Moisiuc et al v. Argent Mortgage Company LLC et al

Filing 55

ORDER granting 19 Motion for Judgment; granting 22 Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim. (Signed by Judge Alfred H Bennett) Parties notified.(gclair, 4)

United States District Court
Southern District of Texas

ENTERED
UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI C OU RT
CT
SO U TH ERN D I
STRI O F TEX A S
CT

March 25, 2019
David J. Bradley, Clerk

H OU STO N DI I ON
V SI

STEFAN M OI UC,etal
SI
,
Pl i if ,
a ntf s
VS.

CI I A CTI N N O . 1 CV V L
O
4: 8- 383

ARGEN T M O RTG A GE CO M PA N Y LLC ,
et
al
,
Def nda s
e nt .
O R D ER

Bef e t Co tar Defnda s M oi fr J
or he ur e e nt' ton o udgme on t Pl di ( /1 ,
nt he ea ngs Doc. /9)
Pli if'Res e( /27) Dee
antfs pons Doc./ , fndant M otont Dimis( /22)(ogehe wih Doc.
s' i o s s Doc./ t t r t
/1 t û otons',Plitfs Res e( #29) a Def nt'Re y( /33 .Ha ng
/ 9,he û i ') anif' pons Doc. , nd enda s pl Doc./ ) vi
M
r viwedt pa tes ar
e e
he ri ' gument a a ia el la hort t Cour gr nt t M otons
s nd pplc bl ega ut iy, he
t a s he
i .
1
.

Bac ound
kgr
Thi i a m o t ge f e os e di put OnJ l 8 2 0 Plitfse e ue a Ad u tbe
ss
r ga or cl ur s e.
uy , 0 4, an if x c td n j sa l

RaeNot (he1Not')andDee ofTr twihAr entM orgageCompa LLC (ç g ) Se
t e t i e'
d
us t g
t
ny,
iAr enf'. e
Doc /2 Ex. a Doc./11 Ex.1 r pec i l l Subs quenty, on O c obe 1 201 t N ot
. / 2, A nd
/ ,
, es tve y.
e
l
t r 5, 2, he e

1The Cour m a c i r t c
t y ons de he opy of t N ot a t c d t t M otons undera Fe r lRul of
he
e ta he o he
i
de a
e
Ci lPr ce e 1 a ys s bec us t N ot i ce r t Pl i i f 'cl m sconc ni m o t ge
vi o dur 2 nal i
a e he e s ntal o a ntf s ai
er ng r ga
l n doc e s a Pl ntf s do notcon e tt a he i iy of t c
oa
um nt , nd ai i f
t s he ut ntc t
he opy. Se ,e g. Doc /11 a
e . , ./ t

! 1 (û- Noea De d ofTr tt t raehe eorh t la n'orEs n Doc t'''
2 tlhe t nd e
us ogehe r nc f t he loa
loa
umens' 5
l
KaneEntr ie v MacGr gor(
eprs s .
e USA)I ,322 F.d 371 37 ( t Ci.2003 (ûhecoul ma
nc.
3
, 4 5h r
) tt
' y
t
r vi w t doc e s a t c d t t m oton t di m i s ...,w he e t c pl ntr e s t t
e e he
um nt ta he o he
i o s s
r he om ai ef r o he

doc nt a t yar ce rlt t cai ')
ume s nd he e nta o he l m. .
'

a d De d o Tr s we ea sg e (h û sg me f)fo Ar e tt W el Fa g Ba k N.
n e f u t r si n d t e k in n ' r m g n o ls r o n , A.
As
(s el Fa g ' t
t ls r o' hough Pli if aleget tt As i
W
)
antfs l ha he sgnmenti af gey.SeeDoc.#11 Ex. ,
s or r
, 7'

i a !33.
d t
Spectc ly, Pli tfs a lge t t Ta a Hil t i pore ' sgna or of t
ii a l
a n if le
ha
nyi
l, he t
pur td' i t y
he
A s i e ,di nots g oraf i hers g t e t t A s i enta t tt s g t e a
sgnm nt d
in
fx
i na ur o he s gnm
nd ha he i na ur bove he
r

sgnaur bl wa l i ora fxe by s onees g t lt knowldgeora hort of
i t e ock s s gned fi d ome le wihout he
s
e
ut iy
Ta aHi1' 1 a !33.l s
nyi 1.' d. t
n uppor oft i f geyalgai Pl ntfsur et Court viualy
t her or r le ton, ai if g he
to s l
Co r f r usdifrngnotrze sgnaursOfTanyi Hi1' 1 a !34. #11 Ex.8.
mpa e s
nume o fei
ai d i t e
a 1. d. t ,
'
Doc. ,
2
l r s ns t a a t m ptt f ec os by W els Fa go a Spe a i d Loa Se vi i
n e po e o n te
o or l e
l r nd
ci lze
n r c ng,

