SCO Grp v. Novell Inc

Filing 381

Proposed Exhibit List and Witness List (Rule 26 Pretrial Disclosures) SECOND AMENDED by Plaintiff SCO Group.. (Normand, Edward)

SCO Grp v. Novell Inc

Doc. 381

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 1 of 23

Brent O. Hatch (5715) Mark F. James (5295) HATCH, JAMES & DODGE, PC 10 West Broadway, Suite 400 Salt Lake City, Utah 84101 Telephone: [phone] Facsimile: [phone] David Boies (admitted pro hac vice) Robert Silver (admitted pro hac vice) Edward Normand (admitted pro hac vice) BOIES, SCHILLER & FLEXNER LLP 333 Main Street Armonk, New York 10504 Telephone: [phone] Facsimile: [phone] Devan V. Padmanabhan (admitted pro hac vice) DORSEY & WHITNEY LLP 50 South Sixth Street, Suite 1500 Minneapolis, Minnesota 55402 Telephone: [phone] Facsimile: [phone]

Stephen N. Zack (admitted pro hac vice) BOIES, SCHILLER & FLEXNER LLP Bank of America Tower ­ Suite 2800 100 Southeast Second Street Miami, Florida 33131 Telephone: [phone] Facsimile: [phone] Stuart Singer (admitted pro hac vice) BOIES, SCHILLER & FLEXNER LLP 401 East Las Olas Blvd. Suite 1200 Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301 Telephone: [phone] Facsimile: [phone]

Attorneys for Plaintiff, The SCO Group, Inc. _______________________________________________________________________________ IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF UTAH

THE SCO GROUP, INC., a Delaware corporation, Plaintiff/Counterclaim-Defendant, vs. NOVELL, INC., a Delaware corporation, Defendant/Counterclaim-Plaintiff.

SCO'S SECOND AMENDED RULE 26(a)(3) PRETRIAL DISCLOSURES Civil No.: 2:04CV00139 Judge Dale A. Kimball Magistrate Brooke C. Wells

Dockets.Justia.com

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 2 of 23

In accordance with the Court's August 10, 2007 Memorandum Decision and Order and pursuant to Rule 26(a)(3) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Plaintiff, The SCO Group, Inc. ("SCO"), respectfully submits to the Court and provides to Defendant, Novell, Inc. ("Novell"), SCO's Second Amended Pretrial Disclosures, consisting of the following information regarding the evidence that SCO may present at trial other than solely for impeachment purposes.1 1. Rule 26(a)(3)(A)-(B) ­ WITNESSES

The following chart contains the name and, if not previously provided or known to Novell, the address and telephone number of each witness whom SCO expects to present at trial or may call at trial. The chart also includes a designation of witnesses whose testimony SCO expects to present by means of a deposition. Person Expect/May Call May Presented Live or By Deposition Live Contact Information

Acheson, Jean

Contact through Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP The SCO Group, Inc. 355 South 520 West Suite 100 Lindon, UT 84042-1911 Phone: [phone] Contact through Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP The SCO Group, Inc. 430 Mountain Avenue

Broderick, William

Expect

Live

In a letter dated June 28, 2007, counsel for SCO informed counsel for Novell that it has waived the attorney-client privilege with respect to many documents listed as entries on Novell's privilege logs, including documents that Novell produced in redacted form and documents that Novell has withheld entirely. With respect to most of these documents, the parties appear to be in disagreement as to whether there has been any waiver and, if so, the extent of its scope and the potential relevance of the referenced documents, but the parties are continuing to meet and confer on the issue. SCO reserves the right to supplement the information provided in its Pretrial Disclosures with any additional documents that Novell has improperly redacted or withheld based on its privilege objection, as well as with the names and contact information of any other witnesses identified through any such documents.

1

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 3 of 23

Person

Expect/May Call

Presented Live or By Deposition

Contact Information

Third Floor Murray Hill, NJ 07974-0004 Phone: [phone] Cargill, Tom May Live Contact through Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP 7892 Edelweiss Court Boulder, CO 80303 Phone: [phone] Chatlos, Ed May Live Contact through Goodwin Procter LLP Albert J. Solecki, Esq. Phone: [phone] Forest View Drive Chester, NJ 07930 Phone: [phone] Dulin, Terry Expect Live Contact through Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP 18 Lindale Road Ringoes, NJ 08551 Phone: [phone] Frankenberg, Robert May Live Contact through Fillmore & Spencer LLC William L. Fillmore, Esq. Phone: [phone] E. Sunburst Lane Alpine, UT 84114 Gasparro, Larry May Live Contact through Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP 9776 Erin Woods Drive Dublin, OH 43017 Phone: [phone]

3

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 4 of 23

Person

Expect/May Call May

Gupta, Sandy

Presented Live or By Deposition Live

Contact Information

Contact through Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP The SCO Group, Inc. 355 South 520 West Suite 100 Lindon, UT 84042-1911 Phone: [phone]

