Thorson v. Aviall Services Inc et al
Filing
55
Redacted, public version of 51 MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER granting in part and denying in part Aviall's Motion to Dismiss. (Ordered by Judge Sidney A Fitzwater on 1/24/2017) (Judge Sidney A Fitzwater) (Main Document 55 replaced on 1/24/2017) (twd).
<![CDATA[
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 1 of 37 PageID 361
,1 7+( 81,7(' 67$7(6 ',675,&7 &2857
)25 7+( 1257+(51 ',675,&7 2) 7(;$6
'$//$6 ',9,6,21
5$&+(/ % 7+25621
3ODLQWLII
96
$9,$// 6(59,&(6 ,1& HW DO
'HIHQGDQWV
&LYLO $FWLRQ 1R &9'
*This memorandum opinion and order was filed under
VHDO RQ -DQXDU\ 7KH FRXUW KDV JUDQWHG WKH
SDUWLHV
MRLQW UHTXHVW WKDW WKLV UHGDFWHG YHUVLRQ EH
SXEOLFO\ ILOHG
0(025$1'80 23,1,21
$1' 25'(5
,Q WKLV DFWLRQ DULVLQJ IURP GHIHQGDQWV¶ DOOHJHG EUHDFK RI D VHYHUDQFH DJUHHPHQW WKH
FRXUW PXVW GHFLGH ZKHWKHU (5,6$ FRPSOHWHO\ SUHHPSWV SODLQWLII¶V VWDWHODZ EUHDFK RI
FRQWUDFW FODLP &RQFOXGLQJ WKDW LW GRHV QRW EXW WKDW SODLQWLII¶V FRPSODLQW LV GHILFLHQW LQ RWKHU
UHVSHFWV WKH FRXUW JUDQWV LQ SDUW DQG GHQLHV LQ SDUW GHIHQGDQW $YLDOO 6HUYLFHV ,QF¶V
³$YLDOO¶V´ )HG 5 &LY 3 E PRWLRQ WR GLVPLVV IRU IDLOXUH WR VWDWH D FODLP
,
'RQ 7KRUVRQ ³'RQ´ DQ HPSOR\HH RI GHIHQGDQW $YLDOO ZDV ODLG RII LQ $XJXVW
DV SDUW RI D FRUSRUDWH UHVWUXFWXULQJ 'RQ GLHG DIWHU ILOLQJ WKLV ODZVXLW DQG 5DFKHO %
7KH (PSOR\HH 5HWLUHPHQW ,QFRPH 6HFXULW\ $FW RI 86&
,Q GHFLGLQJ $YLDOO¶V 5XOH E PRWLRQ WKH FRXUW FRQVWUXHV WKH FRPSODLQW LQ WKH
OLJKW PRVW IDYRUDEOH WR SODLQWLII DFFHSWV DV WUXH DOO ZHOOSOHDGHG IDFWXDO DOOHJDWLRQV DQG
GUDZV DOO UHDVRQDEOH LQIHUHQFHV LQ KHU IDYRU See, e.g., Lovick v. Ritemoney Ltd. )G
WK &LU ³7KH FRXUW¶V UHYLHZ >RI D 5XOH E PRWLRQ@ LV OLPLWHG WR WKH
FRPSODLQW DQ\ GRFXPHQWV DWWDFKHG WR WKH FRPSODLQW DQG DQ\ GRFXPHQWV DWWDFKHG WR WKH
PRWLRQ WR GLVPLVV WKDW DUH FHQWUDO WR WKH FODLP DQG UHIHUHQFHG E\ WKH FRPSODLQW´ Lone Star
Fund V (U.S.), L.P. v. Barclays Bank PLC )G WK &LU
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 2 of 37 PageID 362
7KRUVRQ ³5DFKHO´ KLV PRWKHU ZDV VXEVWLWXWHG DV WKH SODLQWLII XQGHU 5XOH D
'RQ DQG $YLDOO HQWHUHG LQWR D ZULWWHQ ³6HYHUDQFH $JUHHPHQW DQG 5HOHDVH´
³$JUHHPHQW´ XQGHU ZKLFK 'RQ ZDV WR FRQWLQXH WR UHFHLYH KLV EDVH VDODU\ DV VHYHUDQFH SD\
XQWLO 0DUFK 7KH $JUHHPHQW LQFRUSRUDWHG WKH GHILQLWLRQV IURP WKH $YLDOO ,QF
6HYHUDQFH 3D\ 3ODQ IRU ([HPSW (PSOR\HHV ³6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ´ DQG VWDWHG WKDW LW ZDV DQ
DJUHHPHQW ³IRU WKH EHQHILWV SD\DEOH WR >'RQ@ IURP WKH >6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ@´ &RPSO ([ $ DW
5HJDUGLQJ PHGLFDO GHQWDO DQG YLVLRQ EHQHILWV WKH $JUHHPHQW SURYLGHG
&RPSO ([ $ DW
7KH FRPSODLQW DOOHJHV WKDW DOWKRXJK 'RQ EHOLHYHG KLV PHGLFDO EHQHILWV ZHUH WR
FRQWLQXH XQWLO 0DUFK KH ODWHU OHDUQHG WKDW $YLDOO KDG WHUPLQDWHG WKHVH EHQHILWV LQ
1RYHPEHU 2Q )HEUXDU\ 'RQ ZURWH D OHWWHU WR $YLDOO¶V 9LFH 3UHVLGHQW RI
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 3 of 37 PageID 363
+XPDQ 5HVRXUFHV GHPDQGLQJ WKDW KLV KHDOWK LQVXUDQFH EH UHLQVWDWHG $IWHU UHFHLYLQJ 'RQ¶V
OHWWHU $YLDOO DJUHHG WR UHLQVWDWH 'RQ¶V LQVXUDQFH IRU DQ DGGLWLRQDO IRXU PRQWKV ZKLFK ZRXOG
KDYH FRQWLQXHG 'RQ¶V LQVXUDQFH FRYHUDJH WKURXJK -XO\ $YLDOO RQO\ H[WHQGHG WKH
UHLQVWDWHG FRYHUDJH KRZHYHU WKURXJK 0DUFK
2Q 0DUFK $YLDOO VHQW 'RQ D ³ &2%5$ %HQHILW (OHFWLRQ )RUP´ E\
HPDLO DQG VWDWHG WKDW RQFH LW UHFHLYHG WKH FRPSOHWHG IRUP LW ZRXOG FRQWDFW GHIHQGDQW
&RQH[LV %HQHILWV $GPLQLVWUDWRUV /3 ³&RQH[LV´ ZKLFK VHUYHG DV $YLDOO¶V &2%5$
DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ SDUWQHU DQG &RQH[LV ZRXOG JHQHUDWH D &2%5$ HOHFWLRQ IRUP IRU 'RQ WR
FRPSOHWH 'RQ VLJQHG DQG UHWXUQHG WKH IRUP WR $YLDOO 3ODLQWLII DOOHJHV WKDW 'RQ QHYHU
UHFHLYHG DQ\ DGGLWLRQDO &2%5$ IRUPV IURP $YLDOO RU &RQH[LV
2Q -XO\ 'RQ¶V ZLIH 0DULHYD ZDV GLDJQRVHG ZLWK VWDJH FRORQ FDQFHU 'RQ
OHDUQHG RQ WKDW VDPH GDWH WKDW $YLDOO KDG WHUPLQDWHG KLV IDPLO\ FRYHUDJH RQ 0DUFK
LQVWHDG RI H[WHQGLQJ LW DV DJUHHG WR PDNH XS IRU WKH SHULRGV SULRU WR 0DUFK ZKHQ
'RQ ZDV DOOHJHGO\ HQWLWOHG WR FRYHUDJH EXW KDG QRQH 0DULHYD GLHG LQ $XJXVW
'RQ EURXJKW WKH LQVWDQW ODZVXLW DJDLQVW GHIHQGDQWV $YLDOO DQG &RQH[LV DOOHJLQJ WKDW
$YLDOO EUHDFKHG WKH $JUHHPHQW E\ IDLOLQJ WR SURYLGH KLP WKH KHDOWK FDUH FRYHUDJH VSHFLILHG
WKHUHLQ IURP 1RYHPEHU XQWLO WKH ILUVW RU VHFRQG ZHHN RI 0DUFK +H DOVR DOOHJHG
WKDW $YLDOO DQG &RQH[LV EUHDFKHG WKH SDUWLHV¶ VXEVHTXHQW FRQWUDFW WR UHLQVWDWH DQG H[WHQG KLV
KHDOWKFDUH FRYHUDJH IURP 0DUFK WKURXJK -XO\ WR PDNH XS IRU WKH ODSVHG
SHULRG 'RQ DOVR EURXJKW D FODLP XQGHU (5,6$ DOOHJLQJ WKDW GHIHQGDQWV IDLOHG WR JLYH KLP
WLPHO\ SURSHU QRWLFH RI KLV ULJKW WR H[WHQG KHDOWK FDUH FRYHUDJH DIWHU 0DUFK DQG
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 4 of 37 PageID 364
WKDW GHIHQGDQWV IDLOHG WR DFW XSRQ KLV HOHFWLRQ WR VHFXUH VXFK FRYHUDJH
$YLDOO PRYHG WR GLVPLVV 'RQ¶V FRPSODLQW FRQWHQGLQJ WKDW KLV EUHDFK RI FRQWUDFW FODLP
LV FRPSOHWHO\ SUHHPSWHG E\ (5,6$ WKDW FHUWDLQ RI WKH GDPDJHV KH VHHNV LQ FRQQHFWLRQ ZLWK
KLV FRQWUDFW FODLP DUH XQDYDLODEOH XQGHU (5,6$ DQG WKDW KH IDLOHG WR SODXVLEO\ DOOHJH DQ
(5,6$ FODLP 6KRUWO\ DIWHU $YLDOO ILOHG WKH PRWLRQ 'RQ GLHG 7KH FRXUW VWDWLVWLFDOO\
WHUPLQDWHG WKH PRWLRQ WR GLVPLVV VR WKDW D 5XOH D PRWLRQ WR VXEVWLWXWH FRXOG EH ILOHG
7KH FRXUW ODWHU JUDQWHG 5DFKHO¶V PRWLRQ WR EH VXEVWLWXWHG DV SODLQWLII LQ KHU FDSDFLW\ DV
,QGHSHQGHQW $GPLQLVWUDWRU RI 'RQ¶V HVWDWH DQG LW UHDFWLYDWHG $YLDOO¶V PRWLRQ WR GLVPLVV
7KH PRWLRQ KDV EHHQ EULHIHG DQG LV ULSH IRU GHFLVLRQ
,,
8QGHU 5XOH E WKH FRXUW HYDOXDWHV WKH SOHDGLQJV E\ ³DFFHSW>LQJ@ µDOO
ZHOOSOHDGHG IDFWV DV WUXH YLHZLQJ WKHP LQ WKH OLJKW PRVW IDYRUDEOH WR WKH SODLQWLII¶´ In re
Katrina Canal Breaches Litig )G WK &LU TXRWLQJ Martin K. Eby
Constr. Co. v. Dall. Area Rapid Transit )G WK &LU 7R VXUYLYH
GHIHQGDQW¶V PRWLRQ WR GLVPLVV SODLQWLII PXVW DOOHJH HQRXJK IDFWV ³WR VWDWH D FODLP WR UHOLHI
WKDW LV SODXVLEOH RQ LWV IDFH´ Bell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly 86 ³$
FODLP KDV IDFLDO SODXVLELOLW\ ZKHQ WKH SODLQWLII SOHDGV IDFWXDO FRQWHQW WKDW DOORZV WKH FRXUW WR
GUDZ WKH UHDVRQDEOH LQIHUHQFH WKDW WKH GHIHQGDQW>V@ >DUH@ OLDEOH IRU WKH PLVFRQGXFW DOOHJHG´
Ashcroft v. Iqbal 86 ³7KH SODXVLELOLW\ VWDQGDUG LV QRW DNLQ WR D
µSUREDELOLW\ UHTXLUHPHQW¶ EXW LW DVNV IRU PRUH WKDQ D VKHHU SRVVLELOLW\ WKDW D GHIHQGDQW KDV
DFWHG XQODZIXOO\´ Id see also Twombly 86 DW ³)DFWXDO DOOHJDWLRQV PXVW EH
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 5 of 37 PageID 365
HQRXJK WR UDLVH D ULJKW WR UHOLHI DERYH WKH VSHFXODWLYH OHYHO>@´ ³>:@KHUH WKH ZHOOSOHDGHG
IDFWV GR QRW SHUPLW WKH FRXUW WR LQIHU PRUH WKDQ WKH PHUH SRVVLELOLW\ RI PLVFRQGXFW WKH
FRPSODLQW KDV DOOHJHG²EXW LW KDV QRW µVKRZ>Q@¶²µWKDW WKH SOHDGHU LV HQWLWOHG WR UHOLHI¶´
Iqbal 86 DW TXRWLQJ 5XOH D )XUWKHUPRUH XQGHU 5XOH D D SOHDGLQJ
PXVW FRQWDLQ ³D VKRUW DQG SODLQ VWDWHPHQW RI WKH FODLP VKRZLQJ WKDW WKH SOHDGHU LV HQWLWOHG WR
UHOLHI´ $OWKRXJK ³WKH SOHDGLQJ VWDQGDUG 5XOH DQQRXQFHV GRHV QRW UHTXLUH µGHWDLOHG IDFWXDO
DOOHJDWLRQV¶´ LW GHPDQGV PRUH WKDQ ³µODEHOV DQG FRQFOXVLRQV¶´ Iqbal 86 DW
TXRWLQJ Twombly 86 DW $QG ³µD IRUPXODLF UHFLWDWLRQ RI WKH HOHPHQWV RI D FDXVH
RI DFWLRQ ZLOO QRW GR¶´ Id TXRWLQJ Twombly 86 DW
,,,
$YLDOO PDLQWDLQV WKDW WKH $JUHHPHQW DQG WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ DUH JRYHUQHG E\ (5,6$
DQG WKDW DFFRUGLQJO\ SODLQWLII¶V VWDWHODZ EUHDFK RI FRQWUDFW FODLP LV FRPSOHWHO\ SUHHPSWHG
7R GHFLGH ZKHWKHU WKH VWDWHODZ EUHDFK RI FRQWUDFW FODLP LV SUHHPSWHG WKH FRXUW PXVW ILUVW
GHWHUPLQH ZKHWKHU WKH $JUHHPHQW RU WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ²RU ERWK DV $YLDOO PDLQWDLQV²LV
DQ (5,6$ HPSOR\HH ZHOIDUH EHQHILW SODQ See, e.g., Meyers v. Tex. Health Res :/
DW
1' 7H[ 1RY )LW]ZDWHU &- ,Q GRLQJ VR WKH FRXUW IROORZV D
³WKUHHIDFWRU WHVW´ DVNLQJ ZKHWKHU ³ WKH SODQ H[LVWV WKH SODQ IDOOV ZLWKLQ WKH
VDIHKDUERU SURYLVLRQ HVWDEOLVKHG E\ WKH 'HSDUWPHQW RI /DERU DQG WKH HPSOR\HU
HVWDEOLVKHG RU PDLQWDLQHG WKH SODQ ZLWK WKH LQWHQW WR EHQHILW HPSOR\HHV´ Peace v. Am. Gen.
