WI-LAN Inc. v. Alcatel-Lucent USA Inc. et al

Filing 336

NOTICE by Alcatel-Lucent USA Inc., Ericsson Inc., Exedea INC., HTC America, Inc., HTC Corporation, Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., Sony Mobile Communications AB, Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson re 329 Notice (Other), Notice (Other), Notice (Other), Notice (Other) Defendants' Objections to Wi-LAN's Rebuttal Designations (Deoras, Akshay)

Download PDF
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS TYLER DIVISION § § § § § § § § § § WI-LAN INC., Plaintiff, v. ALCATEL-LUCENT USA INC.; et al. Defendants. Civil Action No. 6:10-cv-521-LED JURY TRIAL DEMANDED DEFENDANTS’ OBJECTIONS TO WI-LAN’S REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS Please take notice that Defendants Alcatel-Lucent USA Inc., Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson, Ericsson Inc., Sony Mobile Communications AB, Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., HTC Corporation, HTC America, Inc., and Exedea Inc. hereby make the following objections to Wi-LAN’s rebuttal deposition designations served February 25, 2013. Defendants object to any testimony designated by Wi-LAN that violates any ruling of the Court, including rulings related to the parties’ forthcoming motions in limine. Defendants further object to Wi-LAN’s designations and counter designations to the extent they exceed the length permitted by the Court’s standing order. Defendants object on hearsay grounds to the use of designations from one Defendant’s employees against any other Defendant. Each Defendant reserves the right to amend its objections to respond to issues raised and/or resolved after the submission of this list. Defendants further object to Wi-LAN’s inclusion of “counter-counter” designations in their filing on March 1, 2013. (D.I. 334.) The Court’s Docket Control Order does not allow for “counter-counter” designations. (D.I. 99.) Similarly, the parties’ Joint Pretrial Order does not contemplate “counter-counter” designations. (D.I. 311.) Should the Court allow Wi-LAN to 1 play its “counter-counter” designations, Defendants reserve their right to object to such designations and designate their own “counter-counter” designations. OBJECTION KEY R = Lacks Relevance (FRE 401/402) H = Hearsay (FRE 802) O = Improper Opinion F = Lacks Foundation/Speculative (FRE 602) V = Vague/Ambiguous M = Misleading/Mischaracterizes prior testimony P = Privilege 408 = Settlement (FRE 408) LC = Legal Conclusion D = Duplication A = Argumentative C = Compound L = Leading N = Nonresponsive I = Improper/Incomplete Designation PERSONAL = Testimony by 30(b)(6) designee outside scope of noticed topics 403 = Unduly prejudicial/confusion/waste of time (FRE 403) ATTY = Attorney objections not removed S = Speculation AF = Assumes facts not in evidence ALCATEL-LUCENT, SONY MOBILE, AND ERICSSON’S OBJECTIONS1 Witness BS/ 403/ CS 21:15-22:4 22:6-22:6 Natalya Bezryadina 11/7/2012 AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 9:2-9:4 9:7-9:12 10:18-10:19 11:9-11:16 12:19-12:21 12:23-13:2 14:4-14:4 14:6-14:8 Wi-LAN’s Objections BS/ 403 BS/ 403 402 R/ 403 CS/ I CS/ I 1 Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections 13:04-13:06 20:17-20:19; 20:21-20:21; 21:03-21:05 I Alcatel-Lucent, Sony Mobile, and Ericsson hereby incorporate by reference all of HTC’s objections. 2 Witness David Brant 6/29/2012 AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 22:8-22:11 29:21-29:22 29:24-29:25 38:7-38:9 38:11-38:11 12:16-13:2 14:18-14:25 15:8-16:5 16:14-16:21 18:5-18:11 36:18-37:5 37:9-37:10 41:8-41:11 41:15-41:16 42:6-42:12 42:19-43:16 43:19-43:19 48:18-49:25 51:4-51:8 51:10-51:13 56:23-57:1 64:18-64:24 65:1-65:7 66:9-66:12 66:14-66:19 71:4-71:17 71:20-72:9 72:11-72:23 93:19-94:18 94:20-94:20 95:6-96:16 98:5-98:22 Wi-LAN’s Objections Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections BS/ 403 403 403 BS/ 402 R 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 E/ BS/ 403 E/ BS/ 403 CS/ 403/ BS/ E/ L 15:08—16:17 CS/ 403/ BS/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ BS CS/ 403/ BS/ E/ L CS/ 403/ BS/ E/ L 403 66:20—67:23 403 66:20—67:23 403/ E/ L 72:24—73:03 403/ E/ L 72:24—73:03 403/ E/ L 72:24—73:03 403/ E/ L 72:24—73:03 403/ E/ L 72:24—73:03 402 R/ 403 403 98:23—99:14 101:14-101:16 101:18-101:24 102:2-102:16 105:7-105:15 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 106 20:05—25:04 105:17-105:25 106 20:05—25:04 3 ATTY, H, R, 403 ATTY, H, R, 403 ATTY, H, R, 403 ATTY, H, R, 403 ATTY, H, R, 403 ATTY, H, 403, S, F, AF ATTY, R, 403, H, I ATTY, R, 403, H, I Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 106:3-106:4 Wi-LAN’s Objections 106 20:05—25:04 106:7-106:8 106 20:05—25:04 108:4-108:18 109:20-111:22 111:24-112:3 112:17-113:14 114:22-114:24 115:2-115:3 115:6-115:13 117:4-117:13 