Hunsaker, Jeff

May

Live

Contact through Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP The SCO Group, Inc. 355 South 520 West Suite 100 Lindon, UT 84042-1911 Phone: [phone] Contact through Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP 333 North Jefferson Street, Apt. 203 Chicago, IL 60661 Phone: [phone]

Langer, Philip

May

Live

LaSala, Joseph

May

Live (in 30(b)(6) Capacity) Live

Known to Novell

Maciaszek, John

Expect

Contact through Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP The SCO Group, Inc. 430 Mountain Avenue Third Floor Murray Hill, NJ 07974-0004 Phone: [phone]

Madsen, Kim

Expect

Live

Contact through Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP 344 Laurent Street Santa Cruz, CA 95060 Phone: [phone]

4

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 5 of 23

Person

Expect/May Call Expect

McBride, Darl

Presented Live or By Deposition Live

Contact Information

Contact through Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP The SCO Group, Inc. 355 South 520 West Suite 100 Lindon, UT 84042-1911 Phone: [phone]

Olson, Michael

May

Live

Contact through Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP The SCO Group, Inc. 355 South 520 West Suite 100 Lindon, UT 84042-1911 Phone: [phone]

Petersen, Jay Pettit, Greg

Expect May

Live Live

Contact through Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP Contact through Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP 10 Clover Terrace Natick, MA 01760 Phone: [phone]

Sontag, Chris

Expect

Live

Contact through Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP The SCO Group, Inc. 355 South 520 West Suite 100 Lindon, UT 84042-1911 Phone: [phone]

Thompson, Duff

May

Live

Contact through Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP The SCO Group, Inc. 355 South 520 West Suite 100 Lindon, UT 84042-1911 Phone: [phone]

5

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 6 of 23

Person

Expect/May Call May

Wilt, Jim

Presented Live or By Deposition Live

Contact Information

Contact through Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP P.O. Box 681908 Franklin, TN 37068 Phone: [phone]

Young, Bert

May

Live

Contact through Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP The SCO Group, Inc. 355 South 520 West Suite 100 Lindon, UT 84042-1911 Phone: [phone]

2.

Rule 26(a)(3)(C) ­ EXHIBITS

The following chart identifies the exhibits that SCO expects to offer at trial or may offer at trial, identifying for each document its respective designation.
EXPECT TO OFFER/ MAY OFFER May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

BEGINNING BATES 1710031647 1710123085 SCON0019909 SCON0019930 SCON0019940 SCON0019942 SCON0025785 SCO0984268 SCO1142022 SCO1142031

ENDING BATES 1710031655 1710123090 SCON0019928 SCON0019938 SCON0019940 SCON0019952 SCON0025793 SCO0984272 SCO1142030 SCO1142034

Deposition Exhibit No.

SJ EXHIBIT NO. 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 57 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 5 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 6 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 7 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 8 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 18 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 19 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 20

DOCUMENT DATE 2/1/1985 2/1/1985 2/1/1985 2/1/1985 2/1/1985 2/1/1985 1/28/1986 2/13/1986 8/20/1986 5/28/1987

Deposition Exhibit No.126

6

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 7 of 23

BEGINNING BATES SCO1234295 SCO1033461 SCO1151750 SCO1152813 SCON0036444 SCO0988502 SCO0988493

ENDING BATES SCO1234314 SCO1033465 SCO1151754 SCO1152845 SCON0036455 SCO0988515 SCO0988497

Deposition Exhibit No.

SJ EXHIBIT NO. 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 10 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 21 3/16/2007 James Decl. Ex. 9 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 11 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 22 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 54 4/9/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 23 4/9/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 25 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 24 4/9/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 24 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 83

DOCUMENT DATE 2/15/1988 8/31/1988 11/29/1988 12/6/1988 11/1/1989 11/9/1989 1/4/1990 3/25/1992 5/15/1992

EXPECT TO OFFER/ MAY OFFER May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

SCON0037073 Recall 0001164 NOV 000011858

SCON0037231 Recall 0001165 NOV 000011880 Deposition Exhibit No. 43

5/15/1992 2/12/1993 11/19/1993 3/17/1994 10/28/1994

May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer Expect to offer May offer

SCO1627105 SCO1288978

SCO1627134 SCO1288980

1/16/2007 Sneddon Decl. Ex. 2 3/16/2007 James Decl. Ex. 10 1/31/2007 SCO Reply Ex. 8 Deposition Exhibit No. 73 Deposition Exhibit No. 74

3/3/1995 6/8/1995

SCO1499353 NOV 000016011 NOV 000008813 NOV 000003531 SCO1604953 NOV 000040965 NOV 000041254 JPHQ 00407 NOV 000001272 NOV 000003940 NOV 000003949

SCO1499386 NOV 000016017 NOV 000008813 NOV 000003531 SCO1604953 NOV 000040965 NOV 000041254 JPHQ 00532 NOV 000001273 NOV 000003948 NOV 000003956

7/13/1995 8/1/1995 8/9/1995 8/27/1995 9/1/1995 9/2/1995 9/11/1995 9/19/1995 9/19/1995 9/19/1995 9/19/1995

Expect to offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

7

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 8 of 23

BEGINNING BATES

ENDING BATES

Deposition Exhibit No.