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 6 of 37 PageID 366
Life Ins. Co. )G WK &LU :KHWKHU D SODQ H[LVWV LV D ³IDFWVSHFLILF´
LQTXLU\ Cantrell v. Briggs & Veselka Co. )G WK &LU
,Q LWV VHPLQDO GHFLVLRQ VHWWLQJ RXW WKH UHTXLUHPHQWV IRU WKH H[LVWHQFH RI DQ (5,6$
SODQ WKH 6XSUHPH &RXUW KHOG LQ Fort Halifax Packing Co. v. Coyne 86 WKDW
WR FRQVWLWXWH DQ (5,6$ SODQ D SURJUDP PXVW QHFHVVLWDWH WKH H[LVWHQFH RI ³DQ RQJRLQJ
DGPLQLVWUDWLYH SURJUDP WR PHHW WKH HPSOR\HU¶V REOLJDWLRQ´ Id. DW see also Gomez v.
Ericsson, Inc. )G WK &LU ³,W LV WKXV WKH H[LVWHQFH RU QRQH[LVWHQFH
RI DQ µRQJRLQJ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH SURJUDP¶ WKDW LV WKH NH\ GHWHUPLQDQW RI ZKHWKHU VHYHUDQFH
SODQV DUH JRYHUQHG E\ (5,6$´ FLWDWLRQV RPLWWHG ,Q FRQWUDVW D SURJUDP ZLOO QRW EH DQ
(5,6$ SODQ ZKHUH LW LQYROYHV D ³RQHWLPH OXPSVXP SD\PHQW WULJJHUHG E\ D VLQJOH HYHQW
>WKDW@ UHTXLUHV QR DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH ZKDWVRHYHU´ Fort Halifax 86 DW
³>'@HWHUPLQLQJ WKH HOLJLELOLW\ RI FODLPDQWV FDOFXODWLQJ EHQHILW OHYHOV PDNLQJ GLVEXUVHPHQWV
PRQLWRULQJ WKH DYDLODELOLW\ RI IXQGV IRU EHQHILW SD\PHQWV DQG NHHSLQJ DSSURSULDWH UHFRUGV
LQ RUGHU WR FRPSO\ ZLWK DSSOLFDEOH UHSRUWLQJ UHTXLUHPHQWV´ DUH DOO HYLGHQFH RI DQ
DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH Id. DW $V WKH )LIWK &LUFXLW KDV H[SODLQHG
>H@YHQ IRU SODQV WKDW UHVXOW LQ RQO\ D OXPSVXP SD\PHQW WKDW
DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH FDQ EH IRXQG LQ D QXPEHU RI RWKHU
IHDWXUHV that require discretion WKH HOLJLELOLW\ GHWHUPLQDWLRQ
FDOFXODWLRQV RI WKH SD\PHQW DPRXQW VXFK DV GHGXFWLRQV DQG
GHWDLOHG IRUPXODV WKH SURYLVLRQ RI DGGLWLRQDO VHUYLFHV EH\RQG
WKH VHYHUDQFH SD\PHQW VXFK DV LQVXUDQFH DQG WKH
HVWDEOLVKPHQW RI SURFHGXUHV IRU KDQGOLQJ FODLPV DQG DSSHDOV
7KH SDUWLHV GR QRW GLVSXWH WKDW WKH VHFRQG DQG WKLUG IDFWRUV DUH VDWLVILHG
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 7 of 37 PageID 367
Gomez )G DW HPSKDVLV DGGHG FLWLQJ FDVHV
,9
,W LV XQGLVSXWHG WKDW WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ FRQVWLWXWHV DQ (5,6$ SODQ $YLDOO DGRSWHG
WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ LQ
'
$SS $OWKRXJK WKH FRXUW FDQQRW GHWHUPLQH IURP WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ GRFXPHQWV KRZ
PDQ\ $YLDOO HPSOR\HHV DUH FRYHUHG LW LV FOHDU WKDW WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ LV RQJRLQJ DQG FRYHUV
PXOWLSOH HPSOR\HHV See Gomez )G DW FRQFOXGLQJ SODQ ZDV DQ (5,6$ SODQ
ZKHUH inter alia ³>W@KH 3ODQV >ZHUH@ RQJRLQJ RQ D ODUJH VFDOH´ 0RUHRYHU DOWKRXJK DQ
HQWLWOHPHQW WR EHQHILWV XQGHU WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ LV WULJJHUHG E\ D VLQJOH HYHQW DQ HPSOR\HH¶V
WHUPLQDWLRQ ³WKDW HYHQW ZRXOG RFFXU PRUH WKDQ RQFH DW D GLIIHUHQW WLPH IRU HDFK HPSOR\HH´
Tinoco v. Marine Chartering Co. )G WK &LU FLWDWLRQ RPLWWHG 7KXV
HYHQ LI RQO\ D VPDOO SHUFHQWDJH RI FRYHUHG HPSOR\HHV TXDOLILHG IRU VHYHUDQFH DW VRPH SRLQW
LQ WKHLU FDUHHUV WKLV ZRXOG VWLOO UHVXOW LQ QXPHURXV GLIIHUHQW HYHQWV WKDW WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ
ZRXOG KDYH WR DGPLQLVWHU LQFOXGLQJ WKH FDOFXODWLRQ RI EHQHILWV IRU HDFK HOLJLEOH HPSOR\HH
See Gomez )G DW
$YLDOO VXEVHTXHQWO\ DPHQGHG WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ LQ DQG DJDLQ LQ
7KH WHUP ³(OLJLEOH (PSOR\HH´ LV EURDGO\ GHILQHG WR LQFOXGH $YLDOO¶V
' $SS
)RU H[DPSOH DOWKRXJK WKH DPRXQW RI VHYHUDQFH SD\ ZLOO RQO\ KDYH WR EH FDOFXODWHG
RQH WLPH IRU HDFK HOLJLEOH HPSOR\HH ³6HYHUDQFH 3D\´ LV WR EH FDOFXODWHG XVLQJ WKH
HPSOR\HH¶V EDVH SD\ PXOWLSOLHG E\ D FHUWDLQ VHW QXPEHU RI ZHHNV ZKLFK YDULHV DFFRUGLQJ
WR WKH HPSOR\HH¶V MRE FODVVLILFDWLRQ DQG ZKHWKHU WKH WHUPLQDWLRQ RI HPSOR\PHQW RFFXUV SULRU
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 8 of 37 PageID 368
7KH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ DOVR UHTXLUHV WKH DGPLQLVWUDWRU WR H[HUFLVH D JUHDW GHDO RI
GLVFUHWLRQ 7KH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ SURYLGHV WKDW
' $SS
%XW QRW HYHU\ WHUPLQDWLRQ RI HPSOR\PHQW UHVXOWV LQ WKH SD\PHQW RI VHYHUDQFH SD\ 7KH
6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ GHILQHV ³7HUPLQDWLRQ RI (PSOR\PHQW´ WR PHDQ
' $SS HPSKDVLV
DGGHG DQG GHILQHV ³&DXVH´ WR LQFOXGH HLJKW GLIIHUHQW UHDVRQV IRU GLVFKDUJH )XUWKHU WKH
WR D FKDQJH RI FRQWURO RU ZKHWKHU WKH WHUPLQDWLRQ RI HPSOR\PHQW RFFXUV RQ RU ZLWKLQ RQH
\HDU DIWHU D FKDQJH RI FRQWURO 7KLV FDOFXODWLRQ ZLOO EH GLIIHUHQW IRU HDFK HOLJLEOH HPSOR\HH
XQGHU WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ
7KH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ GHILQHV ³&DXVH´ WR PHDQ
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 9 of 37 PageID 369
6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ VWDWHV WKDW WKH (PSOR\HH %HQHILWV 3ODQ &RPPLWWHH RI %RHLQJ ³&RPPLWWHH´
ZKLFK LV GHVLJQDWHG DV LWV DGPLQLVWUDWRU ³
Id. DW HPSKDVLV DGGHG $FFRUGLQJO\ VLPLODU WR RWKHU
SODQV KHOG WR EH FRYHUHG XQGHU (5,6$ WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ UHTXLUHV LWV DGPLQLVWUDWRU WR
GHWHUPLQH LQ LWV VROH GLVFUHWLRQ ZKHWKHU DQ HPSOR\HH¶V WHUPLQDWLRQ ZDV IRU ³FDXVH´ See,
e.g., Gomez )G DW KROGLQJ WKDW SODQ ZDV (5,6$ SODQ ZKHUH $GPLQLVWUDWRU KDG
³WR H[HUFLVH D JUHDW GHDO RI GLVFUHWLRQ´ ZKLFK LQFOXGHG ³GHWHUPLQ>LQJ@ ZKHWKHU D µJRRG
UHDVRQ¶ H[LVW>HG@ WKDW TXDOLIL>HG@ DQ HPSOR\HH¶V YROXQWDU\ WHUPLQDWLRQ´ Clayton v.
ConocoPhillips Co. )G WK &LU KROGLQJ WKDW GHIHQGDQW ³VKRZ>HG@
WKDW µDQ RQJRLQJ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH SURJUDP¶ >ZDV@ QHFHVVDU\ EHFDXVH RI WKH LQVWDQW 7UXVWHH¶V
FODLPV HOLJLELOLW\ GLVFUHWLRQ´ FLWDWLRQ RPLWWHG
' $SS
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 10 of 37 PageID 370
7KH &RPPLWWHH DV 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ DGPLQLVWUDWRU DOVR KDV
' $SS 7KHVH SRZHUV LQFOXGH ³
Id. ,Q DGGLWLRQ
Id.
$OO RI WKHVH UHVSRQVLELOLWLHV LQGLFDWH DQ RQJRLQJ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH
$FFRUGLQJO\ WKH FRXUW KROGV WKDW WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ LV DQ (5,6$ HPSOR\HH ZHOIDUH SODQ
9
+DYLQJ GHWHUPLQHG WKDW WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ LV JRYHUQHG E\ (5,6$ WKH FRXUW QH[W
FRQVLGHUV ZKHWKHU DV $YLDOO FRQWHQGV WKH Agreement LV DQ (5,6$ SODQ RU LV LQVWHDG PHUHO\
DQ HPSOR\PHQW FRQWUDFW JRYHUQHG E\ VWDWH ODZ
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 11 of 37 PageID 371
$
$YLDOO FRQWHQGV WKDW WKH $JUHHPHQW LV DQ (5,6$ SODQ EHFDXVH LW VHWV IRUWK WKH
GHVFULSWLRQV RI EHQHILWV WKH FODVVHV RI EHQHILFLDULHV LH 'RQ DQG KLV HOLJLEOH GHSHQGHQWV
WKH VRXUFHV RI ILQDQFLQJ LH 'RQ DQG $YLDOO DQG WKH SURFHGXUHV IRU UHFHLYLQJ EHQHILWV ,W
QH[W PDLQWDLQV WKDW WKH WHUPV RI WKH $JUHHPHQW ZHUH FOHDUO\ WDNHQ IURP RQH RI WKH VL[
WHPSODWHV DWWDFKHG WR WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ GRFXPHQW ZLWK $YLDOO¶V XVLQJ WKH WHPSODWH
DSSOLFDEOH WR DQ HPSOR\HH ZKR ZDV RYHU \HDUV ROG DQG QRW VXEMHFW WR D QRQFRPSHWH
DJUHHPHQW DQG WKDW WKH $JUHHPHQW DQG 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ PXVW WKXV EH UHDG WRJHWKHU )LQDOO\
$YLDOO OLVWV WKH YDULRXV DGPLQLVWUDWLYH UHVSRQVLELOLWLHV WKDW WKH $JUHHPHQW LPSRVHV RQ $YLDOO
DQG FRQWHQGV WKDW WKHVH DGPLQLVWUDWLYH UHVSRQVLELOLWLHV IDU H[FHHG WKH RQHWLPH OXPSVXP
VHYHUDQFH SD\PHQW DW LVVXH LQ Fort Halifax DQG GHPRQVWUDWH VXIILFLHQW DGPLQLVWUDWLYH DFWLYLW\
IRU (5,6$ WR DSSO\
3ODLQWLII UHVSRQGV WKDW WKH $JUHHPHQW ZKLFK UHTXLUHV $YLDOO WR FDOFXODWH DQG SD\ WKH
VDPH SRUWLRQ RI 'RQ¶V &2%5$ SUHPLXP WKDW LW SDLG IRU VLPLODUO\ VLWXDWHG HPSOR\HHV GRHV
QRW LQYROYH WKH QHHG IRU DQ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH WKDW QR GLVFUHWLRQDU\ GHFLVLRQV DUH QHHGHG
WR SD\ D SUHFDOFXODWHG DPRXQW WRZDUG 'RQ¶V &2%5$ SUHPLXPV VR QR DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ LV
UHTXLUHG WKDW WKH IDFWV LQ WKLV FDVH VKRZ WKDW WKHUH ZDV no DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ RI WKH SODQ DV
HYLGHQFHG E\ WKH IDFW WKDW ³WKH FDUULHU VKRZV 3ODLQWLII ZDV FRYHUHG WKURXJKRXW WKH VHYHUDQFH
SHULRG VR SUHPLXPV PXVW KDYH EHHQ SDLG DQG WKH GHQLDO RI EHQHILWV WR SODLQWLII DQG KLV
IDPLO\ ZDV FRPSOHWHO\ XQMXVWLILHG´ 3 %U DW DQG WKDW WKH $JUHHPHQW¶V VWDWHPHQW WKDW LW
LV WR EH JRYHUQHG DQG FRQVWUXHG E\ 7H[DV 6WDWH /DZ LV LQFRQVLVWHQW ZLWK (5,6$ SUHHPSWLRQ
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 12 of 37 PageID 372
$YLDOO UHSOLHV inter alia WKDW SDUWLHV WR D VHYHUDQFH DJUHHPHQW FDQQRW FKRRVH VWDWH ODZ
WR SUHHPSW WKH DSSOLFDELOLW\ RI (5,6$ DQG WKDW FRQVLGHULQJ (5,6$¶V SUHHPSWLYH VZHHS 'RQ
DQG $YLDOO FRXOG QRW KDYH DJUHHG WKDW VWDWH ODZ UDWKHU WKDQ (5,6$ JRYHUQHG WKH $JUHHPHQW
%
$YLDOO FRQWHQGV WKDW EHFDXVH WKH $JUHHPHQW XVHV WKH WHUPV IURP WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ
LV LQ FRQVLGHUDWLRQ RI WKH EHQHILWV SD\DEOH XQGHU WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ DQG LV WDNHQ IURP RQH
RI WKH VL[ WHPSODWHV DWWDFKHG WR WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ GRFXPHQW WKH $JUHHPHQW DQG WKH
6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ PXVW EH UHDG WRJHWKHU DQG WKH\ HVWDEOLVK WKDW $YLDOO PDLQWDLQHG DQ (5,6$
SODQ ,Q VXSSRUW RI WKLV SRVLWLRQ $YLDOO UHOLHV RQ Hernandez v. Alcatel USA Resources, Inc.
