WI-LAN Inc. v. Alcatel-Lucent USA Inc. et al
Filing
336
NOTICE by Alcatel-Lucent USA Inc., Ericsson Inc., Exedea INC., HTC America, Inc., HTC Corporation, Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., Sony Mobile Communications AB, Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson re 329 Notice (Other), Notice (Other), Notice (Other), Notice (Other) Defendants' Objections to Wi-LAN's Rebuttal Designations (Deoras, Akshay)
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
TYLER DIVISION
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
WI-LAN INC.,
Plaintiff,
v.
ALCATEL-LUCENT USA INC.; et al.
Defendants.
Civil Action No. 6:10-cv-521-LED
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
DEFENDANTS’ OBJECTIONS TO WI-LAN’S REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS
Please take notice that Defendants Alcatel-Lucent USA Inc., Telefonaktiebolaget LM
Ericsson, Ericsson Inc., Sony Mobile Communications AB, Sony Mobile Communications
(USA) Inc., HTC Corporation, HTC America, Inc., and Exedea Inc. hereby make the following
objections to Wi-LAN’s rebuttal deposition designations served February 25, 2013.
Defendants object to any testimony designated by Wi-LAN that violates any ruling of the
Court, including rulings related to the parties’ forthcoming motions in limine. Defendants
further object to Wi-LAN’s designations and counter designations to the extent they exceed the
length permitted by the Court’s standing order. Defendants object on hearsay grounds to the use
of designations from one Defendant’s employees against any other Defendant. Each Defendant
reserves the right to amend its objections to respond to issues raised and/or resolved after the
submission of this list.
Defendants further object to Wi-LAN’s inclusion of “counter-counter” designations in
their filing on March 1, 2013. (D.I. 334.) The Court’s Docket Control Order does not allow for
“counter-counter” designations. (D.I. 99.) Similarly, the parties’ Joint Pretrial Order does not
contemplate “counter-counter” designations. (D.I. 311.) Should the Court allow Wi-LAN to
1
play its “counter-counter” designations, Defendants reserve their right to object to such
designations and designate their own “counter-counter” designations.
OBJECTION KEY
R = Lacks Relevance (FRE 401/402)
H = Hearsay (FRE 802)
O = Improper Opinion
F = Lacks Foundation/Speculative (FRE 602)
V = Vague/Ambiguous
M = Misleading/Mischaracterizes prior
testimony
P = Privilege
408 = Settlement (FRE 408)
LC = Legal Conclusion
D = Duplication
A = Argumentative
C = Compound
L = Leading
N = Nonresponsive
I = Improper/Incomplete Designation
PERSONAL = Testimony by 30(b)(6) designee
outside scope of noticed topics
403 = Unduly prejudicial/confusion/waste of
time (FRE 403)
ATTY = Attorney objections not removed
S = Speculation
AF = Assumes facts not in evidence
ALCATEL-LUCENT, SONY MOBILE,
AND ERICSSON’S OBJECTIONS1
Witness
BS/ 403/ CS
21:15-22:4
22:6-22:6
Natalya Bezryadina
11/7/2012
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
9:2-9:4
9:7-9:12
10:18-10:19
11:9-11:16
12:19-12:21
12:23-13:2
14:4-14:4
14:6-14:8
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
BS/ 403
BS/ 403
402 R/ 403
CS/ I
CS/ I
1
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
13:04-13:06
20:17-20:19;
20:21-20:21;
21:03-21:05
I
Alcatel-Lucent, Sony Mobile, and Ericsson hereby incorporate by reference all of HTC’s
objections.
2
Witness
David Brant
6/29/2012
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
22:8-22:11
29:21-29:22
29:24-29:25
38:7-38:9
38:11-38:11
12:16-13:2
14:18-14:25
15:8-16:5
16:14-16:21
18:5-18:11
36:18-37:5
37:9-37:10
41:8-41:11
41:15-41:16
42:6-42:12
42:19-43:16
43:19-43:19
48:18-49:25
51:4-51:8
51:10-51:13
56:23-57:1
64:18-64:24
65:1-65:7
66:9-66:12
66:14-66:19
71:4-71:17
71:20-72:9
72:11-72:23
93:19-94:18
94:20-94:20
95:6-96:16
98:5-98:22
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
BS/ 403
403
403
BS/ 402 R
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
E/ BS/ 403
E/ BS/ 403
CS/ 403/ BS/ E/ L 15:08—16:17
CS/ 403/ BS/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ BS
CS/ 403/ BS/ E/ L
CS/ 403/ BS/ E/ L
403
66:20—67:23
403
66:20—67:23
403/ E/ L
72:24—73:03
403/ E/ L
72:24—73:03
403/ E/ L
72:24—73:03
403/ E/ L
72:24—73:03
403/ E/ L
72:24—73:03
402 R/ 403
403
98:23—99:14
101:14-101:16
101:18-101:24
102:2-102:16
105:7-105:15
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
106
20:05—25:04
105:17-105:25
106
20:05—25:04
3
ATTY, H, R, 403
ATTY, H, R, 403
ATTY, H, R, 403
ATTY, H, R, 403
ATTY, H, R, 403
ATTY, H, 403,
S, F, AF
ATTY, R, 403,
H, I
ATTY, R, 403,
H, I
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
106:3-106:4
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
106
20:05—25:04
106:7-106:8
106
20:05—25:04
108:4-108:18
109:20-111:22
111:24-112:3
