Bunnett & Co., Inc. et al v. Dores
ORDER GRANTING Plaintiffs' 21 Motion to Compel. ORDER for Dores to respond to Plaintiffs written discovery requests by 01/11/16. Dores is also ORDERED to present himself to be deposed in Austin, Texas, no later than 01/12/16. Plaintiffs are O RDERED to pay the costs of Doress air travel to Austin, Texas for the deposition. Plaintiffs request for fees and costs is DENIED. ORDER for the parties to appear for an Evidentiary Hearing on Doress 2 Motion toDismiss or Transfer Venue and Plaintiffs 22 Motion for Temporary Restraining Order on 1/13/2016 09:00 AM before Judge Andrew Austin. Signed by Judge Andrew W. Austin. (klw)
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
BUNNETT & CO. and ENERGY
FEEDS INTERNATIONAL, LLC
NO. A-15-CV-1104 LY
Before the Court are Plaintiffs’ Bunnett & Company and Energy Feeds International, LLC’s
Motion to Compel Defendant Frank Dores’s Responses to Discovery (Dkt. No. 21), and Defendant
Frank Dores’s Response to Motion to Compel and, Subject to Pending Motion to Dismiss,
Alternatively Motion to Transfer Venue, Motion for Protection (Dkt. No. 24).
This action was originally brought by Plaintiffs in Travis County District Court, but was
removed to this Court on diversity grounds on December 7, 2015. Prior to removal, Plaintiffs sought
and obtained a temporary restraining order against Defendant on November 24, 2015, as well as an
order shortening the time for Dores to respond to written discovery to seven days, and requiring him
to appear for a deposition within ten days. Dkt. No. 1-1 at 146-49. More than a month after that
order was entered, Dores continues to refuse to respond to the discovery requests, and has not made
himself available for deposition. Accordingly, Plaintiffs filed the instant Motion to Compel, arguing
that Dores is in violation of the state court’s order.
In his response, Dores argues that he is not bound by the state court’s order because the state
court lacked personal jurisdiction over him when it issued the order. He further argues that this Court
should not enforce the state court’s order because (1) Plaintiffs’ initial complaint did not comply with
Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 47(c), as it did not contain a statement of the damages Plaintiffs were
seeking in the suit;1 (2) the question of whether this Court has personal jurisdiction over Dores has
Plaintiffs cured this defect with the First Amended Petition they filed on December 3, 2015,
Dkt. No. 1-1 at 167, ¶ 6, and thus this argument has no merit.
not yet been decided; (3) the discovery requests are overbroad; and (4) the discovery is harassing
because it requires that Dores travel from California to Texas to be deposed.
None of these
arguments have merit. The Travis County District Court’s order was valid when it was entered
(indeed, no jurisdictional issue had been raised or was before the court when the discovery order was
entered), and that order remained valid after the case was removed to this Court. 28 U.S.C. § 1450.
The fact that Dores has raised a question regarding the state court’s jurisdiction over him, and
subsequently, raised that same issue in this Court, does not absolve Dores from complying with that
validly entered order before the time the Court has had an opportunity to reach the jurisdictional
issue. Further, Dores wholly fails to explain in what respect the discovery requests are overbroad,
and failed to timely file any objections on that ground, and that argument is therefore meritless.
Finally, any inconvenience caused to Dores by having to give a deposition in Austin can be cured by
shifting the costs of travel.
Accordingly, the Court hereby GRANTS Plaintiffs’ Motion to Compel, and ORDERS
Dores to respond to Plaintiffs’ written discovery requests by Monday, January 11, 2016. Dores is
also ORDERED to present himself to be deposed in Austin, Texas, no later than Tuesday, January
12, 2016. Plaintiffs are ORDERED to pay the costs of Dores’s air travel to Austin, Texas for the
deposition. Plaintiffs’ request for fees and costs is DENIED.
Finally, the parties are ORDERED to appear for an evidentiary hearing on Dores’s Motion to
Dismiss or Transfer Venue (Dkt. No. 2); and Plaintiffs’ Motion for Temporary Restraining Order
(Dkt. No. 22) at 9:00 a.m. to 12:00 noon, on Wednesday, January 13, 2016, in Courtroom No. 3,
United States Courthouse, 501 West 5th Street, Austin, Texas.
SIGNED this 5 day of January, 2016.
ANDREW W. AUSTIN
UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE JUDGE
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?