EON Corp. IP Holdings, LLC v. Apple Inc.
Filing
1
COMPLAINT against Apple Inc. ( Filing fee $ 350 receipt number 0540-3922929.), filed by EON Corp. IP Holdings, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A - '757 Patent, # 2 Exhibit B - '101 Patent, # 3 Exhibit C - '546 Patent, # 4 Exhibit D - '491 Patent, # 5 Civil Cover Sheet)(Scardino, Daniel)
EXHIBIT C
111111
c12)
1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
US005481546C2
EX PARTE REEXAMINATION CERTIFICATE (8615th)
United States Patent
c1o)
Dinkins
(45)
(54)
INTERACTIVE NATIONWIDE DATA
SERVICE COMMUNICATION SYSTEM FOR
STATIONARY AND MOBILE BATTERY
OPERATED SUBSCRIBER UNITS
(75)
Inventor:
(73)
Assignee: Eon Corporation, Herndon, VA (US)
4,706,121
4,908,834
4,947,244
RE33,417
4,972,457
5,144,648
5,144,663
5,278,891
5,327,478
5,396,228
5,475,585
6,167,278
Gilbert M. Dinkins, Herdon, VA (US)
Reexamination Request:
No. 90/011,265, Oct. 6, 2010
Reexamination Certificate for:
Patent No.:
5,481,546
Issued:
Jan. 2, 1996
Appl. No.:
08/240,147
Filed:
May 10, 1994
Reexamination Certificate Cl 5,481,546 issued Aug. 3, 2010
Related U.S. Application Data
(63)
Continuation of application No. 07/966,414, filed on Oct.
26, 1992, now Pat. No. 5,388,10 1.
(51)
Int. Cl.
H04N 7124
H04N 71173
H04B 71185
H04Q 7112
H04Q 7114
H04H 9100
H04H 3100
(52)
(58)
(2006.01)
(2006.01)
(2006.01)
(2006.01)
(2006.01)
(2006.01)
(2006.01)
U.S. Cl. ............... 370/329; 348/E7.07; 375/E7.025;
455/445; 455/454; 455/507; 455/560; 725/118;
725/123; 725/131; 725/63
Field of Classification Search ........................ None
See application file for complete search history.
References Cited
(56)
U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
3,955,140 A
4,696,034 A
5/1976 Stephens eta!.
9/1987 Wiedemer
\4-
13
IS
'0
AW.D PR.Oc;;.ESS.\~
STA.TU!i\lc.A\... SA.M.P\.EQ
Number:
US 5,481,546 C2
Certificate Issued:
Oct. 4, 2011
A
A
A
E
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
1111987
3/1990
8/1990
10/1990
1111990
9/1992
9/1992
111994
7/1994
3/1995
12/1995
12/2000
Young
Wiedemer
Fenwick eta!.
Bhagat et al.
O'Sullivan
Bhagat et al.
Kudelski eta!.
Bhagat et al.
Lebowitz
Garahi
Bush
Nilssen
FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
CA
CA
wo
1310688
1310699
91103900
1111992
1111992
3/1991
Primary Examiner-Ovidio Escalante
(57)
ABSTRACT
In a two-way interactive communication video network having a network switching center for point-to-point communications between subscribers at different geographic
locations, a local base station configuration is provided for
facilitating low power battery operated portable subscriber
units. The local subscriber units surrounding a base station
are adapted for multiplex transmission of digital messages
synchronously related to a broadcast television signal for
system coordination. Digital messages are transmitted from
the local subscriber units to the base station data processing
facility through a set of receive only cell site subdivision
zones distributed over the base station transmitter geographical range, which communicate with the base station
data processing facility over a communication link such as
wired cable. Messages are compiled and relayed by satellite
to a network switching center transmitter site for nationwide
point-to-point communications. Small-size, inexpensive,
low power, portable, digital-transmitting subscriber units are
introduced compatible with interactive video data system
standards with the ability to cross subdivision and cell zones.
Thus, monitoring of inventory, temperature, and other
parameters for passive automatic alarm systems and the like,
as well as active mobility of subscriber units for meter reading and the like is made possible with direct low-cost nationwide real time reporting capability.
US 5,481,546 C2
1
EX PARTE
REEXAMINATION CERTIFICATE
ISSUED UNDER 35 U.S. C. 307
2
ing communications to and from a plurality of subscriber
units comprising:
THE PATENT IS HEREBY AMENDED AS
INDICATED BELOW.
Matter enclosed in heavy brackets [ ] appeared in the
patent, but has been deleted and is no longer a part of the
patent; matter printed in italics indicates additions made
to the patent.
10
AS A RESULT OF REEXAMINATION, IT HAS BEEN
DETERMINED THAT:
15
The patentability of claims 1 and 14 is confirmed.
Claim 2 is determined to be patentable as amended.
Claims 3 and 5-11, dependent on an amended claim, are
determined to be patentable.
20
Claims 4, 12 and 13 were not reexamined.
2. A two-way communication interactive video network
system having network hub switching center means for rout-
base station repeater cell means for communicating with a
plurality of subscriber units, said base station repeater
cell means and said plurality of subscriber units disposed in a respective geographic area, said base station
repeater cell means further comprising:
data processing and transmission means for transmitting to and receiving from at least one of said plurality of said subscriber units multiplexed synchronously related data messages of variable lengths,
wherein at least one data message that is received is
synchronously related to at least one data message
that is transmitted, such that point-to-point communication between said base station repeater cell
means and said at least one of said plurality of subscriber units is possible,
reception means for receiving and processing said multiplexed synchronously related data messages from said
at least one of said plurality of subscriber units and
relaying said multiplexed synchronously related data
messages from said at least one of said plurality of
subscriber units to said base station repeater cell means.
25
* * * * *
111111
1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
US005481546C 1
c12)
EX PARTE REEXAMINATION CERTIFICATE (7651st)
United States Patent
c1o)
Dinkins
(45)
(54)
INTERACTIVE NATIONWIDE DATA
SERVICE COMMUNICATION SYSTEM FOR
STATIONARY AND MOBILE BATTERY
OPERATED SUBSCRIBER UNITS
Gilbert M. Dinkins, Herdon, VA (US)
(75)
Inventor:
(73)
Number:
US 5,481,546 Cl
Certificate Issued:
Aug. 3, 2010
3,271,511 A
9/1966 Valensi
(Continued)
FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
CA
Assignee: Eon Corporation, Reston, VA (US)
1 131 316
9/1982
(Continued)
Reexamination Request:
No. 90/010,382, Jan. 9, 2009
Reexamination Certificate for:
5,481,546
Patent No.:
Issued:
Jan. 2, 1996
Appl. No.:
08/240,147
Filed:
May 10, 1994
Related U.S. Application Data
(63)
Continuation of application No. 07/966,414, filed on Oct.