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ 106 120:1—124:9 119:5-119:8 402 R/ 403/ 106 120:1—124:9 119:11-119:25 402 R/ 403/ 106 120:1—124:9 122:8-122:24 402 R/ 403/ 106 120:1—124:9 123:1-123:1 402 R/ 403/ 106 120:1—124:9 127:22-128:9 128:11-128:13 128:15-128:19 128:22-129:4 129:10-129:15 129:18-129:23 129:25-130:4 130:6-130:6 130:16-130:19 130:25-131:3 131:6-131:16 131:18-131:23 131:25-132:3 132:5-132:5 133:13-133:17 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 106 133:20-133:20 134:5-134:13 134:19-135:3 135:5-135:13 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 4 Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections ATTY, R, 403, H, I ATTY, R, 403, H, I ATTY, R, H, S, F, AF ATTY, R, H, S, F, AF ATTY, R, H, S, F, AF ATTY, R, H, S, F, AF ATTY, R, H, S, F, AF 403, 403, 403, 403, 403, 132:15—133:20 ATTY, 403, M, I, H, F, AF Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 135:16-136:20 136:22-137:7 137:10-138:10 138:12-138:18 138:21-139:23 140:1-140:24 141:1-141:20 141:23-142:8 142:11-143:8 143:10-144:6 144:9-144:19 144:23-145:11 145:14-145:23 148:14-148:20 148:23-148:23 149:5-149:14 149:16-150:3 150:6-150:16 150:19-152:21 152:23-153:3 153:5-153:5 154:1-154:5 154:8-154:24 155:1-155:1 155:3-156:11 156:20-157:16 157:19-157:20 157:23-157:23 157:25-158:11 158:13-158:16 158:19-158:23 159:1-159:1 161:14-161:17 161:19-161:25 162:13-163:3 163:5-164:5 164:8-164:9 167:19-168:2 168:24-169:16 169:19-169:20 169:23-169:23 Wi-LAN’s Objections 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 106 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 5 Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections 167:19—168:11 ATTY Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 170:2-170:6 170:9-170:14 170:17-170:20 174:9-174:11 174:14-175:2 175:4-175:4 175:13-175:15 175:18-175:19 190:20-191:5 191:6-191:7 195:5-195:7 195:9-195:19 195:21-195:23 195:25-196:2 197:19-197:25 198:2-198:3 198:5-198:11 198:14-198:15 199:10-199:14 199:17-199:19 200:7-200:9 200:12-200:14 201:17-201:19 201:22-201:22 201:24-202:2 202:5-202:9 212:22-213:6 213:8-213:11 213:13-213:18 213:21-213:24 214:1-214:5 214:8-214:13 214:24-215:1 Wi-LAN’s Objections Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS CS/ 402 R/ 403 CS/ 402 R/ 403 CS/ 402 R/ 403 CS/ 402 R/ 403 CS/ 402 R/ 403 CS/ 402 R/ 403 CS/ 402 R/ 403 CS/ 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ BS/ 210:11—210:14, E/ L 236:9—237:8 402 R/ 403/ BS/ 210:11—210:14, E/ L 236:9—237:8 402 R/ 403/ BS/ 210:11—14, E/ L 236:9—237:8 402 R/ 403/ BS/ 210:11—14, E/ L 236:9—237:8 402 R/ 403/ BS/ 210:11—14, E/ L 236:9—237:8 402 R/ 403/ BS/ 210:11—14, E/ L 236:9—237:8 402 R/ 403/ BS/ 210:11—14, E/ L 236:9—237:8 6 AL-E-SM’s Objections ATTY, H, R, 403, L, V, S, F ATTY, H, R, 403, L, V, S, F ATTY, H, R, 403, L, V, S, F ATTY, H, R, 403, L, V, S, F ATTY, H, R, 403, L, V, S, F ATTY, H, R, 403, L, V, S, F ATTY, H, R, 403, L, V, S, F Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 215:3-215:7 Wi-LAN’s Objections Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations 222:4-222:7 222:9-222:18 224:24-225:2 402 R/ 403/ BS/ 210:11—14, E/ L 236:9—237:8 402 R/ 403/ BS/ 210:11—14, E/ L 236:9—237:8 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 236:9—237:8 225:4-225:9 402 R/ 403/ BS 236:9—237:8 225:11-225:15 402 R/ 403/ BS 236:9—237:8 225:18-225:22 402 R/ 403/ BS 236:9—237:8 225:24-226:3 402 R/ 403/ BS 236:9—237:8 226:5-226:20 402 R/ 403/ BS 236:9—237:8 226:23-226:25 402 R/ 403/ BS 236:9—237:8 230:14-230:17 230:19-230:19 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 10:20-11:5 20:6-20:12 20:20-21:3 21:9-21:23 21:25-23:3 33:1-33:4 48:6-48:11 49:5-49:12 49:14-49:14 51:6-51:18 73:6-73:8 73:10-73:11 78:11-78:13 78:15-78:18 80:4-80:9 80:15-80:22 85:14-85:16 85:18-85:22 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ E 402 R/ 403/ E 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 215:9-215:9 Christian Dubuc 8/22/2012 7 AL-E-SM’s Objections ATTY, H, R, 403, L, V, S, F ATTY, H, R, 403, L, V, S, F ATTY, H, R, 403, L, V, S, F ATTY, H, R, 403, L, V, S, F ATTY, H, R, 403, L, V, S, F ATTY, H, R, 403, L, V, S, F ATTY, H, R, 403, L, V, S, F ATTY, H, R, 403, L, V, S, F ATTY, H, R, 403, L, V, S, F Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 92:6-92:8 92:11-92:11 92:15-92:18 92:20-93:2 93:3-93:7 93:9-93:11 94:6-94:12 94:15-94:25 95:11-95:13 95:15-96:4 96:7-96:23 97:9-98:17 98:20-99:1 105:9-105:10 105:12-105:22 107:3-107:8 107:22-107:24 108:1-108:12 108:14-108:16 108:19-108:25 109:3-109:4 109:7-109:11 117:19-119:2 119:5-119:8 119:10-119:12 119:14-119:20 120:14-120:16 120:18-120:18 120:20-120:22 120:25-121:4 Wi-LAN’s Objections CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ L CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L CS/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ L CS/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ L CS/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ L CS/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ L CS/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ L 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 CS/ 402 R/ 403/ BS CS/ 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 8 Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 124:3-124:9 128:14-128:18 128:20-128:23 130:25-131:8 131:10-131:15 161:5-161:7 161:9-161:9 163:18-163:22 163:24-163:24 165:4-165:18 165:20-166:18 167:25-168:4 168:10-168:15 168:17-168:17 168:19-168:21 170:1-170:3 170:9-170:11 176:8-176:16 176:18-176:18 176:24-177:1 177:11-177:13 177:15-177:22 178:3-178:9 178:11-178:17 178:18-178:21 179:2-179:8 179:10-179:15 180:5-180:22 181:3-181:4 182:5-182:21 182:23-182:23 183:8-183:12 183:24-184:24 185:1-185:5 185:9-185:11 185:20-185:22 185:24-185:24 188:10-188:11 188:13-188:19 Wi-LAN’s Objections 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ E/ L/ ML 402 R/ 403/ E/ L/ ML 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ P 402 R/ 403/ P 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 9 Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 191:1-191:7 191:13-191:16 191:18-191:22 191:25-192:2 192:4-192:6 193:13-193:16 193:18-194:14 195:3-195:7 195:14-195:16 195:18-196:4 196:8-196:9 197:18-197:24 198:1-198:5 201:9-201:13 201:19-201:24 202:13-202:14 202:17-202:18 204:17-204:22 205:3-205:10 209:4-209:7 209:10-209:16 210:3-210:9 210:12-210:17 210:21-211:6 213:4-213:7 213:10-213:11 213:13-213:18 213:21-213:25 214:4-214:8 214:12-214:23 215:1-215:1 221:12-221:13 221:15-221:15 225:4-225:23 Wi-LAN’s Objections 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 CS/ 402 R/ 403 CS/ 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ BS/ ML 402 R/ 403/ BS/ ML 402 R/ 403/ BS/ ML 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 10 Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 226:1-226:2 227:14-228:10 228:12-229:17 229:19-230:25 231:13-232:15 232:18-232:19 233:8-233:13 233:15-234:7 235:14-235:20 235:22-236:5 236:17-236:19 236:22-236:23 237:8-237:9 237:12-237:18 237:20-237:20 239:7-239:10 239:13-239:20 254:6-254:10 254:12-254:15 261:12-261:17 261:20-261:25 262:2-262:3 262:5-262:8 262:23-263:1 263:3-263:11 263:14-263:18 263:21-264:2 264:5-264:9 264:11-264:14 264:16-265:4 265:7-265:19 265:21-265:24 266:2-266:2 311:5-311:10 311:15-311:22 327:12-327:14 327:16-327:17 343:19-344:2 344:7-344:10 Wi-LAN’s Objections 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS CS/ 402 R/ 403/ BS CS/ 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ ML 11 Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 344:17-344:20 345:9-345:20 Wi-LAN’s Objections 346:21-347:13 348:20-348:23 348:25-349:6 351:4-351:13 351:15-351:20 351:22-351:23 351:25-353:2 402 R/ 403/ ML CS/ 402 R/ 403/ ML CS/ 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403/ BS 11:24-12:1 12:2-12:4 12:5-12:8 12:9-12:12 12:13-12:15 12:16-12:19 13:13-14:10 23:5-23:20 25:12-25:15 35:3-35:5 35:7-35:8 35:10-35:10 35:14-35:16 35:18-35:18 35:20-36:2 36:11-37:19 39:1-41:2 41:4-41:4 41:9-41:9 44:1-44:5 44:17-44:19 44:23-45:2 45:11-45:25 46:7-46:11 46:19-46:22 46:24-47:2 47:19-47:23 48:5-48:5 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ E 402 R/ 403/ E 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 346:17-346:19 Martin Lysejko 6/28/2012 12 Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 48:7-48:14 48:20-49:1 49:3-49:14 49:25-50:2 58:18-59:4 59:10-59:14 60:14-60:25 61:4-61:7 74:14-74:23 75:21-76:9 77:15-78:1 78:13-79:22 80:1-80:24 82:4-86:8 98:8-99:7 99:11-99:11 99:13-99:18 100:22-100:25 101:3-101:4 105:3-105:4 105:9-105:11 106:23-107:16 108:9-108:11 108:13-108:23 112:11-112:17 113:14-113:23 113:25-114:8 114:10-114:16 114:18-114:18 115:5-115:13 115:19-116:6 116:24-117:2 Wi-LAN’s Objections 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ L CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ L CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ L CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ L CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ L CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ L CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ L CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ L CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ L CS/ 402 R/ 403/ L CS/ 402 R/ 403/ L CS/ 402 R/ 403/ L CS/ 402 R/ 403/ L CS/ 402 R/ 403/ L 402 R/ 403/ L 402 R/ 403/ L 402 R/ 403/ L 402 R/ 403/ L 402 R/ 403/ L CS/ 402 R/ 403/ L 402 R/ 403/ L 402 R/ 403 13 Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 117:15-117:17 117:19-117:21 119:7-119:21 120:13-120:21 120:22-120:24 123:18-123:20 127:2-127:6 127:9-127:12 128:20-130:2 130:22-131:12 133:21-133:22 133:24-134:9 134:12-134:15 134:17-134:19 