Rosetta Stone LTD v. Google Inc.
Filing
154
Objection to 143 Rule 26 Disclosure , Exhibit List and Witness List filed by Rosetta Stone LTD. (Allen, Warren)
<![CDATA[
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF VIRGINIA
Alexandria Division
ROSETTA STONE LTD.,
Plaintiff,
Civil Action No. 1:09cv736(GBL/TCB)
-vGOOGLE INC.,
Defendant.
PLAINTIFF ROSETTA STONE’S OBJECTIONS TO GOOGLE’S
RULE 26(a)(3) DISCLOSURES, EXHIBIT LIST AND WITNESS LIST
Plaintiff Rosetta Stone Ltd. (“Rosetta Stone”), by and through counsel, respectfully
submits these objections to Defendant Google Inc.’s Pre-Trial Disclosures.
Objections to
relevance are made pursuant to Federal Rule of Evidence 402. Objections as to prejudice or
confusion are made pursuant to Federal Rule of Evidence 403. Hearsay objections are made
pursuant to Federal Rule of Evidence 802.
Unless otherwise noted, objections regarding
foundation include authentication pursuant to Federal Rule of Evidence 901.
Counter-
designations of deposition testimony relating to testimony that is the subject of a Rosetta Stone
objection are provided in the event that the objection is overruled. Such counter-designations do
not waive the objection to the subject testimony. Rosetta Stone reserves the right to amend its
objections and designations as appropriate.
I.
Rosetta Stone’s Objections to Google’s Deposition Designations and Rosetta Stone’s
Counter-Designations
A.
Christopher Klipple (March 8, 2010)
Rosetta Stone objects to Google's designation of any deposition testimony from
Christopher Klipple on the basis that he is not unavailable within the meaning of Federal
Rule of Evidence 804. Counter-designations are provided in the event that the Court
nevertheless admits all or a portion of his deposition testimony.
Chris Klipple
Page/Line
Objections
All designations
Hearsay
8:11-12
No other objections
23:25-25:11
No other objections
27:24-28:23
No other objections
31:5-7
No other objections
31:9-32:20
No other objections
41:20-42:25
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing
43:4-43:6
Relevance, prejudicial, asked and answered
43:9-44:13
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing
44:15-44:22
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing and incomplete designation
109:17-109:24
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing
110:1-23
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing
111:1-19
Foundation, speculation, relevance, prejudicial, confusing
111:21-112:5
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing
125:2-127:4
Incomplete designation
130:25-133:5
Foundation, speculation, relevance, prejudicial, confusing
133:15-133:24
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing
134:1-137:19
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing, 136:25-137:5 vague and
ambiguous
137:21-138:25
138:13-17 & 138:21-24 asked and answered; vague and
ambiguous
141:11-142:15
141:11-21 foundation, speculation, vague and ambiguous
184:10-185:2
No other objections
2
Chris Klipple
Page/Line
Objections
187:23-188:11
No other objections
202:21-204:8
No other objections
204:10-22
No other objections
205:7-16
No other objections
245:3-248:5
Foundation, speculation, vague and ambiguous, misstates prior
testimony, assumes facts not in evidence
248:8-13, 15-16
Foundation, speculation, vague and ambiguous, misstates prior
testimony, assumes facts not in evidence
250:2-5, 7-8
Foundation, speculation, vague and ambiguous, misstates prior
testimony, assumes facts not in evidence
252:7-254:2
Foundation, speculation
278:15-278:19
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing, asked and answered
278:21-279:1
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing, asked and answered
279:3-20, 22-23
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing, asked and answered
283:24-284:10
Mischaracterizes the exhibit
284:13-285:14
Misstates prior testimony
288:4-289:12
Foundation, speculation
290:13-18
Foundation, speculation
295:1-296:8
Foundation, speculation
299:4-13
Foundation, speculation
301:18-302:16
Foundation, speculation
306:7-308:10
Foundation, speculation
310:7-311:5
Foundation, speculation
Counter-designations: 52:10-24; 69:19-70:12; 127:5-8; 129:3-130:21; 139:1-16; 140:10141:9; 142:16-143:1; 248:18-249:6; 254:3-24;280:16-283:18; 285:15-286:1; 299:14-18
3
B.
April Garvey (March 1, 2010)
Rosetta Stone objects to Google's designation of any deposition testimony from April
Garvey on the basis that she is not unavailable within the meaning of Federal Rule of
Evidence 804. Counter-designations are provided in the event that the Court nevertheless
admits all or a portion of her deposition testimony.
April Garvey
Page/Line
Objections
All designations
Hearsay
9:10-13
No other objections
12:3-8
No other objections
13:9-19
No other objections
16:4-9
No other objections
38:17-39:11
No other objections
39:23-40:22
No other objections
42:15-24
No other objections
43:6-8, 19-21
43:6-8 asked and answered
43:25-46:7
No other objections
46:23-47:12
No other objections
66:6-7
No other objections
66:11-67:12
67:5-12 foundation, speculation
67:14-19
Foundation, speculation
68:20-69:2
No other objections
69:13-70:3
Incomplete designation; foundation
82:13-19
Incomplete designation
83:13-84:2
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing
101:17-19
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing
101:23-102:24
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing
103:15-104:4
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing
104:7-15
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing
118:1-5
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing
119:17-120:23
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing; 120:22-23 improper
designation
4
April Garvey
Page/Line
Objections
121:10-22
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing
119:4-9
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing
172:10-15, 17
Foundation, speculation, vague and ambiguous; improper lay
opinion; relevance, prejudicial, confusing
173:14-22
Foundation, speculation, vague and ambiguous, improper lay
opinion; relevance, prejudicial, confusing
174:3-5, 9-25
Foundation, speculation, peculation; improper lay opinion;
relevance, prejudicial, confusing
263:22-264:1
Incomplete designation; foundation, speculation, vague and
ambiguous
265:3-6
Incomplete designation
267:6-21
No other objections
272:25-273:4
Foundation, speculation
273:16-20
Improper and/or incomplete designation; foundation,
speculation
273:22-274:1
No other objections
277:3-7
Foundation, speculation, vague and ambiguous
284:21-285:4
No other objections
286:24-287:13
287:10-13 foundation, speculation
298:18-25
No other objections
306:7-307:7
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing
307:13-308:10
308:8-10 foundation, speculation
308:12-18
No other objections
363:7-14
No other objections
364:13-21
Foundation, speculation, vague and ambiguous
364:23-365:7
No other objections
Counter-designations: 11:8-21; 41:3-42:1; 43:9-18; 46:8-10; 47:13-48:1; 69:3-11; 82:2022; 84:3-10; 84:22-85:9; 102:25-103:14; 119:10-16; 120:24-121:9; 266:13-267:2;
267:22-25; 273:5-12; 287:14-288:2; 308:20-309:1; 347:1-349:4; 365:11-368:12
5
C.
Julie Longley (March 12, 2010)
Rosetta Stone objects to Google's designation of any deposition testimony from Julie
Longley on the basis that she is not unavailable within the meaning of Federal Rule of
Evidence 804. Counter-designations are provided in the event that the Court nevertheless
admits all or a portion of her deposition testimony.
Julie Longley
Page/Line
Objections
All Designations
Hearsay
6:12
No other objections
9:6-18, 25
No other objections
10:1-5, 19-25
No other objections
11:1-2
No other objections
13:17-21
No other objections
16:11-15, 19-21, 2425
No other objections
17:1-12
No other objections
23:24-24:4
No other objections
25:7-12, 16-18
No other objections
26:3-14
No other objections
37:20-24
No other objections
38:9-25
No other objections
39:1-5
No other objections
40:3-18
No other objections
41:16-25
No other objections
43:6-7, 11-25
No other objections
44:1-23
No other objections
73:21-25
Incomplete designation
80:19-25
No other objections
81:1-8
No other objections
81:10-17
No other objections
82:17-20, 22, 24-25
No other objections
Counter-designations: 17:13-17:23; 40:19-20; 74:1-21
6
D.
Denis Doyle (March 11, 2010)
Rosetta Stone objects to Google's designation of any deposition testimony from Denis
Doyle on the basis that he is not unavailable within the meaning of Federal Rule of
Evidence 804. Counter-designations are provided in the event that the Court nevertheless
admits all or a portion of his deposition testimony.
Denis Doyle
Page/Line
Objections
All designations
Hearsay
5:9-10
No other objections
10:2-12
No other objections
11:1-4, 8-22
No other objections
12:1-11, 15-17
No other objections
13:4-16
No other objections
15:4-21
No other objections
16:6-8
No other objections
17:13-19
No other objections
20:9-22
No other objections
21:1-5
No other objections
23:5-8, 12-22
No other objections
24:6-15
No other objections
25:7-14
No other objections
37:10-20
No other objections
38:22
No other objections
39:1-22
Relevance
40:1-13
Relevance
42:17-22
No other objections
43:1-5
No other objections
46:13-22
No other objections
52:13-22
Relevance
53:1-2
Relevance
56:2-20
No other objections
57:22
No other objections
7
Denis Doyle
Page/Line
Objections
58:1-4, 7-10, 18-22
No other objections
60:2-10
Relevance
Counter-designations: 6:21-23:11, 24:1-30:12, 34:3-36:17, 37:21-38:21, 47:1-8; 53:3-21,
55:2-15, 57:7-13; 61:4-64:12
E.
Diana Stanley Thomas (March 12, 2010)
Diana Stanley Thomas
Page/Line
Objections
5:12-13
No objection
9:17-22
No objection
10:1-6, 17-22
No objection
11:1-3, 9-22
No objection
12:4-7, 9
No objection
13:4-21
No objection
15:2-11
No objection
18:4-9, 19-22
No objection
19:1-20
No objection
20:11-14
No objection
22:3-14
No objection
23:7-12
No objection
24:7-13
No objection
25:5-16
No objection
35:17-22
No objection
36:1-9
No objection
38:3-4, 8-10, 17-22
No objection
39:15-18
No objection
40:21-22
No objection
41:1-4, 8-15, 20-22
No objection
42:1-5
No objection
42:18-20
No objection
8
Diana Stanley Thomas
Page/Line
Objections
45:19-22
No objection
46:1-12
No objection
47:12-18
No objection
48:13-19
Incomplete designation, include 48:20-21
49:1-3
Incomplete designation
53:20-22
No objection
54:1-6, 16-22
No objection
62:9-15
No objection
70:8-20, 22
No objection
71:1-9, 11-22
No objection
72:1-14
No objection
73:9-21
No objection
74:12-22
Asked and answered
75:4, 6
Incomplete designation, asked and answered
84:18-22
No objection
Counter-designations: 36:10-20; 39:20-22; 41:5-7; 42:9-17; 43:5-15; 45:16-18; 46:1347:7; 47:19-48:8; 48:16-21; 49:4-10; 50:2-5; 52:14-53:8; 55:10-56:10; 62:16-63:3;
82:12-85:2
F.
Steve DuBow (March 8, 2010)
Steve DuBow
Page/Line
Objections
5:7-10
No objection
7:2-8:4
No objection
8:20-10:1
No objection
10:15-13:21
No objection
17:11-18:2
No objection
19:10-18
No objection
22:10-22:13
No objection
22:16-25:11
No objection
9
Steve DuBow
Page/Line
Objections
38:18-41:12
No objection
41:15-41:16
No objection
42:16-42:19
No objection
43:1-43:10
No objection
44:3-45:18
No objection
47:9-49:1
No objection
51:2-52:2
Incomplete designation, relevance
52:10-52:13
No objection
52:17-54:20
No objection
55:3-57:14
No objection
60:4 -61:11
No objection
64:21-65:1
Relevance
65:13-66:1
Relevance
66:7-10
Relevance, prejudicial, calls for legal conclusion
66:13-69:14
Relevance, prejudicial, calls for legal conclusion
70:6-70:21
No objection
74:15-77:19
No objection
77:21-81:7
No objection
81:9-84:12
No objection
85:3-86:6
Incomplete designation, include 86:7-9
88:9-12
No objection
88:18-90:17
No objection
94:3-94:7
Incomplete designation, relevance
94:12-21
Relevance
95:10-97:1
Relevance
97:4-98:7
Foundation, relevance
98:9-98:21
98:17-99:1 foundation, calls for a legal conclusion
99:2-99:21
No objection
126:19-127:5
No objection
10
Steve DuBow
Page/Line
Objections
128:6-128:9
Foundation, calls for a legal conclusion
128:12-128:16
Foundation, calls for a legal conclusion
128:18
Foundation, calls for a legal conclusion
Counter-designations: 52:3-9; 84:13-85:2; 121:13-125-126:18
G.