LLC, anif a s r fur( )camsba e o t alg df r ey:
Plitfs s e t o 4 li
s d n he l e o g r
e
QuitTil
e te;
* V i a i ofSe ton 1 002 oft Te C i lPr tc a Rem edi Code;
ol ton
c i 2.
he xas vi ac i e nd
es

* Vi ai oft Texa De Cole i Ac ( x.Fi Code Ar jj392. ,e
olton he
s bt lcton t Te n.
m.
301 t
s q.( e tSupp. 9).a
e W s
201 ) nd
,
@ Vi ai of t Te De ptve Tr Prctc Ac (
olton
he xas ce i
ade a ies t Tex.Fi Code Ann.
n.
j392. .
404)
I a ! 55- a 7 4.Addii l Pl ntfss e adecaai unde Te a fderl1
d t ! -61 nd 2-9
tonaly, ai if e k
lrton
r xas nd e a aw
co r ng t l ga e f toft a l ed f ge y on C ai if 'a D e enda s r g s a du i
nce ni he e l f ec
he leg or r
t ntf s nd f
pl
nt ' i ht nd tes

i co eci wih't Not a De ofTr t 1 a ! 47-54.
n mz ton t 'he e nd ed
us. d. t !

2 l r s ns t Pl ntf s Com bi M oton f Lea t Conduct Ta ge ed Di cove y on
n e po e o ai i f '
ned
i or
ve o
r t
s
r

Pli if'For r Cli ( ./1 ,t Cour hed a tlphoni he i on Aprl20,201
antfs gey am Doc /3) he
t l ee
c arng
i
8,
w he e n t Cour per it d Pl i if t c uc lm ie di c r r ar ng t e pl e
r i he
t m t e a ntf s o ond t i t d s ove y eg di he m oym nt
hi t y of Tanyi H il a a know l
sor
a l nd ny
edge s m i ht ha had a
he g
ve
bout t A s i nm en .
he
sg
t
Subs ue l t C o the d t t Ba of A m erc N . . Hil s f m er e pl --com ple
eq nty, he ur l ha nk
i a, A - l' or
m oyer
id
wih t Cour' Aprl20,201 dic r i tuc i
t he
ts
i
8 s ove y nsr tons. Se Doc./42. Not bl f l wi t
e
/
a y, olo ng he
lm ie di c r r r ng t a l ged f ge y, ai if ne r s htl a t a end t rFis
i t d s ove y ega di he le
or r Pl ntf s ve oug e ve o m
hei r t
Am e d Com pl n o ot w i e notted t Cour of any a tona f ct s
nde
ai t r her s
ii he
t
ddii l a s uppor i t r
tng hei
f ge y a l ga i .
or r le tons

Se rtl Pli if ase tt tW els Fago vi ae Se ton 1 ( oft Tr h i
paaey, antfs s r ha
l r oltd ci 641g) he ut n
Le ngAc ( U. C.jj 1 e s q.byfii t noiyPl ntfswhent Not a Dee of
ndi t 15 S.
601, t e ) alng o tf ai if
he e nd d

Tr s we ea sg e . 1 .a ! 35 46 i ly Plitfsas a s r ap o so ye tp lcam
u t r sin d d t ! - .Fnal , anif lo s e t r mis r so pe li
ba e on a or c
sd
n al onve s ton t t occ r d i Se e be 2011 r ga di t m odii a i of
r a i ha
ur e n pt m r
e r ng he
f c ton

C et nmaei tr 'oft Not a Dee ofTr t 1 a !!62-71.Acc di t Pli if,
û rai tral ems' he e nd d
c
us. d. t
or ng o antfs
Ba ofAmerc N. tt 1 ofAme ia' hador l pr s d Pl ntfst i woul modiy
nk
ia, A. ûBark
rc '
)
aly omie ai if hat t
d
f
t t r oft N o e a De ofTr ti Pl ntfss
he e ms he t nd ed
us f ai if ubmit ce ti docume s 1 Pl i if
ted ran
nt . d. antfs
ale t tt y s
l ge ha he ubm it d t e docum e s by N ove be 9,2011 but Ba of A m e i a ne r
te hos
nt
m r
,
nk
r c ve

ma t modii a i .1
de he
fc tons d.
N ow ,t r
h ough t M otons Def nda s m ove t di m i s Pl i if c a m s unde Fe r l
he
i , e nt
o s s a ntf s' l i
r de a