)6XSSG (' 7H[ LQ ZKLFK WKH FRXUW KHOG WKDW D VHYHUDQFH DJUHHPHQW WKDW
UHIHUHQFHG D VXPPDU\ WKDW LQ WXUQ UHIHUHQFHG D VHYHUDQFH SODQ ZDV SDUW RI DQ (5,6$ SODQ
7KH Hernandez FRXUW UHMHFWHG WKH SODLQWLII¶V DUJXPHQW WKDW D &RQGLWLRQDO 6HYHUDQFH
$JUHHPHQW DQG *HQHUDO 5HOHDVH ZHUH QRW JRYHUQHG E\ (5,6$ DQG WKDW WKH SODLQWLII¶V FODLP
ZDV IRU D VLPSOH EUHDFK RI WKDW DJUHHPHQW ,W KHOG
7KH &RQILGHQWLDO 6HYHUDQFH $JUHHPHQW DQG *HQHUDO 5HOHDVH
VSHFLILFDOO\ UHIHUHQFHV ([KLELW $ WKH 6XPPDU\ RI WKH %HQHILWV
XQGHU WKH $OFDWHO 86$ ,QF 6HYHUDQFH %HQHILWV 3ODQ 7KH
6XPPDU\ LQ WXUQ UHIHUHQFHV $OFDWHO¶V 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ +HQFH
+HUQDQGH]¶V DUJXPHQWV WKDW WKH &RQILGHQWLDO 6HYHUDQFH
$JUHHPHQW DQG *HQHUDO 5HOHDVH H[LVWV VHSDUDWH DQG DSDUW IURP
$OFDWHO¶V 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ ODFN PHULW
Id. DW
7KH VHYHUDQFH DJUHHPHQW LQ Hernandez VSHFLILFDOO\ UHIHUHQFHG WKH SODQ VXPPDU\
VWDWLQJ
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 13 of 37 PageID 373
>Z@LWKLQ WHQ EXVLQHVV GD\V IROORZLQJ WKH >(QG RI
1RWLILFDWLRQ@ 'DWH $OFDWHO VKDOO SURYLGH WR (PSOR\HH WKH
6HYHUDQFH 3D\ VHW IRUWK LQ WKH DWWDFKHG ([KLELW $ LQ DFFRUGDQFH
ZLWK WKH WHUPV DQG FRQGLWLRQV VHW IRUWK LQ ([KLELW $
Id. DW ([KLELW $ WKH ³6XPPDU\ RI WKH %HQHILWV XQGHU WKH $OFDWHO 86$ ,QF 6HYHUDQFH
%HQHILWV 3ODQ´ H[SODLQHG WKDW LW SUHVHQWHG D VXPPDU\ RI EHQHILWV SURYLGHG XQGHU WKH
VHYHUDQFH SODQ DQG WKDW ³>D@Q\ TXHVWLRQV LQWHUSUHWDWLRQV RU DSSHDOV DUH JRYHUQHG E\ WKH SODQ
GRFXPHQWV DQG VKDOO EH UHVROYHG E\ WKH 3ODQ $GPLQLVWUDWRU DQG $GPLQLVWUDWLRQ &RPPLWWHH´
Id. DW see also Gomez v. Ericsson, Inc. :/ DW
(' 7H[ -DQ
³7KH 6HYHUDQFH $JUHHPHQW EHWZHHQ *RPH] DQG (ULFVVRQ LQFRUSRUDWHV E\ UHIHUHQFH
WKH WHUPV RI WKH 6WDQGDUG 3ODQ DQG WKH 7RS &RQWULEXWRU 3ODQ SURYLGLQJ WKDW VHYHUDQFH
SD\PHQW ZLOO EH PDGH DFFRUGLQJ WR WKHVH SODQ WHUPV 7KXV WR GHWHUPLQH ZKHWKHU WKH
6HYHUDQFH $JUHHPHQW IDOOV ZLWKLQ (5,6$ WKLV &RXUW H[DPLQHV WKH WHUPV DQG DGPLQLVWUDWLYH
VFKHPHV LI DQ\ RI WKH WZR VHYHUDQFH SODQV´ aff’d )G WK &LU
8QOLNH WKH VHYHUDQFH DJUHHPHQWV LQ Hernandez DQG Gomez WKH $JUHHPHQW DW LVVXH
KHUH RQO\ LQFRUSRUDWHV WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ¶V definitions See &RPSO ([ $ DW
,W SURYLGHV IRU WKH SD\PHQW RI 'RQ¶V ³%DVH 3D\´ GHILQHG
LQ WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ
LQ ELZHHNO\ LQVWDOOPHQWV IRU D SHULRG RI ZHHNV EHJLQQLQJ RQ WKH GD\ IROORZLQJ 'RQ¶V
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 14 of 37 PageID 374
³/DVW 'D\ :RUNHG´ DQG HQGLQJ RQ 0DUFK &DOFXODWLRQ RI 'RQ¶V VHYHUDQFH SD\ FDQ
EH PDGH ZLWKRXW UHIHUHQFH WR WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ RWKHU WKDQ IRU FHUWDLQ GHILQHG WHUPV 7KH
$JUHHPHQW DOVR SURYLGHV IRU WKH SD\PHQW RI &2%5$ SUHPLXPV DQG RWKHU EHQHILWV DQG VHWV
RXW YDULRXV REOLJDWLRQV RQ WKH SDUW RI 'RQ DQG $YLDOO QRQH RI ZKLFK LV DOVR SURYLGHG LQ WKH
6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ 0RUHRYHU WKH $JUHHPHQW VWDWHV WKDW LW ³
&RPSO ([
$ DW DQG WKDW LW ³
id. DW ,W QHLWKHU LQFRUSRUDWHV QRU VSHFLILFDOO\ UHIHUV WR WKH 6HYHUDQFH
7KH $JUHHPHQW VWDWHV WKDW $YLDOO¶V ³
&RPSO ([ $ DW $YLDOO GRHV QRW FRQWHQG WKDW WKH
$JUHHPHQW LV DQ (5,6$ SODQ E\ YLUWXH RI LWV LQFRUSRUDWLRQ RI WKH ³KHDOWK FDUH SURJUDP´
ZKLFK WKH FRXUW DVVXPHV LV WKH ³$YLDOO ,QF +HDOWK DQG :HOIDUH 3ODQ´ ³+HDOWK 3ODQ´ WKDW
$YLDOO UHIHUV WR LQ WKH IDFWXDO EDFNJURXQG VHFWLRQ RI LWV PRWLRQ
,Q WKLV VDPH VHFWLRQ WKH $JUHHPHQW DOVR VWDWHV
&RPSO ([ $ DW
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 15 of 37 PageID 375
3ODQ RWKHU WKDQ IRU WKH DSSOLFDWLRQ RI FHUWDLQ GHILQLWLRQV 7KH FRXUW WKHUHIRUH FRQFOXGHV WKDW
WKH $JUHHPHQW H[LVWV VHSDUDWH DQG DSDUW IURP WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ See, e.g., Evans v.
Infirmary Health Servs., Inc. )6XSSG 6' $OD FRQFOXGLQJ
WKDW SODLQWLII¶V VXLW WR UHFRYHU EHQHILWV XQGHU VHYHUDQFH DJUHHPHQW ZDV QRW SUHHPSWHG E\
(5,6$ HYHQ WKRXJK FRPSDQ\¶V OHDGHUVKLS VHYHUDQFH SROLF\ ZDV (5,6$ SODQ ZKHUH
SODLQWLII VRXJKW WR HQIRUFH ULJKWV XQGHU WKH VHYHUDQFH DJUHHPHQW DQG ³KHU DOOHJDWLRQV GR QRW
LQ DQ\ ZD\ LQYROYH FODULILFDWLRQ RU HQIRUFHPHQW RI KHU ULJKWV under the terms of WKH 3ROLF\´
EROG IRQW RPLWWHG
&
7KH FRXUW QH[W FRQFOXGHV DV D PDWWHU RI ODZ WKDW WKH $JUHHPHQW VWDQGLQJ DORQH LV
QRW DQ (5,6$ SODQ
7KH TXHVWLRQ ZKHWKHU WKH $JUHHPHQW LV DQ (5,6$ HPSOR\HH ZHOIDUH EHQHILW SODQ LV
D PL[HG TXHVWLRQ RI IDFW DQG ODZ ³>7@KH H[LVWHQFH RI DQ (5,6$ SODQ ZLWKLQ WKH VWDWXWRU\
GHILQLWLRQ LV D TXHVWLRQ RI IDFW +RZHYHU ZKHUH WKH IDFWXDO FLUFXPVWDQFHV DUH HVWDEOLVKHG DV
D PDWWHU RI ODZ RU XQGLVSXWHG >WKH FRXUW KDV@ WUHDWHG WKH TXHVWLRQ DV RQH RI ODZ>@´ House
v. Am. United Life Ins. Co. )G WK &LU FLWDWLRQV RPLWWHG ³,W LV FOHDU
WKDW ZKLOH QRW VR VWDWLQJ >WKH )LIWK &LUFXLW KDV@ IROORZHG >LWV@ VLVWHU FLUFXLWV LQ WUHDWLQJ WKH
,Q UHDFKLQJ WKLV FRQFOXVLRQ WKH FRXUW KDV GHWHUPLQHG WKDW WKHUH DUH QR GLVSXWHG IDFW
LVVXHV UHJDUGLQJ WKH WHUPV RI WKH $JUHHPHQW RU WKH REOLJDWLRQV WKDW WKH $JUHHPHQW LPSRVHV
RQ $YLDOO
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 16 of 37 PageID 376
H[LVWHQFH RI DQ (5,6$ SODQ DV D PL[HG TXHVWLRQ RI IDFW DQG ODZ´ Id. DW ³,I WKHUH LV QR
JHQXLQH LVVXH UHJDUGLQJ D IDFW WKDW LV SHUWLQHQW WR WK>H@ LQTXLU\ >ZKHWKHU D SODQ LV DQ (5,6$
SODQ@ WKH FRXUW GHFLGHV >WKH TXHVWLRQ@ DV D PDWWHU RI ODZ >@´ Henderson v. Paul Revere Life
Ins. Co. :/ DW
1' 7H[ $SU )LW]ZDWHU &- ³,I WKHUH LV
D JHQXLQH LVVXH RI IDFW KRZHYHU WKH WULHU RI IDFW PXVW UHVROYH WKH LVVXH EHIRUH WKH FRXUW FDQ
GHWHUPLQH EDVHG RQ WKH IDFWV VR IRXQG DQG DV D PDWWHU RI ODZ ZKHWKHU WKH SROLF\ LV SDUW RI
DQ (5,6$ SODQ´ Id.
6LQFH Fort Halifax ZDV GHFLGHG FRXUWV KDYH UHFRJQL]HG WKDW WR EH DQ (5,6$ SODQ
D SURJUDP PXVW UHTXLUH WKDW DQ HPSOR\HU GR PRUH WKDQ PDNH D RQHWLPH OXPSVXP SD\PHQW
RQ WKH RFFXUUHQFH RI D VLQJOH FRQWLQJHQF\ ³%XW FRXUWV KDYH VRPHWLPHV HQFRXQWHUHG
GLIILFXOWLHV GHWHUPLQLQJ ZKHWKHU D SDUWLFXODU SURJUDP FRQVWLWXWHV DQ µRQJRLQJ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH
SURJUDP¶ ZLWKLQ WKH PHDQLQJ RI Fort Halifax´ Kirkindoll v. Nat’l Credit Union Admin. Bd.