26, 1992, now Pat. No. 5,388,10 1.
(51)
Int. Cl.
H04H 20100
H04H 60100
H04B 71185
H04N 7124
H04N 71173
H04Q 9100
(52)
(58)
(2006.01)
(2006.01)
(2006.01)
(2006.01)
(2006.01)
(2006.01)
H04Q 3/58
U.S. Cl. ............... 370/329; 348/E7.07; 375/E7.025;
455/445; 455/454; 455/507; 455/560; 725/118;
725/123; 725/131; 725/63
Field of Classification Search ........................ None
See application file for complete search history.
References Cited
(56)
U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
2,288,802 A
2,992,427 A
3,041,450 A
7/1942 Hanunond, Jr.
7/1961 Franco
6/1962 Parker
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
Federal Communications Commission, Auctions, Auction 2,
Interactive Video and Data Services (IVDS), Jul. 28,
1994-Jul. 29, 1994, 2 pgs.
(Continued)
Primary Examiner-Roland G Foster
(57)
ABSTRACT
In a two-way interactive communication video network having a network switching center for point-to-point communications between subscribers at different geographic
locations, a local base station configuration is provided for
facilitating low power battery operated portable subscriber
units. The local subscriber units surrounding a base station
are adapted for multiplex transmission of digital messages
synchronously related to a broadcast television signal for
system coordination. Digital messages are transmitted from
the local subscriber units to the base station data processing
facility through a set of receive only cell site subdivision
zones distributed over the base station transmitter geographical range, which communicate with the base station
data processing facility over a communication link such as
wired cable. Messages are compiled and relayed by satellite
to a network switching center transmitter site for nationwide
point-to-point communications. Small-size, inexpensive,
low-power, portable, digital-transmitting subscriber units
are introduced compatible with interactive video data system
standards with the ability to cross subdivision and cell zones.
Thus, monitoring of inventory, temperature, and other
parameters for passive automatic alarm systems and the like,
as well as active mobility of subscriber units for meter reading and the like is made possible with direct low-cost nationwide real time reporting capability.
--14-
1"3
DATA. AWII-I..'i~l!io
lo\liNU CORR.I:I..ATIOW
\IER.IFICA"I"ION
$0U~I!
;ER.I'\11111.1.. OIQ.ec::t"OR:'('
IS
D"'TA PAOR.l".IW\
L182"'R'i AMO I:IC>IUW I.D.O.O
FACII.IT'{
lb
A>ID
~ESSIWG
ST"'TISTic:AI.. SAI'\PI..ItR
US 5,481,546 Cl
Page 2
5,153,582
5,155,689
5,162,790
5,175,867
5,177,604
5,179,559
5,187,806
5,223,923
5,224,120
5,224,150
5,239,670
5,282,204
5,315,635
5,327,478
5,335,246
5,337,044
5,396,537
5,408,679
5,430,759
5,432,841
5,436,960
5,444,698
5,475,863
5,479,472
5,546,444
5,633,872
5,638,369
5,663,715
5,710,976
5,7ll,007
5,715,516
5,737,691
5,740,534
5,809,397
5,852,780
5,903,842
5,912,917
5,990,806
6,023,230
6,035,207
6,044,252
6,097,969
H1877
6,173,157
6,173,189
6,282,428
6,469,997
6,515,971
U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
3,761,940
3,854,633
3,882,393
4,037,158
4,056,779
4,096,440
4,128,740
4,144,496
4,144,497
4,220,923
4,228,540
4,245,245
4,313,220
4,317,130
4,321,705
4,352,955
4,369,520
4,481,670
4,482,895
4,485,385
4,495,648
4,509,198
4,513,412
4,513,415
4,521,878
4,525,861
4,528,656
4,550,443
4,578,815
4,591,906
4,633,463
4,644,351
4,646,082
4,659,878
4,660,045
4,675,863
4,704,733
4,723,266
4,727,590
4,737,978
4,747,160
4,750,036
4,755,871
4,783,843
4,792,948
4,799,062
4,799,253
4,801,940
4,849,963
4,866,431
4,870,410
4,875,038
4,875,039
4,882,765
4,901,307
4,907,290
4,928,177
4,940,963
4,941,200
5,020,093
5,036,389
5,056,107
5,081,703
5,090,050
5,093,786
5,101,267
5,ll7,449
5,ll7,502
5,128,934
5,152,002
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
9/1973
12/1974
5/1975
7/1977
1111977
6/1978
12/1978
3/1979
3/1979
9/1980
10/1980
111981
111982
2/1982
3/1982
10/1982
111983
1111984
1111984
1111984
111985
4/1985
4/1985
4/1985
6/1985
6/1985
7/1985
10/1985
3/1986
5/1986
12/1986
2/1987
2/1987
4/1987
4/1987
6/1987
1111987
2/1988
2/1988
4/1988
5/1988
6/1988
7/1988
1111988
12/1988
111989
111989
111989
7/1989
9/1989
9/1989
10/1989
10/1989
1111989
2/1990
3/1990
5/1990
7/1990
7/1990
5/1991
7/1991
10/1991
111992
2/1992
3/1992
3/1992
5/1992
5/1992
7/1992
9/1992
Hollingsworth
Strenglein
Epstein
Eastrnond
Toler
Okasaka
Graziano
Cunningham et al.
Andrea, III
Pelchat et al.
Ogita
Matsumoto et a!.
Lo et al.
Brown
Namiki
Kai eta!.
Cerny, Jr. et al.
Freeburg
Weinberg
Ralston
Giger
Nagatomi
Cox
Martinez
Toyonaga
Freeburg
Morais
Freeburg
Persinotti
Morales-Garza et a!.
Mack
Zabarsky et a!.
Engel eta!.
Dinkins
Clark
Paneth eta!.