Deborah Jeffries (March 9, 2010)
Deborah Jeffries
Page/Line
Objections
7:11-10:13
No objection
21:3-11
No objection
21:15-17
No objection
35:5-36:11
No objection
36:19-38:7
No objection
40:6-41:2
No objection
46:21-47:19
No objection
48:3-18
No objection
50:11-20
No objection
51:1-52:11
No objection
59:14-62:3
No objection
62:5-65:8
No objection
65:12-68:7
No objection
68:9-70:13
No objection
70:15-71:4
Incomplete designation
72:9-76:4
75:5-76:4 relevance, prejudicial, calls for a legal conclusion
76:6-76:11
Relevance, prejudicial, calls for a legal conclusion
76:13-77:10
Relevance, prejudicial, calls for a legal conclusion
79:22-80:17
No objection
80:19
No objection
Counter-designations: 48:19-22
11
H.
Rita Porter (March 10, 2010)
Rita Porter
Page/Line
Objections
6:9-15:9
No objection
36:18-38:2
No objection
41:14-42:7
Incomplete designation, include 41:12-13 and 42:8
43:5-43:15
43:14-15 redundant
43:22-46:3
44:9-44:22 relevance; incomplete designation
48:12-48:16
Incomplete designation, relevance
49:1-8
Incomplete designation
49:14-52:7
49:14-15 relevance, incomplete designation
53:16-54:5
Incomplete designation
54:17-57:6
Incomplete designation, include 57:7
57:9-59:15
Incomplete designation
59:21-23
Incomplete designation
61:16-62:13
Incomplete designation
62:23-66:3
No objection
68:6-14
Incomplete designation, relevance
74:19-75:7
Incomplete designation, relevance, prejudicial;
75:10-76:15
Incomplete designation, relevance, prejudicial
76:18-77:6
Incomplete designation, relevance, prejudicial
77:8-78:2
Incomplete designation, relevance, prejudicial
78:4-78:25
Incomplete designation, relevance, prejudicial
Counter-designations: 53:2-14; 61:5-61:15
12
I.
Rose Hagan (March 5, 2010)
Rosetta Stone objects to Google's designation of any deposition testimony from Rose
Hagan as she voluntarily appeared as a Rule 30(b)(6) witness on behalf of Google and
therefore is not unavailable for trial testimony.
Rose Hagan
Page/Line
Objections
All designations
Hearsay
8:12-9:5
No other objections
9:8-10
No other objections
10:8-14:21
No other objections
23:4-24:15
No other objections
26:1- 28:24
No other objections
40:2-40:14
No other objections
40:16-41:7
No other objections
41:9-41:23
No other objections
42:12-43:3
No other objections
44:19-45:24
Relevance
51:10-53:23
No other objections
54:2-3
No other objections
54:8-22
No other objections
54:24-55:1
No other objections
55:4-57:20
No other objections
57:24-58:2
No other objections
58:4-17
No other objections
60:7-25
No other objections
62:11-63:16
No other objections
65:6-66:16
No other objections
69:20-70:2
No other objections
70:15-72:23
No other objections
73:2-25
No other objections
77:5-15
No other objections
13
Rose Hagan
Page/Line
Objections
79:10-15
No other objections
80:18-81:17
No other objections
81:22-82:7
No other objections
83:3-5
No other objections
83:7-10
No other objections
84:10-85:25
No other objections
86:21-25
No other objections
87:2-5
No other objections
87:13-88:19
88:10-19 relevance, prejudicial, confusing
88:22-90:4
No other objections
90:6-90:9
No other objections
91:4-6
Incomplete
91:21-92:14
No other objections
92:23-96:18
No other objections
97:11-98:10
No other objections
98:18-103:7
Incomplete; 103:3:7 foundation, speculation
114:14-15:1
No other objections
115:5-6
No other objections
115:8-11
No other objections
115:16-116:3
No other objections
116:13-22
No other objections
117:10-20
No other objections
117:23-24
No other objections
123:13-124:3
Foundation, speculation
124:5-23
Foundation, speculation
125:11-126:15
No other objections
126:17-127:2
No other objections
127:14-128:14
No other objections
128:25-129:10
No other objections
14
Rose Hagan
Page/Line
Objections
130:16-131:5
No other objections
131:8-132:14
No other objections
133:6-22
No other objections
133:24
No other objections
134:2-4
No other objections
147:10-148:15
No other objections
148:21-149:19
No other objections
151:17-152:21
No other objections
154:17-155:1
No other objections
157:2-24
No other objections
158:1-7
No other objections
168:13-18
No other objections
168:20-21
No other objections
169:11-19
169:16-19 relevance, prejudicial, confusing, foundation,
speculation
170:15-20
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing, foundation, speculation
170:22-171:3
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing, foundation, speculation
171:19-172:6
Relevance, prejudicial, confusing, foundation, speculation
Counter-designations: 24:16-25:19; 41:25-42:11; 43:8-12; 44:5-16; 61:1-24; 69:6-16;
74:2-5; 76:7-23; 79:25-80:17; 86:1-20; 90:11-22; 96:19-97:10; 98:11-17; 103:8-21;
110:17-111:7; 118:2-120:1; 124:24-125:9; 128:15-24; 158:21-159:17
J.
Heather Ingram (March 4, 2010)
Heather Ingram
Page/Line
Objections
9:21-13:19
No objection
16:24-24:12
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, relevance,
hearsay
33:2-33:9
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, relevance,
hearsay
15
Heather Ingram
Page/Line
Objections
36:8-36:10
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, relevance,
hearsay
47:21-49:18
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, relevance,
hearsay
53:3-57:21
57:19-21 counsel colloquy
58:2-59:1
No objection
59:3-60:7
No objection
60:12-62:24
No objection
63:3-64:6
64:4-6 superseded question
64:10-65:13
No objection
75:5-77:1
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, relevance,
hearsay
84:14-86:5
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
86:24-87:24
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
88:17-88:18
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
88:23-89:23
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
90:7-90:12
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
90:20-91:18
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
91:20-93:14
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
94:9-94:10
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
94:14-95:10
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
96:22-98:20
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
99:4-100:7
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
101:23-103:16
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
103:18-103:20
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
103:22-107:10
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
108:4-111:14
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay, 110:3111:2 speculation
132:12-132:14
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
question only
132:18-132:24
Colloquy should be deleted
16
Heather Ingram
Page/Line
Objections
133:5-133:16
No objection
138:21-139:1
No objection
139:4-139:12
No objection
140:25-141:15
No objection
142:1-142:23
No objection
143:5-144:23
No objection
146:4-148:20
No objection
151:2-152:20
No objection
166:12-170:22
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, relevance,
hearsay
175:11-175:17
No objection
176:15-176:25
No objection
177:2-180:4
No objection
Counter-designations: 36:4-7; 171:23-174:18
K.
John Ramsey (February 25, 2010)
John Ramsey
Page/Line
Objections
10:9-12:1
No objection
12:3-16:8
15:8-16-8 relevance
16:13-16:21
Relevance
16:23-17:13
Relevance
17:17-22:6
Relevance
40:13-41:25
Relevance
42:7-45:11
Relevance
49:18-50:14
Relevance
53:1-59:7
Relevance
61:7-63:12
Relevance
63:14-63:20
Relevance
64:3-67: 15
Relevance
17
John Ramsey
Page/Line
Objections
110:10-112:2
Relevance
112:8-113:13
Relevance
113:15-115:25
Relevance
124:6-124:7
Relevance
124:9-124:20
Relevance
124:22-125:3
Relevance
147:9-152:7
150:6-151:13 Outside the scope of Rule 30(b) testimony,
relevance, hearsay
157:3-159:18
157:9-157:22 Object to counsel's colloquy
159:21-160:9
159:21-160:2; 160:8-9 relevance, argumentative
160:20 – 163:17
160:20-21 argumentative; 163:15-17 relevance
163:24 – 164:5
No objection
166:10 – 167:1
Incomplete designation (middle of an answer); Outside the
scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, relevance, hearsay
167:3-171:1
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, relevance,
hearsay
172:5 – 172:23
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, relevance,
hearsay
173:2 – 177:12
173:2-174:21 Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony;
hearsay; relevance
178:5 – 178:20
No objection
180:16 – 180:23
No objection
185:22 – 186:24
Relevance
188:15 – 189:7
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
191:23 – 193:8
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
193:10 – 194:13
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
203:12 – 205:23
Relevance
206:1 – 209:8
Relevance
211:18 -211:20
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance, question calls for a legal conclusion
18
John Ramsey
Page/Line
212:3 – 212:5
L.
Objections
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay;
relevance; response to an improper question
Van Leigh (February 22, 2010)
Van Leigh
Page/Line
16:18-16:22
Objections
Incomplete answer 16:23
16:24-18:14
No objection
20:7-21:2
No objection
49:21-52:1
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony; hearsay
75:8-75:19
No objection
75:21-77:12
No objection
106:22-108:5
No objection
115:9-116:16
Incomplete include 115:3-7;
119:4-120:10
No objection
124:25-125:14
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
129:18-131:23
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay, 131:8131:15 counsel colloquy
138:5-19
No objection
143:25-153:1
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
162:12-171:16
No objection
171:22-177:10
172:17-173:12 counsel colloquy;
184:25-185:19
No objection
190:22-193:6
No objection
194:23-195:6
No objection
201:12-202:25
No objection
205:6-206:25
No objection
230:14-230:24
Incomplete 230:25-231:2
231:1-232:9
No objection
247:4-253:8
No objection
19
Van Leigh
Page/Line
253:21-262:1
Objections
No objection
264:25-266:2
No objection
299:7-303:16
300:6-301:8 argumentative; counsel colloquy; harassment;
301:25-302-1 argumentative colloquy; 302:15-16 question
only, argumentative, improper question, harassment
307:17-308:8
No objection
309:6-10
No objection
Counter-designations: 112:13-113:17; 116:17-118:4; 120:11-121:9; 125:15-125:23
M.
Michael Hill (February 26, 2010)
Michael Hill
Page/Line
Objections
7:7-8
No objection
19:11-12
No objection
24:5-8, 12-23
No objection
25:24-26:3
No objection
188:10-195:12
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay;
relevance
214:18-217:7
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay;
relevance
217:21- 219:24
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay;
relevance
220:25-223:2
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony; hearsay
277:12 282:14
281:18-282:2 foundation, calls for speculation; relevance
283:6-297:5
283:6-284:15 foundation, calls for speculation, relevance
297:11-310:19
No objection
312:20-319:3
No objection
319:8-11
Object to counsel colloquy
Counter-designations: 195:13-196:7; 214:3-214:17; 219:25-220:19
20
N.
Simon Berriochoa (March 3, 2010)
Simon Berriochoa
Page/Line
6:10-6:25
No objection
29:2-29:11
No objection
29:13-31:20
No objection
31:21-39:12
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
42:3-14
Relevance
42:17-45:19
Relevance
53:13-57:6
Relevance
63:4-14
63:10-14 outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony,
hearsay, relevance
69:18-81:25
80:2-13 and 81:23-25 outside the scope of Rule 30(b)
testimony, hearsay
89:4-97:25
89:4-96:9 and 97:13-25 outside the scope of Rule 30(b)
testimony, hearsay
113:6-120:25
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
137:18-139:11
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
O.
