Riser v. United States Department of State

Filing 65

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER GRANTING 63 MOTION to Dismiss Plaintiff's Legal Fees And Cause Of Action, DENYING 60 MOTION for Summary Judgment, DENYING 64 MOTION to Strike 63 MOTION to Dismiss Plaintiff's Legal Fees And Cause Of Action.(Signed by Judge Keith P Ellison) Parties notified.(sloewe)

U N I E D STA T E S D I T R I T C O U R T T S C SO U TH EM DI T RI T OF TEX AS S C H O U ST O N D I ISI N VO D A R R Y L W .R I E R , S Pl i t f , a n if
C IV I A C T IO N N O .09- 273 L 3

U N I E D STAT E S DE PA R T M EN T O F T ST A T E and U N I ED STAT E S O FF I E T C O F PER SO N N E L M A N A G E M EN T ,
D ef ndant . e s

M EM O M N D U M A N D O R D E R
-

Pe digbefr t eCour aePlitf sMoton frSumm ayJ dgme t( oc. n n oeh t r anif io ru n D No.

60 a d M oton t Sti e( oc No.64) a d Defnda t'M oton t Dim is( oc No. )n i o rk D . ,n e ns i o ssD . 63 .Ha i g consdeed t epa te 'flngs a d t e a plca l lw ,t eCo r tndst a ) vn i r h ris ii n h p i be a h u t i h t
Pli tf sM oton f rSum m a y J do e ta d M oton t Sti e s oul be DENI D a d a n if io ru nn i o rk h d En
t a D e e da t 'M o i n t Di m i s s oul be G R A N T E D . h t fn ns to o s s h d
1.

PLA I T I F' REO U EST FOR FEES.CO STS.A ND DAM A G ES NFS
Pli tf br ught s i a ans De e da t a e c e purua t t t e Fr edom of a n if o u t g i t fn n g n is s n o h e

l fr ain Ac (1O1 ') 5U. . .j 552,a dt ePrva y Ac,5U. . .j 55 a.I hi n o m to t : A ', S C F n h ic t SC 2ns
M oton f r Summ a' J dgm e t Pl i tf now s e s at m e ' f es of $200,pa al g l io tu y n , an if e k to y s e r ea
Riser v. United States Department of State Doc. 65

f e of$35, 00,a d da a e of$1 0, 00. e da t a gu t a no f e orc sss o l es 4 n m gs 0 0 Def n n s r e h t e s o t h u d
be a a de . wrd

l t e Or e of Ocobe 22,201 ( oc.No.55) te Cour de id Plitf s n h dr tr 0D ,h t n e an if
r q e tf r at m e ' f esunde t e Prvac Ac on t e gr unds t a Pli tf i pr s e u s o to y s e rh i y t ho h t a n if s o e

Dockets.Justia.com

a d i nota atr e ,s i notelgi l f rat r ey' fes (#.a 1 (iig Smih v ns n to n y o s i be o to n s e . f t 5 ctn t.

O 'ren,59 F.d 1 41 1995 W L 413 5 ,a *2 ( t Ci.J ne 1 ,1 95 ( e c da ) Bi 3 2, 0 2 t 5h r u 9 9 ) p r u m (npubls e l.Pli tf te fld a ote r ques frfe a d c ss icudig $200f ra u ih d ) anif h n ie n h r e t o e s n o t,n l n o
c ns la i n wih a a t m e , As ok Bal a d ove $35, 00 f r t a a e a s r i e ' o u tto t n to y h i, n r 0 o t r l g l e v c s' p
pr vi e by t o pl i t Pr c s or , a s b- ntt of ç r f s i na Li e Skil M e t r o dd t m a n o e s s' u e iy c ' t o e so l f p ls n o s

a dCoa hes LLC. ( eeDocNo.58,Ame de Re l t M e o a dum a dOr e )'he n c , 'S ' n d py o m r n n dn F
Cour he d a hea ng on t a r que t on Nove be 1 ,201 ,durng whi h Pl i tf tl d ht e s m r7 0 i c an if a kno l dge t a t e onl m e be s ofPr f s i na Lie Skil M e t r and Coac es c w e d hth ymr o e so l f ls n o s h, LLC a e Pl i tf a d hi s ous .The Cour pe m it d Pli tf t s bm i a dii na r an if n sp e t r te an if o u t d to l a t ort ,a dhes bm it d t i r q e tf rf e a d c sspur ua tt t eEqua Ac e st u h iy n u te h s e u s o e s n o t s n o h l cs o

