Utah Coalition of La Raza et al v. Herbert et al

Filing 1

Case has been indexed and assigned to Magistrate Judge Brooke C. Wells. Plaintiffs Centro Civico Mexicano, Alicia Cervantes, Coalition of Utah Progressives, Eliana Larios, Latin American Chamber of Commerce, Milton Ivan Salazar-Gomez, Salt Lake City Brown Berets, Service Employees International Union, Utah Coalition of La Raza, Workers United Rocky Mountain Joint Board is directed to E-File the Complaint and cover sheet (found under Complaints and Other Initiating Documents) and pay the filing fee of $ 350.00 by the end of the business day.NOTE: The court will not have jurisdiction until the opening document is electronically filed and the filing fee paid in the CM/ECF system. Civil Summons may be issued electronically. Prepare the summons using the courts PDF version and email it to [e-mail] for issuance. (tls)

CIVIL COVER SHEET
The JS 44 civil COVel' sheet and the information eontain~d. herein neitheneplllce n(jf &uppl~Dtthe filing and soryice ofpleadings or other pa~ as required by law, except as ~yided
b"'ocal rules ofcoun. This form, approved by the JudIcial Conference of the Umted Stales III September 1974, IS requll'ed for the use of the Clerk ofCourt for the purpose of Inlllatmg
tfe ch'il docket sheet (SEE INSTRUCTIONS ON mE REVERSE OF nm FORM.)

DEFENDANTS

I. (a) PLAINTIFFS

Governor Gary Herbert

Attorney General Mark Shurtleff

Utah Coalition of La Aaza, at al.
(See attached for full list.)

(b) Coullly of Residence of First Listed Plaintiff .:S:::a:::.lt:.;L:;;:ak~a:...._____

County ofResidCllC<: of First Listed Defendant

.;:S;,;a:;;;I.;.I,;;;L,;;;al<;,;e=-_______

(IN U.S. PLAINTIFF CASIiS ONLY)

(EXCEPT IN U.S. PLAINTIFF CASES)

NOTE: IN LAND CONDEMNATION CASES, USE TIlE LOCATION OF THE
I-AND INVOLVEn.

Attorneys (lfl<.n<l\-rn)

(c) Allorne c" S (Firm 1'1"""" ... ddr~ omd Tcl'iJ'bon. NIJIlIl!eT).
Darcy'M. Godoarc! lUbes No.1 <1426), ACLU of Utah, 355 N. 300
W., Salt Lake City, UT 84103. 801-521-9862. (See attached for full list.)

H. BASIS OF JURISDICTION
a

I

2

(l,l,s. Gowmtru.'11t Not. Party)

CitiZWI ofAnother State

'c

"ii'"

(pl.ce an "X" in One Box OnM

, """"""<,>~,,t.

,,'

o 110 In.sw'flll.ce

PERSONAL INJURY
' j 12() Marine
C! J 10 Airplan.
[J 315 Airplane ProdU4\t
o BO Mill", Act
Liability
C! 140 Negotiable In...rumen.
Cl 150 Recovery of Ovelj>ayment 0 320 Assault, Libel &
Slander
& Ellf=menlOnudgment
C1 151 Medi"",o Act
0 330 F.d....1 Employers'
l.illhility
,:::1 IS: RecIW.ryofD.fmllted
CJ 340MRritll!
Student !.ollns
(Excl V<tetlUl&)
0 345 Marine Product
Liability
;J 1SJ Rectr.ry o{Overpayment
ofVe1erttu's Buuc:fi~
C! 350 MolOr V.hiel.
0 355 MolOr Vcblcle
:J 160 Stockhold"n;' Suils
Product Liability
n 190 O,h", COl''''''
i'J 195 C~liIr"':tProductI.ia!lllilY 0 J60 Other Personnl
lll!urv
.1 196 Franchise
RK~l, PRGPI,R::I'Y . . ,c. {;';;,.
Sr·
O. 441 Votlrts
:J 210 Lund Cond<mnolion
0 442 Employml!llt
n 2~O Foreclosure
CI 2.\0 Ront I..,.". & EJoctmellt 0 443 HousiJ13l
Accommodations
:J 2~O Toot>!" Lond
::::1 .14:' Tort Product Liahility
0 444 Welfare
o 290 All OOter R.ul Properly 0 445 Amer. '" Di.abilitiel; •
Employment
0 446 Am.... wIDisabiliri...
O!her
Q( 440 Oth", Civil Rights

V. ORIGIN
I

Original
I'rocceding

o

CJ J Iu<o'l"'ratod or Principal PI"""
ofBusin... In This Slate

o

C!