Objections
Christina Aguiar (March 9, 2010)
Christina Aguiar
Page/Line
Objections
5:16-18
Incomplete designation
14:19-15:19
No objection
16:1-8
No objection
16:14-23
No objection
17:17-18:14
No objection
19:9-14
No objection
20:3-13
No objection
22:8-23:17
No objection
21
Christina Aguiar
Page/Line
Objections
24:18-24
No objection
27:10-28:11
No objection
29:19-30:15
No objection
30:22-31:6
No objection
31:16-17
No objection
32:13-33:3
No objection
34:2-25
No objection
35:3-25
No objection
36:13-38:9
No objection
39:25-40:4
No objection
43:15-19
No objection
44:19-24
Foundation; speculation
45:13-15
No objection
46:1-7
Foundation; speculation
47:13-22
Relevance
48:11-49:12
48:17-22 foundation, speculation
49:22-50:2
No objection
50:8-51:24
50:8-10 foundation, speculation
52:5-7
No objection
52:12-17
No objection
52:20-53:17
No objection
58:5-13
No objection
58:16-19
Incomplete designation
61:14-17
Improper designation (question does not correspond to
designated answer)
62:4-10
Incomplete designation
64:19-25
No objection
65:9-16, 18-20
No objection
66:9-11
No objection
67:9-14
No objection
22
Christina Aguiar
Page/Line
Objections
67:25-69:1
Foundation, speculation
69:9-13
No objection
71:22-25
No objection
72:7-73:12
No objection
73:14-16
No objection
79:18-20
No objection
80:1-7, 14-17
No objection
80:23-81:4
No objection
81:8-16
No objection
84:24-85:2
No objection
85:10-12
No objection
87:15-23
No objection
94:4-7
No objection
94:9-95:1
No objection
95:5-19
No objection
96:15-18
No objection
97:5-98:23
No objection
99:5-19
No objection
99:22-100:15
No objection
100:23-25
No objection
101:3-16
No objection
102:20-103:3
No objection
104:12-14, 25
No objection
105:5-12
Foundation, speculation
105:23-106:23
No objection
107:2-5
No objection
111:21-114:21
113:11-114:15 foundation, speculation
117:1-119:24
No objection
120:9-11, 14-19
No objection
23
Christina Aguiar
Page/Line
Objections
122:2-21
No objection
124:3-125:13
No objection
129:2-7, 11-22
No objection
140:11-141:12
No objection
141:14-142:2
No objection
142:6-16, 19-24
No objection
145:9-10, 13-17
No objection
145:20-146:13
145:25-146:13 foundation, speculation
146:16-17
Foundation, speculation
146:21-147:8
Foundation, speculation
147:22-148:14
148:22-23
Foundation, speculation
No objection
149:1-8
Foundation, speculation
151:16-20
No objection
151:24-152:11
Non-responsive, relevance
153:25-154:3
No objection
154:6-157:4
No objection
157:14-23
No objection
158:1-9
No objection
162:18-20
Incomplete designation
163:18-24
Incomplete designation
164:5-165:4
164:22-165:4 foundation, speculation
167:10-19
No objection
180:14-17
No objection
180:20-181:11
No objection
181:14-182:5
No objection
Counter-designations: 5:19; 15:20-25; 20:14-21:2; 33:4-10; 36:1-5; 38:25-39:9; 41:3-8;
49:13-15; 53:18-22; 58:20-59:2; 61:23-62:1; 80:9-13; 100:17-21; 107:7-12; 108:1-110:10;
130:3-11; 159:11-160:19; 161:11-162:7; 163:12-14; 165:5-10
24
P.
Eric Eichmann (March 3, 2010)
Eric Eichmann
Page/Line
32:17-43:14
Objections
33:14-38:11 outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony;
relevance
43:20-48:12
43:20-48:3 outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony
51:7-53:11
51:13-21 asked and answered
66:7-68:17
No objection
69:2-77:18
75:5-76:15 foundation, relevance
81:1-85:10
83:23-84:3 foundation;
94:7-100:14
No objection
118:21-129:2
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony
130:5-131:5
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony
219:22-239:25
No objection
250:6-253:5
No objection
262:12-266:14
No objection
269:4-270:8
No objection
275:16-288:12
286:15-288:12 relevance, prejudicial
Counter-designations: 48:13-49:21; 100:21-101:1, 101:3-102:24; 129:3-12; 266:15267:7
Q.
Michael Wu (March 5, 2010)
Michael Wu
Page/Line
Objections
16:12-16:20
No objection
17:4-19:10
No objection
19:11-20:9
Relevance
20:1-22:1
Relevance
125:25-131:21
Relevance
133:16-24
Relevance
134:19-135:10
Relevance, 135:9-10 calls for a legal conclusion
135:12-135:23
Relevance; incomplete answer include 135:24-25
25
Michael Wu
Page/Line
Objections
136:5-10
Relevance
138:23-139:23
Relevance
139:25-140:18
Relevance
140:20-24
Relevance
141:1-7, 9-23
Relevance
142:5-144:19
Relevance
150:15-151:17
Relevance
151:19-153:22
Relevance
153:24-154:21
Relevance
154:23-155:16
Relevance
156:2-159:19
Relevance
173:22-177:6
Relevance
177:10-178:20
Relevance
179:1-14
Relevance
180:1-18
Relevance
184:2-7, 9-20
Question calls for a legal conclusion; foundation
186:6-10
Foundation; speculation -- question calls for the witness to
state how a "consumer" might feel
186:12-15
Response to an improper question
187:6-188:22
Relevance, foundation
189:18-192:18
Relevance; prejudicial
192:24-193:17
Relevance; prejudicial
193:20-194:5
Relevance; prejudicial
195:3-196:1
Relevance; prejudicial
198:14-199:14
Relevance; prejudicial
199:16-202:15
Relevance; prejudicial
203:8-203:23
Relevance; prejudicial
203:25-204:1
Relevance; prejudicial
204:9-205:15
Relevance; prejudicial
205:17-208:4
Relevance; prejudicial
26
Michael Wu
Page/Line
Objections
208:7-14, 16-18
Relevance; prejudicial
209:22-211:1
Relevance; prejudicial
211:4-8, 11-17
Relevance; prejudicial
211:20-213:24
Relevance; prejudicial
214:1-17
Relevance
214:23-216:15
Relevance; prejudicial
216:17-18
Relevance; prejudicial
217:2-12
Relevance; prejudicial
237:9-238:9
Relevance; prejudicial
238:11-240:12
Relevance; prejudicial
Counter-designations: 28:12-20; 36:23-37:7; 37:22-38:19; 43:12-44:4; 50:8-25; 135:2425; 145:25-146:11; 162:24-165:19; 170:10-20; 194:6-195:2; 269:12-269:24; 270:4271:21; 281:5-282:9
R.
Jason Calhoun (March 8, 2010)
Jason Calhoun
Page/Line
Objections
6:11
No objection
9:22-10:6
No objection
14:14-20
No objection
15:25-16:10
No objection
18:21-20:7
No objection
20:13-16
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
22:13-23:1
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
24:9-25:7
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
25:17-26:5
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
27:17-28:16
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, relevance,
hearsay
29:7-12
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
incomplete designation
34:3-15
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
27
Jason Calhoun
Page/Line
Objections
36:5-9, 12-16
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
37:8-9, 11-15
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
38:1-7
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
39:3-8
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
43:18-44:3
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
44:5
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
46:10-24
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
49:4-50:5
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
52:19-54:11
52:19-23 confusing, 53:6-9 mischaracterizes the witness's
testimony
55:1-56:22
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
61:13-19
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
62:19-24
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
63:5-11
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
76:13-77:2
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
77:24-78:3
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
78:11-14
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
91:5-8
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance, confusing
91:23-92:12
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
incomplete
99:6-100:15
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
123:16-124:9
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
124:14-125:3
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
28
Jason Calhoun
Page/Line
Objections
125:5-7, 18-25
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay, 125:1817 relevance
139:6-17
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay, over
inclusive 139:17
141:22-142:8
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
145:2-22
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
147:24-148:12
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
167:9-170:4
169:22-170:4 speculation
172:8-13
Incomplete
173:6-8
Incomplete
176:2-7, 9-10
No objection
187:5-190:11
Relevance
198:23-200:3
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
217:9-15
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
219:1-3, 5-6, 8-9
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
219:11-13, 15-17
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay
Counter-designations: 23:2-5; 26:16-27:16; 28:23-29:6; 29:13-30:18; 33:8-33:22; 38:840:2; 46:25-47:10; 54:12-24; 62:10-17; 63:12-65:11; 65:21-66:8; 72:2-25; 75:5-76:7;
92:13-18; 114:2-8; 172:14-25; 173:9-176:1
S.
Tom Adams (March 12, 2010)
Tom Adams
Page/Line
Objections
6:8-6:21
No objection
6:23-7:1
No objection
7:3-7:8
No objection
7:10-8:19
No objection
8:21-9:3
No objection
9:5-9:10
No objection
29
Tom Adams
Page/Line
Objections
9:12-9:21
No objection
9:23-10:3
No objection
10:5-10:16
No objection
10:18-10:24
No objection
11:1-11:23
No objection
11:25-12:4
No objection
12:6-12:12
No objection
12:14
No objection
12:16-13:5
No objection
13:7
No objection
13:9-13:20
No objection
13:22-14:19
14:16-14:19 relevance
14:21-15:13
Relevance
15:15-15:20
Relevance
15:22-16:24
Relevance
17:1-17:6
Relevance
17:8-17:17
Relevance
17:19-18:12
Relevance
18:14-18:19
Relevance
18:21-19:8
Relevance
19:10-19:11
Relevance
44:6-45:18
Relevance
45:20-45:23
Argumentative
45:25-46:22
Relevance
46:25-47:15
Relevance
47:17-48:22
Relevance
48:24-49:7
Relevance
52:10-52:17
Asked and answered; question only
54:18
Relevance, no question pending
30
Tom Adams
Page/Line
Objections
58:2-58:15
Relevance, incomplete
59:1-59:15
Relevance, incomplete
59:20-60:9
Relevance
60:11-60:17
Relevance
61:16-61:19
Relevance
61:21-62:14
Relevance
62:16-62:19
Relevance
62:21-63:10
Relevance
63:12 -63:23
Relevance, calls for a legal conclusion
63:25-64:10
Relevance, calls for a legal conclusion
64:12, 14
Relevance, calls for a legal conclusion
95:20-95:22
No objection
95:24-96:4
Incomplete
96:17-96:20
Incomplete hypothetical
96:22-97:4
Incomplete hypothetical
97:10-97:16
Incomplete hypothetical
97:18-98:23
98:18-23 incomplete hypothetical
99:1-99:19
Response to incomplete hypothetical, incomplete hypothetical
99:22 -100:7
Response to incomplete hypothetical
100:9-100:20
Response to incomplete hypothetical, incomplete hypothetical
100:23-101:6
Response to incomplete hypothetical
101:8-101:24
No objection
110:16-110:20
Lacks foundation
110:22-111:9
No objection
111:11-111:25
No objection
112:2-112:14
No objection
116:12-116:14
Relevance, asked and answered
116:16-116:25
Relevance, asked and answered
117:2-118:9
No objection
31
Tom Adams
Page/Line
Objections
119:13-119:15
Relevance, asked and answered
119:17-119:18
Relevance
131:19-132:4
No objection
132:21-133:4
No objection
133:6-133:8
No objection
134:3-136:5
134:3 argumentative
136:15-136:17
Incomplete question and no response
137:11-138:19
Question is vague
138:21-138:22
Question is vague
138:24-139:3
Response to a vague question
139:14-140:18
Relevance
140:21-140:25
Relevance
141:25-145:8
141:25-144:6 relevance, 145:6 argumentative Question
145:10-146:4
Incomplete response
146:13-146:20
146:13-14 argumentative statement;
146:22-147:4
No objection
147:7-147:8
Argumentative
147:10-147:12
147:12 argumentative question with no response
147:14-147:17
Argumentative
147:19
Argumentative
147:21-147:25
Argumentative
148:3-148:12
148:9-12 Argumentative question with no response
148:14-148:21
Argumentative
148:24-149:4
No objection
149:25-150:8
No objection
150:10-150:12
No objection
169:18-173:23
No objection
205:21-206:8
Calls for a legal conclusion; incomplete hypothetical
206:10-206:20
Response to an improper question
32
Tom Adams
Page/Line
Objections
206:22-207:16
Response to an improper question
207:18, 20
Response to an improper question
208:13-208:16
Relevance, foundation
208:18-209:2
Relevance, foundation
209:5-210:12
Relevance, foundation
210:14-211:15
Relevance, foundation
211:17-212:4
Relevance, foundation
212:17-212:20
Vague as to damaged and calls for a legal conclusion
212:22-213:7
Response to an improper question
228:6-237:11
228: 6-230:14 object to counsel colloquy;
237:16-241:2
240:8-241:2 object to counsel colloquy
Counter-designations: 58:15-23; 59:15-17; 96:5-14; 146:5-10
T.
