Warner Seeds, Inc. et al v. Total Quality Logistics, Inc. et al
Filing
34
MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER:...Plaintiffs' recovery therefore, will be $76,005.00 in liquidated damages, plus $16,005.06 in attorney's fees through the date of judgment, plus $48,261.89 for judgment on the TQL assignment,les s, because of the application of the one satisfaction rule, the $25,000.00 already received from TQL in cash and waiver of invoice payments and the $48,261.89 for the judgment assigned. Judgment will be entered for Plaintiffs for $67,0 10.06, plus taxable costs. Judgment will not be entered for TQL because recovery upon TQL's defaulted causes of action against cross-defendants Mellor and M&M Trucking were assigned to Plaintiffs and are included in the calculation of Plaintiffs' total recovery. See Order for further specifics. (Ordered by Judge Mary Lou Robinson on 9/12/2011) (egb)
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
AMARILLO DIVISION
WARNER SEEDS,INC. and KELLY
GREEN MEXICANA" INC."
$
s
$
PLAINTIFFS,
VS.
KELLY SUE MELLOR, ,Individually, and
dlblaM&M TRUCKING & EXCAVATION,
LLC,
CNIL ACTION CAUSE NUMBER
DEFENDANTS,
2:1O-CV-110-J
and
TOTAL QUALITY LOGISTICS, INC. and
TOTAL QUALITY LOGISTICS, LLC,
DEFENDANTS and
CROSS-PLAINTIFFS.
KELLY SUE MELLOR, ,Individually, and
dlblaM&M TRUCKING & EXCAVATION,
LLC,
$
$
$
CROSS-DEFENDANTS.
$
MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER, and
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
This case is a breach ofcontract action brought by the seller and buyer ofgoods against the
transport service brokers and carriers who transported goods which were damaged in transport.
Damage done to the goods during transport resulted in a total loss of the value of the goods shipped.
Findings und Conclusions
On August 10, 2011, the Court conducted an evidentiary hearing on liquidated and
unliquidated damages. The following findings of fact and conclusions of law are based upon the
pleadings, testimony, evidence and exhibits introduced and admitted at the evidentiary hearing in this
action, and the Court's rulings from the bench. Any finding of fact constituting in whole or in part
a conclusion of law shall be deemed a conclusion
of law. Any conclusion of law constituting in
whole or in part a finding of fact shall be deemed a finding of fact.
Findings of Fact
Background Facts
Plaintiff Warner Seeds, Inc. was the seller of the goods at issue, which were 1,000 20
kilogram bags of hybrid grain sorghum seeds. Plaintiff Kelly Green Mexicana, Inc. was the buyer
of the seed. Defendants Total Quality Logistics, Inc. and Total Quality Logistics, LLC (TQL), were
brokers of transport services. Defendants Kelly Sue Mellor, Individually and dlblaM&MTrucking
and Excavation, LLC (Mellor) are transportation carriers. Defendants Mike Waters and Kelly Waters
(Waters) were the truck drivers who transported the load
of
seeds from Hereford, Texas, to
Brownsville, Texas.
On or about February 2,2010, Warner Seeds delivered to the Waters and Mellor, as a bailee,
$74,090.00 of its seed inventory. TQL and Mellor agreed and contracted to provide a truck to haul
this load of hybrid grain sorghum seed to Brownsville, Texas for $1,165.00. Waters picked up the
load of seed in Hereford, Texas. Waters informed Mellor that his tarp was ripped and therefore, he
could not tarp the load. Rather than require Waters to obtain a new tarp so that the load could be
properly covered, Mellor told the trucker to proceed anyway without the load being covered. Waters
then signed off on
a
copy of the
bill of lading with no exception, exclusions or riders, after
the hybrid
grain sorghum seed was loaded.
While in the custody, control and possession of the Defendants, their agents or employees,
on or about February 2,2010, Defendants negligently caused the truck to remain uncovered and the
-2-
seed unprotected
duringarainevent. The rain being allowed to fall on and permeate the load of seed
caused the total loss of all of
Plaintiffs'
seed, which seed had been bailed to Defendants. Although
the seed was eventually retumed by Defendants to Plaintiffs (and remains in storage in Brownsville,
Texas), Defendants' failure to cover the seed that was placed into their possession, custody, and
control for delivery resulted in a total loss of the load of seed. The total amount of that seed loss was
$74,090.00. The packaging lost was in the amount of $750.00. The freight cost was in the amount
of $1,165.00.
Defendants TQL engaged Defendants Mellor and
transportation services in order to
M&M Trucking
as its agent to provide
fulfill contractual obligations owed by TQL to Plaintiff Warner
Seed. TQL and Mellor entered into a Broker/Carrier Agreement which provides, in pertinentpart,
that Mellor agreed to indemnifu, hold harmless and defend TQL from and against any and all claims
for loss, damages or injury (including but not limited to reasonable attomey's fee), from and against
any lawsuits, actions, and legal proceedings brought against TQL for or on account of any loss or
damage to the tangible property shipped.
