Tawe v. Roesler

Filing 6

MEMORANDUM ON DISMISSAL. Email sent to Manager of Three Strikes List. (Signed by Judge Vanessa D Gilmore) Parties notified.(gclair, 4)

United States District Court
Southern District of Texas

ENTERED
I TH E U NI
N
TED STA TE S D I
STRI T C O U R T
C
FO R TH E SO U TH E RN D I
STR I O F TEX A S
CT
H O USTO N D I SI N
VI O

April 03, 2018
David J. Bradley, Clerk

RI
CHA RD N . W E,
TA

(
TDCJCI #1
- D 596960)
Pl i if
a ntf ,
CI L A CTI 1 -1 3
VI
ON 1 7- 404
M I AEL A .ROESLER,etal,
CH
.
Def
endant
s.
M EM O R AN D UM O N D ISM ISSA L

Ri ha d N .Taw e a i a e oft Texa Depa t e of Cr m i l J tc -Cor ec i na
c r
, n nm t
he
s
rm nt
i na us i e
r to l
I tt i D i s on,s on N ovem be 6,201 a l gi c vi rght vi a i r uli fom a
ns iutons vi i ued
r
7, le ng i l i s ol tons es tng r
vi a i n of prvac a de a of due pr s ; r t laton; a e
ol to
i y;
ni l
oce s e a i i
nd xpos e t uns nia y lvi
ur o
a t r i ng
c tons Ta e pr e ng pr s a i f m a pa r s s s 1 pr s ofk i l a t Eli
ondii . w , oce di
o e nd n or
upe i , ue 20 i on t a s t he ls
Uni. Cour r c dss
t
t e or how t tt s l w s ti one ofni f de all w s t Ta e fl d a ns Eli
ha hi a ui s
ne e r a uis w ie gai t ls
U ni of i e s i 20 l ea h l w s tna i be w e n 1 and 1 ofi e s
t fc r n
7, c a ui m ng t e 0
20 t c r .
The t e hol i s i whet rTa e' c ai ss d be di m i s a f i ous
hr s d s ue s
he w s l m houl
s s ed s rvol .
1.

Taw e' A legatons
s l i

Tawe c pl i t tf m al of i e sa e pr s nti t s e a e w he m a epr s r a e
om a ns ha e e f c r r e e n he how r r a
n l i one s r
s
howerng. He e ai t t i a es who w or i t fel pl c t r boot t t ha bee i
i
xpl ns ha nm t
k n he i d a e hei
s ha ve n n
c a tw ih a m a e r e ,o s l s Ta e c pl i t t i a es m us pl e t i cl a
ont c t ni l xc em nt n he ve . w om a ns ha nm t
t ac he r e n
cl hi on t s s m e di t s l s i t s
ot ng
he e a
ry he ve n he howe a e He a s r st tpr s pf i a sf lt us
r r a.
s e t ha i on fci l ai o e
a s fci ntam ountofde er ntt w a h c ot spr pe l
uf i e
t ge o s l he o ry.

O :M Oh Gh
h
VD 2017h 3404. W PD
l7b01.

Ta e c pl i t tt gr e nce s t doesnotw or H e alege t tl
w om a ns ha he i va
ysem
k.
l s ha aundr of i e s
y fc r

denidhi ablnketnrtlai f hi flngofagre nce.Ta seksa ij tonprve i
e m a i eaiton or s ii
iva
we e n nunci e ntng
t def nda sf om i pl m e i polc e t tvi a ehi ci l i ht .H ef t rs eksu pec fed
he e nt r m e ntng i i s ha ol t s vi r g s
ur he e
ns ii
com pe a or da a .
ns t y m ges
I
I.

St
andard ofR evi
ew

A f de alc t t a hort t dim isa a ton i whi ht pli ifi pr e ng i
e r our has he ut iy o s s n c i n c he antf s oc edi n
f r a pa r sbef e s r e i t c tde er i s t tt a i i f i ous o m alci .28
om
upe i
or e vi e f he our t m ne ha he d on s r vol
r i ous

u. c.j1 5()2)B)i.A c an i fi ousi ilc a arua eba i i 1w orfc. e
s.
9l e( ( () omplit s rvol f t a ks n g bl ss n a
a tSe

Dent v He nande ,504U. 25,31( 992) Rihar onv S roc ,260F. 495, ( hCi.
on . r
z
S.
1 ; c ds . pu l k
3d
498 5t r
2001 (ii Si arv Hi owe 11 F. 1 ,1 (t Ci.1 ) $ c antlc a
) ctng gl . ght r, 2 3d 91 93 5h r 997). t ompli a ks n
A
a gua ebassi l w i i i ba e on a i s a ym e il slgal he y,s h a i t compl nt
r bl i n a f t s s d
n ndiput bl rtes e t or uc s f he
ai
a l ge t vi a i ofa l li er s whi h cl a l doesnotexi t' D av s v Sc t l5 F. d 1
le s he ol ton
ega nt e t c e r y
s .'
i . ot, 7 3 003,

