I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al
Filing
606
Response to 206 MOTION to Seal Portions Of Google Inc.s Brief In Support Of Motion To Compel And Various Exhibits To The Declaration Of Jen Ghaussy in Support Thereof Notice of Filing Response to Agreed Order to Maintain Portions of Documents Under Seal filed by AOL Inc., Gannett Company, Inc., Google Inc., IAC Search & Media, Inc., Target Corporation. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit H (Undreacted, Public Form), # 2 Exhibit I (Unredacted, Public Form), # 3 Exhibit L (Unredacted, Public Form), # 4 Exhibit M (Unredacted, Public Form), # 5 Exhibit N (Unredacted, Public Form), # 6 Exhibit P (Unredacted, Public Form), # 7 Exhibit Q (Unredacted, Public Form), # 8 Exhibit R (Unredacted, Public Form), # 9 Exhibit S (Undredacted, Public Form), # 10 Exhibit T (Unredacted, Public Form), # 11 Exhibit U (Unredacted, Public Form))(Noona, Stephen)
<![CDATA[
(;+,%,71
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
1
6/22/2011
IP00016361
IP00016365
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
2
6/6/2011
IP00016366
IP00016370
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
3
6/22/2011
IP00016371
IP00016373
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
4
6/24/2011
IP00016374
IP00016382
9
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
5
6/22/2011
IP00016383
IP00016387
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
6
6/22/2011
IP00016388
IP00016392
5
7
6/21/2011
IP00017428
IP00017444
17
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
8
6/22/2011
IP00017462
IP00017479
18
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
To:
Description
Basis
Draft Agreement between Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP and Consultant related to legal
support services. This document was prepared
in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Agreement between Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP and Consultant related to legal
support services. This document was prepared
in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Agreement between Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP and Consultant related to legal
support services. This document was prepared
in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Agreement between Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP and Consultant related to legal
support services. This document was prepared
in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Agreement between Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP and Consultant related to legal
support services. This document was prepared
in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Agreement between Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP and Consultant related to legal
support services. This document was prepared
in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Draft Retainer Agreement Letter from Counsel
Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs,
Inc. reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s
seeking of legal services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Letter Agreement from Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs, Inc.
reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s seeking of
legal services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Page 1 of 149
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
9
6/22/2011
IP00017480
IP00017497
18
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
10
6/22/2011
IP00017498
IP00017515
18
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
11
6/22/2011
IP00017516
IP00017534
19
12
6/7/2011
IP00017535
IP00017536
2
13
6/15/2011
IP00017537
IP00017550
14
14
6/13/2011
IP00017551
IP00017565
15
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
Description
Basis
Draft Letter Agreement from Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs, Inc.
reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s seeking of
legal services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Letter communication from Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs, Inc.
reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s seeking of
legal services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Draft Letter Agreement from Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs, Inc.
reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s seeking of
legal services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Draft schedule reflecting legal services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Letter Agreement from Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs, Inc.
reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s seeking of
legal services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Gary M.
Hoffman)
Draft Letter Agreement from Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs, Inc.
reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s seeking of
legal services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Page 2 of 149
To:
Smart Search
Labs, Inc.
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
15
6/15/2011
IP00017583
IP00017597
15
16
6/13/2011
IP00017598
IP00017608
17
6/17/2011
IP00017609
18
6/22/2011
19
20
Description
Basis
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Draft Letter Agreement from Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs, Inc.
reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s seeking of
legal services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
11
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Draft Letter Agreement from Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs, Inc.
reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s seeking of
legal services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
IP00017621
13
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Draft Letter Agreement from Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs, Inc.
reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s seeking of
legal services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
IP00017622
IP00017640
19
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Draft Letter Agreement from Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs, Inc.
reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s seeking of
legal services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
6/6/2011
IP00017641
IP00017642
2
IP00017643
IP00017662
20
Draft schedule reflecting legal services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Letter Agreement from Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs, Inc.
reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s seeking of
legal services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
6/21/2011
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
Page 3 of 149
To:
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
21
6/15/2011
IP00017663
IP00017678
16
22
6/17/2011
IP00017679
IP00017697
23
6/12/2011
IP00017698
24
6/12/2011
25
Description
Basis
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Draft Letter Agreement from Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs, Inc.
reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s seeking of
legal services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
19
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Draft Letter Agreement from Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs, Inc.
reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s seeking of
legal services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
IP00017710
13
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Gary M.
Hoffman)
Draft Letter Agreement from Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs, Inc.
reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s seeking of
legal services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
IP00017711
IP00017726
16
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Gary M.
Hoffman)
Draft Letter Agreement from Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs, Inc.
reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s seeking of
legal services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
1/1/1970
IP00017727
IP00017731
5
6/9/2011
IP00017732
IP00017733
2
27
6/10/2011
IP00017734
IP00017734
1
28
6/10/2011
IP00017735
IP00017738
4
Draft schedule reflecting legal services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft schedule reflecting legal services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft schedule reflecting legal services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft schedule reflecting legal services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
26
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
Page 4 of 149
To:
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
29
6/21/2011
IP00017739
IP00017759
21
30
6/10/2011
IP00017760
IP00017763
4
31
6/12/2011
IP00017764
IP00017774
11
32
6/9/2011
IP00017775
IP00017778
4
33
6/13/2011
IP00017779
IP00017789
11
34
6/10/2011
IP00017790
IP00017793
4
35
6/6/2011
IP00017794
IP00017795
2
36
6/20/2011
IP00017796
IP00017814
19
37
6/12/2011
IP00017815
IP00017825
11
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Gary M.
Hoffman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Gary M.
Hoffman)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
To:
Description
Basis
Draft Letter Agreement reflecting legal services
from Counsel Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart
Search Labs, Inc. This document was prepared
in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft schedule reflecting legal services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Letter Agreement reflecting legal services
from Counsel Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart
Search Labs, Inc. This document was prepared
in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Draft schedule reflecting legal services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Letter Agreement reflecting legal services
from Counsel Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart
Search Labs, Inc. This document was prepared
in anticipation of litigation.
Draft schedule reflecting legal services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft schedule reflecting legal services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Letter Agreement reflecting legal services
from Counsel Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart
Search Labs, Inc. This document was prepared
in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Letter Agreement reflecting legal services
from Counsel Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart
Search Labs, Inc. This document was prepared
in anticipation of litigation.
Page 5 of 149
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
38
6/15/2011
IP00017826
IP00017839
14
39
6/13/2011
IP00017840
IP00017851
12
40
6/17/2011
IP00017852
IP00017864
13
41
6/1/2011
IP00017869
IP00017871
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Bradely D.
Wine)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Bradely D.
Wine)
42
12/31/2007
IP00017872
IP00017879
8
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Bradely D.
Wine)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Bradely D.
Wine)
43
5/20/2011
IP00017880
IP00017882
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Bradely D.
Wine)
44
9/7/2011
IP00018361
IP00018365
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
To:
Description
Basis
Draft Letter Agreement reflecting legal services
from Counsel Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart
Search Labs, Inc. This document was prepared
in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Letter Agreement reflecting legal services
from Counsel Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart
Search Labs, Inc. This document was prepared
in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Letter Agreement reflecting legal services
from Counsel Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart
Search Labs, Inc. This document was prepared
in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Hudson Bay
Capital
Management LP
(Scott Black)
Letter communication from Counsel Bradely D.
Wine at Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Scott Black at
Hudson Bay Capital Management LP reflecting
Hudson Bay's seeking legal services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Hudson Bay
Letter communication from Counsel Bradely D.
Capital
Wine at Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Yoav Roth at
Management LP Hudson Bay Capital Management LP reflecting
(Yoav Roth)
Hudson Bay's seeking legal services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Engagement Letter from Counsel
Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Hudson Bay Capital
Management LP reflecting Hudson Bay's
seeking of legal services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Page 6 of 149
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product; Common
Interest Privilege
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product; Common
Interest Privilege
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
45
9/1/2011
IP00018371
IP00018376
6
46
9/6/2011
IP00018377
IP00018382
6
47
9/7/2011
IP00018388
IP00018392
5
48
9/1/2011
IP00018393
IP00018398
6
49
9/8/2011
IP00018399
IP00018403
5
50
9/12/2011
IP00018404
IP00018409
6
51
9/8/2011
IP00018410
IP00018414
5
52
9/8/2011
IP00018420
IP00018424
5
53
9/7/2011
IP00018425
IP00018430
6
54
9/9/2011
IP00018436
IP00018440
5
55
9/9/2011
IP00018441
IP00018446
6
56
9/9/2011
IP00018447
IP00018452
6
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
To:
Description
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Page 7 of 149
Basis
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
57
9/12/2011
IP00018453
IP00018458
6
58
9/9/2011
IP00018459
IP00018463
5
59
9/12/2011
IP00018464
IP00018469
6
60
9/6/2011
IP00018476
IP00018480
5
61
9/6/2011
IP00018481
IP00018486
6
62
9/12/2011
IP00018487
IP00018492
6
63
9/12/2011
IP00018493
IP00018498
6
64
9/6/2011
IP00018499
IP00018505
7
65
8/19/2011
IP00019006
IP00019028
23
66
8/28/2011
IP00019134
IP00019142
9
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
To:
Description
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft regulatory statement reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft PowerPoint presentation reflecting legal
advice and services with respect to enforcing
U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664.
This document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Page 8 of 149
Basis
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
67
9/12/2011
IP00019160
IP00019189
30
68
9/9/2011
IP00019190
IP00019216
27
69
9/9/2011
IP00019217
IP00019243
27
70
9/9/2011
IP00019244
IP00019244
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
71
9/14/2011
IP00019245
IP00019271
27
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
Basis
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Page 9 of 149
Description
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood,
Frank C.
Cimino,
DeAnna Allen,
Charles J.
Monterio, Jr.,
Jonathan
Falkler)
To:
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
72
8/1/2011
IP00019272
IP00019298
27
73
9/13/2011
IP00019299
IP00019325
27
74
9/9/2011
IP00019326
IP00019352
27
75
8/29/2011
IP00019354
IP00019380
27
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood,
Frank C.
Cimino,
DeAnna Allen,
Charles J.
Monterio, Jr.,
Jonathan
Falkler)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
Description
Basis
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Page 10 of 149
To:
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
76
9/13/2011
IP00019381
IP00019407
27
77
8/21/2011
IP00019408
IP00019433
26
78
9/14/2011
IP00019434
IP00019460
27
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood,
Frank C.
Cimino,
DeAnna Allen,
Charles J.
Monterio, Jr.,
Jonathan
Falkler)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood,
Frank C.
Cimino,
DeAnna Allen,
Charles J.
Monterio, Jr.,
Jonathan
Falkler)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
Description
Basis
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Page 11 of 149
To:
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
79
9/13/2011
IP00019461
IP00019487
27
80
9/9/2011
IP00019488
IP00019515
28
81
8/29/2011
IP00019516
IP00019546
31
82
9/9/2011
IP00019547
IP00019573
27
83
8/25/2011
IP00019626
IP00019626
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood,
Frank C.
Cimino,
DeAnna Allen,
Charles J.
Monterio, Jr.,
Jonathan
Falkler)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
Description
Basis
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Letter Agreement between I/P Engine,
Inc., Dickstein Shapiro LLP, and Consultant
related to legal support services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Page 12 of 149
To:
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
84
8/18/2011
IP00019642
IP00019647
6
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(DeAnna Allen)
85
8/18/2011
IP00019648
IP00019652
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
86
8/18/2011
IP00019653
IP00019658
6
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
87
6/10/2011
IP00019797
IP00019820
24
88
6/15/2011
IP00019821
IP00019826
6
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
89
6/13/2011
IP00019827
IP00019851
25
90
6/15/2011
IP00019852
IP00019857
6
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
To:
Description
Draft Letter Agreement between I/P Engine,
Inc., Dickstein Shapiro LLP, and Consultant
related to legal support services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Letter Agreement between I/P Engine,
Inc., Dickstein Shapiro LLP, and Consultant
related to legal support services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Letter Agreement between I/P Engine,
Inc., Dickstein Shapiro LLP, and Consultant
related to legal support services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Basis
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Page 13 of 149
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
91
6/15/2011
IP00019858
IP00019863
6
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
92
6/15/2011
IP00019890
IP00019916
27
93
6/15/2011
IP00019942
IP00019945
4
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
94
6/15/2011
IP00019946
IP00019972
27
95
6/15/2011
IP00019973
IP00019977
5
96
6/12/2011
IP00019978
IP00020002
25
97
6/10/2011
IP00020003
IP00020007
5
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
To:
Description
Basis
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Page 14 of 149
Attorney Work Product
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Attorney Work Product
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
98
6/12/2011
IP00020008
IP00020012
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
99
6/9/2011
IP00020013
IP00020015
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
100
6/12/2011
IP00020016
IP00020040
25
101
6/15/2011
IP00020041
IP00020045
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
102
6/13/2011
IP00020046
IP00020048
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
103
6/12/2011
IP00020049
IP00020076
28
104
6/15/2011
IP00020077
IP00020103
27
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
To:
Description
Basis
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Page 15 of 149
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
105
6/16/2011
IP00020104
IP00020131
28
106
6/10/2011
IP00020132
IP00020135
4
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
107
6/15/2011
IP00020136
IP00020141
6
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
108
6/15/2011
IP00020142
IP00020168
27
109
6/12/2011
IP00020169
IP00020192
24
110
6/15/2011
IP00020193
IP00020197
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
111
6/15/2011
IP00020198
IP00020201
4
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
To:
Description
Basis
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Page 16 of 149
Attorney Work Product
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
112
6/15/2011
IP00020202
IP00020206
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
113
6/8/2011
IP00020207
IP00020229
23
114
6/10/2011
IP00020230
IP00020253
24
115
6/14/2011
IP00020254
IP00020256
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
116
6/15/2011
IP00020257
IP00020285
29
117
6/15/2011
IP00020286
IP00020314
29
118
6/15/2011
IP00020315
IP00020321
7
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
To:
Description
Basis
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Page 17 of 149
Attorney Work Product
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
119
6/15/2011
IP00020322
IP00020350
29
120
6/6/2011
IP00020351
IP00020372
22
121
6/15/2011
IP00020373
IP00020398
26
122
6/10/2011
IP00020399
IP00020424
26
123
6/6/2011
IP00020425
IP00020446
22
124
6/13/2011
IP00020447
IP00020449
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
125
6/12/2011
IP00020450
IP00020474
25
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
To:
Description
Basis
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Page 18 of 149
Attorney Work Product
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
126
6/15/2011
IP00020475
IP00020478
4
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
127
6/13/2011
IP00020479
IP00020481
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
128
5/16/2011
IP00020490
IP00020494
5
129
6/16/2011
IP00020495
IP00020499
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
130
5/16/2011
IP00020500
IP00020504
5
131
5/16/2011
IP00020505
IP00020511
7
132
8/25/2011
IP00021574
IP00021575
2
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
From:
To:
Description
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Agreement between Hudson Bay Master Fund
Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Basis
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product;
Common Interest
Privilege
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Agreement between Hudson Bay Master
Fund Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Draft Letter of Intent from Hudson Bay Master
Fund, Ltd. to Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Smart Search
Labs, Inc. (Ken
Lang)
Page 19 of 149
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Letter communication from Counsel Jon D.