134:21-134:22 134:24-135:1 135:4-135:5 145:9-145:23 145:25-145:25 146:11-146:13 146:16-146:20 155:17-155:20 155:23-156:17 156:19-156:19 161:25-162:8 162:16-162:25 163:2-163:2 163:4-163:5 163:7-163:9 163:11-163:11 166:11-166:14 166:17-166:17 166:19-166:19 166:22-166:22 167:5-167:17 167:23-167:25 168:2-169:4 169:6-169:8 169:25-170:2 172:2-172:4 173:13-173:13 Wi-LAN’s Objections 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ ID 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 14 Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 173:15-174:3 174:25-175:2 175:5-175:9 175:11-175:14 175:16-175:17 175:20-176:8 186:2-186:4 186:7-186:9 187:1-187:3 187:19-187:21 187:24-188:6 188:23-188:25 189:2-189:5 189:7-189:10 189:13-189:15 189:17-191:5 191:9-191:9 191:11-191:13 191:16-191:17 191:19-191:21 191:23-192:1 192:3-192:5 192:7-192:9 192:15-192:16 192:18-192:19 192:21-193:3 193:17-193:20 193:22-193:23 193:25-194:21 194:23-194:23 194:25-195:13 195:16-195:16 202:14-202:24 210:25-212:2 212:4-212:4 212:6-212:12 213:7-213:8 213:10-213:11 213:24-214:14 214:16-215:5 215:13-215:20 Wi-LAN’s Objections 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 15 Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections Witness 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 223:21-224:11 402 R/ 403 224:13-224:17 402 R/ 403 224:19-224:24 402 R/ 403 225:1-225:1 402 R/ 403 226:19-226:23 402 R/ 403 227:1-227:9 402 R/ 403 228:16-228:22 Shaun McEwan 10/19/2012 AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 220:6-220:19 220:21-220:22 402 R/ 403 8:6-8:8 8:13-8:16 20:8-20:12 20:17-20:19 21:13-21:15 21:17-21:17 22:2-22:6 25:9-25:11 25:13-25:13 26:8-26:9 26:11-26:11 26:13-26:15 26:17-26:17 33:11-33:15 33:17-33:17 45:2-45:5 45:7-45:15 45:17-45:19 Wi-LAN’s Objections Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections 221:4—221:17; 227:17—228:14 221:4—221:17; 227:17—228:14 221:4—221:17; 227:17—228:14 221:4—221:17; 227:17—228:14 221:4—221:17; 227:17—228:14 221:4—221:17; 227:17—228:14 221:4—221:17; 227:17—228:14 221:4—221:17; 227:17—228:14 ATTY, H, 403, F, S, V ATTY, H, 403, F, S, V ATTY, H, 403, F, S, V ATTY, H, 403, F, S, V ATTY, H, 403, F, S, V ATTY, H, 403, F, S, V ATTY, H, 403, F, S, V ATTY, H, 403, F, S, V 45:20-46:01; 46:03-46:09 403, H, N, D R 403/ 402 R 403/ 402 R R 403/ 402 R 403/ BS/ F/ CS 403/ BS/ F/ CS 403/ BS/ F/ CS 403/ BS/ F/ CS 403/ BS/ F/ CS 403/ BS/ F/ CS 403/ I 46:11-46:13 46:15-46:18 59:24-60:4 60:7-60:14 16 R, R, R, R, R, R, R, R, Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 78:16-78:20 82:14-82:16 82:19-82:19 82:21-83:10 83:12-84:14 84:16-85:4 85:6-85:14 85:16-85:19 88:8-88:15 Wi-LAN’s Objections Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations 403/ I 78:21-79:05 403/ BS/ CS/ 402 R 403/ BS/ CS/ 402 R 403/ BS/ CS/ 402 R 403/ BS/ CS/ 402 R 403/ BS/ CS/ 402 R 403/ BS/ CS/ 402 R 403/ BS/ CS/ 402 R 403/ BS/ CS/ 402 R/ ML 113:23-114:22 114:24-115:9 115:11-116:15 116:17-116:22 116:24-117:3 117:5-117:10 117:12-118:6 118:8-118:24 119:3-119:5 119:7-119:7 127:3-127:11 128:24-129:19 CS CS BS/ CS/ F 403/ CS/ I 130:7-130:10 130:13-131:2 131:4-131:9 131:11-131:22 403/ BS/ I 403/ BS/ I 403/ BS/ I AL-E-SM’s Objections V, F 403/ CS 403/ CS 403/ CS 403/ CS 403/ CS/ 402 R 133:4-133:7 133:9-133:10 133:20-133:25 134:3-134:5 17 129:20-129:22; R, 403, H, F, S 129:24-129:24; 130:01-130:06 131:23-132:03; R, 403, H, F, S, 132:06-132:06; N, O, V 132:08-133:02 Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 134:7-135:3 135:5-135:16 135:18-135:24 137:7-137:9 137:11-137:16 166:21-166:25 167:6-168:6 168:8-168:16 168:18-168:18 170:11-170:13 170:15-170:16 170:22-171:7 171:12-171:17 172:6-172:23 173:22-174:5 174:7-174:16 174:18-174:20 174:22-174:23 174:25-175:2 175:22-176:5 183:20-183:23 183:25-184:2 184:4-184:17 184:19-184:20 191:20-193:3 194:14-194:22 195:4-195:14 195:20-196:7 200:14-200:17 200:19-200:24 201:1-201:5 201:7-201:7 Wi-LAN’s Objections 403/ BS 403/ BS 402 R/ BS 402 R/ BS 402 R/ BS 402 R/ BS 402 R/ BS 402 R/ BS 402 R/ BS 402 R/ BS 403/ CS/ 403/ CS/ 403/ CS/ 403/ CS/ 403/ CS/ 403/ CS/ 403/ CS/ 403/ CS/ CS/ BS CS/ BS 402 R/ 403/ CS/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 403/ F/ BS/ CS/ L 403/ F/ BS/ CS/ L 403/ F/ BS/ CS/ L 403/ F/ BS/ CS/ L 18 Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 206:20-206:21 206:23-207:12 208:3-208:11 208:12-209:21 209:23-209:23 229:4-229:21 251:12-251:24 252:1-252:1 253:16-254:6 William Middleton 9/28/2012 9:6-9:9 10:19-11:2 402 R/ 403 12:25-13:6 13:11-13:14 13:16-14:11 14:13-14:18 15:3-15:5 15:7-15:11 19:4-19:8 26:17-27:16 32:13-33:14 35:8-35:11 35:24-36:4 36:6-36:13 39:8-39:14 40:11-40:14 41:3-41:7 41:14-41:16 47:12-48:4 48:6-49:2 49:4-50:20 50:22-51:22 51:25-52:10 52:16-52:24 69:2-69:4 69:6-69:19 70:15-71:8 Wi-LAN’s Objections Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations 403/ MS/ML/ BS/ I 403/ MS/ML/ BS/ 207:14-208:02 I 403/ BS 403/ BS 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ CS 402 R/ 403/ BS/ CS 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ I 402 R/ 403/ I 402 R/ 403/ I 402 R/ 403/ I 402 R/ 403/ I 402 R/ 403/ I 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403 19 14:20-15:02 AL-E-SM’s Objections R, 403, H, I Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 71:10-72:2 72:4-72:16 78:2-78:25 80:11-80:14 80:16-80:24 83:9-83:11 83:13-83:16 83:18-83:23 83:25-84:4 90:13-90:22 91:2-91:5 91:25-92:18 92:20-92:25 94:2-94:7 94:19-94:25 95:8-95:10 111:20-112:9 112:12-112:12 113:2-113:8 113:10-113:15 113:17-113:19 115:9-115:13 115:15-115:25 116:7-116:7 117:22-117:24 117:25-118:13 118:15-118:16 127:10-127:13 127:15-127:19 128:1-128:3 128:5-128:9 128:11-128:11 128:22-128:25 129:2-129:3 130:18-130:20 Wi-LAN’s Objections Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections CS CS H 402 R/ 403/ CS 402 R/ 403/ CS 402 R/ 403/ CS 402 R/ 403/ CS 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ I 402 R/ 403/ I 402 R/ 403/ I 402 R/ 403/ I 402 R/ 403/ I 113:21-113:22; R, 403, H, N, V 113:25-114:22 402 R/ 403/ I 402 R/ 403/ I 402 R/ 403/ I 402 R/ 403/ I 402 R/ 403/ I 402 R/ 403/ I I 130:01-130:02; R, 403, H, F, AF 130:04-130:05; 130:07-130:10; 130:13-130:16 130:22-130:24 135:5-135:9 20 Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 135:11-135:16 137:5-137:11 137:13-137:21 138:24-139:3 139:5-139:11 139:13-139:15 140:1-140:4 140:14-141:6 141:8-142:2 142:4-142:13 146:1-146:12 155:22-156:5 156:8-156:15 156:22-157:11 157:13-157:23 157:25-158:6 162:20-163:3 163:4-163:8 163:9-163:11 163:13-163:16 164:16-164:20 165:2-165:8 187:20-187:22 188:19-189:3 190:21-191:10 191:12-191:13 191:16-191:16 192:2-192:7 192:9-192:10 192:12-192:17 192:19-192:23 192:25-193:1 193:3-193:4 195:9-195:12 195:19-195:23 196:9-196:12 196:16-197:4 197:9-197:10 Wi-LAN’s Objections Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections 402 R/ 403/ CS 402 R/ 403/ CS 402 R/ 403/ CS CS 403 403 402 R/ BS BS/ I 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 21 165:09-165:12; R, 403, H 165:14-165:18; 166:9-166:12; 166:14-166:17 Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 197:24-198:2 198:4-198:12 198:15-198:17 199:14-199:17 199:19-199:23 199:25-200:8 200:10-200:25 201:3-201:3 201:5-201:20 205:22-206:22 206:25-207:14 212:7-213:12 213:15-214:5 214:7-214:7 215:7-215:12 215:15-215:17 216:1-216:22 216:24-216:25 217:2-217:7 217:9-217:20 217:23-218:8 Wi-LAN’s Objections 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ BS 402 R/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS BS BS BS BS BS BS BS 220:8-220:10 220:12-220:15 403/ BS/ I 403/ BS/ I 236:18-236:20 236:22-236:23 240:12-240:15 240:18-240:21 254:13-254:17 254:23-254:24 267:17-267:23 268:1-268:1 268:3-268:9 273:2-273:6 273:9-273:10 275:22-276:17 288:6-288:18 294:24-295:15 296:8-296:15 403/ BS/ I 403/ BS/ I BS BS 401/ 403/ BS/ P 401/ 403/ BS/ P 403/ BS/ F 403/ BS/ F 403/ BS/ F 403/ BS/ F 403/ BS/ F 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 403/ BS/ ML 403/ BS/ ML 22 Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections 219:23-220:01; R, 403, H 220:03-220:06 221:14-221:16; R, 403, H, I 221:18-221:21; 222:09-222:19 236:25-237:05 R, 403, H, F, S Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 296:18-296:24 297:1-297:7 297:9-297:16 313:7-313:11 313:13-314:1 320:15-320:20 320:22-320:22 320:24-321:4 321:7-321:16 321:19-321:23 322:1-322:13 322:15-322:16 345:12-345:13 345:15-345:19 345:21-346:4 353:1-353:4 354:8-354:21 354:24-355:5 355:7-355:8 355:10-355:21 355:23-355:25 367:20-367:25 Andrew Parolin 8/31/2012 9:3-9:6 9:9-9:20 11:10-12:2 12:4-12:10 25:25-26:1 26:3-26:7 26:14-26:20 39:1-39:7 63:4-63:10 63:12-63:21 67:22-67:25 Wi-LAN’s Objections 403/ BS/ ML 403/ BS/ ML 403/ BS/ ML 401/ 403/ BS 401/ 403/ BS 403/ BS 403/ BS 403/ BS 403/ BS 403/ BS 403/ BS 403/ BS 403/ BS 403/ BS 403/ BS 401/ 402 R/ BS/ F 401/ 402 R/ BS/ F 401/ 402 R/ BS/ F 401/ 402 R/ BS/ F 401/ 402 R/ BS/ F 401/ 402 R/ BS/ F 401/ 403/ BS 403/ I BS/ E 23 Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections 319:18-319:20; R, 403, H, I, O, 319:22-320:13 F, S, N 403/ 403/ 403/ 403/ 403/ 403/ Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 68:2-68:3 69:4-69:6 69:8-69:18 73:7-73:16 73:18-73:20 73:22-73:24 74:1-74:3 74:5-74:6 74:25-75:5 77:16-77:21 77:23-78:4 78:6-78:11 81:7-81:17 81:19-81:19 82:8-82:13 83:21-83:22 83:24-84:3 84:6-84:11 87:13-87:20 87:22-87:23 89:25-90:2 90:4-90:7 90:9-90:10 90:16-91:7 105:9-105:10 105:13-105:17 111:23-112:8 112:11-112:11 112:13-113:16 113:18-113:25 114:2-114:11 115:18-115:20 115:22-115:25 117:5-117:6 117:9-117:9 119:14-119:19 119:21-119:23 Wi-LAN’s Objections Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections 68:05-68:06; 68:08-68:15 R, 