Citiwl Of S<>bjoct of.
Foret OJ:un

and On. Bu>;
DEF

o

o 610 Agriculnuo

o 710 Fair !.abor Staodor<h
Act
o 7W L.borlMgmt. Rel.riarur
o 130 Lnbor:Mgml.Reporlillg
&. DisclOtUre Act

Cl 5]0 MotiMslo V.cale
Sentence
Habea. Corpus:

p

3

o

Foreign Notion

o

o

o

C! 620 Other FO<K! &. Dn.g
C! 625 Dn.s Related Setture
Qfl'roperty 21 USC 881
o 630 I.iquor Laws
C! 640 It.R. & Trucl<
CJ 6;0 Airlin<: Rog>.
o 660 Oecupol;"nal
Safet)'/H""lth
0690 Other

422 Appeal 28 USC 158
C! 423 Widulrnwal
28 USC 151

CJ 820 Copyrights
83(1I'.t""l

State Court

6

o 840 Trndemlll'k

o
o
C!
o
o

o 190 Other Labor Litigation
o 791 EJq>1. Ret. InG.

861 HlA O:;95ff)
861 Black Lung (923)

863 DlWClDIWW (405(g)
864 SSID Titl. XVI
865 RS1l405M)

.£1'1'£

Securil)' Act

a

870

'1'"""" (II.S. Plainliff
or Defendant)

o 871 IRS-Third pany
26lJSC 7609

530 Gonenll
535 Doath P""al,y

OS

".;'

S40Mandamus&Otber
SSO Civil. Rights
555 Prison Condition

o 461 Naturalization ApphClloon

o 463 Ha. Corpns •
Alien Detoinee
o 465 Other Immigralion

400 State R..pportiOlllllCllt
Cl 4J 0 Anti"",t
::':I 430 Banks and Banking
C! 4S0 Commerce
0 %!l Deportat:on

0 3 Remanded from

Appellate Court

RacJ<._ Influenced oed

Corrupt Org....izlltioll>
480 Cml$Wller Credit
490 Cable/Sat TV
8) 0 Sel.ctive Servlcc
850 SecuritieslC""uoodiu.,sl
Exchange
0 875 Cus,omerOlallenge
12 USC 3410
0 1!90 Other Slatutory Actio••
C! 1191 Agrlculturul Acts
C1 S92 £!<:cnomic Slabiliutioo Ad
CJ I19l Envlromnetll.1 Matle!1l
0 1!94 Energy Al!OClIlion Act
0 895 Freedom of Information
Act
0 9OOApp"al or F"" Detmrunatiou
Under liquai AQCeSlI
10 Justioo
950 c.m.lilllOOnalil)' or

"

A'k"tioos

o

a

410

o

NS" [J 740 Rail",!!), Labor Act

p
p
p
p

DEF
C! 4

C!

5 TfunsfelT~d from 0 6 Multidistrict
aooth.er d,s!I1ct
Liti"ation
ec
.,
Cite the U.S. Civil Sta!llte under which you are filing (Do not dte jurisdiction..1 stRtutes unle•• diversity):

2 Removed from

4 Rein.tIlted 01' 0
ReopClled

SUtte SI\\tUte<

o

7

Appeal to District
Judge from
M 'Irate
Iu
t

r.::;4~=.=,C='~~~II.IW..~~~~il.J.W.·w.w.i!.ll.l..._ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __

VU. REQUESTED IN
COMPLAINT:
VIII. RELATED CASE(S)
[FANY

DEMANDS

CHECK IF TillS IS A CLASS ACT[ON
UNDER F.R.C.P. 23
(See illStTUOtions):

Jl.1DGE

CHECK YES only if demanded in eomplaint:
IURY DEMAND:
0 Yes
0 No
DOCKET l'o'lJMBER

SIGNATURE OF ATIORNEY OF

DATE

05/0212011

0

PTF
C! 4

."w<q

l'ERSONAL INJURY
D :162 P"",onru lnjury •
Mild. M.lptactice
0 365 Personal [njury •
I'rodu<t Liability
0 368 Asbestoa Penonal
Injury P,oduct
r.iabmty
PERSONAL PROPERTY
C! 310 OIbor Fraud
0 371 Tl11th In Lending
C! 380 Other PemJWlI
Propeny Darnall"
0 385 Property D""",ge
Product Liability

{PlAce an "'x* iJ1 One Box Only)

VI. CAUSE OF ACTION

J

'0' n.'eodont)

Incorporated ant/Principal Place
ofBtlSiness In Another Slllle

(lndicate Citizoosbip ofPorti.. in Uem Ill)

IV. NA TUREOF SUIT

~

Ciliz.n ofThis Slot<

04 Diversity

U.S, Government
Defendant

.

(For Diwr.illy Cos.. Only)
PTF
C! I

It 3 Fed.ral Question

u.s, Govemt1'll!11t
Plaintiff

(1

III. CITIZENSHIP OF PRINCIPAL PARTIES(l'I.ce all uX" in One Box fOll'l.intiff

(pbce an "X" in On. Box Only)

Darcy M. Goddard

FOR OFF(;E USE ONLY

RECfiIPT#_---- AMOUNT _ _ _ _ _ _ __

APPLYING lFP _ _ _ _ __

MAG.JUDCiE

------­

Case: 2:11cv00401
Assigned To : Wells, Brooke C.
Assign. Date : 5/3/2011
Description: Utah Coalition of La
Raza et a1. v. Governor Gary Herbert
et a1.

c

CIVIL COVER SHEET - ADDENDUM
I. (a) PLAINTIFFS

Utah Coalition of La Raza; Service Employees International Union; Workers'
United Rocky Mountain Joint Board; Centro Civico Mexicano; Coalition of Utah
Progressives; Latin American Chamber of Commerce; Salt Lake City Brown Berets;
Jane Doe #1; John Doe #1; Milton Ivan Salazar-Gomez; Eliana Larios; Alicia
Cervantes, John Doe #2
I. (c) Plaintiffs' Attorneys (Firm Name, Address, and Telephone Number)
Linton Joaquin*
Karen C. Tumlin'"
Shiu-Ming Cheer'"
Melissa S. Keaney'"
NATIONAL IMMIGRATION LAW CENTER
3435 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 2850
Los Angeles, California 90010
Telephone: [phone]
Cecillia D. Wang'"
Katherine Desonneau*
AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION FOUNDATION
IMMIGRANTS' RIGHTS PROJECT
39 Drumm Street
San Francisco, California 94111
Telephone: [phone]
Omar C. Jadwat*
Andre Segura'"
Elora Mukherjee'"
AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION FOUNDATION
IMMIGRANTS' RIGHTS PROJECT &
RACIAL JUSTICE PROGRAM
125 Broad Street, 18th Floor
New York, New York 10004
Telephone: [phone]
Darcy M. Goddard (Utah State Bar No. 13426)

Esperanza Granados (Utah State Bar No. 11894)

AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION OF UTAH FOUNDATION, INC.

355 North 300 West

Salt Lake City, Utah 84103

Telephone: [phone]

Bradley S. Phillips*+
MUNGER, TOLLES & OLSON LLP
355 South Grand Avenue
Thirty-Fifth Floor
Los Angeles, CA 90071-1560

Telephone: [phone]

*Application for admission pro hac vice forthcoming
+Attorneyfor all plaintiffs except Service Employees International Union and the Workers'
United Rocky Mountain Joint Board