Grossman at Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Ken
Lang at Smart Search Labs, Inc. reflecting legal
services.
Attorney Work Product
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
133
8/19/2011
IP00022573
IP00022585
13
134
8/22/2011
IP00022586
IP00022601
16
135
8/21/2011
IP00022602
IP00022616
15
136
9/14/2011
IP00022618
IP00022620
3
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
137
9/14/2011
IP00022621
IP00022623
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
138
9/14/2011
IP00022624
IP00022625
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
139
9/14/2011
IP00022626
IP00022628
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
To:
Description
Basis
Draft regulatory statement reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft regulatory statement reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft regulatory statement reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft press release with respect to enforcing
U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664
reflecting legal services and advice. This
document was prepared in conjunction with
Counsel Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft press document with respect to enforcing
U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664
reflecting legal services and advice. This
document was prepared in conjunction with
Counsel Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft press release with respect to enforcing
U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664
reflecting legal services and advice. This
document was prepared in conjunction with
Counsel Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft press document with respect to enforcing
U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664
reflecting legal services and advice. This
document was prepared in conjunction with
Counsel Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Page 20 of 149
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
140
5/25/2011
IP00025032
IP00025034
3
141
7/19/2011
IP00028929
IP00028936
8
142
9/10/2011
IP00029021
IP00029024
4
143
9/7/2011
IP00029274
IP00029278
5
144
9/1/2011
IP00029284
IP00029289
6
145
9/6/2011
IP00029290
IP00029295
6
146
9/7/2011
IP00029301
IP00029305
5
147
9/1/2011
IP00029306
IP00029311
6
148
9/8/2011
IP00029312
IP00029316
5
149
9/12/2011
IP00029317
IP00029322
6
150
9/8/2011
IP00029323
IP00029327
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
and Alexander
Berger
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Michael E.
Zolandz and
Peter G.
Feldman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
Description
Basis
Draft document reflecting legal advice and
services with respect to enforcing U.S. Patent
Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This document
was prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Letter Agreement between I/P Engine,
Inc., Dickstein Shapiro LLP, and Consultant
related to legal support services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Page 21 of 149
To:
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
151
9/8/2011
IP00029333
IP00029337
5
152
9/7/2011
IP00029338
IP00029343
6
153
9/9/2011
IP00029349
IP00029353
5
154
9/9/2011
IP00029354
IP00029359
6
155
9/9/2011
IP00029360
IP00029365
6
156
9/12/2011
IP00029366
IP00029371
6
157
9/9/2011
IP00029372
IP00029376
5
158
9/6/2011
IP00029389
IP00029393
5
159
9/6/2011
IP00029394
IP00029399
6
160
9/12/2011
IP00029400
IP00029405
6
161
9/6/2011
IP00029412
IP00029418
7
162
9/14/2011
IP00029438
IP00029449
12
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
To:
Description
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft regulatory statement reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Page 22 of 149
Basis
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
163
8/28/2011
IP00030336
IP00030349
14
164
9/10/2011
IP00031341
IP00031344
4
165
9/12/2011
IP00034572
IP00034601
30
166
9/9/2011
IP00034602
IP00034628
27
167
9/9/2011
IP00034629
IP00034655
27
168
9/9/2011
IP00034656
IP00034656
1
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
169
9/14/2011
IP00034657
IP00034683
27
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
To:
Description
Basis
Draft regulatory statement reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Executive Summary reflecting legal
services and advice. This document was
prepared in furtherance of litigation.
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Page 23 of 149
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Sherwood,
Cimino, Allen,
Monterio,
Falkler)
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
170
8/1/2011
IP00034684
IP00034710
27
171
9/13/2011
IP00034711
IP00034737
27
172
9/9/2011
IP00034738
IP00034764
27
173
8/29/2011
IP00034766
IP00034792
27
174
9/13/2011
IP00034793
IP00034819
27
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Sherwood,
Cimino, Allen,
Monterio,
Falkler)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Sherwood,
Cimino, Allen,
Monterio,
Falkler)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Sherwood,
Cimino, Allen,
Monterio,
Falkler)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
Description
Basis
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Page 24 of 149
To:
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
175
8/21/2011
IP00034820
IP00034845
26
176
9/14/2011
IP00034846
IP00034872
27
177
9/13/2011
IP00034873
IP00034899
27
178
9/9/2011
IP00034900
IP00034927
28
179
8/29/2011
IP00034928
IP00034958
31
180
9/9/2011
IP00034959
IP00034985
27
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Sherwood,
Cimino, Allen,
Monterio,
Falkler)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Sherwood,
Cimino, Allen,
Monterio,
Falkler)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
Description
Basis
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Page 25 of 149
To:
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
181
8/28/2011
IP00035014
IP00035022
9
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
182
8/29/2011
IP00035023
IP00035053
31
183
9/9/2011
IP00035054
IP00035080
27
184
8/21/2011
IP00035081
IP00035106
26
185
8/29/2011
IP00035107
IP00035133
27
186
9/9/2011
IP00035134
IP00035161
28
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood and
DeAnna Allen)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
Description
Basis
Draft PowerPoint presentation reflecting legal
advice and services with respect to enforcing
U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664.
This document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Complaint reflecting legal services with
respect to enforcing U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420
and 6,775,664. This document was prepared
by Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Page 26 of 149
To:
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
187
6/1/2011
IP00037053
IP00037055
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Bradely D.
Wine)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Bradely D.
Wine)
Hudson Bay
Capital
Management LP
(Scott Black)
188
8/2/2011
IP00037056
IP00037063
8
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Bradely D.
Wine)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Bradely D.
Wine)
189
5/20/2011
IP00037064
IP00037066
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Bradely D.
Wine)
190
7/19/2011
IP00037255
IP00037262
8
191
7/19/2011
IP00037263
IP00037270
8
192
8/18/2011
IP00037465
IP00037470
6
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Michael E.
Zolandz and
Peter G.
Feldman)
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Michael E.
Zolandz and
Peter G.
Feldman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(DeAnna Allen)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Description
Letter communication from Counsel Bradely D.
Wine at Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Scott Black at
Hudson Bay Capital Management LP reflecting
Hudson Bay's seeking legal services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Hudson Bay
Letter communication from Counsel Bradely D.
Capital
Wine at Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Yoav Roth at
Management LP Hudson Bay Capital Management LP reflecting
(Yoav Roth)
Hudson Bay's seeking legal services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Engagement Letter from Counsel
Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Hudson Bay Capital
Management LP reflecting Hudson Bay's
seeking of legal services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Counsel SNR Labrador Search Letter from Counsel Michael E. Zolandz and
Denton US LLP
Corporation
Peter G. Feldman at SNR Denton US LLP to
(Michael E.
(Alexander R. Alexander R. Berger at Labrador Search
Zolandz and
Berger)
Corporation reflecting legal services. This
Peter G.
document was prepared in anticipation of
Feldman)
litigation.
Counsel SNR Labrador Search Letter from Counsel Michael E. Zolandz and
Denton US LLP
Corporation
Peter G. Feldman at SNR Denton US LLP to
(Michael E.
(Alexander R. Alexander R. Berger at Labrador Search
Zolandz and
Berger)
Corporation reflecting legal services. This
Peter G.
document was prepared in anticipation of
Feldman)
litigation.
Draft agreement between I/P Engine and
Consultant with respect to enforcing U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Page 27 of 149
Basis
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product; Common
Interest Privilege
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product; Common
Interest Privilege
Attorney Work Product
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product; Common
Interest Privilege
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product; Common
Interest Privilege
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
193
8/18/2011
IP00037471
IP00037475
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
194
8/18/2011
IP00037476
IP00037481
6
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
195
6/22/2011
IP00037896
IP00037900
5
196
6/6/2011
IP00037901
IP00037905
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
197
6/22/2011
IP00037906
IP00037908
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
198
6/24/2011
IP00037909
IP00037917
9
199
6/22/2011
IP00037918
IP00037922
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
200
6/22/2011
IP00037923
IP00037927
5
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
Basis
Attorney Work Product
Draft Agreement between Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP and Consultant related to legal
support services. This document was prepared
in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Agreement between Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP and Consultant related to legal
support services. This document was prepared
in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Agreement between Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP and Consultant related to legal
support services. This document was prepared
in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Draft Agreement between Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP and Consultant related to legal
support services. This document was prepared
in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Agreement between Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP and Consultant related to legal
support services. This document was prepared
in anticipation of litigation.
Page 28 of 149
Description
Draft agreement between I/P Engine and
Consultant with respect to enforcing U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft agreement between I/P Engine and
Consultant with respect to enforcing U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Agreement between Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP and Consultant related to legal
support services. This document was prepared
in anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
To:
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
201
8/19/2011
IP00038012
IP00038024
13
202
8/22/2011
IP00038025
IP00038040
16
203
8/21/2011
IP00038041
IP00038055
15
204
8/2/2011
IP00041889
IP00041891
3
205
6/15/2011
IP00041945
IP00041950
6
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
206
6/15/2011
IP00041976
IP00041981
6
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
207
6/15/2011
IP00041982
IP00041987
6
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
To:
Description
Basis
Draft regulatory statement reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft regulatory statement reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Smart Search
Labs, Inc. (Ken
Lang)
Attorney Work Product
Draft regulatory statement reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney-Client
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Page 29 of 149
Letter communication from Counsel Jon D.
Grossman at Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Ken
Lang at Smart Search Labs, Inc. reflecting legal
services.
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
208
6/15/2011
IP00042066
IP00042069
4
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
209
6/15/2011
IP00042097
IP00042101
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
210
6/10/2011
IP00042127
IP00042131
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
211
6/12/2011
IP00042132
IP00042136
5
212
6/9/2011
IP00042137
IP00042139
213
6/15/2011
IP00042165
214
6/13/2011
IP00042170
Description
Basis
Draft Letter Agreement from Smart Search Lab,
Inc. to Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Draft Letter Agreement from Smart Search Lab,
Inc. to Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Draft Agreement between Smart Search Labs,
Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and Lycos,
Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S. Patent
Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This document
was prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Draft Agreement between Smart Search Labs,
Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and Lycos,
Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S. Patent
Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This document
was prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Draft Agreement between Smart Search Labs,
Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and Lycos,
Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S. Patent
Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This document
was prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
IP00042169
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Attorney Work Product
IP00042172
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Draft Letter Agreement from Smart Search Lab,
Inc. to Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
Page 30 of 149
To:
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
215
6/10/2011
IP00042256
IP00042259
4
216
6/15/2011
IP00042260
IP00042265
217
6/15/2011
IP00042317
218
5/16/2011
219
Description
Basis
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Draft Agreement between Smart Search Labs,
Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and Lycos,
Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S. Patent
Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This document
was prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
6
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Attorney Work Product
IP00042321
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
IP00042614
IP00042618
5
6/16/2011
IP00042619
IP00042623
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Draft Letter Agreement between Smart Search
Labs, Inc., Hudson Bay Master Fund, Ltd. and
Lycos, Inc. related to the enforcement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Letter Agreement from Smart Search Lab,
Inc. to Lycos, Inc. reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Agreement between Hudson Bay Master Fund
Ltd. and Lycos, Inc. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
220
8/25/2011
IP00042636
IP00042637
2
221
6/21/2011
IP00042638
IP00042654
17
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
From:
Smart Search
Labs, Inc.
(Alexander R.
Berger)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
To:
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product;
Common Interest
Privilege
Lycos, Inc. (Mark Letter Agreement from Alexander R. Berger at
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Blais)
Smart Search Lab, Inc. to Mark Blais at Lycos,
Work Product; Common
Inc. reflecting legal advice and services. This
Interest Privilege
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Smart Search Letter communication from Counsel Jon D.
Attorney-Client
Labs, Inc. (Ken Grossman at Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Ken
Lang)
Lang at Smart Search Labs, Inc. reflecting legal
services.
Draft letter agreement between Dickstein
Shapiro LLP and Smart Search Labs, Inc. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Page 31 of 149
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
222
6/22/2011
IP00042672
IP00042689
18
223
6/22/2011
IP00042690
IP00042707
18
224
6/22/2011
IP00042708
IP00042725
18
225
6/22/2011
IP00042726
IP00042744
19
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
226
6/7/2011
IP00042745
IP00042746
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
227
6/15/2011
IP00042747
IP00042760
14
228
6/13/2011
IP00042761
IP00042775
15
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Gary M.
Hoffman)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Letter communication from Counsel Jon D.
Grossman at Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart
Search Labs, Inc. reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Draft Retainer Agreement Letter from Counsel
Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs,
Inc. reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s
seeking of legal services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
Draft letter agreement between Dickstein
Shapiro LLP and Smart Search Labs, Inc. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Letter communication from Counsel
Jeffrey K. Sherwood at Dickstein Shapiro LLP
to Smart Search Labs, Inc. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Retainer Agreement Letter from Counsel
Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs,
Inc. reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s
seeking of legal services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Page 32 of 149
Basis
Draft letter agreement between Dickstein
Shapiro LLP and Smart Search Labs, Inc. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Smart Search
Labs, Inc.
Description
Draft letter agreement between Dickstein
Shapiro LLP and Smart Search Labs, Inc. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon D.
Grossman)
To:
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
229
6/17/2011
IP00042776
IP00042792
17
230
6/15/2011
IP00042793
IP00042807
15
231
6/13/2011
IP00042808
IP00042818
11
232
6/17/2011
IP00042819
IP00042831
13
233
6/22/2011
IP00042832
IP00042850
19
234
6/6/2011
IP00042851
IP00042852
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
235
6/21/2011
IP00042853
IP00042872
20
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
To:
Description
Draft Letter communication from Counsel
Jeffrey K. Sherwood at Dickstein Shapiro LLP
to Smart Search Labs, Inc. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Letter communication from Counsel
Jeffrey K. Sherwood at Dickstein Shapiro LLP
to Smart Search Labs, Inc. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Letter communication from Counsel
Jeffrey K. Sherwood at Dickstein Shapiro LLP
to Smart Search Labs, Inc. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Letter communication from Counsel
Jeffrey K. Sherwood at Dickstein Shapiro LLP
to Smart Search Labs, Inc. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Letter communication from Counsel
Jeffrey K. Sherwood at Dickstein Shapiro LLP
to Smart Search Labs, Inc. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Letter communication from Counsel
Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs,
Inc. reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Letter communication from Counsel
Jeffrey K. Sherwood at Dickstein Shapiro LLP
to Smart Search Labs, Inc. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Page 33 of 149
Basis
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
236
6/15/2011
IP00042873
IP00042888
16
237
6/17/2011
IP00042889
IP00042907
19
238
6/12/2011
IP00042908
IP00042920
13
239
6/12/2011
IP00042921
IP00042936
16
240
5/1/2011
IP00042937
IP00042941
5
241
6/9/2011
IP00042942
IP00042943
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Gary M.