:/ DW
1' 7H[ 1RY )LW]ZDWHU &- ³%HFDXVH WKH TXHVWLRQ
µ>Z@KHWKHU D SODQ H[LVWV LV IDFWVSHFLILF¶ FRXUWV KDYH HQJDJHG LQ D SURFHVV RI FRPSDULQJ DQG
FRQWUDVWLQJ WKH SURJUDP LQ TXHVWLRQ ZLWK WKH IDFWRUV RQ ZKLFK RWKHU FRXUWV KDYH UHOLHG ZKHQ
GHFLGLQJ WKDW D SDUWLFXODU SURJUDP GLG RU GLG QRW TXDOLI\ DV DQ (5,6$ SODQ´ Id. DOWHUDWLRQ
LQ RULJLQDO TXRWLQJ Cantrell )G DW 7KH FRXUW ZLOO IROORZ WKLV DSSURDFK LQ WKH
LQVWDQW FDVH Id.
(5,6$ LV FRQFHUQHG ZLWK ³EHQHILW SODQV´ UDWKHU WKDQ VLPSO\ ZLWK ³EHQHILWV´ EHFDXVH
:HVWODZ UHIOHFWV WKDW WKH GDWH RI WKLV PHPRUDQGXP RSLQLRQ DQG RUGHU LV 0D\
7KDW LV WKH GDWH WKH RSLQLRQ ZDV XQVHDOHG 7KH GDWH LW ZDV ILOHG LV $SULO
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 17 of 37 PageID 377
³>R@QO\ µSODQV¶ LQYROYH DGPLQLVWUDWLYH DFWLYLW\ SRWHQWLDOO\ VXEMHFW WR HPSOR\HU DEXVH´ Fort
Halifax 86 DW 7KH &RXUW LQ Fort Halifax KHOG WKDW D OXPS VXP VHYHUDQFH SD\PHQW
WULJJHUHG E\ D VLQJOH HYHQW WKDW PD\ QHYHU RFFXU LV QRW D ³SODQ´ IRU SXUSRVHV RI (5,6$
7KH UHTXLUHPHQW RI D RQHWLPH OXPSVXP SD\PHQW WULJJHUHG E\
D VLQJOH HYHQW UHTXLUHV QR DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH ZKDWVRHYHU WR
PHHW WKH HPSOR\HU¶V REOLJDWLRQ 7KH HPSOR\HU DVVXPHV QR
UHVSRQVLELOLW\ WR SD\ EHQHILWV RQ D UHJXODU EDVLV DQG WKXV IDFHV
QR SHULRGLF GHPDQGV RQ LWV DVVHWV WKDW FUHDWH D QHHG IRU ILQDQFLDO
FRRUGLQDWLRQ DQG FRQWURO 5DWKHU WKH HPSOR\HU¶V REOLJDWLRQ LV
SUHGLFDWHG RQ WKH RFFXUUHQFH RI D VLQJOH FRQWLQJHQF\ WKDW PD\
QHYHU PDWHULDOL]H 7KH HPSOR\HU PD\ ZHOO never KDYH WR SD\ WKH
VHYHUDQFH EHQHILWV 7R WKH H[WHQW WKDW WKH REOLJDWLRQ WR GR VR
DULVHV VDWLVIDFWLRQ RI WKDW GXW\ LQYROYHV RQO\ PDNLQJ D VLQJOH VHW
RI SD\PHQWV WR HPSOR\HHV DW WKH WLPH WKH SODQW FORVHV 7R GR
OLWWOH PRUH WKDQ ZULWH D FKHFN KDUGO\ FRQVWLWXWHV WKH RSHUDWLRQ RI
D EHQHILW SODQ 2QFH WKLV VLQJOH HYHQW LV RYHU WKH HPSOR\HU KDV
QR IXUWKHU UHVSRQVLELOLW\ 7KH WKHRUHWLFDO SRVVLELOLW\ RI D
RQHWLPH REOLJDWLRQ LQ WKH IXWXUH VLPSO\ FUHDWHV QR QHHG IRU DQ
RQJRLQJ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH SURJUDP IRU SURFHVVLQJ FODLPV DQG
SD\LQJ EHQHILWV
Id. DW 7KH EHQHILWV DW LVVXH LQ Fort Halifax ZHUH WR EH SURYLGHG E\ WKH HPSOR\HU SXUVXDQW
WR D VWDWH VWDWXWH WKDW UHTXLUHG WKDW ³DQ\ HPSOR\HU WKDW WHUPLQDWHV RSHUDWLRQV DW D SODQW ZLWK
RU PRUH HPSOR\HHV RU UHORFDWHV WKRVH RSHUDWLRQV PRUH WKDQ PLOHV DZD\ PXVW
SURYLGH RQH ZHHN¶V SD\ IRU HDFK \HDU RI HPSOR\PHQW WR DOO HPSOR\HHV ZKR KDYH ZRUNHG LQ
WKH SODQW DW OHDVW WKUHH \HDUV´ Id DW 7KH 6XSUHPH &RXUW KHOG WKDW WKH VWDWXWH ZDV QRW
SUHHPSWHG E\ (5,6$ ³EHFDXVH WKH VWDWXWH QHLWKHU HVWDEOLVKHV QRU UHTXLUHV DQ HPSOR\HU WR
PDLQWDLQ DQ HPSOR\HH ZHOIDUH EHQHILW µSODQ¶´ ZLWKLQ WKH PHDQLQJ RI WKH (5,6$ VWDWXWH Id.
DW
&RXUWV LQ WKH )LIWK &LUFXLW KDYH IROORZHG Fort Halifax LQ KROGLQJ WKDW ZKHUH SODQV
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 18 of 37 PageID 378
UHTXLUH D RQHWLPH OXPSVXP SD\PHQW WULJJHUHG E\ D VLQJOH VSHFLILF HYHQW WKH SODQV GR QRW
UHTXLUH DQ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH WR PHHW WKH HPSOR\HU¶V REOLJDWLRQ DQG DUH WKHUHIRUH QRW
(5,6$ SODQV See, e.g., Fontenot v. NL Indus., Inc. )G WK &LU
KROGLQJ ³JROGHQ SDUDFKXWH´ SODQ WKDW UHTXLUHG RQHWLPH OXPS VXP SD\PHQW UHTXLUHG QR
DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH DQG ZDV QRW (5,6$ SODQ EHFDXVH HPSOR\HHV ZRXOG UHFHLYH EHQHILWV
XSRQ WHUPLQDWLRQ UHJDUGOHVV RI UHDVRQ IRU WHUPLQDWLRQ DQG WKH ³WKHRUHWLFDO SRVVLELOLW\ RI D
RQHWLPH REOLJDWLRQ LQ WKH IXWXUH FUHDWHG QR QHHG IRU DQ RQJRLQJ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH SURJUDP WR
SURFHVV FODLPV DQG SD\ EHQHILWV´ Wells v. Gen. Motors Corp )G WK &LU
KROGLQJ WKDW ZKHUH HPSOR\HHV FRXOG HOHFW WR UHFHLYH RQHWLPH OXPS VXP SD\PHQW LI
WKH\ FHDVHG ZRUNLQJ DW HPSOR\HU¶V SODQW SODQ ZDV QRW DQ ³HPSOR\HH EHQHILW SODQ´ IRU
SXUSRVHV RI (5,6$ EHFDXVH LW ZDV QRW RQJRLQJ DQG DOWKRXJK HPSOR\HHV FRXOG HOHFW WZR\HDU
LQVWDOOPHQW SD\PHQW RSWLRQ WKHUH ZDV QR QHHG IRU FRQWLQXLQJ DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ RI WKH SD\PHQW
SURJUDP Tinoco )G DW KROGLQJ WKDW SODQ WKDW RIIHUHG SODLQWLIIV FKRLFH RI OXPS
VXP SD\PHQW RU VWUHDP RI SD\PHQWV XQWLO WKH\ UHDFKHG DJH ZDV QRW (5,6$ SODQ EHFDXVH
UHJDUGOHVV RI KRZ WKH\ FKRVH WR UHFHLYH SD\PHQW WKH WRWDO DPRXQW WR EH SDLG ZDV EDVHG RQ
RQHWLPH FDOFXODWLRQ XVLQJ IL[HG IRUPXOD DQG SODLQWLIIV SURGXFHG QR HYLGHQFH WKDW SODQ
UHTXLUHG DQ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH WR PDNH RQJRLQJ GLVFUHWLRQDU\ GHFLVLRQV EDVHG RQ
VXEMHFWLYH FULWHULD see also Bogue v. Ampex Corp. )G WK &LU
IROORZLQJ Fontenot LGHQWLI\LQJ ³WKH IHQFH EHWZHHQ FDVHV LQYROYLQJ UHDO (5,6$ SODQV DQG
FDVHV VXFK DV Fort Halifax´ DV ³ZKHWKHU WKH SODQ LQ TXHVWLRQ UHTXLUHV DQ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH
VFKHPH EHFDXVH WKH FLUFXPVWDQFHV RI HDFK HPSOR\HH¶V WHUPLQDWLRQ KDYH WR EH DQDO\]HG LQ
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 19 of 37 PageID 379
OLJKW RI FHUWDLQ FULWHULD´ DQG FRQFOXGLQJ WKDW HYHQ WKRXJK SURJUDP ZDV WULJJHUHG E\ VLQJOH
HYHQW WKLV HYHQW ZRXOG RFFXU PRUH WKDQ RQFH DW GLIIHUHQW WLPH IRU HDFK HPSOR\HH DQG
³>W@KHUH ZDV QR ZD\ WR FDUU\ RXW WKDW REOLJDWLRQ ZLWK WKH XQWKLQNLQJ RQHWLPH
QRQGLVFUHWLRQDU\ DSSOLFDWLRQ RI WKH SODQ DGPLQLVWUDWRUV LQ Fort Halifax DQG Wells´ EUDFNHWV
DQG LQWHUQDO TXRWDWLRQ PDUNV RPLWWHG
,Q FRQWUDVW ZKHUH EHQHILWV SODQV UHTXLUH PDQDJHULDO GLVFUHWLRQ UHTXLUH WKH HPSOR\HU
WR DQDO\]H WKH FLUFXPVWDQFHV RI HDFK HPSOR\HH¶V WHUPLQDWLRQ VHSDUDWHO\ LQ OLJKW RI FHUWDLQ
FULWHULD see Schonholz v. Long Island Jewish Medical Center )G G &LU
RU LQYROYH PRUH WKDQ MXVW WKH RQHWLPH SD\PHQW RI VHYHUDQFH EHQHILWV FRXUWV KDYH KHOG WKDW
WKH\ DUH FRYHUHG E\ (5,6$ )RU H[DPSOH LQ Suda v. BP Corp. North America, Inc
:/ DW
WK &LU $SU SHU FXULDP XQSXEOLVKHG RSLQLRQ WKH SDQHO
FRQWUDVWHG WKH SODQ DW LVVXH ZLWK WKH SODQV LQ Fontenot DQG Fort Halifax ,W QRWHG WKDW
WKH %3 3ODQ DOWKRXJK HVWDEOLVKLQJ D VHHPLQJO\ VLPSOH IRUPXOD
IRU GHWHUPLQLQJ WKH VHYHUDQFH DOORZDQFH IRU ZKLFK D WHUPLQDWHG
%3 HPSOR\HH ZDV HOLJLEOH PDGH WKDW DOORZDQFH VXEMHFW WR D
YDULHW\ RI GHGXFWLRQV WKDW FRPSOLFDWHG WKH FDOFXODWLRQ RI WKH
VHYHUDQFH DOORZDQFH ,W DOVR SURYLGHG QRQWULYLDO FULWHULD IRU
GHWHUPLQLQJ HPSOR\HH HOLJLELOLW\ 0RUHRYHU WKH %3 3ODQ
$GPLQLVWUDWRU KDG ZLGH GLVFUHWLRQ DQG WKH 3ODQ SURYLGHG IRU D
WZROHYHO DGPLQLVWUDWLYH FODLPV SURFHGXUH )XUWKHUPRUH WKH %3
3ODQ SURYLGHG PRUH WKDQ D RQHWLPH VHYHUDQFH SD\PHQW LW
SURYLGHG RQJRLQJ KHDOWK DQG OLIH LQVXUDQFH UHORFDWLRQ DQG
HGXFDWLRQDO DLG %3 KDG WR GR PRUH WKDQ ³ZULWH D FKHFN´ $OO
RI WKLV UHTXLUHG DQ ³RQJRLQJ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH´ DOEHLW D
PRGHVW RQH
Id. FLWDWLRQV RPLWWHG see also Crowell v. Shell Oil Co. )G WK &LU
FRQFOXGLQJ WKDW OHWWHUV RI DJUHHPHQW WKDW SURYLGHG IRU SD\PHQWV WR HPSOR\HHV ZKHQ
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 20 of 37 PageID 380
HPSOR\HU FKDQJHG FRQWURO ZHUH (5,6$ SODQV EHFDXVH SD\PHQW ZDV HPEHGGHG ZLWKLQ OHWWHU
WKDW LQFOXGHG D PRUH FRPSUHKHQVLYH SODQ DPRXQW RI WKH PRQWKO\ SHQVLRQV DQG RQHWLPH
SD\PHQW UHOLHG GLUHFWO\ RQ FDOFXODWLRQV PDGH LQ SUHGHFHVVRU FRPSDQ\¶V HPSOR\HH EHQHILWV
SODQV SURYLVLRQ IRU RQHWLPH FDVK SD\PHQW FRQWDLQHG H[SOLFLW ODQJXDJH DERXW ³DGPLQLVWUDWLYH
SURFHGXUHV´ UHTXLUHG IRU FDOFXODWLRQ DQG OHWWHUV RI DJUHHPHQW LQFOXGLQJ SRUWLRQV UHIHUULQJ
WR RQHWLPH FDVK SD\PHQW XSRQ FKDQJH RI FRQWURO UHTXLUHG RQJRLQJ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH
LQYROYHPHQW
5HFHQWO\ WKH )LIWK &LUFXLW KHOG LQ Gomez WKDW WKH HPSOR\HUV¶ SODQV ZKLFK UHTXLUHG
³DEXQGDQW´ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH DFWLYLW\ FRQVWLWXWHG (5,6$ SODQV Gomez )G DW 7KH
SODQV FRYHUHG RYHU HPSOR\HHV DFURVV WKH QDWLRQ ZKLFK ³PHDQV WKH\ DUH D IDU FU\ IURP
µVLQJOH HYHQW¶ SODQV´ Id. FLWDWLRQ RPLWWHG ,Q DGGLWLRQ WKH SODQV UHTXLUHG WKH DGPLQLVWUDWRU
WR H[HUFLVH ³D JUHDW GHDO RI GLVFUHWLRQ´ LQFOXGLQJ GHWHUPLQLQJ ZKHWKHU D ³JRRG UHDVRQ´
H[LVWHG WKDW TXDOLILHG DQ HPSOR\HH¶V YROXQWDU\ WHUPLQDWLRQ FDOFXODWLQJ RIIVHWV DQG
GHGXFWLRQV DQG PRQLWRULQJ SD\PHQW REOLJDWLRQV LQ WKH HYHQW DQ HPSOR\HH UHWXUQHG WR ZRUN
GXULQJ WKH VHYHUDQFH SHULRG VLQFH WKH SODQV FRQWHPSODWHG VHWRII RI VHYHUDQFH DPRXQWV
UHFHLYHG DJDLQVW WKDW IXWXUH SD\ Id. 7KH FRXUW WKHQ QRWHG ³>I@LQDOO\ WKH 6WDQGDUG 3ODQ
SURYLGHV IRU &2%5$ LQVXUDQFH FRYHUDJH ZKLFK DORQH JLYHV ULVH WR D KRVW RI LVVXHV
FRQFHUQLQJ HOLJLELOLW\ OHQJWK RI FRYHUDJH FRVW DQG ZKHWKHU WKH FRYHUDJH WHUPLQDWHV EHFDXVH
WKH HPSOR\HH DFTXLUHV QHZ LQVXUDQFH GXULQJ WKH HOLJLELOLW\ SHULRG µRU RWKHUZLVH EHFRPH>V@
LQHOLJLEOH¶´ Id. DW FLWDWLRQ RPLWWHG 7KH FRXUW WKXV FRQFOXGHG WKDW EHFDXVH WKH
HPSOR\HU¶V ³3ODQV FKHFN RII PRVW RI WKH IDFWRUV LQGLFDWLYH RI (5,6$ SODQV>@ >W@KH\
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 21 of 37 PageID 381
DUH JRYHUQHG E\ WKH IHGHUDO VWDWXWH´ Id.