1 (t Ci.1 )( i Mccor c v St der 05F. 1 1 ( h Ci.l )
005 5h r 998 quotng
mik . al ,1 3d 059, 061 5t r 997).
11 TheAbs nc o Physc l ur
1.
e ef
ial nj y
The PLRA pr bisr co r ofda age by prs r i ca est tdo noti vephys ca
ohi t e ve y
m s
i one s n s ha
nvol
i l

ij r Th P
n uy. e LRA e rsl p o d st a kn oFe ea cvl cinma b b o g t yap io e
xp e sy r vie h tû j d r l i ia to y e r u h b rs n r
g
c n i e i a alp io , r te c re to l a ii frme tl r mo in lnu ys fee wh l
o fn d n j i, rs n o oh r o rcina fcly,o na o e to a ij r u frd ie
t
i c td wih u ap irs o ngo p ysc lij r . 42U. C. 1 9 ee . tee tn t a
n uso y t o t ro h wi f h ia nu y'
'
S. j 9 7 () To h x e t h t
Ta sc a m sa e ba e on m e a ore otona ha m , sr que tf c pe a or da a sm us
we' l i r s d
nt l m i l r hi e s or om ns t y m ge
t
be di i sed f f l e t s at acl m upon whi r i m ay be gr ed. G ei v.Jower 404
sm s or aiur o t e ai
ch elef
ant See ger
s,

F. 37l 375( t Ci.2005)( di t taprs rsfiur t alegephysc ij yprcl s
3d ,
5h r
hol ng ha ione ' al e o l
ial nur e ude
hi rc r ofco ns t y da
s e ove y
mpe aor mage f e i orme alij i purua t 42 U. C.
s or motonal
nt nures s nt o
S.
O : O h DG h 7h 7h
M
V
201 l 3404. . PD
b01 W

jl
997e(). TheFit Cic thashed t tale tonsofd a a s e i ldites,
e)
fh rui
l ha lgai
l
mentl nguih, motona sr s

ps hol ca har a i omni 'aeba rdbyj 1 () SeeGegerv. r ,404F. 371
yc ogi l m, nd ns a' r re
997ee .
i
Jowe s
3d ,
37 ( t Ci.2005)
4 5h r
.

Ab e t nalg to h t wes fe e ap y ia ij r i c n e to wi t ec mpli d
s n a le ai nta Ta u fr d h sc lnu y n o n ci n t h o ane h
ofcondii ofc i
ton onfneme ,hi cli f c
nt s am or ompe aor da a lc a a gua ebassi lw.
ns t y m ges a ks n r bl
i n a
I .
V

T he R et i i C l m
alat on ai

Ta e aleg t tpr s ofi i l r t la ed a i t hi f tlng greva es The Fi t
w
l es ha i on te a s e a i t ga ns m or i i
i nc .
fh

Cic thashel t tprs ofi a sar pr biedfom r t la i a ns i t whoe r iet
r ui
d ha ion fcil e ohi t r e a itng gai t nma es
xe c s he
rghtofac es t t c t,orwho c pl n ofprs c to ora
i
c s o he ours
om ai
ion ondii ns boutofii lmic
fc a s onduct
.

Woodsv Smih, F. 11 ,11 ( t Ci.1 )(iai omitd) he aprs rcamst t
. t 60 3d 6l 64 5h r 995 cttons te .W n ione li ha
ofii l r t it d a i thi b is ng a f s dicplna y r por,f vor bl t nai oft
fc as e ala e gans m y s ui
ale s i i r e t a a e enni ton he
unde l ng dicplnay c r i notapr r qui ief brngi t c am .Woods 60 F. a 11
ryi s i i l ha ge s
e e st or i ng he l i
,
3d t 64.
The c
once n i whet rt r w asr t la i f t e r s ofa c tt i
r s
he he e
e a i ton or he xe ci e
ons iutonalrght s pa a e a
i , e r t nd
a r f om t a
pa t r he ppar ntvaldiy oft underyi di c plnar r por . d.a 11 11 SAn a ton
e
it
he
l ng s i i y e t 1 t 64- 65. i c i
m otva e byr t la i f t e r i e ofac tt i l ot t d rghti a t o bl e n i t
i t d e a i ton or he xe c s
ons iutonalypr ec e i s c i na e, ve f he

a t whe t nf adifr ras mi ha be nl tmae. l a 11 (iai o te .
c, n ake or feent e on, ght ve e egii t ' d t 65 cttons mitd)
'
I a ton,pr e ngs t t a e notot r i e cons iutonaly de i e m a be i i e by
n ddii
oce di
ha r
he w s
tt i l fci nt y
nvaldat d

rtlaor a mus I ( ttonsomitd)
eait y ni . d.ciai
te .
Toprvaio acli ofrtlai aprs rmus esa iht f lwi ()t e rie
e l n am eaiton, ione
t tbls he olo ng: 1 he xecs
ofas cii c tt i lrght ()t defnda ' i entor tlaea ns t prs rfrhi o
pe fc onsiutona i ; 2 he e nts nt t eait gai t he ione o s r
he e r s oft trght ( artlaor ad rea ;a ( c aton. sv Gr ni r,1
r xecie ha i ; 3) eait y ves ct nd 4) aus i Jone . e nge 88