SCO1185893

SCO1185990

Recall 0005688 SCO1228501

Recall 0005688 SCO1228506

Deposition Exhibit No. 1 Deposition Exhibit No. 11 Deposition Exhibit No. 1030 Deposition Exhibit No. 1028

SJ EXHIBIT NO. 4/9/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 1 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 1 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 3 4/20/2007 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 2 9/29/2006 Jacobs Decl. Ex. 1 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 1 4/19/2007 Braham Decl. Ex. 2 5/29/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 29

DOCUMENT DATE

EXPECT TO OFFER/ MAY OFFER

9/19/1995

May offer

9/20/1995 9/20/1995

May offer May offer

NOV 000008778 Recall 0005722 NOV 000040745 NOV 000041350 SCO1643179 NOV 000000100 SCO1605019 SCO1642206

NOV 000008780 Recall 0005733 NOV 000040762 NOV 000041369 SCO1643189 NOV 000000100 SCO1605022 SCO1642225 Deposition Exhibit No. 1061 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 84

9/20/1995 10/2/1995 10/3/1995 10/4/1995 10/4/1995 10/9/1995 10/10/1995 10/16/1995 10/16/1995

May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

5/29/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 2 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 12 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 93 12/12/2006 Hatch Decl. Ex. 1 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 43

SCO1579298 SCO1604957

SCO1579298 SCO1604979

10/18/1995 10/19/1995

May offer May offer

SCO1642723 SCO1642722 NOV 000002805 NOV 000002260 NOV 000002695 NOV 000015338

SCO1642725 SCO1642722 NOV 000002817 NOV 000002272 NOV 000002700 NOV 000015342

10/28/1995 11/3/1995 11/4/1995 11/15/1995 11/16/1995 11/16/1995 11/16/1995

May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

8

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 9 of 23

BEGINNING BATES SCO1230548 NOV 000002538 SCO1299904 SCO1299904

ENDING BATES SCO1230568 NOV 000002545 SCO1299904 SCO1299934

Deposition Exhibit No.

SJ EXHIBIT NO. 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 70 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 91 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 13

DOCUMENT DATE 11/16/1995 12/4/1995 12/4/1995 12/4/1995

EXPECT TO OFFER/ MAY OFFER May offer May offer May offer May offer

NOV 000000376 NOV 000000453 NOV 000000455 NOV 000000997 NOV 000001932 NOV 000002075

NOV 000000413 NOV 000000454 NOV 000000457 NOV 000001003 NOV 000001934 NOV 000002084

Deposition Exhibit No. 1073

5/29/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 1 4/20/2007 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 24

12/6/1995 12/6/1995 12/6/1995 12/6/1995 12/6/1995 12/6/1995

May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

NOV 000042308 NOV 000042319

NOV 000042308 NOV 000042319

Deposition Exhibit No. 70

4/20/2007 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 27 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 3 4/9/2007 Norman Decl. Ex. 3 4/9/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 2 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 2 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 49 9/29/2006 Jacobs Decl. Ex. 2 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 3 4/20/2007 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 26 4/9/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 4 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 4 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 7 4/20/2007 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 5 1/16/2007 Sneddon Decl. Ex. 11 5/14/2007 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 44

12/6/1995 12/6/1995

May offer May offer

SCO1186000

SCO1186017

Deposition Exhibit No. 1026 Deposition Exhibit No. 34

12/6/1995

May offer

SCO1186018

SCO1186022

Deposition Exhibit No. 1008 Deposition Exhibit No. 1096

12/6/1995

May offer

12/6/1995

May offer

9

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 10 of 23

BEGINNING BATES NOV 000002828 NOV 000000451 JPHQ 00394 NOV 000000240 SCO1166932 SCO1167886

ENDING BATES NOV 000002834 NOV 000000452 JPHQ 00406 NOV 000000241 SCO1166932 SCO1167886

Deposition Exhibit No.

SJ EXHIBIT NO.

