AdKnowledge, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 706 2000 Engage, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 707 1998 AdKnowledge, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 708 Deposition Exhibit 275 02/22/1999 AdKnowledge, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive 02/22/1999 AdKnowledge, Inc., republished by The Internet Archive 2001 Tom Shields Deposition Exhibit 276 07/13/1999 Tiffany Kary, CNET News Deposition Exhibit 709 GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 19 Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 20 of 24 PageID #: 7769 TITLE DATE AUTHOR(S) Deposition Exhibit 277 06/19/1998 ClickZ News Deposition Exhibit 278 1998 NetGravity, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 279 1996 NetGravity, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 280 1998 NetGravity, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 281 1996-2001 Deposition Exhibit 282 1997 NetGravity, Inc., DoubleClick, Inc, and employees of same including Russ Seligman NetGravity, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 283 1997 NetGravity, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 284 1997 NetGravity, Inc. Deposition Exhibit 285 1998 Clickz News Deposition Exhibit 286 1998 NetGravity, Inc. III. PERSONS WHO MAY BE RELIED UPON AS A PRIOR INVENTOR OR AS HAVING PRIOR KNOWLEDGE OF OR AS HAVING PREVIOUSLY USED OR OFFERED FOR SALE THE ALLEGED INVENTION OF THE ASSERTED PATENTS NAME Arthur Britto Michael Dean Karen Delfau Christopher Evans Roy Fielding, Ph.D. Internet Archive (Christopher Butler) (Declaration) Baseview Products, Inc. (Chris Kempton) LAST KNOWN ADDRESS 2536 College Avenue, #4A Berkeley, CA 94704 1021 Wilder Way Tyler, TX 75703 Google Inc. 1600 Amphitheatre Parkway Mountain View, CA 94043 1025 Bear Glades Lane Raleigh, North Carolina 27605 80 Corsica Drive Newport Beach, CA 92660 116 Sheridan Avenue The Presidio of San Francisco San Francisco, CA 94129 597 Kuehnle Avenue Ann Arbor, MI 48103 GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 20 Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 21 of 24 PageID #: 7770 NAME Sandilee Mathers Kurt Pires (Declaration) Stephen Rupp Andrew Schulz Mark Scheele Russ Seligman Tom Shields Lucinda Stone WPP Group, 24/7 Real Media (Nicolle Pangis) Robbin Warner Zeff Dated: October 2, 2009 LAST KNOWN ADDRESS 2536 Santa Ana, #2 Costa Mesa, CA 92627 869 52nd Street Oakland, CA 94608 Google Inc. 1600 Amphitheatre Parkway Mountain View, CA 94043 267 Kelton Avenue San Carlos, CA 94070 Google Inc. 1600 Amphitheatre Parkway Mountain View, CA 94043 4207 Highview Drive San Mateo, CA 94403 1205 Drake Avenue Burlingame, CA 94010 1021 Wilder Way Tyler, TX 75703 125 Park Avenue New York, NY 10017 119 Ave de l'Armee 1040 Brussels, Belgium Respectfully submitted, QUINN EMANUEL URQUHART OLIVER & HEDGES, LLP By: /s/ James M. Glass Charles K. Verhoeven (admitted pro hac) Lead Attorney charlesverhoeven@quinnemanuel.com Amy H. Candido (admitted pro hac) amycandido@quinnemanuel.com Billie D. Salinas (admitted pro hac) billiesalinas@quinnemanuel.com Carl G. Anderson (admitted pro hac) carlanderson@quinnemanuel.com QUINN EMANUEL URQUHART OLIVER & HEDGES, LLP 50 California Street, 22nd Floor San Francisco, California 94111 Telephone: (415) 875-6600 Facsimile: (415) 875-6700 Stan Karas (admitted pro hac) GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 