WI-LAN Inc. v. Alcatel-Lucent USA Inc. et al

Filing 334

RESPONSE to 329 Notice (Other), Notice (Other), Notice (Other), Notice (Other) Wi-LAN's Objections to Defendants Counter Designations filed by WI-LAN Inc.. (Weaver, David)

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
TYLER DIVISION
WI-LAN INC.,

§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§

Plaintiff,
v.
ALCATEL-LUCENT USA INC.; et al.
Defendants.

Civil Action No. 6:10-cv-521-LED
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED

PLAINTIFF WI-LAN INC.'S OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANTS COUNTER
DESIGNATIONS

Please take notice that Plaintiff Wi-LAN Inc. ("Wi-LAN") hereby makes the following
objections to Defendants’ counter trial deposition designations served February 25, 2013:

Wi-LAN’s OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT ALCATEL-LUCENT, ERICSSON AND
SONY MOBILE’S COUNTER DESIGNATIONS
Witness

Mattias Akervik
08.29.2012

Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
5:05-5:11
6:21-7:4
25:8-25:15
39:20-40:13
42:9-43:20
45:21-46:4
46:22-47:11
50:25-52:23
Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
5:3-5:11 (OC)

Defendants’ Objections

Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations

AF; F; R

Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations

Witness

Stephen Becker
12.21.2012

6:8-6:14
49:16-50:3 (OC)
50:12-50:24 (OC)
56:3-56:12 (OC)
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
47:23-49:2
49:4-49:10
49:11-49:20
134:23-136:14

Witness

Per Johan Beming
08.29.2012

136:21-137:10
138:1-138:3
Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
136:15-136:20
(OC)
137:12-137:25
(OC)
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
5:3-5:9
5:15-5:17
47:6-48:8
49:3-49:14
60:23-61:3
61:25-63:1
66:25-67:24

402 R/ 403
H/ 403/ F
H/ 403
H/ 403
Defendants’ Objections

47:23-48:25 – F; M; V 49:1
– F; M; V; A
F; M; V; A
F
135:25-136:7 – M; V
136:11-136:14 – M; I
137:4-137:10 – I
Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations
402 R/ CS

Defendants’ Objections

47:21 – 48:8 403; ATTY
V; PERSONAL; ATTY
F; S; I; 403; PERSONAL
62:17 – 63:1 V; F; AF; S;
403; C; PERSONAL
V; S; 403; ATTY;
PERSONAL

Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
48:9-48:15 (OC)
60:10-60:22 (OC)
61:4-61:6 (OC)

Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations
H/ 403/ I
403
403

2

Witness

David Brant
06.29.2012

61:20-61:24 (OC)
67:25-68:17
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
15:8-16:17
20:6-25:4
42:6-43:19
120:1-124:9
124:23-127:21
129:10-129:18
129:20-129:25
130:2-130:6
130:16-130:23
132:15-133:20
167:19-168:11
173:7-173:25
196:7-196:25
210:11-210:14
215:11-216:22
235:17-236:8
Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
117:4-117:16
117:20-118:4
118:6-118:17
118:19-119:4
127:22-128:9
128:11-128:19
128:22-129:4
129:6-129:9
174:9-174:11
174:14-174:15
174:17-175:2
175:4-175:4
175:6-175:7
175:11-175:15
175:18-175:19
175:21-175:23
197:19-197:25
198:3-198:3

403
H/ 403/ F/ I
Defendants’ Objections

H
ATTY; H; C
ATTY; H; S
ATTY; H; S; R
ATTY; H; S; V
ATTY; H
ATTY; H
ATTY; H
ATTY; H
ATTY; H
ATTY; H; F
ATTY; H; F; AF; V
S; V; H
ATTY; D; V; H
ATTY; S; H
D; H
Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ AF/ C
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ AF/ C
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ AF/ C
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ AF/ C
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ AF
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ AF
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ AF
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ AF
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ AF
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ AF
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ AF
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ AF
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD

3

198:5-198:5
198:7-198:11
198:14-198:15
198:22-198:24
199:2-199:2
199:4-199:6
199:8-199:8
199:10-199:14
199:17-199:19
199:21-199:23
200:1-200:5
200:7-200:9
200:12-200:14
201:17-201:19
201:22-201:22
201:24-202:2
202:5-202:9
212:22-213:6

CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ F
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ F
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ F
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ F
H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ ID/ F/ A/
I
Counter-designation:
212:14-212:19
236:20-237:8
H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ ID/ F/ A/
I

213:8-213:11

Counter-designation:
212:14-212:19
236:20-237:8
H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ ID/ F/ A/
I

213:13-213:18

Counter-designation:
212:14-212:19
236:20-237:8
H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ ID/ F/ A/
I

213:21-213:24

Counter-designation:
212:14-212:19
236:20-237:8

4

214:1-214:5

H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ ID/ F/ A/
I
Counter-designation:
212:14-212:19
236:20-237:8
H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ ID/ F/ A/
I

214:8-214:10

Counter-designation:
212:14-212:19
236:20-237:8
H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ ID/ F/ A/
I

214:12-214:13

Counter-designation:
212:14-212:19
236:20-237:8

Witness

Deborah Butler
08.15.2012

236:9-236:16
236:18-236:18
236:20-236:22
237:1-237:1
237:3-237:5
237:8-237:8
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
6:25-7:4
7:10-7:11
7:12-7:18
34:7-34:20
50:10-50:18
75:20-75:24
124:16-124:17
124:19-124:20
Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
33:18-34:4
48:22-49:6
49:19-50:1
50:3-50:5
74:12-74:20

Defendants’ Objections

R; 403; V; I; S; F
R; 403; V; M; ATTY
R; 403; I
R; 403; V; O; F; S
R; 403; V; O; F; S
Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations

402 R/ 403/ BS/ H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ H
402 R
5

Witness

Asok Chatterjee
08.03.2012

74:22-75:13
75:15-75:19
75:25-76:3
100:8-100:15
100:17-100:19
119:25-120:1
120:4-120:4
120:6-120:11
123:25-124:1
124:3-124:11
124:13-124:14
125:10-125:13
125:15-125:16
125:18-125:20
126:24-126:25
127:2-127:3
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
5:9-5:11
7:6-7:9
11:14-11:23
45:15-46:2

Witness

Michael Cromie
09/13/2012

46:4-46:9
46:11-46:12
Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
5:15-5:16 (OC)
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
5:6-5:8
8:23-9:3
9:10-9:15
31:24-33:7
107:02-107:12
109:12-110:5

402 R/ 403/ BS/ H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ H/ CS
402 R/ 403/ BS/ H/ CS
Defendants’ Objections

V; R; S; PERSONAL
45:21 – 46:2 R; S; O; 403;
PERSONAL
R; S; O; 403; PERSONAL
R; S; O; 403; PERSONAL
Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations
402 R/ 403/ CF/ V/ Imp/ H
Defendants’ Objections

R; V
ATTY; R; V
I; R; V; F

6

Witness

Johannes Derksen
08.24.2012

Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
110:6-110:10
(OC)
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
6:3-6:6
7:8-7:14
21:8-21:10
22:7-22:8
22:12-22:15
22:19-22:23
35:8-36:1
37:23-37:25
39:11-40:11
41:23-42:9
43:17-45:6
45:9-45:10
45:15-45:20
45:21-46:16
46:23-47:11
66:17-67:2
69:4-69:17
75:22-76:4
85:19-86:17
86:18-86:22
87:6-87:11
114:20-114:24
118:7-119:7
127:15-127:22
Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
20:19-21:7
21:11-21:19
22:9-22:11 (OC)
22:16-22:18 (OC)
36:2-36:14 (OC)
37:4-37:22 (OC)

Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations

Defendants’ Objections

M
F
A; M
V; S
A; M; V
F; S; V; M
F; V
F; V; S
F; V; S
M; F; V; S
F; V; S
M; F; V
M; V; F; R
F; V; S
R
V; S
F; V
F; V
M; V
F; M; A; 403
Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations
H/ 402 R/ 403
H/ 402 R/ 403/ CS
402 R/ 403/ CS
H/ 402 R/ 403
H/ 402 R/ 403

7

Witness

Emad Farag
09.06.2012

42:10-42:12
42:13-42:21
43:9-43:12
47:12-48:7
66:9-16 (OC)
69:18-20 (OC)
125:14-126:5
127:9-127:14
(OC)
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
11:22-12:9
15:3-15:7
20:24-21:14
27:25-28:2
28:10-28:22
31:11-32:16
42:24-43:12
46:5-46:10
55:20-56:1
69:15-69:20
71:24-72:9
78:21-79:5
82:5-82:14
88:4-89:15
91:12-92:6
93:12-95:4
95:15-97:5
99:10-103:20
116:15-119:23
121:7-121:10
129:4-129:18
131:8-131:23
134:19-135:5
149:4-149:14
149:24-158:19
159:8-160:20
180:7-182:2
190:9-192:9

H/ 402 R/ 403/ CS
H/ 402 R/ 403/ CS
I/ H/ 403/ 404/ 402 R/ BS
I/ 402 R/ 403/ H/ BS
I/ H
403 Leading/ 402 R/ H/ BS
H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ L
Defendants’ Objections

V; F; 403; I; R; ATTY
V; F; 403; I
V; F; 403; I; R;
PERSONAL; ATTY
V; F; 403; I; ATTY
V; F; I; M; ATTY
V; F; 403; I; R; ATTY
V; F; M; ATTY
V; F; 403
V; F; 403; I
V; F; 403
V; F; 403; I; R; ATTY
V; F; 403; I; R; ATTY
V; F; 403; I; R; ATTY
V; F; 403; I; R; ATTY
V; F; 403; I; R; C; ATTY
V; F; 403; I; R; C; ATTY
V; F; 403; M; I; R; C; ATTY
V; F; 403; M; I
V; F; 403; M; I; D; ATTY
V; F; 403; M; I; C; ATTY
V; F; 403; I; C; ATTY
V; F
V; F; 403; I; M; C; R; ATTY
V; F; 403; I; M; LC; R;
ATTY
V; F; 403; I; M; C; R
V; F; 403; I; M; LC; C; R;
ATTY

8

255:1-256:16

V; F; 403; I; M; LC; C; R;
ATTY

Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
22:15-23:8

Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations
H/ I
Counter-designation:
88:4-89:15 (already designated)
258:13-262:10
H/ I
Counter-designation:
91:12-92:6 (already designated)
284:16-284:19
285:10-285:16
286:7-287:15
H/ I
Counter-designation:
117:8-119:23 (already
designated)
H/ I
Counter-designation:
117:8-119:23 (already
designated)
H/ I
Counter-designation:
38:23-39:5
214:12-214:20
215:17-215:21
216:4-216:14
216:25-217:9
H/ I
Counter-designation:
38:23-39:5
214:12-214:20
215:17-215:21
216:4-216:14
216:25-217:9
H/ I
Counter-designation:
38:23-39:5
214:12-214:20
215:17-215:21
216:4-216:14
216:25-217:9

24:11-24:17

34:15-34:15

34:17-34:24

37:14-37:16

37:18-37:25

38:15-38:17

9

38:19-38:22

H/ I
Counter-designation:
38:23-39:5
214:12-214:20
215:17-215:21
216:4-216:14
216:25-217:9
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H/ I
Counter-designation:
161:10-161:22
H
H
H
H
H
H
H/ I
Counter-designation:
35:11-37:13
H/ I
Counter-designation:
35:11-37:13
H
H

43:13-43:17
56:2-56:11
71:11-71:14
71:16-71:22
83:4-83:6
83:8-83:17
89:16-89:19
89:21-90:6
92:7-92:10
92:12-92:16
119:24-120:1
120:3-121:6
121:11-121:14
121:16-122:1
134:6-134:9
134:11-134:18
135:6-135:9
135:11-135:22
148:22-149:3
160:21-160:24
161:1-161:9

167:12-167:13
167:15-167:19
167:21-168:6
174:19-175:5
176:23-176:25
177:2-177:14
179:4-179:6

179:8-179:22

182:24-183:8
185:6-185:12

10

186:1-186:3

H/ I
Counter-designation:
35:11-37:13
H/ I
Counter-designation:
35:11-37:13
H/ I
Counter-designation:
35:11-37:13
H
H
H
H
H
Counter-designation:
116:15-119:23
H
H
H
H
H
H
H/ I
Counter-designation:
159:8-161:9
H/ I
Counter-designation:
159:8-161:9

186:5-186:5

186:7-186:9

188:22-188:25
189:2-189:19
189:21-190:3
190:5-190:8
231:25-232:22

250:7-250:10
251:10-251:13
251:15-252:7
252:9-253:13
253:15-254:13
254:16-254:25
312:14-313:23

314:11-315:18

Witness

Nils Frederik
Gessler
08.28.2012

Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
9:21-10:4

12:13-12:21
14:2-14:9
16:07-16:11
18:1-18:5
23:19-23:21
26:4-26:4
26:7-26:14
26:17-27:2
29:17-29:25
31:14-31:22

Defendants’ Objections

I; 403
I; R
I; R

11

34:2-34:13
44:11-45:8
51:14-52:5
71:4-72:2
72:11-73:20
74:4-76:7
87:23-88:6
88:18-88:22
93:11-95:8
100:12-101:10
101:15-101:25
104:22-105:12
122:2-122:6
122:7-122:11
122:18-122:19
122:21-123:4
123:13-124:1
124:9-124:18
131:20-132:22
135:15-135:17
155:12-155:22
156:17-156:20
156:22-156:23
156:24-157:7
157:9-157:13
Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
23:23-24:2 (OC)

S; F
V; S; R; AF; F
R; S; F; AF
V; R; F
V; F; AF
V; F; AF; R
V; F; AF
V; F; AF
V; F; AF
V; F; AF; S
V; F; AF
V; F; AF
V; F; AF
V; F; AF

V; I; S; F; AF; PERSONAL
V; I; S; F; AF; PERSONAL
V; I; S; F; AF; PERSONAL
V; I; S; F; AF; PERSONAL
Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations
402 R/ 403/ C/ H/ BS/ I
Counter-Designation
23:22-22:22
402 R/ 403/ H/ BS
402 R/ 403/ H/ BS
402 R/ C
402 R/ 403/ H/ BS
402 R/ 403/ H/ BS
402 R/ 403/ H/ BS

30:1-30:5 (OC)
30:22-31:13 (OC)
34:14-34:15 (OC)
50:14-50:24
51:4-51:5
105:13-105:21
(OC)
124:2-124:4 (OC)
124:6-124:8 (OC)