DOCUMENT DATE 12/7/1995 12/11/1995 12/13/1995 1/22/1996 1/26/1996 1/26/1996

EXPECT TO OFFER/ MAY OFFER May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 119

Deposition Exhibit No. 1029 EY 000621 EY 000622 Deposition Exhibit No. 1057

12/12/2006 Hatch Decl. Ex. 3 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 45

1/27/1996 1/31/1996

May offer May offer

NOV 000008756 SCO1040150 SCO1299938 SCO1627071 SCON0122780

NOV 000008758 SCO1040150 SCO1299982 SCO1627099 SCON0122782

1/31/1996 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 15 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 11 1/16/2007 Sneddon Decl. Ex. 3 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 16 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 110 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 21 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 95 2/13/1996 2/15/1996 3/3/1996 3/22/1996

May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

SCON0087822 NOV 000007409

SCON0087827 NOV 000007427 Deposition Exhibit No. 1062 Deposition Exhibit No. 1000 Deposition Exhibit No. 1063

3/25/1996 3/27/1996

May offer May offer

SCO1234265

SCO1234265

3/28/1996

May offer

NOV 000038594 NOV 000038163

NOV 000038596 NOV 000038164

4/4/1996 4/7/1996 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 96 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 14 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 111 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 98 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 24

May offer May offer

SCO1290675

SCO1290676

4/10/1996

May offer

SCO1175928

SCO1175931 Deposition Exhibit No. 1064

4/11/1996

May offer

SCO1298084

SCO1298085

4/19/1996

May offer

10

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 11 of 23

BEGINNING BATES

ENDING BATES

Deposition Exhibit No.

SCO1298086

SCO1298087 Deposition Exhibit No. 1046 Deposition Exhibit No. 355 Deposition Exhibit No. 1047

SCO1298082 NOV 000036839

SCO1298083 NOV 000036842

SJ EXHIBIT NO. 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 23 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 97 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 25 5/18/2007 James Dec. Ex. 99

DOCUMENT DATE

EXPECT TO OFFER/ MAY OFFER

4/19/1996

May offer

4/23/1996 4/26/1996

May offer May offer

SCO1788879

SCO1788879

1/16/2007 Sneddon Decl. Ex. 5 12/12/2006 Hatch Decl. Ex. 4 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 46

4/26/1996

May offer

4/27/1996

May offer

NOV 000008791 SCO1647466

NOV 000008792 SCO1647466

Deposition Exhibit No. 1047 Deposition Exhibit No. 1072

4/29/1996 4/30/1996

May offer May offer

NOV 000040587 SCO1647459 NOV 000038601 SCO1647427 1710015630 NOV 000038347 NOV 000001799 NOV 000038608 SCON0036494 NOV 000038350 NOV 000046930 NOV 000046912 NOV 000046926 NOV 000046942 NOV 000046956

NOV 000040588 SCO1647462 NOV 000038601 SCO1647427 1710015632 NOV 000038349 NOV 000001801 NOV 000038609 SCON0036505 NOV 000038352 NOV 000046931 NOV 000046913 NOV 000046927 NOV 000046943 NOV 000046956

5/1/1996 5/1/1996 5/7/1996 5/8/1996 5/20/1996 5/20/1996 5/31/1996 6/12/1996 6/13/1996 6/14/1996 6/18/1996 6/26/1996 6/27/1996 6/27/1996 6/27/1996 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 27 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 101

May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

SCO1501628 NOV 000046898 NOV 000046904 NOV 000046920

SCO1501631 NOV 000046900 NOV 000046905 NOV 000046921

6/27/1996 7/9/1996 7/15/1996 7/15/1996

May offer May offer May offer May offer

11

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 12 of 23

BEGINNING BATES NOV 000046936 NOV 000046928 NOV 000038353

ENDING BATES NOV 000046937 NOV 000046929 NOV 000038354

Deposition Exhibit No.

SJ EXHIBIT NO.

DOCUMENT DATE 7/15/1996 7/23/1996 7/24/1996

EXPECT TO OFFER/ MAY OFFER May offer May offer May offer

1710015659 SCO1788878 Recall 0002629

17010015660 SCO1788878 Recall 0002637 Deposition Exhibit No. 262

12/12/2006 Hatch Decl. Ex. 5 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 47 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 28 1/16/2007 Sneddon Decl. Ex. 6 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 103 5/29/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 34

7/27/1996 8/28/1996 8/29/1996 9/19/1996 9/30/1996 10/8/1996

May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

NOV 000000730

NOV 000000732 Deposition Exhibit No. 1002 Deposition Exhibit No. 115 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 29 1/31/2007 SCO Reply Ex. 4 4/9/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 5 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 5 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 8 9/29/2006 Jacobs Decl. Ex. 3 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 4 4/20/2007 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 28 1/31/2007 SCO Reply Ex. 7 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 30 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 44 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 30

SCO1234107

SCO1234116

10/16/1996

May offer

SCO1451873

SCO1451875

Deposition Exhibit No. 1009

10/16/1996

May offer

SCO1579207 EY 000624 NOV 000007442

SCO1579211 EY 000630 NOV 000007462

Deposition Exhibit No. 1001 Deposition Exhibit No. 357

10/16/1996 10/26/1996 10/26/1996

May offer May offer May offer

12/12/2006 Hatch Decl. Ex. 2 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 44

10/26/1996

May offer

12

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 13 of 23

BEGINNING BATES

ENDING BATES

Deposition Exhibit No. Deposition Exhibit No. 1093

SJ EXHIBIT NO.

