XVP Sports, LLC v. Bangs

Filing 24

OPINION and ORDER adopting and approving the findings and recommendations set forth in the Report of the United States Magistrate Judge, as supplemented by this Order; granting defendant Gary Bangs' motion for summary judgment. Signed by District Judge Mark S. Davis and filed on 9/17/12. (mwin, )

FILED
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

I

1 ccp 17 2012

FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF VIRGINP*
Norfolk Division
XVP SPORTS,

'

i

i
=„.~T nrw irt
CLERK USDISIHlU COURT

LLC,

Plaintiff,
v.

CIVIL ACTION NO.

2:llcv379

GARY BANGS,
Defendant.

OPINION AND ORDER

This

matter

("Plaintiff"

Magistrate

is

or

before

"XVP")

Judge's

the

Court

objections

Report

defendant Gary Bangs

considering

the

to

and

recommending that this Court grant

on

XVP

the

LLC's

United

States

Recommendation

("R&R")

summary judgment in favor of

("Defendant" or "Bangs").

Magistrate

Sports

Judge's

After carefully

thorough

R&R

and

the

objections thereto, this Court conducted a de novo review as to
all proposed findings and recommendations that were objected to
by Plaintiff.

Having completed such

adopts and approves
in

the

R&R,

findings and

supplemented

as

the

by

review,

this

Court

hereby

recommendations set

this

Order.

Accordingly,

forth
the

Court GRANTS Defendant's motion for summary judgment.
I.

On

September

president
firearms

of

XVP,

license

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

14,

2009,

submitted
("FFL")

to

Tim

Donaldson

XVP's
the

("Donaldson"),

application
United

for

States

a

the

federal

government's