Kamenicky v. Davis

Filing 12

MEMORANDUM AND OPINION granting 9 MOTION for Summary Judgment with Brief in Support. COA is denied. (Signed by Judge Vanessa D Gilmore) Parties notified.(gclair, 4)

United States District Court
Southern District of Texas

ENTERED
I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF TEXAS
CT
H OUSTON DI SI
VI ON

November 30, 2018
David J. Bradley, Clerk

J
OHN A .
KAM ENI
CKY,

(
TDCJCI #02020271
- D
)
Pe ii r
ttone ,
V S.

CI L A CTI N N O . 1 1 3758
VI
O
1 - 7-

LORI D AV I
E
S,
R e ponde .
s
nt

M EM O M N DU M A N D O PI I N
N O

Peii r J
ttone, ohn

Ka c s e ha s cor elef unde 28 U. C.j 225
meniky, e ks bea pusr i
r
S.
4,

cha l ngi aconvi ton i t 232nd J c a D i ti tCour ofHani Count Te s Re ponde
le ng
c i n he
udi i l s r c
t
s
y, xa . s
nt

tldaM otonf Summa' J me ,(
ie
i or
l udg nt Docke EntyNo.9) a c esoft sat c trcor
y
t l
'
, nd opi
he t e our e d.
Ka niky has fld hi rs e.( ke Enty No.
me c
ie s e pons Doc t r

The t e hol is i whehe
hrs d sue s t r

Ka e c scl i s a e pr dur l de a t
m ni ky' a m r oce aly f uled.
1
.

Background

A j r f u d Ka n c y g l of t e f ln o fn e o mu d r ( us Nu e
uy o n
me ik uiy
t
h eo y fe s f r e . Ca e mb r
1
47761 01 ) OnAug t21 201 t co 's ntnc dKa nikyt lf i ionmen .The
301 0 .
us , 5,he ul e e e me c o ie mprs
t
t
Fi s Cour ofA ppe sofTexa a f r e Ka e c sc c i on D e em ber1 201 The Te s
rt
t
al
s f im d m ni ky' onvi t on
c
, 6.
xa
CourtofCr m i A ppeal ref
i nal
s used Kam eni s petton f di etonar r ew on M ar 29,
cky' ii or scr i y evi
ch

201 K a e cky tl d a a i a i f s a e ha as c pus r lefon J y 1 201 w hi h t
7. m ni
i e n pplc ton or t t be or
ei
ul 7, 7, c he

O : Oh D Gh 7h 7y
M
V
201 1 3758. .
b01 wpd

Te sCour ofCrmi l
xa
t
i na Appeasde e wihoutwrte or r on fndi oft tilc twihout
l ni d t
it n de , i ngs he ra our, t
a hea i on N ove be 8,201 Expar e Kam e c y Applc ton N o. 87, 01 a cove .
rng
m r
7.
t
ni k
iai
472- t
r

On De embe 1 201 t s Cour r eve Ka eni s f de a pe ii Ka e c
c
r 2, 7, hi
t ec i d m cky' e r l tton. m niky
c ends t t hi co c i i voi be us he w a not e ua e f com pe e y be or t i .
ont
ha s nvi ton s d ca e
s
val t d or
t nc f e ral

( ke EntyNo.1 Peii f rW rtofHa a Cor ,p. .
Doc t r
, tton o i
be s pus 6)
II
.

The A pplcabl LegalStandards
i e

Thi Cour r vi w sK a e c spe ii f wrtofha asc pusunde t f de al
s
te e
m ni ky' tton or i
be or
r he e r habe s
a

saues a a nde byt Anttnors a Efeci De t Pe t Ac of1 (
ttt , s me d he ie im nd f tve ah naly t 996 AEDPA) 28
.
U. C.j2254;Woodsv.Cock el307F. 353,356(t Ci.
S.
r l,
3d
5h r 2002) Noblsv Johns 1 F.
; e .
on, 27 3d