402 R/ 403/ H/ BS
402 R/ 403/ H/ BS

12

Witness

Helmut Hansen
08.27.2012

Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
11:10-12:11

Defendants’ Objections

18:9-19:7
19:15-20:11
35:6-36:18
41:1-41:24
55:25-58:7
63:3-64:23
72:14-73:2
76:18-77:7
78:10-78:18
81:17-82:15
82:16-83:3
84:15-85:20
97:4-98:25
109:12-109:25
110:3-110:18
126:11-126:15
171:1-171:9
189:18-190:4
210:5-211:10
216:5-216:25
217:18-218:4
Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
7:6-7:11 (OC)
19:8-19:10 (OC)
19:12-19:14 (OC)
58:8-58:10 (OC)
58:11-58:14
58:16-58:16
58:25-59:4
59:17-59:22
62:9-62:16
67:10-67:14 (OC)
75:23-76:3 (OC)
76:11-76:14 (OC)
83:4-83:9 (OC)
85:21-86:2 (OC)

R
V; F; R; ATTY
V; F; AF; S; 403
V; F; AF; 403; ATTY
403; ATTY
S; PERSONAL
F; 403
V; 403
V; F; AF
V; F; AF; 403
V; 403
V; F; AF; M; S; R; 403
109:16-25 V; F; AF; 403
V; F; AF; C; 403
V; F
V; F
V; F; I; 403; ATTY
V; F; AF; C; ATTY
V; F; AF; 403
V; F; AF; 403
Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations

403
H/ 403
H
403
H/ 403
403
H/ 403
H/ 403
H
H/ 403
H/ 403
H/ 403
403

13

Witness

Timothy Hernquist
08.17.2012

86:13-17 (OC)
93:10-93:25
96:5-96:25
102:10-102:15
103:11-103:15
105:14-106:8
114:12-114:25
115:6-115:11
122:24-123:8
(OC)
124:6-124:9 (OC)
127:9-128:1
183:9-183:13
183:15-183:17
189:8-189:17
208:4-208:11
209:11-209:22
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
7:12-7:20
20:6-20:11
27:7-27:21
28:5-28:9
28:19-29:17
31:23-32:24
33:9-33:15
33:16-33:24
37:13-37:24
37:25-38:7
38:11-38:12
40:17-40:25
46:7-46:17
47:2-47:17
94:15-94:16
95:18-95:20
116:9-116:10
116:11-117:5
153:19-154:04
154:22-155:08
159:6-159:21
159:23-159:24
160:1-160:5

H/ 403
H/ 403/ I/ F
CS/ H/ 403/ F
H/ 403/ I/ F
403
H/ 403
CS/ H/ 403/ F
CS/ H/ 403/ F
H/ 403/ I
H/ 403
CS/ H/ 403/ F
403/ I
H/ 403
CS/ H/ 403/ I/ F
H/ 403/ F
H/ 403/ I/ F
Defendants’ Objections

R

F; V; ATTY
I; F; V; ATTY

I
I; F; S; ATTY
I

S; F; R
M

14

Witness

Albert Lee Hill
08.07.2012

Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
6:2-6:6
6:13-6:14
27:22-28:4 (OC)
48:6-48:14
78:18-78:24
78:25-79:5
83:9-83:19
91:20-92:10
94:17-95:17 (OC)
115:13-116:8
126:4-126:17
126:20-126:24
126:25-127:5
134:4-135:15
141:13-143:10
154:5-145:7 (OC)
160:23-160:24
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
9:23-10:2
10:7-10:10
30:14-30:21
34:14-34:19
34:25-35:19
41:9-41:13
41:15-41:17
42:13-42:17
42:19-42:24
43:5-43:11
43:14-43:20
47:20-47:23
48:3-48:9
48:21-49:3
49:19-50:19
55:20-55:24
56:2-56:15
58:23-59:2
59:6-59:8

Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations
402 R/ H
402 R/ H
403/ 402 R/ H
403/ H/ CS/ 402 R/ BS
402 R/ 403/ H/ CS
402 R/ 403/ H/ CS/ BS
402 R/ 403/ H/ BS
402 R/ 403/ H/ CS/ BS
94:18-95:17 - 403/ H
403/ H/ 402 R/ BS
H/ CS/ F/ 403/ 402 R/ BS
H/ CS/ F/ 403/ 402 R/ BS
H/ CS/ F/ 403
H/ 403/ 402 R/ BS
H/ I/ 403/ BS
H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS
Defendants’ Objections

R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403; I
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403

R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403

15

Witness

Matthew Hodulik
09.11.2012

69:3-69:5
69:6-69:7
69:13-69:19
69:25-70:01
70:11-70:13
70:24-71:5
74:25-75:3
75:5-75:5
77:7-77:9
77:11-77:13
77:15-77:25
80:18-80:21
80:22-81:4
143:4-143:12
143:21-144:5
144:13-145:4
146:14-146:19
147:15-147:22
149:7-149:16
Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
5:22-5:25
8:25-9:6
10:3-10:6 (OC)
10:11-10:16 (OC)
16:1-16:10
49:3-49:18 (OC)
75:5-75:11 (OC)
148:22-149:6
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
17:18-17:25

R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
V; R
V; R
F; V; M
F; V; M
R; 403
R; PERSONAL; S
R; PERSONAL; S
R
R
R; 403
403; F
R; 403

41:21-41:25
43:5-44:9
44:20-45:17
45:22-46:11
46:12-46:14
46:17-46:25
51:22-52:1
52:3-52:5

ATTY; R; 403; V
ATTY; R; 403; V
ATTY; R; 403; V
ATTY; R; 403; V
R; 403; V
R; 403; V
R; 403; V
R; 403; V

Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations

402 R/ 403/ BS/ H

402 R/ C
402 R/ 403
H/ BS/ 403 LEADING/ 402 R/
Defendants’ Objections

16

52:7-52:17
52:20-53:6
53:8-53:12
80:15-80:22
144:2-144:4
144:6-144:10
161:20-161:21
161:23-162:12
162:14-162:15
163:21-163:25
164:4-164:20
164:22-164:24
165:12-165:15
165:17-165:17
Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
36:22-36:25
37:2-37:7
38:22-38:25
39:2-39:21
40:5-40:8
40:10-40:14
40:24-40:25
41:2-41:7
41:9-41:10
42:1-42:3
42:5-42:7
45:18-45:19
45:21-45:21
51:1-51:5
51:7-51:12
51:14-51:21
53:13-53:20
53:22-54:13
54:22-55:1
55:3-55:13
55:15-55:25
56:2-56:23
56:25-57:9
65:4-65:19
145:23-146:17
154:4-154:7
154:12-154:21

R; 403; V
R; 403; V
R; 403; V
R; 403
R; 403; V
R; 403; V
R; 403; V; F; S
R; 403; V; F; S
R; 403; V; F; S
R; 403; V
R; 403; V
R; 403; V
R; 403; V
R; 403; V
Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R

402 R/ C
402 R/ C
402 R/ C
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R

17

Witness

David Irving
08.21.2012

155:4-155:8
165:18-165:20
168:5-169:3
169:5-169:10
169:12-169:16
169:18-169:18
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
11:2-11:4
11:5-12:3
12:4-12:8
22:23-23:15
27:25-28:2
28:9-28:18
28:24-29:1
29:4-29:6
29:9-29:13
30:4-30:18
34:22-35:9
38:11-38:14
38:20-39:04
47:4-47:23
48:05-48:19
49:10-49:14
52:24-54:3
88:14-88:22
88:23-89:5
95:3-95:21
96:1-96:20
98:7-99:11
107:13-108:3
109:14-110:4
110:23-111:7
115:6-116:2
124:14-125:5
125:9-126:04
132:1-132:22
161:5-162:2

BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R
CS
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R/ L
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R/ L
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R/ L
BS/ 403/ H/ 402 R/ L
Defendants’ Objections

