Gant v. Fondren Orthopedic Group L.L.P.
Filing
62
ORDER granting 25 Motion to Dismiss. Case terminated on 5/22/2017. (Signed by Judge Alfred H Bennett) Parties notified.(gclair, 4)
United States District Court
Southern District of Texas
ENTERED
UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SOU TH ERN D I
STRI O F TEX A S
CT
H OU STON D I I ON
V SI
May 23, 2017
David J. Bradley, Clerk
ROX AN NE GAN T,
j
j
Pli if
antf,
j
j
j
FONDREN ORTHOPEDI GROUP L. P. j
C
L. ,
j
Defnda .
e nt
j
C I I A CTI N O .4: 6- - 48
V L
ON
1 CV 006
O R D ER
Bef e t Cour i D ef nda Fondr n O rhope c G r L. P.S M oton t D im i s
or he
t s e nt
e
t di oup L. '
i o s s
Plitf' Fis Ame d d Co litf rLa ko S b e tM atrJ rs ito a df rFalr t
anifs rt n e mpan o c f u j c- te u idci n n o iu e o
Stt aCli ( ./25) Pli ifsOppostont Motont Dimis( /32) andn r
ae am Doc / , antf
ii o i o s s Doc./ ,
umeous
NoiesofSu e nt Aut rt by Pli if( ./53)a Defnda ( . 41, 46,
tc
pplme al ho iy
antf Doc / nd e nt Docs ## 44,
47 49,50,5 58,59,60) Afe c i rngt applca el ala hort a c es
,
2,
. tr onsdei he i bl eg ut iy nd ouns l'
a gum e s t Cour gr s D e e nt sM oto t D im i s
r
nt , he
t ant f nda '
in o s s.
1.
Background
The a l ge f t ar r a i y s m pl Pl ntf a l ge t D e enda w il uly vi a e
le d ac s e el tvel i e. ai i f le s hat f
nt lf l ol t d
t Fara Acc aeCr tTrnsci Ac (C
he i nd urt edi a a ton t S
FACTA' l5U. C.jj 1 1e s q.FACTA
'
)
S.
68 t e
m and t s t tw hen a c t e us a c e tca d,t e r ton da e oft c edi ca d m a not
a e ha
us om r es r di r he xpi a i
t
he r t r
y
bei ude ont rc pt l U. C.j 1 1 ( .Pli ifalge t tDeenda i ude t
ncl d he e ei . 5 S.
68 cg) antf le s ha f nt ncl d he
expi i dat ofhercr tcar on t r pt
raton e
edi d
he ecei .
She alege no a t lda a ,buti i t ad a ki f sa ut y da a unde t
l s
c ua m ges
s ns e s ng or t t or m ges
r he
saut ofbewe n $1 $1 pervi a i FACTA a l f saut y da ag i t ca eof
tt e
t e 00- 000
olton.
lows or t t or m es n he s
a w ilulvi aton oft st ut
lf ol i
he at e.
I
l.
Anal s
ysi
A. LegalSt
andards
Rul 1 b)6)al dimis li apli iff l io sae acai upon whih rle c n
e 2( ( lows s sa f antf ais ç tt l m
t
c eif a
begrntd. Fe R.Ci P.1 b)6) Unde Rul 8()2) apladi mus c an i s ta
a e ' d.
'
v. 2( ( .
r e a( , e ng t onti t hor nd
a
pli sae ntoft cam s ngt tt pl de i e ildt r i . Fe R. v.P.8( ( .
an ttme
he li howi ha he ea r s ntte o elef' d. Ci
'
a)2)
l or t s a e a c a m upon w hi h r i c n be gr nt d,a pl i i f m us e t bls
n der o t t
li
c elef a
a e
a ntf
t s a ih
s a ng.Thi i a f
t ndi
s s unda ent pr nc pl unde l ng t c tt i llm ia i oft cou t t
m al i i e
ryi he ons iutona i t ton
he r s o
onl a es a t c e orc r se .S o,I .v Robis,l S.Ct 1 ( 6) To
y ddr s cual as s ontoveris poke nc . n 36
. 540 201 .
etbih sa dn Plitf d th v s fee a ij r i fc a iv so o a lg l
sa ls tn ig, anif s
mus a e u fr d n nu y n a t n n a in f e al
y
prtced i ees whih i ( c rt a pariulrz a ( acualor i ne ,not
oe t ntr t c s a) oncee nd tc a ied, nd b) t
mmi nt
c ne t rl rh p t eia. Lu a v De n e so Widfe 5 4U.. 5 , 6 ( 9 7 .