$JDLQVW WKLV EDFNGURS WKH FRXUW KROGV WKDW WKH $JUHHPHQW LV QRW DQ (5,6$ HPSOR\HH
EHQHILW SODQ EXW LV LQVWHDG DQ HPSOR\PHQW FRQWUDFW DUUDQJHPHQW JRYHUQHG E\ VWDWH ODZ
7KH $JUHHPHQW UHTXLUHV $YLDOO WR FRQWLQXH WR SD\ 'RQ¶V FXUUHQW EDVH SD\ DV GHILQHG
E\ WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ DV VHYHUDQFH SD\ LQ ELZHHNO\ LQVWDOOPHQWV IRU ZHHNV ,W DSSOLHV
WR D VLQJOH HPSOR\HH 'RQ DQG SD\PHQW LV WULJJHUHG E\ D VLQJOH HYHQW 'RQ¶V WHUPLQDWLRQ
$OWKRXJK WKH DPRXQW GXH XQGHU WKH $JUHHPHQW PXVW EH FDOFXODWHG LQFOXGLQJ DPRXQWV WR EH
ZLWKKHOG IRU WD[HV DQG
&RPSO ([ $ DW WKLV LV D RQHWLPH
FDOFXODWLRQ /LNH WKH DUUDQJHPHQW LQ Tinoco WKH DPRXQW $YLDOO DJUHHG WR SD\ DV VHYHUDQFH
SD\ LV ³EDVHG RQ D RQHWLPH FDOFXODWLRQ XVLQJ D IL[HG IRUPXOD´ DQG ZULWLQJ D FKHFN HYHU\
RWKHU ZHHN IRU D IL[HG SHULRG RI WLPH ³LV KDUGO\ DQ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH´ Tinoco )G
DW ,Q RWKHU ZRUGV ³WKH SUHGHWHUPLQHG EHQHILW HYHQ ZKHQ SDLG RYHU WLPH >GRHV@ QRW
DPRXQW WR DQ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH´ Peace )G DW
1RU GRHV WKH UHTXLUHPHQW WKDW $YLDOO FDOFXODWH DQG SD\ IRU D SHULRG RI WLPH D SRUWLRQ
RI 'RQ¶V &2%5$ SUHPLXPV FRQWLQJHQW XSRQ 'RQ¶V HOHFWLQJ VXFK FRYHUDJH DQG SD\LQJ KLV
VKDUH LI DQ\ RI SUHPLXPV QHFHVVLWDWH DQ RQJRLQJ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH /LNH WKH SD\PHQW
RI VHYHUDQFH EHQHILWV WKH SD\PHQW RI &2%5$ SUHPLXPV UHTXLUHV D RQHWLPH FDOFXODWLRQ DQG
WKHUHDIWHU UHTXLUHV $YLDOO WR GR OLWWOH PRUH WKDQ ZULWH D FKHFN 7KH PLQLPDO DPRXQW RI
PRQLWRULQJ SRWHQWLDOO\ UHTXLUHG RI $YLDOO WR GHWHUPLQH ZKHWKHU LWV REOLJDWLRQ WR SD\ D SRUWLRQ
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 22 of 37 PageID 382
RI 'RQ¶V &2%5$ SUHPLXPV KDV WHUPLQDWHG GRHV QRW LQYROYH WKH H[HUFLVH RI GLVFUHWLRQ DQG
GRHV QRW RWKHUZLVH UHTXLUH DQ RQJRLQJ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH
7KH $JUHHPHQW DOVR GRHV QRW UHTXLUH D SODQ DGPLQLVWUDWRU WR PDNH GLVFUHWLRQDU\
GHFLVLRQV VXFK DV GHFLGLQJ ZKHWKHU DQ HPSOR\PHQW RIIHU LV IRU ³µVXEVWDQWLDOO\ HTXLYDOHQW¶
HPSOR\PHQW´ Bogue )G DW RU ZKHWKHU D ³JRRG UHDVRQ´ H[LVWV WKDW TXDOLILHV DQ
HPSOR\HH¶V YROXQWDU\ WHUPLQDWLRQ Gomez )G DW 1RU GRHV LW H[SOLFLWO\ DXWKRUL]H
$YLDOO WR PDNH VXFK GLVFUHWLRQDU\ GHFLVLRQV UHIHUHQFH DQ\ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH SURFHGXUHV WKDW
PXVW EH IROORZHG RU SURYLGH DQ\ UHYLHZ SURFHGXUHV Cf. Bogue )G DW
Kirkindoll :/ DW
7KH $JUHHPHQW SURYLGHV
&RPSO ([ $ DW
7KH FRXUW GLVDJUHHV WKDW WKH $JUHHPHQW¶V UHTXLUHPHQWV WKDW $YLDOO
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 23 of 37 PageID 383
7R WKH H[WHQW WKH $JUHHPHQW UHTXLUHV $YLDOO WR SURYLGH LWV ³KHDOWK FDUH SURJUDP
EHQHILWV´ LQ DFFRUGDQFH ZLWK &2%5$ DQG WKH WHUPV RI $YLDOO¶V KHDOWK FDUH SURJUDP WKH
FRXUW FRQFOXGHV WKDW QR DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH LV UHTXLUHG $OWKRXJK VRPH FRXUWV KDYH
VXJJHVWHG WKDW &2%5$ FRQWLQXDWLRQ FRYHUDJH ³SODFHV RQJRLQJ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH EXUGHQV RQ WKH
HPSOR\HU´ Eberlein v. Provident Life & Accident Insurance Co. :/ DW
'
&ROR FLWLQJ Demars v. CIGNA Corp )G VW &LU see also
Mimbs v. Commercial Life Insurance Co. ) 6XSS 6' *D
WKH FRXUW FRQFOXGHV WKDW KHUH ZKHUH DOO RI WKH RWKHU KDOOPDUNV RI DQ (5,6$ SODQ DUH ODFNLQJ
WKH SURYLVLRQ RI &2%5$ FRQWLQXDWLRQ FRYHUDJH GRHV QRW FRQYHUW WKH $JUHHPHQW LQWR DQ
(5,6$ SODQ Cf. Gomez )G DW QRWLQJ WKDW ZKHQ HPSOR\HU SURYLGHV &2%5$
LQVXUDQFH FRYHUDJH WKLV ³DORQH JLYHV ULVH WR D KRVW RI LVVXHV FRQFHUQLQJ HOLJLELOLW\ OHQJWK RI
FRYHUDJH FRVW DQG ZKHWKHU WKH FRYHUDJH WHUPLQDWHV EHFDXVH WKH HPSOR\HH DFTXLUHV QHZ
LQVXUDQFH GXULQJ WKH HOLJLELOLW\ SHULRG µRU RWKHUZLVH EHFRPH>V@ LQHOLJLEOH¶´ DQG FRQFOXGLQJ
WKDW HPSOR\HU¶V SODQV ³FKHFN RII PRVW RI WKH IDFWRUV LQGLFDWLYH RI (5,6$ SODQV´ 7KLV LV
EHFDXVH WKH OLPLWHG FRQWLQXHG KHDOWK FDUH FRYHUDJH UHTXLUHV QR DGGLWLRQDO XQLTXH
W
QHFHVVLWDWH DQ RQJRLQJ
DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH %HFDXVH WKHVH REOLJDWLRQV DUH FRQWLQJHQW RQ DQ HYHQW WKDW PD\ QHYHU
PDWHULDOL]H DQG LQ IDFW WKHUH LV QR VXJJHVWLRQ LQ WKH UHFRUG WKDW $YLDOO HYHU KDG WR SHUIRUP
DQ\ RI WKHVH REOLJDWLRQV WKHUH LV QR QHHG IRU DQ RQJRLQJ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH SURJUDP WR SHUIRUP
WKHVH WDVNV See, e.g., Peace )G DW ³:H KDYH FRQFOXGHG WKDW D RQHWLPH OXPS VXP
SD\PHQW contingent upon an event that may never materialize µFUHDWH>V@ QR QHHG IRU DQ
RQJRLQJ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH SURJUDP WR SURFHVV FODLPV DQG SD\ EHQHILWV¶ DQG WKHUHIRUH LV QRW D
SODQ´ HPSKDVLV DGGHG TXRWLQJ Fontenot )G DW
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 24 of 37 PageID 384
DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH RWKHU WKDQ ZKDW ZDV DOUHDG\ LQ SODFH IRU SURFHVVLQJ KHDOWK FDUH FODLPV
DQG FRXUWV LQFOXGLQJ LQ WKLV FLUFXLW ³KDYH IRXQG WKDW VXFK FRQWLQXHG FRYHUDJH GRHV QRW
FRQVWLWXWH DQ HPSOR\HH EHQHILW SODQ VR ORQJ DV LW GRHV QRW UHTXLUH WKH FUHDWLRQ RI D QHZ
DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH RU GRHV QRW PDWHULDOO\ DOWHU DQ H[LVWLQJ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH´
Nelson v. Gen. Motors Corp )G :/ DW
WK &LU
XQSXEOLVKHG WDEOH RSLQLRQ see also, e.g., Angst v. Mack Trucks, Inc )G
G &LU KROGLQJ WKDW ZKHUH SODQ SURYLGHG IRU ³FRQWLQXDWLRQ RI FHUWDLQ EHQHILWV´ WKDW
ZRXOG EH DGPLQLVWHUHG XQGHU SUHH[LVWLQJ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH ³OLNH WKH RQHWLPH VHYHUDQFH
SD\PHQW >WKH FRQWLQXDWLRQ RI H[LVWLQJ EHQHILWV@ ZRXOG QRW UHTXLUH WKH FUHDWLRQ RI D QHZ
DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH´ DQG WKXV GLG QRW ³LQYRNH>@ WKH DSSOLFDWLRQ RI (5,6$ XQGHU WKH Fort
Halifax WHVW´ Fontenot )G DW KROGLQJ ³JROGHQ SDUDFKXWH´ SURJUDP
SURYLGLQJ inter alia IRU D WKUHH\HDU FRQWLQXDWLRQ RI FHUWDLQ EHQHILWV WR HOLJLEOH H[HFXWLYHV
ZDV QRW (5,6$ SODQ EHFDXVH HPSOR\HU ZDV QRW UHTXLUHG WR HVWDEOLVK VHSDUDWH DQG RQJRLQJ
DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH WR PDNH SD\PHQWV DQG SURYLGH EHQHILWV XQGHU SURJUDP Willis Re Inc.