Kawano
Perry
Kawano eta!.
Burke et al.
Bossard
Martinez
Morales-Garza et a!.
Leff eta!.
Hangen eta!.
Sanderford, Jr. et al.
Stern eta!.
Maetal.
Kawano eta!.
Andros et al.
Andros et al.
Siwiaketal.
Andros et al.
Maxwell eta!.
Gilhousen et a!.
Crompton
Martinez
Gutman et a!.
Leslie eta!.
Pireh
Morales
Johnson et a!.
Lee
Heffernan
Derks
Morales-Garza
Metroka et a!.
Onoda eta!.
Jasinski
Leslie eta!.
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
H
B1
B1
B1
B1
B2
10/1992
10/1992
1111992
12/1992
111993
111993
2/1993
6/1993
6/1993
6/1993
8/1993
111994
5/1994
7/1994
8/1994
8/1994
3/1995
4/1995
7/1995
7/1995
7/1995
8/1995
12/1995
12/1995
8/1996
5/1997
6/1997
9/1997
111998
111998
2/1998
4/1998
4/1998
9/1998
12/1998
5/1999
6/1999
1111999
212000
3/2000
3/2000
8/2000
10/2000
1/2001
1/2001
8/2001
10/2002
2/2003
Davis
Wortham
Jasinski
Wejke eta!.
Martinez
Crisler eta!.
Johnson et al.
Morales-Garza
Schilling
Neustein
Schwendeman et al.
Shpancer et a!.
Kane eta!.
Lebowitz
Yokev eta!.
Folger eta!.
Schwendeman
Masuda
Yokev eta!.
Rimer
Campana, Jr. eta!.
Kito
Simpson et a!.
Campana, Jr. eta!.
Roach, Jr. et al.
Dinkins
Ayerst eta!.
Godoroja
Hill eta!.
Lin eta!.
Howard et al.
Wang eta!.
Ayerst eta!.
Harthcock et a!.
Wang eta!.
Wang eta!.
Engelbrecht eta!.
Mock eta!.
Dorenbosch et a!.
Wang eta!.
Dorenbosch
Angus eta!.
Van Etten et a!.
Godoroja eta!.
Lockhart
Ho eta!.
Dorenbosch et a!.
Nelson eta!.
FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
CA
CA
CA
DE
EP
EP
EP
EP
EP
EP
EP
EP
EP
EP
EP
FR
GB
GB
GB
JP
JP
1 205 140
1 269 441
1 281 126
28 39 864
0 049 280
0 085 575
0 201 254
0 280 543
0 282 347
0 402 809
0 475 348
0 486 229
0 501 706
0 712 215 A2
1 378 815 A2
2 672 756
924 145
1 295 845
2 203 018
59-147585
2-193423
5/1986
5/1990
3/1991
4/1980
4/1982
8/1983
1111986
8/1988
9/1988
12/1990
3/1992
5/1992
9/1992
5/1996
112004
8/1992
4/1963
1111972
10/1988
8/1984
7/1990
US 5,481,546 Cl
Page 3
JP
JP
JP
wo
wo
wo
wo
wo
wo
wo
wo
wo
wo
wo
2-193424
2-193425
63-219238
85/01854
87-07109
88-09969
91-02435
91108652
91115071
92/00636
92/02084
93/07691
93/14580
94/10803
7/1990
7/1990
9/1998
4/1985
1111987
12/1988
2/1991
6/1991
10/1991
111992
2/1992
4/1993
7/1993
5/1994
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
Baker, "An Introduction to Multistatic Radar," College of
Engineering and Computer Science, ANU, NATO Research
and Technology Organisation, May 2009, pp. 2-1-2-20.
Newton's Telecom Dictionary, 16'h Expanded & Updated
Edition, Feb. 2000, p. 560.
Newton's Telecom Dictionary, 16'h Expanded & Updated
Edition, Feb. 2000, p. 917.
Newton's Telecom Dictionary, Fifth Expanded & Updated
Edition, Dec. 1992, p. 560.
Newton's Telecom Dictionary, Fifth Expanded & Updated
Edition, Dec. 1992, p. 917.
Feher et a!., "Simultaneous Transmission of Digital PhaseShift Keying and of Analog Television Signals," IEEE
Transactions on Communications, Dec. 1975, pp.
1509-1514.
Barber, "Cofrequency Cross-Polarized Operation of a 91
Mbit/s Digital Radio," IEEE Transactions on Communications, vol. COM-32, No. 1, Jan. 1984, pp. 87-91.
"New Products and Accessories for Two-Way Radio Systems," Communications News, Aug. 1995, pp. 64-69.
Evans, "MMDS Technology-An International Opportunity," MTX Telecom Services, Inc., Canada, 1986, pp.
321-325.
Feldman et a!., "A Study on the Technical Feasibility of
Terrestrial Onmidirectional Television Transmissions in the
12-GHz Band," IEEE Transactions on Communication
Technology, vol. COM-17, No.4, Aug. 1969, pp. 475-480.
Hearson, "Unusual Propagation Factors in Point-to-Point
Microwave System Performance," IEEE Transactions on
Communication Technology, vol. COM-15, No. 4, Aug.
1967,pp. 615-625.
Hewitt et a!., "A Cost Effective 19GHz Digital Multipoint
Radio System for Local Distribution Applications," ICC '84,
Links for the Future, Science, Systems & Services for Communications, IEEE International Conference on Communications, May 14-17, 1984, RAI Congress Centre, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 16 pgs.
Jakubowski, "A New Generation of High-Power Cellular
Repeaters," The Antenna Specialists Company, Cleveland,
Ohio, May 1990, pp. 24-28.
Jakubowski, "Propagation Considerations of Low Power
Cellular Boosters and Case Histories," The Antenna Specialists Company, Cleveland, Ohio, May 1989, pp. 523-527.
Koch eta!., "Transmitting Antenna with Cosecant-Shaped
Vertical Pattern for the 12-GHz Television System," IEEE
Transactions on Communications, vol. COM-22, No. 9,
Sep. 1974,pp. 1391-1393.
Kuramoto et a!., "Second Generation Mobile Radio Telephone System in Japan," IEEE Communications Magazine,
vol. 24, No.2, Feb. 1986, pp. 16-21.