112:17-113:14
114:22-114:24
115:2-115:3
115:6-115:13
117:4-117:13
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ 106
120:1—124:9
119:5-119:8
402 R/ 403/ 106
120:1—124:9
119:11-119:25
402 R/ 403/ 106
120:1—124:9
122:8-122:24
402 R/ 403/ 106
120:1—124:9
123:1-123:1
402 R/ 403/ 106
120:1—124:9
127:22-128:9
128:11-128:13
128:15-128:19
128:22-129:4
129:10-129:15
129:18-129:23
129:25-130:4
130:6-130:6
130:16-130:19
130:25-131:3
131:6-131:16
131:18-131:23
131:25-132:3
132:5-132:5
133:13-133:17
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
106
133:20-133:20
134:5-134:13
134:19-135:3
135:5-135:13
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
4
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
ATTY, R, 403,
H, I
ATTY, R, 403,
H, I
ATTY, R,
H, S, F, AF
ATTY, R,
H, S, F, AF
ATTY, R,
H, S, F, AF
ATTY, R,
H, S, F, AF
ATTY, R,
H, S, F, AF
403,
403,
403,
403,
403,
132:15—133:20 ATTY, 403, M,
I, H, F, AF
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
135:16-136:20
136:22-137:7
137:10-138:10
138:12-138:18
138:21-139:23
140:1-140:24
141:1-141:20
141:23-142:8
142:11-143:8
143:10-144:6
144:9-144:19
144:23-145:11
145:14-145:23
148:14-148:20
148:23-148:23
149:5-149:14
149:16-150:3
150:6-150:16
150:19-152:21
152:23-153:3
153:5-153:5
154:1-154:5
154:8-154:24
155:1-155:1
155:3-156:11
156:20-157:16
157:19-157:20
157:23-157:23
157:25-158:11
158:13-158:16
158:19-158:23
159:1-159:1
161:14-161:17
161:19-161:25
162:13-163:3
163:5-164:5
164:8-164:9
167:19-168:2
168:24-169:16
169:19-169:20
169:23-169:23
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
106
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
5
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
167:19—168:11 ATTY
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
170:2-170:6
170:9-170:14
170:17-170:20
174:9-174:11
174:14-175:2
175:4-175:4
175:13-175:15
175:18-175:19
190:20-191:5
191:6-191:7
195:5-195:7
195:9-195:19
195:21-195:23
195:25-196:2
197:19-197:25
198:2-198:3
198:5-198:11
198:14-198:15
199:10-199:14
199:17-199:19
200:7-200:9
200:12-200:14
201:17-201:19
201:22-201:22
201:24-202:2
202:5-202:9
212:22-213:6
213:8-213:11
213:13-213:18
213:21-213:24
214:1-214:5
214:8-214:13
214:24-215:1
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
CS/ 402 R/ 403
CS/ 402 R/ 403
CS/ 402 R/ 403
CS/ 402 R/ 403
CS/ 402 R/ 403
CS/ 402 R/ 403
CS/ 402 R/ 403
CS/ 402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ BS/ 210:11—210:14,
E/ L
236:9—237:8
402 R/ 403/ BS/ 210:11—210:14,
E/ L
236:9—237:8
402 R/ 403/ BS/ 210:11—14,
E/ L
236:9—237:8
402 R/ 403/ BS/ 210:11—14,
E/ L
236:9—237:8
402 R/ 403/ BS/ 210:11—14,
E/ L
236:9—237:8
402 R/ 403/ BS/ 210:11—14,
E/ L
236:9—237:8
402 R/ 403/ BS/ 210:11—14,
E/ L
236:9—237:8
6
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
ATTY, H, R,
403, L, V, S, F
ATTY, H, R,
403, L, V, S, F
ATTY, H, R,
403, L, V, S, F
ATTY, H, R,
403, L, V, S, F
ATTY, H, R,
403, L, V, S, F
ATTY, H, R,
403, L, V, S, F
ATTY, H, R,
403, L, V, S, F
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
215:3-215:7
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
222:4-222:7
222:9-222:18
224:24-225:2
402 R/ 403/ BS/ 210:11—14,
E/ L
236:9—237:8
402 R/ 403/ BS/ 210:11—14,
E/ L
236:9—237:8
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS 236:9—237:8
225:4-225:9
402 R/ 403/ BS
236:9—237:8
225:11-225:15
402 R/ 403/ BS
236:9—237:8
225:18-225:22
402 R/ 403/ BS
236:9—237:8
225:24-226:3
402 R/ 403/ BS
236:9—237:8
226:5-226:20
402 R/ 403/ BS
236:9—237:8
226:23-226:25
402 R/ 403/ BS
236:9—237:8
230:14-230:17
230:19-230:19
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
10:20-11:5
20:6-20:12
20:20-21:3
21:9-21:23
21:25-23:3
33:1-33:4
48:6-48:11
49:5-49:12
49:14-49:14
51:6-51:18
73:6-73:8
73:10-73:11
78:11-78:13
78:15-78:18
80:4-80:9
80:15-80:22
85:14-85:16
85:18-85:22
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ E
402 R/ 403/ E
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
215:9-215:9
Christian Dubuc
8/22/2012
7
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
ATTY, H, R,
403, L, V, S, F
ATTY, H, R,
403, L, V, S, F
ATTY, H, R,
403, L, V, S, F
ATTY, H, R,
403, L, V, S, F
ATTY, H, R,
403, L, V, S, F
ATTY, H, R,
403, L, V, S, F
ATTY, H, R,
403, L, V, S, F
ATTY, H, R,
403, L, V, S, F
ATTY, H, R,
403, L, V, S, F
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
92:6-92:8
92:11-92:11
92:15-92:18
92:20-93:2
93:3-93:7
93:9-93:11
94:6-94:12
94:15-94:25
95:11-95:13
95:15-96:4
96:7-96:23
97:9-98:17
98:20-99:1
105:9-105:10
105:12-105:22
107:3-107:8
107:22-107:24
108:1-108:12
108:14-108:16
108:19-108:25
109:3-109:4
109:7-109:11
117:19-119:2
119:5-119:8
119:10-119:12
119:14-119:20
120:14-120:16
120:18-120:18
120:20-120:22
120:25-121:4
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
CS/ H/ 402 R/
403/ BS/ E/ L
CS/ H/ 402 R/