Hoffman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Gary M.
Hoffman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
242
6/10/2011
IP00042944
IP00042944
1
243
6/10/2011
IP00042945
IP00042948
4
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
Page 34 of 149
Description
Basis
Draft Letter communication from Counsel
Jeffrey K. Sherwood at Dickstein Shapiro LLP
to Smart Search Labs, Inc. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Letter communication from Counsel
Jeffrey K. Sherwood at Dickstein Shapiro LLP
to Smart Search Labs, Inc. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft Letter communication from Counsel Gary
M. Hoffman at Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart
Search Labs, Inc. reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Draft Letter communication from Counsel Gary
M. Hoffman at Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart
Search Labs, Inc. reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Draft schedule reflecting legal services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft communication from Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs, Inc.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft schedule reflecting legal services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft schedule reflecting legal services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
To:
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
244
6/21/2011
IP00042949
IP00042969
21
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Draft Retainer Agreement Letter from Counsel
Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs,
Inc. reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s
seeking of legal services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
245
6/10/2011
IP00042970
IP00042973
4
6/12/2011
IP00042974
IP00042984
11
247
6/9/2011
IP00042985
IP00042988
4
248
6/13/2011
IP00042989
IP00042999
11
249
6/10/2011
IP00043000
IP00043003
4
250
6/6/2011
IP00043004
IP00043005
2
251
6/20/2011
IP00043006
IP00043024
19
Draft schedule reflecting legal services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Letter communication from Counsel Gary
M. Hoffman at Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart
Search Labs, Inc. reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Draft schedule reflecting legal services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Letter communication from Counsel
Jeffrey K. Sherwood at Dickstein Shapiro LLP
to Smart Search Labs, Inc. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft schedule reflecting legal services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft letter agreement between Dickstein
Shapiro LLP and Smart Search Labs, Inc. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Draft Retainer Agreement Letter from Counsel
Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs,
Inc. reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s
seeking of legal services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
246
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Gary M.
Hoffman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Page 35 of 149
To:
Description
Basis
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
252
6/12/2011
IP00043025
IP00043035
11
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Gary M.
Hoffman)
Draft Retainer Agreement Letter from Counsel
Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs,
Inc. reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s
seeking of legal services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
253
6/15/2011
IP00043036
IP00043049
14
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Draft Retainer Agreement Letter from Counsel
Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs,
Inc. reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s
seeking of legal services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
254
6/13/2011
IP00043050
IP00043061
12
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Draft Retainer Agreement Letter from Counsel
Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs,
Inc. reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s
seeking of legal services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
255
6/17/2011
IP00043062
IP00043074
13
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey K.
Sherwood)
Draft Retainer Agreement Letter from Counsel
Dickstein Shapiro LLP to Smart Search Labs,
Inc. reflecting Smart Search Labs, Inc.'s
seeking of legal services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
256
8/19/2011
IP00043279
IP00043301
23
Draft regulatory statement reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney Work Product
257
9/14/2011
IP00043392
IP00043392
1
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Draft press release with respect to enforcing
U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664
reflecting legal services and advice. This
document was prepared in conjunction with
Counsel Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney Work Product
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
Page 36 of 149
To:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
258
9/14/2011
IP00043393
IP00043395
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
259
9/14/2011
IP00043396
IP00043398
3
260
9/14/2011
IP00043399
IP00043400
2
261
9/14/2011
IP00043401
IP00043403
3
262
6/10/2011
IP00043527
IP00043527
1
263
5/22/2011
IP00043567
IP00043568
2
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
To:
Description
Draft press release with respect to enforcing
U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664
reflecting legal services and advice. This
document was prepared in conjunction with
Counsel Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Counsel
Draft press document with respect to enforcing
Dickstein
U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664
Shapiro LLP
reflecting legal services and advice. This
document was prepared in conjunction with
Counsel Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Counsel
Draft press release with respect to enforcing
Dickstein
U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664
Shapiro LLP
reflecting legal services and advice. This
document was prepared in conjunction with
Counsel Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
Counsel
Draft press document with respect to enforcing
Dickstein
U.S. Patent Nos. 6,314,420 and 6,775,664
Shapiro LLP
reflecting legal services and advice. This
document was prepared in conjunction with
Counsel Dickstein Shapiro LLP in anticipation of
litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Counsel Jeffrey Sherwood reflecting legal
(Jeffrey
advice and services. This document was
Sherwood)
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Mark Hogge;
Shailendra
Maheshwari)
Page 37 of 149
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Mark Hogge, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Basis
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney Work Product
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
264
6/23/2011
IP00043624
IP00043624
1
265
6/23/2011
IP00043625
IP00043629
5
266
6/23/2011
IP00043630
IP00043636
7
267
6/9/2011
IP00043657
IP00043657
1
268
6/9/2011
IP00043658
IP00043660
3
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Description
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Hudson Bay
Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
Capital GP LLC
Grossman &
(Counsel Scott
Schole LLP
Black); cc: I/P
(Barry
Engine, Inc.
Grossman)
(Yoav Roth)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Hudson Bay
Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
Capital GP LLC
Grossman &
(Counsel Scott
Schole LLP
Black); cc: I/P
(Barry
Engine, Inc.
Grossman)
(Yoav Roth)
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger); cc:
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP Counsel Dickstein
(Jon Grossman)
(Jon
Shapiro LLP
Grossman)
(Jeffrey
Sherwood;
Bradley Wine)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Scott Black, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00043657 from
Counsel Jon Grossman to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood;
Bradley Wine)
Page 38 of 149
Basis
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00043624 from Alex Work Product; Common
Berger to Counsel Scott Black, et al. reflecting
Interest
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00043624 from Alex Work Product; Common
Berger to Counsel Scott Black, et al. reflecting
Interest
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
269
6/9/2011
IP00043681
IP00043681
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Levi)
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
270
6/9/2011
IP00043682
IP00043684
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Levi)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Levi)
271
5/9/2011
IP00043806
IP00043808
3
272
5/9/2011
IP00043809
IP00043814
6
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Shapiro LLP
Grossman;
(Jon Grossman)
Jonathan Levi; cc:
Frank Cimino;
Bradley Wine)
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00043806 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
273
7/19/2011
IP00043815
IP00043817
3
Counsel
Counsel
Schulte Roth & Schulte Roth &
Zabel LLP
Zabel LLP
(Brett Director) (Brett Director)
Email communication from Counsel Brett
Director to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00043681 from
Counsel Jon Grossman to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
Grossman;
advice and services. This document was
Jonathan Levi; cc: prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Frank Cimino;
Bradley Wine)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Page 39 of 149
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
274
6/23/2011
IP00043818
IP00043826
9
275
6/23/2011
IP00043827
IP00043835
276
7/19/2011
IP00043836
277
7/19/2011
278
279
To:
Description
Basis
Counsel
Counsel
Schulte Roth & Schulte Roth &
Zabel LLP (Lyle
Zabel LLP
Stein)
(Brett Director)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00043815 from
Counsel Brett Director to Alex Berger reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
9
Counsel
Counsel
Schulte Roth & Schulte Roth &
Zabel LLP (Lyle
Zabel LLP
Stein)
(Brett Director)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00043815 from
Counsel Brett Director to Alex Berger reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
IP00043842
7
Counsel
Schulte Roth &
Zabel LLP
(Brett Director)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00043815 from
Counsel Brett Director to Alex Berger reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
IP00043843
IP00043855
13
Counsel
Schulte Roth &
Zabel LLP
(Brett Director)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00043815 from
Counsel Brett Director to Alex Berger reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
6/12/2011
IP00043860
IP00043861
2
6/10/2011
IP00043862
IP00043886
25
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Counsel Bradley Wine reflecting legal advice
(Bradley Wine) and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
attachment of Document IP00043860 from Alex
Work Product
Shapiro LLP
(Bradley Wine) Berger to Counsel Bradley Wine reflecting legal
(Jon Grossman)
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Page 40 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
280
6/10/2011
IP00043887
IP00043912
26
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
(Bradley Wine)
(Jon Grossman)
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00043860 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Bradley Wine reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
281
6/13/2011
IP00043934
IP00043935
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
282
6/13/2011
IP00043936
IP00043960
25
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Levi)
283
6/15/2011
IP00043962
IP00043963
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
284
6/15/2011
IP00043964
IP00043964
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
285
6/3/2011
IP00043965
IP00043967
3
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
286
6/3/2011
IP00043968
IP00044264
297
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan
Falkler)
From:
To:
Description
Basis
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00043934 from
Work Product
Counsel Jon Grossman to Alex Berger
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Attorney-Client
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Attorney-Client
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00043962 from
Work Product
Counsel Jon Grossman to Alex Berger
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Counsel SNR Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
Denton US LLP Counsel Shailendra Maheshwari reflecting legal
(Shailendra
advice and services. This document was
Maheshwari)
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Counsel SNR Document communicated as an attachment of
Work Product; Common
Denton US LLP Document IP00043965 from Alex Berger to
Counsel Shailendra Maheshwari reflecting legal
Interest
(Shailendra
advice and services. This document was
Maheshwari)
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Page 41 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
287
6/3/2011
IP00044265
IP00044278
14
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan
Falkler)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Shailendra
Maheshwari)
288
6/3/2011
IP00044279
IP00044280
2
289
7/20/2011
IP00044300
IP00044301
2
290
5/6/2011
IP00044303
IP00044304
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) (Yoav Roth); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Levi)
291
5/6/2011
IP00044305
IP00044308
4
292
5/6/2011
IP00044309
IP00044314
6
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) (Yoav Roth); cc: attachment of Document IP00044303 from Alex
Work Product
Shapiro LLP
Counsel Dickstein Berger to Counsel Jonathan Levi, et al.
(Jonathan Levi)
Shapiro LLP
reflecting legal advice and services. This
(Jonathan Levi) document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) (Yoav Roth); cc: attachment of Document IP00044303 from Alex
Work Product
Shapiro LLP
Counsel Dickstein Berger to Counsel Jonathan Levi, et al.
(Jonathan Levi)
Shapiro LLP
reflecting legal advice and services. This
(Jonathan Levi) document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Description
Basis
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00043965 from Alex Work Product; Common
Berger to Counsel Shailendra Maheshwari
Interest
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Counsel SNR Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Denton US LLP attachment of Document IP00043965 from Alex Work Product; Common
Shapiro LLP
(Shailendra
Berger to Counsel Shailendra Maheshwari
Interest
(Charles
Maheshwari)
reflecting legal advice and services. This
Monterio)
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client; Attorney
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Counsel Jeffrey Sherwood reflecting legal
Work Product
(Jeffrey
advice and services. This document was
Sherwood)
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Page 42 of 149
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jonathan Levi, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
293
6/22/2011
IP00044325
IP00044325
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
294
6/22/2011
IP00044326
IP00044343
18
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
295
6/21/2011
IP00044348
IP00044348
1
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00044325 from
Counsel Jon Grossman to Alex Berger
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Counsel
Counsel
Counsel Ellenoff Email communication from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
Schulte Roth & Schulte Roth &
Grossman &
advice and services. This document was
Zabel LLP
Zabel LLP
Schole LLP
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
(Clara Zylberg) (Clara Zylberg)
(Benjamin
Reichel; Edwin
Opoku); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Alex
Berger); Counsel
Schulte Roth &
Zabel LLP
(Eleazer Klein;
Brett Director;
Adriana Schwartz;
Lyle Stein)
Page 43 of 149
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product; Common
Interest
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
296
6/21/2011
IP00044349
IP00044366
18
Counsel
Counsel Ellenoff
Schulte Roth &
Grossman &
Zabel LLP
Schole LLP
(Clara Zylberg)
(Benjamin
Reichel; Edwin
Opoku); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Alex
Berger); Counsel
Schulte Roth &
Zabel LLP
(Eleazer Klein;
Brett Director;
Adriana Schwartz;
Lyle Stein)
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00044348 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
297
6/21/2011
IP00044367
IP00044382
16
Counsel
Counsel Ellenoff
Schulte Roth &
Grossman &
Zabel LLP
Schole LLP
(Clara Zylberg)
(Benjamin
Reichel; Edwin
Opoku); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Alex
Berger); Counsel
Schulte Roth &
Zabel LLP
(Eleazer Klein;
Brett Director;
Adriana Schwartz;
Lyle Stein)
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00044348 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Page 44 of 149
To:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
298
6/21/2011
IP00044383
IP00044386
4
Counsel
Counsel Ellenoff
Schulte Roth &
Grossman &
Zabel LLP
Schole LLP
(Clara Zylberg)
(Benjamin
Reichel; Edwin
Opoku); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Alex
Berger); Counsel
Schulte Roth &
Zabel LLP
(Eleazer Klein;
Brett Director;
Adriana Schwartz;
Lyle Stein)
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00044348 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
299
6/21/2011
IP00044387
IP00044424
38
Counsel
Counsel Ellenoff
Schulte Roth &
Grossman &
Zabel LLP
Schole LLP
(Clara Zylberg)
(Benjamin
Reichel; Edwin
Opoku); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Alex
Berger); Counsel
Schulte Roth &
Zabel LLP
(Eleazer Klein;
Brett Director;
Adriana Schwartz;
Lyle Stein)
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00044348 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Page 45 of 149
To:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
300
6/21/2011
IP00044425
IP00044462
38
Counsel
Counsel Ellenoff
Schulte Roth &
Grossman &
Zabel LLP
Schole LLP
(Clara Zylberg)
(Benjamin
Reichel; Edwin
Opoku); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Alex
Berger); Counsel
Schulte Roth &
Zabel LLP
(Eleazer Klein;
Brett Director;
Adriana Schwartz;
Lyle Stein)
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00044348 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
301
6/21/2011
IP00044463
IP00044472
10
Counsel
Counsel Ellenoff
Schulte Roth &
Grossman &
Zabel LLP
Schole LLP
(Clara Zylberg)
(Benjamin
Reichel; Edwin
Opoku); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Alex
Berger); Counsel
Schulte Roth &
Zabel LLP
(Eleazer Klein;
Brett Director;
Adriana Schwartz;
Lyle Stein)
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00044348 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Page 46 of 149
To:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
302
5/5/2011
IP00044473
IP00044473
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Levi;
cc: Bradley Wine;
Frank Cimino)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jonathan Levi, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
303
6/10/2011
IP00044474
IP00044474
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman;
Jonathan Levi)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
304
6/10/2011
IP00044475
IP00044498
24
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Shapiro LLP
Grossman;
(Jon Grossman)
Jonathan Levi)
305
6/16/2011
IP00044514
IP00044514
1
306
6/16/2011
IP00044515
IP00044516
2
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00044474 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Benjamin Reichel, et al. reflecting legal
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
advice and services. This document was
Schole LLP
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
(Benjamin
Reichel; Barry
Grossman); I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Ken
Lang)
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00044515 from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Counsel Benjamin Reichel, et al. reflecting legal
Schole LLP
advice and services. This document was
(Benjamin
Reichel; Barry prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Grossman); I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Ken
Lang)
Page 47 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
307
6/17/2011
IP00044517
IP00044517
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Schulte
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director);
cc: I/P Engine,
Inc. (Yoav Roth)
308
6/16/2011
IP00044518
IP00044519
2
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Schulte
(Alex Berger) Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director);
cc: I/P Engine,
Inc. (Yoav Roth)
309
6/15/2011
IP00044700
IP00044700
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
310
6/15/2011
IP00044701
IP00044705
5
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
311
6/14/2011
IP00044749
IP00044749
1
312
5/16/2011
IP00044750
IP00044754
5
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting legal advice
Grossman)
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon attachment of Document IP00044749 from Alex
Work Product
Shapiro LLP
Grossman)
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting
(Jon Grossman)
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
313
5/16/2011
IP00044755
IP00044761
7
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Shapiro LLP
Grossman)
(Jon Grossman)
Page 48 of 149
Description
Basis
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Brett Director, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00044517 from Alex Berger to
Counsel Brett Director, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client; Common
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Interest
Counsel Scott Black reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00044700 from Alex Work Product; Common
Berger to Counsel Scott Black reflecting legal
Interest
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00044749 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
314
6/12/2011
IP00044762
IP00044762
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman);
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
315
5/16/2011
IP00044763
IP00044767
5
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Shapiro LLP
Grossman);
(Jon Grossman)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00044762 from Alex Work Product; Common
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman, et al.
