Doggett Company, LLC v. Thermo King Corporation

Filing 49

ORDER granting in part, denying in part #40 MOTION to Compel Documents and Interrogatory Responses, #41 MOTION to Compel Documents from Plaintiff. Parties are to produce the compelling information within 14 days of entry of this order. (Signed by Magistrate Judge Stephen Smith) Parties notified.(gclair, 4)

:

:
United States District Court
Southern District of Texas

?

ENTERED

UN I
TED STA TES DISTR I C O URT
CT
SO UTH ERN D I
STRICT O F TEX AS
H O U STO N DIVISIO N

April 20, 2017
David J. Bradley, Clerk

D OGGEU COMP
ANY,
LLC,

Pl nth
ai l
f
CI LA CTI 1 - 2673
VI
ON 1 16-

VS.

THERMO K I CORPOM TI
NG
ON,

De e ant
f nd .
O RDER

Thsmatri beor tec ur onc eigmoto t c lds o r ( . 0
i te s f e h o t omp tn
ins o ompe ic vey Dkt4

( anig a Dkt41( ee da l. moton aeg a e i pata de idi p r.
plitf nd . d fn nt)The i s r rntd n r nd ne n a t
Bac
kground
Pl ntf Dogget Com pa LLC ha s d def
ai if
t
ny,
s ue
endantTher o I ng f vi aton of
m fi or ol i

j57. oft Fai Pr ctcesofEqui
102 he r a i
pmentM a act er Diti or ,W hol alr ,and
nuf ur s, srbut s
es e s

De lr Ac (h De lrhi Ac)ThemoKi ma ufcue ta s r tmpeaur c ntol
aes tte aes p t. r
ng n a trs r n po te rt e o r
pr
oduct and s l t m t ough anet or ofdea er hi .Dogget cont ct Ther o Ki
s
els he hr
w k
l s ps
t
a ed
m
ng
by l t a
eter bout pur i t o Ther o K i deal s ps i Te
chas ng w
m
ng
er hi n xas know n as t Kiby
he r

Dea e s ps Ther K i i or ed KibyandD ogget t i w oul not
l r hi .
mo ng nf m
r
t hat t
d appr apr
ove opos
ed
s l of t Kiby Deal s ps t D ogge t becaus D ogget i af ii t wih a tuc ng
ae
he r
er hi o
t
e
t s fla ed t
r ki
busne .
i ss Ther o K i ca l t sis'
m
ng ls hi t '
OEM 'polcy. ogget cont
' i D
t endsTher o K i vi at
m
ng ol ed

t Dea er hi A ct bec e t tuc ng bus nes /
he
l s p
aus he r ki
i s oEM polcy i not a r ona e
i s
eas bl
r r entconsit nty i pos byTher o K i Ther o Ki sprm ar pos ton i t t
equiem
s e l m ed
m
ng.
m
ng' i y ii s ha

t pr e i oft D ea e s p A ctwer nott i ed by D ogget' l te .D ogget se
he ot ctons he
l r hi
e
rgger
ts e t r
t eks

b h ij c i r le a l tp o isda ge .
ot n un tve e if nd os r ft ma s
1.

Do t ' M oto t Compe ( . )
gge ts i n o
l Dkt 40 .

Dogget s eks s em e al r pons t is r
t e
uppl nt es
es o t eques f pr
t or odùcton N o. 3 and
i

i e r ores No.3 a 12.Se D kt 40 at3- Thi di cover i ai ed atdet m i ng
nt r ogat i
nd
e
.
7. s s
y s m
er ni
whet Ther o K i s sat d r on f not appr ng Dogget' pur has r l ct
her
m
ng' t e eas
or
ovi
ts
c e efe s
'eas bl r r e sc s e l i pos f deal shi ta f s'
' ona e equiem nt onsit nty m ed or
r
er p r ns er .'
Dogget' r
ts eques sw ilbe lm ied t t tm epe i 2011t pr ent They ar f t
t l i t o he i
rod
o es .
e urher
lm ied t i or aton r l ed t Ther o Ki sOEM polc pr bii dea er f om bei
i t o nf m i e at o
m
ng'
i y ohi tng l s r
ng
afii ed w ih a tuc ng c pany,nota 1r r
flat
t r ki om
1 equiement f deal s p a oval Ther o
s or
er hi ppr .
m
Ki has alea agr ed t pr
ng
r dy e o oduce doc ent r l ed t t o c pa e a oved f
um s e at o w om ni s ppr
or

dea er hi snce2011t appeari
l s ps i
hat
ncons sent ih t OEM polcy, i H awai a one
i t w t hat
i one n
i nd
i M ai
n
ne.