DOCUMENT DATE

EXPECT TO OFFER/ MAY OFFER

Recall 0007097 SCO1041481 Recall 0001816

Recall 0007111 SCO1041494 Recall 0001834 Deposition Exhibit No. 1058 3/16/2007 James Decl. Ex. 11 1/31/2007 SCO Reply Ex. 9 12/12/2006 Hatch Decl. Ex. 38 4/9/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 30 5/29/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 7

11/25/1996 12/31/1996 1/7/1997 1/31/1997

May offer May offer May offer May offer

NOV 000038150

NOV 000038151

3/8/1997

May offer

SCO0977740 SCO0977791 SCO1501699 SCO0977802 SCO1041736

SCO0977771 SCO0977791 SCO1501699 SCO0977802 SCO1041746 Deposition Exhibit No. 1059

3/14/1997 5/6/1997 5/6/1997 5/12/1997 5/20/1997

Expect to offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

4/9/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 31

NOV 000005831 SCO0977892 SCO1641437 SCO1042254 SCO1185461

NOV 000005831 SCO0977892 SCO1641437 SCO1042259 SCO1185473

6/2/1997 12/12/2006 Hatch Decl. Ex. 43 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 39 4/9/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 32 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 116 6/30/1997 7/7/1997 11/4/1997 11/24/1997 11/24/1997 11/25/1997

May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

Recall 0002391

Recall 0002393 5/29/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 10 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 118 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 117

11/25/1997 12/1/1997 12/10/1997

May offer May offer May offer

SCO1185456

SCO1185458 Deposition Exhibit No. 261 Deposition Exhibit No. 353 Deposition Exhibit No. 353

NOV 000004907 NOV 000038120

NOV 000004907 NOV 000038121

3/6/1998 3/6/1998

May offer May offer

13

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 14 of 23

BEGINNING BATES SCO1578984 Recall 0000132 NOV 000003777 SCON0098857 AA 00775 AA 00777

ENDING BATES SCO1578988 Recall 0000185 NOV 000003778 SCON0098869 AA 00776 AA 00779

Deposition Exhibit No.

SJ EXHIBIT NO. 12/12/2006 Hatch Decl. Ex. 9

DOCUMENT DATE 5/29/1998 10/23/1998 9/18/1999 12/21/1999 1/20/2000 1/21/2000

EXPECT TO OFFER/ MAY OFFER Expect to offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

SCO1268486 AA 00784

SCO1268488 AA 00787

1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 38 12/12/2006 Hatch Decl. Ex. 8 12/12/2006 Hatch Decl. Ex. 44 5/29/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 15 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 104 9/26/2006 Jacobs Decl. Ex. 6

1/28/2000 3/10/2000 6/8/2000

May offer May offer May offer

SCO1269019 SCO1634414

SCO1269126 SCO1634418

Deposition Exhibit No. 1067

8/1/2000 9/13/2000 10/31/2000 12/12/2000 1/31/2001 2/9/2001

May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

SCO1634444 SCOTR003531 SCO1578447

SCO1634447 SCOTR003569 SCO1578456 Deposition Exhibit No. 1071

SCOTR003942

SCOTR003981 Deposition Exhibit No. 1068 5/29/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 16 5/18/2007 James Decl. 105 4/20/2007 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 13

4/27/2001 4/30/2001

May offer May offer

SCO1578583 SCOTR004387 SCON0020898 SCOTR003570 SCOTR003982 SCOTR004421 SCO1277300 SCOTR003604 SCO1760640 SCOR10729 SCO1287208

SCO1578608 SCOTR004420 SCON0020949 SCOTR003603 SCOTR004017 SCOTR004425 SCO1277302 SCOTR003637 SCO1760640 SCOR10729 SCO1287221

5/7/2001 7/31/2001 9/30/2001 1/31/2002 4/30/2002 7/31/2002 1/22/2003 1/31/2003 2/10/2003 2/20/2003

May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer Expect to offer

Deposition Exhibit No. 218

Deposition Exhibit No. 86

9/29/2006 Jacobs Decl. Ex. 9

2/25/2003

14

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 15 of 23

BEGINNING BATES

ENDING BATES

SCO1788880 SCON0000106 CAN000514 SCO1605380 SCOTR004018

SCO1788884 SCON0000108 CAN000514 SCO1605393 SCOTR004060

Deposition Exhibit No. Deposition Exhibit No. 363 Deposition Exhibit No. 1011

SJ EXHIBIT NO.

