Plattenburg v. Jenner et al

Filing 3

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER. Email sent to Manager of Three Strikes List. (Signed by Judge Alfred H Bennett) Parties notified.(rosaldana, 4)

United States District Court
Southern District of Texas

ENTERED
I TH E UN I
N
TED STATES DISTR I CO U RT
CT
FO R TH E SO U TH ER N D I
STRI T O F TEXA S
C
H O USTO N DI I O N
V SI

June 14, 2017
David J. Bradley, Clerk

DERRECK PLATTEN BURG ,
TD CJ#01835684,

Pl ntf ,
ai if
CI I A CTI N O . 1-1 687
V L
ON
1 7-1
KRI J
S ENN ER,

Def
endant
.

M EM O R AN DU M O PI I N AND O R D ER
N O
Pl i ifD er ec Pl t
a ntf
r k atenbur a s a e i a e pr edi
g, t t nm t oce ngrr s has fl a Prs r
o e,
ied
i one

Ci lRiht Co a n und r42 U. C.j 1 3 ( ke En r No.1 a i tt lvii n
vi g s mpli t e
S.
98 Doc t ty
) gans ee so

rai sa KrsJ nn r atn r i idys e sla t p o e d i f r pa pe i.
e lt tr i e e .Plte bu g mple l e k e ve o r c e n o ma u rs
y
Bec e Pl t
aus atenbur i i r r t d,t courti r r t s utni t cl m s and
g s nca ce a e he
s equied o cr i ze he ai
dim i s t com pl nt i w hol or i par, i i de er i t t c pl nt (i
s s he
ai , n
e
n
t f t t m nes hat he om ai çs

fi ous m a i i ,or f l t sat a c ai upon w hi r i m a be gr ed' orts ks
rvol , lc ous
ais o t e l m
ch elef y
ant ' tee

mon t r r le fo a de e da t who i i
ea y ei f r m
fn n
s mmun fo s h r le . 28 U. C. j
e r m uc e if'
'
S.
1 5 b) Afe r viwi a1oft epla ngs t c ur c c u st tt i c s mus be
91 A( . tr e e ng 1 h e di ,he o t on l de ha h s a e t
dim i s f t r onsexpl ned bel .
s s ed or he eas
ai
ow
1 Backer
.
ound

Pl te
at nbur i confned c r nty by t Te D e t ent of Crm i J tce g s
i
ur e l
he xas parm
i nal us i
Cor ec i
r tonal I tt i
ns iutonal D i s on at t Eli Uni i Hunt vil Te , whe e he i
vi i
he ls
tn
s le, xas
r
s

s r ig a sy a s ne e f o ey c u i bodl ij y i Ha rs Co t c us
e vn
-e r e tnc orr bb r a sng iy nur n ri uny a e
num ber 11 7701 0. 1 On M ay 31 201 Pl t
981
01
, 7, atenbur execut hi com pl i unde 42
g
ed s
a nt
r

U. C.j 1 3. Alho difc tt a c ran,Plte ur a a s t cam t a t e
S.
98
t ugh fiul o s e ti a tnb g ppe r o li h t h
def nda i tyi t kilhi and has bee usng he t evi i f e t ha as hi .
e nt s r ng o l m
n i
r el son am o r s m
Pl tenbur s eksr eas fom prs s he m ay as itof i r i ar es i t def ndant
at
g e
el e r
ion o
ss fce s n r tng he e
.

Pltenbur f t rs
at
g urhe eeksover$6. milon f hi t t '
7 li or s t h.
wor '
I . Di cus i
I
s s on

To s a e a vi bl cl m unders ton 1
tt
a e ai
ec i 983,a pl ntf û us fr ts
ai i f ç t is how a vi aton
m
ol i
oft Cons iuton or off der lw ,and t s
he
tt i
e al a
hen how t tt vi a i w as com m it by
ha he ol ton
ted
s eone actng under col of sat l .' Ateber y v.Nocona Ge H os ,430 F.
om
i
or
t e aw ' t r
n. p.
3d

2 ,25 3 ( t Ci. 5) S a ea t r a es j c t cvi la l y whe t nde c lr
45 2-5 5h r 200 . t t c o s r ub e t o i l ibii
t
n, t r oo
u

o a sau e o dna e r g ai c tm,o us ge ofa Sae't o fca s be t,
f ny ttt , r i nc , e ulton, uso r a , ny tt, he fiil u j cs
'
o c us s t be s j ce a pe s ço t e d p i to o a y rgh s p i lg s o
r a e o
ub e t d,
ron < h e rvai n f n i t , rvie e , r
t
i nii s s c r d by t Con tt in a d lws ( t e Unie Stt s . 42 U. C.j
mmu te e u e
he siuto n a of h
t d ae l'
'
S.
1
983. $ dit i cour m ay dim i s as f i ous t com pl ntofa pr s r pr di
t srct
A
t
s s
rvol
he
ai
i one ocee ng