403/ BS/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ BS/
E/ L
402 R/ 403/ BS/
E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
CS/ 402 R/ 403/
BS/ E/ L
CS/ 402 R/ 403/
BS/ E/ L
CS/ 402 R/ 403/
BS/ E/ L
CS/ 402 R/ 403/
BS/ E/ L
CS/ 402 R/ 403/
BS/ E/ L
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
CS/ 402 R/ 403/
BS
CS/ 402 R/ 403/
BS
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
8
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
124:3-124:9
128:14-128:18
128:20-128:23
130:25-131:8
131:10-131:15
161:5-161:7
161:9-161:9
163:18-163:22
163:24-163:24
165:4-165:18
165:20-166:18
167:25-168:4
168:10-168:15
168:17-168:17
168:19-168:21
170:1-170:3
170:9-170:11
176:8-176:16
176:18-176:18
176:24-177:1
177:11-177:13
177:15-177:22
178:3-178:9
178:11-178:17
178:18-178:21
179:2-179:8
179:10-179:15
180:5-180:22
181:3-181:4
182:5-182:21
182:23-182:23
183:8-183:12
183:24-184:24
185:1-185:5
185:9-185:11
185:20-185:22
185:24-185:24
188:10-188:11
188:13-188:19
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ E/ L/
ML
402 R/ 403/ E/ L/
ML
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ P
402 R/ 403/ P
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
9
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
191:1-191:7
191:13-191:16
191:18-191:22
191:25-192:2
192:4-192:6
193:13-193:16
193:18-194:14
195:3-195:7
195:14-195:16
195:18-196:4
196:8-196:9
197:18-197:24
198:1-198:5
201:9-201:13
201:19-201:24
202:13-202:14
202:17-202:18
204:17-204:22
205:3-205:10
209:4-209:7
209:10-209:16
210:3-210:9
210:12-210:17
210:21-211:6
213:4-213:7
213:10-213:11
213:13-213:18
213:21-213:25
214:4-214:8
214:12-214:23
215:1-215:1
221:12-221:13
221:15-221:15
225:4-225:23
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
CS/ 402 R/ 403
CS/ 402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ BS/
E/ L
402 R/ 403/ BS/
E/ L
402 R/ 403/ BS/
E/ L
402 R/ 403/ BS/
E/ L
402 R/ 403/ BS/
ML
402 R/ 403/ BS/
ML
402 R/ 403/ BS/
ML
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
10
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
226:1-226:2
227:14-228:10
228:12-229:17
229:19-230:25
231:13-232:15
232:18-232:19
233:8-233:13
233:15-234:7
235:14-235:20
235:22-236:5
236:17-236:19
236:22-236:23
237:8-237:9
237:12-237:18
237:20-237:20
239:7-239:10
239:13-239:20
254:6-254:10
254:12-254:15
261:12-261:17
261:20-261:25
262:2-262:3
262:5-262:8
262:23-263:1
263:3-263:11
263:14-263:18
263:21-264:2
264:5-264:9
264:11-264:14
264:16-265:4
265:7-265:19
265:21-265:24
266:2-266:2
311:5-311:10
311:15-311:22
327:12-327:14
327:16-327:17
343:19-344:2
344:7-344:10
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
CS/ 402 R/ 403/
BS
CS/ 402 R/ 403/
BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ ML
11
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
344:17-344:20
345:9-345:20
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
346:21-347:13
348:20-348:23
348:25-349:6
351:4-351:13
351:15-351:20
351:22-351:23
351:25-353:2
402 R/ 403/ ML
CS/ 402 R/ 403/
ML
CS/ 402 R/ 403/
ML
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ BS
11:24-12:1
12:2-12:4
12:5-12:8
12:9-12:12
12:13-12:15
12:16-12:19
13:13-14:10
23:5-23:20
25:12-25:15
35:3-35:5
35:7-35:8
35:10-35:10
35:14-35:16
35:18-35:18
35:20-36:2
36:11-37:19
39:1-41:2
41:4-41:4
41:9-41:9
44:1-44:5
44:17-44:19
44:23-45:2
45:11-45:25
46:7-46:11
46:19-46:22
46:24-47:2
47:19-47:23
48:5-48:5
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ E
402 R/ 403/ E
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
346:17-346:19
Martin Lysejko
6/28/2012
12
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
48:7-48:14
48:20-49:1
49:3-49:14
49:25-50:2
58:18-59:4
59:10-59:14
60:14-60:25
61:4-61:7
74:14-74:23
75:21-76:9
77:15-78:1
78:13-79:22
80:1-80:24
82:4-86:8
98:8-99:7
99:11-99:11
99:13-99:18
100:22-100:25
101:3-101:4
105:3-105:4
105:9-105:11
106:23-107:16
108:9-108:11
108:13-108:23
112:11-112:17
113:14-113:23
113:25-114:8
114:10-114:16
114:18-114:18
115:5-115:13
115:19-116:6
116:24-117:2
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
CS/ H/ 402 R/
403/ E/ L
CS/ H/ 402 R/
403/ E/ L
CS/ H/ 402 R/
403/ E/ L
CS/ H/ 402 R/
403/ E/ L
CS/ H/ 402 R/
403/ E/ L
CS/ H/ 402 R/
403/ E/ L
CS/ H/ 402 R/
403/ E/ L
CS/ H/ 402 R/
403/ E/ L
CS/ H/ 402 R/
403/ E/ L
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ L
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ L
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ L
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ L
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ L
402 R/ 403/ L
402 R/ 403/ L
402 R/ 403/ L
402 R/ 403/ L
402 R/ 403/ L
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ L
402 R/ 403/ L
402 R/ 403
13
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
117:15-117:17
117:19-117:21
119:7-119:21
120:13-120:21
120:22-120:24
123:18-123:20