4 9 41 ( t Ci.1 9 ) ctn fi d v Muph , 21U. 3 0( 9 )
0 , 3 5h r 9 7 , iig n h . r y 5
S. 2 1 97 .
Se tons225 d)1 a ( ofAEDPA s outt sa dsofrvi f q si offc,
ci
4( ( ) nd 2)
et he tndar
e ew or uetons a t

q e to oflw, n mi dq e to so fc a lw t t eul i a a j iai no teme is
u sins a a d xe u sin f a t nd a ha r s t n n dudc to n h rt.
Ana j dc to o t emeisisatr o a th t e est wh t r c u tsd s sto o t ec s
d u iain n h rt k em f r ta r fr o ehe a o r' ipo i n f h a e
i
i
i s tni asoppos dt pr edurl' Milrv Johns ,200F. 274,281( hCi.
s ubsa tve,
e o oc a. le .
'
on
3d
5t r 2000) A
.
s a e c t t r i ton ofques i of1 w and m i d que tonsofl w a f c i r vi w e unde
t t - our de e m na i
tons a
xe
si
a nd a t s e e d
r

28 U. C. j 225 d () a r eve deernc unls i ( s c rr t or i ve a
S.
4() 1 nd ec i s f e e e s t d
wa ontay o, nvol d n
unr as bl a i a i ofc e ry e t bls d Fe a l w , de e m i d by t Supr m eC o t
e ona e pplc ton l a l s a i he der l a as t r ne
he
e
ur of

t UniedStts' Hilv John on 21 F. 48l, ( h Ci.2000) A saec tde soni
he t ae .' l . s , 0 3d
485 5t r
. tt-our cii s

d rr t ' e Courprce nti: 1 t saec tsconcusoni S
i ay o'Suprme
cont
t e de f () he tt our'
l i s i iet t ra d
oppost o hate che
by ghe Su e Cour)on a quesi oflw' or( t ktt c tc r sf t t tae
t
prme
t
ton a ' 2) he s ae our onfont acs ha r
s
m a e i ly i s i ui ha e f om a r e ntSupr m e Coul pr ce ' and a r ve a a oppost
t r a l ndi tng s bl r
el va
e
' e dent'
t
ri s t n
ie

r ul. Wilamsv Ta or l S.Ct 1 (
es t li
. yl , 20
. 495 2000) A saec tunr s bl a i Suprme
. tt our ea ona y pples e
O : Oh Gy 7h 7h
M
VD 201 1 3758. . pd
b01w

Coul pr c denti i unr as bl a i st c r tlga r e t t f c sofa pa tc a c e, or
' ee
t
f t e ona y pple he orec e l ul o he a t
riul r as

iCu e s bl e e al lprnci efom g e Coul)prce ntt ane c extwhee
tdnr a ona y xtnds ega i pl r supr me
' e de o w ont
t
r
i s d no a y orunr a ona y r f est e e t tpr nci e t a ne c e w her i s d
t houl t ppl
e s bl e us o xt nd ha i pl o
w ont xt
e t houl

a y. 1 a 1
ppl ' d. t 495.Queto offc fundbyt saec taei es
'
sins a t o
he tt our r û umedt bec rc ... nd
pr
o ore t a

ge ev )d frnc . . nls i ç sba e o a u r a o a l d tr nain o t fcsi lg t
rc ie eee e . u e s t wa s d n n n e s n b e eemi to f he a t n i h
oft e denc pr e e i t Stt courpr ee ng.' Hil21 F. a 485( i 28U. C.
he vi e esntd n he ae t oc di '' l, 0 3d t quotng
S.
j2254( ( )
d)2).
A s a ec tsf c ua fndi a e e il d t de e e e on f de a ha sc pusr vi w a
t t our ' a t l i ngs r ntte o f r nc
e r l bea or
e e nd

aepr u dcor c unde s ci 2254()1 unls t peii rrbust efndi wih( e r
r es me re t r e ton
e( ) e s he ttone e t hos i ngs t s a
cl

a con ncnge denc 'Ga ci v Quareman, 4F. 44l444( hCi. )( tngf l c.
nd vi i vi e. r a . tr 45 3d , 5t r2006 cii ff cç
'
g/
v Dr te,41 F. 58 589( t Ci. )a 28U. C.j2254()1) Thi def e e ends
. ek 2 3d 2, 5h r 2005 nd
S.
e( ). s ernce xt
notonl t expr s tndi of f t butt t i plc tfndi oft s a e c tasw el. Gar i
yo
e s i ngs ac ,
o he m i i i ngs he t t our
l
c a,

45 F. a 444- ( tngSu r v. eke 431F. 861 876(t Ci.
4 3d t 45 cii mme s Dr t ,
3d , 5h r 2005) Youngv Dr k
;
. ete,
35 F. 61 629( h Ci.2004).
6 3d 6,
5t r
)