Interest
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
316
5/16/2011
IP00044768
IP00044773
6
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Shapiro LLP
Grossman);
(Jon Grossman)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00044762 from Alex Work Product; Common
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman, et al.
Interest
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
317
6/12/2011
IP00044774
IP00044778
5
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Shapiro LLP
Grossman);
(Jon Grossman)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00044762 from Alex Work Product; Common
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman, et al.
Interest
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
318
6/21/2011
IP00044780
IP00044780
1
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Barry
Grossman)
From:
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Barry
Grossman)
To:
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Page 49 of 149
Description
Email communication from Counsel Barry
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Basis
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
319
6/13/2011
IP00044834
IP00044834
1
320
6/13/2011
IP00044835
IP00044859
25
321
6/20/2011
IP00044896
IP00044896
1
322
6/14/2011
IP00044970
IP00044971
2
323
6/14/2011
IP00044974
IP00044974
1
324
6/14/2011
IP00044975
IP00044977
3
325
6/14/2011
IP00044978
IP00044982
5
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting legal advice
Grossman)
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon attachment of Document IP00044834 from Alex
Work Product
Shapiro LLP
Grossman)
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting
(Jonathan Levi)
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
(Jeffrey
Sherwood)
Sherwood)
Hudson Bay
Hudson Bay
I/P Engine, Inc.
Capital GP LLC Capital GP LLC
(Alex Berger)
(Counsel Scott (Counsel Scott
Black)
Black)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman)
Email communication from Counsel Jeffrey
Sherwood to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Shapiro LLP
Grossman)
(Jonathan Levi)
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00044974 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon attachment of Document IP00044974 from Alex
Work Product
Shapiro LLP
Grossman)
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting
(Jonathan Levi)
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Page 50 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
326
6/14/2011
IP00044983
IP00044984
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
327
6/22/2011
IP00044994
IP00044994
1
328
6/22/2011
IP00044995
IP00044999
329
6/22/2011
IP00045000
330
6/21/2011
331
332
To:
Description
Basis
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
Counsel
Counsel
Ellenoff
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Grossman &
Schole LLP
Schole LLP
(Edwin Opoku) (Edwin Opoku)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Edwin
Opoku to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Levi)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Edwin Opoku)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00044994 from
Counsel Edwin Opoku to Alex Berger reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product; Common
Interest
IP00045006
7
Richardson and
Patel
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Edwin Opoku)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00044994 from
Counsel Edwin Opoku to Alex Berger reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
IP00045050
IP00045052
3
6/21/2011
IP00045053
IP00045054
2
6/18/2011
IP00045058
IP00045059
2
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Hudson Bay
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Interest
Capital GP LLC Counsel Scott Black reflecting legal advice and
(Counsel Scott services. This document was prepared in
Black)
anticipation of litigation.
Counsel SNR Counsel SNR
I/P Engine, Inc. Email communication from Counsel Shailendra
Attorney-Client
Denton US LLP Denton US LLP (Alex Berger; cc: Maheshwari to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
(Shailendra
(Shailendra
Ken Lang)
legal advice and services. This document was
Maheshwari)
Maheshwari)
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
Hudson Bay
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott (Counsel Scott
Black)
Black)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Page 51 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
333
6/18/2011
IP00045060
IP00045061
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Shailendra Maheshwari, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
334
6/13/2011
IP00045062
IP00045063
2
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Shailendra Maheshwari, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
335
6/13/2011
IP00045064
IP00045066
3
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Shailendra
Maheshwari)
Email communication from Counsel Shailendra
Maheshwari to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
336
6/12/2011
IP00045067
IP00045067
1
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Shailendra
Maheshwari)
Email communication from Counsel Shailendra
Maheshwari to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Shailendra
Maheshwari); cc:
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Ken Lang)
I/P Engine, Inc.
Counsel SNR
(Alex Berger)
Denton US LLP
(Shailendra
Maheshwari);
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth)
Counsel SNR
I/P Engine, Inc.
Denton US LLP (Alex Berger; cc:
(Shailendra
Yoav Roth);
Maheshwari)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Counsel SNR
I/P Engine, Inc.
Denton US LLP (Alex Berger; cc:
(Shailendra
Yoav Roth); cc:
Maheshwari)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Page 52 of 149
Description
Basis
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
337
6/22/2011
IP00045080
IP00045081
2
338
6/22/2011
IP00045082
IP00045099
18
339
6/22/2011
IP00045100
IP00045103
4
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Schulte Roth & Schulte Roth &
(Alex Berger);
Zabel LLP
Zabel LLP
Counsel Schulte
(Clara Zylberg) (Clara Zylberg) Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director;
Adriana
Schwartz); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Benjamin
Reichel)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Schulte Roth &
(Alex Berger);
Zabel LLP
Counsel Schulte
(Clara Zylberg) Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director;
Adriana
Schwartz); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Benjamin
Reichel)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Schulte Roth &
(Alex Berger);
Zabel LLP
Counsel Schulte
(Clara Zylberg) Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director;
Adriana
Schwartz); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Benjamin
Reichel)
Page 53 of 149
Description
Basis
Email communication from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00045080 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00045080 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
340
6/22/2011
IP00045104
IP00045141
38
341
6/22/2011
IP00045142
IP00045151
10
342
6/22/2011
IP00045152
IP00045189
38
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Schulte Roth &
(Alex Berger);
Zabel LLP
Counsel Schulte
(Clara Zylberg) Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director;
Adriana
Schwartz); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Benjamin
Reichel)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Schulte Roth &
(Alex Berger);
Zabel LLP
Counsel Schulte
(Clara Zylberg) Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director;
Adriana
Schwartz); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Benjamin
Reichel)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Schulte Roth &
(Alex Berger);
Zabel LLP
Counsel Schulte
(Clara Zylberg) Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director;
Adriana
Schwartz); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Benjamin
Reichel)
Page 54 of 149
Description
Basis
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00045080 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00045080 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00045080 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
343
6/22/2011
IP00045190
IP00045205
16
344
6/22/2011
IP00045206
IP00045234
29
345
7/1/2011
IP00045237
IP00045239
3
346
6/9/2011
IP00045240
IP00045241
2
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Schulte Roth &
(Alex Berger);
Zabel LLP
Counsel Schulte
(Clara Zylberg) Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director;
Adriana
Schwartz); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Benjamin
Reichel)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Schulte Roth &
(Alex Berger);
Zabel LLP
Counsel Schulte
(Clara Zylberg) Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director;
Adriana
Schwartz); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Benjamin
Reichel)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
(Bradley Wine) (Bradley Wine)
Page 55 of 149
Description
Basis
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00045080 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00045080 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Counsel Bradley
Wine to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
347
6/9/2011
IP00045242
IP00045243
2
Counsel
Counsel
Dickstein
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
(Bradley Wine) (Bradley Wine)
348
6/10/2011
IP00045275
IP00045276
2
349
6/10/2011
IP00045277
IP00045277
1
350
6/7/2011
IP00045282
IP00045282
1
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
351
6/6/2011
IP00045283
IP00045304
352
5/12/2011
IP00045305
353
6/22/2011
IP00045308
To:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Bradley
Wine to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Hudson Bay
I/P Engine, Inc.
Capital GP LLC
(Alex Berger)
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Hudson Bay
I/P Engine, Inc.
Capital GP LLC
(Alex Berger)
(Counsel Scott
Black)
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman; cc:
Jonathan Levi;
Bradley Wine)
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
22
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Shapiro LLP
Grossman; cc:
(Jon Grossman)
Jonathan Levi;
Bradley Wine)
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00045282 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
IP00045307
3
IP00045308
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Counsel Jonathan Levi reflecting legal advice
(Jonathan Levi) and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Email communication from Counsel Jon
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
and services. This document was prepared in
(Jon Grossman)
(Jon
anticipation of litigation.
Grossman)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Page 56 of 149
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
354
6/12/2011
IP00045312
IP00045312
1
355
5/26/2011
IP00045313
IP00045314
2
356
6/10/2011
IP00045320
IP00045321
2
Counsel
Counsel
Dickstein
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
(Bradley Wine) (Bradley Wine)
357
6/10/2011
IP00045322
IP00045322
1
358
6/10/2011
IP00045323
IP00045324
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting legal advice
Grossman)
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
Grossman; cc: advice and services. This document was
Jeffrey Sherwood; prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Bradley Wine;
Frank Cimino)
359
6/10/2011
IP00045325
IP00045326
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
360
6/10/2011
IP00045327
IP00045328
2
Hudson Bay
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott (Counsel Scott
Black)
Black)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Hudson Bay
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott (Counsel Scott
Black)
Black)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
To:
Description
Basis
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Counsel SNR Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
Denton US LLP Counsel Shailendra Maheshwari reflecting legal
(Shailendra
advice and services. This document was
Maheshwari)
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. Email communication from Counsel Bradley
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
Wine to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Page 57 of 149
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client; Common
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Interest
Counsel Scott Black reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
361
6/11/2011
IP00045344
IP00045345
2
362
6/20/2011
IP00045346
IP00045347
2
363
7/18/2011
IP00045360
IP00045362
3
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Schulte
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director; cc:
Lyle Stein); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Brett Director, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
364
6/27/2011
IP00045373
IP00045374
2
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
365
6/22/2011
IP00045413
IP00045413
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
Hudson Bay
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Capital GP LLC
(Shilpi Shah; cc:
Nadya Frukter;
Counsel Scott
Black) cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Counsel
Counsel
Ellenoff
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Grossman &
Schole LLP
Schole LLP
(Barry
(Barry
Grossman)
Grossman)
Counsel
Counsel
Schulte Roth & Schulte Roth &
Zabel LLP
Zabel LLP
(Brett Director) (Brett Director)
To:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Barry
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Brett
Director to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Page 58 of 149
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Scott Black, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
366
6/22/2011
IP00045414
IP00045417
4
367
6/22/2011
IP00045418
IP00045433
16
368
6/22/2011
IP00045434
IP00045443
10
369
6/22/2011
IP00045444
IP00045481
38
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
To:
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Shilpi Shah; cc:
Nadya Frukter;
Counsel Scott
Black) cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth)
Hudson Bay
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Capital GP LLC
(Shilpi Shah; cc:
Nadya Frukter;
Counsel Scott
Black) cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth)
I/P Engine, Inc.
Hudson Bay
(Alex Berger)
Capital GP LLC
(Shilpi Shah; cc:
Nadya Frukter;
Counsel Scott
Black) cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth)
Hudson Bay
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Capital GP LLC
(Shilpi Shah; cc:
Nadya Frukter;
Counsel Scott
Black) cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth)
Page 59 of 149
Description
Basis
Attorney-Client; Common
Draft legal document communicated as an
Interest
attachment of Document IP00045413 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Scott Black, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Draft legal document communicated as an
Interest
attachment of Document IP00045413 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Scott Black, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Draft legal document communicated as an
Interest
attachment of Document IP00045413 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Scott Black, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Draft legal document communicated as an
Interest
attachment of Document IP00045413 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Scott Black, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
370
6/22/2011
IP00045482
IP00045499
18
371
6/22/2011
IP00045500
IP00045537
38
372
6/22/2011
IP00045538
IP00045566
29
373
6/22/2011
IP00045699
IP00045699
1
374
5/6/2011
IP00045702
IP00045702
1
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
To:
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Shilpi Shah; cc:
Nadya Frukter;
Counsel Scott
Black) cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth)
Hudson Bay
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Capital GP LLC
(Shilpi Shah; cc:
Nadya Frukter;
Counsel Scott
Black) cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth)
I/P Engine, Inc.