Plaintiffs sued Defendants TQL, Mellor and M&M Trucking for the loss of the property
shipped. The TQL Defendants filed a cross action against Mellor and M&M Trucking based upon
the indemnity agreement.
Procedural Background
This case was removed to this Court from state court. On April 29, 2010, a copy of the
citation and Plaintiffs' original state court petition and requests for disclosure was received by the
Texas Secretary of State and a copy forwarded on May 5, 2010, by certified mail, return receipt
requested to Kelly Sue Mellor, Individually and dlblaM & M Trucking and Excavation LLC in Salt
-3-
Lake City, Utah. The return receipt was received by the Texas Secretary of State's office onMay 12,
2010, bearing the signature of the addressee's agent. The officer's return of service was filed with
the Deaf Smith County District Clerk on May 26,2010.
On August 25,2010, Defendants TQL sent service of process on its cross action against
Defendant Mellor and M&M Trucking to the Texas Secretary of State, which forwarded service by
certified mail, return receipt requested to Kelly Sue Mellor, Individually and dlblaM & M Trucking
and Excavation LLC in Salt Lake City, Utah. The retum receipt was received by the Texas Secretary
of State's office on September 3,2010, bearing the signature of the addressee. The officer's return
of service was filed with this Court on September 15, 2010.
On May 12,2011, pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 4(m) Plaintiffs' causes of
action against Defendants Mike Waters and Kelly Waters were dismissed without prejudice for
failure to timely perfect service of process.
On May
and
17
,2011, Plaintiffs moved for entry of default judgment against Defendants Mellor
M&M Trucking
on both Plaintiffs' direct causes of action and upon the assignment to Plaintiffs
of TQL's cause of action based upon the indemnity agreement. A copy ofthe motion for default was
served upon Defendants Mellor and
M&M Trucking. In that motion, Plaintiffs sought default
judgment for the $74,090 in lost seed, packaging loss in the amount of $750, freight costs in the
amount
of $1,165, $13,568.50 for Plaintiffs' attorney's fees, court costs, and $48,261.89 for
Defendants Total Quality Logistics,Inc. and Total Quality Logistics, LLC's assigned claims, causes
of action and rights of recovery against Defendants Kelly Sue Mellor, Individually and d/b/a M&M
Trucking and Excavation, LLC. The assignment cause of action was detailed in Plaintiffs' motion
for default judgment to include $25,000.00 in settlement payments and credits, plus costs, attorneys
-4-
fees, and expenses of suit. The $25,000 was composed of $22,612 paid in cash by TQL and $2,388
in waiver of payment for TQL invoices to Warner Seeds, Inc. In addition, the $48,261.89 included
522,153 in attorneys' fees paid by TQL and $1,108.89 as its expenses of suit.
Defendant M&M Trucking and Excavation, L.L.C. is not an infant, an incompetent person,
or in military service. Defendant Kelly Sue Mellor is not an infant, an incompetent person, or in
military service.
Neither Defendant Kelly Sue Mellor, individually and/or DIBIA M&M Trucking and
Excavation, L.L.C., nor M&M Trucking and Excavation, L.L.C. frled a responsive pleading or
otherwise defended this
suit. On September
default with the United States District
13, 2010, Plaintiffs filed their request for entry
of
Clerk. On September 14, 2010, the United States District
Clerk entered the Clerk's certificate of default against Mellor. Defendants Kelly Sue Mellor,
individually and dlbla M&M Trucking and Excavation, L.L.C. have defaulted in this action on all
claims and cross claims.
TQL Settlement
On October 22,2010, Plaintiffs entered into a settlement agreement with Defendants Total
Quality Logistics, Inc. and Total Quality Logistics, L.L.C. As
a
result of the mediated settlement
agreement and indemnity provision contained in the parties' Broker/Carrier Agreement, Defendants
Total Quality Logistics, Inc. and Total Quality Logistics, L.L.C. assigned to Plaintiffs all of its
claims, causes of action and rights of recovery Total Quality Logistics, Inc. and Total Quality
Logistics, L.L.C. has against Defendants Kelly Sue Mellor, Individually, and/or dlb/a M&M
Trucking and Excavation, L.L.C. including, but not limited to, the right to recover settlement
payments, costs, attomeys fees and expenses incurred in this action. That assignment is part
of
Plaintiffs' recovery in this case. The amount of settlement payments, attorneys fees, and expenses
incuned inthis actionby Defendants Total QualityLogistics,Inc. and Total Quality Logistics, L.L.C.
is $48,261.89. That amount is composed of: $22,612 paid in cash to Plaintiffs by TQL, $2,388 in
waiver of payments due from Wamer Seeds,Inc.,$22,153 in TQL's attomeys' fees, and $1,108.89
for TQL's expenses of suit.
Conclusions of Law
This Court has jurisdiction over the parties and the subject matter, and venue for this action
properly lies within the Northern District of Texas, Amarillo Division. The city of Hereford, Texas,
is within the Amarillo Division.