v. Hearn :/ DW
(' 3D $XJ ³>$@ RQHWLPH OXPSVXP
SD\PHQW ZKLFK GRHV QRW FUHDWH D QHZ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH RU LPSRVH QHZ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH
UHTXLUHPHQWV EXW UHTXLUHV FRQWLQXDWLRQ RI DQ H[LVWLQJ SURFHGXUH LV QRW DQ (5,6$ SHQVLRQ
SODQ´
,Q VXP EHFDXVH WKH $JUHHPHQW UHTXLUHV WKH SD\PHQW RI D VHW DPRXQW 'RQ¶V EDVH
SD\ SDLG LQ ELZHHNO\ LQVWDOOPHQWV IRU ZHHNV WULJJHUHG E\ D VLQJOH VSHFLILF HYHQW
JLYHV 'RQ WKH RSWLRQ RI continuing KLV KHDOWK FDUH SURJUDP EHQHILWV XQGHU DQ DOUHDG\
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 25 of 37 PageID 385
HVWDEOLVKHG DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH DQG GRHV QRW RWKHUZLVH LQFOXGH DQ\ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH
UHTXLUHPHQWV WKDW ZRXOG UHTXLUH WKH H[HUFLVH RI GLVFUHWLRQ WKH FRXUW FRQFOXGHV WKDW WKH
$JUHHPHQW GRHV QRW UHTXLUH DQ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VFKHPH WR PHHW WKH HPSOR\HU¶V REOLJDWLRQ DQG
WKHUHIRUH LV QRW DQ (5,6$ SODQ
9,
+DYLQJ FRQFOXGHG WKDW WKH $JUHHPHQW LWVHOI LV QRW DQ (5,6$ SODQ WKH FRXUW QRZ WXUQV
WR $YLDOO¶V DUJXPHQW WKDW SODLQWLII¶V FODLP WKDW $YLDOO EUHDFKHG WKH WHUPV RI WKH $JUHHPHQW
DQG VXEVHTXHQW FRQWUDFW WR UHLQVWDWH DQG H[WHQG 'RQ¶V KHDOWKFDUH FRYHUDJH LV FRPSOHWHO\
SUHHPSWHG E\ (5,6$
$
7KHUH DUH WZR W\SHV RI (5,6$ SUHHPSWLRQ FRQIOLFW DQG FRPSOHWH SUHHPSWLRQ See
Ellis v. Liberty Life Assur. Co. of Bos. )G Q WK &LU GLVFXVVLQJ
(5,6$ FRQIOLFW DQG FRPSOHWH SUHHPSWLRQ &RQIOLFW RU RUGLQDU\ SUHHPSWLRQ RFFXUV
ZKHQ WKHUH LV D GLUHFW FRQIOLFW EHWZHHQ WKH RSHUDWLRQ RI IHGHUDO DQG VWDWH ODZ VR WKDW LW LV
LPSRVVLEOH WR FRPSO\ ZLWK ERWK RU ZKHQ WKH VWDWH ODZ ³VWDQGV DV DQ REVWDFOH WR WKH
DFFRPSOLVKPHQW DQG H[HFXWLRQ RI WKH IXOO SXUSRVHV DQG REMHFWLYHV RI &RQJUHVV´ LQ WKH IHGHUDO
VWDWXWH Boggs v. Boggs 86 LQWHUQDO TXRWDWLRQ PDUNV RPLWWHG
TXRWLQJ Gade v. Nat’l Solid Wastes Mgmt. Ass’n 86 see also Crosby
v. Nat’l Foreign Trade Council 86 &RPSOHWH SUHHPSWLRQ RQ WKH
RWKHU KDQG ³H[LVWV ZKHQ D UHPHG\ IDOOV ZLWKLQ WKH VFRSH RI RU LV LQ GLUHFW FRQIOLFW ZLWK >
86& D @ DQG WKHUHIRUH LV ZLWKLQ WKH MXULVGLFWLRQ RI IHGHUDO FRXUW´ Haynes v.
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 26 of 37 PageID 386
Prudential Health Care )G WK &LU FLWLQJ Metro. Life Ins. Co. v.
Taylor 86
$YLDOO FRQWHQGV WKDW SODLQWLII¶V VWDWHODZ EUHDFK RI FRQWUDFW FODLP LV FRPSOHWHO\
SUHHPSWHG E\ (5,6$ $ VWDWHODZ FODLP FDQ EH FRPSOHWHO\ SUHHPSWHG XQGHU (5,6$
WKH VWDWXWH¶V FLYLOHQIRUFHPHQW SURYLVLRQ ZKLFK ³&RQJUHVV LQWHQGHG WR EH WKH H[FOXVLYH
YHKLFOH IRU VXLWV E\ D EHQHILFLDU\ WR UHFRYHU EHQHILWV IURP D FRYHUHG SODQ´ Mem’l Hosp. Sys.
v. Northbrook Life Ins. Co. )G WK &LU $ VWDWHODZ FODLP WKDW LV
FRPSOHWHO\ SUHHPSWHG XQGHU LV WUDQVIRUPHG LQWR D QHZ IHGHUDO FODLP See Aetna Health
Inc. v. Davila 86 6HFWLRQ D % SUHHPSWV DOO VXLWV
LQYROYLQJ (5,6$JRYHUQHG SODQV ³EURXJKW E\ D SDUWLFLSDQW RU EHQHILFLDU\ WR UHFRYHU
EHQHILWV GXH WR KLP XQGHU WKH WHUPV RI KLV SODQ WR HQIRUFH KLV ULJKWV XQGHU WKH WHUPV RI WKH
SODQ RU WR FODULI\ KLV ULJKWV WR IXWXUH EHQHILWV XQGHU WKH WHUPV RI WKH SODQ´ 86&
D % $ FDXVH RI DFWLRQ IDOOV ZLWKLQ WKH VFRSH RI D % DQG LV WKHUHIRUH
FRPSOHWHO\ SUHHPSWHG LI WKH ³LQGLYLGXDO DW VRPH SRLQW LQ WLPH FRXOG KDYH EURXJKW KLV
FODLP XQGHU (5,6$ D % ´ DQG ³ZKHUH WKHUH LV QR RWKHU LQGHSHQGHQW OHJDO GXW\
WKDW LV LPSOLFDWHG E\ D GHIHQGDQW¶V DFWLRQV´ Davila 86 DW
%
$YLDOO FRQWHQGV WKDW (5,6$ FRPSOHWHO\ SUHHPSWV SODLQWLII¶V VWDWHODZ FODLP IRU EUHDFK
RI FRQWUDFW ,W DUJXHV WKDW WKH FODLP LV EDVHG RQ DOOHJDWLRQV WKDW $YLDOO EUHDFKHG WKH
$JUHHPHQW E\ IDLOLQJ WR SURYLGH 'RQ¶V IDPLO\ ZLWK PHGLFDO FRYHUDJH WKURXJK 0DUFK
DQG WKHQ EUHDFKHG D VXEVHTXHQW FRQWUDFW WR FRQWLQXH FRYHUDJH IURP 0DUFK WKURXJK -XO\
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 27 of 37 PageID 387
WKDW WKLV FODLP IDOOV VTXDUHO\ ZLWKLQ WKH VFRSH RI WKH FLYLO HQIRUFHPHQW SURYLVLRQ LQ
D % DQG WKDW WKH EUHDFK RI FRQWUDFW FODLP LV FRPSOHWHO\ SUHHPSWHG DQG PXVW EH UH
FKDUDFWHUL]HG LQWR D IHGHUDO FODLP XQGHU D %
&
$ VWDWHODZ FDXVH RI DFWLRQ LV FRPSOHWHO\ SUHHPSWHG XQGHU (5,6$ D % RQO\
LI WKH SODLQWLII ³DW VRPH SRLQW LQ WLPH FRXOG KDYH EURXJKW KLV FODLP XQGHU (5,6$
D % ´ DQG ³ZKHUH WKHUH LV QR RWKHU LQGHSHQGHQW OHJDO GXW\ WKDW LV LPSOLFDWHG E\ D
GHIHQGDQW¶V DFWLRQV´ Davila 86 DW
3ODLQWLII FRXOG QRW KDYH EURXJKW WKLV VWDWHODZ FODLP UHJDUGLQJ WKH $JUHHPHQW DQG
VXEVHTXHQW FRQWUDFW WR UHLQVWDWH DQG H[WHQG 'RQ¶V KHDOWKFDUH FRYHUDJH DV D FODLP IRU
6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ EHQHILWV XQGHU D % RI (5,6$ 6HFWLRQ D % DXWKRUL]HV
FLYLO DFWLRQV E\ D SDUWLFLSDQW ³WR UHFRYHU EHQHILWV GXH WR KLP XQGHU WKH WHUPV RI KLV SODQ WR
HQIRUFH KLV ULJKWV XQGHU WKH WHUPV RI WKH SODQ RU WR FODULI\ KLV ULJKWV WR IXWXUH EHQHILWV XQGHU
WKH WHUPV RI WKH SODQ´ 86& D % 6HFWLRQ D % ³LV UHODWLYHO\
VWUDLJKWIRUZDUG ,I D SDUWLFLSDQW RU EHQHILFLDU\ EHOLHYHV WKDW EHQHILWV SURPLVHG WR KLP XQGHU
WKH WHUPV RI WKH SODQ DUH QRW SURYLGHG KH FDQ EULQJ VXLW VHHNLQJ SURYLVLRQ RI WKRVH EHQHILWV´
Davila 86 DW 7R VDWLVI\ WKH ILUVW SURQJ RI Davila D FODLP PXVW DVVHUW ULJKWV WR
ZKLFK WKH SODLQWLII LV HQWLWOHG ³only because of WKH WHUPV RI DQ (5,6$UHJXODWHG HPSOR\HH
EHQHILW SODQ´ Id HPSKDVLV DGGHG
,Q WKH VWDWHODZ EUHDFK RI FRQWUDFW FODLP SODLQWLII DOOHJHV WKDW $YLDOO EUHDFKHG WKH
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 28 of 37 PageID 388
$JUHHPHQW E\ IDLOLQJ WR SURYLGH 'RQ WKH VSHFLILHG KHDOWK FDUH FRYHUDJH IURP 1RYHPEHU
WKURXJK 0DUFK DQG EUHDFKHG D VXEVHTXHQW FRQWUDFW WR UHLQVWDWH DQG H[WHQG 'RQ¶V
KHDOWKFDUH FRYHUDJH IURP 0DUFK WKURXJK -XO\ WR PDNH XS IRU WKH ODSVHG
SHULRG 3ODLQWLII GRHV QRW VHHN WR UHFRYHU EHQHILWV GXH 'RQ XQGHU WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ HQIRUFH
'RQ¶V ULJKWV XQGHU WKH WHUPV RI WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ RU FODULI\ KLV ULJKWV WR IXWXUH EHQHILWV
XQGHU WKH WHUPV RI WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ 1RU FRXOG SODLQWLII GR VR VLQFH WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ
GRHV QRW SURYLGH DQ\ KHDOWK FDUH EHQHILWV 3ODLQWLII¶V VWDWHODZ FODLP UHJDUGLQJ WKH
$JUHHPHQW DQG VXEVHTXHQW FRQWUDFW WR UHLQVWDWH DQG H[WHQG 'RQ¶V KHDOWKFDUH FRYHUDJH DULVHV
under the Agreement and subsequent contract QRW XQGHU WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ See Kirkindoll
v. Nat’l Credit Union Admin. Bd. :/ DW
1' 7H[ 'HF
)LW]ZDWHU - KROGLQJ WKDW (5,6$ GLG QRW SUHHPSW SODLQWLII¶V VWDWHODZ FODLPV IRU PRQH\
RZHG ZKHUH FODLPV DURVH XQGHU WHUPV RI DJUHHPHQW QRW XQGHU (5,6$ SODQ $FFRUGLQJO\
ZLWK UHJDUG WR SODLQWLII¶V VWDWHODZ FRQWUDFW FODLP UHODWHG WR WKH $JUHHPHQW DQG VXEVHTXHQW
FRQWUDFW WR UHLQVWDWH DQG H[WHQG 'RQ¶V KHDOWKFDUH FRYHUDJH WKLV FODLP FRXOG QRW KDYH EURXJKW
XQGHU (5,6$ D % LQ UHODWLRQ WR WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ $QG $YLDOO GRHV QRW DUJXH
$YLDOO FRQWHQGV RQO\ WKDW WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ DQG $JUHHPHQW FRQVWLWXWH DQ (5,6$
SODQ 7KH FRXUW KDV UHMHFWHG $YLDOO¶V DUJXPHQW WKDW WKH $JUHHPHQW LV D (5,6$ SODQ
$FFRUGLQJO\ WKH RQO\ ³SODQ´ WKH FRXUW FRQVLGHUV LQ WKH FRQWH[W RI $YLDOO¶V PRWLRQ WR GLVPLVV
LV WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ $OWKRXJK WKH FRXUW DVVXPHV WKDW KHDOWK FDUH EHQHILWV DUH SDUW $YLDOO¶V
+HDOWK 3ODQ $YLDOO KDV QRW LQFOXGHG D FRS\ RI WKH +HDOWK 3ODQ LQ LWV DSSHQGL[ DQG LW KDV QRW
SURYLGHG WKH FRXUW DQ\ GHWDLOV UHJDUGLQJ WKLV SODQ 1RU GRHV $YLDOO DUJXH (5,6$ SUHHPSWLRQ
EDVHG RQ WKH +HDOWK 3ODQ $FFRUGLQJO\ WKH FRXUW KDV QRW FRQVLGHUHG²EHFDXVH $YLDOO GRHV
QRW PDNH WKLV DUJXPHQW²ZKHWKHU WKH +HDOWK 3ODQ FRQVWLWXWHV DQ (5,6$ SODQ RU ZKHWKHU
3ODLQWLII¶V EUHDFK RI FRQWUDFW FODLP FRXOG KDYH EHHQ EURXJKW XQGHU D % DV D FODLP
IRU EHQHILWV XQGHU WKH +HDOWK 3ODQ
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 29 of 37 PageID 389
WKDW SODLQWLII FRXOG KDYH EURXJKW WKLV FODLP XQGHU (5,6$ D % LQ UHODWLRQ WR DQ\