V; I
V; I
V; I
M; I; ATTY; LC; 403; S
F; V
F; V; 403; R; I
F; V
F; V
F; V
R; V; C; F
V; R; F; I
V; F
V; C; 403; R
C; 403; ATTY; R; S; F
F; V; 403; ATTY; S; R
O; V; 403; ATTY; LC; S; R
V; M; 403; ATTY; F; R
F; V; 403; S; D; R
F; V; M; 403; ATTY; R
V; 403; ATTY; F; R
V; C; 403; ATTY; F; R; M
V; I; 403; ATTY; R; A; F; S
V; I; 403; ATTY; F; S; R
V; C; 403; ATTY; F; S; R
V; C; 403; ATTY; F; S; R
V; M; C; 403; ATTY; F; S;
R
V; 403; ATTY; F; R
F; V; 403; ATTY; S; R; O;
A
V; M; C; I; 403; ATTY; F ;
S; R; O; A
V; C; 403; ATTY; F; S; R

18

163:23-164:16
165:14-165:25
168:17-169:12
169:14-169:23
174:18-174:23
198:20-200:9
204:15-205:1
205:2-205:9
209:22-210:4
211:23-212:13
214:6-215:14
216:18-217:15
218:6-219:18
222:6-222:10
228:13-229:10
Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
22:13-22:15

V; M; C; 403; ATTY; F; S;
R
O; F; V; C; 403; ATTY; S; R
O; F; V; 403; ATTY; LC; S;
R
V; 403; ATTY; O; LC; S; R
V; 403; ATTY; D; M
O; F; V; 403; ATTY; R; S
V; 403; ATTY; F; S; R; O
V; 403; ATTY; F; S; R; O
O; F; V; 403; ATTY; LC; R;
S
O; V; 403; ATTY; R
O; F; V; 403; ATTY; M; LC;
R
O; F; V; 403; ATTY; LC; R
V; 403; ATTY; R; F; D
V; 403; ATTY; D; M
O; F; V; 403; ATTY; S; R
Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations
H/ I
Counter-designation:
22:23-23:15 (already
designated)
H
H
H
H
403/ H
H
H
H/ I
Counter-designation:
88:14-89:5
H/ I
Counter-designation:
88:14-89:5
H
H
H
403/ H
403/ H

34:19-34:21
48:20-48:23
49:1-49:8
49:15-49:19
49:21-49:24
54:4-54:8
54:10-54:20
58:2-58:4

58:6-58:16

89:6-89:8
89:10-89:15
95:22-95:25
97:13-97:16
97:18-98:6

19

108:4-108:7
108:9-108:15
108:17-108:19
110:5-110:12
110:14-110:22
116:3-116:5

H
H
H
H
403/ H as to 110:20-110:22
H/ I
Counter-designation:
32:14-33:4
33:5-34:18
95:3-10 (already designated)
96:1-96:20 (already designated)
97:3-97:8
109:8-110:4
H/ I
Counter-designation:
32:14-33:4
33:5-34:18
95:3-10 (already designated)
96:1-96:20 (already designated)
97:3-97:8
109:8-110:4
H/ I
Counter-designation:
32:14-33:4
33:5-34:18
95:3-10 (already designated)
96:1-96:20 (already designated)
97:3-97:8
109:8-110:4
H
H
H/ I
Counter-designation:
32:14-33:4
33:5-34:18
95:3-10 (already designated)
96:1-96:20 (already designated)
97:3-97:8
109:8-110:4

116:7-116:17

116:19-116:25

121:9-121:13
121:21-122:4
123:23-124:1

20

124:3-124:10

H/ I
Counter-designation:
32:14-33:4
33:5-34:18
95:3-10 (already designated)
96:1-96:20 (already designated)
97:3-97:8
109:8-110:4
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
403/ V/ H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
402 R/ 403/ H
402 R/ 403/ H
402 R/ 403/ H
402 R/ 403/ H
N/ H
N/ H
N/ H
N/ H
N/ H
H/ I
Counter-designation:
216:18-217:15
228:13-229:10
H/ I
Counter-designation:
216:18-217:15
228:13-229:10

127:9-127:12
127:16-127:16
127:19-128:4
164:17-164:19
164:21-165:7
165:9-165:12
166:9-166:13
166:16-166:21
166:24-168:1
168:3-168:7
169:24-170:13
170:15-170:23
170:25-171:2
171:4-171:7
171:9-171:21
171:23-171:25
172:5-172:6
172:8-172:15
203:10-203:13
203:15-203:20
204:6-204:10
204:12-204:14
210:5-210:8
210:16-210:18
210:20-211:4
212:22-212:24
213:1-213:13
215:25-216:2

216:4-216:10

21

228:4-228:6

H/ I
Counter-designation:
228:13-229:10
H/ I
Counter-designation:
228:13-229:10

228:8-228:11

Witness

Bengt-Peter
Karlsson
08.31.2012

Witness

Ming-Chieh Kuo
09.28.2012

Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
7:11-7:18

Defendants’ Objections

13:13-13:16
21:23-23:20
39:8-40:13
41:4-41:10
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
10:4-10:16

V; F; AF
V; F; AF; R
F; AF; R; ATTY

13:25-14:23
25:20-25:24
68:11-68:14
106:10-106:13
157:11-157:15
157:18-158:2
159:3-159:16
162:22-163:6
164:16-164:21
216:5-216:8
221:21-222:3
234:15-234:20
252:3-252:11
259:16-260:4
261:10-261:16
264:20-265:9
265:10-265:23
266:24-267:9
268:5-268:20

Defendants’ Objections

F; AF
F; AF
R; F; Not Testimony; Not for
Jury; 403; I
I
ATTY; V
V; F
I; R
F; V
F; V; S
F; V

ATTY; V; F
ATTY; V; F
ATTY; V; F

22

Witness

Yan Liu
01.17.2013

Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
7:15-7:17
7:21-7:25
260:19-21
260:23-261:3
261:5-261:6
271:20-272:7
272:9-272:12
272:14-272:14
272:17-272:19
272:21-273:1
273:4-273:9
273:11-273:14
273:16-273:19
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
10:23-11:3
11:15-11:20
21:14-22:1
25:18-25:23
27:10-27:16
33:5-33:9
33:17-33:20
63:4-64:8

Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations

I/ 403
I/ 403
I/ 403
E/ 403
E/ 403
CS/ 402 R/ E/ 403
CS/ 402 R/ E/ 403
CS/ 402 R/ E/ 403
CS/ 402 R/ E/ 403
CS/ 402 R/ E/ 403
Defendants’ Objections

V; F; AF; PERSONAL
V; F; AF
V; F; AF; R; 403
V; F; AF; R; 403;
PERSONAL
V; F; AF; R; 403;
PERSONAL
V; F; AF; R; 403;
PERSONAL

Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
19:8-19:12 (OC)
19:15-19:24 (OC)
25:24-25:24 (OC)
26:21-27:9 (OC)
27:17-28:3 (OC)

Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations

ID/WD/ 403/ I
ID/WD/ 403/ I/ CS
ID/WD/ 403

23

Witness

Martin Lysejko
06.28.2012

Witness

James Mahon
08.07.2012

Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
13:4-14:1

Defendants’ Objections

43:4-43:6
211:18-212:1
Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
12:16-12:19
210:25-211:17
212:2-212:2
212:4-212:4
212:6-212:12
213:24-214:14
214:16-215:5
224:19-224:24
225:1-225:1
226:19-226:23
227:1-227:9
228:16-228:22
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
4:25-5:1

H; F; V; I
H; F; V; I; R

5:14-5:17
6:1-6:2
6:5-6:6
7:5-7:22
8:22-9:5
10:11-10:14
10:19-11:1
11:12-11:17
12:1-12:3
15:25-16:21
19:11-19:15
22:5-22:15
22:20-23:1
23:7-23:13
24:15-24:25