Rul ofCi lPr edur 1 b)6)a 1 c .$ Rul 1 c motonma dipos ofaca ewhe
es
vi oc e 2( ( nd 2() 1
A e 2() i
y s e
s
n

te ea en d s u e mae ila t a dt c u'c nrn e a u g n o t eme isb s do t e
h r r o ip td tra fcs n he o l a e d r j d me t n h rt a e n h
t
s b tn eo t pe d n sa da yj diilyn tc d fcs' Liio v Hi , 0 F.d5 9 5 3
u sa c f he la i g n n u cal oie a t. nc mn . l 9 2 3 2 , 3
'
l
( hCi. )(ntr lciai omit .I i uncea fom t paris brefngwhehe t eae
5t r2018 i ena tton ted) ts l r r he te ' i i
t r her r
dipu e f c s A c or ngl outofa abunda ofc uton, he Cour wilpr e by a l i
s t d a t . c di y,
n
nce a i t
t l oc ed
na yzng

Plitfs cli unde t 1 b)6)sa r
anif' ams r he 2( ( tndad.
II
.

LegalSt
andard

a. Fe alRul ofCi lPr dur 1 b)6)
der
e
vi oce e 2( (
Tos vveaRul 1 b)6)motont dimis acompli ne onl algefcss fce
ur i
e 2( (
i o s s,
ant ed y le a t ufiint
t s a e a cl i f r lef t t i pl us bl on is f e a ne d not c a n de aied f c ua
o tt
a m or e i ha s a i e
t ac nd e
ont i t l a t l

algai .Litlv. t l p. Dit,8 F. 616, ( hCi. 8)(ii As r.
le tons tel Houson nde Sch. s. 94 3d
622 5t r 201 ctng hc ot
j
v I ,1 S. .1 (
.qbal 29 Ct 937 2009)a BelAt.Cor v Twombl 1 S. .1 (
nd l l p. .
y, 27 Ct 955 2007).EA cai
) ( lm
ha f c alpl usbiiy whe t pl ntf pl a f c ua c e t a l s t co tt dr w t
s a i a i lt
n he ai i f e ds a t l ont nt hat low he ur o a he

r a o bl i er nce t tt def nda i la e f t micondud a l ed. Si nii a l a
e s na e nf t
ha he e nt s ibl or he s
leg
g fc nty,
c m pli tm a pr e e n i r co r i ve y r mot a unlkel s l a t a l d f c s
o a n y oce d ve f e ve y s r e e nd i y, o ong s he lege a t

r s arg t r ifabovet s ultvel l' I (nt na cttonsomit . l s sa
aie iht o ele
he pec ai eve. d i er l iai
'
ted) s misl
Di

unde Rul 1 b)6)ba e on saut oflmiai i pr pe onl wher i i e de fom t
r e 2( ( s d tt e i ttons s o r y
e t s vi nt r he
c m pl i tt tt a ton i bar e a t c pl i f ist r i e s e bas sf t lng. l i w e l
o a n ha he c i s r d nd he om a nt a l o a s om
i or oli
ts l

esa ihe t tt lm iatonspe i r fom t mom e apl i if scai a cr s. Unie
t bls d ha he i t i
rod uns r he
nt antf l m c ue '
' td

St e v fumi Gene aton Co.L. . ,905 F. 8 880 ( h Ci.201 (ntr lcttons
ats .
nant
r i
, L C.
3d 74,
5t r 8) i e na iai
o te .
mitd)
b. For r and Fe r Rul ofCi lPr dur 9(
ge y
de al e
vi oce e b)