DOCUMENT DATE

EXPECT TO OFFER/ MAY OFFER

2/27/2003 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 25 3/6/2003 3/13/2003 4/29/2003 4/30/2003

May offer May offer May offer Expect to offer May offer

NOV 000043051

NOV 000043052

Deposition Exhibit No. 1021 Deposition Exhibit No. 1012 Deposition Exhibit No. 1080 Deposition Exhibit No. 1013 4/9/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 36 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 36

5/12/2003

May offer

NOV 000043053

NOV 000043055

5/28/2003

May offer

SCO1270695

SCO1270700

5/28/2003

May offer

5/28/2003 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 26 5/29/2003 5/29/2003

May offer May offer May offer

SCON0011987 SCOR0004240

SCON0011990 SCOR0004244 Deposition Exhibit No. 1027

NOV 000043056

NOV 000043057

6/6/2003 4/9/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 38 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 38 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 40 4/9/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 38 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 38 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 40

May offer

NOV 000043058

NOV 000043059

Deposition Exhibit No. 1014

6/6/2003

May offer

NOV 000043059

NOV 000043059

NOV 000043060 SCOTR004833

NOV 000043060 SCOTR004834

Deposition Exhibit No. 1014 Deposition Exhibit No. 1014

6/6/2003

May offer

12/1/2006 Brakebill

6/9/2003 6/11/2003 6/11/2003

May offer May offer May offer

15

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 16 of 23

BEGINNING BATES

ENDING BATES

Deposition Exhibit No. Deposition Exhibit No. 1018 Deposition Exhibit No. 1019

SJ EXHIBIT NO. Decl. Ex. 28 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 30

DOCUMENT DATE

EXPECT TO OFFER/ MAY OFFER

NOV 000043066

NOV 000043067

6/12/2003

May offer

NOV 000043068 SCO1556043

NOV 000043069 SCO1556044

6/12/2003 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 32 6/16/2003

May offer May offer

NOV 000043070

NOV 000043070

NOV 000043072

NOV 000043074

Deposition Exhibit No. 1020 Deposition Exhibit No. 1038 Deposition Exhibit No. 1022 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 43 5/14/2007 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 50 12/12/2006 Hatch Decl. Ex. 45

6/18/2003

May offer

6/24/2003

May offer

NOV 000043075

NOV 000043075

6/26/2003 6/26/2003 6/27/2003 6/30/2003 6/30/2003

May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

SCOR0004304 SCOR0004249 SCOTR004817

SCOR0004331 SCOR0004252 SCOTR004818 Deposition Exhibit No. 1121 Deposition Exhibit No. 1122

DEL 00008

DEL 00013

7/2/2003

May offer

DEL 00026 SCOR0004274 SCOR0004332 SCOR0004362 SCOR0004245 SCOR0004253 SCOR0004423 SCOR0004454 SCOR0004484 SCOTR004827 SCOTR004829

DEL 00027 SCOR0004303 SCOR0004361 SCOR0004391 SCOR0004248 SCOR0004256 SCOR0004453 SCOR0004483 SCOR0004512 SCOTR004828 SCOTR004830

7/2/2003 7/2/2003 7/2/2003 7/2/2003 7/3/2003 7/3/2003 7/3/2003 7/3/2003 7/3/2003 7/3/2003 7/3/2003

May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

DEL 00037 SCOR0004261 SCOR0004265 SCOTR004821

DEL 00037 SCOR0004264 SCOR0004273 SCOTR004822

Deposition Exhibit No. 1123

7/5/2003 7/7/2003 7/7/2003 7/7/2003

May offer May offer May offer May offer

16

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 17 of 23

BEGINNING BATES SCOTR004823 SCOTR004825

ENDING BATES SCOTR004824 SCOTR004826

Deposition Exhibit No.

SJ EXHIBIT NO.

DOCUMENT DATE 7/7/2003 7/7/2003

EXPECT TO OFFER/ MAY OFFER May offer May offer

NOV 000043076 SCOR0004392 SCOTR004819

NOV 000043076 SCOR0004422 SCOTR004820

Deposition Exhibit No. 1039

7/8/2003 7/8/2003 7/9/2003

May offer May offer May offer

INTEL00001 SCOTR004831

INTEL00003 SCOTR004832

Deposition Exhibit No. 1015 Deposition Exhibit No. 12

7/16/2003 7/16/2003 7/21/2003 7/31/2003 7/31/2003

May offer May offer May offer Expect to offer May offer

SCO1300026 SCOTR004463

SCO1300046 SCOTR004534 Deposition Exhibit No. 1023 Deposition Exhibit No. 13 Deposition Exhibit No. 234 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 44 5/14/2007 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 52

NOV 000043080

NOV 000043080

8/4/2003

May offer

SCO1328534 SCO1287184 SCO1463814 NOV 000043165 NOV 000039601 NOV 000039605

SCO1328535 SCO1287186 SCO1463818 NOV 000043165 NOV 000039602 NOV 000039606 Deposition Exhibit No. 270

4/20/2007 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 54 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 38 4/20/2007 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 56

8/5/2003 8/14/2003 8/20/2003 8/28/2003 9/10/2003 9/22/2003 9/22/2003

May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

NOV 000043089

NOV 000043090

SCON0024157 SCON0024164

SCON0024159 SCON0024165

Deposition Exhibit No. 1034 Deposition Exhibit No. 1032

10/7/2003 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 33 4/20/2007 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 19 4/20/2007 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 20 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 34 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 56

May offer

10/7/2003 10/7/2003

May offer May offer

NOV 000043173 SCO1555782

NOV 000043174 SCO1555783

Deposition Exhibit No. 271

10/9/2003 10/10/2003

May offer May offer

17

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 18 of 23

BEGINNING BATES

ENDING BATES

Deposition Exhibit No.