127:2-127:6
127:9-127:12
128:20-130:2
130:22-131:12
133:21-133:22
133:24-134:9
134:12-134:15
134:17-134:19
134:21-134:22
134:24-135:1
135:4-135:5
145:9-145:23
145:25-145:25
146:11-146:13
146:16-146:20
155:17-155:20
155:23-156:17
156:19-156:19
161:25-162:8
162:16-162:25
163:2-163:2
163:4-163:5
163:7-163:9
163:11-163:11
166:11-166:14
166:17-166:17
166:19-166:19
166:22-166:22
167:5-167:17
167:23-167:25
168:2-169:4
169:6-169:8
169:25-170:2
172:2-172:4
173:13-173:13
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ ID
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
14
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
173:15-174:3
174:25-175:2
175:5-175:9
175:11-175:14
175:16-175:17
175:20-176:8
186:2-186:4
186:7-186:9
187:1-187:3
187:19-187:21
187:24-188:6
188:23-188:25
189:2-189:5
189:7-189:10
189:13-189:15
189:17-191:5
191:9-191:9
191:11-191:13
191:16-191:17
191:19-191:21
191:23-192:1
192:3-192:5
192:7-192:9
192:15-192:16
192:18-192:19
192:21-193:3
193:17-193:20
193:22-193:23
193:25-194:21
194:23-194:23
194:25-195:13
195:16-195:16
202:14-202:24
210:25-212:2
212:4-212:4
212:6-212:12
213:7-213:8
213:10-213:11
213:24-214:14
214:16-215:5
215:13-215:20
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
15
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
Witness
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
223:21-224:11
402 R/ 403
224:13-224:17
402 R/ 403
224:19-224:24
402 R/ 403
225:1-225:1
402 R/ 403
226:19-226:23
402 R/ 403
227:1-227:9
402 R/ 403
228:16-228:22
Shaun McEwan
10/19/2012
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
220:6-220:19
220:21-220:22
402 R/ 403
8:6-8:8
8:13-8:16
20:8-20:12
20:17-20:19
21:13-21:15
21:17-21:17
22:2-22:6
25:9-25:11
25:13-25:13
26:8-26:9
26:11-26:11
26:13-26:15
26:17-26:17
33:11-33:15
33:17-33:17
45:2-45:5
45:7-45:15
45:17-45:19
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
221:4—221:17;
227:17—228:14
221:4—221:17;
227:17—228:14
221:4—221:17;
227:17—228:14
221:4—221:17;
227:17—228:14
221:4—221:17;
227:17—228:14
221:4—221:17;
227:17—228:14
221:4—221:17;
227:17—228:14
221:4—221:17;
227:17—228:14
ATTY, H,
403, F, S, V
ATTY, H,
403, F, S, V
ATTY, H,
403, F, S, V
ATTY, H,
403, F, S, V
ATTY, H,
403, F, S, V
ATTY, H,
403, F, S, V
ATTY, H,
403, F, S, V
ATTY, H,
403, F, S, V
45:20-46:01;
46:03-46:09
403, H, N, D
R
403/ 402 R
403/ 402 R
R
403/ 402 R
403/ BS/ F/ CS
403/ BS/ F/ CS
403/ BS/ F/ CS
403/ BS/ F/ CS
403/ BS/ F/ CS
403/ BS/ F/ CS
403/ I
46:11-46:13
46:15-46:18
59:24-60:4
60:7-60:14
16
R,
R,
R,
R,
R,
R,
R,
R,
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
78:16-78:20
82:14-82:16
82:19-82:19
82:21-83:10
83:12-84:14
84:16-85:4
85:6-85:14
85:16-85:19
88:8-88:15
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
403/ I
78:21-79:05
403/ BS/ CS/ 402
R
403/ BS/ CS/ 402
R
403/ BS/ CS/ 402
R
403/ BS/ CS/ 402
R
403/ BS/ CS/ 402
R
403/ BS/ CS/ 402
R
403/ BS/ CS/ 402
R
403/ BS/ CS/ 402
R/ ML
113:23-114:22
114:24-115:9
115:11-116:15
116:17-116:22
116:24-117:3
117:5-117:10
117:12-118:6
118:8-118:24
119:3-119:5
119:7-119:7
127:3-127:11
128:24-129:19
CS
CS
BS/ CS/ F
403/ CS/ I
130:7-130:10
130:13-131:2
131:4-131:9
131:11-131:22
403/ BS/ I
403/ BS/ I
403/ BS/ I
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
V, F
403/ CS
403/ CS
403/ CS
403/ CS
403/ CS/ 402 R
133:4-133:7
133:9-133:10
133:20-133:25
134:3-134:5
17
129:20-129:22; R, 403, H, F, S
129:24-129:24;
130:01-130:06
131:23-132:03; R, 403, H, F, S,
132:06-132:06; N, O, V
132:08-133:02
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
134:7-135:3
135:5-135:16
135:18-135:24
137:7-137:9
137:11-137:16
166:21-166:25
167:6-168:6
168:8-168:16
168:18-168:18
170:11-170:13
170:15-170:16
170:22-171:7
171:12-171:17
172:6-172:23
173:22-174:5
174:7-174:16
174:18-174:20
174:22-174:23
174:25-175:2
175:22-176:5
183:20-183:23
183:25-184:2
184:4-184:17
184:19-184:20
191:20-193:3
194:14-194:22
195:4-195:14
195:20-196:7
200:14-200:17
200:19-200:24
201:1-201:5
201:7-201:7
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
403/ BS
403/ BS
402 R/
BS
402 R/
BS
402 R/
BS
402 R/
BS
402 R/
BS
402 R/
BS
402 R/
BS
402 R/
BS
403/ CS/
403/ CS/
403/ CS/
403/ CS/
403/ CS/
403/ CS/
403/ CS/
403/ CS/
CS/ BS
CS/ BS
402 R/ 403/ CS/
BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
403/ F/ BS/ CS/ L
403/ F/ BS/ CS/ L
403/ F/ BS/ CS/ L
403/ F/ BS/ CS/ L
18
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
206:20-206:21
206:23-207:12
208:3-208:11
208:12-209:21
209:23-209:23
229:4-229:21
251:12-251:24
252:1-252:1
253:16-254:6
William Middleton
9/28/2012
9:6-9:9
10:19-11:2
402 R/ 403
12:25-13:6
13:11-13:14
13:16-14:11
14:13-14:18
15:3-15:5
15:7-15:11
19:4-19:8
26:17-27:16
32:13-33:14
35:8-35:11
35:24-36:4
36:6-36:13
39:8-39:14
40:11-40:14
41:3-41:7
41:14-41:16
47:12-48:4
48:6-49:2
49:4-50:20
50:22-51:22
51:25-52:10
52:16-52:24
69:2-69:4