Mohamed eta!., "29 GHz Point-to-Point Radio Systems for
Local Distribution," Br Telecom Technology Journal, vol. 2,
No.1, Jan. 1984, pp. 29-40.
Shindo, "Radio Subscriber Loop System for High-Speed
Digital Communications," International Conference on
Communications, Denver, Colorado, Jnn. 14-18, 1981, pp.
66.1.1-66.1.5.
Tanenbaum, "Computer Networks," Prentice-Hall, Inc.,
1981, pp. 250-273.
Towaij et a!., "The Microcell Land Mobile Radio System,"
Vehicular Technology Conference, May 1983, pp. 247-250.
Wireless Modem for ARDIS (IBM Library Document
#GX27-4000--01); 1995, 135 pgs.
Kannismaa et a!., "On Frequency Radio (OFR) Repeater as
Fade Filler," Kava! Electronics, Inc., Markham, Ontario,
L3R 4N4, Canada, Jan. 1, 1989, IEEE, pp. 528-531.
Beaman, "Vehicular Mounted Repeater in Emergency Medical Services (EMS) Communications," IEEE Transactions
on Vehicular Technology, vol. VT-28, No.4, Nov. 1979, pp.
307-310.
Howat, "Cell Like Performance Using the Remotely Controlled Cellular Transmitter," NYMEX Mobile Commnnications, Pearl River, NY 10965, Jan. 1, 1989 IEEE, pp.
535-541.
Jog, eta!., "A Modern Communication System for Maharashtra Police," Jan. 1, 1989 IEEE, pp. 538-541.
Rustad eta!., "New Radio Networks for Tactical Communication," IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Commnnications, vol. 8, No.5, Jun. 1990, pp. 713-727.
Vaddiparty et a!., Satellite System for Tactical MILSATCOM Applications, Ford Aerospace Corporation, Palo Alto,
CA., Jnn. 29, 1990, pp. 0278-0288.
Isberg, "Radio Communication in Subways and Mines
Through Repeater Amplifiers and Leaky Transmission
Lines," Comsul, Ltd., San Francisco, CA., Vehicular Technology Conference, 1978, 28'h IEEE, vol. 28, publication
date Mar. 22-24, 1978, current version published Jun. 19,
2006, pp. 248-254.
Antonio et a!., "OnmiTRACS: A Commercial Ku-Band
Mobile Satellite Terminal and its Applicability to Military
Mobile Terminals," Qualcomm, Inc., San Diego, CA, Jan. 1,
1988 IEEE, pp. 0761-0764.
Chang eta!., "Computer-Based Communication System for
Police," Chung Shan Institute of Science and Technology,
Taiwan, Republic of China, Jan. 1, 1989 ICCST, Zurich
Switzerland, pp. 251-254.
Carlisle, "Edison's Netcomm Project," Southern California
Edison Company, Rosemead, CA, Sep. 1988, pp.
B5-1-B5-4.
Bustillo et a!., "Datamovil: A Practical Implementation of
Tradamo Mobile Data Transmission Protocol," Area de I+D
Sistemas de Telecomnnicacion, Madrid, Spain, Jan. 1, 1989,
IEEE, pp. 31-37.
LeF!och et a!., "Digital Sound Broadcasting to Mobile
Receivers," CCETT (Centre Commnn d'Edutes de Telediffusion et Telecommnnucations) 35512 Cesson Sevigne,
France, Jun. 9, 1989 IEEE, Manuscript received Jun. 9,
1989,pp.493-503.
Waters et a!., "Plans and Studies in the EBU for Satellite
Broadcasting of Sound Radio," EBU Review Technical,
Nos. 241-242, Jun./Aug. 1990, pp. 70-81.
US 5,481,546 Cl
Page 4
Shelswell et a!., "Digital Audio Broadcasting: The First UK
Field Trial," BBC Research Data Report, Jan. 1, 1991, pp.
1-24.
Frankel et a!., "An Overview of the Army/DARPA Distributed Communications and Processing Experiment," IEEE
Journal on Selected Areas in Communications, vol. SAC-4,
No.2, Mar. 1986, pp. 207-215.
Bannister et a!., "The Australian Digital Radio Concentrator
System-DRCS," Telecom Australia, Rural Telecommunications, Jan. 1, 1988, publication date May 23-25, 1988,
current version published Aug. 6, 2002, pp. 56-62.
LeFloch, "Channel Coding and Modulation for DAB," First
International Symposium on Digital Audio Broadcasting,
Montreux, Switzerland, Jun. 8-9, 1992, 12 pgs.
Ratliff et a!., "The Convergence of Satellite and Terrestrial
System Approaches to Digital Audio Broadcasting with
Mobile and Portable Receiver," EBUReview, Nos. 241-242,
Jun./Aug. 1990, 14 pgs.
Ratliff, "EBU/DAB Studies for a New Digital Sound Radio
Broadcasting System---CD Quality for Mobiles," Technical
Symposium, New Horizons in Electronic Media, 1st World
Electronic Media Symposium, Oct. 4-7, 1989; Palexpo,
Geneva, Switzerland, pp. 377-284.
Voyer et a!., "Digital Audio Broadcasting Experimentation
and Planning in Canada," EBU Review Technical, Manuscript Received Feb. 15, 1991, 11 pgs.
Lery eta!., "Extending HDTV Coverage Using Low Power
Repeaters-a Cellular Approach," General Instrument Corporation-VideoCipher Division, San Diego, CA, IEEE
Transactions on Broadcasting, vol. 38, No. 3, Sep. 1992, pp.
145-150.
Al-Kadi, "Integration of Two Telecommunication Services:
Mobile Radio and Rural Subscriber Radio," Electrotechnics,
1988, Conference Proceedings on Area Communication,
EUROCON 88, Stockholm, Sweden, publication date Jun.
13-17, 1988, current version published Aug. 6, 2002, pp.
322-325.
PerComm, Inc., ESO User's Guide, Sep. 23, 2003, 58 pgs.
Wireless Application Development, Issues and Guidelines
Paging Systems Emphasis, Motorola Personal Networks
Group, Jan. 1, 1999, 59 pgs.
ReFLEX Rules, The Role of Pervasive Low-Cost Networks
and Devices in the Future of Mobile Data Messaging, A Sag
Harbor Group White Paper, Jan. 1, 2001, 59 pgs.