W ih t above m odii i ,Dogget' m oton t com peli gr nt a f l .
t he
fcatons
ts
i o
s a ed s olows
The mo K i i or ed t conduc a r s bl s r h of is dea er hi devel ent
r
ng s der o
t ea ona e ea c
t
l s p
opm

de t
parmentf docum ent dat 2011 t pr entt tr f r t is tucki busnes /
or
s ed
o es ha e e o t r ng i s oEM
polcy,i udi com m uni i t pot i ldeal r r di t polcy, em aist or
i ncl ng
catons o enta
e s egar ng he i and
l o
f om t hea oft deparm ent Ti ot M i , hi pr es oron t t c.
r he d he
t
, m hy nor and s edec s
hat opi Ther o
m
K i i f t ror ed t s e entisr pons t i erogat y 1 t i ntf any buye
ng s urhe der o uppl m
t es
e o nt r or 2 o de iy
r

2

'
#

w ho m ade a i or alr
n nf m eques ori r a
t nquiy boutbec i a Ther o K i deal butw as
om ng
m
ng
er

rjce bae o tetuc n b i s/
ee td s d n h r kig usne soEM p iy
olc .
2.

The moK i sm o i t c
r
ng' ton o ompe ( . )
l Dkt 41

Ther o K i s kspr
m
ng ee
oduc i ofaw i r nge offnanci doc ent f om Dogget
ton
de a
i
al um s r
t
and r at entte on t gr
el ed ii s he oundst t y ar r evantt D ogget' a t r i cl i f l t
hat he e el
o
t le natve a m or os
s
pr is Ther o K i al o s
oft .
m
ng s eeks doc ent r at t whet ot m anuf ct e s or
um s el ed o
her her
a ur r

s i shaver r ment smiart istucki busnes/
uppler
equie
s i l o t r ng i soEM polcy.
i
Ther o Ki hasper ua dt cour t i i e il d t fnanci i or atonbe
m
ng
s de he
t hat t s ntte o i
al nf m i
yond
t r vi w ed orr i upon by Dogget' e r .For e pl docum ent r l ed t t
hat e e
eled
ts xpe t
xam e,
s e at o he
s ce of f
our
unds Dogget ha avaiabl f t pur s m i be r eva t r
t d
l e or he
cha e ght
el nt o ebutt
he
m et
hodol and as um ptonsm a by t exper .H oweve ,t r
ogy
s
i
de
he
t
r he eques satis w ilbe
t
s ue l
lm ied t docum ent r l ed t t pl i ifher a is3 afii t oper tng com pani ,
i t o
s e at o he a ntf e nd t
fla ed
ai
es not

t o e LeleDog tpes nal (xc p t tee e Mr Do etpe s al wa t
he wn r si
get ro ly e e t o h xtnt . gg t ron ly s he
i ended s ce of f
nt
our
unds i whi ca e Ther o K i m a r s tt s r rcton w ih a
,n
ch s
m
ng y evii hi esti i
t

raonà er q e tf rlmie a dii lif r tonfom hi . t r ter q sswil
e s bl e u s o i td d tona n o mai r m) Furhe ,h e ue t l
be lm ied i tm e t 2011 t t pr ent
i t n i o
o he es .
Li ieddicove y i oot s i r polc r ti i ondea e s p ta f sm i
mt s
r nt her upple s' i y esrctons
l r hi r ns er ght
be appr i e her on t f l i condii I Dogget i ends t ar t Ther o
oprat
e
he olow ng
ton. f
t nt
o gue hat
m
Ki sO EM polcy i unr as
ng'
i s e onabl beca ei i noti pos by ot equi ents
e
us t s
m ed
her
pm
uppler ,
is

t e Dog t' de l rh p a e me s wih is s ple s a e r lva a d s j c t
hn
get ae s i gr e nt t t up ir r ee nt n ub e t o
s
3

1

pr
oduc i lD ogge tm ay a d t spr
ton.
t
voi hi oducton onl i i si at t i doesnoti end t
i
y f t tpul es hat t
nt
o
pr s evi ncer di t ta f r ti tonsofot equi ents i r .
e ent de
egar ng he r ns er esr c i
her
pm
upple s
Conc us on
l i

Themoi st c e ( s 40, )aeg a tdi pat n d nidi pat ssae
ton o omp l Dkt. 41 r r ne n r a d e e n r a ttd
a
bove.
The pari ar t pr
tes e o oduce t com peled i or a i w ihi 1 da ofe r oft s
he
l nf m ton t n 4 ys nty hi
or .
der

Si
gned atHous on,Texason A prl20,2017.
t
i

Q
t
ephen W m .Sm ih
t
Unied St t M a sta e J
t
a es gi r t udge

I t c r ntpr e i or ri i uf i i ntf t spur e,t pa te a e t a e t a
f he ur e
ot ctve de s ns f c e or hi
pos he r i s r o gr e o n
a opr a e a ende pr e i or r
ppr i t m
d ot ctve de .
4