Hudson Bay
(Alex Berger)
Capital GP LLC
(Shilpi Shah; cc:
Nadya Frukter;
Counsel Scott
Black) cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman)
Description
Attorney-Client; Common
Draft legal document communicated as an
Interest
attachment of Document IP00045413 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Scott Black, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Draft legal document communicated as an
Interest
attachment of Document IP00045413 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Scott Black, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Draft legal document communicated as an
Interest
attachment of Document IP00045413 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Scott Black, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Counsel Jonathan Levi, et al. reflecting legal
(Jonathan Levi; advice and services. This document was
cc: Jon
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Grossman)
Page 60 of 149
Basis
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
375
7/18/2011
IP00045712
IP00045713
2
376
7/18/2011
IP00045714
IP00045715
2
377
6/14/2011
IP00045726
IP00045727
2
378
6/14/2011
IP00045728
IP00045730
3
379
6/14/2011
IP00045731
IP00045732
2
380
6/12/2011
IP00045733
IP00045735
3
381
6/12/2011
IP00045736
IP00045740
5
382
6/12/2011
IP00045741
IP00045744
4
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Ellenoff
Ellenoff
(Alex Berger);
Grossman &
Grossman &
Counsel Ellenoff
Schole LLP
Schole LLP
Grossman &
(Lawrence
(Lawrence
Schole LLP
Rosenbloom)
Rosenbloom)
(Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
Description
Basis
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Attorney-Client
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting legal advice
Grossman)
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Counsel Bradley Wine reflecting legal advice
(Bradley Wine) and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Hudson Bay
Hudson Bay
I/P Engine, Inc. Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Capital GP LLC Capital GP LLC
(Alex Berger)
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
(Counsel Scott (Counsel Scott
services. This document was prepared in
Black)
Black)
anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Email communication from Counsel Jon
Attorney-Client
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
and services. This document was prepared in
(Jon Grossman)
(Jon
anticipation of litigation.
Grossman)
Page 61 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
383
6/21/2011
IP00045745
IP00045745
1
384
6/12/2011
IP00045746
IP00045747
385
5/6/2011
IP00045748
386
5/10/2011
387
Description
Basis
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP (Barry
Grossman)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Barry Grossman reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
2
Counsel
Counsel
Dickstein
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
(Bradley Wine) (Bradley Wine)
Email communication from Counsel Bradley
Wine to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
IP00045749
2
Attorney-Client
IP00045890
IP00045894
5
5/10/2011
IP00045897
IP00045901
5
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Counsel Bradley Wine reflecting legal advice
(Bradley Wine) and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting legal advice
Grossman)
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
Grossman;
advice and services. This document was
Jonathan Levi) prepared in anticipation of litigation.
388
6/16/2011
IP00045908
IP00045908
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
389
6/10/2011
IP00045909
IP00045912
4
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
To:
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger);
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman;
Jonathan Levi)
Page 62 of 149
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
390
6/10/2011
IP00045913
IP00045915
3
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman;
Jonathan Levi)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
391
6/15/2011
IP00045916
IP00045917
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
392
6/22/2011
IP00045979
IP00045980
2
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman;
Charles Monterio;
cc: Jeffrey
Sherwood)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
393
6/22/2011
IP00045981
IP00045985
5
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Shapiro LLP
Grossman;
(DeAnna Allen)
Charles Monterio;
cc: Jeffrey
Sherwood)
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00045979 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
394
6/22/2011
IP00045986
IP00045993
8
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Shapiro LLP
Grossman;
(DeAnna Allen)
Charles Monterio;
cc: Jeffrey
Sherwood)
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00045979 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Page 63 of 149
To:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
395
6/22/2011
IP00045994
IP00045996
3
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Charles Monterio reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
396
6/17/2011
IP00045997
IP00045997
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman; cc:
Jeffrey Sherwood;
Jeffrey Rhodes)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
397
6/22/2011
IP00045998
IP00045999
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood;
Charles Monterio)
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
398
6/22/2011
IP00046000
IP00046004
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood;
Charles Monterio)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00045998 from
Counsel Jon Grossman to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Page 64 of 149
Description
Basis
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
399
6/22/2011
IP00046005
IP00046006
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger);
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio; cc:
Jeffrey Sherwood)
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
400
6/29/2011
IP00046018
IP00046019
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger; Ken
Lang; Yoav Roth);
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Frank Cimino;
DeAnna Allen;
Charles Monterio;
Jonathan Falkler)
Email communication from Counsel Jeffrey
Sherwood to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
401
7/8/2011
IP00046020
IP00046022
3
Email communication from Counsel Donald
Stout to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
402
6/27/2011
IP00046029
IP00046029
1
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Counsel
Antonelli, Terry, Antonelli, Terry,
(Alex Berger)
Stout, & Kraus, Stout, & Kraus,
LLP (Donald
LLP (Donald
Stout)
Stout)
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger);
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP Counsel Dickstein
(Jonathan
(Jonathan
Shapiro LLP
Falkler)
Falkler)
(Charles
Monterio; cc: Jon
Grossman;
DeAnna Allen)
Email communication from Counsel Jonathan
Falkler to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Page 65 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
403
6/23/2011
IP00046083
IP00046083
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger);
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Falkler;
cc: DeAnna
Allen); cc:
Counsel Schulte
Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director)
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
404
7/16/2011
IP00046110
IP00046113
4
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(DeAnna Allen;
Jeffrey Sherwood;
Frank Cimino;
Charles Monterio;
Jonathan Falkler);
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Ken
Lang); Hudson
Bay Capital GP
LLC (Sander
Gerber)
405
5/25/2011
IP00046118
IP00046118
1
406
5/13/2011
IP00046121
IP00046122
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting legal advice
Grossman)
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Counsel Bradley Wine reflecting legal advice
(Bradley Wine) and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Page 66 of 149
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel DeAnna Allen, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
407
6/22/2011
IP00046148
IP00046150
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood;
Bradley Wine)
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
408
6/22/2011
IP00046151
IP00046151
1
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Barry
Grossman)
Email communication from Counsel Barry
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
409
6/22/2011
IP00046152
IP00046154
3
Attorney-Client
410
6/22/2011
IP00046155
IP00046155
1
Legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00046151 from
Counsel Barry Grossman to Alex Berger
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00046151 from Counsel Barry
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
411
6/22/2011
IP00046159
IP00046161
3
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Barry
Grossman)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Barry
Grossman)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Barry
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman; cc:
Jeffrey Sherwood;
Bradley Wine)
Page 67 of 149
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
412
6/22/2011
IP00046162
IP00046179
18
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Shapiro LLP
Grossman; cc:
(Jon Grossman)
Jeffrey Sherwood;
Bradley Wine)
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00046159 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
413
6/22/2011
IP00046180
IP00046198
19
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Shapiro LLP
Grossman; cc:
(Jon Grossman)
Jeffrey Sherwood;
Bradley Wine)
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00046159 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
414
6/28/2011
IP00046199
IP00046199
1
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
415
6/16/2011
IP00046200
IP00046204
5
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Shapiro LLP
Schole LLP
(Jon Grossman)
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Page 68 of 149
To:
Description
Basis
Attorney-Client
Legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00046199 from Alex Work Product; Common
Berger to Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al.
Interest
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
416
7/7/2011
IP00046205
IP00046205
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel Antonelli,
Terry, Stout, &
Kraus, LLP
(Donald Stout);
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; cc:
Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Falkler)
Email communication from Counsel Charles
Monterio to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
417
7/7/2011
IP00046206
IP00046219
14
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel Antonelli,
Terry, Stout, &
Kraus, LLP
(Donald Stout);
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; cc:
Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Falkler)
Legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00046205 from
Counsel Charles Monterio to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product; Common
Interest
418
7/18/2011
IP00046221
IP00046221
1
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger); cc:
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP Counsel Dickstein
(DeAnna Allen) (DeAnna Allen)
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood;
Charles Monterio)
Page 69 of 149
Description
Email communication from Counsel DeAnna
Allen to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Basis
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
419
7/18/2011
IP00046222
IP00046225
4
420
7/15/2011
IP00046226
IP00046226
1
421
9/15/2011
IP00046713
IP00046713
1
422
6/9/2011
IP00055432
IP00055432
1
423
6/9/2011
IP00055433
IP00055435
3
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger); cc:
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP Counsel Dickstein
(DeAnna Allen) (DeAnna Allen)
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood;
Charles Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
(Alex Berger); cc:
Shapiro LLP Counsel Dickstein
(DeAnna Allen)
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood;
Charles Monterio)
Description
Basis
Legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00046221 from
Counsel DeAnna Allen to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
Legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00046221 from
Counsel DeAnna Allen to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
Hudson Bay
Hudson Bay
I/P Engine, Inc.
Capital GP LLC Capital GP LLC
(Alex Berger)
(Counsel Scott (Counsel Scott
Black)
Black)
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger); cc:
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP Counsel Dickstein
(Jon Grossman)
(Jon
Shapiro LLP
Grossman)
(Jonathan Levi)
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Attorney-Client
Grossman to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Levi)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00055432 from
Counsel Jon Grossman to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Levi)
Page 70 of 149
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
424
6/9/2011
IP00055437
IP00055437
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood;
Bradley Wine)
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
425
6/9/2011
IP00055438
IP00055440
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood;
Bradley Wine)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00055437 from
Counsel Jon Grossman to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
426
6/9/2011
IP00055441
IP00055442
2
Counsel
Counsel
Dickstein
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
(Bradley Wine) (Bradley Wine)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Bradley
Wine to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
427
6/9/2011
IP00055443
IP00055444
2
Counsel
Counsel
Dickstein
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
(Bradley Wine) (Bradley Wine)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Bradley
Wine to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
428
6/10/2011
IP00055448
IP00055449
2
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
429
6/10/2011
IP00055450
IP00055450
1
430
6/10/2011
IP00055451
IP00055452
2
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Page 71 of 149
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
431
6/10/2011
IP00055453
IP00055454
2
432
6/11/2011
IP00055455
IP00055456
2
433
6/11/2011
IP00055457
IP00055458
2
434
6/11/2011
IP00055464
IP00055464
1
435
6/12/2011
IP00055471
IP00055472
2
436
6/12/2011
IP00055473
IP00055476
4
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
To:
Description
Basis
Counsel
Counsel
Dickstein
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
(Bradley Wine) (Bradley Wine)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Bradley
Wine to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Counsel
Counsel
Ellenoff
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Grossman &
Schole LLP
Schole LLP
(Barry
(Barry
Grossman)
Grossman)
Counsel
Counsel
Ellenoff
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Grossman &
Schole LLP
Schole LLP
(Barry
(Barry
Grossman)
Grossman)
Hudson Bay
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott (Counsel Scott
Black)
Black)
Counsel
Counsel
Dickstein
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
(Bradley Wine) (Bradley Wine)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Barry
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Barry
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Bradley
Attorney-Client
Wine to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
From:
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Page 72 of 149
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
437
6/12/2011
IP00055477
IP00055477
1
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Barry
Grossman)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Barry
Grossman)
438
6/12/2011
IP00055478
IP00055479
2
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Shailendra
Maheshwari)
439
6/12/2011
IP00055480
IP00055484
5
440
6/13/2011
IP00055486
IP00055488
3
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Shailendra
Maheshwari)
441
6/13/2011
IP00055489
IP00055490
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
442
6/13/2011
IP00055491
IP00055515
25
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Levi)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
To:
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger; Ken
Lang); Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Benjamin
Reichel)
Counsel SNR
I/P Engine, Inc.
Denton US LLP (Alex Berger; cc:
(Shailendra
Yoav Roth); cc:
Maheshwari)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Hudson Bay
I/P Engine, Inc.
Capital GP LLC
(Alex Berger)
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Counsel SNR
I/P Engine, Inc.
Denton US LLP (Alex Berger; cc:
(Shailendra
Yoav Roth);
Maheshwari)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
Page 73 of 149
Description
Basis
Email communication from Counsel Barry
Grossman to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Counsel Shailendra
Maheshwari to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Shailendra Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Maheshwari to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00055489 from
Counsel Jon Grossman to Alex Berger
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
443
6/14/2011
IP00055565
IP00055566
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
444
6/14/2011
IP00055567
IP00055568
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
445
6/14/2011
IP00055600
IP00055601
2
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
446
6/14/2011
IP00055604
IP00055606
3
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Attorney-Client
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
447
6/15/2011
IP00055610
IP00055611
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
448
6/15/2011
IP00055612
IP00055613
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
449
11/2/2011
IP00055614
IP00055614
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger eflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00055612 from
Counsel Jon Grossman to Alex Berger
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Page 74 of 149
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
450
6/16/2011
IP00055617
IP00055617
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
451
6/16/2011
IP00055622
IP00055622
1
452
6/18/2011
IP00055652
IP00055653
2
453
6/19/2011
IP00055654
IP00055655
2
454
6/20/2011
IP00055674
IP00055675
2
455
6/21/2011
IP00055710
IP00055712
3
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
To:
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
(Jon
Grossman)
Counsel SNR Counsel SNR
I/P Engine, Inc.