Nino Ninov (February 22, 2010)
Nino Ninov
Page/Line
Objections
7:7-8
No objection
8:25-9:13
No objection
10:7-14:22
11:1-14:22 relevance
14:23-15:7
No objection
16:4-9
No objection
39:7-16
No objection
60:24-65:10
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
67:1-70:16
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
70:20-72:8
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
86:20-87:2
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
33
Nino Ninov
Page/Line
Objections
87:17-88:1
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
90:3-8, 14-20
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
95:13-96:9
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
96:14-97:4
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b) testimony, hearsay, relevance
108:14-109:14
No objection
111:6-25
No objection
112:19-113:3
No objection
119:14-18
No objection
120:21-121:3
Incomplete response, include 121:4-11
121:15:122:5
No objection
128:16-129:20
No objection
153:21-154:4
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
155:12-13
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
155:21-156:2
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
156:10-157:12
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
157:16-158:25
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
159:6-22
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
167:19-22
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
168:7-9, 11-16
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
169:5-13
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
170:14-16
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
34
Nino Ninov
Page/Line
171:5-18
Objections
Outside the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) testimony, hearsay,
relevance
Counter-designations: 87:3-12; 88:2-6; 90:21-91:3; 97:12-99:19; 100:17-101:25; 109:1624; 112:1-18; 118:2-119:13; 127:7-128:15; 130:9-132:15
35
II.
Rosetta Stone’s Objections to Google’s Exhibits
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
1
GOOG-RS-0492712 GOOG-RS-0492718
Relevance, foundation
2
GOOG-RS-0494054 GOOG-RS-0494055
Did not produce until
4/1/10, foundation,
hearsay
3
GOOG-RS-0494052 GOOG-RS-0494053
Did not produce until
4/1/10, relevance,
foundation, hearsay
4
GOOG-RS-0494050 GOOG-RS-0494051
Did not produce until
4/1/10, foundation,
hearsay
5
GOOG-RS-0494048 GOOG-RS-0494049
Did not produce until
4/1/10, foundation,
hearsay
6
GOOG-RS-0494045 GOOG-RS-0494047
Did not produce until
4/1/10, foundation,
hearsay
7
GOOG-RS-0494044 GOOG-RS-0494044
Did not produce until
4/1/10, foundation,
hearsay
8
GOOG-RS-0494039 GOOG-RS-0494043
Did not produce until
4/1/10, foundation,
hearsay
9
GOOG-RS-0494036 GOOG-RS-0494038
Did not produce until
4/1/10, foundation,
hearsay
10
GOOG-RS-0494032 GOOG-RS-0494035
Did not produce until
4/1/10, relevance,
foundation, hearsay
11
GOOG-RS-0494030 GOOG-RS-0494031
Did not produce until
4/1/10, relevance,
foundation, hearsay
36
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
12
GOOG-RS-0494019 GOOG-RS-0494020
Relevance (no
challenge to
authenticity of Amazon
documents identified
therein)
13
GOOG-RS-0494014 GOOG-RS-0494018
Relevance, hearsay
14
GOOG-RS-0494011 GOOG-RS-0494013
Relevance, hearsay
15
GOOG-RS-0494009 GOOG-RS-0494010
Relevance, hearsay,
duplicative of Exhibit
14
16
GOOG-RS-0492994 GOOG-RS-0492996
Relevance, foundation
17
GOOG-RS-0492990 GOOG-RS-0492993
Relevance, foundation
18
GOOG-RS-0492984 GOOG-RS-0492986
Relevance, foundation
19
GOOG-RS-0492982 GOOG-RS-0492983
Relevance, foundation
20
GOOG-RS-0492979 GOOG-RS-0492981
Relevance, foundation
21
GOOG-RS-0492925 GOOG-RS-0492927
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
22
GOOG-RS-0492911 GOOG-RS-0492912
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
23
GOOG-RS-0492848 GOOG-RS-0492853
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
24
GOOG-RS-0492835 GOOG-RS-0492836
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
25
GOOG-RS-0492784 GOOG-RS-0492788
Relevance, foundation
hearsay
26
GOOG-RS-0492775 GOOG-RS-0492776
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
27
GOOG-RS-0492735 GOOG-RS-0492735
Relevance, foundation
37
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
28
GOOG-RS-0492732 GOOG-RS-049734
Relevance, foundation
29
GOOG-RS-0492729 GOOG-RS-0492731
Relevance, foundation,
multiple documents in
a single exhibit,
incomplete
30
GOOG-RS-0492727 GOOG-RS-0492728
Relevance, foundation,
incomplete
31
GOOG-RS-0492726 GOOG-RS-0492726
Relevance, foundation
32
GOOG-RS-0492723 GOOG-RS-0492725
Relevance, foundation
33
GOOG-RS-0492719 GOOG-RS-0492722
Relevance, foundation
34
GOOG-RS-0492710 GOOG-RS-0492710
Relevance, foundation,
incomplete
35
GOOG-RS-0492709 GOOG-RS-0492709
Relevance, foundation
36
GOOG-RS-0492703 GOOG-RS-0492708
Relevance, foundation
37
GOOG-RS-0492702 GOOG-RS-0492702
Relevance, foundation
38
GOOG-RS-0492701 GOOG-RS-0492701
Relevance, foundation,
incomplete
39
GOOG-RS-0492699 GOOG-RS-0492699
Relevance, foundation,
incomplete
40
GOOG-RS-0492698 GOOG-RS-0492698
Relevance, foundation
41
GOOG-RS-0492692 GOOG-RS-0492697
Relevance, foundation
42
GOOG-RS-0492691 GOOG-RS-0492691
Relevance, foundation
43
GOOG-RS-0492688 GOOG-RS-0492690
Relevance, foundation
44
GOOG-RS-0492687 GOOG-RS-0492687
Relevance, foundation
45
GOOG-RS-0492683 GOOG-RS-0492686
Relevance, foundation
46
GOOG-RS-0492680 GOOG-RS-0492682
Relevance, foundation
38
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
47
GOOG-RS-0492676 GOOG-RS-0492679
Relevance, foundation
48
GOOG-RS-0492674 GOOG-RS-0492675
Relevance, foundation
49
GOOG-RS-0492668 GOOG-RS-0492673
Relevance, foundation
50
GOOG-RS-0492665 GOOG-RS-0492667
Relevance, foundation
51
GOOG-RS-0492664 GOOG-RS-0492664
Relevance, foundation
52
GOOG-RS-0492656 GOOG-RS-0492663
Relevance, foundation
53
GOOG-RS-0492652 GOOG-RS-0492655
Relevance, foundation
54
GOOG-RS-0492644 GOOG-RS-0492651
Relevance, foundation
55
GOOG-RS-0492641 GOOG-RS-0492643
Relevance, foundation
56
GOOG-RS-0492639 GOOG-RS-0492640
Relevance, foundation
57
GOOG-RS-0492637 GOOG-RS-0492638
Relevance, foundation
58
GOOG-RS-0492635 GOOG-RS-0492636
Relevance, foundation
59
GOOG-RS-0492632 GOOG-RS-0492634
Relevance, foundation
60
GOOG-RS-0492629 GOOG-RS-0492631
Relevance, foundation
61
GOOG-RS-0492625 GOOG-RS-0492628
Relevance, foundation
62
GOOG-RS-0492623 GOOG-RS-0492624
Relevance, foundation
63
GOOG-RS-0492617 GOOG-RS-0492619
Relevance, foundation
64
GOOG-RS-0492602 GOOG-RS-0492616
Relevance, foundation
65
GOOG-RS-0492600 GOOG-RS-0492601
Relevance, foundation
66
GOOG-RS-0492598 GOOG-RS-0492599
Relevance, foundation
67
GOOG-RS-0492594 GOOG-RS-0492597
Relevance, foundation
68
GOOG-RS-0492592 GOOG-RS-0492593
Relevance, foundation
69
GOOG-RS-0492590 GOOG-RS-0492591
Relevance, foundation
39
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
70
GOOG-RS-0492588 GOOG-RS-0492589
Relevance, foundation
71
GOOG-RS-0492586 GOOG-RS-0492587
Relevance, foundation
72
GOOG-RS-0492582 GOOG-RS-0492582
Relevance, foundation,
incomplete
73
GOOG-RS-0492579 GOOG-RS-0492581
Relevance, foundation
74
GOOG-RS-0492576 GOOG-RS-0492578
Relevance, foundation
75
GOOG-RS-0492574 GOOG-RS-0492574
Relevance, foundation
76
GOOG-RS-0492573 GOOG-RS-0492573
Relevance, foundation
77
GOOG-RS-0492177 GOOG-RS-0492186
Foundation, hearsay,
incomplete
78
GOOG-RS-0492107 GOOG-RS-0492114
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
79
GOOG-RS-0479836 GOOG-RS-0479836
Relevance, incomplete
(no records attached or
referenced)
80
GOOG-RS-0479815 GOOG-RS-0479815
Relevance, foundation
81
GOOG-RS-0479809 GOOG-RS-0479809
Relevance, foundation
82
GOOG-RS-0479801 GOOG-RS-0479801
Relevance, foundation
83
GOOG-RS-0479756 GOOG-RS-0479756
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
84
GOOG-RS-0479752 GOOG-RS-0479755
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
85
GOOG-RS-0479751 GOOG-RS-0479751
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
86
GOOG-RS-0479748 GOOG-RS-0479750
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
40
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
87
GOOG-RS-0479747 GOOG-RS-0479747
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
88
GOOG-RS-0479746 GOOG-RS-0479746
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
89
GOOG-RS-0479745 GOOG-RS-0479745
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
90
GOOG-RS-0479741 GOOG-RS-0479744
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
91
GOOG-RS-0479739 GOOG-RS-0479740
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
92
GOOG-RS-0479737 GOOG-RS-0479738
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
93
GOOG-RS-0479716 GOOG-RS-0479736
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
94
GOOG-RS-0479714 GOOG-RS-0479715
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
95
GOOG-RS-0479710 GOOG-RS-0479713
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
96
GOOG-RS-0479665 GOOG-RS-0479709
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
97
GOOG-RS-0479662 GOOG-RS-0479664
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
98
GOOG-RS-0479660 GOOG-RS-0479661
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
99
GOOG-RS-0479242 GOOG-RS-0479242
Foundation
100
GOOG-RS-0349138 GOOG-RS-0349165
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