RWKHU SODQ LQFOXGLQJ WKH $YLDOO ,QF +HDOWK DQG :HOIDUH 3ODQ RU WKDW WKLV FODLP LV FRPSOHWHO\
SUHHPSWHG E\ &2%5$
1RU GRHV SODLQWLII¶V VWDWHODZ FODLP UHJDUGLQJ WKH $JUHHPHQW DQG VXEVHTXHQW FRQWUDFW
WR UHLQVWDWH DQG H[WHQG 'RQ¶V KHDOWKFDUH FRYHUDJH VDWLVI\ WKH VHFRQG UHTXLUHPHQW RI Davila
8QGHU WKLV HOHPHQW D FODLP LV FRPSOHWHO\ SUHHPSWHG RQO\ ZKHQ WKHUH LV QR RWKHU LQGHSHQGHQW
OHJDO GXW\ WKDW LV LPSOLFDWHG E\ D GHIHQGDQW¶V DFWLRQV Davila 86 DW ³,I WKHUH LV
VRPH RWKHU LQGHSHQGHQW OHJDO GXW\ EH\RQG WKDW LPSRVHG E\ DQ (5,6$ SODQ D FODLP EDVHG RQ
WKDW GXW\ LV QRW FRPSOHWHO\ SUHHPSWHG XQGHU D % ´ Marin Gen. Hosp. v. Modesto
& Empire Traction Co. )G WK &LU
3ODLQWLII DOOHJHV WKDW $YLDOO YLRODWHG WKH FRQWUDFWXDO GXW\ RZHG WR 'RQ XQGHU VWDWH ODZ
E\ IDLOLQJ WR SURYLGH KLP ZLWK KHDOWK FDUH FRYHUDJH DV VSHFLILHG LQ WKH $JUHHPHQW DQG E\
IDLOLQJ WR UHLQVWDWH DQG H[WHQG KLV KHDOWKFDUH FRYHUDJH IURP 0DUFK WKURXJK -XO\
WR PDNH XS IRU WKH ODSVHG SHULRG +LV VWDWHODZ FODLP LV ³EDVHG RQ µRWKHU LQGHSHQGHQW
OHJDO GXW>LHV@¶ ZLWKLQ WKH PHDQLQJ RI Davila´ Id. DW DOWHUDWLRQ LQ RULJLQDO
'
,Q VXP WKHUH FDQ EH QR VHULRXV GLVDJUHHPHQW WKDW WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ LV DQ (5,6$
SODQ 3ODLQWLII KRZHYHU LV QRW VHHNLQJ UHOLHI XQGHU WKH WHUPV RI WKDW (5,6$ SODQ DW DOO EXW
LV LQVWHDG SURFHHGLQJ VROHO\ RQ WKH EDVLV RI D VHSDUDWH IUHHVWDQGLQJ VHYHUDQFH DJUHHPHQW
8QGHU WKHVH FLUFXPVWDQFHV WKHUH LV QR FRPSOHWH (5,6$ SUHHPSWLRQ EHFDXVH WKH RQO\ (5,6$
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 30 of 37 PageID 390
SODQ $YLDOO KDV HVWDEOLVKHG LV WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ SODLQWLII¶V VWDWHODZ FODLP UHJDUGLQJ WKH
$JUHHPHQW DQG VXEVHTXHQW FRQWUDFW WR UHLQVWDWH DQG H[WHQG 'RQ¶V KHDOWKFDUH FRYHUDJH FRXOG
QRW DW VRPH SRLQW LQ WLPH KDYH EHHQ EURXJKW XQGHU (5,6$ D % WR UHFRYHU EHQHILWV
WR HQIRUFH ULJKWV RU WR FODULI\ KLV ULJKW WR IXWXUH EHQHILWV XQGHU WKH 6HYHUDQFH 3ODQ DQG
SODLQWLII¶V EUHDFK RI FRQWUDFW FODLP LPSOLFDWHV RWKHU OHJDO GXWLHV WKDW DUH LQGHSHQGHQW RI
(5,6$ $FFRUGLQJO\ WKH FRXUW GHQLHV $YLDOO¶V PRWLRQ WR GLVPLVV SODLQWLII¶V VWDWHODZ FODLP
RQ WKH EDVLV RI FRPSOHWH (5,6$ SUHHPSWLRQ XQGHU D %
9,,
7KH FRXUW WXUQV QH[W WR $YLDOO¶V FRQWHQWLRQ WKDW SODLQWLII FDQQRW UHFRYHU RQ D EUHDFK
RI FRQWUDFW FODLP DJDLQVW $YLDOO DEVHQW DQ DOOHJDWLRQ WKDW 'RQ HOHFWHG &2%5$ FRQWLQXDWLRQ
FRYHUDJH DV WKH $JUHHPHQW UHTXLUHV
$
7KH HOHPHQWV RI D FODLP IRU EUHDFK RI FRQWUDFW XQGHU 7H[DV ODZ DUH ³ WKH H[LVWHQFH
RI D YDOLG FRQWUDFW SODLQWLII¶V SHUIRUPDQFH RI GXWLHV XQGHU WKH FRQWUDFW GHIHQGDQWV¶
%HFDXVH $YLDOO PRYHV WR GLVPLVV SODLQWLII¶V VWDWHODZ FODLP RQO\ RQ WKH EDVLV RI
complete SUHHPSWLRQ XQGHU D % WKH FRXUW GRHV QRW DGGUHVV ZKHWKHU WKH FODLP LV
SUHHPSWHG XQGHU WKH GRFWULQH RI FRQIOLFW SUHHPSWLRQ
$YLDOO UDLVHV WKLV DUJXPHQW EDVHG RQ WKH SUHVXPSWLRQ WKDW SODLQWLII¶V EUHDFK RI
FRQWUDFW FODLP LV FRPSOHWHO\ SUHHPSWHG E\ (5,6$ DQG WKXV FRQYHUWHG LQWR D FODLP EURXJKW
XQGHU (5,6$ See ' %U ³0RUHRYHU >'RQ@ FDQQRW UHFRYHU XQGHU (5,6$ RQ KLV
FODLPV DJDLQVW $YLDOO EHFDXVH KH GRHV QRW DQG LQ DOO SUREDELOLW\ FDQQRW DOOHJH WKDW KH
HOHFWHG &2%5$ FRQWLQXDWLRQ FRYHUDJH´ %XW $YLDOO¶V DUJXPHQWV DUH DSSOLFDEOH HYHQ
WKRXJK WKH FRXUW KDV UHMHFWHG $YLDOO¶V FRQWHQWLRQ WKDW SODLQWLII¶V EUHDFK RI FRQWUDFW FODLP LV
FRPSOHWHO\ SUHHPSWHG E\ (5,6$ DQG FRQYHUWHG LQWR D FODLP XQGHU D %
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 31 of 37 PageID 391
EUHDFK RI WKH FRQWUDFW DQG GDPDJHV WR SODLQWLII UHVXOWLQJ IURP WKH EUHDFK´ Orthoflex,
Inc. v. ThermoTek, Inc. )6XSSG 1' 7H[ )LW]ZDWHU &- appeal
docketed 1R WK &LU 6HSW FLWDWLRQ RPLWWHG
8QGHU 7H[DV ODZ WKH FRXUW¶V SULPDU\ FRQFHUQ ZKHQ LQWHUSUHWLQJ
D FRQWUDFW LV WR DVFHUWDLQ WKH SDUWLHV¶ LQWHQWLRQV DV H[SUHVVHG
REMHFWLYHO\ LQ WKH FRQWUDFW ,Q GRLQJ VR WKH FRXUW PXVW H[DPLQH
DQG FRQVLGHU WKH HQWLUH ZULWLQJ LQ DQ HIIRUW WR KDUPRQL]H DQG
JLYH HIIHFW WR DOO FRQWUDFWXDO SURYLVLRQV VR WKDW QRQH ZLOO EH
UHQGHUHG PHDQLQJOHVV /DQJXDJH VKRXOG EH JLYHQ LWV SODLQ DQG
JUDPPDWLFDO PHDQLQJ XQOHVV LW GHILQLWHO\ DSSHDUV WKDW WKH
SDUWLHV¶ LQWHQWLRQ ZRXOG WKHUHE\ EH GHIHDWHG :KHUH WKH
FRQWUDFW FDQ EH JLYHQ D GHILQLWH OHJDO PHDQLQJ RU LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ
LW LV QRW DPELJXRXV DQG WKH FRXUW ZLOO FRQVWUXH LW DV D PDWWHU RI
ODZ $ FRQWUDFWXDO SURYLVLRQ LV DPELJXRXV ZKHQ LWV PHDQLQJ LV
XQFHUWDLQ DQG GRXEWIXO RU LI LW LV UHDVRQDEO\ VXVFHSWLEOH WR PRUH
WKDQ RQH LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ :KHWKHU D FRQWUDFW LV DPELJXRXV LV D
TXHVWLRQ RI ODZ IRU WKH FRXUW WR GHFLGH E\ ORRNLQJ DW WKH FRQWUDFW
DV D ZKROH LQ OLJKW RI WKH FLUFXPVWDQFHV SUHVHQW ZKHQ WKH
FRQWUDFW ZDV HQWHUHG
Hoffman v. L&M Arts )6XSSG 1' 7H[ )LW]ZDWHU &- FLWLQJ
Bank One, Tex., N.A. v. FDIC )6XSSG 1' 7H[ )LW]ZDWHU - aff’d
in part, rev’d in part on other grounds )G WK &LU ³$ FRQWUDFW LV QRW
DPELJXRXV PHUHO\ EHFDXVH WKH SDUWLHV KDYH D GLVDJUHHPHQW RQ WKH FRUUHFW LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ´
REO Indus., Inc. v. Natural Gas Pipeline Co. of Am. )G WK &LU
&RXUWV DUH WR FRQVWUXH FRQWUDFWV ³µIURP D XWLOLWDULDQ VWDQGSRLQW EHDULQJ LQ PLQG WKH SDUWLFXODU
EXVLQHVV DFWLYLW\ VRXJKW WR EH VHUYHG¶ DQG µZLOO DYRLG ZKHQ SRVVLEOH DQG SURSHU D
FRQVWUXFWLRQ ZKLFK LV XQUHDVRQDEOH LQHTXLWDEOH DQG RSSUHVVLYH¶´ Frost Nat’l Bank v. L &
F Distribs., Ltd. 6:G 7H[ TXRWLQJ Reilly v. Rangers Mgmt., Inc
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 32 of 37 PageID 392
6:G 7H[
%
6HFWLRQ RI WKH $JUHHPHQW SURYLGHV
&RPSO ([ $ DW HPSKDVLV DGGHG 7KXV 'RQ ZDV UHTXLUHG WR HOHFW &2%5$
FRQWLQXDWLRQ FRYHUDJH LQ RUGHU WR FRQWLQXH WKH KHDOWK FDUH FRYHUDJH VSHFLILHG LQ RI WKH
$JUHHPHQW 3ODLQWLII GRHV QRW DOOHJH WKDW 'RQ HOHFWHG &2%5$ FRQWLQXDWLRQ FRYHUDJH
3ODLQWLII DVVHUWV WKDW XQGHU WKH $JUHHPHQW ³>'RQ@¶V VDODU\ DQG PHGLFDOKRVSLWDOKHDOWK
EHQHILWV were to continue XQWLO 0DUFK DW ZKLFK WLPH >'RQ@¶V HPSOR\PHQW DW
'HIHQGDQW ZRXOG HQG´ &RPSO HPSKDVLV DGGHG %XW WKLV DOOHJDWLRQ LV DW RGGV ZLWK
WKH WHUPV RI WKH $JUHHPHQW LWVHOI ZKLFK SODLQWLII KDV DWWDFKHG WR WKH FRPSODLQW DQG WKH FRXUW
LV SHUPLWWHG WR FRQVLGHU LQ GHFLGLQJ $YLDOO¶V PRWLRQ WR GLVPLVV See Lone Star Fund V (U.S.),
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 33 of 37 PageID 393
L.P. v. Barclays Bank PLC )G WK &LU
,Q UHVSRQVH WR $YLDOO¶V PRWLRQ WR GLVPLVV SODLQWLII FRQWHQGV WKDW WKH $JUHHPHQW LV
DPELJXRXV DV WR ZKHWKHU D &2%5$ QRWLFH ZDV QHFHVVDU\ WR EHJLQ FRYHUDJH ³DQG LQ IDFW
$YLDOO EHJDQ FRYHUDJH DQG FRQWLQXHG LW IRU DERXW WKUHH PRQWKV EHIRUH FDQFHOOLQJ LW LQ
0DUFK HYHQ DIWHU 3ODLQWLII KDG ILOHG DQ HOHFWLRQ WR FRQWLQXH LW´ WKDW ³>F@RQWUDU\ WR
$YLDOO¶V FODLPV WKDW WKH LQVXUDQFH VKRXOG QHYHU KDYH FRQWLQXHG SDVW 0DUFK WKH
HQG RI WKH VHYHUDQFH SHULRG >'RQ@¶V SD\FKHFNV UHIOHFW GHGXFWLRQ RI LQVXUDQFH SUHPLXPV IRU
DERXW WKUHH PRQWKV WKHQ D FHVVDWLRQ RI UHGXFWLRQV WKHQ D UHVXPSWLRQ RI GHGXFWLRQV
WKURXJK WKH HQG RI WKH VHYHUDQFH SHULRG´ DQG WKDW WKH LQVXUDQFH FDUULHU¶V UHFRUGV UHIOHFW WKDW
'RQ KDG SROLF\ FRYHUDJH IRU WKH HQWLUH VHYHUDQFH SHULRG ³VR WKH GHQLDO RI EHQHILWV WR >'RQ@
DQG KLV IDPLO\ ZDV DUELWUDU\ DQG XQMXVWLILHG´ 3 %U
7KH FRXUW GLVDJUHHV WKDW WKH $JUHHPHQW LV DPELJXRXV DV WR ZKHWKHU &2%5$ QRWLFH
ZDV QHFHVVDU\ WR EHJLQ FRYHUDJH ,W VWDWHV FOHDUO\ DQG XQDPELJXRXVO\ WKDW ³
&RPSO ([ $ DW $QG SODLQWLII¶V RWKHU
DOOHJDWLRQV²WR WKH H[WHQW WKH\ DUH DFWXDOO\ SOHDGHG LQ WKH FRPSODLQW²GR QRW SODXVLEO\ DOOHJH
WKDW 'RQ HOHFWHG &2%5$ FRYHUDJH RU WKDW $YLDOO²H[SOLFLWO\ RU LPSOLFLWO\²H[FXVHG KLV
REOLJDWLRQ WR VR
$FFRUGLQJO\ WKH FRXUW JUDQWV $YLDOO¶V PRWLRQ WR GLVPLVV SODLQWLII¶V EUHDFK RI FRQWUDFW
FODLP WR WKH H[WHQW WKLV FODLP LV EDVHG RQ $YLDOO¶V ³IDLO>XUH@ WR SURYLGH WR >'RQ@ WKH KHDOWK
FDUH FRYHUDJH VSHFLILHG LQ RI WKH >$@JUHHPHQW IURP 1RYHPEHU WKURXJK WKH ILUVW
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 34 of 37 PageID 394
RU VHFRQG ZHHN RI 0DUFK ´ &RPSO.