J sieAc ($ AJ ',28U. . .j2 1 . u tc t t A ' E ) SC 4 2
Pa ae alf esm a be r c ve a l unde t e EAJ .Se Ri hln Se .Se vc Co. r lg e y e o rb e rh A e c i c r ie

v Ch rof 5 3 U..5 1 ( 0 8 .Ho e e,te Fi h Cic i h shed t a Rihi ' . e tfi 5 S 7 2 0 ) w v r h h ru t a l h t c ln s
t ic s i n ofpar l ga f eswa c nfne s l l t t os f e as oc a e wih pa a e a s û s u so d ae l e s o i d o ey o h e e s s i t d t r l g l e pl ye by t e 1w 511 r pr s ntng t e pli tf . Unie St t s v Cl r ,579 F. d mod ha 11 e e e i h a n if' ' td a e . a o 3

4 2 4 7( t Ci. 0 9 .nt i c s , an ifh sma en cam (e ao es o ig t a 5 , 6 5h r 2 0 ) I h s a e Plitf a d o li lt ln h w n ) h t
t e pa aega s r i e we e c nne t d t a y at r e ,ltaone a at m e r pr s ntng h r l l e v c s r o c e o n to n y e l n to y e e e i Pli tf Ac or i gl , t e Cour tnds no ba i t a a d s c f e . a n if c d n y h ti s s o w r u h e s1

M or ove ,by Pl i tf s own a m is o a t e Nove be 1 hea i g,t e onl er an if d sin t h m r7 rn h y
e pl ye s of t e t a alga s r i e ' c m pa y a e Pli tf a d hi s o s . l hi moe h t r e l e v c s' o n r a n if n p s p ue n s
1TheCo r noest at i t epa ae als r iesc m pa ywc epr cii g lw wihoutt es pe viin ofan u t t h , f h r lg e vc o n r a tcn a t h u r so at m e ,t i woul r ie a dif r nts tofis es Te as1w pr hi ist os who ae nota m itd t t e to y h s d as fe e e su . x a o bt h e r d te o h sae barfom pr ctci g lw ,de ied asite pr parton ofa pla i g oroterdoc m enti cdentt an tt r a in a fn th e a i e dn h u ni o a ton ors e ilpr ce dig ort e ma a em e toft e a ton orpr ce dig on behafofa cle tbef r a ci p ca o e n h ng n h ci oen l in o e

jd ei c u t swel sasr iern ee o to c u ticu igtegvn o a vieo tern eigo u g n o r a la e vc e d rd u f o r,n ldn h iig f d c r h e d rn f
any s r ie r quii g te us of lgals ilor knowldge,s c asprpa ig a wil c ntac,or ot e e vc e rn h e e kl e uh e rn l, o r t hr isr m e t t e lgal e fct of whi h under t e f cs and co cl so s i vol ed mus be caef ly n tu n , h e fe c h at n u in n v t r ul

d tr ie . Te . tCo e j811 1& 1 2. eem n d' x Gov. d . .0 ' 0

pe ii n f rf e prort t a he rng,howe e ,Pl i tf f ie t r vea t t eCo r t a tto o e s i o h t a i v r an if al d o e l o h u th t he had a y c nneci n t t e c m pa y;onl t e Cour' l tr e r s ar h r veae hi no to o h o n yh ts n e n t e e c e ld s

r l .Asnot d durng t ehe rng, he Co r fndst i l c ofc ndorv e ty to blng. At oe e i h ai t u ti hs ak a al r u i
ami i um ,i c eaest ei pr s i n t a Pl i tf s ug tr i bur e e tf rpa m e t t nm t r t h m e so h t a n if o h em s m n o y n s o hi own pa a e a s r i e co pa y i o de t cr um ve tt e Cour' prorr lng t a a s r l g l e v c s m n n r r o ic nh ts i u i h t pr s ,non-a ye pary i note tte t a t m e ' f e .Unde t e EAJ , court m ay oe lw r t s n il d o to y s e s rh A s

deciet a ad fe wheetpe ilcic m sa ce ma eanawa d unus '28U.. .j ln o w r e s r % ca ru tn s k s r j t' SC 241 ( )1( ) a dunderFOI c ursG a a s s a ans teUnie Sttsr a o a l 2 d ( )A , n A o t G y se s g i t h m td ae e s n b e at m e fesand ote ltgain coss.... 5 U. . .b552()4)E)(mpha i a de ) to y e h r ii to t ' ' SC a( ( e ss d d .
D ue t Pl i tf s f iur t dic os hi i vol e e t wih t e pa a e al s r i es o an if a l e o s l e s n v m n th rlg e vc