H; F; V; I; R

Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations

402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS/ I
402 R/ 403/ BS/ I
402 R/ 403/ BS/ I
402 R/ 403/ BS/ F
402 R/ 403/ BS/ F
402 R/ 403/ LD
402 R/ 403/ LD
402 R/ 403/ BS/ F
402 R/ 403/ BS/ F
402 R/ 403/ BS
Defendants’ Objections

R; 403
403

R; M
I; F
I; F; M
D

24

25:9-25:12
26:18-27:7
27:8-27:12
27:15-27:21
36:6-36:14
Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
4:23-4:24
5:2-5:13 (OC)
7:3-7:4
9:22-10:2
11:18-11:18
11:22-11:25
12:4-12:9 (OC)
12:10-12:19
18:23-19:10
20:7-21:1
22:18-22:18 (OC)
23:3-23:6 (OC)
23:18-20 (OC)
23:22-24:13 (OC)
28:2-28:19 (OC)
30:12-30:15

Witness

Luke McLeroy
09.19.2012

30:24-31:18
36:15-37:10 (OC)
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
6:12-6:13
6:18-6:24
44:23-45:12
49:9-49:12
50:8-50:21
58:22-59:1
59:9-59:15
61:2-61:17
63:21-64:07
65:8-65:16
67:24-68:5
73:4-73:12

Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations

402 R/ 403/ H/ BS
402 R/ 403/ H/ BS

402 R/ 403/ H/ BS
402 R/ 403/ H/ BS

402 R/ 403/ H/ BS
402 R/ 403/ H/ BS
402 R/ 403/ H/ BS
402 R/ 403/ H/ BS/ 403
Cumulative
402 R/ 403/ H/ BS/ C
Defendants’ Objections

S; V
V; R; S
S; R
R
S; V; R
I; V; S
M; R; V

25

74:9-74:19

Witness

William Middleton
09.28.2012

92:21-92:23
93:2-93:11
93:21-94:08
115:5-116:16
117:2-117:15
122:14-123:7
123:8-123:12
140:4-140:13
Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
59:16-60:10 (OC)
116:17-116:25
(OC)
117:20-118:15
(OC)
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
151:08-151:13
151:15-151:24
178:22-179:01
179:03-179:08
179:15-179:25
Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
178:15-178:21
(OC)
179:10-179:11
(OC)
179:13-179:13
(OC)

M; R; V 74:17 – N 74:18-19
–A
R
R
R
F; R
F; R
F; V; R
F; V; R
R; V
Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations
I/ 403

402 R/ 403
Defendants’ Objections

H; I; LC; R; 403; F; S
H; I; LC; R; 403; F; S
H; I; LC; 403; F; S
H; I; LC; 403; F; S
H; I; LC; 403; F; S
Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations
I/ 403
I/ 403/ 402 R
I/ 403/ 402 R

26

Witness

Susan Miller
08.02.2012

Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
8:4-8:18
15:7-15:17
41:22-42:4
48:4-48:8
63:23-64:11
76:6-76:19
85:25-86:4
86:10-86:16
87:2-88:4
141:11-141:17
141:24-142:7
142:11-142:16
142:20-142:24
143:3-143:7
143:11-143:17
146:24-147:11
147:15-147:23
148:15-148:21
148:25-149:4
156:8-156:14
Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
9:16-9:17
9:19-9:22
63:2-63:4
63:6-63:9
63:11-63:12
85:13-85:22
85:24-85:24
86:5-86:6
86:9-86:9
88:16-88:25
89:3-89:6

Defendants’ Objections

V; ATTY; F; R; 403
V; ATTY; F; R
V; 403; R; F
V; M; F; LC
O; F; V; M; ATTY;
PERSONAL; 403; S
V; C; F; S; R
F; V; 403; ATTY;
PERSONAL; I; R; S
F; V; C; 403; ATTY;
PERSONAL; I; R; S
F; V; PERSONAL; 403;
ATTY; I; R; S
F; V; 403; PERSONAL
F; V; 403; PERSONAL
F; V; 403; PERSONAL
F; V; 403; PERSONAL
F; V; 403; PERSONAL
F; V; 403; PERSONAL
F; V; 403; PERSONAL
F; V; 403; PERSONAL
F; V; 403; PERSONAL
F; V; 403; PERSONAL
F; V; 403; PERSONAL
Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations
H/ I/ 403
H/ I/ 403
H/ V
H/ V
H/ V
H/ 402 R
H/ 402 R
H/ 402 R
H/ 402 R
H/ I/ 403
H/ I/ 403

27

Witness

Lennart Marten
Pehrson
08.23.2012

Witness

Douglas Pulley
07.26.2012

Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
9:14-9:21

Defendants’ Objections

22:8-22:10
23:16-23:19
24:18-25:1
31:18-32:5
33:17-34:6
48:10-50:1
67:23-68:2
98:24-99:18
Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
29:6-29:20 (OC)
68:3-68:10
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
50:22-51:4

V; F; AF; 403; PERSONAL
V; F; PERSONAL
V; F; PERSONAL
V; F; PERSONAL
V; F; PERSONAL

113:22-114:23
126:7-126:16
128:10-128:15
156:13-156:23

V; 403; ATTY; H; R; I; F
F; V; ATTY; H; R; I; 403; S
V; 403; ATTY; H; R; I; F; S
V; C; 403; ATTY; F; H; R;
I; S
403; F; V; C; H; R; I; S
V; 403; ATTY; F; C; H; R;
I; S

158:12-158:19
185:20-186:18

V; F; PERSONAL
V; R; 403
Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations
H/ 403
403/ I
Defendants’ Objections

F; V; ATTY; O; S; 403; R; I

28

Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
11:14-11:16

Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations
H/ I
Counter-designation:
13:23-14:7
15:15-15:19
31:14-31:20
153:19-154:1
160:16-160:20
165:20-165:23
169:14-169:18
177:5-177:9
179:8-179:12
188:7-188:10
191:8-191:11
194:10-194:13
199:2-199:5
H/ I
Counter-designation:
13:23-14:7
15:15-15:19
31:14-31:20
153:19-154:1
160:16-160:20
165:20-165:23
169:14-169:18
177:5-177:9
179:8-179:12
188:7-188:10
191:8-191:11
194:10-194:13
199:2-199:5

11:19-11:22

29

11:24-12:1

H/ I
Counter-designation:
13:23-14:7
15:15-15:19
31:14-31:20
153:19-154:1
160:16-160:20
165:20-165:23
169:14-169:18
177:5-177:9
179:8-179:12
188:7-188:10
191:8-191:11
194:10-194:13
199:2-199:5
H/ I
Counter-designation:
13:23-14:7
15:15-15:19
31:14-31:20
153:19-154:1
160:16-160:20
165:20-165:23
169:14-169:18
177:5-177:9
179:8-179:12
188:7-188:10
191:8-191:11
194:10-194:13
199:2-199:5
H/ I
Counter-designation:
50:22-51:4 (already designated)
H/ I
Counter-designation:
50:22-51:4 (already designated)
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H/ I
Counter-designation:
156:13-156:23

12:4-12:4

49:20-49:22

49:24-50:3

53:4-53:5
53:10-53:16
54:16-54:17
54:20-54:25
103:1-103:5
103:10-103:13
137:22-138:3
156:1-156:3