&
7KH FRXUW GHQLHV $YLDOO¶V PRWLRQ WR GLVPLVV SODLQWLII¶V EUHDFK RI FRQWUDFW FODLP RQ WKH
EDVLV WKDW (5,6$ SURKLELWV RUDO PRGLILFDWLRQV WR ZULWWHQ HPSOR\HH EHQHILW SODQV 7KH FRXUW
KDV FRQFOXGHG DERYH WKDW WKH $JUHHPHQW GRHV QRW FRQVWLWXWH DQ HPSOR\HH EHQHILW SODQ
JRYHUQHG E\ (5,6$ See supra 9 & $FFRUGLQJO\ $YLDOO¶V DUJXPHQW WKDW WKH
$JUHHPHQW FDQQRW EH RUDOO\ PRGLILHG based on the provisions of ERISA LV LQDSSOLFDEOH
9,,,
)LQDOO\ $YLDOO PDLQWDLQV WKDW (5,6$ SUHHPSWV DOO RI SODLQWLII¶V UHTXHVWV IRU H[WUD
FRQWUDFWXDO GDPDJHV ,W FLWHV FDVHV LQ ZKLFK LW PDLQWDLQV FRXUWV KDYH KHOG WKDW ³H[WUD
FRQWUDFWXDO GDPDJHV DNLQ WR WKRVH VRXJKW E\ >'RQ@ LQ WKH &RPSODLQW WR EH XQDYDLODEOH LQ DQ
(5,6$ DFWLRQ VXFK DV WKLV´ ' %U $QG $YLDOO PRYHV WKH FRXUW WR GLVPLVV ZLWK SUHMXGLFH
DOO RI SODLQWLII¶V UHTXHVWV IRU H[WUDFRQWUDFWXDO GDPDJHV
$W WKH PRWLRQ WR GLVPLVV VWDJH WKH FRXUW PXVW GHFLGH ZKHWKHU SODLQWLII KDV SOHDGHG D
SODXVLEOH FODLP IRU UHOLHI See, e.g., Twombly 86 DW ,Q WKH VHFRQG FRXQW RI WKH
FRPSODLQW SODLQWLII DOOHJHV WKDW $YLDOO ³IDLOHG WR JLYH WLPHO\ SURSHU QRWLFH RI WKH ULJKW RI
>'RQ@ WR H[WHQG KHDOWK FDUH FRYHUDJH DIWHU 0DUFK DQGRU WR DFW XSRQ >'RQ@¶V
HOHFWLRQ WR VHFXUH VXFK FRYHUDJH´ &RPSO ,Q FRQQHFWLRQ ZLWK WKLV FODLP SODLQWLII
VHHNV ³WKH ILQHV DQG SHQDOWLHV DQG RWKHU UHPHGLHV LQFOXGLQJ GDPDJHV DQG DWWRUQH\V¶ IHHV
%HFDXVH WKH TXHVWLRQ KDV QRW EHHQ UDLVHG WKH FRXUW GRHV QRW FRQVLGHU ZKHWKHU 7H[DV
ODZ ZRXOG VLPLODUO\ SURKLELW WKH DOOHJHG RUDO PRGLILFDWLRQ RI WKH $JUHHPHQW
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 35 of 37 PageID 395
SURYLGHG LQ (5,6$ LQFOXGLQJ WKH FLYLO UHPHGLHV SURYLGHG LQ D IRU SDLQ
VXIIHULQJ DQG GHDWK DQG IRU SDLG DQG LQFXUUHG KRVSLWDOL]DWLRQ DQG PHGLFDO FRVWV DQG
H[SHQVHV´ Id. $YLDOO GRHV QRW PRYH WR GLVPLVV FRXQW WZR RI WKH FRPSODLQW RQ WKH
PHULWV
6HFWLRQ D RI 7LWOH SURYLGHV LQ SHUWLQHQW SDUW WKDW D FLYLO DFWLRQ PD\ EH
EURXJKW
E\ D SDUWLFLSDQW EHQHILFLDU\ RU ILGXFLDU\ $ WR HQMRLQ DQ\ DFW
RU SUDFWLFH ZKLFK YLRODWHV DQ\ SURYLVLRQ RI WKLV VXEFKDSWHU RU WKH
WHUPV RI WKH SODQ RU % WR REWDLQ RWKHU DSSURSULDWH HTXLWDEOH
UHOLHI L WR UHGUHVV VXFK YLRODWLRQV RU LL WR HQIRUFH DQ\
SURYLVLRQV RI WKLV VXEFKDSWHU RU WKH WHUPV RI WKH SODQ
Id. $OWKRXJK WKH VWDWXWH FRQIHUV EURDG GLVFUHWLRQ RQ FRXUWV ZKHQ JUDQWLQJ HTXLWDEOH GDPDJHV
VRPH FRXUWV KDYH OLPLWHG UHFRYHULHV LQ WKH FRQWH[W RI &2%5$ QRWLFH YLRODWLRQV 6XFK
UHFRYHULHV KDYH EHHQ FRQILQHG WR FRPSHQVDWRU\ GDPDJHV PHDVXUHG E\ WKH H[WUD PHGLFDO
H[SHQVHV WKDW WKH SODLQWLII LQFXUUHG SRVWWHUPLQDWLRQ EHFDXVH KH ZDV QRW QRWLILHG RI KLV ULJKW
WR FRQWLQXH FRYHUDJH PLQXV GHGXFWLEOHV DQG SUHPLXPV WKDW WKH SODLQWLII ZRXOG KDYH KDG WR
SD\ XQGHU &2%5$ WR FRQWLQXH FRYHUDJH See, e.g., Sonnichsen v. Aries Marine Corp.
)6XSSG :' /D ³:KHQ &2%5$ YLRODWLRQV UHVXOW LQ WKH ORVV RI D
TXDOLILHG EHQHILFLDU\¶V LQVXUDQFH FRYHUDJH FRXUWV KDYH LQWHUSUHWHG (5,6$¶V FLYLO
HQIRUFHPHQW VWDWXWH DV HQWLWOLQJ WKH TXDOLILHG EHQHILFLDU\ WR FRPSHQVDWRU\ GDPDJHV LQ DQ
DPRXQW HTXDO WR PHGLFDO H[SHQVHV PLQXV GHGXFWLEOHV DQG SUHPLXPV WKDW WKH EHQHILFLDU\
ZRXOG KDYH KDG WR SD\ IRU &2%5$ FRYHUDJH´ Ward v. Bethenergy Mines, Inc.
)6XSS 6' : 9D ³7KH SXUSRVH RI WKH FLYLO HQIRUFHPHQW SURYLVLRQV RI
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 36 of 37 PageID 396
&2%5$ LV DERYH DOO WR SXW SODLQWLIIV LQ WKH VDPH SRVLWLRQ WKH\ ZRXOG KDYH EHHQ LQ EXW IRU
WKH YLRODWLRQ´ FLWDWLRQ RPLWWHG
,I SODLQWLII LV VXFFHVVIXO RQ 'RQ¶V (5,6$ FODLP WKH FRXUW ZLOO DZDUG DQ\ SURYHG
GDPDJHV WKDW DUH DYDLODEOH XQGHU WKH VWDWXWH ,I SODLQWLII FDQ VKRZ DQ HQWLWOHPHQW WR
FRPSHQVDWRU\ GDPDJHV SODLQWLII PD\ DOVR EH HQWLWOHG WR DWWRUQH\¶V IHHV DQG FRVWV See
86& J $OWKRXJK WKH FRXUW GRHV QRW VXJJHVW WKDW SODLQWLII ZLOO EH DEOH WR UHFRYHU
H[WUDFRQWUDFWXDO GDPDJHV LQ FRQQHFWLRQ ZLWK WKH (5,6$ FODLP WKH FRXUW GHFOLQHV DW WKLV
VWDJH LQ WKH SURFHHGLQJV WR GLVPLVV SODLQWLII¶V UHTXHVWV IRU H[WUDFRQWUDFWXDO GDPDJHV
7KH KROGLQJV LQ 9,, % DQG 9,,, DUH GLVWLQJXLVKDEOH EHFDXVH WKH\ DGGUHVV
GLIIHUHQW RPLVVLRQV DQG EHQHILWV WKDW UHODWH WR GLIIHUHQW WLPH SHULRGV
6HFWLRQ 9,, DGGUHVVHV SODLQWLII¶V EUHDFK RI FRQWUDFW FODLP KROGLQJ WKDW LI 'RQ ZDQWHG
WR HOHFW &2%5$ FRYHUDJH IRU WKH LQLWLDO VHYHUDQFH SHULRG DQG DIWHU WKDW IRU D ORQJHU SHULRG
DW WKLV RZQ H[SHQVH KH ZDV UHTXLUHG XQGHU WKH $JUHHPHQW WR HOHFW &2%5$ FRYHUDJH
%HFDXVH SODLQWLII GRHV QRW SODXVLEO\ DOOHJH WKDW 'RQ PDGH VXFK DQ HOHFWLRQ WKH FRXUW
GLVPLVVHV SODLQWLII¶V EUHDFK RI FRQWUDFW FODLP WR WKH H[WHQW LW LV EDVHG RQ $YLDOO¶V IDLOXUH WR
SURYLGH 'RQ WKH KHDOWK FDUH FRYHUDJH VSHFLILHG LQ RI WKH $JUHHPHQW IURP 1RYHPEHU
WKURXJK WKH ILUVW RU VHFRQG ZHHN RI 0DUFK
6HFWLRQ 9,,, LQ FRQWUDVW DGGUHVVHV SODLQWLII¶V (5,6$ FODLP ZKLFK DOOHJHV WKDW $YLDOO
IDLOHG WR DGHTXDWHO\ QRWLI\ 'RQ RI KLV ULJKW XQGHU (5,6$ WR H[WHQG KHDOWK FDUH FRYHUDJH DIWHU
WKH HQG RI WKH QRUPDO VHYHUDQFH SHULRG DQGRU WR DFW XSRQ KLV HOHFWLRQ WR VHFXUH VXFK
FRYHUDJH %HFDXVH SODLQWLII KDV DGHTXDWHO\ SOHDGHG WKDW $YLDOO ³IDLOHG WR JLYH WLPHO\ SURSHU
QRWLFH RI WKH ULJKW RI 3ODLQWLII WR H[WHQG KHDOWK FDUH FRYHUDJH DIWHU 0DUFK DQGRU
WR DFW XSRQ >'RQ@¶V HOHFWLRQ WR VHFXUH VXFK FRYHUDJH´ &RPSO WKH FRXUW GHFOLQHV WR
GLVPLVV SODLQWLII¶V FODLP IRU H[WUDFRQWUDFWXDO GDPDJHV XQGHU (5,6$
$YLDOO PDLQWDLQV WKDW EHFDXVH FODLPV IRU EHQHILWV XQGHU D % GR QRW
HQWLWOH WKH SDUWLFLSDQW WR D MXU\ WULDO ³WKH &RXUW VKRXOG ILQG WKDW >SODLQWLII@ LV QRW HQWLWOHG WR
D MXU\ WULDO RQ DQ\ RI >SODLQWLII¶V@ FODLPV´ ' %U 3ODLQWLII KDV QRW UHVSRQGHG WR WKLV
DUJXPHQW %HFDXVH WKH FRXUW KDV FRQFOXGHG WKDW (5,6$ GRHV QRW FRPSOHWHO\ SUHHPSW
SODLQWLII¶V VWDWHODZ EUHDFK RI FRQWUDFW FODLP LW GHFOLQHV DW WKLV MXQFWXUH WR KROG WKDW SODLQWLII
LV QRW HQWLWOHG WR D MXU\ WULDO RQ DQ\ FODLP 7KH FRXUW ZLOO UHYLVLW WKLV TXHVWLRQ ODWHU LI
QHFHVVDU\
Case 3:15-cv-00571-D Document 51 Filed 01/06/17
Page 37 of 37 PageID 397
$FFRUGLQJO\ IRU WKH UHDVRQV H[SODLQHG WKH FRXUW JUDQWV $YLDOO¶V PRWLRQ WR GLVPLVV
SODLQWLII¶V FODLP IRU EUHDFK RI WKH $JUHHPHQW EXW LW RWKHUZLVH GHQLHV WKH PRWLRQ
SO ORDERED
-DQXDU\
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
6,'1(< $ ),7=:$7(5
81,7(' 67$7(6 ',675,&7 -8'*(
]]>
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