W hl,k l ag n r l rn i e Ru e5 o t eF d r l e of viP o e u e r ltn t
i da s e ea p icpl, l 6 f h e ea Ruls Ci l r c d r ,eaig o
e g
s mmayj g n ,a p iswi e u lf rei t e c n e to h be s c r u c s s' Clr v
u r ud me t p le t q a o c n h o tx f a a o p s a e , a k .
h
'
John on,202F. 760,76 ( hCi., r. e 531U. 8 (
s
3d
4 5t r)ce tdeniJ
S. 31 2000)t r ea isonl t t
,he ul pple y o he
extntt ti doe no c lc wiht ha sr es Seci 2254() 1 - whih ma tst t
e ha t s t ontit t he bea ul . ton
e ()
c ndae ha
fndi off c m a by a s a e c t r S es e t be c r c '- over i t or na yr et t
i ngs a t de
t t our a e û um d o
pr
or e t'
rdes he di r ul ha ,

i as mmayj d me t r c e ig, ld s u e fcsmu t ec n tu di t el h mo t a r be
n u r u g n p o e dn al ip td a t s b o sr e n h i t s fvo a l
g
t t nonmovi pa t Unl st peii rc nkebut 1t pr umptonofc rcne sbyclar
o he
ng ry. es he ttone a û g he es i
r
ore t s
e

O :M O h D Gh
h
V
20l7 l 3758. . d
h 7b01 N

a c nci evi nc 'ast t saecour' fndi off c , hos fndi mus bea ce e as
nd onvi ng de e' o he t t
ts i ngs a t t e i ngs t c pt d

c rc.Smihv.Coc r l 311F. 661,668(t Ci.
ore t
t
k el,
3d
5h r 2002)
.
Ka nikyi pr e ngpr s A pr s ha aspe ii i consr d lbe a l a not l
me c s oc edi o e.
o e be
tton s
tue i r ly nd hed
t t s e s rnge and rgor uss a r a pl a ngstl d by l w ye s Se M ar i v M a y,98
o he am t i nt
i o t nda ds s e di i e
a r. e
tn . xe

F. 844,847n. (t Ci.1 ;Gui o v L
3d
4 5h r 996) dr z . ynaugh, F. 832,834(t Ci.1988 ;Woodal
852 2d
5h r
)
l
v Fot,6 F. 268, 1( hCi. tA J 1 1 .Thi Courbr l i eprt Ka ni y'
. i 48 2d
27 5t r Uni une 98 ) s t oady ntr es me ck s
saea f rlha aspeii .Blds v Johns ,1 F. 250,255(t Ci.1 .
tt nd edea be ttons e ue .
on 88 3d
5h r 999)
11
1.

The C l m Bas on a D eni ofa C om pet
ai
ed
al
ency H eari
ng

The s ope off de alha sr viw i lmie by t i e t ne doc rnesofpr e a
c
e r
bea e e s i td
he nt rwi d ti
oc dur l

dea ta e
ful nd xhausi Bl uev.
ton. eds Johns ,1 F. 250,254( hCi.1 .Or naiy, sae
on 88 3d
5t r 999) di rl a tt
prs rseki fderlha asr le mus trtCe ust t r me esavalbl i t c t of
ione e ng e a be eif tis ûxha gl he e di
ia e n he ours
t Stt '28U. C. 2254( ( )A)t rbyaf di hos c tdhefrto runiyt a e s
he ae,
'
S. j
b)1( ,hee for ngt e oursû is ppo t t o ddr s
t

a c rc algedvi ai ofghe prs rsfdea rght. Colmanv Thomps 501U.
nd ore t le
oltons t j ione ' e rl i s' e
'
.
on,
S.