403, H, O, F, S, V 75:06-75:08; 75:10-75:11 R, 403, H, F, S, I, V 403 403 401 403/ BS/ I/ E/ CS 403/ BS/ I/ E/ CS 403/ BS/ I/ E/ CS 84:12-84:17; 84:19-85:06 R, 403, F, S, H, O, V 401 403 401/ 402 R/ 403 401/ 402 R/ 403 401/ 402 R/ 403 401/ 402 R/ 403 401/ 402 R/ 403 I 403 403 402 R/ 403/ BS/ L 402 R/ 403/ BS/ L 402 R/ 403/ BS/ L 402 R/ 403/ BS/ L 401/ 402 R/ L/ F 401/ 402 R/ L/ F 403/ BS/ I/ ML 403/ BS/ I/ ML 401/ 403 401/ 403 24 116:21-117:04 R, 403, H Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 126:13-126:16 126:18-126:23 126:25-127:11 127:13-127:20 127:22-127:25 Wi-LAN’s Objections 401/ 403 401/ 403 401/ 403 401/ 403 401/ 403 158:14-158:15 158:17-158:18 160:1-160:12 160:14-160:14 160:16-160:21 160:23-161:5 161:7-161:10 161:13-161:14 165:16-165:19 165:21-165:22 188:21-188:24 189:2-189:6 189:9-189:11 206:2-206:5 206:7-206:15 206:21-206:21 206:23-207:5 207:7-207:20 207:22-207:24 215:20-215:21 215:23-216:6 216:8-216:18 216:20-216:20 403 403 403/ ML 403/ ML 403/ ML 403/ ML 403/ ML 403/ ML 403 403 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 403/ ML 403/ ML 403/ ML 403/ ML 403/ ML 403/ ML 401/ 403/ I 401/ 403/ I 401/ 403/ I 401/ 403/ I 219:2-219:6 219:8-219:9 220:11-220:13 220:15-220:24 221:1-221:10 221:12-221:14 230:20-231:24 232:1-232:12 234:7-234:14 237:18-238:1 239:2-240:15 E E 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R 401/ 403/ I 25 Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections 132:20-132:22; R, 403, H, I, M, 132:25-133:03 V, F 216:22-216:22; R, 403, H 216:25-217:12 Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 240:17-240:18 246:18-246:24 254:6-255:20 255:22-256:8 Wi-LAN’s Objections Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections 240:34-241:10; R, 403, H, F, S, 241:12-241:13; I, ATTY 242:02-242:04; 242:06-242:11 I 256:09-256:15; H, 403, ATTY 256:17-256:18 256:19-256:24 257:06-257:08; R, 403, M, H 257:10-257:10 260:2-260:10 260:12-260:16 260:18-260:18 260:20-261:4 261:6-261:6 261:18-261:24 262:1-262:7 262:9-262:11 262:13-262:20 262:22-263:1 263:3-263:8 263:10-263:12 265:3-266:2 266:4-266:9 266:11-266:16 266:18-266:23 266:25-267:7 267:9-267:11 267:13-267:22 267:24-268:4 268:6-268:12 272:21-272:24 273:2-273:4 273:6-273:9 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ I 402 R/ 403/ I 402 R/ 403/ I 274:13-274:15 274:17-274:17 274:19-274:20 274:22-275:3 401/ 402 R/ 403 401/ 402 R/ 403 401/ 402 R/ 403 401/ 402 R/ 403 401/ 403 401/ 403 26 273:10-273:12; R, 403, H, F, S, 273:14-273:15; I, ATTY 274:07-274:10 Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 275:5-275:8 277:13-277:15 277:17-277:17 278:4-278:7 278:9-278:11 278:13-278:17 279:4-279:7 279:10-279:14 283:21-284:5 284:7-284:12 285:3-285:7 285:9-285:16 285:18-286:2 286:4-286:12 288:18-288:21 288:23-288:25 289:2-289:3 290:22-290:23 290:25-291:1 299:18-299:21 299:23-299:25 300:2-300:5 300:7-300:8 300:10-300:13 300:15-300:15 300:17-300:20 300:22-300:22 300:24-301:1 302:17-302:19 302:21-302:23 302:25-303:5 303:16-303:19 303:21-303:22 310:10-310:11 310:13-310:15 311:4-311:7 311:9-311:12 311:14-311:19 311:21-311:21 329:23-330:23 Wi-LAN’s Objections Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections 401/ 402 R/ 403 401/ 402 R/ 403 401/ 402 R/ 403 403/ E 403/ E/ BS 403/ E/ BS 401/ 402 R/ 403 401/ 402 R/ 403 403/ ML 403/ ML 401/ 402 R/ 403 401/ 402 R/ 403 401/ 402 R/ 403 401/ 402 R/ 403 401/ 402 R/ 403 401/ 402 R/ 403 401/ 402 R/ 403 401/ 402 R/ 403 401/ 402 R/ 403 403/ I 403/ I 403/ I 401/ 402 R/ 403 401/ 402 R/ 403 27 303:07-303:09; R, 403, H 303:11-303:14 Witness Paul Struhsaker 7/2/2012 403/ BS/ E 403/ BS/ E 403/ BS/ E 403/ BS/ E 403/ BS/ E 403/ BS/ E 403/ E/ I/ BS 403/ E/ I/ BS 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 6:5-6:8 6:15-6:17 6:21-7:1 7:4-7:5 7:12-7:18 102:12-102:15 102:18-102:24 103:1-103:5 103:10-103:13 137:22-138:3 403 403 403 403 403/ I 203:8-203:10 203:13-203:17 Douglas Pulley 7/26/2012 AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 331:1-331:14 331:23-332:15 334:14-334:19 334:21-334:21 337:11-337:13 337:15-337:20 360:3-360:6 360:9-360:9 360:11-360:14 360:17-360:17 360:19-360:21 360:24-360:24 361:23-362:5 362:7-362:7 398:7-398:10 398:12-399:8 Wi-LAN’s Objections 403 403/ I 7:21-7:23 10:17-10:21 11:3-11:6 28 Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations 361:19-361:22 AL-E-SM’s Objections R, 403, H, I, O 138:4-11; R; F; H; I; 403; 138:14-139:3; V 203:19-204:18; 204:21-205:8; 205:11-21; 205:24-206:3 203:19-204:18; R; F; H; I; 403; 204:21-205:8; V 205:11-205: 21; 205:24-206:3 Witness AL-E-SM Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 15:18-15:21 15:23-15:23 25:2-25:6 27:19-27:21 29:24-30:3 30:7-30:14 35:12-35:15 37:15-38:4 62:18-63:1 64:14-65:6 67:4-68:2 68:5-68:11 68:13-68:20 70:2-70:23 78:15-78:19 83:14-83:19 84:10-84:14 85:4-85:5 85:8-85:12 87:19-88:6 88:8-88:10 90:22-91:5 95:4-95:9 