101
GOOG-RS-0346813 GOOG-RS-0346813
Foundation
41
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
102
GOOG-RS-0346808 GOOG-RS-0346812
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
103
GOOG-RS-0346770 GOOG-RS-0346771
Foundation
104
GOOG-RS-0344103 GOOG-RS-0344103
Relevance, foundation
105
GOOG-RS-0343378 GOOG-RS-0343665
Relevance, foundation
106
GOOG-RS-0342454 GOOG-RS-0343377
Relevance, foundation
107
GOOG-RS-0342347 GOOG-RS-0342453
Relevance, foundation
108
GOOG-RS-0342334 GOOG-RS-0342335
Foundation
109
GOOG-RS-0342323 GOOG-RS-0342333
Foundation
110
GOOG-RS-0342308 GOOG-RS-0342322
Foundation
111
GOOG-RS-0342293 GOOG-RS-0342303
Foundation, incomplete
112
GOOG-RS-0339503 GOOG-RS-0339505
Foundation
113
GOOG-RS-0339370 GOOG-RS-0339376
Foundation, incomplete
114
GOOG-RS-0337418 GOOG-RS-0337419
Relevance, incomplete
(no records attached)
115
GOOG-RS-0335878 GOOG-RS-0335879
Foundation
116
GOOG-RS-0335875 GOOG-RS-0335876
Foundation
117
GOOG-RS-0335874 GOOG-RS-0335874
Foundation
118
GOOG-RS-0335867 GOOG-RS-0335868
Foundation
119
GOOG-RS-0335467 GOOG-RS-0335467
Foundation, hearsay,
incomplete
120
GOOG-RS-0335013 GOOG-RS-0335016
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, unfairly
prejudicial, duplicative
of Exhibit 233
42
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
121
GOOG-RS-0334828 GOOG-RS-0334839
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, incomplete
122
GOOG-RS-0333791 GOOG-RS-0333791
Foundation, duplicative
of Exhibit 138
123
GOOG-RS-0333790 GOOG-RS-0333790
Foundation, duplicative
of Exhibit 137
124
GOOG-RS-0332952 GOOG-RS-0332958
Foundation, hearsay
125
GOOG-RS-0332940 GOOG-RS-0332944
Foundation, hearsay
126
GOOG-RS-0332875 GOOG-RS-0332875
Foundation, hearsay
127
GOOG-RS-0310071 GOOG-RS-0310073
Foundation, hearsay
128
GOOG-RS-0309919 GOOG-RS-0309985
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, multiple
documents in a single
exhibit, incomplete,
unfairly prejudicial
129
GOOG-RS-0309869 GOOG-RS-0309880
Foundation, hearsay
130
GOOG-RS-0309154 GOOG-RS-0309165
Foundation, hearsay,
duplicative of Exhibit
131
131
GOOG-RS-0309153 GOOG-RS-0309165
Foundation, hearsay
132
GOOG-RS-0309121 GOOG-RS-0309131
Relevance, foundation
133
GOOG-RS-0308672 GOOG-RS-0308673
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
134
GOOG-RS-0308586 GOOG-RS-0308592
Relevance, foundation,
duplicative of Exhibit
135
135
GOOG-RS-0308570 GOOG-RS-0308593
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, multiple
documents in a single
exhibit
43
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
136
GOOG-RS-0308092 GOOG-RS-0308097
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, authenticity
(GOOG-RS-030809497)
137
GOOG-RS-0308091 GOOG-RS-0308091
Foundation
138
GOOG-RS-0308090 GOOG-RS-0308090
Foundation
139
GOOG-RS-0278286 GOOG-RS-0282326
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, multiple
documents in a single
exhibit
140
GOOG-RS-0278168 GOOG-RS-0278175
Foundation, hearsay,
incomplete
141
GOOG-RS-0275634 GOOG-RS-0275635
Foundation, hearsay
142
GOOG-RS-0275530 GOOG-RS-0275531
Foundation, hearsay
143
GOOG-RS-0275092 GOOG-RS-0275092
Foundation, hearsay,
incomplete
144
GOOG-RS-0275011 GOOG-RS-0275018
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, incomplete
145
GOOG-RS-0274959 GOOG-RS-0274959
Foundation, hearsay
146
GOOG-RS-0274906 GOOG-RS-0274907
Foundation, hearsay
147
GOOG-RS-0274676 GOOG-RS-0274677
Foundation, hearsay
148
GOOG-RS-0274550 GOOG-RS-0274569
Foundation, hearsay
149
GOOG-RS-0274521 GOOG-RS-0274549
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
150
GOOG-RS-0273315 GOOG-RS-0273336
Foundation, hearsay
151
GOOG-RS-0273083 GOOG-RS-0273084
Foundation, hearsay
152
GOOG-RS-0273079 GOOG-RS-0273080
Foundation, hearsay
44
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
153
GOOG-RS-0273077 GOOG-RS-0273078
Foundation, hearsay
154
GOOG-RS-0273028 GOOG-RS-0273028
Foundation, hearsay
155
GOOG-RS-0273026 GOOG-RS-0273026
Foundation, hearsay
156
GOOG-RS-0273020 GOOG-RS-0273021
Foundation, hearsay
157
GOOG-RS-0272894 GOOG-RS-0272907
Foundation, hearsay
158
GOOG-RS-0272882 GOOG-RS-0272886
Foundation, hearsay
159
GOOG-RS-0272812 GOOG-RS-0272859
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, multiple
documents in a single
exhibit
160
GOOG-RS-0272802 GOOG-RS-0272805
Foundation, hearsay
161
GOOG-RS-0272797 GOOG-RS-0272801
Foundation, hearsay
162
GOOG-RS-0272796 GOOG-RS-0272796
Foundation
163
GOOG-RS-0272789 GOOG-RS-0272791
Foundation
164
GOOG-RS-0272751 GOOG-RS-0272760
Foundation, hearsay
165
GOOG-RS-0272607 GOOG-RS-0272624
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, unfairly
prejudicial
166
GOOG-RS-0272511 GOOG-RS-0272526
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
167
GOOG-RS-0271019 GOOG-RS-0271020
Foundation, hearsay
168
GOOG-RS-0271004 GOOG-RS-0271009
Foundation, hearsay
169
GOOG-RS-0270488 GOOG-RS-0270492
Foundation, hearsay,
incomplete
170
GOOG-RS-0270369 GOOG-RS-0270378
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
45
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
171
GOOG-RS-0270345 GOOG-RS-0270345
Foundation, hearsay
172
GOOG-RS-0270044 GOOG-RS-0270045
Foundation, hearsay
173
GOOG-RS-0270031 GOOG-RS-0193004
Document
unidentifiable from the
bates range provided,
all objections reserved
174
GOOG-RS-0269908 GOOG-RS-0269920
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
175
GOOG-RS-0269602 GOOG-RS-0269602
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
176
GOOG-RS-0269598 GOOG-RS-0269599
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
177
GOOG-RS-0269562 GOOG-RS-0269564
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
178
GOOG-RS-0268866 GOOG-RS-0268870
Foundation, hearsay
179
GOOG-RS-0268304 GOOG-RS-0268305
Foundation, hearsay
180
GOOG-RS-0268141 GOOG-RS-0268170
Relevance, foundation
181
GOOG-RS-0265472 GOOG-RS-0265477
Foundation, hearsay
182
GOOG-RS-0265459 GOOG-RS-0265463
Foundation, hearsay
183
GOOG-RS-0265450 GOOG-RS-0265452
Foundation, hearsay
184
GOOG-RS-0263218 GOOG-RS-0263220
Foundation, hearsay
185
GOOG-RS-0262131 GOOG-RS-0262142
Foundation
186
GOOG-RS-0261327 GOOG-RS-0261332
Hearsay, foundation
187
GOOG-RS-0260742 GOOG-RS-0260751
Foundation, hearsay
188
GOOG-RS-0260650 GOOG-RS-0260662
Foundation, hearsay
46
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
189
GOOG-RS-0260425 GOOG-RS-0260446
Incomplete (parent
document withheld as
privileged), foundation,
hearsay
190
GOOG-RS-0258340 GOOG-RS-0258601
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
191
GOOG-RS-0258215 GOOG-RS-0258249
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
192
GOOG-RS-0255825 GOOG-RS-0255865
Foundation, hearsay
193
GOOG-RS-0253537 GOOG-RS-0253537
Foundation, hearsay
194
GOOG-RS-0253434 GOOG-RS-0253435
Foundation, hearsay
195
GOOG-RS-0253119 GOOG-RS-0253120
Foundation, hearsay
196
GOOG-RS-0252607 GOOG-RS-0252672
Foundation, hearsay
197
GOOG-RS-0251106 GOOG-RS-0251139
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
198
GOOG-RS-0251045 GOOG-RS-0251052
Foundation, hearsay
199
GOOG-RS-0251003 GOOG-RS-0251007
Foundation, hearsay
200
GOOG-RS-0250990 GOOG-RS-0250990
Foundation
201
GOOG-RS-0249959 GOOG-RS-0249963
Foundation, hearsay,
multiple documents in
a single exhibit
202
GOOG-RS-0194340 GOOG-RS-0194342
Foundation, hearsay,
duplicative of Exhibit
201
203
GOOG-RS-0193766 GOOG-RS-0193771
Foundation, hearsay
204
GOOG-RS-0193133 GOOG-RS-0193135
Foundation, hearsay
205
GOOG-RS-0193011 GOOG-RS-0193011
Foundation
47
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
206
GOOG-RS-0192299 GOOG-RS-0192299
Foundation, hearsay
207
GOOG-RS-0139147 GOOG-RS-0139149
Foundation, relevance
208
GOOG-RS-0139141 GOOG-RS-0139143
Relevance, foundation
209
GOOG-RS-0134987 GOOG-RS-0135012
Foundation, hearsay
210
GOOG-RS-0134939 GOOG-RS-0134943
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
211
GOOG-RS-0134093 GOOG-RS-0134096
Foundation, hearsay
212
GOOG-RS-0132544 GOOG-RS-0132544
Foundation, hearsay
213
GOOG-RS-0132290 GOOG-RS-0132290
Foundation, hearsay
214
GOOG-RS-0131246 GOOG-RS-0131248
Relevance, foundation
215
GOOG-RS-0131240 GOOG-RS-0131242
Foundation, relevance
216
GOOG-RS-0095828 GOOG-RS-0095832
Foundation, hearsay
217
GOOG-RS-0094401 GOOG-RS-0094402
Foundation, hearsay
218
GOOG-RS-0083307 GOOG-RS-0083311
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
219
GOOG-RS-0080079 GOOG-RS-0080082
Foundation, hearsay
220
GOOG-RS-0068456 GOOG-RS-0068505
Foundation, hearsay
221
GOOG-RS-0068374 GOOG-RS-0068374
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
222
GOOG-RS-0062303 GOOG-RS-0062303
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
223
GOOG-RS-0053638 GOOG-RS-0053809
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, multiple
documents in a single
exhibit
48
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
224
GOOG-RS-0041133 GOOG-RS-0041231
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
225
GOOG-RS-0028918 GOOG-RS-0028977
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
226
GOOG-RS-0027918 GOOG-RS-0029401
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, multiple
documents in a single
exhibit, incomplete
documents
227
GOOG-RS-0024967 GOOG-RS-0024989
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
228
GOOG-RS-0018775 GOOG-RS-0018821
