Canady v. Stephens

Filing 53

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER granting 44 MOTION to Dismiss as Moot and Cancel Telephone Hearing, with Brief in Support. All pending motions are denied as moot. (Signed by Chief Judge Lee H Rosenthal) Parties notified.(gclair, 4)

United States District Court
Southern District of Texas

ENTERED
I TH E U NI
N
TED STAT ES DI
STR I T C O U R T
C
FO R TH E SO U TH ER N DISTR ICT O F TEX A S
H O U STO N D I I O N
V SI

June 01, 2017
David J. Bradley, Clerk

W ARREN PI
ERRE CAN A D Y ,
Pe ii r
ttone ,
CI I A CTI N O .14-1124
V L
ON

LORI DA V I
E
S,
Re ponde .
s
nt

M EM ORANDUM AND O RDER
W a r n Pi r e C a dy fl a pe ii f a w rtofha scor , ha l ngi t r ulsof
r e e r na ied
tton or
i
bea
pus c le ng he es t
a pr s n dici i r he i On M a 15,201 r s
i o s plna y arng.
y
7, e ponde tl d a m oton t di m i st s c s as
nt i e
i o s s hi a e
m oot The m oton s a e t tt pr s di ci i r c s gi ng r s t Ca dy' pe ii ha bee
.
i t t s ha he i on s plna y a e vi i e o na s tton s n

ove t ne a Cana sf f t good tm ec e tha bee r sor d.On M a 18, 7, hi co t
rur d nd
dy' oreied
i r di s n e t e
y 201 t s ur
or r M r Ca dy t s
de ed . na o how c us w hy t c e s d notbe di m i s a m oot
a e
he as houl
s s ed s
.
O n M ay 30,201 M r Ca dy f l d hi r pons t t m oton t di m i s Hi r pons
7, . na ie s es
e o he
i o s s . s es
e
a no l dge t thi dici i r c s ha be ove t ne a t thi f f ie good tm e c e t
ck w e s ha s s plna y a e s en r ur d nd ha s or e t d
i r dis
ha bee r s or H e a gues how e , ha he ha had pe s lpr ry t ke f om hi ,a he
ve n e t ed.
r
,
ver t t
s
r ona ope t a n r
m nd
s e t r t n oft tpr pe t and m one da a . Thes cl i s ca
e ks he e ur
ha o ry
y m ges
e am
nnotbe r i e i a ha as
asd n
be
c pus pe ii
or
tton.
The f de a ha a co puss a ut a l st s c tt
e r l be s r
t t e low hi our o
e e t n a a i a i f a w rt of ha a c pus i be l of a
nt rai n pplc ton or
i
be s or
n ha f

p ro i c so yp ru n t tej d me t f S aec u t nyo te
e s n n u td u s a t o h u g n o a tt o r o l n h
gr t hei i c t yi vol i o heConsiutonorl or
ound hat s n usod n i aton ft
tt i
aws
te iso he Unie St e .
r ate ft
td ats
28U. C. 2254()(mphassa d) I t c e ofaprs dici i r heai habe cor
S. j
a e
i dde . n he ontxt
ion s plnay rng, as pus
t appr i e rem edy i t petton chalenges t f or d a i of t pe ii ne '
he
oprat
f he
ii
l
he act
ur ton
he tt o r s
Pr Esprs n rha as l 1 1 24Ca a ore Grnt Moto t Dimiswp
h
cAs ï io e - be oo 4h4- 1 . n dy d r a i
ng in o s s . d

confne nt See eg.Pr ie v Rodrgue ,41lU. 485,500(1 .
i me . , . , es r . i z
S.
973)
W ih r ga d t t l sofpr
t e r o he os
opery, r Ca y doe notcha l nge t f c ordur ton ofhi
t M . nad
s
le
he a t
ai
s
c i m e . The l s of pr ry a f t t c tons but not t dur ton,of M r Ca y'
onfne nt
os
ope t f ec s he ondii ,
he a i
. nad s
c i me .
onfne nt

Ge al j 1983 s t ae t pr r ve cl t atc
nerly,
uis r he ope
hi e o ta k
unconsiuto l ondii ofc i
tt i na c tons onfneme a
nt ndprs
ionpr dur . e
oee es Se

Co kv T x sDe tfcrmia J sieT a sto a Plnnn De t
o . e a p'o i n l u tc r n i n l a ig p'
i
,
27F. 1 1 (t Ci.994)A habe peiin, t ot rha
3d 66, 68 5h r1 .
as tto on he he nd,
i t pr
s he operve cl t s e r e efom cusody. ePu v Pars
hi e o e k elas r
t Se gh . ih

o .T mman 8 F.d4 6 4 9 (t Ci.9 9 .
fst a
y, 75 2 3 , 3 5h rl 8 )
Car onv John 11 F. 818, (t Ci.1 .Theefr ,alws tunde 42U. C.j1
s . son, 2 3d
820 5h r 997)
r o e a ui
r
S.
983
i t pr rm ehod f M r Ca dy t s k c pe a i f hi l tpr ry.
s he ope t
or . na o ee om ns ton or s os ope t
kl a diput ha be n r s ve ori i ha e ne c d bec us ofc nged cr
lf s e s e e ol d f t s va s e
a e ha
icumsanc s...
t e

i i c i rd moo .
t s onsdee
t'
'Ame c M e As n v Bo n,857 F. 267,270 (t Ci.1 . The
rian d s' . we
2d
5h r 988)
aler d r s uto of t dicplnar hea i a r sor i ofM r nad s good tme c e t
t e e ol i n
he s i i y rng nd e t aton
.Ca y'
i
r di

r ol st sdiput a ii now moo .Thers
es ve hi s e, nd t s
t
e ponde ' motont dimis(
nts i o s s Docke EntyNo.
t r
44)
i gr e A l ot pe ng m otons a e deni d as m oot
s ant d. l her ndi
i
r
e
.

soxsoti.? a o- y 2 7a Ho so , ea.
l
hs5 , y t , 01,t utn ' x s
va
r

Lee H .Ros nt l
e ha
Chi fUnied St t s D it i tJ
e
t
a e s rc udge

Pr Espùs n rh be sz 4h4- 1 4. n dyore Grn i Moto t Dimiswp
h
cAs y o e -a a hol 1 1 2 Ca a d r a tng in o s s . d