30

156:6-156:11

Witness

Mikael Rylander
08.23.2012

Witness

Stephen Sneeden
08.17.2012

203:8-203:10
203:13-203:17
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
9:6-9:13
18:12-18:14
19:16-19:25
31:11-32:01
Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
17:23-18:4
19:5-19:11 (OC)
34:21-35:4
35:8-35:12
46:24-47:6
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
7:5-7:9
7:23-7:24
12:9-12:12
13:5-13:7
32:25-33:7
34:1-34:4
34:23-35:10
41:8-41:13
42:21-43:2
43:4-43:10
44:3-44:8
44:24-45:3
49:18-50:7
50:14-51:1

H/ I
Counter-designation:
156:13-156:23
H
H
Defendants’ Objections

Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations
403
CS/ H/ 403
H/ 403
H/ 403
403
Defendants’ Objections

PERSONAL; ATTY; R
S; F
ATTY
F; S; ATTY

31

Witness

Malek Shahid
09.11.2012

Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
5:1-5:3
5:21-5:23
7:25-8:12 (OC)
8:20-9:16
12:13-13:4 (OC)
31:19-32:7
33:8-33:15 (OC)
34:4-34:11 (OC)
34:14-34:21
39:9-39:11
39:13-39:14
39:16-40:3
44:10-44:23 (OC)
45:5-45:13 (OC)
50:8-50:13 (OC)
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
10:22-11:18
17:15-17:23
36:21-37:5
39:16-40:3
41:1-41:23
42:12-42:14
43:9-43:11
68:21-69:17
81:12-81:20
101:23-102:4
102:25-103:7
106:12-106:22
111:2-111:13
112:12-113:3
115:13-116:12
117:3-117:19
119:4-119:19
141:25-143:16
153:24-156:12
174:15-174:22

Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations

402 R
402 R
402 R/ H/ BS
402 R/ H/ D
403
403

402 R/ 403/ H/ BS
I/ 403
Defendants’ Objections

V; 403; I
N; I; 403
F; V; M; ATTY; S; O
F; V; M; 403; ATTY
C; V; 403; N; I; F; R
V; I; 403; F; R
V; I; 403; F; R
C; F; PERSONAL; 403;
ATTY; S; V; R; O
F; V; 403; S; R
C; V; I; M; 403
F; I; 403; S
F; I; 403; ATTY; S; V
F; 403; ATTY; V; S; I
F; 403; ATTY; V; S; I
F; 403; ATTY; V; S; I
F; 403; ATTY; V; S; I
F; 403; ATTY; V; S; I
C; F; V; 403; S; R; I
H; F; 403; V; S; I
F; 403; ATTY; V; S; I; R

32

Witness

Paul Struhsaker
07.02.2012

Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
17:24-18:12
42:8-42:11
42:15-42:18
42:24-43:8
43:12-43:23
43:25-44:1
52:3-52:5
52:8-52:18
101:8-101:22
106:4-106:6
106:8-106:10
113:24-114:1
114:3-114:4
138:1-139:22
140:20-141:2
156:23-157:4
157:8-157:22
159:20-159:24
160:1-160:12
160:14-161:9
166:11-166:13
166:15-166:18
203:22-203:24
204:1-204:5
262:22-263:3
263:5-263:9
263:11-263:15
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
115:17-116:13

Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
402 R/ 403/ N/ H
H
H
402 R/ 403/ A/ CF/ V/ H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
Defendants’ Objections

F; V; I; ATTY

Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
117:15-117:18
123:16-123:23

Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations
403
403

33

Witness

Said Tatesh
09.13.2012

Witness

Frank Vecella
09.05.2012

Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
7:6-7:10

Defendants’ Objections

I

7:23-8:7
8:14-8:23
33:16-34:6
34:25-35:7
37:15-38:5
Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
7:11-7:22
21:25-22:3
22:17-22:24
34:7-34:24
35:9-36:22
42:2-42:10
43:7-44:18
44:20-45:6
45:8-46:16
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
7:08-7:17

J; 403
I; V; 403
C; F; V; 403; R; O; S
F; V; 403; ATTY
F; V; I; M; 403; ATTY; S

14:12-14:14
15:18-16:3
16:6-16:6
16:7-16:15
16:18-16:19
17:18-17:24
18:2-18:6
18:8-18:12
18:15-18:18
18:20-18:24
19:15-19:16
19:19-19:19
24:8-24:22
25:15-25:24
32:10-32:13

R; PERSONAL
R; PERSONAL
R; PERSONAL
R; PERSONAL
R; PERSONAL
R (17:23-24); A; S; O
R; A; S; O
R; A; S; O
R; A; S; O
R; A; S; O
R; A; S; O
R; A; S; O
R; 403; F
R; 403; F

Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations
H
H
H
H
H
H
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ H
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ H
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ H
Defendants’ Objections

34

Witness

William Zucker
12.06.2012

32:17-32:19
33:6-33:8
34:20-34:24
35:18-35:18
35:21-35:23
35:24-35:25
36:18-36:25
37:6-37:20
37:22-37:25
39:3-39:14
44:10-44:15
50:4-50:25
51:2-51:3
51:7-51:11
54:3-54:13
54:16-54:17
55:14-55:17
55:19-55:22
56:8-56:13
64:17-64:19
65:18-66:6
66:9-66:11
68:3-68:7
68:11-68:20
Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
38:1-38:4 (OC)
38:6-38:11 (OC)
40:12-40:24 (OC)
42:9-42:17
43:18-44:6 (OC)
Wi-LAN’s
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
13:2-13:12

R; 403; 408
R; 403; 408
R; 403; 408
R; 403; 408
R; 403; 408
R; 403; 408
R; 403; 408
R; 403; 408
R; 403; 408
R; 403; 408

25:23-26:1
26:13-26:18
34:18-35:1
40:3-41:1
43:1-43:12
73:7-73:18

R; 403
R; 403; F; S
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403; S; F
R; 403; S; F

Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations
P/ H/ 402 R/ 403
P/ H/ 402 R/ 403
H/ I/ 403
I/ 403
H/ 402 R/ 403
Defendants’ Objections

35

75:6-75:10
87:24-88:15
95:17-97:6
98:5-98:20
144:9-144:20
Defendants’
Counter
Designations
[Page:lines]
26:2-26:12
27:14-28:7
35:15-35:25
39:8-39:13
42:4-42:6
73:19-73:20
75:22-76:1
76:16-77:2
83:25-84:22
86:8-87:8
89:17-90:4
97:7-97:9
97:11-97:17
99:13-99:18
158:17-158:22
174:15-175:5
176:11-176:15
176:24-177:2

R; 403; S; F
R; 403 S; F
R; 403; S; F; H; O; M
R; 403; S; F; O; M
R; 403; S; F; M
Wi-LAN’s Objections to
Defendants’ Counter
Designations

H/ 403
H/ 402 R/ 403
H
403/ Misleading/ 402 R/ BS
I/ 403/ H/ 402 R/ BS
H/ 402 R/ 403
I/ 403/ 402 R/ H/ BS
H/ 403/ 408/ 402 R/ BS
I/ H/ 402 R/ BS
H/ 402 R/ 403
H/ 402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ H/ BS
I/ 403/ 402 R/ BS
I/ 403/ H/ 402 R/ BS
H/ 402 R/ BS
H/ 402 R/ BS

36

Wi-LAN’s OBJECTIONS TO HTC’S COUNTER DESIGNATIONS
Witness

Wi-LAN’s Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]

HTC’s Objections

David Brant
06.29.2012

15:8-16:17

H

20:6-25:4
42:6-43:19
120:1-124:9
124:23-127:21
129:10-129:18
129:20-129:25
130:2-130:6
130:16-130:23
132:15-133:20
167:19-168:11
173:7-173:25
196:7-196:25
210:11-210:14
215:11-216:22
235:17-236:8
HTC’s Counter
Designations [Page:lines]