Buckenbarn et a!., "ReFLEX Wireless Data Technology,
Why ReFLEX has become the Industry Standard for Wireless Data Delivery," USA Mobility, Sep. 5, 2000, 2nd version, Jul. 9, 2004, 20 pgs.
Skytel Attribute Characterization, Sky Tel WCTP 1.1/WCTP
1.2 Beta Release 1, Document #S266 Revision 1.02, Sep. 11,
2002, 31 pgs.
Sudhir Murthy, Lexington Consulting Company, Lexington,
MA, "Data Communication with Remote Sensors Using
Reflex Narrowband PCS Technology," Final Report for
ITS-IDEA Project 74, Transporation Research Board,
National Research Council, Dec. 2001, 34 pgs.
Motorola Talkabout T900, The T900 and SkyTel Service:
The Low-Cost Wirelesss Solution to Tough Communication
Problems, Jan. 1, 2001, 2 pgs.
Motorola Timeport P935, SkyTel and the P935: The Best
Way to Stay Informed, Organized and Connected, Jan. 1,
2001, 2 pgs.
USA Mobility, One Source for Wireless, Federal Sales-Department of Defense (DOD), Blanket Purchase Agreement
(BPA) Jul. 24, 2006, 2 pgs.
Sytechl Corporation, "Off the Air" and "Switch" Based
Pager Intercept System, Jan. 1, 2003, 4 pgs.
Bellis, "Pager Testing with a Specially Equipped Signal
Generator," Technology Industry, Industry: Email Alert RSS
Feed, Hewlett-Packard Journal, Feb. 1998, 3 pgs.
Rysavy, "Making the Call with Two-Way Paging," Network
Computing, Jan. 15, 1997, 4 pgs.
Somers, "A Cost Effective Approach to C&I AMR and
Power Quality, Power Reliability Reporting," United Telecom Council, Phoenix, AZ, Jun. 28, 2000, 16 pgs.
The Wireless Communication Transfer Protocol (WCTP)
Protocol Specification, Personal Communications Industry
Association, Jun. 6, 2000, 141 pgs.
SkyTel, Using Your AccessLink Pager, AccessLink Pager
Instructions, Jan. 1, 1997, 5 pgs.
ATCOM Wireless, Inc., ATlOO User Guide, Jan. 1, 2004, 80
pgs.
Motorola, PageWriter 2000X User Guide, Jan. 1, 1999, 90
pgs.
Motorola, Timeport Personal Interactive Communicator
User's Guide, Jan. 1, 2000, 170 pgs.
Unication, m90 Messenger, Advanced 2-Way Messaging
Device, User's Guide, Jan. 1, 2006, 66 pgs.
SmartSynch News, SmartSynch to Develop Key Component
for Elster Two-Way AMI System, Jackson MS, Oct. 23,
2006,2 pgs.
Alpha Security Concepts, Shreveport/Bossier City, LA, A
Brinks Home Security Authorized Dealer, Help Protect Your
Home! Jan. 1, 2008, 3 pgs.
All Page of Houston, Houston TX, Local, State or Nationwide Paging, Be it ... Numeric, Alphanumeric or Two Way
Pagers! Jan. 1, 2003, 1 pg.
American Messaging, Partner P900---Features, Jan. 1, 2006,
1 pg.
American Messaging, Paging Products, Jan. 1, 2006, 2 pgs.
American Messaging, American Messaging's Contract with
the State of Texas, Jan. 1, 2006, 5 pgs.
American Messaging, 2-Way Paging Coverage Maps, Jan.
1' 2006, 1 pg.
Unilex, The Power of Knowing, Frequently Asked Questions, Jan. 1, 2007, 2 pgs.
Frost & Sullivan Profile, Strategies and Competitive Analysis, SmartSynch Meter System, Jan. 1, 2000, 4 pgs.
American Messaging, Intelligent Remote Control (IRC),
Jan. 1, 2006, 2 pgs.
Inilex, The Power of Knowing, The Power of Tracking, The
Kepler Advantage, Jan. 1, 2007, 3 pgs.
The Paging Information Resource, ReFLEX Device Status
Report and Directory, Jan. 1, 2003, 6 pgs.
American Messaging, P900 2-Way Pager for $49.95, Jan. 1,
2006, 1 pg.
A Complete Control and Monitoring Solution-Motorola's
CreataLink 2 XT Two-Way Data Transceiver Can Provide
Wireless Communications Between Devices and People,
Business Wire, Sep. 1, 1999, 2 pgs.
American Messaging, New to 2-Way?, Jan. 1, 2006, 3 pgs.
American Messaging, Enhanced Services Pricing, Jan. 1,
2006,3 pgs.
SmartSynch News, "SmartSynch Acquires CreataLink 2XT
Product Line from Motorola," Jackson, MS, Mar. 11, 2002, 2
pgs.
US 5,481,546 Cl
Page 5
Access My Library, "SmartSynch Buys CreataLink 2XT.
(Strictly Business).(Brief Article)(Company Profile)," Mississippi Business Journal, Mar. 25, 2002, 2 pgs.
Transmission and Distribution World, "SmartSynch to
Develop Key Component for Elster Two-Way AMI System," Oct. 25, 2006, 3 pgs.
SkyTel Telemetry Case Study, Automating Meter Reading:
SmartSynch Leverages the SkyTel Network, Jan. 1, 2003, 2
pgs.
SkyTel M2M Case Study, Automating Meter Reading:
Smartsynch Leverages the SkyTel Network, Jan. 1, 2009, 2
pgs.
The SmartSynchAdvantage, Jan. 1, 2005, 9 pgs.
Initex, The Power of Knowing, The Power of Tracking, The
Kepler, Jan. 1, 2007, 3 pgs.
AMR/AMI Case Study, "Trico Electric Cooperative Puts
SmartSynch SmartMeters to Work," Nov. 2008, 2 pgs.
WebLink Wireless Approves Advantra Telemetry Module;
Baran to be Available for Development and Purchase, Dallas, Texas, Dec. 9, 2002, 2 pgs.
Nigthhawk-Take Remote Control, CCU-1, Jan. 1, 2006, 1
pg.
Nigthhawk-Take Remote Control, CE0-700, Jan. 1, 2006,
1 pg.