Appl ng Te lw,t Fit Cic tha hel t tCadoc e i f ge i i i sgne by
yi
xas a he fh r ui s d ha t
um nt s or d f t s i d

o ewh p r o t t a ta a o h r' B a ev Ba ko w Y r Mel n o CWMBS I c As en o u p rs o c s n t e . yn n . n fNe o k lo f r
'
,n . st
Ba k dCe t c tsSe is20 624 8 6F.d35 , 6 (t Ci. 7 (iig V z u zv De tc e
c e rl ae re 0 - , 6 3 1 3 0 5h r201 ) ctn a q e . us h
h
BankNat Tr Co.N A.441S. . 783,787 ( x.
. . , ,
W 3d
-88 Te App. Houson( s Ditl201 nope.)
t 1t s. 4, t).
H owe r t alega i off ge y m us m e tt hei ene pl adi s a r ofFe r Rul of
ve , he l ton or r
t e he ght d e ng t nda d
de al e

Ci lPr edur 9( . I ( di t ta f gey alegai wasi ufi enl plade whe is
vi oc e b) d. hol ng ha or r l ton
ns fci ty e d n t

o l s p r c me fo a e i tviual c mpaig sg au e ) Rul 9b)çe ur st t
ny u po t a r m n xhbi s l o rn i n tr s. e ( t q ie ha
y
r
g antfjsaewih pa tc aiyt cic tnce c tt i t fa
pli if tt t riulrt he rumsa s onsiutng he r ud.Putsmpl Rul 9(
i y, e b)
r quiest w ho, ha ,w he w her ,a how t be l d out' Shandon Yi ang Che .I du .
e r he
w t
n,
e nd
o ai
.'
g ngu
m n s

J ntSt kCo.Lt v Pote 607F. 1 1 ( hCi.201 (ntr ciai omitd)
oi oc , d . tr,
3d 029, 032 5t r 0) i enal ttons te .
c. St ut ofL i i a i
at e
m t t ons

d amsgs etd u d rj 1 41g g fteTr t i Le d n Aclaes b e tt ao y a
d i a s re l n e 6 ( ) o h uh n n i g t r u j c o ne e r
cl
sa u e of lm ia i w hi h r
tt t
i t tons
c uns f om t e of t 30 days pe i a t r t da e of a
r
he nd
he
rod f e he t
n
as i m e . Benie v.Am .s Whol s e Len r CI . .N o.1 - 4s gn nt'
'
tz
'
e al
de , V A
1 1 953,201 W L 3388650,a
4
t

4

* ( D. x. ul 9 2 4 ( iig 1 U. C. 1 4 (); e alo Wil msv Co nr d Ho
2 S. Te J y , 01 ) etn 5 S. j 6 0 e) s e s li . u tywi e me
a
L a s l c, 0 F. u p. d 1 6 1 6( D. x. 00 ) af 2 9Fe App . 2 (t Ci. 0 8 .
o n , n .5 4 S p 2 7 , 8 S. Te 2 7 ,f d, 6 d. x 5 3 5h r 2 0 )
U nde Texa l w ,t he s a u e oflm ia i f pr i s y e t
r
s a i ttt
t
i t tons or om s or s oppelc a m s i f ye r .
l i s our a s

Hu tnv Gu r in L# I s Co o
no . a da
n . . fAm. 2 F.S p 2 6 6, 3n.6 ( D. x. 0 2 ,f n
, 43 u p. d 8 71 4 S. Te 2 0 ) atd,
71Fe Appx.441( t Ci.2003) Furhemo e lhe lts a c us ofacin f ' o soy
d.
5h r
. t r r , s aet a e
t
to olpr mis x
esoppe c d a r i w he t pr i o br a s hi pr i e ' l
t l oul cc ue s
n he om s r e che s om s .' d
11
1.

A nal s
ysi
a. Pl nt f s' f
ai i f orgery alegati
l
ons f l to m eet t hei ened pl ng
ai
he
ght
eadi

sandar ofFe ralRul ofCi lProc dur 9( .
t
d
de
e
vi
e e b)
A s t onl s
he y uppor f t i alega i t tt A s i e w asnots gne by Ta a Hil
t or he r l ton ha he s gnm nt
i d
nyi l

( bys me wiht knowl oraut iyofHi1,Pli if poi t Cour t e biswih
or o one t he
edge
hort
l) antfs nt he
to xhi t t

d r difrng notrz sgnaur ofTa a Hil' Doc./11 a !34. Addii l
s
numeous fei
aied i t es
nyi l.
'
/ t
tonaly,
Pl i if l outg r a w e st d hew ho, ha , he w he e,a how ' r quie e sofRul
a ntf s ay
ene al ns r o t
t
w t w n, r nd
' e r m nt
e