7 , 31( 9 1 .Th a e uaea di d p nd n saeg o n d crn f rh r t a o j cie f r
22 7 1 9 ) e d q t n n e e e t tt r u d o ti e u te s h t be t , o
v
w iho i, s beaspe ii r w oul bea et a d t exha tonr quie e bydef uli t i
t ut t d
ha
ttone s
d bl o voi he
us i e r m nt
a tng he r

fderlcamsi saec t' Wale v Mari 1 S. .1l ( 1 ( i Col
e a li n tt our.' k r . tn, 31 Ct 20 201 ) quotng eman, U.
501 S.

a 732) Exha ton rquiest tt prs rû vef rypr s nt t s tnc ofhi cli t
t .
usi e r ha he ione i
ha ail e e ed he ubsa e s am o
t saecours'Noblsv Johnson 1 F. 409,420 (t Ci.1 ) Bec us t e usi
he tt
t.' e .
, 27 3d
5h r 997 . a e he xha ton
doc rne i desgned t gi t s a e cours a f l a f i opporuniy t r ol f de a
ti s
i
o ve he t t
t
ul nd a r
t t o es ve e r l
cons iutonalcl m sbef et e cl m sar pr ent t t f alcourt st eprioner m us gi
tt i
ai
or hos ai
e es ed o he eder
s, at s s t ve

t s a e c t one f loppor uniy t r s ve a c tt i
he t t our s
ul
t t o e ol ny ons iutonali s s by i
s ue
nvoki one co pl t
ng
m ee
r
ound oft st e' es abls appelat r ew pr
he at s t i hed
l e evi
ocess.O ' ul i v.Boerckel 526 U . 838,846
S lvan
,
S.

0 : A0W D 6y 7h 7h
R
201 1 3758. . pd
b01w

(9 9 . i tr nng wheh r a p tto e e h u td hi cam i sae c u ti a c s -a d
1 9 ) s emii
De
t e eiin r x a se s li n tt o r s a e n
fd-pe fci r 'Moor v Quare man 533F.d 338,341( t Ci. )(nba )
a s eii nquiy.
'
e.
tr ,
3
5h r 2008 e nc .
l Te s aci na dee ntma c lng aeonvitonbyt ki t f l ngpahs ( )
n xa , rmi l fnda
y hale e
ei
a ng he olowi t : 1
t pe ii ne m a f l a di e ta alf l e i nec s a y, a pe ii f di c e i y r vi w
he tto r y ie r c ppe olow d, f e s r by
tton or s r tonar e e

i t Te sCo tofCrmi lAppe l;a o ( hema tl apeii f wrtofha a c pus
n he xa ur
i na
as nd/r 2)
y ie tton or i
be s or
unde Aril 11. o t Te Code ofCrm i lPr dur i t co c i cour,whih i
r tc e 07 f he xas
i na oce e n he nvitng
t
c s
ta mit t t TexasCour ofCrmi lAppea sonc t tilc 'de e neswhe he fndi
r ns ted o he
t
i na
l
e he ra oul t nni
t
t r i ngs

aenec s ay. eTe CodeCrm. oc. r.11. j3() s ealoBus yv Dr te 359F.d708,
r e s r Se x.
i Pr a t 07, c; e s
b . ek ,
3

723 (t Ci.2004)(klbe peii r mus exha tsaerme e by purui t rcl ms
5h r
i-a as ttone s t us tt e dis
l
s ng hei ai
t oughonec eec eofet rsaedie ta lorpos-onvitoncolaea pr e ngs'
hr
omplt ycl ihe tt rc ppea
tc ci
ltrl oc edi .
).
Af r c t
ede al our gene a l ca
r ly nnotr vi w t m e isofasa eprs r sha spe ii i t
e e he rt
tt ione ' bea tton f he
c a m s i t pe ii a e pr dur ly de a t Se ,e g. M agwood v.Pate son 561 U . 320,
l i n he tton r oce a l f uled. e . ,
tr ,
S.

3 ( 0)(ûfapeii rdoe notstsyt pr durlr r nt f brngi a er t t
40 201 tl ttone s aif he oce a equieme s or i ng n ror o he
s a e c tsa t nton -w he he i t i ,a la e orha a pr e ngs ass a e l w m a r r t t our ' te i
t r n ral ppe l t ,
be s oc edi , t t a
y equie

pr e al fulwil fderlrvi '.A ha scai c nbepr edurlydef t i et r
oc dur dea t lbar e a e ew.)
'
bea l m a
oc al auled n ihe