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, incomplete,
duplicative of exhibit
229
229
GOOG-RS-0018774 GOOG-RS-0018821
Relevance, hearsay,
foundation
230
GOOG-RS-0014880 GOOG-RS-0014924
Relevance, hearsay,
foundation
231
GOOG-RS-0008717 GOOG-RS-0008718
Foundation, hearsay
232
GOOG-RS-0007811 GOOG-RS-0007847
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, foundation,
unfairly prejudicial
233
GOOG-RS-0007744 GOOG-RS-0007749
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, unfairly
prejudicial
234
GOOG-RS-0006525 GOOG-RS-0006553
Foundation, hearsay
235
GOOG-RS-0003129 GOOG-RS-0003130
Foundation, hearsay
236
GOOG-RS-0003127 GOOG-RS-0003128
Foundation, hearsay,
duplicative of Exhibit
238
49
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
237
GOOG-RS-0003124 GOOG-RS-0003124
Foundation, hearsay
238
GOOG-RS-0003110 GOOG-RS-0003112
Foundation, hearsay
239
GOOG-RS-0002583 GOOG-RS-0002587
Foundation, hearsay
240
GOOG-RS-0002429 GOOG-RS-0002435
Foundation, hearsay
241
GOOG-RS-0002150 GOOG-RS-0002195
Foundation, hearsay
242
GOOG-RSGA-00088 GOOG-RSGA-00088
Foundation
243
GOOG-RSGA-00086 GOOG-RSGA-00087
Foundation
244
GOOG-RSGA-00085 GOOG-RSGA-00085
Foundation
245
GOOG-RSGA-00084 GOOG-RSGA-00084
Foundation
246
GOOG-RSGA-00083 GOOG-RSGA-00083
Foundation
247
GOOG-RSGA-00081 GOOG-RSGA-00081
Foundation, incomplete
248
GOOG-RSGA-00080 GOOG-RSGA-00080
Foundation
249
GOOG-RSGA-00079 GOOG-RSGA-00079
Foundation
250
GOOG-RSGA-00076 GOOG-RSGA-00078
Foundation
251
GOOG-RSGA-00074 GOOG-RSGA-00075
Foundation
252
GOOG-RSGA-00073 GOOG-RSGA-00073
Foundation
253
GOOG-RSGA-00072 GOOG-RSGA-00072
Foundation
254
GOOG-RSGA-00061 GOOG-RSGA-00071
Foundation
255
GOOG-RSGA-00059 GOOG-RSGA-00060
Foundation
256
GOOG-RSGA-00058 GOOG-RSGA-00058
Foundation
257
GOOG-RSGA-00057 GOOG-RSGA-00057
Foundation
258
GOOG-RSGA-00056 GOOG-RSGA-00056
Foundation
259
GOOG-RSGA-00054 GOOG-RSGA-00055
Foundation
50
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
260
GOOG-RSGA-00053 GOOG-RSGA-00053
Foundation
261
GOOG-RSGA-00052 GOOG-RSGA-00052
Foundation
262
GOOG-RSGA-00051 GOOG-RSGA-00051
Foundation
263
GOOG-RSGA-00049 GOOG-RSGA-00050
Foundation
264
GOOG-RSGA-00038 GOOG-RSGA-00048
Foundation
265
GOOG-RSGA-00036 GOOG-RSGA-00037
Foundation
266
GOOG-RSGA-00035 GOOG-RSGA-00035
Foundation
267
GOOG-RSGA-00033 GOOG-RSGA-00034
Foundation
268
GOOG-RSGA-00031 GOOG-RSGA-00032
Foundation
269
GOOG-RSGA-00029 GOOG-RSGA-00030
Foundation
270
GOOG-RSGA-00027 GOOG-RSGA-00028
Foundation
271
GOOG-RSGA-00025 GOOG-RSGA-00026
Foundation
272
GOOG-RSGA-00022 GOOG-RSGA-00024
Foundation
273
GOOG-RSGA-00020 GOOG-RSGA-00021
Foundation
274
GOOG-RSGA-00018 GOOG-RSGA-00019
Foundation
275
GOOG-RSGA-00016 GOOG-RSGA-00017
Foundation
276
GOOG-RSGA-00014 GOOG-RSGA-00015
Foundation
277
GOOG-RSGA-00013 GOOG-RSGA-00013
Foundation
278
GOOG-RSGA-00012 GOOG-RSGA-00012
Foundation
279
GOOG-RSGA-00011 GOOG-RSGA-00011
Foundation
280
GOOG-RSGA-00010 GOOG-RSGA-00010
Foundation
281
GOOG-RSGA-00009 GOOG-RSGA-00009
Foundation
282
GOOG-RSGA-00007 GOOG-RSGA-00007
Foundation
51
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
283
GOOG-RSGA-00006 GOOG-RSGA-00006
Foundation
284
GOOG-RSGA-00005 GOOG-RSGA-00005
Foundation
285
GOOG-RSGA-00004 GOOG-RSGA-00004
Document cannot be
viewed, all objections
reserved
286
GOOG-RSGA-00003 GOOG-RSGA-00003
Foundation
287
GOOG-RSGA-00002 GOOG-RSGA-00002
Foundation
288
GOOG-RSGA-00001 GOOG-RSGA-00001
Foundation
289
GOOG-RS-BLAIR-0001 GOOG-RS-BLAIR-0037
Foundation
290
RS-015-000001.12
RS-015-000001.12
Foundation
291
RS-015-000001.11
RS-015-000001.11
Foundation
292
RS-015-000001.10
RS-015-000001.10
Foundation
293
RS-015-000001.09
RS-015-000001.09
Foundation
294
RS-015-000001.08
RS-015-000001.08
Foundation
295
RS-015-000001.07
RS-015-000001.07
Foundation
296
RS-015-000001.06
RS-015-000001.06
Foundation
297
RS-015-000001.05
RS-015-000001.05
Foundation
298
RS-015-000001.04
RS-015-000001.04
Foundation
299
RS-015-000001.03
RS-015-000001.03
Foundation
300
RS-015-000001.02
RS-015-000001.02
Foundation
301
RS-015-000001.01
RS-015-000001.01
Foundation
302
RS-014-012206
RS-014-012235
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, multiple
documents in a single
exhibit
52
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
303
RS-014-009601
RS-014-009632
Relevance, foundation
304
RS-014-000038
RS-014-009600
Relevance, foundation
305
RS-014-000298
RS-014-001209
Relevance, foundation
306
RS-013-001064
RS-013-001067
Foundation, hearsay
307
RS-013-000975
RS-013-000981
Foundation
308
RS-013-000963
RS-013-000970
Foundation, duplicative
of Exhibit 309
309
RS-013-000957
RS-013-000974
Foundation, multiple
documents in a single
exhibit
310
RS-013-000951
RS-013-000956
Foundation
311
RS-013-000944
RS-013-000950
Foundation
312
RS-013-000941
RS-013-000943
Foundation
313
RS-013-000934
RS-013-000938
Foundation, incomplete
314
RS-013-000932
RS-013-000933
Foundation
315
RS-013-000922
RS-013-000931
Foundation
316
RS-013-000912
RS-013-000921
Foundation
317
RS-013-000907
RS-013-000911
Foundation
318
RS-013-000903
RS-013-000906
Foundation
319
RS-013-000899
RS-013-000902
Foundation
320
RS-013-000893
RS-013-000898
Foundation
321
RS-013-000890
RS-013-000892
Foundation
322
RS-013-000887
RS-013-000889
Foundation
323
RS-013-000883
RS-013-000886
Foundation
53
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
324
RS-013-000880
RS-013-000882
Foundation
325
RS-013-000877
RS-013-000879
Foundation
326
RS-013-000874
RS-013-000876
Foundation
327
RS-013-000871
RS-013-000873
Foundation
328
RS-013-000869
RS-013-000870
Foundation
329
RS-013-000866
RS-013-000868
Foundation
330
RS-013-000862
RS-013-000865
Foundation
331
RS-013-000859
RS-013-000861
Foundation
332
RS-013-000857
RS-013-000858
Foundation
333
RS-013-000854
RS-013-000856
Foundation
334
RS-013-000851
RS-013-000853
Foundation
335
RS-013-000844
RS-013-000850
Foundation
336
RS-013-000697
RS-013-000709
Relevance, foundation
337
RS-011-004895
RS-011-004963
Foundation
338
RS-009-000045
RS-009-000368
Foundation
339
RS-009-000033
RS-009-000044
Foundation
340
RS-007-000290
RS-007-000365
Foundation
341
RS-007-000022
RS-007-000066
Foundation
342
RS-007-000001
RS-007-000021
Foundation
343
RS-006-000033
RS-006-000038
Foundation
344
RS-006-000017
RS-006-000032
Foundation
345
RS-006-000010
RS-006-000016
Foundation
346
RS-006-000001
RS-006-000009
Foundation
54
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
347
RS-005-006255
RS-005-006256
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, duplicative of
Exhibit 348
348
RS-005-006255
RS-005-006256
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
349
RS-005-006253
RS-005-006254
Foundation
350
RS-005-006230
RS-005-006252
Relevance, foundation
351
RS-005-006228
RS-005-006229
Relevance, foundation,
352
RS-005-006226
RS-005-006227
Relevance, foundation,
353
RS-005-006125
RS-005-006225
Foundation
354
RS-005-005914
RS-005-005921
Relevance, incomplete
355
RS-005-005761
RS-005-005913
Foundation
356
RS-005-005760
RS-005-005760
Foundation
357
RS-005-005616
RS-005-005617
Foundation
358
RS-005-005484
RS-005-005615
Duplicative of Exhibit
691, no objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
359
RS-005-005272
RS-005-005483
Duplicative of Exhibit
692, no objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
360
RS-005-005061
RS-005-005271
Duplicative of Exhibit
693, no objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
361
RS-005-004944
RS-005-005060
Duplicative of Exhibit
694, no objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
55
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
362
RS-005-004823
RS-005-004943
Duplicative of Exhibit
695, no objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
363
RS-005-004648
RS-005-004814
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
364
RS-005-004629
RS-005-004647
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
365
RS-005-003181
RS-005-003190
Incomplete document,
no objection to relevant
excerpts, if any
366
RS-005-003179
RS-005-003180
Foundation
367
RS-005-003177
RS-005-003178
Foundation
368
RS-005-003152
RS-005-003176
Foundation
369
RS-005-003131
RS-005-003151
Foundation
370
RS-005-003130
RS-005-003130
Foundation
371
RS-005-003122
RS-005-003129
Foundation
372
RS-005-003119
RS-005-003121
Foundation
373
RS-005-003101
RS-005-003118
Foundation
374
RS-005-002063
RS-005-002063
Foundation
375
RS-005-002059
RS-005002062
No objection
376
RS-005-002055
RS-005-002058
No objection
377
RS-005-002051
RS-005-002054
No objection
378
RS-005-001950
RS-005-002050
Foundation
379
RS-005-001867
RS-005-001949
Foundation
56
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
380
RS-005-001842
RS-005-001842
Foundation
381
RS-005-001836
RS-005-001837
Foundation
382
RS-005-001829
RS-005-001835
Foundation
383
RS-005-001828
RS-005-001828
Foundation
384
RS-005-001827
RS-005-001827
Foundation
385
RS-005-001539
RS-005-001682
Foundation
386
RS-005-001535
RS-005-001538
Foundation
387
RS-005-000331
RS-005-000332
Foundation
388
RS-005-000330
RS-005-000330
Foundation
389
RS-004-000628
RS-004-000637
Relevance, foundation
390
RS-003-000011
RS-003-000011
Foundation
391
RS-003-000001
RS-003-000010
Foundation
392
RS-00219385 RS-00219386
Foundation, hearsay
393
RS-00219002 RS-00219004
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
394
RS-00218209 RS-00218222
Relevance, foundation.