Nigthhawk-Take Remote Control, HYDRO 1, Jan. 1, 2006,
1 pg.
Nigthhawk-Take Remote Control, PTlLC, Jan. 1, 2006, 1
pg.
Nigthhawk-Take Remote Control, Welcome to Nigthhawk
Systems, Jan. 1, 2006, 1 pg.
Jal, TMCnet Contributing Edicor, Nighthwak Systems Intros
New Two-Way Wireless Product Line, Nov. 4, 2008, 3 pgs.
Aberdeen Group Profile, "The Business Case for Smart
Metering," SmartSynch, Jan. 1, 2002, 6 pgs.
American Messaging, Product Archive, Jan. 1, 2006, 5 pgs.
Motorola, Timeport World Message Pager, Model PF1500,
User's Guide, Jan. 1, 1999, 13 pgs.
All Page of Houston, Two-Way Pagers from All Pageii, Jan.
1' 2003, 1 pg.
Inilex, The Power of Knowing, The Power of Telemetry,
Telemetry, Jan. 1, 2007, 2 pgs.
Consumer Complaints Board, Brinks Home Security, Jan. 1,
2009, 9 pgs.
Brinks Business Security, Business Security Products &
Equipment, Jan. 1, 2009, 4 pgs.
SmartSynch, Case Study: Florida Power & Light, Jan. 1,
1998, 3 pgs.
ReFLEX 50 Hardware Spedicifations, Jan. 1, 2000, 2 pgs.
Sky Tel, Comprehensive End-to-End Solutions, Jan. 1,
2008, 1 pg.
SkyTel, Serving the End-User Business and Government
Marketplace, Jan. 1, 2008, 1 pg.
SkyTel, Serving Application Developers and Other M2M
Solutions Providers, Jan. 1, 2008, 1 pg.
Sky Tel, Sky Tel vs. Other Wireless Providers, Jan. 1, 2008, 2
pgs.
Sky Tel, M2M Solutions, Powering Innovations in Machineto-Machine Communications, Jan. 1, 2008, 1 pg.
SkyTel, Service/Device User Guides, Jan. 1, 2008, 3 pgs.
SkyTel Skywriter, Motorola Timeport P935, A Powerful,
Flexible Communications Package and PIM Device, Jan. 1,
2001, 1 pg.
SkyTel, Products & Services: SkyTel Telemetry ServicesTechnology, Advanced Messaging Network, Jan. 1, 2008, 2
pgs.
SkyTel, Products & Services: SkyTel Telemetry ServicesNetwork Access Program, Jan. 1, 2008, 2 pgs.
SkyTel, ReFLEX, Jan. 1, 2008, 1 pg.
SkyTel, Products & Services: SkyTel Product Portfolio, Jan.
1, 2008, 2 pgs.
SkyTel, ReFLEX Developer Tools, Jan. 1, 2008, 2 pgs.
SkyTel, Partnerships: Developer Resources Center-Email
Solutions/SMTP, Jan. 1, 2008, 4 pgs.
Sky Tel, Partnerships: Developer Resources Center-Technical Support, Jan. 1, 2008, 1 pg.
SkyTel, Partnerships: Development Resources CenterSNPP, Jan. 1, 2008, 9 pgs.
Sky Tel, Partnerships: Developer Resources Center-TAP,
Jan. 1, 2008, 8 pgs.
Motorola, Talkabout, Personal Interactive Communicator,
Model T900, User's Guide, Oct. 2001, 91 pgs.
SkyTel, Partnerships: Development Resources CenterWCTP, Jan. 1, 2008, 4 pgs.
SkyTel, Partnerships: Developer Resources Center-Terminal Emulation, Jan. 1, 2008, 1 pg.
Consumer Affairs.com/Brinks Security Complaints, May 5,
2009, 16 pgs.
Sky Tel, Hunetec H200, Performance Spefications, Jan. 1,
2004, 1 pg.
USA Mobility, M2M Services-Overview, Jul. 2, 2008, 2
pgs.
The Paging Information Resource, An Introduction to TwoWay Technology, Mar. 25, 2009, 12 pgs.
USA Mobility, M2M Services-Overview, Mar. 25, 2009,
12 pgs.
SkyTel ST900 Two-Way Pager, User's Manual, Oct. 2005,
20 pgs.
SkyTel, The Unication M90 Offers the Latest in Advanced
2Way Messaging Features, Jan. 1, 2008, 1 pg.
Brinks Rapid Security, Jan. 1, 1998, 4 pgs.
Inilex, Kepler Plus, Jan. 1, 2007, 1 pg.
Inilex, Kepler, Jan. 1, 2007, 1 pg.
Inilex, Advantra, Karti ReFLEX Module, Jan. 1, 2007, 1 pg.
Advantra, Advanced Transmission Solutions, Karli, Jan. 1,
2007, 1 pg.
Inilex, Advantra, Barran ReFLEX Module, Jan. 1, 2007, 1
pg.
Advantra, Advanced Transmission Solutions, Barran, Jan. 1,
2007, 1 pg.
Numeric Pagers from Allpage, Brand New Messenger m90
Two Way Pager by Unication, Jan. 1, 2003, 2 pgs.
Inilex, Advantra, Wirlki ReFLEX Module, Jan. 1, 2007, 1
pg.
SmarthSynch, A3 Alpha SmartMeter, Elster, May 5, 2009, 4
pgs.
SmarthSynch, SmartSynch Quick Facts, May 5, 2009, 1 pg.
SmarthSynch, SmartSynch, Inc., May 5, 2009, 2 pgs.
SmarthSynch, Advanced Communication Network, May 5,
2009,2 pgs.
SmarthSynch, 1-210+c SmartMeter, May 5, 2009, 4 pgs.
SmarthSynch, kV2c SmartMeter, May 5, 2009, 4 pgs.
SmarthSynch, Managed Services Solution, May 5, 2009, 2
pgs.
SmarthSynch, Sentinel GPRS SmartMeter, May 5, 2009, 4
pgs.
US 5,481,546 Cl
Page 6
SmarthSynch, Advanced Communication Network, May 5,
2009,2 pgs.
USA Mobility, Solutions, M2M Services, Mar. 20, 2009, 1
pg.
USA Mobility, Keeping Sprint Connected, Mar. 20, 2009, 3
pgs.