oft wa .Colman v Dr k ,3 F. 21 220( t Ci.2004) ce t de e 546U. 938
wo ys e
. ete 95 3d 6,
5h r
, r. nid,
S.
(
2005)Se ge r l O 'ulv v Boe ck l526U. 8 850 ( 999)( eve , .disntng)
. e ne aly S lian . r e,
S. 38, -56 1
St ns J, se i
(xpli ngt difr nc bewee t t vaitesofpr durl ful)Bldsuev.
e ani he fe e es t n he wo rei
oce a dea t; e
Johns ,1
on 88
F.d 250,254(t Ci.1 .
3
5h r 999)
Fis,ûg r edurldeaul ...oc ur whe a prs rf l t e us a l e sae
rt ûploc a f t
c s n
ione ais o xha t vaiabl tt
r m e e a t c t o whi h pe ii rw oul be r quie t pr s nthi cl i s i or rt m e t
e di s nd he our t
c ttone
d
e rd o e e
s a m n de o e

t e usi r quieme
he xha ton e r ntwoul now fndt cai spr dur l red.' li v Thalr 602
d
i he l m oce alyba r 'Wilams . e ,
O :R AOh D GQ 01 l 3758. v pd
y
V
7h 7b0lw

F. 29l,3 ( t Ci.201 .W l saermt e aer ndeeduna ia ebypeii rsown
3d
05 5h r Q) wn tt e dis r e r
valbl
ttone '
pr dur lde a t orwhe 'i i obvi t tt une use c am woul bepr ed a l ba r
oee a f ul,
n st s
ous ha he xha t d l i
d
oc ur ly red

i saec u t we wi f r g t en e ls S diilpig p n a h l t ecam p o e u al
n tt o r,
l o e o h e de s j ca n - o g' nd od h li r c d rly
l
u
bardfom ha srviw.' sv Har t 61F. 41 41 (t Ci.1 ( i Stelv
re r
bea e e 'Sone . get,
3d 0, 6 5h r 995) quotng e .
l fg,11F. 1518,1 ( 0t Ci 1 ) s ealoCol
' n
ot
3d
524 1 h r. 993 ) e s emanv.
Thomps ,50lU. 7 736n.
on
S. 22,
1

( 9 1)($ 1 t epeiine f i dt e ha s saerme isa t c u towhihp tto e wo l
1 9 ) klf h tto r al o x u t tt e d e nd he o r t c eiin r u d
(
e
ber quie t pr e hi cl m si or rt m e tt e usi r quiemen woul no fnd t
e r d o es nt s ai n de o e he xha ton e r
t
d w i he

cai pr edu al bar ...ghe t r i apr durldea tf pur esoffderlhabe s.
l ms oc r ly red, t n) hee s oce a ful or pos
e a
a

Se ond,i t prs rhaspr s nt t c ai t t hi he ta ia e s a e cour butt t
c
f he i one
e e ed he l m o he g s va l bl t t
t
ha

c t sdimis d t cli ona sa e lw pr dur lgr
our ha s s e he a m
tt -a oce a ound i t adofde di i ont me is
nse
ci ng t he rt ,
t c a m ha be n de i d on a i pe nta ade t s a e l w gr
he l i
s e c de
n nde nde nd qua e t t - a
ound. ,e. ,H ar i v
See g.
rs .

Ree ,489U. 255,262 ( 98 .ûl asae c 'cl ry a expr sy ba esisdimis lofa
d
S.
1 9) tf tt oul eal nd
t
esl s t s sa
pr s r s c a m on a s a e pr e a r e a t tpr edur lr e pr de a i pe nta
i one ' l i
t t oc dur l ul , nd ha oc
a ul ovi s n nde nde nd

a quae g ound f dim is l t prs
de t r
or s s a , he ionerha pr e al de a t hi f de a ha asc am .
s oc dur ly f uled s e r l be l i '
'

NoblsvJohns 1 F. 409, ( hCi.1997)c r.de e 5 U. 11 ( 998 .Thesae
e .
on, 27 3d 420 5t r
, e t ni4 23 S. 39 1 )
tt
pr e alr e m us be û7 h i pe
oc dur ul
t $ 0t nde nden oft m e isoft f de alcl i a a ade t ba i
1
t he rt
he e r a m nd n qua e s s

f t cou tsdecson. Fi e v.
or he r' ii ' nly Johns ,243F. 21 21 ( hCi. ) A saepr e al
'
on
3d 5, 8 5t r2001. tt oc dur
r e i a ade t ba i f t cour ' de i i onl i i i Ss rc l or r ul l a i d
ul s n
qua e s s or he
ts c s on
y f t s tt i ty
eg ary pple

e e h n e l t teva tmao iyo smia cams'Amo v S ot 61F.d 3 3, 3 (t Ci.
v n a d dy o h s j rt f i lr li .
' s.c t
,
3 3 3 9 5h r)
(mpha i omitd) cc /denid,51 U. 1 (995 .
e
ss te , r. e 6 S. 005 1 )

O : O h DG h 7y 7y
M
V
201 1 3758. .
b01 wpd

Ka e cky a s r st tt t i e tf ie t e
m ni
s e t ha he ral our a l d o ondud a c pe ene he r ng prort t i l
om t y a i
i o ra .