115:17-115:22 116:3-116:16 117:15-117:18 118:17-119:22 123:16-123:23 184:12-185:5 186:1-186:5 Wi-LAN’s Objections Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations AL-E-SM’s Objections 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ E 402 R/ 403/ E 402 R/ 403/ E 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 Kuo, Ming-Chieh - 09/28/2012 Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations Sony Mobile and Ericsson’s Objections 105:7—106:23 105:17–106:23 - V, F, M, 403, O, PERSONAL, ATTY 164:7—24 R, V, F, M, 403, PERSONAL, ATTY 252:3—11 F, V 256:10—19 R, V, F, 403, ATTY 29 HTC’S OBJECTIONS2 Witness HTC Deposition Designations [Page:lines] Wi-LAN’s Objections 403 BS/ 403/ 402 R 403/ I F/ 403/ H/ CS 402 R/ BS/ F/ CS CS/ BS/ 403/ 402 R CS/ I BS BS/ CS/ F BS/ CS/ F/ 403 15:16-24 22:14 - 24:16 106 41:17 - 43:19 46:4 - 47:25 64:18 - 65:8 68:20 - 69:11 108:19 - 109:12 117:4 - 122:21 402 R/ 403/ BS CS/ 403/ BS/ E/ L CS/ 402 R/ 403/ L 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ 106 HTC’s Objections BS/ 403 49:11 - 50:8 51:17 - 56:8 56:18 - 60:25 68:17 - 69:13 87:3-25 93:18 - 95:10 96:11-24 Brandt, David 21:15 - 22:16 29:11-25 35:20 - 38:16 44:5 - 45:21 Bezryadina, Natalya Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations 124:23 - 125:24 106 129:10 - 130:23 132:15 - 134:4 148:14 - 150:23 69:16-69:17 20:5—25:4 (already designated) 120:1—124:9 (already designated) 236:9—237:8 124:23—127:21 (already designated) R/S/H/F/H/I 402 R/ 403/ ID 159:3 - 160:20 46:25-47:01; 47:03-47:08 403 2 HTC hereby incorporates by reference all of Alcatel-Lucent, Sony Mobile, and Ericsson’s objections and includes them herein prior to the Court’s ruling on the motion to sever. 30 Witness HTC Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 173:7 - 175:23 176:11 - 181:25 182:12 - 183:1 184:14-21 186:17-21 210:11 - 214:16 Wi-LAN’s Objections Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations 223:23 - 228:2 229:10-21 230:14-19 235:1 - 236:8 Dubuc, Christian 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 236:9—237:8 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ L 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ L 210:11—14 (already designated) 236:9—237:8 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 22:13 - 23:11 33:1 - 34:17 69:13-23 402 R/ 403 CS/ 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 73:19 - 75:22 402 R/ 403/ BS 85:14 - 86:6 87:23 - 89:9 89:25 - 90:6 92:6 - 93:2 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ L CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ L 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ E/ L/ ML 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403/ P 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ L 99:10 - 100:5 107:3-8 158:25 - 159:18 161:11-19 163:17-24 164:1-20 165:4 - 167:20 176:6-18 176:24 - 177:1 182:5 - 183:12 191:1-7 191:13-19 202:13 - 203:17 31 HTC’s Objections R/S/H R/S/H Witness McEwan, Shaun HTC Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 207:4 - 209:2 214:2 - 215:6 225:12 - 226:2 227:19 - 228:22 231:1-11 234:17 - 235:13 236:6-16 237:8 - 238:12 238:24 - 239:20 244:12 - 245:15 246:24 - 247:16 254:17 - 255:2 299:1-16 308:11 - 309:13 327:12-17 344:17 - 346:15 350:6 - 351:16 357:12 - 358:1 22:21 - 23:16 26:8 - 27:17 29:6-25 33:11-17 34:11 - 36:25 45:2-13 73:20 - 74:12 79:11 - 82:13 87:1 - 88:15 90:23 - 92:7 94:16 - 96:10 105:3-15 113:22 - 114:18 115:20-24 117:10-20 133:4 - 134:13 141:4-17 171:21 - 172:23 Wi-LAN’s Objections Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations HTC’s Objections 402 R/ 403/ BS/ ML 402 R/ 403/ BS/ ML 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS CS/ 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS CS/ 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403/ ML 402 R/ 403/ L 403/ BS/ F/ CS 403/ BS/ F/ CS 403/ BS/ F/ CS 403/ BS/ F/ CS 403/ I 402 R/ 403/ BS/ CS/ H 402 R/ 403/ ML 403/ I 403/ I 403/ CS 402 R/ 403/ CS 403 403 32 96:12-96:18 R/403/I/S Witness HTC Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 182:25 - 183:19 184:22 - 185:12 199:22 - 201:7 206:16 - 207:8 209:10 - 210:9 218:4-25 221:17 - 223:6 Wi-LAN’s Objections 402 R/ 403/ BS 402 R/ 403/ BS 403/ BS/ CS/ F/ L 403/ BS/ I/ MS/ML 403/ BS 403/ BS/ CS/ F 403/ BS/ CS/ F/ I 231:10-15 232:22 - 233:15 247:14 - 248:4 252:24 - 253:13 209:15 - 210:10 402 R/ BS 212:11 - 213:18 227:21 - 228:16 230:12 - 231:22 237:17 - 238:9 239:14-23 242:16 - 243:25 246:12-21 249:19 - 250:23 255:20 - 256:16 275:22 - 278:17 294:24 - 295:15 297:1-16 312:4 - 313:6 316:24 - 318:7 322:18 - 325:12 344:24 - 345:10 353:6 - 354:6 Middleton, William BS/ F 403/ BS/ CS/ F 403/ BS/ CS/ F/ L 402 R/ 403/ BS 403/ BS 403/ BS 403/ BS 403/ BS 403/ BS 403/ BS 401/ 402 R/ 403/ BS 401/ 403/ BS/ P/ F 402 R/ 403/ BS 403/ BS/ ML 403/ BS/ ML 401/ 403/ BS 403/ BS/ I 