69:6-69:19
70:15-71:8
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
403/ MS/ML/ BS/
I
403/ MS/ML/ BS/ 207:14-208:02
I
403/ BS
403/ BS
403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ CS
402 R/ 403/ BS/
CS
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ I
402 R/ 403/ I
402 R/ 403/ I
402 R/ 403/ I
402 R/ 403/ I
402 R/ 403/ I
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403
19
14:20-15:02
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
R, 403, H, I
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
71:10-72:2
72:4-72:16
78:2-78:25
80:11-80:14
80:16-80:24
83:9-83:11
83:13-83:16
83:18-83:23
83:25-84:4
90:13-90:22
91:2-91:5
91:25-92:18
92:20-92:25
94:2-94:7
94:19-94:25
95:8-95:10
111:20-112:9
112:12-112:12
113:2-113:8
113:10-113:15
113:17-113:19
115:9-115:13
115:15-115:25
116:7-116:7
117:22-117:24
117:25-118:13
118:15-118:16
127:10-127:13
127:15-127:19
128:1-128:3
128:5-128:9
128:11-128:11
128:22-128:25
129:2-129:3
130:18-130:20
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
CS
CS
H
402 R/ 403/ CS
402 R/ 403/ CS
402 R/ 403/ CS
402 R/ 403/ CS
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ I
402 R/ 403/ I
402 R/ 403/ I
402 R/ 403/ I
402 R/ 403/ I
113:21-113:22; R, 403, H, N, V
113:25-114:22
402 R/ 403/ I
402 R/ 403/ I
402 R/ 403/ I
402 R/ 403/ I
402 R/ 403/ I
402 R/ 403/ I
I
130:01-130:02; R, 403, H, F, AF
130:04-130:05;
130:07-130:10;
130:13-130:16
130:22-130:24
135:5-135:9
20
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
135:11-135:16
137:5-137:11
137:13-137:21
138:24-139:3
139:5-139:11
139:13-139:15
140:1-140:4
140:14-141:6
141:8-142:2
142:4-142:13
146:1-146:12
155:22-156:5
156:8-156:15
156:22-157:11
157:13-157:23
157:25-158:6
162:20-163:3
163:4-163:8
163:9-163:11
163:13-163:16
164:16-164:20
165:2-165:8
187:20-187:22
188:19-189:3
190:21-191:10
191:12-191:13
191:16-191:16
192:2-192:7
192:9-192:10
192:12-192:17
192:19-192:23
192:25-193:1
193:3-193:4
195:9-195:12
195:19-195:23
196:9-196:12
196:16-197:4
197:9-197:10
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
402 R/ 403/ CS
402 R/ 403/ CS
402 R/ 403/ CS
CS
403
403
402 R/ BS
BS/ I
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
21
165:09-165:12; R, 403, H
165:14-165:18;
166:9-166:12;
166:14-166:17
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
197:24-198:2
198:4-198:12
198:15-198:17
199:14-199:17
199:19-199:23
199:25-200:8
200:10-200:25
201:3-201:3
201:5-201:20
205:22-206:22
206:25-207:14
212:7-213:12
213:15-214:5
214:7-214:7
215:7-215:12
215:15-215:17
216:1-216:22
216:24-216:25
217:2-217:7
217:9-217:20
217:23-218:8
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ BS
402 R/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
BS
BS
BS
BS
BS
BS
BS
220:8-220:10
220:12-220:15
403/ BS/ I
403/ BS/ I
236:18-236:20
236:22-236:23
240:12-240:15
240:18-240:21
254:13-254:17
254:23-254:24
267:17-267:23
268:1-268:1
268:3-268:9
273:2-273:6
273:9-273:10
275:22-276:17
288:6-288:18
294:24-295:15
296:8-296:15
403/ BS/ I
403/ BS/ I
BS
BS
401/ 403/ BS/ P
401/ 403/ BS/ P
403/ BS/ F
403/ BS/ F
403/ BS/ F
403/ BS/ F
403/ BS/ F
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
403/ BS/ ML
403/ BS/ ML
22
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
219:23-220:01; R, 403, H
220:03-220:06
221:14-221:16; R, 403, H, I
221:18-221:21;
222:09-222:19
236:25-237:05
R, 403, H, F, S
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
296:18-296:24
297:1-297:7
297:9-297:16
313:7-313:11
313:13-314:1
320:15-320:20
320:22-320:22
320:24-321:4
321:7-321:16
321:19-321:23
322:1-322:13
322:15-322:16
345:12-345:13
345:15-345:19
345:21-346:4
353:1-353:4
354:8-354:21
354:24-355:5
355:7-355:8
355:10-355:21
355:23-355:25
367:20-367:25
Andrew Parolin
8/31/2012
9:3-9:6
9:9-9:20
11:10-12:2
12:4-12:10
25:25-26:1
26:3-26:7
26:14-26:20
39:1-39:7
63:4-63:10
63:12-63:21
67:22-67:25
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
403/ BS/ ML
403/ BS/ ML
403/ BS/ ML
401/ 403/ BS
401/ 403/ BS
403/ BS
403/ BS
403/ BS
403/ BS
403/ BS
403/ BS
403/ BS
403/ BS
403/ BS
403/ BS
401/ 402 R/
BS/ F
401/ 402 R/
BS/ F
401/ 402 R/
BS/ F
401/ 402 R/
BS/ F
401/ 402 R/
BS/ F
401/ 402 R/
BS/ F
401/ 403/ BS
403/ I
BS/ E
23
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
319:18-319:20; R, 403, H, I, O,
319:22-320:13 F, S, N
403/
403/
403/
403/
403/
403/
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
68:2-68:3
69:4-69:6
69:8-69:18
73:7-73:16
73:18-73:20
73:22-73:24
74:1-74:3
74:5-74:6
74:25-75:5
77:16-77:21
77:23-78:4
78:6-78:11
81:7-81:17
81:19-81:19
82:8-82:13
83:21-83:22
83:24-84:3
84:6-84:11
87:13-87:20
87:22-87:23
89:25-90:2
90:4-90:7
90:9-90:10
90:16-91:7
105:9-105:10
105:13-105:17
111:23-112:8
112:11-112:11
112:13-113:16
113:18-113:25
114:2-114:11
115:18-115:20
115:22-115:25
117:5-117:6
117:9-117:9
119:14-119:19
119:21-119:23
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