o jcua o y o h tc l' j n . # d r f l l , 0 S 5 5 5 0 1 9 )
'
O fpari ul r c
tc a once n i t pr e ca e i w he he Pl ntf ha e r e ed a ( oncr t '
r n he es nt s s
t r ai i f s xpe i nc
t
c
e e'
ij r .Th ti,d e t e p i t g o t e e piain d t o t e ce i c r ,whc viltst e
nu y a s o s h rni f h x rto ae f h rd t ad ih oae h
n
s a ut i a of is l ,c ea e a c r t ha m ? Cour s a ound t c r have s i on t s
t t e, n nd
t ef r t
onc e e r
t r
he ounty
plt
hi
isl.Co le eg,i r u V c ltRe t r n o De Pe e LLC,8 3 F.d 7 4 (t Ci.
st
e mpt .. vy r .Nio e sau a t f
r
v
r,
4 3 2 7h r
2 6 , t De c a fv Ame ian V ltt Li u ie I c, ta . No 1 - 3 6 01 ) wi s h a . rc ee o mo sn n . e l, . 6 CV- 4 4 PHX- S
h
GM
( Arz. b.1 201 .
D. i Fe 5, 7)
I S eo,t Supr e Cour s a e i di t t t a c r t har nee not be t ngi e.
n pok
he
em
t t t d n c a ha
onc e e m
d
a bl
1 S. . a 1
36 Ct t 549. For e pl , t i e e r s of da age c be a c r e ha m . 1
xam e he ncr as d i k
m
an
onc et r d.
Ho v r S k o h l t a j s b c u e a saue ha b e vo ae , d e n t me n a
we e, po e ed h t u t e a s
tt t s e n iltd o s o a
pl i tf / ttone ha s ts i t r bur n f r pur e of s a ng.1 a 15 Tha i t s y,
a n ifpe ii r s a i fed hei
de o
pos s t ndi d. t 48. t s o a
Cong es ca
r s nnot c ea e s a ng sm pl by cr a i a c us of ac i I The Cons iuton
r t t ndi i y
e tng
a e
ton. d
tt i
r quie t pl ntf t pl ad a conc e e ha m .
e r s he ai if o e
rt r
B. A pplcaton
i i
l ti c s ,P an ifha n talg da y ij r b y n t evolto o t saue Th r
n h s a e litf s o l e n nu y e o d h i ain f he tt t. ee
e
has no be n a alegai of a c ee ha m .As s h,t s Cour agr es wih t Se nt
t e ny l ton
oncr t r
uc hi
t e
t he ve h
Cic tCour ofA ppea s a t ot r c t t tha f
r ui
t
l nd he he our s ha ve ound t ta vi a i of FACTA ,i and
ha
ol ton
n
of is f doe not e t i h s a ng. W hie Congr s ha t cons iut ona r s
t el, s
s abls t ndi
l
e s s he
tt i l e pons biiy t
i lt o
c e t ca e of ac i t t a lt s d no be c l t d w ih t a lt t c ea e s a ng.
r a e us s
ton, ha biiy houl t
onta e
t he biiy o r t t ndi
Thi i t ue e n whe Cong e s pa s s a s a ut w ih i ent t a es a pos i e ha m
s s r
ve
n
rs
se
t t e t nt
o ddr s
s bl r
e re e by t publc ie,t t of c e tc r i or ton.The ne s iy f a c r t
xpe i nc d
he
i .. hef
r di a d nf ma i
ce st or onc ee
ij r i p r mo n f ra p o e o e v to o t e spaain o p wes Ass c ,Plitf s
n uy s a a u t o r p r bs r ai n f h e rto f o r . u h an if
a l ga i nsf i t es a i h s a ng.
le to a l o t bls t ndi
11
1.
Conc us on
l i
A c or ngl D e enda ' M oton f Sum m a y J m e i G RAN TED .Thi c e i
c di y, f
nt s
i or
r udg nt s
s as s
DI I
SM SSED .
l i s O RD ERED .
ts o
MA 2 t 2 1
ï
27
D ae
t
The H o r bl A lr
no a
fe
U nie St t s D i ti tJ
t d a e src u
enne t
t
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?