403/ BS 403/ BS 401/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ F 401/ 402 R/ 403/ BS 401/ 403/ BS/ CS/ P 359:8-24 367:20 - 370:2 Lysejko, Martin 12:4 12:9-12 12:20 - 14:10 33 Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations HTC’s Objections 207:14-208:02 I/403/R/V 223:14-224:25; 225:02-225:21 403/R/V I/S Witness HTC Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 15:21 - 16:7 19:7 - 20:25 21:15 - 22:19 23:15 - 24:24 28:21 - 29:23 39:1-17 47:7-11 48:13 - 50:2 58:22 - 59:4 59:10-14 73:7 - 76:25 77:15-25 78:22 - 81:5 Wi-LAN’s Objections 106 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 113:21 - 117:2 117:15 - 119:21 120:22-24 129:1-14 131:15 - 132:8 134:17 - 135:6 135:14 - 140:12 173:13 - 176:8 176:16 - 177:10 202:14 - 203:6 210:25 - 212:12 212:23 - 213:6 214:8 - 215:5 217:4 - 218:7 224:19 - 225:1 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ L CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ L CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ L CS/ 402 R/ 403/ L 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 237:1-23 238:17 - 239:23 242:11 - 243:22 245:2-7 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 82:4 - 86:8 98:13 - 102:1 Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations 34 221:4—221:17; 227:17—228:14 HTC’s Objections Witness Struhsaker, Paul HTC Deposition Designations [Page:lines] 245:10 - 248:9 255:2 - 256:14 261:16 - 265:12 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 7:21-23 10:17 - 11:6 87:19 - 89:2 101:4-12 115:5 - 116:13 127:20 - 130:25 182:10-25 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403/ E/ L 402 R/ 403 402 R/ 403 Kuo, Ming-Chieh 7:15-25 108:1 - 109:23 Wi-LAN’s Objections 403 112:25 - 113:6 189:18 - 191:25 199:17 - 203:2 403/ 106 403 403 246:20 - 253:12 403 271:11 - 274:13 Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations 105:7—106:23, 164:7—24; 252:3—11 (already designated) 256:10--19 403 Dated: March 1, 2013 105:7—106:23, 164:7—24; 252:3—11 (already designated); 256:10--19 105:7—106:23, 164:7—24; 256:10—19 Respectfully submitted, By: /s/ Akshay S. Deoras______________ Gregory S. Arovas (pro hac vice) Robert A. Appleby (pro hac vice) 35 HTC’s Objections Jeanne M. Heffernan (pro hac vice) Akshay S. Deoras (pro hac vice) KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP 601 Lexington Avenue New York, NY 10022 Tel: (212) 446-4800 Fax: (212) 446-4900 Alcatel-Lucent-Wi-LAN-Defense@kirkland.com Michael E. Jones Allen F. Gardner POTTER MINTON PC 110 N. College, Suite 500 (75702) P.O. Box 359 Tyler, Texas 75710 (903) 597 8311 (903) 593 0846 (Facsimile) mikejones@potterminton.com allengardner@potterminton.com ATTORNEYS FOR LUCENT USA INC. DEFENDANT ALCATEL- /s/ Martin R. Bader (with permission) Stephen S. Korniczky (pro hac vice) Martin R. Bader (pro hac vice) Daniel N. Yannuzzi (pro hac vice) Lee Hsu (pro hac vice) Graham M. Buccigross (pro hac vice) SHEPPARD MULLIN RICHTER & HAMPTON LLP 12275 El Camino Real, Suite 200 San Diego, CA 92130 Tel: (858) 720-8924 Fax: (858) 847-4892 LegalTm-WiLAN-Alcatel-@sheppardmullin.com Eric Hugh Findlay (TX Bar No. 00789886) Brian Craft (TX Bar No. 04972020) FINDLAY CRAFT 6760 Old Jacksonville Hwy, Suite 101 Tyler, TX 75703 Tel: (903) 534-1100 Fax: (903) 534-1137 efindlay@findlaycraft.com bcraft@findlaycraft.com 36 ATTORNEYS FOR CORPORATION, HTC EXEDA INC. DEFENDANTS AMERICA INC., HTC AND /s/ Richard L. Wynne, Jr. (with permission) Bruce S. Sostek (TX Bar 18855700) Richard L. Wynne, Jr. (TX Bar 24003214) Adrienne E. Dominguez (TX Bar 00793630) J. Michael Heinlen (TX Bar 24032287) Timothy E. Hudson (TX Bar 24046120) Justin S. Cohen (TX Bar 24078356) THOMPSON & KNIGHT LLP 1722 Routh Street Suite 1500 Dallas, Texas 75201-2533 Tel: (214) 969-1700 Fax: (214) 969-1751 bruce.sostek@tklaw.com richard.wynne@tklaw.com adrienne.dominguez@tklaw.com michael.heinlen@tklaw.com tim.hudson@tklaw.com justin.cohen@tklaw.com William J. Cornelius (TX Bar 04834700) Jennifer Ainsworth (TX Bar 00784720) WILSON ROBERTSON & CORNELIUS PC 909 ESE Loop 323, Suite 400 P.O. Box 7339 Tyler, TX 75711-7339 Tel: (903) 509-5000 Fax: (903) 509-5092 wc@wilsonlawfirm.com jainsworth@wilsonlawfirm.com ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANTS ERICSSON INC., TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON, SONY MOBILE COMMUNICATIONS (USA) INC., AND SONY MOBILE COMMUNICATIONS AB 37 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that all counsel of record who have consented to electronic service are being served with a copy of this document via the Court’s CM/ECF system per Local Rule CV-5(a)(3) on this the 1st day of March, 2013. Any other counsel of record will be served by first class U.S. mail on this same date. /s/ Akshay S. Deoras____________ Akshay S. Deoras 38

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?