1 i i l c a a gua eba i i 1w orf c . Gei rv J we s 40 F.d 3 ,3 3 ( t
FP f t a ks n r bl ss n a
a t' ge . o r , 4 3 71 7 5h
'
Ci. 005 . 1 c mpli lc a a g bl ba i i 1w i i i ba e o a idipu a y
r 2 ) t o ant a ks n r ua e ss n a f t s s d n n n s tbl
A
m e il s l
rtes egalt y,s h as i t com pl ntaleges vi aton of a l
heor uc
f he
ai l
ol i
egali er tw hih
nt es
c

ce ry d sno e s. amf r v Dr te 5 F.d 67 678( t Ci.2 9)(iains
lal oe t xit'
'S o d . ek , 62 3 4,
5h r 00 ctto

Ofe
f nder I or a i De al Te
nf m ton
t i, xas De rme of Crmi l J tce a ia e
pa t nt
i na usi , va lbl

htp:ofe rt itxasg (as viie J 7,201 .
t / fnde .dc.e .ov l t std une
/
7)

a it r lq t to ma ksomitd) A c mpl itl c a a g bl ba i i f c wh n
nd n e na uo a in r
te . o an a ks n r ua e ss n a t e
t pl ntf alegatons ar s ûf nciul' û a a tc ' and tdel i ' ast be Gwholy
he ai ips l i
e o ça f ,' l nt s i ,'
f
û us onal' o
û l

i r di e' De t n
nc e bl.
' no

He na e , 5 4 U. 25 3
r nd z 0 S. , 2-33 ( 99 ( uo i Netk v
1 2) q tng i e .
z

Wi i ,4 U. 31 325 3 ( 989 )
l ams 90 S. 9, , 28 1 ).
l

Plte ur sc an o it o dsoi e ,u nelgbl algai s t tdo
atnb g' omplitc nsss f ij ntd nitlii e le ton ha
not sa e a cohe ent ca e of acton agai t t def nda . Even unde t lber l
tt
r
us
i
ns he
e nt
r he i a
c tucton t ti t caly a ded t pr s pl di ,t c pl i f l t a
onsr i ha s ypi l ccor
o o e ea ngs he om a nt ais o dvanc
e
a c edi e t or ofr
ny r bl he y
ecover and l cksan ar
y
a
guabl bas si f . NordoesPlte
e i n act
a tnbur
g
a l orot
lege
henvie s
s how t t def ndanti a sat act f pur esof s i 1983.
hat he e
s t e or or pos
ecton
Beca e t com pl nt f l t r s a vi e s cton 1923 c ai ,t l w s t m us be
us he
ai ais o ai e
abl e i
l m he a ui
t
dim i s
s s ed.
1 1 C oncl i
1.
us on
Bas on t f egoi t cour O RD ER S as f l s:
ed
he or ng, he
t
olow

Th c mpl i fl d b De r c Plte bu g ( c t Enty No.
e o ant ie y re k at n r Do ke
r

DI I
SM SSED wih pr j c a fi o a d f r f iu e t sae a vibl
t e udie s rvolus n o a lr o tt
ae
cl m f r i unde s cton 1983. The di m i s cons iut a tsrke' f
ai or elef
r e i
s s al
tt es ûti ' or

p pos sof28U . C.j 1 5 g)
ur e
S.
91 ( .
The TD CJ I at Tr tFund i O RD ER ED t deductf
nm e us
s
o
unds f om t t us
r he r t

a c ntofDe r c Pl te bu g(
c ou
re k a tn r TDCJ#01 6 4)a d f nv r t m t t e
835 8 n o a d he o h
Cl k on a r ar bas s i compla
er
egul
i, n
i nce w ih t pr sons of 28 U . C .
t he ovi i
S.

j 1 1 ( ,u i t e iefln f e( 35 00 ha b e pa d.
9 5 b) ntl he ntr iig e $ 0. ) s e n i

The Cl k i diec ed t pr de a copy oft sM e or ndum Opi on a Or rt
er s r t o ovi
hi
m a
ni nd de o
t pl ntf . The Cl k w il al o provi a copy by regul m ai, f s m ie
he ai if
er
l s
de
ar
l ac i l

t ans s i ore mai t 1 t TDCJ -Ofi e o t Ge r Couns l P. Box
r mison, - l o:( ) he
fc f he ne al
e, O.

1 0 ,Aus i Te s 7 1 Fa Num be ( 2 93 21 a ( )t M ana r o
3 84
tn, xa , 871 , x
r 51 ) 6- 59; nd 2 he
ge f
t
he

Three st i
- r kes

Li t
s

f
or

t
he

Sout
hern

D it it
s rc

of

Texas
,

Thr St i l t - court .
ee r kes xs us
seov.

SI
GNED atH ouson,Texas,on
t

JUh 1 3 2 1
27

ALFRED H .
UN I
TED STA

.

TT
SDI
STRI JUD GE
CT

at