(
Docke EntyNo.1Fe r l tton, 6) Res
t r
, de a Peii p. . ponde aguest thi cai i pr durlybard
nt r ha t s l m s oce al re
be a e Ka c fie t e us a ia e sae c tr di . ( ke Enty No.9,
c us meniky ald o xha t valbl tt our eme es Doc t r
Re ponde ' M oin f SummayJ me , 7)
s
nts to or
r udg ntp. .
The sa e co tr c d s w s t t Kame c pr ent fve g ounds c lngng t
t t ur e or ho
ha
ni ky es ed i r
hale i he

s fcenc oft e de ei hi saea iatonf pos-onvitonr le .( ke Enr
ufii y he vi nc n s tt pplc i or tc ci eif Doc t tyNo.1
01 pp.1 1 . Ka ni y alo c lnge t s fce y oft e de i hi peii f
7,
0- 9) me ck s hale d he ufiinc
he vi nce n s tton or
dicei r rviw.( ke EntyNo.l 9,p. .
srtonay e e Doc t r
0- 9)
l t i t ntf r pe ii K a e c c pl nst the s d ha had a com pe e y
n he ns a ede al tton, m ni ky om ai ha
houl ve
t nc
e m i ton be o e ti l o eve ,K a e c di notr s t i s ofcom pe e y i e t rhi
xa na i
f r r a .H w r m ni ky d
ai e he s ue
t nc n ihe s

sa ea ia i orpe ii f dicr tona y r vi w.
t t pplc ton
tton or s e i r e e

Asnotd,ûg)pr dur dea t..oc ur whe aprs rfist e us avalbl sae
e ûa oce al ful . c s n ione al o xha t ia e tt
r m edi and t cour t whi h t pe ii r woul be r r t pr s nthi c a m s i or rt
e
es
he
to
c he ttone
d
equied o e e
s l i n de o
m ee t e us i r quiem e
t he xha ton e r ntwoul now fndt c a m spr dlr lyba T d. .r àf :v Johns
d
i he l i
oce l a l l e ' ht hc .
' /
on,

1 F. 409, (t Ci.1 (iai a i ena quottonmar omit .Kame c fie
27 3d 420 5h r 997) ctton nd ntr l ai
ks ted)
niky ald
t e
o xhaus s a e cour r edi s w ih r ar t hi com pe e y he r ng cl m r i e i hi f r
t tt
t em e t eg d o s
t nc a i
ai a s d n s ede al
ha a pe ii
be s tton. Shoul t s Cour r quie K a eni k t r t n t s a e co t t s ts y t
d hi
te r
m c y o e ur o t t ur o a i f he
e us i r quie e w ih t Te sCour ofCrm i lAppe s t tc t oul fnd t c ai s
xha ton e r m nt t he xa
t
i na
al , ha our w d i he l m

pr edurly bar unde t a eoft wrtdocrnef
oc al red
r he bus he i ti ound i Ari e 11. j4 oft Te
n tcl 07,
he xas
Code ofCrm i Pr ed e Be a e Te sw oul lke y ba a herha sco pusa i a i by
i nal oc ur . c us xa
d i l r not
bea r
pplc ton
K a eni ky,he has c m it d a pr dur de aul t t i s fci ntt barf r lha s c pus
m c
om te
oce al f t ha s uf i e o
ede a bea or

rviw.See eg. Bagwelv Dr k 372F. 748,755- ( h Ci.200 ( di apeii r
e e
,. ,
l . ete,
3d
56 5t r 4) hol ng ttone
O :M O h DG h 7h 7h
V
201 1 3758. . d
b01 N

pr dur ly de a t d by f lng t C ail pr en ' acl m t t sa e c t i hi sa e ha s
oce a l f ule
aii o s ry es t' ai o he t t ours n s t t bea
f