Denton US LLP Denton US LLP (Alex Berger; cc:
(Shailendra
(Shailendra
Ken Lang)
Maheshwari)
Maheshwari)
Description
Basis
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
Work Product
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Counsel Shailendra
Maheshwari to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Shailendra
Maheshwari); I/P
Engine, Inc. (Alex
Berger)
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Schulte Roth & Schulte Roth &
(Alex Berger)
Zabel LLP
Zabel LLP
(Brett Director) (Brett Director)
Email communication from Ken Lang to
Counsel Shailendra Maheshwari, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
Hudson Bay
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott (Counsel Scott
Black)
Black)
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Ken Lang)
(Ken Lang)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Page 75 of 149
Email communication from Counsel Brett
Director to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
456
6/21/2011
IP00055762
IP00055762
1
Counsel
Counsel
Counsel Ellenoff
Schulte Roth & Schulte Roth &
Grossman &
Zabel LLP
Zabel LLP
Schole LLP
(Clara Zylberg) (Clara Zylberg)
(Benjamin
Reichel; Edwin
Opoku); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Alex
Berger); Counsel
Schulte Roth &
Zabel LLP
(Eleazer Klein;
Brett Director;
Adriana Schwartz;
Lyle Stein)
457
6/21/2011
IP00055763
IP00055780
18
Counsel
Counsel Ellenoff
Schulte Roth &
Grossman &
Zabel LLP
Schole LLP
(Clara Zylberg)
(Benjamin
Reichel; Edwin
Opoku); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Alex
Berger); Counsel
Schulte Roth &
Zabel LLP
(Eleazer Klein;
Brett Director;
Adriana Schwartz;
Lyle Stein)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Page 76 of 149
To:
Description
Basis
Email communication from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product; Common
Interest
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00055762 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
458
6/21/2011
IP00055781
IP00055796
16
Counsel
Counsel Ellenoff
Schulte Roth &
Grossman &
Zabel LLP
Schole LLP
(Clara Zylberg)
(Benjamin
Reichel; Edwin
Opoku); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Alex
Berger); Counsel
Schulte Roth &
Zabel LLP
(Eleazer Klein;
Brett Director;
Adriana Schwartz;
Lyle Stein)
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00055762 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
459
6/21/2011
IP00055797
IP00055800
4
Counsel
Counsel Ellenoff
Schulte Roth &
Grossman &
Zabel LLP
Schole LLP
(Clara Zylberg)
(Benjamin
Reichel; Edwin
Opoku); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Alex
Berger); Counsel
Schulte Roth &
Zabel LLP
(Eleazer Klein;
Brett Director;
Adriana Schwartz;
Lyle Stein)
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00055762 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Page 77 of 149
To:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
460
6/21/2011
IP00055801
IP00055838
38
Counsel
Counsel Ellenoff
Schulte Roth &
Grossman &
Zabel LLP
Schole LLP
(Clara Zylberg)
(Benjamin
Reichel; Edwin
Opoku); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Alex
Berger); Counsel
Schulte Roth &
Zabel LLP
(Eleazer Klein;
Brett Director;
Adriana Schwartz;
Lyle Stein)
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00055762 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
461
6/21/2011
IP00055839
IP00055876
38
Counsel
Counsel Ellenoff
Schulte Roth &
Grossman &
Zabel LLP
Schole LLP
(Clara Zylberg)
(Benjamin
Reichel; Edwin
Opoku); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Alex
Berger); Counsel
Schulte Roth &
Zabel LLP
(Eleazer Klein;
Brett Director;
Adriana Schwartz;
Lyle Stein)
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00055762 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Page 78 of 149
To:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
462
6/21/2011
IP00055877
IP00055886
10
463
6/21/2011
IP00055891
IP00055891
1
464
6/22/2011
IP00055960
IP00055960
1
465
6/22/2011
IP00055961
IP00055978
18
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
466
6/22/2011
IP00055979
IP00055979
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Counsel
Counsel Ellenoff
Schulte Roth &
Grossman &
Zabel LLP
Schole LLP
(Clara Zylberg)
(Benjamin
Reichel; Edwin
Opoku); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Alex
Berger); Counsel
Schulte Roth &
Zabel LLP
(Eleazer Klein;
Brett Director;
Adriana Schwartz;
Lyle Stein)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Barry
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
Description
Basis
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00055762 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Barry
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Barry
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00055960 from
Work Product
Counsel Jon Grossman to Alex Berger
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Attorney-Client
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Page 79 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
467
6/22/2011
IP00055981
IP00055982
2
468
6/22/2011
IP00055983
IP00056000
18
469
6/22/2011
IP00056001
IP00056004
4
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Schulte Roth & Schulte Roth &
(Alex Berger);
Zabel LLP
Zabel LLP
Counsel Schulte
(Clara Zylberg) (Clara Zylberg) Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director;
Adriana
Schwartz); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Benjamin
Reichel)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Schulte Roth &
(Alex Berger);
Zabel LLP
Counsel Schulte
(Clara Zylberg) Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director;
Adriana
Schwartz); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Benjamin
Reichel)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Schulte Roth &
(Alex Berger);
Zabel LLP
Counsel Schulte
(Clara Zylberg) Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director;
Adriana
Schwartz); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Benjamin
Reichel)
Page 80 of 149
Description
Basis
Email communication from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00055981 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00055981 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
470
6/22/2011
IP00056005
IP00056042
38
471
6/22/2011
IP00056043
IP00056052
10
472
6/22/2011
IP00056053
IP00056090
38
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Schulte Roth &
(Alex Berger);
Zabel LLP
Counsel Schulte
(Clara Zylberg) Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director;
Adriana
Schwartz); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Benjamin
Reichel)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Schulte Roth &
(Alex Berger);
Zabel LLP
Counsel Schulte
(Clara Zylberg) Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director;
Adriana
Schwartz); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Benjamin
Reichel)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Schulte Roth &
(Alex Berger);
Zabel LLP
Counsel Schulte
(Clara Zylberg) Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director;
Adriana
Schwartz); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Benjamin
Reichel)
Page 81 of 149
Description
Basis
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00055981 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00055981 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00055981 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
473
6/22/2011
IP00056091
IP00056106
16
474
6/22/2011
IP00056107
IP00056135
29
475
6/22/2011
IP00056140
IP00056140
1
476
6/22/2011
IP00056141
IP00056145
5
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Schulte Roth &
(Alex Berger);
Zabel LLP
Counsel Schulte
(Clara Zylberg) Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director;
Adriana
Schwartz); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Benjamin
Reichel)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Schulte Roth &
(Alex Berger);
Zabel LLP
Counsel Schulte
(Clara Zylberg) Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director;
Adriana
Schwartz); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Benjamin
Reichel)
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Ellenoff
Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Grossman &
Schole LLP
Schole LLP
(Edwin Opoku) (Edwin Opoku)
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00055981 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00055981 from Counsel Clara
Zylberg to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Email communication from Counsel Edwin
Opoku to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Counsel
Counsel
Ellenoff
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Grossman &
Schole LLP
Schole LLP
(Edwin Opoku) (Edwin Opoku)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00056140 from
Counsel Edwin Opoku to Alex Berger reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Page 82 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
477
6/22/2011
IP00056146
IP00056152
7
Counsel
Counsel
Ellenoff
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Grossman &
Schole LLP
Schole LLP
(Edwin Opoku) (Edwin Opoku)
478
6/22/2011
IP00056153
IP00056154
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
479
6/22/2011
IP00056156
IP00056157
2
480
6/22/2011
IP00056158
IP00056162
5
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00056140 from
Counsel Edwin Opoku to Alex Berger reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger);
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio; cc:
Jeffrey Sherwood)
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood;
Charles Monterio)
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood;
Charles Monterio)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00056156 from
Counsel Jon Grossman to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Page 83 of 149
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
481
6/22/2011
IP00056165
IP00056167
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood;
Bradley Wine)
Email communication from Counsel Jon
Grossman to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
482
6/22/2011
IP00056168
IP00056168
1
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Barry
Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Barry
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
483
11/2/2011
IP00056169
IP00056171
3
484
11/2/2011
IP00056172
IP00056172
1
485
6/23/2011
IP00056218
IP00056218
1
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Barry
Grossman)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Barry
Grossman)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Barry
Grossman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon
Grossman)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00056168 from
Counsel Barry Grossman to Alex Berger
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. Draft legal document communicated as an
(Alex Berger)
attachment of Document IP00056168 from
Counsel Barry Grossman to Alex Berger
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. Email communication from Counsel Jon
(Alex Berger); Grossman to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
Counsel Dickstein advice and services. This document was
Shapiro LLP
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
(Jonathan Falkler;
cc: DeAnna
Allen); cc:
Counsel Schulte
Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director)
Page 84 of 149
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
486
6/27/2011
IP00056263
IP00056264
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan
Falkler)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan
Falkler)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger);
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio; cc: Jon
Grossman;
DeAnna Allen)
Email communication from Counsel Jonathan
Falkler to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
487
6/29/2011
IP00056300
IP00056301
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger; Ken
Lang; Yoav Roth);
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Frank Cimino;
DeAnna Allen;
Charles Monterio;
Jonathan Falkler)
Email communication from Counsel Jeffrey
Sherwood to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
488
6/30/2011
IP00056322
IP00056322
1
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Email communication from Counsel Christopher
Seamster to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
489
6/30/2011
IP00056323
IP00056338
16
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Draft document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00056322 from
Counsel Christopher Seamster to Alex Berger,
et al. reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Page 85 of 149
Description
Basis
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
490
6/30/2011
IP00056339
IP00056345
7
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Draft document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00056322 from
Counsel Christopher Seamster to Alex Berger,
et al. reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
491
7/7/2011
IP00056379
IP00056379
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel Antonelli,
Terry, Stout, &
Kraus, LLP
(Donald Stout);
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; cc:
Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Falkler)
Email communication from Counsel Charles
Monterio to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
492
11/2/2011
IP00056380
IP00056393
14
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel Antonelli,
Terry, Stout, &
Kraus, LLP
(Donald Stout);
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; cc:
Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Falkler)
Legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00056379 from
Counsel Charles Monterio to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product; Common
Interest
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Page 86 of 149
Description
Basis
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
493
7/8/2011
IP00056401
IP00056403
3
494
7/18/2011
IP00056708
IP00056708
1
495
7/18/2011
IP00056709
IP00056712
4
496
7/15/2011
IP00056713
IP00056713
1
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
Description
Basis
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Antonelli, Terry, Antonelli, Terry,
(Alex Berger)
Stout, & Kraus, Stout, & Kraus,
LLP (Donald
LLP (Donald
Stout)
Stout)
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger); cc:
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP Counsel Dickstein
(DeAnna Allen) (DeAnna Allen)
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood;
Charles Monterio)
Email communication from Counsel Donald
Stout to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Counsel DeAnna
Allen to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger); cc:
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP Counsel Dickstein
(DeAnna Allen) (DeAnna Allen)
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood;
Charles Monterio)
Legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00056708 from
Counsel DeAnna Allen to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
Legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00056708 from
Counsel DeAnna Allen to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
From:
To:
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
(Alex Berger); cc:
Shapiro LLP Counsel Dickstein
(DeAnna Allen)
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood;
Charles Monterio)
Page 87 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
497
7/18/2011
IP00056720
IP00056721
2
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Schulte Roth & Schulte Roth & (Alex Berger; cc:
Zabel LLP
Zabel LLP
Yoav Roth); cc:
(Brett Director) (Brett Director) Counsel Schulte
Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director;
Lyle Stein)
Email communication from Counsel Brett
Director to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
498
7/14/2011
IP00056722
IP00056726
5
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Schulte Roth & (Alex Berger; cc:
Zabel LLP
Yoav Roth); cc:
(Brett Director) Counsel Schulte
Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director;
Lyle Stein)
Legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00056720 from
Counsel Brett Director to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
499
7/18/2011
IP00056753
IP00056754
2
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Email communication from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
500
7/20/2011
IP00056844
IP00056845
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger);
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Leslie Jacobs)
Email communication from Counsel Jeffrey
Sherwood to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
501
7/27/2011
IP00057381
IP00057382
2
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel DeAnna
Allen to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
To:
Page 88 of 149
Description
Basis
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
502
7/18/2011
IP00057383
IP00057386
4
503
7/15/2011
IP00057387
IP00057387
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
504
7/27/2011
IP00057390
IP00057390
1
8/1/2011
IP00057600
IP00057600
1
506
8/1/2011
IP00057601
IP00057602
2
507
8/1/2011
IP00057619
IP00057621
3
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
505
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(DeAnna Allen)
To:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00057381 from
Counsel DeAnna Allen to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00057381 from
Counsel DeAnna Allen to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Page 89 of 149
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
508
8/5/2011
IP00058100
IP00058100
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger; Ken
Lang); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood;
DeAnna Allen;
Frank Cimino;
Jonathan Falkler)
Email communication from Counsel Charles
Monterio to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
509
8/5/2011
IP00058101
IP00058125
25
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger; Ken
Lang); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood;
DeAnna Allen;
Frank Cimino;
Jonathan Falkler)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00058100 from
Counsel Charles Monterio to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
510
8/5/2011
IP00058139
IP00058140
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Yoav Roth)
(Yoav Roth)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc. (Alex
Berger)
Email communication from Yoav Roth to
Counsel Charles Monterio, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
511
8/5/2011
IP00058141
IP00058142
2
Email communication from Counsel Charles
Monterio to Yoav Roth, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; cc:
Alex Berger)
Page 90 of 149
Description
Basis
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
512
8/5/2011
IP00058144
IP00058145
2
513
8/6/2011
IP00058192
IP00058193
2
514
8/9/2011
IP00058280
IP00058281
2
515
8/12/2011
IP00058899
IP00058899
1
516
8/12/2011
IP00058900
IP00058922
23
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Yoav Roth)
(Yoav Roth)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc. (Alex
Berger)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Ellenoff
(Alex Berger; Ken
Grossman & Lang; Yoav Roth);
Schole LLP
cc: Counsel
(Lawrence
Ellenoff
Rosenbloom)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster; Barry
Grossman)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Ellenoff
(Alex Berger; Ken
Grossman & Lang; Yoav Roth);
Schole LLP
cc: Counsel
(Lawrence
Ellenoff
Rosenbloom)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster; Barry
Grossman)
Page 91 of 149
Description
Basis
Email communication from Yoav Roth to
Counsel Charles Monterio, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Counsel Charles
Monterio to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Counsel Charles
Monterio to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00058899 from
Work Product
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom to Alex Berger,
et al. reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
517
8/18/2011
IP00059916
IP00059917
2
518
8/18/2011
IP00059918
IP00059942
25
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Ken Lang)
519
8/21/2011
IP00060091
IP00060091
1
520
8/21/2011
IP00060092
IP00060117
26
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Ken Lang)
(Ken Lang)
To:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger);
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio; cc:
Jeffrey Sherwood;
DeAnna Allen;
Frank Cimino;
Jonathan Falkler)
Email communication from Ken Lang to
Counsel Jeffrey Sherwood, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger);
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio; cc:
Jeffrey Sherwood;
DeAnna Allen;
Frank Cimino;
Jonathan Falkler)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00059916 from Ken
Lang to Counsel Jeffrey Sherwood, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
I/P Engine, Inc. Email communication from Counsel Charles
(Alex Berger; cc: Monterio to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
Ken Lang)
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. Draft legal document communicated as an
(Alex Berger; cc: attachment of Document IP00060091 from
Ken Lang)
Counsel Charles Monterio to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Page 92 of 149
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
521
8/21/2011
IP00060118
IP00060118
1
522
8/24/2011
IP00060681
IP00060682
2
523
8/29/2011
IP00061493
IP00061493
1
524
8/29/2011
IP00061494
IP00061520
27
525
8/30/2011
IP00061790
IP00061790
1
526
9/1/2011
IP00062038
IP00062039
2
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger; cc:
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
Ken Lang)
(Charles
(Charles
Monterio)
Monterio)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Counsel
Antonelli, Terry, Antonelli, Terry,
(Alex Berger)
Stout, & Kraus, Stout, & Kraus,
LLP (Donald
LLP (Donald
Stout)
Stout)
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
(Charles
Monterio)
Monterio)
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
(Charles
Monterio)
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger; Ken
Lang); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Page 93 of 149
Description
Basis
Email communication from Counsel Charles
Monterio to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Counsel Donald
Stout to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Counsel Charles
Monterio to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00061493 from
Counsel Charles Monterio to Alex Berger
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Charles
Monterio to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
Email communication from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
527
9/1/2011
IP00062113
IP00062113
1
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Email communication from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Ken Lang, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
528
9/1/2011
IP00062114
IP00062119
6
Dr. Oren Fuerst
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
529
9/1/2011
IP00062127
IP00062128
2
530
9/1/2011
IP00062133
IP00062134
2
531
9/6/2011
IP00062266
IP00062266
1
532
9/6/2011
IP00062281
IP00062281
1
Counsel
Counsel
Ellenoff
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Grossman &
Schole LLP
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
Counsel
Ellenoff
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Grossman &
Schole LLP
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
Counsel
Dickstein
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan
(Jonathan
Falkler)
Falkler)
Hudson Bay
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott (Counsel Scott
Black)
Black)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Ken Lang; Alex
Berger); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Ken Lang; Alex
Berger); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00062113 from
Work Product
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom to Ken Lang, et
al. reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Alex Berger reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Alex Berger reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Jonathan
Falkler to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Page 94 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
533
9/6/2011
IP00062289
IP00062290
2
534
9/7/2011
IP00062426
IP00062427
2
535
9/7/2011
IP00062462
IP00062463
2
536
9/7/2011
IP00062484
IP00062484
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan
Falkler)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan
Falkler)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Email communication from Counsel Jonathan
Falkler to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
537
9/7/2011
IP00062485
IP00062490
6
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan
Falkler)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan
Falkler)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00062484 from
Counsel Jonathan Falkler to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Ken Lang)
(Ken Lang)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster; cc:
Lawrence
Rosenbloom); cc:
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger;
Yoav Roth)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Luna
Samman)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Luna
Samman)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Description
Basis
Email communication from Ken Lang to
Counsel Christopher Seamster, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Counsel Luna
Samman to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Ken Lang)
Page 95 of 149
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
538
9/7/2011
IP00062498
IP00062498
1
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
539
11/2/2011
IP00062499
IP00062499
540
11/2/2011
IP00062500
541
9/8/2011
IP00065374
From:
To:
Description
Basis
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Ellenoff
(Alex Berger); cc:
Grossman &
Counsel Ellenoff
Schole LLP
Grossman &
(Lawrence
Schole LLP (Barry
Rosenbloom)
Grossman)
Email communication from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
1
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Ellenoff
(Alex Berger); cc:
Grossman &
Counsel Ellenoff
Schole LLP
Grossman &
(Lawrence
Schole LLP (Barry
Rosenbloom)
Grossman)
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00062498 from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
IP00062500
1
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Ellenoff
(Alex Berger); cc:
Grossman &
Counsel Ellenoff
Schole LLP
Grossman &
(Lawrence
Schole LLP (Barry
Rosenbloom)
Grossman)
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00062498 from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
IP00065375
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Email communication from Counsel Charles
Monterio to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger; cc:
Ken Lang);
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Falkler)
Page 96 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
542
9/8/2011
IP00065376
IP00065380
5
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan
Falkler)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger; cc:
Ken Lang);
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Falkler)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00065374 from
Counsel Charles Monterio to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
543
9/8/2011
IP00065462
IP00065462
1
IP00065463
IP00065467
5
545
9/8/2011
IP00065470
IP00065470
1
546
9/9/2011
IP00065471
IP00065471
1
Email communication from Counsel Michael
Zolandz to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00065462 from
Counsel Michael Zolandz to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Michael
Zolandz to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Alex Berger reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
9/8/2011
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Michael
Zolandz)
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Michael
Zolandz)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
544
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Michael
Zolandz)
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Michael
Zolandz)
547
9/9/2011
IP00065472
IP00065472
1
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Counsel SNR Counsel SNR
I/P Engine, Inc.