F. 322, 25( hCi.1 (ii Mc
3d
324- 5t r 999) ctng Donal v Stwar 1 F. 225, ( hCi.1 )
d . e d, 32 2d
23l 5t r 998).
O JR AOï GQ OI 1 3404. . PD
h
VD
7ï 7b01 W

Ca a i r r s a s i t tt f t r t la or m otve,t c pl i of i i nt...
us ton equi e how ng ha k or he e a i t y
but
i he om a ned nc de

woul notha oc ured. M c
d
ve c r ' Donal 1 2F. at231( tngJohns v.
'
d, 3 3d
cii
on Rodri z 11 F. 299,
gue , 0 3d
31 (t Ci.1 )
0 5h r 997).
The c tt i
ons iutonalpr e tonsaf o ded t e w ho s k ac es t t c t e end onl t
ot c i
fr
hos
ee c s o he our s xt
yo

t e who prpae l lwor f t ms ve ll lihe a fi o flngsnors e r
hos
e r ega
k or he el s. t et r ny rvolus ii
e onday
ltga i ac i t ie. e r s r h a wr tng t t doe not i ve pr pa a i of l uis
ii ton tviy, . ,l gal e ea c nd ii ha
s
nvol
e r ton
aws t

c le ng awrtwrtrsown convitont)ort condii ofhi orherc i
halngi
i ie '
ci s
he
tons
s
onfnemen,ma
t y
c
omprs t bassofa r t lai cai . Johns 11 F. a 311.
ie he i
e ai ton l m '
'
on, 0 3d t
I r e ngcai sof eala i a ii fom t contxtofprs dici i r c r s t
n eviwi l m
r t iton rsng r he
e
ion s plna y ha ge ,he

Fi' Cic thasr cog z t tdglamsofrt ito mus ... r gade wih s ptcs l t
fh rui
t
e nied ha tcli
ealain t be e r d t ke iim,es
f de alc t e br lt m s l i e y di c plna y ac t toc ur i s a e pe li tt i .
e r our s m oi he e ves n ver s i i r t ha c s n t t na ns iutons'
'

Woods 60F.d a 11 ( tngAdamsv.Rie,40F. 72,74 ( h Ci.l ) TheFit Cicui
,
3 t 66 cii
c
3d
4t r 994).
fh r t
r ct d t a ia esanda d ofr viw :
e ie he pplc bl t r
e e
To a s et t i one sdo noti ppr i el i ul t t m s vesf om di ci i r
s ur ha pr s r
na oprat y ns a e he el r
s plna y
a tons by d a i t s e d ofr t i ton a ound t m , ralc t m us ca e uly
ci
r w ng he hi l
e ala i r
he t i our s
t rf l
scr i ze t e cl m s,To s at a cl m of r alat on an i ate m us alege t
utni hes ai
t e
ai
et i i
nm
t l
he
vi aton ofa s f ccons iutonalrghtand bepr ed t es abls t butf t
ol i
pecii
tt i
i
epar o t ih hat
or he
r t la or otvet c pl i ofi de - uc ast flng ofdi c plna yr po t
e a i t ym i he om a ned nci nt s h he ii
s i i r e rs
a i t c s a barwoul notha oc r d. splc as g fca bur non t
s n he a e t d
ve cure Thi a es i nii nt de
he
i a e M e e c l or ale tons of r t la i w ilnot w ihs a a s m a y
nm t . r onc us y l ga i
e a i ton l
t t nd um r

j dg n c le g . eimaemu t o u edr c e ie eo moi to o ,h
u me t haln e Th n t s pr d c ie t vd nc f tvain r te
m or pr bl s na i i le a c onol ofe nt f o whi h r t i ton m a
e oba e ce r o, ' l ge hr ogy
a
ve s r m
c e ala i
y
pl us bl be i e r d.
a iy
nf r e '
'

Woodsv Smih,60 F. 11 ,11 ( t Ci.1 (nt na ciai a f noesomit .
. t
3d 61 66 5h r 995)i er l ttons nd oot t
ted)

Concl or algai ofrtlai wilnotwihsa as
us y le tons eaiton l
t tnd ummayj me c l .
r udg nt halenge
Woods 60 F. a l1 (ii Ri ds v Donnel,84l F. 1 l (t Ci.1
,
3d t 66 ctng char on .Mc
l
2d 20, 23 5h r 988)

O :M Oï D Gh 7h 7- 40 b01 W PD
h
V
201 1 3 4. .