USA Mobility, One Source for Wireless, National
Accounts-Products and Services, Mar. 20, 2009, 4 pgs.
USA Mobility, Motorola T900, Mar. 19, 2009, 1 pg.
USA Mobility, Motorola TimePort P935, Mar. 19, 2009, 1
pg.
USA Mobility, Advanced 2-Way Messaging Device, M90
Messenger, Mar. 10, 2009, 2 pgs.
USA Mobility, Reliability of ReFLEX, Mar. 10,2009,2 pgs.
USA Mobility, Wireless Messaging-Products and Services, Mar. 10, 2009, 1 pg.
The Paging Information Resource, Two-Way Pagers and
Telemetry Modules, ReFLEX Device Status Report and
Directory, Mar. 10, 2009, 6 pgs.
SmartSynch, Creatalink 2XT Data Transceiver, Jan. 1, 1998,
1 pg.
SmartSynch, SmartSynch News, SmartSynch to Develop
Key Component for Elster Two-Way AMI System, Oct. 23,
2006,2 pgs.
Carrier, Alliance Partners, SkyTel Telemetry Services, Jan.
1, 2009, 1 pg.
SkyTel M2M Case Study, Remote Energy Management:
ComfortChoice® from Carrier Corporation, Jan. 1, 2009, 2
pgs.
Carrier ComfortChoice®, Verifiable Demand Response,
Two-Way Communicating Thermostat, Jan. 1, 2008, 4 pgs.
Carrier Comfort Choice, Jan. 1, 2009, 1 pg.
Carrier, Questions??? ComfortChoice, Jan. 1, 2009, 1 pg.
Carrier, Energy Management, Jan. 1, 2009, 1 pg.
Carrier, Comfort Choice, Questions??? Curtailment Process,
Jan. 1, 2009, 1 pg.
Carrier, ComfortChoice, System Elements and Hardware,
Jan. 1, 2009, 1 pg.
US 5,481,546 Cl
1
EX PARTE
REEXAMINATION CERTIFICATE
ISSUED UNDER 35 U.S. C. 307
NO AMENDMENTS HAVE BEEN MADE TO
THE PATENT
2
AS A RESULT OF REEXAMINATION, IT HAS BEEN
DETERMINED THAT:
The patentability of claims 1-14 is confirmed.
* * * * *
111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
US005481546A
United. States Patent
[11]
Dinkins
[54]
INTERACTIVE NATIONWIDE DATA
SERVICE COMMUNICATION SYSTEM FOR
STATIONARY AND MOBILE BATTERY
OPERATED SUBSCRIBER UNITS
[75]
Inventor:
Gilbert M. Dinkins, Herdon, Va.
[73]
Assignee: Eon Corporation, Reston, Va.
[ *]
Notice:
[21]
Appl. No.: 240,147
[22]
Filed:
May 10,1994
Related U.S. Application Data
[63]
Continuation of Ser. No. 966,414, Oct. 26, 1992, Pat. No.
5,388,101.
[51]
Int. Cl. 6
[52]
[58]
H04N 7/173; H04B 7/24;
H04L 12/18
U.S. Cl•....................... 370/95.1; 455/33.1; 455/53.1;
34817; 348/13
Field of Search ............................... 348/6, 8, 12, 13,
34817, 10; 379/58, 59, 63, 90, 93; 370171,
73, 75, 85.1, 95.1, 95.3, 104.1; 455/33.1,
53.1
•••••••••••••••.••••.••••••••
[56]
References Cited
U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
5,036,389
Date of Patent:
5,177,604
111993 Martinez ................................... 348/13
Primary Examiner-Wellington Chin
Attorney, Agent, or Firm-Patrick T. King; John P. Wagner,
Jr.
[57]
The portion of the term of this patent
subsequent to Feb. 7, 2012, has been
disclaimed.
5,481,546
* Jan. 2, 1996
Patent Number:
[45]
[19]
ABSTRACT
In a two-way interactive communication video network
having a network switching center for point-to-point communications between subscribers at different geographic
locations, a local base station configuration is provided for
facilitating low power battery operated portable subscriber
units. The local subscriber units surrounding a base station
are adapted for multiplex transmission of digital messages
synchronously related to a broadcast television signal for
system coordination. Digital messages are transmitted from
the local subscriber units to the base station data processing
facility through a set of receive only cell site subdivision
zones distributed over the base station transmitter geographical range, which communicate with the base station
data processing facility over a communication link such as
wired cable. Messages are compiled and relayed by satellite
to a network switching center transmitter site for nationwide
point-to-point communications. Small-size, inexpensive,
low-power, portable, digital-transmitting subscriber units
are introduced compatible with interactive video data system
standards with the ability to cross subdivision and cell zones.
Thus, monitoring of inventory, temperature, and other
parameters for passive automatic alarm systems and the like,
as well as active mobility of subscriber units for meter
reading and the like is made possible with direct low-cost
nationwide real time reporting capability.
7/1991 Morales .................................... 348113
14 Claims, 7 Drawing Sheets
PA.R.TIC.\ PA.WT
---
17
MEioi\OR.'(
I~
'!:1\JJITC.I-\
~TR.OL
CEN"TER.
A.UClE.NC.E
CO~~L A.NO
OA.TA. C£NTER..
OA."TA.
?R.OG.R.~""
00\AJ~
Ll BI2.A.R'( A.NO
LOAD
F~CILIT'(
lb
TAAWSII.crl~
ANO
SlLLINGO
?R.OCESSI~G.
STA.T\STI~~
LOCI\.~
A-REA.
REPEA.iER.
ReMOTe
M.EWU CORR.ELP..TIOW
SOUR.C.5 VER.IFICA.TION
\ER..Joi\1\I~L 0\Q..~C::.TOR.'(
IS
?R..OG.t:!A"M
I NTeR.AC.TO~
STP..TION AND
DA.TA. A.NA.~'f&IS
1"3
1
A.NO
SA.M?LE"R
REC.GiiVr=:R
RE~?ONSE:.
\JN\\
TERM.\N~L
"I.DA.
U.S. Patent
Jan.2, 1996
t
I
I
-
\
\
\
\
.c(
I
I
I
I
I
\
t'\
I
t
I
I
\
Sheet 1 of 7
5,481,546
U.S. Patent
j
Jan.2, 1996
f
BR.OAO CAS\
\WTe.R.\1.6\l..