hearsay
395
RS-00217963 RS-00217967
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
396
RS-00215837 RS-00215841
Relevance, foundation
397
RS-00209075 RS-00209108
Relevance, foundation
398
RS-00205371 RS-00205399
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
57
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
399
RS-00205221 RS-00205342
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
400
RS-00205155 RS-00205162
Relevance, foundation
401
RS-00205153 RS-00205154
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
402
RS-00204837 RS-00204838
Foundation
403
RS-00204834 RS-00204834
Foundation
404
RS-00204710 RS-00204711
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
405
RS-00204640 RS-00204653
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
406
RS-00204613 RS-00204615
Foundation, hearsay
407
RS-00204599 RS-00204601
Foundation
408
RS-00204595 RS-00204596
Foundation, hearsay
409
RS-002-000154 RS-002-000161
Foundation
410
RS-002-000001 RS-002-000153
Foundation
411
RS-00182497 RS-00182500
Relevance, foundation
412
RS-00181348 RS-00181358
Foundation
413
RS-00181161 RS-00181232
Relevance, foundation
414
RS-00180954 RS-00180955
Foundation
415
RS-00180854 RS-00180854
Foundation
416
RS-00180318 RS-00180320
Relevance, foundation
417
RS-00180168 RS-00180182
Relevance, foundation
418
RS-00180105 RS-00180126
Foundation
58
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
419
RS-00179900 RS-00179978
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
420
RS-00179580 RS-00179602
Relevance, foundation
421
RS-00179572 RS-00179572
Relevance, foundation
422
RS-00179473 RS-00179477
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, duplicative of
Exhibit 423
423
RS-00179473 RS-00179477
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
424
RS-00179466 RS-00179468
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
425
RS-00179003 RS-00179005
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
426
RS-00178932 RS-00178932
Relevance, foundation
427
RS-00178848 RS-00178848
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
428
RS-00178837 RS-00178838
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
429
RS-00178813 RS-00178813
Foundation, hearsay,
incomplete
430
RS-00178806 RS-00178807
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
431
RS-00178795 RS-00178795
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
432
RS-00178758 RS-00178765
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
433
RS-00177261 RS-00177263
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
434
RS-00177197 RS-00177198
Relevance, foundation
59
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
435
RS-00177185 RS-00177186
Relevance, foundation
436
RS-00177183 RS-00177183
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
437
RS-00177161 RS-00177165
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
438
RS-00177128 RS-00177129
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
439
RS-00177123 RS-00177123
Foundation, hearsay
440
RS-00177097 RS-00177100
Relevance, foundation
441
RS-00177083 RS-00177096
Relevance, foundation
442
RS-00176873 RS-00176873
Foundation, hearsay
443
RS-00176184 RS-00176205
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
444
RS-00176098 RS-000176100
Relevance, foundation
445
RS-00176095 RS-00176097
Foundation
446
RS-00175803 RS-00175833
Foundation
447
RS-00175777 RS-00175779
Foundation
448
RS-00175706 RS-00175709
Foundation
449
RS-00175640 RS-00175640
Foundation
450
RS-00175531 RS-00175562
Relevance, foundation
451
RS-00102641 RS-00102680
Foundation
452
RS-00102447 RS-00102448
Foundation
453
RS-00102407 RS-00102408
Foundation
454
RS-00101974 RS-00101974
Foundation, hearsay
60
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
455
RS-00101942 RS-00101942
Foundation
456
RS-00101392 RS-00101392
Foundation
457
RS-00101379 RS-00101380
Foundation
458
RS-00101334 RS-00101335
Foundation, hearsay
459
RS-00101332 RS-00101333
Foundation, hearsay
460
RS-00101246 RS-00101246
Foundation
461
RS-00101200 RS-00101203
Foundation, hearsay
462
RS-00101195 RS-00101195
Foundation, hearsay
463
RS-00101192 RS-00101192
Foundation
464
RS-00101185 RS-00101185
Foundation, hearsay
465
RS-001-006381 RS-001-006381
Foundation
466
RS-001-006254 RS-001-006254
Foundation
467
RS-001-006134 RS-001-006134
Foundation
468
RS-001-004068 RS-001-004074
Foundation
469
RS-001-001896 RS-001-001897
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
470
RS-00099539 RS-00099540
Foundation
471
RS-00099417 RS-00099417
Foundation
472
RS-00099406 RS-00099408
Foundation, hearsay
473
RS-00099376 RS-00099389
Foundation, hearsay
474
RS-00099141 RS-00099143
Foundation, hearsay
475
RS-00099047 RS-00099048
Foundation, hearsay
61
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
476
RS-00098946 RS-00095947
Document
unidentifiable from the
bates range provided,
all objections reserved
477
RS-00098895 RS-00098896
Foundation
478
RS-00098573 RS-00098573
Foundation
479
RS-00098531 RS-00098543
Relevance, foundation
480
RS-00098289 RS-00098289
Foundation
481
RS-00098288 RS-00098288
Foundation
482
RS-00098261 RS-00098261
Foundation, hearsay
483
RS-00098159 RS-00098161
Relevance, foundation
484
RS-00097581 RS-00097582
Relevance, foundation
485
RS-00097346 RS-00097351
Foundation
486
RS-00097309 RS-00097313
Foundation
487
RS-00096902 RS-00096902
Relevance, foundation,
duplicative of Exhibit
489, incomplete
488
RS-00096899 RS-00096901
Relevance, foundation,
duplicative of Exhibit
489, incomplete
489
RS-00096899 RS-00096902
Relevance, foundation
490
RS-00096594 RS-00096594
Foundation, duplicative
of Exhibit 491
491
RS-00096590 RS-00096594
Foundation, hearsay
492
RS-00096330 RS-00096330
Relevance, foundation
493
RS-00096329 RS-00096329
Foundation
62
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
494
RS-00095885 RS-00095886
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
495
RS-00095753 RS-00095753
Foundation
496
RS-00095739 RS-00095741
Foundation, hearsay
497
RS-00095530 RS-00095531
Foundation
498
RS-00095516 RS-00095517
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
499
RS-00095464 RS-00095465
Foundation, hearsay,
duplicative of Exhibit
500
500
RS-00095464 RS-00095465
Foundation, hearsay
501
RS-00095124 RS-00095125
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, duplicative of
Exhibit 502
502
RS-00095115 RS-00095125
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
503
RS-00095109 RS-00095114
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
504
RS-00094935 RS-00094935
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, duplicative of
Exhibit 505,
505
RS-00094935 RS-00094935
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
506
RS-00094924 RS-00094925
Foundation, hearsay
507
RS-00094832 RS-00094832
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
508
RS-00094822 RS-00094822
Foundation
509
RS-00094605 RS-00094606
Relevance, foundation
63
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
510
RS-00094585 RS-00094586
Foundation
511
RS-00094526 RS-00094526
Foundation
512
RS-00094512 RS-00094512
Foundation
513
RS-00094342 RS-00094346
Foundation
514
RS-00094236 RS-00094247
Foundation
515
RS-00094194 RS-00094195
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
516
RS-00092969 RS-00092972
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
517
RS-00092827 RS-00092828
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, incomplete
518
RS-00092805 RS-00092806
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
519
RS-00092658 RS-00092662
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
520
RS-00092462 RS-00092462
Foundation
521
RS-00092421 RS-00092421
Foundation
522
RS-00092377 RS-00092378
Foundation, hearsay
523
RS-00092164 RS-00092165
Foundation, hearsay
524
RS-00092139 RS-00092158
Foundation, hearsay
525
RS-00092133 RS-00092136
Foundation, hearsay
526
RS-00092110 RS-00092114
Foundation, hearsay
527
RS-00092076 RS-00092076
Foundation, hearsay
528
RS-00092006 RS-00092008
Foundation
64
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
529
RS-00091943 RS-00091944
Foundation, duplicative
of Exhibit 530
530
RS-00091940 RS-00091944
Foundation, hearsay
531
RS-00091925 RS-00091939
Foundation, duplicative
of Exhibit 532
532
RS-00091922 RS-00091939
Foundation, hearsay
533
RS-00091917 RS-00091921
Foundation, hearsay
534
RS-00091899 RS-00091916
Foundation
535
RS-00091734 RS-00091736
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
536
RS-00089765 RS-00089765
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
537
RS-00089723 RS-00089724
Foundation
538
RS-00088422 RS-00088423
Foundation
539
RS-00088271 RS-00088279
Relevance, foundation
hearsay
540
RS-00088251 RS-00088270
Foundation hearsay
541
RS-00087757 RS-00087759
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
542
RS-00087696 RS-00087697
Foundation, hearsay
543
RS-00087650 RS-00087653
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
544
RS-00087632 RS-00087649
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
545
RS-00087574 RS-00087574
Foundation
546
RS-00087551 RS-00087553
Foundation, hearsay
65
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
547
RS-00087527 RS-00087528
Foundation, hearsay
548
RS-00087434 RS-00087435
Foundation
549
RS-00087430 RS-00087433
Foundation
550
RS-00087344 RS-00087357
Foundation
551
RS-00087330 RS-00087343
Foundation
552
RS-00087320 RS-00087322
Foundation, hearsay
553
RS-00083739 RS-00083739
Foundation
554
RS-00083735 RS-00083735
Foundation
555
RS-00083712 RS-00083712
Relevance, foundation
556
RS-00083420 RS-00083420
Foundation
557
RS-00083391 RS-00083394
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
558
RS-00083372 RS-00083372
Foundation
559
RS-00083343 RS-00083344
Relevance, foundation
hearsay, unfairly
prejudicial
560
RS-00083320 RS-00083321
Foundation
561
RS-00083219 RS-00083219
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
562
RS-00083116 RS-00083116
Foundation
563
RS-00083106 RS-00083106
Foundation
564
RS-00083078 RS-00083078
Relevance, foundation
565
RS-00083042 RS-00083042
Foundation
566
RS-00082936 RS-00082936
Foundation
66
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
567
RS-00082867 RS-00082868
Foundation
568
RS-00082855 RS-00082858
Foundation
569
RS-00082799 RS-00082800
Relevance, foundation
570
RS-00082708 RS-00082710
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, unfairly
prejudicial
571
RS-00082609 RS-00082629
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay, unfairly
prejudicial
572
RS-00082607 RS-00082608
Relevance, foundation,
unfairly prejudicial
573
RS-00082605 RS-00082605
Relevance, foundation
574
RS-00082591 RS-00082592
Relevance, foundation
575
RS-00082564 RS-00082565
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
576
RS-00082504 RS-00082505
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
577
RS-00082499 RS-00082499
Foundation
578
RS-00082473 RS-00082474
Foundation
579
RS-00081643 RS-00081661
Foundation
580
RS-00081507 RS-00081509
Foundation
581
RS-00081500 RS-00081501
Foundation
582
RS-00081488 RS-00081490
Relevance, foundation
583
RS-00079529 RS-00079564
Relevance, foundation
584
RS-00079395 RS-00079395
Foundation
585
RS-00079392 RS-00079394
Foundation
67
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
586
RS-00079363 RS-00079377
Foundation
587
RS-00079362 RS-00079362
Foundation
588
RS-00079344 RS-00079345
Foundation
589
RS-00079338 RS-00079338
Foundation
590
RS-00078997 RS-00078997
Relevance, foundation,
unfairly prejudicial
591
RS-00077657 RS-00077657
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
592
RS-00077654 RS-00077656
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
593
RS-00077651 RS-00077653
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
594
RS-00076981 RS-00076982
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
595
RS-00076581 RS-00076582
Relevance, foundation
hearsay
596
RS-00075662 RS-00075667
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
597
RS-00075651 RS-00075653
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
598
RS-00075590 RS-00075593
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
599
RS-00074875 RS-00074876
Foundation, hearsay
600
RS-00074322 RS-00074330
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
601
RS-00037840 RS-00037842
Foundation, hearsay
602
RS-00037659 RS-00037660
Foundation, hearsay
68
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
603
RS-00037572 RS-00037572
Foundation
604
RS-00037528 RS-00037530
Relevance, foundation,
hearsay
605
RS-00036926 RS-00036927
Foundation, hearsay
606
RS-00036883 RS-00036884
Foundation, hearsay
607
RS-00036592 RS-00036592
Foundation, hearsay
608
RS-00036559 RS-00036559
Foundation, hearsay
609
RS-00035721 RS-00035721
Foundation, hearsay
610
RS-00035684 RS-00035685
Foundation, hearsay
611
RS-00035644 RS-00035647
Foundation, hearsay
612
RS-00035614 RS-00035616
Foundation, hearsay
613
RS-00035555 RS-00035556
Foundation, hearsay
614
RS-00035473 RS-00035474
Foundation, hearsay
615
RS-00035457 RS-00035457
Foundation, hearsay
616
RS-00033851 RS-00033864
Foundation
617
RS-00033272 RS-00033283
Relevance, foundation
618
RS-00033157 RS-00033169
Foundation
619
RS-00029286 RS-00029286
Relevance, foundation
620
RS-00028534 RS-00028573
Foundation
621
RS-00022729 RS-00022743
Foundation
622
RS-00022269 RS-0002227
Foundation
623
RS-00022091 RS-00022093
Foundation
624
RS-00021802 RS-00021810
Foundation
69
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
625
RS-00021799 RS-00021800
Foundation, hearsay,
duplicative of Exhibit
626
626
RS-00021799 RS-00021800
Foundation, hearsay
627
RS-00021759 RS-00021759
Foundation, duplicative
of Exhibit 628
628
RS-00021759 RS-00021759
Foundation
629
RS-00021703 RS-00021704
Foundation, hearsay
630
RS-00021682 RS-00021683
Foundation
631
RS-00021674 RS-0021675
Foundation
632
RS-00021658 RS-00021659
Foundation
633
RS-00019545 RS-00019547
Foundation, hearsay
634
RS-00019497 RS-00019497
Foundation
635
RS-00019400 RS-00019400
Foundation
636
RS-00019341 RS-00019349
Foundation
637
RS-00018968 RS-00018970
Foundation
638
RS-00018507 RS-00018509
Foundation
639
RS-00018429 RS-00018429
Foundation
640
RS-00018205 RS-00018239
Foundation
641
RS-00017634 RS-00017640
Foundation
642
RS-00014979 RS-00014979
Foundation, hearsay
643
RS-00014908 RS-00014908
Foundation
644
RS-00014823 RS-00014823
Foundation
645
RS-00014625 RS-00014629
Foundation
70
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
646
RS-00013689 RS-00013696
Foundation
647
RS-00012447 RS-00012458
Foundation
648
RS-00011997 RS-00012024
Foundation
649
RS-00011979 RS-00011995
Relevance, foundation
650
RS-00010848 RS-00010850
Foundation
651
RS-00008653 RS-00008666
Relevance, foundation
652
RS-00008551 RS-00008551
Foundation
653
RS-00006572 RS-00006572
Foundation
654
RS-00005604 RS-00005606
Foundation
655
RS-00002738 RS-00002746
Foundation
656
Expert Report of James E. Malackowski
No objection
657
Supplemental Expert Report of James E. Malackowski
No objection
658
Exhibit 1 to Supplemental Expert Report of James E.