c pusa i to ;Smih v.Cock el 311F.d 661,68 (t Ci.200 ( di unex use
or pplcain) t
r l,
3
4 5h r 2) hol ng
ha td
camswe epr e al ba rd)Jone v.
li
r oc dur ly re ; s Johns 1 F. 270,276- (t Ci.1 )(a )
on, 71 3d
77 5h r 999 s me .
To ove co et pr dur l ron none us i n, a eni ky m us tde ons r t c us f
r m he oce a ba
xha t o K m c
t d m t a e a e or

ted fut n a ta p eu iea ars lo t alg dvo aino f d rla o d mo taet a
h e a la d cu l rj dc s e ut fhe le e ilto f e ea lw, r e nsr t h t
f i r t c n ie t e camswilrs ti a f n a n a mic rig o j sie' Co e n v
al e o o sd r h li
u
l eul n u d me tl s ara e f u tc . lma .
'
Thomps , 501
on

Quare man,5 F. 51 523- (t Ci.2008) me c ofe sno ag nt t twoul
tr
22 3d 7, 24 5h r
.Ka niky fr
r ume s ha
d
e us t pr edur l def ul. K a e ck does not di put t t t s cl i i une used.
xc e he oc
a
a t
m ni y
s e ha hi a m s
xha t
Kam e c scl i r l tngt t f iur t c
ni ky' a m e a i o he a l e o onduc ac pe e yexa i t o i dim i s dbe us
t om t nc
m na i n s s s e ca e
i i pr e a l ba r d.
t s oc dur ly- r e
I .
V

Conc us on
l i

Re ponde ' M oton f Summay J
s
nts i or
r udgme ,(
nt Docke Enty No.9) i GRANTED.
t r
,s
Kam e c s petton f a w rt of ha s c pus i D EN I . Thi ca e i D I I
ni ky'
ii or
i
bea or
s
ED
s s s SM SSED . A ny
r ai ng pendi m otonsare D EN I asm oot
em ni
ng
i
ED
.

The s i nec s r f a Ce tf c t of A ppe a lt i a s t ntals
how ng es a y or
r ii a e
al biiy s ubs a i howi of t
ng
he

de a ofac tt i li . r
nil onsiutona rghtHe nande .
zvJohns 21 F. 243, (t Ci.
on, 3 3d 248 5h r zooolctngk ck
tii s
o
v.Mc e,429 U. 473,483 (
Danil
S.
2000). An a i ntmakesa s tnta s ng whe he
)
pplca
ubsa il howi
n
de taest thi applc ton i ve is t taede tbl a
monsrt ha s iai nvol s sues ha r baa e mongj it ofras t
urss e on,hat
ano he c tc d r s ve t i s dif r nty,ort tt i s ar s t bl e
t r our oul e ol he s ues f e e l
ha he s ues e uia e nough t de e v
o sre

ene a me t pr e f t r Se Cl kv Johns ,202F. 760,763( t Ci.
ourge nt o oc ed urhe . e ar .
on
3d
5h r 2000)
.

O :M O y DG h 7y 7y
V
201 1 3758. wpd
b01.

W he t dititcour de esaha spe ii o pr dur gr
n he src
t ni
bea tton n oce al oundswihoutr c ng t
t
ea hi he
prs r sunderyi c tt i cli ,a COA s d is whe t prs rs
ione '
l ng onsiutonal am
houl s ue
n he ione hows a las,
, te t

ta j rssof e s nwo l fndid b tbewh te t ep tto sae av ldcam o t d n a
h tu it r a o ud i t e aa l eh r h eiin tts ai li f he e il
o ac nsi to a rg t ndt a j rsso ra o wo l fn i d b tb ewh t rtedsrc c u t
f o tt in l ih a h t u it f e s n u d i d t e aa l ehe h itit o r
u
wasc rctnispr e alulng.
ore i t oc dur r i RuddvJohns 256F. 31 31 ( hCi. lcii Sl k
.
on,
3d 7, 9 5t rzool t tng ac ,
5 U. a 48 .Ka ni ha notmadet nec s r s ng.Ac or ngl ac rii t of
29 S. t 4) me cky s
he esay howi
c di y, e tfcae
a a a lt i D EN I .
ppe l biiy s
ED

SG DaHos nTexas,on
INE t ut
o
,

.

7

,2018.

V AN ESSA D .GI O RE
LM
UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J D GE
CT U

O :M Oy D Gh 7y 7h
V
201 1 3758. . pd
b01w