The Court may render a default judgment against a party who has not filed a responsive
pleading or otherwise defended the suit. Fed. R. Civ. Pro. 5a
&
55(a)& (b). A default judgment
must not differ in kind from, or exceed in amount, what is demanded in the pleadings. Fed. R. Civ.
Pro. 54@. After an entry of default,
a
plaintiffmay apply for a judgment based on such default either:
(1) by the Clerk if the plaintiff s claim is for a sum certain or a sum that can be made certain by
computationwithan affidavit showingthe amountdue, or(2) bythe Courtforunliquidated damages.
Fed. R. Civ. Pro. 55(b); N.Y. Life Ins. Co. v. Brown, 84 F.3d 137,
I4I
(5th Cir. 1996).
Plaintiffs have pled for and are entitled to relief against Defendants Kelly Sue Mellor,
Individually, and dlbla M&M Trucking and Excavation, L.L.C. because Kelly Sue Mellor,
Individually, and dlblaM&M Trucking and Excavation, L.L.C. failed to transport Plaintiffs' hybrid
grain sorghum seed with
a
tarp pursuant to Plaintiffs' instructions and requirements thereby allowing
rain to fall on and permeate the load of seed causing a total loss of all of Plaintiffs' seed. Plaintiffs
have been damaged in the amount of $74,090.00 for the seed, $1,165.00 for transportation costs,
-6-
$750.00 for packaging loss, plus attorneys fees, and costs of court. The amount of reasonable and
necessary attorney's fees incurred by Plaintiffs in this case through and including the evidentiary
hearing is $16,005.06. Taxable costs will be determined pursuant to a timely filed bill of costs.
Pursuant to the Texas
Civil Practice and Remedies Code, $ 38.001(5) & (8), a person may
recover reasonable attorney's fees from an individual or corporation, in addition to the amount of a
valid claim and costs, if the claim is for lost or damaged freight or an oral or written contract. That
statutory provision for recovery of attorney's fees applies in this case.
However, Texas tort law recognizes a "one satisfaction" rule: "[A]n injured party is entitled
to but one satisfaction for a single injury, so that an amount received in settlement from one alleged
tortfeasor must be applied as a credit reducing the amount to be recovered against other defendants."
Ratner v. Sioux Natural Gas Corp.,719 F.2d 801, 804 (5th Cir. 1983)(citing Gill v. United States,
429
F
.2d 1072,
107 9
(5th Cir.
197
0). "The
purpose of the rule is to ensure that a plaintiff receives
no more than full compensation for his loss." Id. at 804. "The one satisfaction rule applies to
prevent a plaintiff from obtaining more than one recovery for the same injury." Stewart Title Guar.
Co. v. Sterling, 822 S.W.2d 1, 7 (Tex. 1991). Texas "courts have applied the one satisfaction rule
when the defendants commit the same act as well as when defendants commit technically differing
acts which result in a single
injury." Id. (citingAmerican Baler Co. v. SRSSystems, lnc.,748 S.W.2d
243,246 (Tex. App.-Houston IlstDist.] 1988,writ denied)). The one satisfactionrule also applies
inthiscase. Plaintiffs'twocausesofaction-negligenceandbreachofcontract-arebasedonthe
same
wrongful act, the failure to tarp the load to prevent rain from ruining the seed. The Plaintiffs
can not doubly recover for their actual damages caused by the same act.
-7-
Plaintiffs have received in settlement with TQL payment of $25,000.00 in cash and invoice
waivers and the assigned right to judgment for $48,261.89 on TQL's indemnity cause of action in
settlement of their claims against the TQL Defendants. Defendants Mellor and
M&M Trucking
are
entitled to a reduction in those amounts in Plaintiffs' judgment in this case.
Plaintiffs' recovery therefore, will be $76,005.00 in liquidated damages, plus $16,005.06 in
attorney's fees through the date ofjudgment, plus $48,261.89 for judgment on the TQL assignment,
less, because of the application of the one satisfaction rule, the $25,000.00 already received from
TQL in cash and waiver of invoice payments and the $48,261.89 for the judgment
assigned.
Judgment will be entered for Plaintiffs for $67,010.06, plus taxable costs./l
Judgment
will not be entered for TQL
because recovery upon
TQI,'s defaulted causes of
action against cross-defendants Mellor and M&M Trucking were assigned to Plaintiffs and are
included in the calculation of Plaintiffs' total recovery.
The judgment
will
be a final judgment on the causes of action asserted by Plaintiffs in their
original complaint, and a final judgment on the cross-action which TQL filed against Mellor and
M&M Trucking
and which was later assigned to
plaintiffs.
It is SO ORDERED.
Signed this
the
A4ray
of Septemb er, 20rt.
Mary
'
Although Plaintiffs have in effect recovered twice for the $25,000 received in cash and
waived invoices - once in payment on their causes of action for actual damages and again as part of the
cause of action assigned in the settlement of TQL's causes of action the Plaintiffs' judgment entered
here will permit full satisfaction for their loss, plus attorney's fees, but will permit only one satisfaction
in accordance with Texas law.
-8-
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?