Malackowski
No objection
659
Exhibit 2 to Supplemental Expert Report of James E.
Malackowski
No objection
660
Exhibit 3 to Supplemental Expert Report of James E.
Malackowski
No objection
661
Exhibit 4 to Supplemental Expert Report of James E.
Malackowski
No objection
662
Exhibit 5 to Supplemental Expert Report of James E.
Malackowski
No objection
663
Exhibit 6 to Supplemental Expert Report of James E.
Malackowski
No objection
664
Exhibit 7 to Supplemental Expert Report of James E.
Malackowski
No objection
665
Exhibit 8 to Supplemental Expert Report of James E.
Malackowski
No objection
71
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
666
Exhibit 9 to Supplemental Expert Report of James E.
Malackowski
No objection
667
Exhibit 10 to Supplemental Expert Report of James E.
Malackowski
No objection
668
Exhibit 11 to Supplemental Expert Report of James E.
Malackowski
No objection
669
Expert Report of Michael J. Wagner
Foundation
670
Tab 1 to Expert Report of Michael J. Wagner
Foundation
671
Tab 2 to Expert Report of Michael J. Wagner
Foundation
672
Tab 3 to Expert Report of Michael J. Wagner
Foundation
673
Tab 4 to Expert Report of Michael J. Wagner
Foundation
674
SEC Form S-1 8/10/2009
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
675
SEC Form 10-Q 9/30/2009
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
676
SEC Form 10-Q 3/31/2005
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
677
SEC Form 10-Q 6/30/2005
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
678
SEC Form 10-Q 9/30/2005
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
679
SEC Form 10-Q 3/31/2006
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
72
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
680
SEC Form 10-Q 6/30/2006
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
681
SEC Form 10-Q 9/30/2006
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
682
SEC Form 10-Q 3/31/2007
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
683
SEC Form 10-Q 6/30/2007
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
684
SEC Form 10-Q 9/30/2007
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
685
SEC Form 10-Q 3/31/2008
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
686
SEC Form 10-Q 6/30/2008
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
687
SEC Form 10-Q 9/30/2008
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
688
SEC Form 10-Q 3/31/2009
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
689
SEC Form 10-Q 6/30/2009
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
690
SEC Form 10-Q 9/30/2009
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
73
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
691
SEC Form 10-K 12/31/2004
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
692
SEC Form 10-K 12/31/2005
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
693
SEC Form 10-K 12/31/2006
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
694
SEC Form 10-K 12/31/2007
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
695
SEC Form 10-K 12/31/2008
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
696
Google 2008 Annual Report
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
697
Google Initiating at Outperform and $145 Target
9/28/2004
Not produced, all
objections reserved
698
Citigroup Google Heady Revenue Growth Expected
Not produced, all
objections reserved
699
Prudential Equity Group Rearch for Google Inc. 9/7/2004
Not produced, all
objections reserved
700
CIBC World Markets Google Inc. Equity Research
9/13/2004
Not produced, all
objections reserved
701
Google Named World's No1 Brand
Not produced, all
objections reserved
702
2004 Monthly Financial Information
Not produced, all
objections reserved
703
RBC Capital Markets
Not produced, all
objections reserved
74
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
704
Google AdWords Help AdWords Auction
Not produced, all
objections reserved
705
Google AdWords Help Benefits of AdWords
Not produced, all
objections reserved
706
Google Unveils Nexus One Superphone
Not produced, all
objections reserved
707
Nexus One Phone Demo
Not produced, all
objections reserved
708
Bear Sterns Research Analysis 12/19/2005
Not produced, all
objections reserved
709
Yahoo! To Launch New Search Marketing Ranking
Model in U.S. on Feb. 5
Not produced, all
objections reserved
710
Cantor Fitzgerald Equity Research 1/24/2007 for Yahoo!
Not produced, all
objections reserved
711
RBC Capital Markets Equity Research 5/5/2008 Yahoo
Not produced, all
objections reserved
712
Adwords P&L
Not produced, all
objections reserved
713
Jefferies & Company Equity Research 9/12/2008
Not produced, all
objections reserved
714
Bear Sterns Research Analysis 9/22/2004
Not produced, all
objections reserved
715
Credit Suisse Research Analysis 11/20/2007
Not produced, all
objections reserved
716
DataMonitor Research Analysis 12/2007
Not produced, all
objections reserved
717
Google Tops, But Yahoo Switch Success So Far
Not produced, all
objections reserved
718
Nielsen NetRatings Search Engine Ratings
Not produced, all
objections reserved
75
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
719
comScore Media Metrix Search Engine Ratings
Not produced, all
objections reserved
720
Hitwise Search Engine Ratings
Not produced, all
objections reserved
721
Top Search Providers for August 2009
Not produced, all
objections reserved
722
Google's Gains Continue in comScore's October 2008
Not produced, all
objections reserved
Rankings
723
RBC Capital Markets Research Analysis 1/11/2005
Not produced, all
objections reserved
724
Oppenheimer Equity Research 1/12/2006
Not produced, all
objections reserved
725
DataMonitor Research Analysis 1/2007
Not produced, all
objections reserved
726
Branded Term Conversion
Not produced, all
objections reserved
727
Q&A with Google's VP of Marketing
Not produced, all
objections reserved
728
Wired Googlenomics Explained
Not produced, all
objections reserved
729
UBS Investment Research 11/4/2004
Not produced, all
objections reserved
730
Deutsche Bank Equity Research 7/10/2008
Not produced, all
objections reserved
731
Thomson StreetEvents Equity Research 1/31/2008
Not produced, all
objections reserved
732
Morgan Stanley Equity Research 2/1/2008
Not produced, all
objections reserved
76
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
733
ThinkEquity Partner Equity Research 10/23/2007
Not produced, all
objections reserved
734
Soliel Equity Research Yahoo! 8/2/2009
Not produced, all
objections reserved
735
Thomson StreetEvents Equity Research 7/29/2009
Yahoo!
Not produced, all
objections reserved
736
US DTC Data
Not produced, all
objections reserved
737
Product P&L FY2008 Wuarterly
Not produced, all
objections reserved
738
US DTC Data 2005-2009 Breakout
Not produced, all
objections reserved
739
TM Counterfeit AdWords Help
Not produced, all
objections reserved
740
Exhibit 9 to Wagner Deposition
Foundation
741
Exhibit 29 to Eichmann Deposition
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
742
Exhibit 1 to Duehring Deposition
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
743
Declaration of Christina Aguiar
Foundation, hearsay
744
FlowChart of Google Campaign Data Classification &
Damages Analysis
Not produced, all
objections reserved
745
Expert Report of Edward A. Blair
Foundation
746
RBC Capital Markets Company Update for Google Inc.
Exhibit 50 to Malackowski Deposition
Relevance, foundation
747
Exhibit 11 to Chen Deposition
Foundation
77
Google
Exhibit
Document Description
Rosetta Stone
Objections
748
Exhibit 4 To Chiang Deposition
Foundation
749
Exhibit 30 to Eichmann Deposition
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
750
Exhibit 1 to Alferness Deposition
Foundation
751
Exhibit 6 to Wagner Deposition
Foundation
752
Exhibit 1 to Stanley Thomas Deposition
No objection
753
Exhibit 2 to Liere Deposition
Relevance, foundation
754
Exhibit 10 To Leigh Deposition
Foundation
755
Exhibit 13 to Ramsey Deposition
Relevance, foundation,
unfairly prejudicial
756
Exhibit 14 To Ramsey Deposition
Relevance, foundation,
unfairly prejudicial
757
Exhibit 8 To Ramsey Deposition
Relevance, foundation
758
Exhibit 14 To Leigh Deposition
Foundation
759
Exhibit 8 To Nowaczyk Deposition
No objection to
relevant excerpts, if
any
78
Respectfully submitted,
April 9, 2010
Of Counsel:
Mitchell S. Ettinger
(Pro hac vice)
Clifford M. Sloan
(Pro hac vice)
Jennifer L. Spaziano
(Pro hac vice)
Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom, LLP
1440 New York Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20005-2111
/s/
Warren T. Allen II
Virginia Bar Number 72691
Attorney for Plaintiff Rosetta Stone Ltd.
Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom, LLP
1440 New York Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20005-2111
(202) 371-7000
(202) 393-5760
wtallen@skadden.com
79
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on April 9, 2010 I will electronically file the foregoing with the
Clerk of the Court using the CM/ECF system which will then send a notification of such filing
(NEF) to the following:
Jonathan D. Frieden
ODIN, FELDMAN & PETTLEMAN, P.C.
9302 Lee Highway, Suite 1100
Fairfax, VA 22031
jonathan.frieden@ofplaw.com
Counsel for Defendant, Google Inc.
April 9, 2010
Date
/s/
Warren T. Allen II (Va. Bar No. 72691)
Attorney for Rosetta Stone Ltd.
Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP
1440 New York Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20005-2111
Telephone: (202) 371-7000
Facsimile: (202) 393-5760
Warren.Allen@skadden.com
]]>
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