SJ EXHIBIT NO. 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 36

DOCUMENT DATE 10/13/2003 10/14/2003 10/14/2003 10/14/2003 10/14/2003 10/14/2003 10/14/2003 10/14/2003 10/14/2003 10/14/2003 11/5/2003 12/3/2003 12/10/2003

EXPECT TO OFFER/ MAY OFFER May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

NOV 000039607 NOV 000039609 NOV 000039611 NOV 000039613 NOV 000039615 NOV 000039617 NOV 000039621 NOV 000039623 NOV 000039627

NOV 000039608 NOV 000039610 NOV 000039612 NOV 000039614 NOV 000039616 NOV 000039618 NOV 000039622 NOV 000039624 NOV 000039628 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 41

SCO1268841 NOV 000039619

SCO1268849 NOV 000039620 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 53 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 60

NOV 000043107

NOV 000043107 9/29/2006 Jacobs Decl. Ex. 15 Deposition Exhibit No. 1016 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 45 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 49

12/22/2003 12/23/2003 1/7/2004

May offer May offer May offer

NOV 000030195 NOV 000030412 SCO1448009 SCON0037232 SCOTR003638 SCOTR003707

NOV 000030195 NOV 000030415 SCO1448009 SCON0037234 SCOTR003706 SCOTR003767

1/13/2004 1/13/2004 1/22/2004 1/29/2004 1/31/2004 1/31/2004

May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

NOV 000043114

NOV 000043115

Deposition Exhibit No. 1033

12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 39 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 41

2/6/2004 2/11/2004 3/4/2004

May offer May offer Expect to offer May offer May offer

SCO1268521

SCO1268569 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 54 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 55 Deposition Exhibit No. 1210

3/16/2004 3/16/2004

ISCO 0015435

ISCO 0015436

3/23/2004

May offer

18

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 19 of 23

BEGINNING BATES

ENDING BATES

Deposition Exhibit No.

SJ EXHIBIT NO. 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 58 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 42

DOCUMENT DATE 3/23/2004 3/25/2004 4/30/2004 4/30/2004 6/29/2004 7/16/2004 7/31/2004 7/31/2004 7/31/2004 8/31/2004 10/15/2004 1/31/2005 1/31/2005 4/30/2005 4/30/2005 7/31/2005 1/31/2006 2/16/2006 4/21/2006 4/30/2006 6/6/2006 7/31/2006 8/22/2006 11/6/2006 1/31/2007 2/2/2007 2/8/2007 4/30/2007 00/00/0004 00/00/1995 00/00/1996 00/00/1996 00/00/1996 00/00/1997 00/00/1998 00/00/1999 00/00/2001

EXPECT TO OFFER/ MAY OFFER May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

SCOTR004061 SCOTR004140 SCOTR004835 NOV 000043025 NOV 000046014 SCOTR004535 SCOTR004610 SCO1685280 ISCO 0003333 SCOTR003768 SCOTR003778 SCOTR004213 SCOTR004221 SCOTR004676 SCOTR003846 SCOTR001004 SCOTR004841 SCOTR004285 ROY 00000444 SCOTR004740

SCOTR004139 SCOTR004212 SCOTR004836 NOV 000043049 NOV 000046077 SCOTR004609 SCOTR004675 SCO1685281 ISCO 0003529 SCOTR003777 SCOTR003845 SCOTR004220 SCOTR004284 SCOTR004739 SCOTR003893 SCOTR001016 SCOTR004842 SCOTR004335 ROY 00000446 SCOTR004791 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 46

12/12/2006 Hatch Decl. Ex. 46 SCOTR001017 SCOTR003894 SCOTR001029 SCOTR001039 SCOTR004336 SCOTR003318 NOV 000001452 Recall 0005357 Recall 0007246 SCOTR001028 SCOTR003941 SCOTR001038 SCOTR001051 SCOTR004386 SCOTR003328 NOV 000001491 Recall 0005385 Recall 0007285 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 82 4/9/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 27 4/9/2007 Normand Decl. Ex. 28

PWC 1354 JPHQ 00267 SCOTR002691

PWC 1390 JPHQ 00297 SCOTR002780

19

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 20 of 23

BEGINNING BATES SCOTR002781 SCOTR002793 SCOTR002848 SCOTR002217 SCO1783978 SCOTR002316 SCOTR003152

ENDING BATES SCOTR002792 SCOTR002847 SCOTR002943 SCOTR002315 SCO1783980 SCOTR002418 SCOTR003317

Deposition Exhibit No.