Sheet 2 of 7
\
)
ER.R.OR.
C.OQ.Q.e:c.T \ ~c;:,
ANO
RESER."t:.O
HU
RE~PON.&E
\N~VAL
HU
RESPONSE
\N.\ER.\I~L
FIG.3
5,481,546
HU
R.ECS.PON«&E
\ WT eR\S A.,\...
REMO\E
REC.e\\1\:R.
-fa
REMOTE.
REC.E\\JE.R
-f2.
Rl:;~O\E.
RE'c.E\ \JE:R
-fn.
Y...,.'(
I.D/HU TOO
A.?P CODE.
( C.L\C.K.
C.OOR....t>\N~le.~)
\-\000
C..R.C.
?
1.0
'32.
?
L t:NG.1'\-\
PAC\<.E.\
~
RE~ER.\IEO
~
-~
b
B'e:R
PAC.KE.T
S\J \ L DER.
PAC.KET
~U\LOER.
SU\LOER.
@>U\Lt>ER
I
I
I
I
I
L
ll\ A
•
=
""""
;...;
-------------------------------------A~-----------------------------I
~
•
00.
•
I
- • •
I'.
PACK.E\
BU\Lt>£R.
~
~
\C
\C
=-.
tJ:l
=!l
~
~
PR.lCE
-...1
?~C.KET'S
~
ASSEMBLE.
I
t
T\ME
tit
/
~
I
:. '_JSAT
I
.&;;;...
FIG.S
~
~
~
tit
.&;;;...
="
U.S. Patent
Jan.2, 1996
\ v---~\
)3
C.E'-L
5,481,546
Sheet 4 of 7
a~se
~T"1'\0W
4Sb
TX.q
Rx.-l
T~
MODEM
\
v
2l
R)(.su
vv12'
RECE\VER
~'(NC.
c.e:LL '3 seLEC..T5 Se-:=,\
ID (:t:t>A) ANO RE~"lS
t=R.E:Q.. OP SE5'T R~
R,.ec.e &Ve.s lW.FO o\IER
5USSC.~\8E12.
CELL "I..O
-
l.f 2.1.
~R..
1,5'3
1-
Rx. .a.
4
Tu~es T)C.. -ro se~T 'R.R.
FR.e.~ o:,\,6..~\ 'P~S~ \No ~\TS
Re:cel\JE"::. oN
~
/t-.~0
R.EC.E\Ves S.U8SC.R.\SI.;RS
TRAWS.M\S~\oW OW .Rx.~u
PA.5Se'5 @.l T 0\\l "TO C.e..L. 3
~4
ow. TX.a.
TR.A.NSM IT
"I.O
r---
FIG.6A
RJ:Mo\E..
BROAt>CAST
~
UN\T
"I.OA
MODeM /"-' Q'J.
..f-a
-
o~
/V
REMOTE
R.ec.E\VER
v
\
R')la'
HO~E
P~SS~
R..~a\
v11
QlT ON
TO 486
f3
4SC.
se"O'S 1+L~NK
PU.OC.e~S e,\IS
UP TO 1"\-lE. \/'::>~\
J
FIG. 6B
U.S. Patent
Jan.2, 1996
5,481,546
Sheet 5 of 7
-- ---- ----..
---------------~
3
1.0A.
CELL
FIG.7A
C.E.LL
~
0
IDA R.>C..
'IDA. T)(.
FR.AMe \
(!I0.6,..._sec.
~
I
To
(11:1 ,u.-:s""c.
R.ec..e\\IEO
~
l:D~
RESPON-SE.
~ .1 .,.u.. ~e: c.
T, =-To-t IDA
"'A,: L\ Wk.
FIG. 7B
~
FRAME 2. OR. 3
A.T R.R.
r,
l.DP\
Rf=SPON5E
PR.OCE'SS\\.lG7 \\~E.
SE'T\AJ E E\.l
DEL~'(
R.E"'OTE. REC.E \ VER. P.."D CGLL
t%
'L
U.S. Patent
Jan.2, 1996
cc.uA.RD
S~NO
~.N€.\-M
l5.6:2.S' l!S
k.\-\2.
1
Stt.WO
5'(S1'e~
GUto.1Ul
BA.\10
B
15".625 lS'."'lS 15' C.H~\.tN ICi\..5 \5,6'2.5
kHz..
466. IS K.\-l:z..
KHz.
\<.'"''Z.
C.HI".NNEL..~
46.8 .1 5
k\4z.
A
GUNt.l)
a~wo
GUARO
5,481,546
Sheet 6 of 7
:.o
lb
lS"
'l..lB
2..\8.5
Ml-tz.
\oi\H2.
FIG.SA
5'(~TE:M
'
2.
3
4
5
6
7
A.
2.\8,0~125
':.'l~TElJ\
MHz.
2lS.Oo'1.5'
2\8.09375
~.us. \2.5'
2.lS .15625'
1.1S.5b'2.5"
'~
2.18.6'25'
2.18. 6!5"61...5
9
2.\~.
10
II
2..\S."~l 1S
242S
2\8. 34"375
2b
l1.
2.1S. ~/5'
~~
2\8.40625
2\B.4'3"15
'2.18.4-bS?S
21
28
\S
2.lf>.5C3'31S
2.0
21
2!2.
a
\4-
2\6.5'3\25 MH'Z.
lb
\I
IS.
2.\8.1t!>15
21S. 2..\SIS
218..25
2.Bl'25
8
23
~\f>.bB1S
21B. 75BIS
2te,. 75
218. 78l1.5
2\B.S\25"
1JB. B437S
2.\8.815
2.1e. 90b'25
2~
2\B.C:.~I5
30
'2.1B.'9bB,S"
FIG.SB
U.S. Patent
\!Z.--
41
2.18 MH1..
5,481,546
Sheet 7 of 7
Jan.2, 1996
I~ \R~W5C.E.I\IER~--------~
5\
50
\NPU\
R.EG\ C:.\E.Q.
t=ruaGt UE.~C.'(
L...--..~
51
OUTPUT
Rl:G\STER.
F\·"'EO
VAQ.IABLE
C..ONTR.OL
SOFTVJ/!A.RE C.ON1'l
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?