( p odig s mma y j d me t ds sa o rt l to cam whee imae n v r o fr d
u h l n u r u g n imis l f eai in li
a
r n t e e fee
doc ntr ortsi a e denc i s
ume a y e tmonil vi e n uppor ofase tons) Jone ,1 F. a 326(û a e
t s ri l; s 88 3d t
s us
bec
Joneshasaleged no fact s i entt dem ons r e t t appeleeshave engaged i conductt
l
s uffci o
t at hat he
l
n
hat

wilrs ti avi ai ofhi rg ofa ce st t cou thi rtlai cli fi.'.So a t,
l e ul n olton
s iht c s o he r s eaiton ams a1' me cs
)
e nt
ve hough t m a bek otva ed by r t i t y i e , r s dem i m i t tt yw oul notde e
hey y û i t
m
e ala or nt nt a e o
ni s ha he
d
tr

t or nayperon fo f t e r ieofhi rghta M ori v Powel 449F. 682,68 (t
he di r s r m urher xe cs
s i s' rs .
'
l,
3d
6 5h

Ci. 0 6 ( in Cr w o d v Brto , 2 U.. 7 , 8 n 1 ( 9 ).d C u ha t d n t ie
r2 0 ) ct g a f r -El . i n 5 3 S 5 4 5 8 .0 1 98)1 .c c cs o o rs
i
t
s
t t lve ofc tt ina vi ainsa ca f m t ba i ofaj1 cli 'I Reaiton
o he e l onsiuto l olto nd nnot or he ss
983 am.'d tlai
i a tona eo yi i ç sc pabl ofde e rngape s ofor na yfr nes fom f t re r sng
s c i bl nl f t û a e
i
tri
r on
di r im s r urhe xe cii

hi consiutonalrght. Bi v Eary,5 F. 267, (t Ci.2008)(iai omitd)
s tt i
i s' bbs . l 41 3d
'
270 5h r
ctton te .
Ta a lgest t ionofi a sdenidhi ablnke i ealai f hi flngag iva
we le ha prs
fcil
e m
a tnr t i ton or s ii
re nce
r ar ng f m a e of i e s i t s
eg di e l f c r n he hower Eve t
.
n hough Ta e ca res t bur n of es a i hi
w
r i he de
t bls ng
r t la i he ofer no s c fc f t or doc e a y evi e t s
e a i ton,
f s
pe i i ac s
um nt z
denc o uppol hi a l ga i of
' s le ton
t

rtlai SeeMc
eaiton.
Donal l F. a 23l(nmaefie t pr deevi nc ofrtlaoyi e )
d, 32 3d t
i t ald o ovi
de e eaitr ntnt.
Ta eha i ntteda c tt i l i ht t r g t f l c pl nt orgre nc aga ns a of i r
w
s de ii
ons iutona r g , he i ht o ie om ai s
i va es i t n fce .
l negl c i t alege f c - pe i i de ais Tawe ha notdem ons r t d t ta oft i vi l
n
e tng o l
a t s c fc t l ,
s
ta e ha ny he ndi dua s
i ved i de ng hi a bl thad kno l dge of a ale com pl i s o greva es tl d
nvol
n nyi
m
anke
w e
ny l ged
a nt r i nc i e
a i tt m .Tawe ha f ie t de ons r t t t he ei vi l deni d hi abl nke t r t i t
ga ns he
s a ld o m
ta e ha t s ndi dua s
e m
a t o e ala e
a i thi f tlng com pl i sorgreva esa i tprs of i i l .Ta e' cl i ofr a i ton,
ga ns m or i i
a nt
i nc ga ns i on fc a s w s a m
et la i
s a ng a one,f ist m ee t r qui ie pr ofc us ton:he hasf l t es a ih t tbutf
t ndi l
al o
t he e s t oof a a i
aied o t bls ha
or

hi flng c
s ii ompl i sand gre nc a ns a TDCJ CI e oye he woul no ha be n
ant
iva es gai t ny
- D mpl e,
d t ve e
de ed a bl ke . Se M c onal 1 F. a 231.
ni
an t
e D
d, 32 3d t
O :RA Oy D Gh
y
V
2017h173404. . PD
b01 W

Fi l Ta e' a l ga i c nnotbe de m e t pr de$ac o ogy ofeve sf om whi h
naly, w s le ton a
e d o ovi $ hr nol
nt r
c
r t la i m a pl us bl be i e r d. W oods 60 F. at 11
e a i ton y a i y
nf r e '
'
,
3d
66. Ta e as e t t he fl d a
w
s r s hat
ie
gr e nc r ga di f a e of i er i t s
i va e e r ng em l fc s n he howera e on J
ra
une l 20l He cl i s t the w a
3, 6.
a m ha
s
deni d a bl nke f om J y t N ovem be 201 Gr e nc r co ds s
e
a tr
ul o
r 6. i va e e r how t tdi ha a bl rke i
ha d ve a l t n
De m be 201 Tawe' m e e us of t w or r t la i i t a e
ce r
6.
s r e
he
d e a i ton n he bs nce of s ii f c s or
pec t c a t
d
ocum e a y e de e c nno s
nt l vi nc a t uppor acl i ofr t i ton.Cons quen l Ta e' cl i m us f i .
t am
e ala i
e
ty, w s a m
t al

