Anascape, Ltd v. Microsoft Corp. et al

Filing 311

ORDER on Anascape's supplemental objections to Dfts' deposition designations. Signed by Judge Ron Clark on 5/2/0. (djh, )

Anascape, Ltd v. Microsoft Corp. et al

Doc. 311

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS LUFKIN DIVISION ANASCAPE, LTD., PLAINTIFF, V. MICROSOFT CORP., AND NINTENDO OF AMERICA, INC., DEFENDANTS. ORDER ON PLAINTIFF ANASCAPE, LTD.'S SUPPLEMENTAL OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANTS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS I. Anascape's Supplemental Objections to Defendants' Deposition Designations: Brian Carlson, 10/4/07 6:11-6:14 8:14-10:11 14:9-16 15:6-20 16:9-12 16:21-18:2 28:14-29:4 29:5-7 30:14-30:16 30:17-31:2 31:3-31:13 31:14-24 37:9-37:16 38:16-39:8 60:4-60:15 61:6-61:13 62:6-63:11 63:15-64:7 66:24-67:11 68:12-19 68:20-69:22 69:23-70:4 These exhibits are objectionable under Rule 403, as Armstrong's access to the GameCube controller at the time period when he was prosecuting the `700 Patent does not substantially support Nintendo's priority date argument, and encourages the jury to determine the priority date issue on inapposite facts. Overruled. The first reference (6:11 ­ 6: 14 is the name of the witness. The court is not going to plow through multifarious objections looking for a good one. CIVIL ACTION NO. 9:06-CV-158-RC

These exhibits are objectionable under Rule Overruled. See above. 403, as Armstrong's access to the GameCube controller at the time period when he was prosecuting the `700 Patent does not substantially support Nintendo's priority date argument, and encourages the jury to determine the priority date issue on inapposite facts. 1
Dockets.Justia.com

75:22-76:5 76:16-76:21 77:17-78:10 85:12-85:21 88:8-90:16 90:16-25 91:9-91:25 93:8-93:11 93:12-14 93:15-93:18 93:19-23 93:24-94:12 95:7-95:13 95:14-96:6 96:7-96:14 97:8-97:20 98:10-98:16 98:17-99:7 99:8-99:12 101:16-102:4 102:5-103:12 104:13-104:20 105:17-106:1 106:8-107:2 107:14-23 127:19-129:1 129:2-129:19 130:1-133:7

So ORDERED and SIGNED this 2 day of May, 2008.

___________________________________ Ron Clark, United States District Judge

2