68:05-68:06;
68:08-68:15
R, 403, H, O, F,
S, V
75:06-75:08;
75:10-75:11
R, 403, H, F, S,
I, V
403
403
401
403/ BS/ I/ E/ CS
403/ BS/ I/ E/ CS
403/ BS/ I/ E/ CS 84:12-84:17;
84:19-85:06
R, 403, F, S, H,
O, V
401
403
401/ 402 R/ 403
401/ 402 R/ 403
401/ 402 R/ 403
401/ 402 R/ 403
401/ 402 R/ 403
I
403
403
402 R/ 403/ BS/ L
402 R/ 403/ BS/ L
402 R/ 403/ BS/ L
402 R/ 403/ BS/ L
401/ 402 R/ L/ F
401/ 402 R/ L/ F
403/ BS/ I/ ML
403/ BS/ I/ ML
401/ 403
401/ 403
24
116:21-117:04
R, 403, H
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
126:13-126:16
126:18-126:23
126:25-127:11
127:13-127:20
127:22-127:25
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
401/ 403
401/ 403
401/ 403
401/ 403
401/ 403
158:14-158:15
158:17-158:18
160:1-160:12
160:14-160:14
160:16-160:21
160:23-161:5
161:7-161:10
161:13-161:14
165:16-165:19
165:21-165:22
188:21-188:24
189:2-189:6
189:9-189:11
206:2-206:5
206:7-206:15
206:21-206:21
206:23-207:5
207:7-207:20
207:22-207:24
215:20-215:21
215:23-216:6
216:8-216:18
216:20-216:20
403
403
403/ ML
403/ ML
403/ ML
403/ ML
403/ ML
403/ ML
403
403
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
403/ ML
403/ ML
403/ ML
403/ ML
403/ ML
403/ ML
401/ 403/ I
401/ 403/ I
401/ 403/ I
401/ 403/ I
219:2-219:6
219:8-219:9
220:11-220:13
220:15-220:24
221:1-221:10
221:12-221:14
230:20-231:24
232:1-232:12
234:7-234:14
237:18-238:1
239:2-240:15
E
E
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R
401/ 403/ I
25
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
132:20-132:22; R, 403, H, I, M,
132:25-133:03 V, F
216:22-216:22; R, 403, H
216:25-217:12
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
240:17-240:18
246:18-246:24
254:6-255:20
255:22-256:8
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
240:34-241:10; R, 403, H, F, S,
241:12-241:13; I, ATTY
242:02-242:04;
242:06-242:11
I
256:09-256:15; H, 403, ATTY
256:17-256:18
256:19-256:24
257:06-257:08; R, 403, M, H
257:10-257:10
260:2-260:10
260:12-260:16
260:18-260:18
260:20-261:4
261:6-261:6
261:18-261:24
262:1-262:7
262:9-262:11
262:13-262:20
262:22-263:1
263:3-263:8
263:10-263:12
265:3-266:2
266:4-266:9
266:11-266:16
266:18-266:23
266:25-267:7
267:9-267:11
267:13-267:22
267:24-268:4
268:6-268:12
272:21-272:24
273:2-273:4
273:6-273:9
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ I
402 R/ 403/ I
402 R/ 403/ I
274:13-274:15
274:17-274:17
274:19-274:20
274:22-275:3
401/ 402 R/ 403
401/ 402 R/ 403
401/ 402 R/ 403
401/ 402 R/ 403
401/ 403
401/ 403
26
273:10-273:12; R, 403, H, F, S,
273:14-273:15; I, ATTY
274:07-274:10
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
275:5-275:8
277:13-277:15
277:17-277:17
278:4-278:7
278:9-278:11
278:13-278:17
279:4-279:7
279:10-279:14
283:21-284:5
284:7-284:12
285:3-285:7
285:9-285:16
285:18-286:2
286:4-286:12
288:18-288:21
288:23-288:25
289:2-289:3
290:22-290:23
290:25-291:1
299:18-299:21
299:23-299:25
300:2-300:5
300:7-300:8
300:10-300:13
300:15-300:15
300:17-300:20
300:22-300:22
300:24-301:1
302:17-302:19
302:21-302:23
302:25-303:5
303:16-303:19
303:21-303:22
310:10-310:11
310:13-310:15
311:4-311:7
311:9-311:12
311:14-311:19
311:21-311:21
329:23-330:23
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
401/ 402 R/ 403
401/ 402 R/ 403
401/ 402 R/ 403
403/ E
403/ E/ BS
403/ E/ BS
401/ 402 R/ 403
401/ 402 R/ 403
403/ ML
403/ ML
401/ 402 R/ 403
401/ 402 R/ 403
401/ 402 R/ 403
401/ 402 R/ 403
401/ 402 R/ 403
401/ 402 R/ 403
401/ 402 R/ 403
401/ 402 R/ 403
401/ 402 R/ 403
403/ I
403/ I
403/ I
401/ 402 R/ 403
401/ 402 R/ 403
27
303:07-303:09; R, 403, H
303:11-303:14
Witness
Paul Struhsaker
7/2/2012
403/ BS/ E
403/ BS/ E
403/ BS/ E
403/ BS/ E
403/ BS/ E
403/ BS/ E
403/ E/ I/ BS
403/ E/ I/ BS
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
6:5-6:8
6:15-6:17
6:21-7:1
7:4-7:5
7:12-7:18
102:12-102:15
102:18-102:24
103:1-103:5
103:10-103:13
137:22-138:3
403
403
403
403
403/ I
203:8-203:10
203:13-203:17
Douglas Pulley
7/26/2012
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
331:1-331:14
331:23-332:15
334:14-334:19
334:21-334:21
337:11-337:13
337:15-337:20
360:3-360:6
360:9-360:9
360:11-360:14
360:17-360:17
360:19-360:21
360:24-360:24
361:23-362:5
362:7-362:7
398:7-398:10
398:12-399:8
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
403
403/ I
7:21-7:23
10:17-10:21
11:3-11:6
28
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
361:19-361:22
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
R, 403, H, I, O
138:4-11;
R; F; H; I; 403;
138:14-139:3; V
203:19-204:18;
204:21-205:8;
205:11-21;
205:24-206:3
203:19-204:18; R; F; H; I; 403;
204:21-205:8; V
205:11-205: 21;
205:24-206:3
Witness
AL-E-SM
Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
15:18-15:21
15:23-15:23
25:2-25:6
27:19-27:21
29:24-30:3
30:7-30:14
35:12-35:15
37:15-38:4
62:18-63:1
64:14-65:6
67:4-68:2
68:5-68:11
