Nyabwa v. United States Of America
Filing
30
ORDER denying 29 Motion for Reconsideration. (Signed by Judge Keith P Ellison) Parties notified.(gclair, 4)
United States District Court
Southern District of Texas
ENTERED
I THE UN I
N
TED STA TES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE SOU THERN D I
STRI OF TEX A S
CT
HOU STON DI SI
VI ON
June 29, 2017
David J. Bradley, Clerk
CO LLI S O M AN D IN YABW A ,
N
Pl nt
ai ?
CI I A CTI No.1 1 0783
V L
ON
1- 6UN I
TED STATES OF A M ERI ,
CA
Dee da .
f n nt
O RD ER
Pe i be o et Co r i pl itfo pr s mo i n t at rora n t j g nt
ndng f r he u ts an its / e to o le me d he ud me
p s ntoRu e5 e , d r l e o Ci l oc d r .( ke EntyNo. 9. I s po t
urua t l 9( )Fe e a Ruls f viPr e u e Doc t r
2 ) n up r,
pl ntf cl m st tt Supr e Cour ' r entde son i Nel v.Col ado,
ai if ai ha he
em
ts ec
ci i n son
or
U.
S.
1 7 S.Ct 1 9 ( 1 ,e tte hi t m o t r c mpe ai n und rt FTCA
3
. 24 20 7) n ils m o nea y o ns to
e he
f l i t vaca urofhi s a e convi ton.
olow ng he
t
s tt
ci
I Nel t Supr e Coul de er i t ta s a e sat evi a ed duepr es by
n son, he
em
. t m ned ha t t t ut olt
t
oc s
r rng def nda s w hos c ctons ha been r ver ed or vaca ed t pr
equii
e nt
e onvi i
ve
e s
t o ove t i
her
i
nnoce by c ea a convi i e dence i or t obt n t r und ofc t f ,a
nce
l r nd
nc ng vi
n der o ai he ef
oss, ees nd
rsi inpadp s n t t ivai c vito TheSu e Co r hedt tIwl na
ett o i urua to he n ld on cin.
ut
prme u t l ha,ç he
g
ci i c
rm nal onvi ton i i i edby ar viw i c ta nor t i wil ur'duepr s
c i s nvaldat
e e ng our nd e ral l occ ,'
oces
r r t s a e ç o r und f es c tc t a r tt i e t f om t def nt
equies he t t k ef
t
e , our oss, nd es iuton xac ed r
he enda
upon,and a acons
s
equence of t convi ton.'1 a 1252.Oncea def ndant sconviton
, he
c i ' d. t
e
'
ci
i S r s d t pr s i n of( s i no e e (s r sor d, i a 1 5, ndt saeC s
s t a e , he e umpto
e
hiq n c nc il e t e ' d. t 25 a he tt l
'
ha
noi e e ti wih di fo ( mjmon yt whiht e(la ec re tyha z r cam of
ntr s n t hol ng r m hi
e o c h st t u r n l s e o l i
rgh . 1 a 1 7. l s r,t sa eç y n p e u ape s n,a j dg d gui y ofn
i t' d. t 25 n ho t he t t ç
'
ma ot r s me r o d u e l
t
o
crm e,none hel sguit enough f m onet r exa i ' 1 a 1
i
t es
ly
or
a y ctons.' d. t 256.
I t i t nt l w s t pl i if s
n he ns a a ui, a ntf ought m onet r com pe a i fom t f r
ay
ns ton r
he ede al
gove nm entf hi 1 de enton and l soflbe t pe ng deporatonpr
r
or s CE t i
os
i ry ndi
ti
oceedi .That
ngs
Nel pr deshi no ba sf r
son ovi
m
si or ecove y ofcom pens ton f t tl si m adecl i t
r
a i or ha os s
ear n he
f l i pa agr ph oft deci i
olow ng r a
he
son:
Col a a gued on bref t t i t Exone a i A c pr des s fci nt
or do r
i ha f he
r ton t ovi
ufi e
pr st c
oces o ompens t a def
ae
endantf t l ofhe lbe t t A cts d
or he oss
r i ry, he
houl
alo s fce û hen a def nts
s ufi l
w
enda eeks com pe a i f t l s s gnii nt
ns ton or he es i fca
deprva i ofm one a y a se s ent pai pur uantt a convi ton t i l t
i ton
tr s s m s d s
o
c i hat s a er
ove t ned. Thecom pars i i pt Nel and M adden see re or i
rur '
'
ion s na . son
k st aton
of nd t ypai t t St e n c mpe s i f tmpo ar de iaino
f u s he d o he at, ot o n aton or e r y prv to f
t s f nd . Peiiness e o y t i mo y ba k no itrs on t e
ho e u s tto r e k nl her ne c , t nee t hos
f
unds f t perod t f
or he i he unds wer i t St t s c t
e n he a e' us ody. Jus as t
t
he
r so atono i e t o r v r al fac vito i no c mpe s ton net r
e tr i flb ry n e e s o on c in s t o n a i , ihe
i t r t r o ne t e b t St eonac o to hec nvc in.
s he eu n fmo y ak n y he at
c un ft o ito
Nel a 1
son, t 257.Thus c r t t Nelon decii w ast r t n ofpr t t i
, ent al o he s
s on
he e ur
opery o nnoce
nt
pari , r
tes not ecove yofcom pens ton f hepa tes' empor y l soft tpr t N elon
r
a i ort
ri t
ar os
ha opery. s
di nothol unconsiutonalt tpori of t sat e r rng pari t pr
d
d
tt i
ha
ton
he t ut equii
tes o ove ac ual
t
i
nnoc
ence by c ea a convi ng e dence i or rt r
l r nd
nci vi
n de o ecove com pe at y dam agesf
r
ns or
or
l soflbe t
os
i ry.
Pl ntf f l t es a ih i hi l ui a rghtt r
ai if aied o t bls n s aws t i o ecove m one ar com pe a i
r
t y
ns ton
un rt FTCA, ndhefr snobet ri t i t n mo i n.Pl itf Rul 5 e mo i n
de he
a
ae
te n he nsa t to
an ifs e 9( ) to
f r le ( c e En r No. )i DENI
or ei f Do k t ty 29 s
ED.
N
Sg e aHo so , e a,ntiteV cdyo Jn , 0 7
ind t utn T xso hsh
a fu e2 1 .
J
KEI P.ELLI
TH
SON
UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI J GE
CT UD
3
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?