c mp n ,te Co r f d ta ç p ca cru sa c sma e a a ad u j s' u d rte o a y h u t i s h t t e il ic m tn e k n w r n u t n e h n s '
EA J ,a d,i is di c e i n unde FO I ,a s tnds i i a pr prae t a a d Pl i tf A n n t s r to r A lo i t n p o i t o w r an if

at m e ' f e of$200. to y s e s 2

Tot ee tn t a Plitf s e sfe a d e ssu de j5 2 ( )3 o t eP ia y h x e t h t an if e k e s n o t n r 5 ag ( ) f h rv c
Ac ,t e Cour,i isdi c e i n,de i ss c r que tf rt e r a o sdi c s e a ove.To th t n t s r to ne u h e s o h esn su sd b

t e e tnttatPlitf s e sfesa d cossunde 9 552ag)4)ofte Prvac Ac,te h xe h anif e k e n t r (( h i y th
Cour deni s s c r ques be aus t e e i nots fi i ntevi e ce t demonsr t t a t e uh e t c e hr s u fc e dn o tae h t t he a e cy a t d i a ma ner whih wa i t ntona a d wilu . W ih r ga d t ' t gn ce n n c s ne i l n lf l' t e r o '

Pl i tf scli f rda age unde t e Prva y Ac,t eCour ar a y de i d t i r ques a n if am o m s rh i c th t le d n e h s e t
i t eOcobe 22 or e on t egr undst a Pl i tf ha notpr ve i t ntona orwilu nh tr dr h o h t a n if s o n ne i l lf l

2I s holi g, t eCour e pr sesno opii n a t whehe Pl itf woul ot e wiequalf f rf e a d n o dn h t x es n o s o t r an if d hr s iy o e s n c ssunde t e saut s Fore a pl,t eCour doe notde ie wheterPli tf is bsantalypr vaied' ot r h tt e . xm e h ts cd h an if lu t i l e l ' unde FOI ,whehe he i a ç r valng pary' unde t e EAJ ,orwhet e Pli tf s c ns lai n wih rA t r s ç e ii p t' rh A h r a n if o u tto t at m eyAs okB alwass fiintyr l tdt t i c s . to h i u fce l ea e o h s a e

c nd c byt eage ce ora y pa tc lra ve s ef c heha s fe e .( oc. 55,a o ut h n is n riu a d rè fe t s u fr d D No. t

1 - 5. 41 )
lI.

PL A I TI F ' M O T I N T O STR IK E NFS O
-

Pli tf moves t srke Def nda t ' M oton t Dim is a d Re pons t a n if o ti e ns i o ssn s eo

Pli tf sM oto f rSumm a y J dr e ton t ep oundst a i i vol e aG ootis e, a n if in o ru n h h ttn v s ' m su ' '
t ati i a és andal usm at r' and t a Def nda t ç al d t def nd agans Pl i tf s h t s çc o te ,' h t e n s l ie o e f i t an if

M o in f rSu m ayJ dg e t' e Fe . Ci . 1 ( .Th Co r d e n tfndt a to o m r u m n . S e d R. v P. 2 9 e u t o s o i h t '
Def nda t ' flng c nsiut s Ea i s fi int de ens o a y r dundant i m ae i l e n s ii o tt e tn n u fc e f ern e , m t ra , i pe tne t ors a da ousm at n'1 .Ac or i gl ,t eM oton t Sti e i de i d. m ri n , c n l te ' d c d n y h i o rk s n e

11 1.

GOVERNM EN T ' M P T I N TO DI M I S S O SS
-

The Cour fndst a t e De e da ta e ce ha e now f ly c m ple wih t er ti h th f n n g n is v ul o id t h i oblgai nsunde FOI ,t e Prva y Ac ,and t e Cou ts or e s a d have pr duce a1 i to r A h ic t h r' d r, n o d1

r c r sr s onsve t Pl i tf sr que t t ata e note e ptd by saut .Ac o di gl , e o d e p i o a n if e ss h r xm e tt e c r n y t e Co r fndsi a pr praet dim i st eca e h u t i s p o it o s s h s .

I. V

CONCLUSI N O

For t e r a ons s ae i t i or e ,Pli tf s N oton f r Sun n a y J dgn e t h es t td n h s d r a n iF f i o xA r u xn

( oc No.60)a d Moton t Sti e( oc. 64)aeDENI D,a dDefnda t'Moton D. n i o rk D No. r En e ns i

t Dim is( o . . 3 i GRANTED. o s s D c No 6 ) s

I I SO O R D E R E D . TS

SI N ED atHo son,Texas on t i t e G ut , hs h

W Aay ofDece ber 2010. d m,

4

K EI H ELLISON T U N I ED A TE S D I TR I T J D G E T SCU

5