21 Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 22 of 24 PageID #: 7771 stankaras@quinnemanuel.com QUINN EMANUEL URQUHART OLIVER & HEDGES, LLP 865 S. Figueroa Street, 10th Floor Los Angeles, CA 90017 Telephone: (213) 443-3000 Facsimile: (213) 443-3100 Edward J. DeFranco (admitted pro hac) eddefranco@quinnemanuel.com James M. Glass (admitted pro hac) jimglass@quinnemanuel.com Patrick Curran (admitted pro hac) patrickcurran@quinnemanuel.com QUINN EMANUEL URQUHART OLIVER & HEDGES, LLP 51 Madison Avenue, 22nd Floor New York, New York 10010 Telephone: (212) 849-7000 Facsimile: (212) 849-7100 Harry L. Gillam, Jr., Bar No. 07921800 gil@gillamsmithlaw.com Melissa R. Smith, Bar No. 24001351 melissa@gillamsmithlaw.com GILLAM & SMITH, L.L.P. 303 South Washington Avenue Marshall, TX 75670 Telephone: (903) 934-8450 Facsimile: (903) 934-9257 Counsel for Defendant and Counter-Claimant GOOGLE INC. GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 22 Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 23 of 24 PageID #: 7772 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE The undersigned hereby certifies that a true and correct copy of GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 has been served on October 2, 2009 to all counsel of record who are deemed to have consented to electronic service via the Court’s CM/ECF system per Local Rule CV-5(a)(3), listed below: S. Calvin Capshaw, Esq. Elizabeth L. DeRieux, Esq. D. Jeffery Rambin, Esq. Capshaw Derieux, LLP 1127 Judson Road, Suite 220 P.O. Box 3999 Longview, TX 75601-5157 E-mail: ccapshaw@capshawlaw.com ederieux@capshawlaw.com jrambin@capshawlaw.com Attorneys for Plaintiff/Counterclaim Defendant FUNCTION MEDIA, L.L.C. Max L. Tribble, Jr. Joseph S. Grinstein Lexie G. White Sandeep Seth Susman Godfrey LLP 1000 Louisiana, Suite 5100 Houston, TX 77002-5096 E-mail: mtribble@susmangodfrey.com jgrinstein@susmangodfrey.com lwhite@susmangodfrey.com sseth@susmangodfrey.com Attorneys for Plaintiff/Counterclaim Defendant FUNCTION MEDIA, L.L.C. Jeremy J. Brandon Susman Godfrey LLP 901 Main Street, Suite 5100 Dallas, TX 75202 E-mail: jbrandon@susmangodfrey.com Attorneys for Plaintiff/Counterclaim Defendant FUNCTION MEDIA, L.L.C. Justin Adatto Nelson Susman Godfrey LLP 1201 Third Avenue, Suite 3800 Seattle, WA 98101 E-mail: jnelson@susmangodfrey.com Attorneys for Plaintiff/Counterclaim Defendant FUNCTION MEDIA, L.L.C. GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 23 Case 2:07-cv-00279-RSP Document 191 Filed 10/02/09 Page 24 of 24 PageID #: 7773 Charles Ainsworth, Esq. Robert C. Bunt, Esq. Parker Bunt & Ainsworth 100 E. Ferguson, Suite 1114 Tyler, TX 75702 Email: charley@pbatyler.com rcbunt@pbatyler.com Attorneys for Plaintiff/Counterclaim Defendant FUNCTION MEDIA, L.L.C. Franklin Jones, Jr., Esq. Jones & Jones 201 W. Houston Street P.O. Drawer 1249 Marshall, TX 75670 Email: maizieh@millerfirm.com Attorney for Plaintiff/Counterclaim Defendant FUNCTION MEDIA, L.L.C. Otis Carroll, Esq. Collin Maloney, Esq. Deborah Race, Esq. Ireland, Carroll & Kelley, PC 6101 S. Broadway, Suite 500 Tyler, TX 75703 Email: fedserv@icklaw.com Attorney for Plaintiff/Counterclaim Defendant FUNCTION MEDIA, L.L.C. /s/ Carl G. Anderson Carl G. Anderson 3133070_2.DOC GOOGLE INC.’S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S.C. § 282 - Page 24

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?