9( . Doc #29 a l 1. Howe r at c i rng amos i ntc f ger al tons t
b)
.
t 0-1
ve , fer onsdei l t de ial or y legai , he
Fit Cic thed t tt al tonswer i ufi e unde Fe r Rul 9( ' heghtne
fh rui l ha he legai
e ns fcint
r deal e b)s i e d
pl di sa d. Bynane,866 F.d a 360 ( ai ifs( oncus y alegai t tJ on'
ea ng tndar
3 t
Pl ntf s l or l ton ha ohns s
c

sgnaur wa f ge ( a e i l difr ntt n he sgnaur on a un eltd asi
i t e s or d bec us t ooks fe e ha r i t e n z ae sgnmen)
t
f is t m e t t hei e d pl di sanda d' be aus i lcks a f c s r a i t who
a l o e he ght ne ea ng t r ' c e t a
ny a t eltng o

peper td t alege f gey orhow,when,a whe e t ale d f gey wa e c e .
r tae he l d or r
nd r he lge or r s xe utd)
Si ia l he e Pl ntf s f i t pl a any pa tc a f c sr a i t t w ho, ha ,whe wher ,
m l ry, r , ai if a l o e d
ri ul r a t el tng o he
w t
n,
e

a how oft alged f gey. Asar ul (nd ast Fit Cic thel i Bynane ,Pl ntfs
nd
he le
or r
es t a
he fh rui d n
) ai if
l c sa ngt as e t hei c am sbas on f ger a lga i ,i udi t i q e tte,Se ton
a k tndi o s r t r l i
ed or y le tons ncl ng he r uit il c i
1 002,Te Deb Colec i A c ,a Te D e e i Tr Pr tc A c c a m s a t i
2.
xas
t l ton t nd xas c ptve ade ac i es t l i
nd he r

rques f adecartonoflga rght.Doc./ 1a ! 47-61and72-94.
e t or
l ai
e li s
/1 t ! 5

Pli tf sha ha a e tm e -ove 1 mont - t sae pl usbl f gey a l tons
a n if ve d mpl i r 3
hs o tt a i e or r legai
wih s e pa tc a iy. A fe t a ton w a r ove t t s Cour ,Pl i ifha a o
t om
r i ul rt
t r he c i
s em d o hi
t a ntf d n pporuniy
t t

t boltrt ralegai whe t y a e d t rOrgi lCom pl i .Se Doe./11 l f d,
o se hei l tons
n he m nde hei i na
ant e
: . n a
/
t Cour pe m it di c r lm ied t t a l ga i ,but eve t n,Pl ntf s ne s ht
he
t r ted s ove y i t o he le tons
n he
ai if ver oug
l a t am e t rFi s A m e d Com pl i tor ot w i e notfed t Cour ofa a tona
e ve o
nd hei r t
nde
an
her s
ii he
t ny ddii l
f css
a t uppor i t r f r r a l ga i . I i evi ntt tPl i if ha no bas st as e tt i
tng hei o ge y le tons t s de ha a ntf s ve
i o s r he r
f r r cl i s
o ge y a m .
Acc di y, be us Pl ntf s have f ie t alege f ct s
or ngl
ca e ai i f
a ld o l
a s uppori t i f ger
tng he r or y
ale tons s fci nt t sa e cl m s f r i t ta e pl us bl on t r f ce a ha f l d t
l ga i
uf i e o t t ai or elef ha r a i e
hei a nd ve aie o
sa e w ih pa tcul r t t cic s a s s r
t t t ri a iy he r um t nce ur oundi t a l ge f ger t C o t g a s t
ng he le d or y, he ur r nt he
M otons a t Pl ntf s qui t tte, Se ton 1 002, Texa D e Colec i Act a Texa
i
s o ai if ' e il
ci
2.
s bt
l ton
, nd
s
D e e i Tr Pr c i A c c ai sand t rr ques f a dec ar ton ofr ght .
c ptve ade a tces t l m
hei e
t or
l ai
i s

b. Pl ntfs cai asere unde Seci 1641g) of t Tr h i
ai if' l ms s td
r ton
(
he ut n
L endi Actare tm eng
i barred.