68:13-68:20
70:2-70:23
78:15-78:19
83:14-83:19
84:10-84:14
85:4-85:5
85:8-85:12
87:19-88:6
88:8-88:10
90:22-91:5
95:4-95:9
115:17-115:22
116:3-116:16
117:15-117:18
118:17-119:22
123:16-123:23
184:12-185:5
186:1-186:5
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
AL-E-SM’s
Objections
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ E
402 R/ 403/ E
402 R/ 403/ E
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
Kuo, Ming-Chieh - 09/28/2012
Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal Designations
Sony Mobile and Ericsson’s Objections
105:7—106:23
105:17–106:23 - V, F, M, 403, O, PERSONAL,
ATTY
164:7—24
R, V, F, M, 403, PERSONAL, ATTY
252:3—11
F, V
256:10—19
R, V, F, 403, ATTY
29
HTC’S OBJECTIONS2
Witness
HTC Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
403
BS/ 403/ 402 R
403/ I
F/ 403/ H/ CS
402 R/ BS/ F/ CS
CS/ BS/ 403/ 402 R
CS/ I
BS
BS/ CS/ F
BS/ CS/ F/ 403
15:16-24
22:14 - 24:16
106
41:17 - 43:19
46:4 - 47:25
64:18 - 65:8
68:20 - 69:11
108:19 - 109:12
117:4 - 122:21
402 R/ 403/ BS
CS/ 403/ BS/ E/ L
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ L
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ 106
HTC’s
Objections
BS/ 403
49:11 - 50:8
51:17 - 56:8
56:18 - 60:25
68:17 - 69:13
87:3-25
93:18 - 95:10
96:11-24
Brandt, David
21:15 - 22:16
29:11-25
35:20 - 38:16
44:5 - 45:21
Bezryadina,
Natalya
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
124:23 - 125:24
106
129:10 - 130:23
132:15 - 134:4
148:14 - 150:23
69:16-69:17
20:5—25:4
(already
designated)
120:1—124:9
(already
designated)
236:9—237:8
124:23—127:21
(already
designated)
R/S/H/F/H/I
402 R/ 403/ ID
159:3 - 160:20
46:25-47:01;
47:03-47:08
403
2
HTC hereby incorporates by reference all of Alcatel-Lucent, Sony Mobile, and Ericsson’s
objections and includes them herein prior to the Court’s ruling on the motion to sever.
30
Witness
HTC Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
173:7 - 175:23
176:11 - 181:25
182:12 - 183:1
184:14-21
186:17-21
210:11 - 214:16
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
223:23 - 228:2
229:10-21
230:14-19
235:1 - 236:8
Dubuc, Christian
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
236:9—237:8
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ L
402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ L 210:11—14
(already
designated)
236:9—237:8
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
22:13 - 23:11
33:1 - 34:17
69:13-23
402 R/ 403
CS/ 402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
73:19 - 75:22
402 R/ 403/ BS
85:14 - 86:6
87:23 - 89:9
89:25 - 90:6
92:6 - 93:2
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/
BS/ E/ L
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/
BS/ E/ L
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ E/ L/
ML
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ P
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ L
99:10 - 100:5
107:3-8
158:25 - 159:18
161:11-19
163:17-24
164:1-20
165:4 - 167:20
176:6-18
176:24 - 177:1
182:5 - 183:12
191:1-7
191:13-19
202:13 - 203:17
31
HTC’s
Objections
R/S/H
R/S/H
Witness
McEwan, Shaun
HTC Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
207:4 - 209:2
214:2 - 215:6
225:12 - 226:2
227:19 - 228:22
231:1-11
234:17 - 235:13
236:6-16
237:8 - 238:12
238:24 - 239:20
244:12 - 245:15
246:24 - 247:16
254:17 - 255:2
299:1-16
308:11 - 309:13
327:12-17
344:17 - 346:15
350:6 - 351:16
357:12 - 358:1
22:21 - 23:16
26:8 - 27:17
29:6-25
33:11-17
34:11 - 36:25
45:2-13
73:20 - 74:12
79:11 - 82:13
87:1 - 88:15
90:23 - 92:7
94:16 - 96:10
105:3-15
113:22 - 114:18
115:20-24
117:10-20
133:4 - 134:13
141:4-17
171:21 - 172:23
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
HTC’s
Objections
402 R/ 403/ BS/ ML
402 R/ 403/ BS/ ML
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ L
403/ BS/ F/ CS
403/ BS/ F/ CS
403/ BS/ F/ CS
403/ BS/ F/ CS
403/ I
402 R/ 403/ BS/ CS/
H
402 R/ 403/ ML
403/ I
403/ I
403/ CS
402 R/ 403/ CS
403
403
32
96:12-96:18
R/403/I/S
Witness
HTC Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
182:25 - 183:19
184:22 - 185:12
199:22 - 201:7
206:16 - 207:8
209:10 - 210:9
218:4-25
221:17 - 223:6
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
403/ BS/ CS/ F/ L
403/ BS/ I/ MS/ML
403/ BS
403/ BS/ CS/ F
403/ BS/ CS/ F/ I
231:10-15
232:22 - 233:15
247:14 - 248:4
252:24 - 253:13
209:15 - 210:10
402 R/ BS
212:11 - 213:18
227:21 - 228:16
230:12 - 231:22
237:17 - 238:9
239:14-23
242:16 - 243:25
246:12-21
249:19 - 250:23
255:20 - 256:16
275:22 - 278:17
294:24 - 295:15
297:1-16
312:4 - 313:6
316:24 - 318:7
322:18 - 325:12
344:24 - 345:10
353:6 - 354:6
Middleton,
William
BS/ F
403/ BS/ CS/ F
403/ BS/ CS/ F/ L
402 R/ 403/ BS
403/ BS
403/ BS
403/ BS
403/ BS
403/ BS
403/ BS
401/ 402 R/ 403/ BS
401/ 403/ BS/ P/ F
402 R/ 403/ BS
403/ BS/ ML
403/ BS/ ML
401/ 403/ BS
403/ BS/ I
403/ BS
403/ BS
