Nyabwa v. United States Of America

Filing 30

ORDER denying 29 Motion for Reconsideration. (Signed by Judge Keith P Ellison) Parties notified.(gclair, 4)

United States District Court
Southern District of Texas

ENTERED
I THE UN I
N
TED STA TES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE SOU THERN D I
STRI OF TEX A S
CT
HOU STON DI SI
VI ON

June 29, 2017
David J. Bradley, Clerk

CO LLI S O M AN D IN YABW A ,
N

Pl nt
ai ?
CI I A CTI No.1 1 0783
V L
ON
1- 6UN I
TED STATES OF A M ERI ,
CA

Dee da .
f n nt
O RD ER

Pe i be o et Co r i pl itfo pr s mo i n t at rora n t j g nt
ndng f r he u ts an its / e to o le me d he ud me
p s ntoRu e5 e , d r l e o Ci l oc d r .( ke EntyNo. 9. I s po t
urua t l 9( )Fe e a Ruls f viPr e u e Doc t r
2 ) n up r,
pl ntf cl m st tt Supr e Cour ' r entde son i Nel v.Col ado,
ai if ai ha he
em
ts ec
ci i n son
or

U.
S.

1 7 S.Ct 1 9 ( 1 ,e tte hi t m o t r c mpe ai n und rt FTCA
3
. 24 20 7) n ils m o nea y o ns to
e he
f l i t vaca urofhi s a e convi ton.
olow ng he
t
s tt
ci
I Nel t Supr e Coul de er i t ta s a e sat evi a ed duepr es by
n son, he
em
. t m ned ha t t t ut olt
t
oc s
r rng def nda s w hos c ctons ha been r ver ed or vaca ed t pr
equii
e nt
e onvi i
ve
e s
t o ove t i
her
i
nnoce by c ea a convi i e dence i or t obt n t r und ofc t f ,a
nce
l r nd
nc ng vi
n der o ai he ef
oss, ees nd

rsi inpadp s n t t ivai c vito TheSu e Co r hedt tIwl na
ett o i urua to he n ld on cin.
ut
prme u t l ha,ç he
g
ci i c
rm nal onvi ton i i i edby ar viw i c ta nor t i wil ur'duepr s
c i s nvaldat
e e ng our nd e ral l occ ,'
oces
r r t s a e ç o r und f es c tc t a r tt i e t f om t def nt
equies he t t k ef
t
e , our oss, nd es iuton xac ed r
he enda
upon,and a acons
s
equence of t convi ton.'1 a 1252.Oncea def ndant sconviton
, he
c i ' d. t
e
'
ci

i S r s d t pr s i n of( s i no e e (s r sor d, i a 1 5, ndt saeC s
s t a e , he e umpto
e
hiq n c nc il e t e ' d. t 25 a he tt l
'
ha
noi e e ti wih di fo ( mjmon yt whiht e(la ec re tyha z r cam of
ntr s n t hol ng r m hi
e o c h st t u r n l s e o l i
rgh . 1 a 1 7. l s r,t sa eç y n p e u ape s n,a j dg d gui y ofn
i t' d. t 25 n ho t he t t ç
'
ma ot r s me r o d u e l
t
o
crm e,none hel sguit enough f m onet r exa i ' 1 a 1
i
t es
ly
or
a y ctons.' d. t 256.

I t i t nt l w s t pl i if s
n he ns a a ui, a ntf ought m onet r com pe a i fom t f r
ay
ns ton r
he ede al
gove nm entf hi 1 de enton and l soflbe t pe ng deporatonpr
r
or s CE t i
os
i ry ndi
ti
oceedi .That
ngs
Nel pr deshi no ba sf r
son ovi
m
si or ecove y ofcom pens ton f t tl si m adecl i t
r
a i or ha os s
ear n he
f l i pa agr ph oft deci i
olow ng r a
he
son:
Col a a gued on bref t t i t Exone a i A c pr des s fci nt
or do r
i ha f he
r ton t ovi
ufi e
pr st c
oces o ompens t a def
ae
endantf t l ofhe lbe t t A cts d
or he oss
r i ry, he
houl
alo s fce û hen a def nts
s ufi l
w
enda eeks com pe a i f t l s s gnii nt
ns ton or he es i fca
deprva i ofm one a y a se s ent pai pur uantt a convi ton t i l t
i ton
tr s s m s d s
o
c i hat s a er
ove t ned. Thecom pars i i pt Nel and M adden see re or i
rur '
'
ion s na . son
k st aton

of nd t ypai t t St e n c mpe s i f tmpo ar de iaino
f u s he d o he at, ot o n aton or e r y prv to f
t s f nd . Peiiness e o y t i mo y ba k no itrs on t e
ho e u s tto r e k nl her ne c , t nee t hos
f
unds f t perod t f
or he i he unds wer i t St t s c t
e n he a e' us ody. Jus as t
t
he

r so atono i e t o r v r al fac vito i no c mpe s ton net r
e tr i flb ry n e e s o on c in s t o n a i , ihe
i t r t r o ne t e b t St eonac o to hec nvc in.
s he eu n fmo y ak n y he at
c un ft o ito
Nel a 1
son, t 257.Thus c r t t Nelon decii w ast r t n ofpr t t i
, ent al o he s
s on
he e ur
opery o nnoce
nt
pari , r
tes not ecove yofcom pens ton f hepa tes' empor y l soft tpr t N elon
r
a i ort
ri t
ar os
ha opery. s
di nothol unconsiutonalt tpori of t sat e r rng pari t pr
d
d
tt i
ha
ton
he t ut equii
tes o ove ac ual
t
i
nnoc
ence by c ea a convi ng e dence i or rt r
l r nd
nci vi
n de o ecove com pe at y dam agesf
r
ns or
or
l soflbe t
os
i ry.

Pl ntf f l t es a ih i hi l ui a rghtt r
ai if aied o t bls n s aws t i o ecove m one ar com pe a i
r
t y
ns ton

un rt FTCA, ndhefr snobet ri t i t n mo i n.Pl itf Rul 5 e mo i n
de he
a
ae
te n he nsa t to
an ifs e 9( ) to
f r le ( c e En r No. )i DENI
or ei f Do k t ty 29 s
ED.

N

Sg e aHo so , e a,ntiteV cdyo Jn , 0 7
ind t utn T xso hsh
a fu e2 1 .

J
KEI P.ELLI
TH
SON
UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI J GE
CT UD

3