I 'Johns 11 F. a 3l (lthe rl nts ng i s caesmus be mor t n t
d.
,
on, 0 3d t 0 ûgl eeva howi n uch s
t
e ha he
prs rsk rona bei t thei t vitm ofrtlai ' ( i Woodsv Edwar s, F.
ione' k s l lefha s he ci eaiton.) quotng
pe
'
.
d 51 3d
577,580 (t Ci.1 );Rihar son,8 F. at1 Ta salgai t t de a ofa
5h r 995) c d
41 2d 20. we' le ton hat he nil
bl nketw a r t i t y i notac i bl .
a
s e ala or s
tona e
On J 1 201 Tawe fl d St p 1gr e nc #201 5838 co pl i ng oft pr s nc
une 3, 6,
ie e
i va e
61
0, m a ni
he e e e

off mal ofi r i t s
e e fce s n he howera e
r a.Prs ofii l r ponded t t $An i tga i i oyour
ion fc a s es
ha :C nvesi ton nt
c ai w asco
lm
nduc e Acc di t LM J ns t blndst tw e e putup bl ki t ba h hous
t d. or ng o
oh on he i ha r
oc ng he t
e
ofi e s vi w e ur we a e f l i PREA codes N o f t r a ton w a r nt d by t s ofi e.
tc r e ns e
r olow ng
.
ur he c i
ra e
hi t c '
'

(
Docke EntyNo.1- , l2)
t r
l pp. - .
On J y 8,201 Taw e f l d St p 2 g i va e /201 58380. Prs of i a s r s
ul
6,
ie e
r e nc / 61
i on fci l e ponde .
d'
û
û
vburSt p 2 gre nc hasbee i tga e by t sof i e. ou w e e a opra e y a s a t
e
i va e
n nves i t d hi f c Y
r ppr i t l dvi ed t he

Stp llvelNo f t ri tgai i warntdbyt sofie. ( ke Enr No.1 1 pp. 4)
e e . urhe nvesi ton s ra e
hi fc ' Doc t ty
'
- , 3- .
O n D e e be 1 201 Ta e fl d St p 1gre
c m r 4, 6, w i e e
i vanc #201
e
705611 c pl i ngt ti J y
6, om a ni ha n ul
201 prs ofi i sf ie t pa k hi bl nke dur ng hi tans ert m e um c t
6, i on t c al a l d o c s a t i
s r f o di
us ody. Tawe s a e
tt s
t the c i d t c pl i and r ques a bl nke f om J y t N ove be ,butprs of i i l
ha
ontnue o om a n
e
t a tr
ul o
m r
i on fc a s
i no e hi r que t Pr s ofi a s r s
g r d s e s s. i on tci l e ponde t t k n i s i t o i o y c a m ha bee
d ha : t nve tga i n nt our l i
A.
s n
O : AOh DGy 7h 7h
R
V
20l 1 3404. . PD
b01 W

c
onduc e On 1 1 1 LSM Byr ca t yource l ndve ii t tyoudoi f c ha abl nke
t d.
2/ 9/ 6
d me o
la
rted ha
n a t ve a t

i yourposesi Nof t ra i wa edbyt sofi .'Doc EntyNo.1 1 p.6)
n
s son. urhe cton nunt
hi fce'( ket r
-, .
O n Fe ua y 1 201 Ta et l d St p 2 gr e nce#201
br r , 7, w i e e
i va
705611 Pr s ofi i l r ponde
6. i on tc a s es
d:
CYourSt p 2 g i va e hasbe n i s i t d by t sof i e.You w e e a opra e y ad s a t
û
e
r e nc
e nve tga e
hi fc
r ppr i t l vied t he

Stp 1lvelYoural ga i ofmic
e e .
le tons
s onduc bysa fc dnot s t i Nof t ri si ton
t t f oul
be usaned. urhe nve tgai

i warntdbyt sofie. ( ke Enr No.l 1 p.8)
s ra e
hi fc ' Doc t ty
'
-, .
Ta m a nt i t tt de e nt r t la c a i thi be us he a ie hi s foft
wc i a ns ha he f nda s e a i t d ga ns m ca e
va l d m el he
g i va e pr es Thi i a i ufi i talega i ofca a i asét por lpr m iy a one i
r e nc oc s. s s n ns t c en l ton
us ton ûem a oxi t l
s
i ufi i ntt pr butf c a i 'St ong v Uni H e t ar S . L. . , 2 F. 80 808
ns fc e o ove
or aus ton. r
'
. v. alhc e ys, L C. 48
3d 2,

(t Ci.
5h r 2007)s ealoJohns v Rodrgue ,11 F. 299,31 ( hCi.1 .Thef tha o
;e s
on . i z 0 3d
0 5t r 997)
ac t t ne
e ntf l w s a he i tm e doesno r i e a i er nc ofr t i ton. ow v Ti hom i go Cn/ ,
ve olo
not r n i
t a s n nf e e e ala i Enl . s
n
y.

Nls .45F. 885,889( h Ci.1 .
is, 3d
5t r 995)
Ta e has not s fc e l alege a r t la o y m otve by t de e
w
uf i i nty l d e a i t r
i
he f ndant ,a he has not
s nd

al ge ac onol ofe sfom whi r t lai m a bepl usbl i e r Tawe' pe s
le d hr ogy vent '
r
ch e ai ton y
a i y nf red.
s r onal
be i fa conc us y alega i a e i ufi i ntt r i e a f c ua di put t t de e nt a t
le nd
l or l tons r ns t c e o a s a t l s e hat he f nda s c ed

t rtlae Se Jone v.Gr ni r 1 F. 322,
o eait. e s
e nge, 88 3d
324-25( hCi.1 ,Wood ,60F. a l1
5t r 999)
.
s
3d t 66.
Ta e' r t i ton c a m l c m e i a i dim i s d,w ihoutl ave t am e bec us a e e
w s e ala i l i a ks rt nd s s s e
t
e
o
nd a e m ndm nt
woul be f ie.
d
utl
V.