ATTY; H; C
ATTY; H; S
ATTY; H; S; R
ATTY; H; S; V
ATTY; H
ATTY; H
ATTY; H
ATTY; H
ATTY; H
ATTY; H; F
ATTY; H; F; AF; V
S; V; H
ATTY; D; V; H
ATTY; S; H
D; H

117:4-117:16
117:20-118:4
118:6-118:17
118:19-119:4
127:22-129:9
174:9-174:11
174:14-174:15
174:17-175:2
175:4-175:4
175:6-175:7

37

Wi-LAN’s Objections
to Defendants’
Counter Designations

Wi-LAN’s Objections
to Defendants’
Counter Designations
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ AF/
C
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ AF/
C
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ AF/
C
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ AF/
C
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ AF
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ AF
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ AF
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ AF
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ AF

175:11-175:15
175:18-175:19
175:21-175:23
197:19-197:25
198:3-198:3
198:5-198:5
198:7-198:11
198:14-198:15
198:22-198:24
199:2-199:2
199:4-199:6
199:8-199:8
199:10-199:14
199:17-199:19
199:21-199:23
200:1-200:5
200:7-200:9
200:12-200:14
201:17-201:19
201:22-201:22
201:24-202:2
202:5-202:9
212:22-213:6

CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ AF
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ AF
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ AF
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ AF/ LD
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ F
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ F
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ F
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ F
H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/
ID/ F/ A/ I
Counter-designation:
212:14-212:19
236:20-237:8
H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/
ID/ F/ A/ I

213:8-213:11

Counter-designation:
212:14-212:19
236:20-237:8
H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/
ID/ F/ A/ I

213:13-213:18

Counter-designation:
212:14-212:19
236:20-237:8

38

213:21-213:24

H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/
ID/ F/ A/ I
Counter-designation:
212:14-212:19
236:20-237:8
H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/
ID/ F/ A/ I

214:1-214:5

Counter-designation:
212:14-212:19
236:20-237:8
H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/
ID/ F/ A/ I

214:8-214:10

Counter-designation:
212:14-212:19
236:20-237:8
H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/
ID/ F/ A/ I

214:12-214:13

Counter-designation:
212:14-212:19
236:20-237:8

Witness
Ming-Chieh Kuo
09.28.2012

236:9-236:16
236:18-236:18
236:20-236:22
237:1-237:1
237:3-237:5
237:8-237:8
Wi-LAN’s Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
10:04-10:16
13:25-14:23
25:20-25:24
68:11-68:14
106:10-106:13
157:11-157:15
157:18-158:02
159:03-159:16

HTC’s Objections

F; I; R

39

162:22-163:06
164:16-164:21
216:05-216:08
221:21-222:03
234:15-234:20
252:03-252:11
259:16-260:04
261:10-261:16
264:20-265:09
265:10-265:23
266:24-267:09
268:05-268:20
HTC’s Counter
Designations [Page:lines]

Witness
Hsiu Fen Lai
08.09.2012

159:17-161:16
163:7-163:11
164:22-165:6
220:12-223:11
234:2-236:21
246:20-253:12
Wi-LAN’s Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
9:15-9:16
9:20-9:24
76:16-76:21

F; I; R; V
F; I; R; V
F; I; S; V
F; I; S; V
F; I; S

Wi-LAN’s Objections
to Defendants’
Counter Designations
402 R/ CS
I/ ID/WD
CS/ ID/WD
I/ 403
I/ 403
I/ 403/ ID/WD
HTC’s Objections

76:16 - F; S; H;
PERSONAL

77:17-78:03
HTC’s Counter
Designations [Page:lines]

Witness
Yan Liu
07.17.2013

76:22-77:16
Wi-LAN’s Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
10:23-11:03
11:15-11:20
21:14-22:01

40

Wi-LAN’s Objections
to Defendants’
Counter Designations
402 R/ 403/ H
HTC’s Objections

25:18-25:23
27:10-27:16
33:05-33:09
33:17-33:20
63:04-64:08
HTC’s Counter
Designations [Page:lines]

Witness
Martin Lysejko
06.28.2012

24:13-26:07
33:21-34:23
Wi-LAN’s Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
13:4-14:1
43:4-43:6
211:18-212:1
HTC’s Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
12:16-12:19
210:25-211:17
212:2-212:2
212:4-212:4
212:6-212:12
213:24-214:14
214:16-215:5
224:19-224:24
225:1-225:1
226:19-226:23
227:1-227:9
228:16-228:22
245:10-245:16
245:21-246:2
246:4-246:16
246:19-246:21
246:24-247:7
247:10-247:15
247:17-248:6

41

I

V; S; P; I
Wi-LAN’s Objections
to Defendants’
Counter Designations
I/ 403/ CS/ F
402 R/ 403
HTC’s Objections
H; F; V; I; R
H; F; V; I
H; F; V; I; R
Wi-LAN’s Objections
to Defendants’
Counter Designations
402 R/ 403/ BS/H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ I/ H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ I/ H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ I/ H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ F/ H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ F/ H
402 R/ 403/ LD/ H
402 R/ 403/ LD/ H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ F/ H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ F/ H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ H
402 R/ 403/ E/ L/ H
402 R/ 403/ E/ L/ H
402 R/ 403/ E/ L/ H
402 R/ 403/ E/ L/ H
402 R/ 403/ E/ L/ H
402 R/ 403/ E/ L/ H
402 R/ 403/ E/ L/ H
402 R/ 403/ E/ L/ H

Witness
Marcia Markovich
09.19.2012

248:9-248:9
255:2-255:4
255:8-256:4
256:7-256:12
256:14-256:14
261:16-262:1
262:4-262:7
262:10-262:11
262:13-262:18
262:22-263:9
263:11-264:8
264:12-264:22
264:24-265:12
Wi-LAN’s Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
09:16-09:20
11:23-12:04
63:23-64:14
69:01-69:07
70:15-70:19
76:07-76:08
76:10-76:17
80:08-80:11
84:14-84:21
90:20-91:01
100:20-100:23
115:08-115:13
122:21-123:13
HTC’s Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
76:18-76:23
80:12-80:20
91:02-91:07
94:12-94:19
95:10-95:24
100:14 - 100:19

CS/ 402 R/ 403/ F/ H
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ F/ H
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ F/ H
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ F/ H
402 R/ 403/ E/ L/ H
402 R/ 403/ E/ L/ H
402 R/ 403/ E/ L/ H
402 R/ 403/ E/ L/ H
402 R/ 403/ E/ L/ H
402 R/ 403/ E/ L/ H
402 R/ 403/ E/ L/ H
402 R/ 403/ E/ L/ H
402 R/ 403/ BS/ H
HTC’s Objections

H; S
F; S
S; F; PERSONAL

S; V
S; F; PERSONAL
F; S; V
Wi-LAN’s Objections
to Defendants’
Counter Designations
402 R/ 403/ H/ BS
402 R/ CS/ H/ 403
H/ BS/ 402 R/ 403
I/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ I

42

Witness
William Middleton
09.28.2012

114:02-114:24
120:07-120:25
122:02-122:05
Wi-LAN’s Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
151:08-151:13
151:15-151:24
178:22-179:01
179:03-179:08
179:15-179:25
HTC’s Counter
Designations [Page:lines]

Witness
Paul Struhsaker
07.02.2012

178:15-178:21 (OC)
179:10-179:11 (OC)
179:13-179:13 (OC)
Wi-LAN’s Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
115:17-116:13