Denton US LLP Denton US LLP
(Alex Berger)
(Michael
(Michael
Zolandz)
Zolandz)
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Ellenoff
Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Grossman &
Schole LLP
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Ellenoff
Ellenoff
(Alex Berger; cc:
Grossman &
Grossman &
Ken Lang);
Schole LLP
Schole LLP
Counsel Ellenoff
(Lawrence
(Lawrence
Grossman &
Rosenbloom)
Rosenbloom)
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Page 97 of 149
Email communication from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
548
9/9/2011
IP00065480
IP00065481
2
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
549
9/9/2011
IP00065482
IP00065483
2
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
550
9/9/2011
IP00065489
IP00065489
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
551
9/9/2011
IP00065490
IP00065516
27
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
To:
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger; cc:
Ken Lang);
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Ellenoff
(Alex Berger; cc:
Grossman &
Ken Lang);
Schole LLP
Counsel Ellenoff
(Lawrence
Grossman &
Rosenbloom)
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
(Alex Berger; Ken
Shapiro LLP Lang); I/P Engine,
(Charles
Inc. Consultant
Monterio)
(Don Kosak); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Falkler)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger; Ken
Lang); I/P Engine,
Inc. Consultant
(Don Kosak); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Falkler)
Page 98 of 149
Description
Basis
Email communication from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Counsel Charles
Monterio to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00065489 from
Counsel Charles Monterio to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product; Common
Interest
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
552
9/9/2011
IP00065548
IP00065549
2
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Email communication from Counsel Christopher
Seamster to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
553
9/9/2011
IP00065550
IP00065550
1
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00065548 from
Counsel Christopher Seamster to Alex Berger,
et al. reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
554
9/9/2011
IP00065551
IP00065553
3
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00065548 from
Counsel Christopher Seamster to Alex Berger,
et al. reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
555
9/9/2011
IP00065554
IP00065557
4
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00065548 from
Counsel Christopher Seamster to Alex Berger,
et al. reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Page 99 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
556
9/9/2011
IP00065558
IP00065561
4
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00065548 from
Counsel Christopher Seamster to Alex Berger,
et al. reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
557
9/9/2011
IP00065562
IP00065564
3
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00065548 from
Counsel Christopher Seamster to Alex Berger,
et al. reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
558
9/9/2011
IP00065565
IP00065567
3
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00065548 from
Counsel Christopher Seamster to Alex Berger,
et al. reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
559
9/9/2011
IP00065568
IP00065568
1
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00065548 from
Counsel Christopher Seamster to Alex Berger,
et al. reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
560
9/9/2011
IP00065583
IP00065583
1
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Hudson Bay
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott (Counsel Scott
Black)
Black)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Page 100 of 149
Description
Basis
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
Interest
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
561
9/9/2011
IP00065584
IP00065610
27
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
562
9/9/2011
IP00065613
IP00065614
2
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
563
9/9/2011
IP00065615
IP00065620
6
564
9/9/2011
IP00065623
IP00065624
2
565
9/12/2011
IP00065638
IP00065639
2
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger; cc:
Ken Lang);
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Ellenoff
Ellenoff
(Alex Berger; cc:
Grossman &
Grossman &
Ken Lang);
Schole LLP
Schole LLP
Counsel Ellenoff
(Lawrence
Grossman &
Rosenbloom)
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Consultant
Consultant
Shapiro LLP
(Don Kosak)
(Don Kosak)
(Charles
Monterio; cc:
Jonathan Falkler);
cc: I/P Engine,
Inc. (Alex Berger;
Ken Lang)
Counsel
Counsel
Antonelli, Terry, Antonelli, Terry,
Stout, & Kraus, Stout, & Kraus,
LLP (Donald
LLP (Donald
Stout)
Stout)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Page 101 of 149
Description
Basis
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00065583 from
Counsel Scott Black to Alex Berger reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product; Common
Interest
Email communication from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00055432 from
Work Product
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom to Alex Berger,
et al. reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Email communication from Don Kosak to
Interest
Counsel Charles Monterio, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Donald
Stout to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
566
9/12/2011
IP00065653
IP00065653
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger; cc:
Ken Lang); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Falkler)
Email communication from Counsel Charles
Monterio to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
567
9/12/2011
IP00065835
IP00065837
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger; cc:
Ken Lang);
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Falkler)
Email communication from Counsel Charles
Monterio to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
568
9/12/2011
IP00065838
IP00065843
6
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger; cc:
Ken Lang);
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Falkler)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00065835 from
Counsel Charles Monterio to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
569
9/12/2011
IP00065896
IP00065896
1
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Email communication from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Page 102 of 149
Description
Basis
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
570
9/12/2011
IP00065897
IP00065902
6
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
571
9/13/2011
IP00065952
IP00065953
2
572
9/13/2011
IP00066046
IP00066046
1
Counsel
Antonelli, Terry,
Stout, & Kraus,
LLP (Donald
Stout)
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Shailendra
Maheshwari)
573
9/13/2011
IP00066051
IP00066052
2
574
9/13/2011
IP00066053
IP00066054
575
9/13/2011
IP00066055
IP00066056
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Antonelli, Terry,
(Alex Berger)
Stout, & Kraus,
LLP (Donald
Stout)
Counsel SNR
I/P Engine, Inc.
Denton US LLP (Alex Berger); cc:
(Shailendra
Counsel SNR
Maheshwari)
Denton US LLP
(Peter Feldman)
Description
Basis
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00065896 from
Work Product
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom to Alex Berger,
et al. reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Donald
Stout to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Counsel Shailendra
Maheshwari to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Counsel SNR Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP Denton US LLP
(Peter
(Peter
Feldman)
Feldman)
Email communication from Counsel Peter
Feldman to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
2
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Shailendra
Maheshwari)
Email communication from Counsel Shailendra
Maheshwari to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
2
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Shailendra
Maheshwari)
Email communication from Counsel Shailendra
Maheshwari to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger);
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Shailendra
Maheshwari)
Counsel SNR
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP Denton US LLP
(Shailendra
(Peter Feldman);
Maheshwari)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Counsel SNR
I/P Engine, Inc.
Denton US LLP (Alex Berger); cc:
(Shailendra
Counsel SNR
Maheshwari)
Denton US LLP
(Peter Feldman)
Page 103 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
576
9/13/2011
IP00066082
IP00066082
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger; Ken
Lang); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood;
DeAnna Allen;
Jonathan Falkler;
Frank Cimino)
Email communication from Counsel Charles
Monterio to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
577
9/13/2011
IP00066083
IP00066109
27
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger; Ken
Lang); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood;
DeAnna Allen;
Jonathan Falkler;
Frank Cimino)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00066082 from
Counsel Charles Monterio to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
578
9/13/2011
IP00066111
IP00066111
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger; Ken
Lang); Counsel
Dickstein Shapiro
LLP (Charles
Monterio; cc:
Jeffrey Sherwood;
DeAnna Allen;
Jonathan Falkler;
Frank Cimino)
Email communication from Counsel Charles
Monterio to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Page 104 of 149
Description
Basis
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
579
9/13/2011
IP00066112
IP00066138
27
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger; Ken
Lang); Counsel
Dickstein Shapiro
LLP (Charles
Monterio; cc:
Jeffrey Sherwood;
DeAnna Allen;
Jonathan Falkler;
Frank Cimino)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00066111 from
Counsel Charles Monterio to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
580
9/13/2011
IP00066165
IP00066169
5
Email communication from Counsel Shailendra
Maheshwari to Counsel Michael Zolandz, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
581
9/13/2011
IP00066173
IP00066178
6
Counsel SNR Counsel SNR
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP Denton US LLP Denton US LLP
(Shailendra
(Shailendra
(Michael
Maheshwari)
Maheshwari) Zolandz); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc. (Alex
Berger)
Counsel SNR Counsel SNR
I/P Engine, Inc.
Denton US LLP Denton US LLP (Alex Berger); cc:
(Shailendra
(Shailendra
Counsel SNR
Maheshwari)
Maheshwari)
Denton US LLP
(Michael Zolandz)
Email communication from Counsel Shailendra
Maheshwari to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
582
9/14/2011
IP00066222
IP00066224
3
583
9/14/2011
IP00066235
IP00066235
1
Hudson Bay
Hudson Bay
I/P Engine, Inc.
Capital GP LLC Capital GP LLC
(Alex Berger)
(Counsel Scott (Counsel Scott
Black)
Black)
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger); cc:
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP Counsel Dickstein
(Jeffrey
(Jeffrey
Shapiro LLP
Sherwood)
Sherwood)
(DeAnna Allen;
Charles Monterio)
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Jeffrey
Attorney-Client
Sherwood to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Page 105 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
584
9/14/2011
IP00066236
IP00066241
6
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(DeAnna Allen;
Charles Monterio)
585
9/14/2011
IP00066258
IP00066258
1
586
9/14/2011
IP00066259
IP00066260
2
587
9/14/2011
IP00066261
IP00066262
2
588
9/14/2011
IP00066264
IP00066266
3
589
9/14/2011
IP00066267
IP00066268
2
590
9/14/2011
IP00066269
IP00066269
1
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Description
Basis
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00066235 from
Work Product
Counsel Jeffrey Sherwood to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Email communication from Counsel Charles
Attorney-Client
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger; cc: Monterio to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
Ken Lang)
advice and services. This document was
(Charles
(Charles
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Monterio)
Monterio)
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Email communication from Counsel Charles
Attorney-Client
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger; cc: Monterio to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
Ken Lang)
advice and services. This document was
(Charles
(Charles
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Monterio)
Monterio)
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Email communication from Counsel Charles
Attorney-Client
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger; cc: Monterio to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
Ken Lang)
advice and services. This document was
(Charles
(Charles
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Monterio)
Monterio)
Hudson Bay
Hudson Bay
I/P Engine, Inc. Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Capital GP LLC Capital GP LLC
(Alex Berger)
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
(Counsel Scott (Counsel Scott
services. This document was prepared in
Black)
Black)
anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Email communication from Counsel Charles
Attorney-Client
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Monterio to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
and services. This document was prepared in
(Charles
(Charles
anticipation of litigation.
Monterio)
Monterio)
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Email communication from Counsel DeAnna
Attorney-Client
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Allen to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
services. This document was prepared in
(DeAnna Allen) (DeAnna Allen)
anticipation of litigation.