SJ EXHIBIT NO.

DOCUMENT DATE 00/00/2002 00/00/2002 00/00/2002 00/00/2003 00/00/2004 00/00/2004 00/00/2004

EXPECT TO OFFER/ MAY OFFER May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 79

Deposition Exhibit No. 1010 SCOTR002419 SCOTR003329 SCOTR002538 SCOTR003433 SCOTR002944 SCON0000672 SCOTR002537 SCOTR003432 SCOTR002690 SCOTR003530 SCOTR003151 SCON0000715

5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 51

00/00/2004 00/00/2005 00/00/2005 00/00/2006 00/00/2006 00/00/2007 01/00/1989

May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

NOV 000007592 Recall 0006023 NOV 000041521 NOV 000000134 NOV 000003818

NOV 000007595 Recall 0006050 NOV 000041541 NOV 000000154 NOV 000003819

12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 12 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex. 37 1/16/2007 Sneddon Decl. Ex. 27 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 115

01/00/1997 06/00/1996 09/00/1995 N/A N/A

May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

NOV 000010141 NOV 000025342 NOV 000039603 NOV 000039693 NOV 000043736 Recall 0005636 Recall 0005672 SCO1603611

NOV 000010162 NOV 000025391 NOV 000039604 NOV 000039694 NOV 000043737 Recall 0005662 Recall 0005685 SCO1603615

Deposition Exhibit No. 26 Deposition Exhibit No. 358

12/12/2006 Hatch Decl. Ex. 6 1/17/2000 Hatch Decl. Ex. 10 5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 31 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 2 4/20/2007 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 22

N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A

May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

5/18/2007 James Decl. Ex. 85 Deposition

20

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 21 of 23

BEGINNING BATES

ENDING BATES

SCO1626825 SCON0029957 SCOTR004426 SCOTR004792 SCOTR004853 SCOTR004853 SCOTR004854 SCOTR004855 SCOTR004856 SCOTR004857 SCOTR004859 SCOTR004859 SCOTR004859 SCOTR004860 SCOTR004861 SCOTR004863 SCOTR004864

SCO1626826 SCON0029962 SCOTR004462 SCOTR004793 SCOTR004853 SCOTR004853

Deposition Exhibit No. Exhibit No. 1070 Deposition Exhibit No. 1069

SJ EXHIBIT NO.

DOCUMENT DATE

EXPECT TO OFFER/ MAY OFFER

N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A

May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer May offer

SCOTR004854 N/A SCOTR004855 N/A SCOTR004856 N/A SCOTR004857 N/A SCOTR004859 N/A SCOTR004859 N/A SCOTR004859 N/A SCOTR004860 N/A SCOTR004861 N/A SCOTR004863 N/A SCOTR004864 N/A N/A

WSGR01167

WSGR01169

21

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 22 of 23

BEGINNING BATES WSGR02008 WSGR02011 WSGR02077

ENDING BATES WSGR02010 WSGR02016 WSGR02101

Deposition Exhibit No.

SJ EXHIBIT NO.

DOCUMENT DATE N/A N/A N/A

EXPECT TO OFFER/ MAY OFFER May offer May offer May offer

Deposition Exhibit No. 1103 Deposition Exhibit No. 1114 Deposition Exhibit No. 337

N/A

May offer

N/A 1/17/2007 Hatch Decl. Ex 35 12/1/2006 Brakebill Decl. Ex. 40 N/A N/A

May offer Expect to offer May offer

DATED this 22nd day of August, 2007.

HATCH, JAMES & DODGE, P.C. Brent O. Hatch Mark F. James BOIES, SCHILLER & FLEXNER LLP David Boies Robert Silver Stuart H. Singer Stephen N. Zack Edward Normand DORSEY & WHITNEY LLP Devan V. Padmanabhan

Counsel for The SCO Group, Inc. By: ___/s/ Edward Normand________

22

Case 2:04-cv-00139-DAK-BCW

Document 381

Filed 08/22/2007

Page 23 of 23

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE Plaintiff/Counterclaim Defendant, The SCO Group, Inc., hereby certifies that a true and correct copy of the foregoing SCO's Second Amended Rule 26(a)(3) Pretrial Disclosures was served on Defendant, Novell, Inc., on this 22nd day of August, 2007, by email and/or CM-ECF to: Thomas R. Karrenberg John P. Mullen Heather M. Sneddon ANDERSON & KARRENBERG 700 Bank One Tower 50 West Broadway Salt Lake City, UT 84101 Michael A. Jacobs Matthew I. Kreeger MORRISON & FOERSTER 425 Market Street San Francisco, CA 94105-2482 ___/s/ Edward Normand________

23