The C l m Based on an I
ai
nadequate G ri
evance Sys em
t

Tawe a l ge t t he de e
le s ha t
f ndant vi a ed hi c vi rght by f ii t r s vet c pl nt
s ol t
s i l i s a lng o e ol he om ai s
pr s nt i hi g i va s $ pr s
e e ed n s r e nce . i i oner has a lbe t i e es onl i f e
A
i r y nt r t y n r edom s f om r s r nt
r
e tai
i posng a y c a s gni i a ha ds p on t i a e i r l ton t t or na y i de s of
m i t pi al nd i fc nt r hi
he nm t n e a i o he di r nci nt
O :RA Oh Gh 7 1 3404. . PD
h
VD 201 h 7b0l W

prs lf ' Gege vJowes, F. 371 373- ( hCi.
ion ie. i r . r 404 3d , 74 5t r2005)(ntr ciatona quotton
'
i enal t i nd ai
o te .Ani t doesnotha ac tt inal pr ecedlbe t i ees i ha nggre nc s
mitd)
nmae
ve onsiuto ly ot t i ry ntr tn vi iva e
r ol d t hi s ts a ton. The e i no due pr s vi a i w he prs ofi i s f i t do s
es ve o s a i f c i
r s
oce s ol ton
n i on f c al a l o
o.

Gei rv Jowes 404F. 371 373- (t Ci.
ge . r,
3d , 74 5h r 2005) s ealoEdmondv M ari e al si op.
.
,e s
. tn, t . lp
,
no.9560666( h Ci.Oc.2,1
5t r, t 996)(
unpubls d)( ionerscam t ta dee ntSfie t
ihe prs ' li ha
fnda sald o
i si t a de e hi giva e'as noc tt i lis ;Thomasv fen n et .si
nve tgae nd nid s re nc 'ries onsiutona suel
. sig, al, lp

op.no.0130658( h Ci.De 11 2001 (
5t r, c. , ) unpubls d)(a ) Thedefnda s alge f l e
ihe s me .
e nt' le d aiur
t a e s t g i va e t Ta e' s i f cto di no vi at hi c tt i
o ddr s he r e nc s o w s ats a i n d t ol e s ons iutonal rght The
i s.
e e p sf om t g i va r pons s it d by Ta e s
xc r t r he r e nce es
es ubm te
w how t tt def nt i tga ed hi
ha he enda s nves i t s
gre nce a pr ded tm e y r s
i va s nd ovi
i l e pons .
es
Ta e' duepr es c a m bas d onan i dequa e g i va pr edur l ksm e i . U . C .
w s
oc s l i
e
na
t r e nce oc
e ac
r t 28 S.

j l 5()2)B)i.
91 e( ( ()
VI.

The C l m Based on U nsaniary Condii
ai
t
tons

The Ei t A m e
gh h
ndm e pr hi t t i pos to of c ueland unus lpu s e . The
nt o bis he m
ii n
r
ua nihm nt
s a r ofde e m i ng whe hert c tonsa e c ue a u ua i us dr w ism ea ng f o
t nda d
t r ni
t he ondii
r r l nd nus l t t a t
m
ni r m
t e vi s a
he vol ng t ndar of de e y t m a k t pr r s of a m a urng s e y. Rhodes v
ds
c nc hat r he og e s
t i oci t '
'
.

Cha
pman,452 U. 337,346 ( 984) Condii û one ori c nai 'ma a untt a
S.
1 .
tons k
al
n ombi ton' y mo o
c tt ina vi ai I a 347.I Wis v Seie ,501U. 29 ( 991 ,heSu e Cour
onsiuto l olton. d t
n lon . tr
S. 4 1 ) t
prme
t
s r s d t tt Cons iuton doe notm a t c f t e pr s a onl de i tonsde ng
tes e ha he
tt i
s
nda e om orabl i ons nd y pr va i
nyi
i he m i m alci lze m e ur of lf s ne es ii s 'f r t bas s of a Ei h Am e
û
t
ni
vii d as e
ie' c s te ' o m he
i
n ght
ndm e
nt
vi ato Condii t ta e ' es rc i or e n ha s ...a e pa4 oft pe ly t tc i i l
ol i n.
tons ha r t t i tve
r
ve r h
r l
he na t ha rm na
of ender pay f t rof ensesagai s et ' Rhodesv.Cha an,452 U . at347.A tt sam e
f
s
or hei f
nst oci y.'
pm
S.
he
O :M Oh Gh
h
VD 2017h 3404. W PD
17b01.