401/ 402 R/ 403/
BS/ F
401/ 402 R/ 403/ BS
401/ 403/ BS/ CS/ P
359:8-24
367:20 - 370:2
Lysejko, Martin
12:4
12:9-12
12:20 - 14:10
33
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
HTC’s
Objections
207:14-208:02
I/403/R/V
223:14-224:25;
225:02-225:21
403/R/V
I/S
Witness
HTC Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
15:21 - 16:7
19:7 - 20:25
21:15 - 22:19
23:15 - 24:24
28:21 - 29:23
39:1-17
47:7-11
48:13 - 50:2
58:22 - 59:4
59:10-14
73:7 - 76:25
77:15-25
78:22 - 81:5
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
106
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
113:21 - 117:2
117:15 - 119:21
120:22-24
129:1-14
131:15 - 132:8
134:17 - 135:6
135:14 - 140:12
173:13 - 176:8
176:16 - 177:10
202:14 - 203:6
210:25 - 212:12
212:23 - 213:6
214:8 - 215:5
217:4 - 218:7
224:19 - 225:1
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/
E/ L
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/
E/ L
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/
E/ L
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ L
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
237:1-23
238:17 - 239:23
242:11 - 243:22
245:2-7
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
82:4 - 86:8
98:13 - 102:1
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
34
221:4—221:17;
227:17—228:14
HTC’s
Objections
Witness
Struhsaker, Paul
HTC Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
245:10 - 248:9
255:2 - 256:14
261:16 - 265:12
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
7:21-23
10:17 - 11:6
87:19 - 89:2
101:4-12
115:5 - 116:13
127:20 - 130:25
182:10-25
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
Kuo, Ming-Chieh 7:15-25
108:1 - 109:23
Wi-LAN’s
Objections
403
112:25 - 113:6
189:18 - 191:25
199:17 - 203:2
403/ 106
403
403
246:20 - 253:12
403
271:11 - 274:13
Wi-LAN’s
Rebuttal
Designations
105:7—106:23,
164:7—24;
252:3—11
(already
designated)
256:10--19
403
Dated: March 1, 2013
105:7—106:23,
164:7—24;
252:3—11
(already
designated);
256:10--19
105:7—106:23,
164:7—24;
256:10—19
Respectfully submitted,
By:
/s/ Akshay S. Deoras______________
Gregory S. Arovas (pro hac vice)
Robert A. Appleby (pro hac vice)
35
HTC’s
Objections
Jeanne M. Heffernan (pro hac vice)
Akshay S. Deoras (pro hac vice)
KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP
601 Lexington Avenue
New York, NY 10022
Tel: (212) 446-4800
Fax: (212) 446-4900
Alcatel-Lucent-Wi-LAN-Defense@kirkland.com
Michael E. Jones
Allen F. Gardner
POTTER MINTON PC
110 N. College, Suite 500 (75702)
P.O. Box 359
Tyler, Texas 75710
(903) 597 8311
(903) 593 0846 (Facsimile)
mikejones@potterminton.com
allengardner@potterminton.com
ATTORNEYS FOR
LUCENT USA INC.
DEFENDANT
ALCATEL-
/s/ Martin R. Bader (with permission)
Stephen S. Korniczky (pro hac vice)
Martin R. Bader (pro hac vice)
Daniel N. Yannuzzi (pro hac vice)
Lee Hsu (pro hac vice)
Graham M. Buccigross (pro hac vice)
SHEPPARD MULLIN RICHTER & HAMPTON LLP
12275 El Camino Real, Suite 200
San Diego, CA 92130
Tel: (858) 720-8924
Fax: (858) 847-4892
LegalTm-WiLAN-Alcatel-@sheppardmullin.com
Eric Hugh Findlay (TX Bar No. 00789886)
Brian Craft (TX Bar No. 04972020)
FINDLAY CRAFT
6760 Old Jacksonville Hwy, Suite 101
Tyler, TX 75703
Tel: (903) 534-1100
Fax: (903) 534-1137
efindlay@findlaycraft.com
bcraft@findlaycraft.com
36
ATTORNEYS
FOR
CORPORATION, HTC
EXEDA INC.
DEFENDANTS
AMERICA INC.,
HTC
AND
/s/ Richard L. Wynne, Jr. (with permission)
Bruce S. Sostek (TX Bar 18855700)
Richard L. Wynne, Jr. (TX Bar 24003214)
Adrienne E. Dominguez (TX Bar 00793630)
J. Michael Heinlen (TX Bar 24032287)
Timothy E. Hudson (TX Bar 24046120)
Justin S. Cohen (TX Bar 24078356)
THOMPSON & KNIGHT LLP
1722 Routh Street
Suite 1500
Dallas, Texas 75201-2533
Tel: (214) 969-1700
Fax: (214) 969-1751
bruce.sostek@tklaw.com
richard.wynne@tklaw.com
adrienne.dominguez@tklaw.com
michael.heinlen@tklaw.com
tim.hudson@tklaw.com
justin.cohen@tklaw.com
William J. Cornelius (TX Bar 04834700)
Jennifer Ainsworth (TX Bar 00784720)
WILSON ROBERTSON & CORNELIUS PC
909 ESE Loop 323, Suite 400
P.O. Box 7339
Tyler, TX 75711-7339
Tel: (903) 509-5000
Fax: (903) 509-5092
wc@wilsonlawfirm.com
jainsworth@wilsonlawfirm.com
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANTS ERICSSON INC.,
TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON, SONY
MOBILE COMMUNICATIONS (USA) INC., AND
SONY MOBILE COMMUNICATIONS AB
37
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that all counsel of record who have consented to electronic service are being
served with a copy of this document via the Court’s CM/ECF system per Local Rule CV-5(a)(3) on
this the 1st day of March, 2013. Any other counsel of record will be served by first class U.S. mail
on this same date.
/s/ Akshay S. Deoras____________
Akshay S. Deoras
38
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?