I/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS
H/ CS/ 402 R/ 403/ BS
I/ 403/ 402 R/ BS/ H
HTC’s Objections
H; I; LC; R; 403; F;
S
H; I; LC; R; 403; F;
S
H; I; LC; 403; F; S
H; I; LC; 403; F; S
H; I; LC; 403; F; S
Wi-LAN’s Objections
to Defendants’
Counter Designations
I/ 403
I/ 403/ 402 R
I/ 403/ 402 R
HTC’s Objections
H; F; V; I; ATTY

HTC’s Counter
Designations [Page:lines]

Witness
Frank Wu
08.07.2012

Wi-LAN’s Objections
to Defendants’
Counter Designations
403/ H
403/ H

117:15-117:18
123:16-123:23
Wi-LAN’s Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
8:05-8:12

HTC’s Objections

15:25-16:08
16:22-16:23
16:24-17:04
24:16-24:23
25:08-25:11
25:21-27:03
27:25-30:01
30:03-30:22

H; F; S
H; F; S
H; F; S
F; I; S
F; I; S
F; H; S; I
F; H; S; I
F; H; S; I

43

31:06-31:24
36:15-37:02
39:16-40:21
46:21-47:06
51:01-51:17
HTC’s Counter
Designations [Page:lines]

Witness
Lin Yu
08.08.2012

14:12-14:23
17:05-17:10
34:10-35:01
35:14-35:25
43:09-43:12
45:24-46:08
53:08-54:05
57:09-57:18
61:09-61:16
Wi-LAN’s Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
06:18-06:18
08:05-08:10
17:01-17:06
20:13-20:18
20:21-21:03
31:08-31:11
31:12-31:15
31:16-31:17
31:18-31:18
47:03-47:15
48:24-49:07
55:19-56:03
58:20-58:23
59:02-59:04
59:06-59:11
61:11-61:13
61:14-61:19
64:07-64:25

F; H; I; S
H; F; S; I
H; F; S; I
F; I; H; S
Wi-LAN’s Objections
to Defendants’
Counter Designations
403
H/ 403/ I/ F
H
H
H
CS/ H/ 403/ I/ F
CS/ H/ 403/ F
CS/ H/ 403/ I/ F
CS/ H/ 403/ I/ F
HTC’s Objections

R; 408; 403; M
R; 408; 403; M
R; 408; M; 403
R; M; 408; 403
R; M; 408; 403
M; 408; R; I
R; M; 408; 403

44

74:14-74:24
75:01-75:19
76:11-76:13
93:03-93:06
93:08-93:12
93:23-93:24
94:01-94:04
98:25-99:04
141:23-141:25
142:01-142:06
HTC’s Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
83:23-83:10
84:05-84:13

408; 403; R; I; M; S
408; 403; R; S; I; M
A; 408; 403; S; R
R; I; V; S
R; I; V; S
R; I; S
R; V; S
R; S; I; V

Wi-LAN’s Objections
to Defendants’
Counter Designations
402 R/ 403/ H

WI-LAN’s OBJECTION KEY TO DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS
Abbreviation
CS
H
402/R
403
BS
E
I or 106
P
L
ID/WD
MS/ML
F
xxx
N
AF
C
LD
A
CF
V
Imp
D

Objection
Calls for Speculation
Hearsay
Irrelevant
Unduly Prejudicial / Confusing / Vague / Misleading / Cumulative / Out of
Context/ Attorney Objection
Improper 30(b)(6) testimony / Beyond Scope
Improper Expert Testimony
Incomplete
Privileged
Call for Legal Conclusion
Inaccurate Description/Insufficient Identification of Exhibit
Subject to Motion to Strike or Motion in Limine
Lack of proper foundation
FRE xxx
Nonresponsive
Assumes facts not in evidence
Compound
Leading
Argumentative
Confusing
Vague/Ambiguous
Improper/Incomplete Designation
Duplicative

45

DEFENDANTS - OBJECTION KEY
R = Lacks Relevance (FRE 401/402)
H = Hearsay (FRE 802)
O = Improper Opinion
F = Lacks Foundation/Speculative (FRE 602)
V = Vague/Ambiguous
M = Misleading/Mischaracterizes
prior testimony
P = Privilege
408 = Settlement (FRE 408)
LC = Legal Conclusion
D = Duplication

A = Argumentative
C = Compound
L = Leading
N = Nonresponsive
I = Improper/Incomplete Designation
PERSONAL = Testimony by 30(b)(6)
designee outside scope of noticed topics
403 = Unduly prejudicial/confusion/waste
of time (FRE 403)
ATTY = Attorney objections not removed
S = Speculation
AF = Assumes facts not in evidence

Wi-LAN further objects to any testimony designated by any Defendant that violates any
ruling of the Court, including rulings related to the parties’ forthcoming Motions in Limine. WiLAN further objections to Defendants’ designations to the extent they exceed the length
permitted by the Court’s standing order. Wi-LAN reserves the right to amend its objections and
deposition designations to respond to issues raised and/or resolved after the submission of this
list. Wi-LAN also reserves the right to designate the depositions of any witnesses that any
Defendant removes from its Witness List identified as “will call” and/or “may call.” In making
any designations above, Wi-LAN is not in any way waiving any objections to the admissibility
of any of Defendants’ designations.

46

Dated: March 1, 2013

Respectfully submitted,

By:
Local Counsel
Johnny Ward (TX Bar No. 00794818)
Wesley Hill (TX Bar No. 24032294)
WARD & SMITH LAW FIRM
P.O. Box 1231
1127 Judson Rd., Ste. 220
Longview, TX 75606-1231
Tel: [phone]
Fax: [phone]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]

/s/ David B. Weaver
David B. Weaver (TX Bar No. 00798576)
Lead Attorney
Avelyn M. Ross (TX Bar No. 24027817)
Ajeet P. Pai (TX Bar No. 24060376)
Syed K. Fareed (TX Bar No. 24065216)
Jeffrey T. Han (TX Bar No. 24069870)
Seth A. Lindner (TX Bar No. 24078862)
Janice Ta (TX Bar No. 24075138)
VINSON & ELKINS LLP
2801 Via Fortuna, Suite 100
Austin, TX 78746
Tel: [phone]
Fax: [phone]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
Steve R. Borgman (TX Bar No. 02670300)
Gwendolyn J. Samora
(TX Bar No. 00784899)
VINSON &ELKINS LLP
1001 Fannin Street, Suite 2500
Houston, TX 77002-6760
Tel: [phone]
Fax: [phone]
[e-mail]
Chuck P. Ebertin (CA Bar No. 161374)
VINSON & ELKINS LLP
525 University Avenue, Suite 410
Palo Alto, CA 94301-1918
Tel: [phone]
Fax: [phone]
[e-mail]
Constance S. Huttner
(NY Bar No. 1722024)
VINSON & ELKINS LLP

47

666 5th Avenue, 26th Floor
New York, NY 10103-0040
Tel: [phone]
Fax: (9l7) 849-5339
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
Attorneys for Plaintiff, Wi-LAN Inc.

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
The undersigned certifies that the foregoing document was filed electronically in
compliance with Local Rule CV-5(a). As such, this document was served on all counsel who are
deemed to have consented to electronic service. Local Rule CV-5(a)(3)(A). Pursuant to Fed. R.
Civ. P. 5(d) and Local Rule CV-5(d) and (e), all other counsel of record not deemed to have
consented to electronic service were served with a true and correct copy of the foregoing by
email and/or fax, on this the 1st day of March, 2013.

/s/ David B. Weaver
David B. Weaver

48