8

tme i o d r osaeac g ia l cam, rs n r t le ef cs h wigt tal fiil a td
i ,n r e t tt o nz be li ap io e mus alg a t s o n haj io fcas ce
w ih a cul e s a e of m i
t
pabl t t
nd t tt y ac e w ih de i r e i f er nce W is 501 U . a
ha he t d t lbe at ndi f e . l on,
S. t

3 2 3 3, b riv Sh r o i r i Cz/. Te . 9 7F.d 9 4 1 0 ( t Ci.1 91 .Th Fit
0 - 0 . e t . e # fla rs 7 , x, 3 2 8 , 0 4 5 h r 9 ) e fh
Al
y
Ci ut a o s r e t a û e ti p io c ndto sgr )s ka e ihu na db r ai' h the
r ih s b e v d h tt ran rs n o i n ae o b s ,n ma n ab rc t a t y
c
c
i
vi ae t Eiht Amendme .'Nov v.Bet,453 F. 661 665 (t Ci.1 ) One s
olt he g h
nt' ak
o
2d ,
5h r 971 .
uch
co ton i dhe de i ton ofba i elm e sofhygi .' d.
ndii s t
t
prva i
sc e nt
ene'1
TheFit Cie tha r vi w e a va i t ofca e w hi h il t a et t ofc tonst t
fh r ui s e e d
rey
s s c lus r t he ype ondii ha

a ene s a y t bec i r d c ue a unus l l Binv v Be r gar Pars Polc Jur
r ce s r o
onsde e r l nd
ua . n e enu . au e d
ih ie y,

705F. 1 ( t Ci.1 ,hec t l t ttcla l Binve ssaeme st thedee nt
2d 457 5h r 983)t ourhed ha,t e ry, e nu' tt nt ha t fnda

pat i tn in ly s b e td hm t a c l r iy r a h if se fclt a d f r ih d hm wih
ry ne to al u j ce i o od, an , o c -n e td a i y n u n s e i t
i
i r tve, s - ncr t d w a hi a t l f ciii s s fc e l ale s a c e of a ton
nope a i
cum e us e
s ng nd oiet a lte uf i i nty l ge
aus
ci

cog z bl unde 42U. C.j1 a t eght andf te hamendme s' 1 a 1 ( tng
nia e r
S. 983 nd he i h
oure nt
nt.' d. t 460 cii
Rui v Esele, F. 11l 11 -40( hCi., nde i parandva at i pa t688F. 266
z , t l 679 2d 5, 37 5t r)ame d n t
c ed n r,
2d

(98 )
1 2).
I Pal rv Johns ,1 F. 3 353( h Ci.1 ,Pame cai t thewasnot
n me .
on 93 3d 46,
5t r 999) l r l med ha
al dt us aba hr durngt s ve ee hourout
lowe o e t oom i he e nt ndoorc i m e a wasi t a t d t t
onfne nt nd
nse d ol ha
hi onl opton wast ur na eand def a e i t c i a eat the s r d w ih f t e g ot
s y i
o i t
ec t n he onfned r ha
ha e t ory- i ht her
i a e The Fi t Ci e thel t ta c pl t de i ton oft l t f s or ofi a e c i
nm t s.
f h r ui d ha om e e pr va i
oie s or c es nm t s onfned
i t s m e s al a e c tt ed c ue a unus l puni hm e unde t Ei h A m e e
n he a
m l r a ons iut r l nd
ua
s nt
r he ght
ndm nt
be a e i a ount d t a l
c us t m
e o k i ton ofba i e e e sofhygi ne ' I H uto v Fi y,437 U .
deprva i
s c l m nt
e .' n
t . nne
S.

678,686 ( 978) t Supr me Cour saed,iti e l pl n,howe r t tt l t of
-87 1 , he
e
t tt k s qualy ai
l
ve, ha he engh
confnem entcannotbe i ed i deci ng w het t confnem entm eet constt i s andar
i
gnor n
di
her he
i
s
iutonal t
ds.
O :RA OW D GQ 017h17h
3404. . PD
b01 W

9

A flhy, r r wdedc l nd aditoft ue'm i bet er bl f af da a i olr bl r l
it ove c o
ela
e t ' ght ol a e or ew ys nd nt e a yc ue
gr
f wee orm ont '
or ks
hs.
'
The uns niar c t on of be ng f c t pl c hi cl a c ot ng on a dit s l i t
a t y ondii
i or ed o a e s e n l hi
ry he f n he

s
howe a e i muc l s ha s t t c to de c i i Pal r
r ra s
h e s r h han he ondii ns s rbed n me .Thef c sa aleg donot
a t s l ed
rs t t l lofa c tt i lvi a i Ta e' c ai f l t s a e a c a m upon w hi h r i
i e o he eve
ons iutona ol ton. w s l m ais o t t l i
c elef
m a be g a e a i f i ousi t ti l cksany bas s i l w a f ct
y
r nt d nd s r vol
n ha t a
i n a nd a .
Vl
l. The C l m B ased on a V i aton oft R i t Pri
ai
ol i
he ght o vacy