Cli a s re u d r S ci n 1 41g ae i efc s b e tt a l - nh sau e o
ams se td n e e to 6 ( ) r n fe t u j c o 3 mo t ttt f
lm ia i ns Be t z,201 W L 3388 0,a * Her ,a or ng t Pl i i f 'ow n exhi t t
i t to . nie
4
65 t 2.
e cc di o a ntf s
bi, he

As i
sgnme oc r d on Ocober 1 201 See Doc./11,Ex.7.The ef e Pli tfsha untl
nt cure
t
5, 2.
/
r or , a n if d i

Nove r1 201 t ase tt i Seci 1 ( cli Howe ,Pli if frtase tdt
mbe 5, 3, o s r her ton 641g) am.
ver antfs is sre he
cli onM a c 29,201 i t rFis Ame d Compl i .Se Doc./ 1.Acc di y, a e
am
rh
8, n hei r t
nde
ant e
/1
or ngl bec us

Pl nif'Se ton 1 ( camsar tme- rd,t Cour g a st M oi a t Pli if'
aitfs ci 641g) li
e i bare he
t r nt he tons s o antfs
Se ton l 41g)cl ms3
ci 6 ( ai .
3 A lhough Pl i if a g t t di c r r e s d t l t lm ia i pe i f r t i
t
a ntf s r ue hat he s ove y ul houl ol he i t tons r od o he r

S cin1 41j camsPlitfsh ven t one teCo rt a yc nr ln a toiyrg rig
eto 6 () li , anif a o p itd h u to n o tol g uh rt e adn
i
t nle' a l biiy t a Seci 1 ( cai Addii l Pli if ha fie t pla
he l s pplca lt o
ton 641g) l m.
tonaly, antfs ve ald o e d
s fc e f c s s
ufi i nt a t uppo tng a f a en c
ri
r udul t once m e t or t t m i t lt lm iatons pe i
al nt he y ha ght ol he i t i
r od

f Pli if'Se to 1 ( cli i t sc e.
or antfs cin 64lg) ams n hi as
6

c. Pl ntf s'prom isory est
ai if
s
oppelcl m s are t m e-barred.
ai
i

Pr mis r e tp e camsa es be tt a fu - e rsau e o l tto su d rTe a
o s o y so p l li r u j c o o ry a ttt f i ain n e x s
mi
lw. Hunt 243 F.Supp.2d a 71 1. (shelt taca eofa ton f pr sor e t l
a
on,
t 3 146 çt aes us
ci or omis y soppe
c dac r i whe t pr s br c hi pr s ' .Her Pl ntfsalget tBa of
oul cue s n he omior ea hes s omie.'
)
e, ai if le ha nk
A m e i a m a an or pr i e t m odiy ce t n m a era t m s oft N ot a D e ofTr ti
rc
de
al om s o
f rai
t i l er
he
e nd ed
us n

Se e r2011i Pli if s te c t ndoc
ptmbe
f antfs ubmitd erai ument.Doc./ 1a !!62
s
/1 t
-71.Pli if aleg
antfs l e
t tt y s it d t e docume sby Nove r9,2011 1 ftue, he c ra nl by t e
ha he ubm te hos
nt
mbe
. d.l r t n e ti y
he nd

o 201 (..mo et ayea ltr,Pli if wer a r t tBa ofAme iaha br c d is
f 2 ie, r han
r ae) antfs e wa e ha nk
rc d ea he t
a l ged pr i e by notm odi yi t t m s Thatga Pl ntf sunt lt e of201 t a s r a
le
om s
f ng he er .
ve ai i f
i he nd
6 o set
pr i s ' e t
om s ol s oppelcl m . H ow e r Pl i i f di notas e ts h c ai s untlM ar h 29,201
y
ai
ve , a ntf s d
s r uc l m
i
c
8,

i t i Fis Am e d Compl i . 1 Acc di y,be a e Pl ntfs pr s or e t l
n her rt
nde
ant d.
or ngl
c us ai if ' omis y soppe
cl i sa e tm e- r ed, he Cour gr nt t M otons a t Pl i if pr i s y es oppelc a m s
a m r i ba r t
t a s he
i
s o a ntf s' om s or t
li .
l
V.

Conc us on
l i

Fort f egoi r s , he M otonsa e her by G RAN TED unde Fe r lRul ofCi l
he or ng ea ons t
i
r
e
r de a
e
vi

Pr e e1 b)6) a Pl ntfs cl msaeDI I
oc dur 2( ( , nd ai if' ai r SM SSED.
I i s ORD ER ED .
ts o

MA2 25 2 1
12
Da e
t

The Hono abl A lr d H .
r
fe
Benne t
t
Unied St t s ititJ
t
a e src udge

7