Zeedyk v. Thaler

Filing 31

ORDER denying 30 Motion for Relief from Judgment. (Signed by Judge Lee H Rosenthal) Parties notified.(gclair, 4)

United States District Court
Southern District of Texas

ENTERED
I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
FO R TH E SO U TH ER N D I
STR I T O F TEX A S
C
HO USTO N DI SI
VI ON

October 21, 2016
David J. Bradley, Clerk

PAU L J SEPH ZEED Y K ,
O

(
TDCJCI #1
- D 608279)
Pe ii r
ttone ,
VS.

CI L ACTI NO .4- 3VI
ON
1 1 0781

LORI D A VI
E
S,

Res
ponde .
nt
O RD ER

Thepeii r Pa J e Zee s
ttone, ul osph dyk, oughtha a c
be s omusr ifunde 28U. C.j2254,
ele
r
S.
c le ng hi 2009sa ef l c ci f f l drvi whiei oxi t d, hid ofe e.On
ha lngi s
t t eoùy onvi ton or eony i ng l nt ca e t r f ns

Mac 1 , 01 ,hi c u t r ne t er s o e tsmoin f rs
rh 2 2 4 t s o r ga t d h e p nd n ' to o ummayj d me ta dds se
r u g n n imis d
Ze dyk' pe ii on t m e is
e
s tton
he rt .

Ze d k' Rue6 ( mo ina k t i c u toro ntej d me ta dg a t m r l f n
e y s l 0b) to s s hs o r t e pe h u g n n rn hi ei o
e
hi s fcinc of e denc cli .He a g st tt r wasi ufi inte de et s
s uf e y- - vi e am
r ue ha he e
ns fc e vi nc o uppo tt
r he
de dl we pon fndi on hi drvi whie i oxi t d c c i
a y a
i ng
s i ng
l nt ca e onviton. He a gues t the i not
r
ha
s

c le nghi c ci andt thei a t lyi
halngi s onviton
ha s cual nnoce a t t de ywe po fndi ( ke
nt s o he adl a n i ng. Doc t
EntyNo.30)
r
.

Ze d kmo e f rr le fo tej d me tu d rt et ac al r viin' fRue6 ()
e y v d o eif r m h u g n n e h s th l p o so 'o l 0b .
c
Soi v Dr te 4 6F. p' 3 , 0 (t Ci. 011.TheFit Cic iha f o sse tyh l t a
l . ek , 3 Ap x 03 3 6 5h r 2 )
s
fh rut s ç n itn l ed h t
c
rle unde ge tonl60( ( i mut l e l i fom r le t rs tons( )4 .9 si v.
eif r s ci
b)6) s ualy xcusve r eif mde eci 1-5)5He lng
CSX Tr p.I . 396F.d 632,643( h Ci. )
ans , nc,
3
5t r 2005 .

Rue6 ( )6 i E ne ta r iayr me y' e a eû (l d sr f r u iil r c s t a
l 0 b ( ) s t xr o dn r e d 'b c us ç the e ie o aj dca p o e s h t
a
d
i p e itb ema d tsc u ini r o e n j d me t.' re v Fe n r 1 6F.d 1 0 ,1 0
s r dca l n ae a to n e p nig u g n s' Ca tr . n e , 3 3 0 0 0 7
'
(t Ci. 9 8 ( uoi Balyv Ry nStv d rn Co,I c, 9 F.d 1 7,1 0(t Ci.1 9 :.
5h r 1 9 ) q tng ie . a e e o ig . n . 8 4 2 5 6 5h r 9 0
Rul 60( ( moto t l begr e onl i e r di ycrtmsnnce ar prs nt'He sv
e b)6) ins i l antd y f xtaor nar icz t s e e e .' s .
wi
Coc r l,281F. 21 21 ( t Ci.
k el
3d 2, 6 5h r 2002)
.

Ze ykague t thei entte t rlefunde Rul 60( ( be aus t sc tovel
ed r s ha s ild o ei
r e b)6) c e hi our rooked
hi c lng t t s t inc oft e de ast t de ywe pon fndi l isor rgr ntng
s hale e o he ufk e y he vi nce o he adl a
ng. n t de a i

ters o d n ' mo inf rs mmayj d me t t i c u tds se Ze d k' s fkin y o t
h e p n e ts to o u r u g n , h s o r imis d e y s u f e c f he
e de e c am be us i wa pr ed al ba r Ale nai l t sc tf
vi nc l i ca e t s oc m ly red. t r tvey, hi our ound t tZe yk'
ha ed s

c aln et t s fi in yo t ee d n elc e me i.( c t tyNo 1 , p. - 2 .
h l g o he u tce c f h vie c a k d rt Do ke Enr . 3 p 313 )
e
Tot e tn t a Ze d ka ks h sc u tor o nis u me tb s do t esr n t o h s
he x e t h t e y s t i o r t e pe t j dg n a e n h te gh f i
s fcenc oft - de c am ,he ha no s
ufi i y- -he evi nce l i
s t hown aba i f r lef M c ilan v M Bank For
ss or e i . M li .
t

Worh,N A. 4 F. 362,367 ( t Ci.1993) An a a,no a Rul 60( ()moton,i t
t
, 3d
5h r
.
ppe l t
e b)6
i s he
a opraeve cet c l adititc tsj
ppr it hil o halenge src our' udgmentont meis SeeDizv Stphe ,
he rt.
a . e ns 731
F. 370,377- (t Ci. 3) edy a aldt sc tsdeni oft ha speii The
3d
78 5h r 201 .Ze k ppe e hi our'
al he bea tton.
Fit Cic tde edac rii a eofa
fh r ui ni
e tfc t
ppeaabiiyon J y 1 201 The Supr m eCour a fnne a
l lt
ul , 5.
e
t fi d nd
de e c r i ar on J nual 11 201
ni d e tor i a y , 6.

Zee k ha s
dy s hown nobassf hi cou t or co i rhi s fcinc oft evi nc cli
i ort s r t e nsde s ufi e y- -he- de e a m
c lengi t me is.Ze
hal ng he rt
edyk' r e a gument do notsr ngt n t c am t tt sc ta
s ec nt r
s
te he he l i ha hi our nd

t a laec tde ed.Thec t lnots nds acej iiles c rviii t eis s.
he ppelt ours ni
ourwil pe c r udca r om es e stng hes sue

2

Th moinf rrle fo j dg n ,Do k t tyNo. 0 ,sd n e f rher a o p e iusys t
e to o eif r m u me t( c e En r 3 )i e id o t e s ns r vo l e
frhi t or rentr donM ac 1 201 ( ke EntyNo.1 .
o t n he de e e
rh 2, 4. Doc t r
3)
SI
GNED on Ocobe 21 201 a Houson, xas
t r , 6, t
t Te .

-

(

M

.

Le H .Ros ha
e
ent l
Unie St t Diti tJ
td aes src udge