A p io e ' rg tt p i c i ( nma,a b s, wh nj x a o e wi te lgtmae
rs n rs ih o rva y s û i l t e t' e u tp s d t h e ii t
mi
'
h
s c iyne oft i tt i Se Olv rv Sc t276F. 736,745 (t Ci.2002) s ealo
e urt eds he nsiuton. e ie . ot,
3d
5h r
;e s
Eli tv Lynn,38 F. l8,1 91(t Ci.1 .Thus t Fi' Cic tha hedt ttgl
lot .
3d
90- 5h r 994)
, he fh rui s l ha ûthe
t
pr e off m a e prs gua ds f s curt r a ons on t e oc as ons whe m al pr s sa e
es nce e l i on r or e iy e s
hos c i
n
e i oner r

na i not c tt i lvi ai 'Pet v Johns l F. 51 1 W L 7
ked s a onsiutona oltona' ty .
on, 93 3d 8, 999
07860, t*l(t
a 5h

Ci.l ( bls dtbl op.(ii fec rv Tu ne 968F. 508, 0( hCi.1 ) The
r 999)unpu ihe a e ) ctng the . r r,
2d
51 5t r 992).
Fit Cic tha aloc it ntyhel t tt pr tc ofconduc i srp s a c si t pr s nc
fh r ui s s onsse l d ha he aci e
tng ti e r he n he e e e
of f m a e of i r i notunc tt i l Se O lve ,276 F. a 7 ,Eli t 38 F. at 1 - .
e l fce s s
ons iutona . e i r
3d t 47. lot,
3d
90 92,
fe c r 968 F. a 51 Ta e' c a m t t srght o prvac asvi a e bec us f m al of i e s
t he ,
2d t 0. w s l i ha hi i t i yw
ol t d a e e e f c r
w e e pr e w he he w ass e i i f i ous
r es nt
n
how rng s r vol .
V lI C oncl on
l.
usi

Theacinfl byRihadN. we(
to ied
c r Ta TDCJCI I t #1
- D nmae 596960)lc a agua ebass
a ks n r bl i

i lw. Hi cai ae DI I
na
s l ms r SM SSED wih prj c unde 28 U. C.j 1 e)2)B)i. Thi
t eudie
r
S.
915( ( ( ()
s
dimis lc tttsasrkef pur esof28U. C.j 1 5( .Publccour r or s t t
s s a onsiue ti or pos
S.
9l g)
i
tec ds how ha

ti ds sa sa d a Ta ' sv nhsrk , n hei bardfo p o e digif r
h s imis l tn s s we s e e t tie a d s re r m r c e n n o mapa pe i
u rs
O :RA O$ D GQ 0l h 7$
V
7 l 3404. . PD
b0l W

1
0

i cvilws t ora asSeeFlwcv Clmons C. No. l cv- 7( D. x. . 201 .
n i la uis ppe l.
. e , A. 4:7- 018 S. Te Apr25, 7)
,
Ftw:v Unk
z . nownPs hi rs,C. No. 11c 1 1 ( D. J 8, 11, z v Fegu on,
yc atit A. 3: -v- 0 6' Tex.une 20 ) Ftw: . r s
N.
.

C. No. 1 cv- ( D. x. c. 201 ,Ftwcv Eligt C. No. 1 c 3444( D.
A. 4:7- 3420 S. Te De 7, 7) z . ln on, A. 4:7-v.
S.
Te De 29,201 .Sho dTa a a t i tntdimis ,hewilbede e lavet pr e
x. c.
7) ul we ppe l he nsa s sal
l
nid e o oc ed
i f m a pa r s Any r m a ni pe ng m otons a e D EN I a m oo .
n or
upe i .
e i ng ndi
i
r
ED s
t
The TDCJ CI s l de tt e y pe c nt of e c depos tm ade t Ta s i ua e t s
- D ha l duc w nt r e
ah
i
o we' m t nlt

a ounta f wa dpa
cc
nd or r yment t t Coul on ar gul rbass pr dedt a count ee $1 00,
s o he
'
t
e a i , ovi he c
exc ds 0.
untlt flng f eoblga i of$350. i pad i f l
i he ii e
i ton
00 s i n ul.
TheCl r w il ovi a c oft sor rby r ul rm a l f s m ie ta m i s on, e- a l
e k l pr de opy hi de
eg a i, ac i l r ns s i or m i

t TD CJ-Ofi e oft G e r lCouns l Ca t St ton, O .
he
tc
he ne a
e , piol a i P. Box 1 4, us i
308 A tn,
Texas,78711,Fax:[phone],
936.

t I t Tr t Fund, P. Box 629, Huntvil Te s 77342he nma e us
O.
s le, xa
0629, Fa
x:
936- 437 4793;a
nd

( t M a r of t Thre- rkes Lit f t Sout r Ditit of Te s a:
3) he nage
he e sti
s or he
hen src
xa t

Th e S rk s t .s o rsg v.
re tie @ xsu c u t.o
'

SI N ED atHouson,Texas,
G
t

'

t

al
oa

,

t
'

.

*

N ESSA D .G I O
LM
UN I
TED STATES D I
STRI JU D GE
CT

O CRA Oh Gï 7ï 7h
VD ZOI 1 3404. . PD
b01 W