Page 106 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
591
9/14/2011
IP00066270
IP00066271
2
592
9/14/2011
IP00066272
IP00066274
3
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
593
9/14/2011
IP00066275
IP00066278
4
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
594
9/14/2011
IP00066279
IP00066280
2
595
9/14/2011
IP00066281
IP00066282
2
596
9/14/2011
IP00066283
IP00066294
12
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
Email communication from Counsel DeAnna
Allen to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger; cc:
Ken Lang);
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Email communication from Counsel Christopher
Seamster to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Christopher
Seamster to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00066275 from Counsel
Christopher Seamster to Alex Berger reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Charles
Monterio to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00066281 from
Counsel Charles Monterio to Alex Berger
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Counsel
Counsel
Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
(DeAnna Allen);
(DeAnna Allen) (DeAnna Allen) I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Page 107 of 149
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
597
9/14/2011
IP00066319
IP00066319
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood)
Email communication from Counsel Charles
Monterio to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
598
9/14/2011
IP00066320
IP00066346
27
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00066319 from
Counsel Charles Monterio to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
599
9/14/2011
IP00066347
IP00066348
2
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Email communication from Counsel Christopher
Seamster to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
600
9/14/2011
IP00066349
IP00066350
2
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00066347 from
Counsel Christopher Seamster to Alex Berger,
et al. reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
601
9/14/2011
IP00066472
IP00066472
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood)
Email communication from Counsel Charles
Monterio to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Page 108 of 149
Description
Basis
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
602
9/14/2011
IP00066473
IP00066474
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00066472 from
Counsel Charles Monterio to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
603
9/14/2011
IP00066482
IP00066482
1
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Email communication from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
604
9/14/2011
IP00066501
IP00066501
1
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger);
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Email communication from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
605
9/14/2011
IP00066502
IP00066503
2
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00066501 from
Work Product
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom to Alex Berger,
et al. reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
606
9/14/2011
IP00066514
IP00066515
2
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Page 109 of 149
Email communication from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Alex Berger reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
607
9/14/2011
IP00066522
IP00066522
1
608
9/15/2011
IP00066549
IP00066551
3
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
609
9/15/2011
IP00066555
IP00066556
2
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
610
9/15/2011
IP00066678
IP00066679
2
611
9/15/2011
IP00066694
IP00066696
3
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth)
(Yoav Roth)
To:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger);
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster); I/P
Engine, Inc. (Alex
Berger; cc: Ken
Lang)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Email communication from Yoav Roth to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Counsel Charles
Monterio to Counsel Christopher Seamster, et
al. reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Counsel Charles
Monterio to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger;
Yoav Roth)
Email communication from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger;
Yoav Roth); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Email communication from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Page 110 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
612
9/15/2011
IP00066751
IP00066751
1
9/15/2011
IP00066904
IP00066904
1
614
9/15/2011
IP00066906
IP00066907
2
615
9/15/2011
IP00066908
IP00066908
1
616
9/16/2011
IP00066980
IP00066981
2
617
9/16/2011
IP00067031
IP00067032
2
618
9/16/2011
IP00067036
IP00067038
3
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Barry
Grossman)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
613
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood)
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Barry
Grossman)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Description
Basis
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Charles
Attorney-Client
Monterio to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger;
Yoav Roth)
Email communication from Counsel Lawrence
Rosenbloom to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Jeffrey
Sherwood to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Barry
Grossman to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Counsel Scott Black Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
to Alex Berger reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Page 111 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
619
9/18/2011
IP00067220
IP00067221
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Bradley Wine);
cc: I/P Engine,
Inc. (Alex Berger)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Bradley Wine reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
620
11/2/2011
IP00067222
IP00067222
1
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Bradley Wine);
cc: I/P Engine,
Inc. (Alex Berger)
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP0067220 from Alex Berger to
Counsel Bradley Wine, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
621
5/5/2011
IP00070614
IP00070614
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Levi;
cc: Bradley Wine;
Frank Cimino)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jonathan Levi, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
622
5/6/2011
IP00070616
IP00070616
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Levi;
cc: Jon
Grossman)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jonathan Levi, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
623
5/6/2011
IP00070617
IP00070618
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) (Yoav Roth); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Levi)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jonathan Levi, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Page 112 of 149
To:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
624
5/6/2011
IP00070619
IP00070622
4
625
5/6/2011
IP00070623
IP00070628
6
626
5/6/2011
IP00070629
IP00070630
2
627
5/9/2011
IP00070643
IP00070645
3
628
5/9/2011
IP00070646
IP00070651
6
629
5/10/2011
IP00070652
IP00070656
5
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) (Yoav Roth); cc: attachment of Document IP00070617 from Alex
Work Product
Shapiro LLP
Counsel Dickstein Berger to Counsel Jonathan Levi, et al.
(Jonathan Levi)
Shapiro LLP
reflecting legal advice and services. This
(Jonathan Levi) document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) (Yoav Roth); cc: attachment of Document IP00070617 from Alex
Work Product
Shapiro LLP
Counsel Dickstein Berger to Counsel Jonathan Levi, et al.
(Jonathan Levi)
Shapiro LLP
reflecting legal advice and services. This
(Jonathan Levi) document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Counsel Bradley Wine reflecting legal advice
(Bradley Wine) and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
Grossman;
advice and services. This document was
Jonathan Levi; cc: prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Frank Cimino;
Bradley Wine)
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman;
Jonathan Levi; cc:
Frank Cimino;
Bradley Wine)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00071643 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting legal advice
Grossman)
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Page 113 of 149
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
630
5/10/2011
IP00070657
IP00070661
5
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman;
Jonathan Levi)
631
5/12/2011
IP00070662
IP00070664
3
632
5/13/2011
IP00070665
IP00070666
2
633
5/22/2011
IP00070675
IP00070676
2
634
5/25/2011
IP00070691
IP00070691
1
635
6/1/2011
IP00070703
IP00070703
1
636
6/3/2011
IP00070712
IP00070714
3
637
11/2/2011
IP00070715
IP00071011
297
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Counsel Jonathan Levi, et al. reflecting legal
(Jonathan Levi) advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Counsel Bradley Wine reflecting legal advice
(Bradley Wine) and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
Counsel SNR Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Denton US LLP Counsel Mark Hogge, et al. reflecting legal
(Mark Hogge; advice and services. This document was
Shailendra
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Maheshwari)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting legal advice
Grossman)
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Counsel DeAnna Allen reflecting legal advice
(DeAnna Allen) and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
Counsel SNR Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Denton US LLP Counsel Shailendra Maheshwari, et al.
(Shailendra
reflecting legal advice and services. This
Maheshwari)
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Counsel SNR Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Denton US LLP attachment of Document IP00070712 from Alex Work Product; Common
Shapiro LLP
(Shailendra
Berger to Counsel Shailendra Maheshwari
Interest
(Jonathan
Maheshwari)
reflecting legal advice and services. This
Falkler)
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Page 114 of 149
To:
Description
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Basis
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
638
6/3/2011
IP00071012
IP00071025
14
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan
Falkler)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Shailendra
Maheshwari)
639
6/3/2011
IP00071026
IP00071027
2
640
6/7/2011
IP00071039
IP00071039
1
641
6/6/2011
IP00071040
IP00071061
22
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Shapiro LLP
Grossman; cc:
(Jon Grossman)
Jonathan Levi;
Bradley Wine)
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00071039 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
642
6/10/2011
IP00071080
IP00071082
3
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman;
Jonathan Levi)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
643
6/10/2011
IP00071083
IP00071083
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman;
Jonathan Levi)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Description
Basis
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00070712 from Alex Work Product; Common
Berger to Counsel Shailendra Maheshwari
Interest
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Counsel SNR Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Denton US LLP attachment of Document IP00070712 from Alex Work Product; Common
Shapiro LLP
(Shailendra
Berger to Counsel Shailendra Maheshwari
Interest
(Charles
Maheshwari)
reflecting legal advice and services. This
Monterio)
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
Grossman; cc: advice and services. This document was
Jonathan Levi; prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Bradley Wine)
Page 115 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
644
6/10/2011
IP00071084
IP00071107
24
645
6/10/2011
IP00071108
IP00071111
4
646
6/10/2011
IP00071113
IP00071113
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jeffrey Sherwood reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
647
6/10/2011
IP00071114
IP00071115
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
648
6/10/2011
IP00071116
IP00071116
1
649
6/10/2011
IP00071117
IP00071117
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman)
650
6/10/2011
IP00071118
IP00071119
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman; cc:
Jeffrey Sherwood;
Bradley Wine;
Frank Cimino)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Scott Black reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Shapiro LLP
Grossman;
(Jon Grossman)
Jonathan Levi)
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00071083 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger); Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
Counsel Dickstein advice and services. This document was
Shapiro LLP (Jon prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Grossman;
Jonathan Levi)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman)
Page 116 of 149
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
651
6/11/2011
IP00071120
IP00071121
2
652
6/10/2011
IP00071122
IP00071146
25
653
6/10/2011
IP00071147
IP00071172
26
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
(Bradley Wine)
(Jon Grossman)
654
6/12/2011
IP00071173
IP00071175
3
655
6/12/2011
IP00071176
IP00071176
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Counsel Bradley Wine reflecting legal advice
(Bradley Wine) and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
Grossman);
advice and services. This document was
Hudson Bay
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
656
5/16/2011
IP00071177
IP00071181
5
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Counsel Bradley Wine reflecting legal advice
(Bradley Wine) and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
attachment of Document IP00071120 from Alex
Work Product
Shapiro LLP
(Bradley Wine) Berger to Counsel Bradley Wine reflecting legal
(Jon Grossman)
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman);
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Page 117 of 149
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00071120 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Bradley Wine reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Attorney-Client; Common
Legal document communicated as an
Interest
attachment of Document IP00071176 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
657
5/16/2011
IP00071182
IP00071187
6
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman);
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Attorney-Client; Common
Legal document communicated as an
Interest
attachment of Document IP00071176 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
658
6/12/2011
IP00071188
IP00071192
5
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Shapiro LLP
Grossman);
(Jon Grossman)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00071176 from Alex Work Product; Common
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman, et al.
Interest
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
659
6/13/2011
IP00071195
IP00071195
1
660
6/13/2011
IP00071196
IP00071220
25
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting legal advice
Grossman)
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon attachment of Document IP00071195 from Alex
Work Product
Shapiro LLP
Grossman)
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting
(Jonathan Levi)
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
661
6/14/2011
IP00071291
IP00071291
1
662
6/14/2011
IP00071292
IP00071294
3
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting legal advice
Grossman)
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon attachment of Document IP00071291 from Alex
Work Product
Shapiro LLP
Grossman)
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting
(Jonathan Levi)
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Page 118 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
663
6/14/2011
IP00071295
IP00071299
5
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Shapiro LLP
Grossman)
(Jonathan Levi)
664
6/14/2011
IP00071305
IP00071305
1
665
6/14/2011
IP00071306
IP00071306
1
666
5/16/2011
IP00071307
IP00071311
5
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client; Attorney
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting legal advice
Work Product
Grossman)
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting legal advice
Grossman)
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon attachment of Document IP00071306 from Alex
Work Product
Shapiro LLP
Grossman)
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting
(Jon Grossman)
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
667
5/16/2011
IP00071312
IP00071318
7
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Shapiro LLP
Grossman)
(Jon Grossman)
668
6/14/2011
IP00071319
IP00071320
2
669
6/14/2011
IP00071321
IP00071323
3
670
6/15/2011
IP00071324
IP00071324
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting legal advice
Grossman)
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting legal advice
Grossman)
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
Hudson Bay
Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Capital GP LLC Counsel Scott Black reflecting legal advice and
(Counsel Scott services. This document was prepared in
Black)
anticipation of litigation.
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Page 119 of 149
To:
Description
Basis
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00071291 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00071306 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
671
6/15/2011
IP00071325
IP00071329
5
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jon Grossman)
672
6/17/2011
IP00071337
IP00071337
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman; cc:
Jeffrey Sherwood;
Jeffrey Rhodes)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
673
6/18/2011
IP00071344
IP00071345
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Shailendra Maheshwari, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
674
6/18/2011
IP00071346
IP00071348
3
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Shailendra Maheshwari, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
675
6/20/2011
IP00071359
IP00071360
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Edwin Opoku, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
676
6/21/2011
IP00071369
IP00071370
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Shailendra
Maheshwari); cc:
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Ken Lang)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Ken Lang);
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Shailendra
Maheshwari)
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Edwin Opoku; cc:
Barry Grossman;
Sarah Williams)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Page 120 of 149
Description
Basis
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00071324 from Alex Work Product; Common
Berger to Counsel Scott Black reflecting legal
Interest
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Scott Black reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
677
6/21/2011
IP00071413
IP00071413
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP (Barry
Grossman)
678
6/22/2011
IP00071479
IP00071479
1
679
6/22/2011
IP00071635
IP00071636
2
680
6/22/2011
IP00071656
IP00071657
2
681
6/22/2011
IP00071658
IP00071662
5
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman;
Charles Monterio;
cc: Jeffrey
Sherwood)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00071656 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
682
6/22/2011
IP00071663
IP00071670
8
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman;
Charles Monterio;
cc: Jeffrey
Sherwood)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00071656 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Description
Basis
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Barry Grossman reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman reflecting legal advice
Grossman)
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
Hudson Bay
Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Capital GP LLC Counsel Scott Black reflecting legal advice and
(Counsel Scott services. This document was prepared in
Black)
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
Grossman;
advice and services. This document was
Charles Monterio; prepared in anticipation of litigation.
cc: Jeffrey
Sherwood)
Attorney-Client
Page 121 of 149
To:
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
683
6/22/2011
IP00071671
IP00071673
3
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Grossman; cc:
Jeffrey Sherwood;
Bradley Wine)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jon Grossman, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
684
6/22/2011
IP00071674
IP00071691
18
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Shapiro LLP
Grossman; cc:
(Jon Grossman)
Jeffrey Sherwood;
Bradley Wine)
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00071671 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
685
6/22/2011
IP00071692
IP00071710
19
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger) Shapiro LLP (Jon
Shapiro LLP
Grossman; cc:
(Jon Grossman)
Jeffrey Sherwood;
Bradley Wine)
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00071671 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Jon Grossman, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
686
6/22/2011
IP00071711
IP00071713
3
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Charles Monterio reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
687
6/23/2011
IP00071751
IP00071751
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Scott Black, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
688
6/23/2011
IP00071752
IP00071756
5
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Barry
Grossman)
From:
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
To:
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth)
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth)
Page 122 of 149
Description
Basis
Attorney-Client
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00071751 from Alex Work Product; Common
Berger to Counsel Scott Black, et al. reflecting
Interest
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
689
6/23/2011
IP00071757
IP00071763
7
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
690
6/28/2011
IP00071780
IP00071780
1
691
6/16/2011
IP00071781
IP00071785
5
692
7/1/2011
IP00071811
IP00071813
3
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
To:
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster)
Page 123 of 149
Description
Basis
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00071751 from Alex Work Product; Common
Berger to Counsel Scott Black, et al. reflecting
Interest
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00071780 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
693
7/16/2011
IP00071963
IP00071966
4
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(DeAnna Allen;
Jeffrey Sherwood;
Frank Cimino;
Charles Monterio;
Jonathan Falkler);
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Ken
Lang); Hudson
Bay Capital GP
LLC (Sander
Gerber)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel DeAnna Allen, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
694
7/18/2011
IP00071967
IP00071969
3
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Schulte
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) Roth & Zabel LLP
(Brett Director; cc:
Lyle Stein); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Brett Director reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
695
7/18/2011
IP00071970
IP00071971
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Page 124 of 149
To:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
696
7/19/2011
IP00071987
IP00071990
4
697
11/2/2011
IP00071991
IP00071991
698
11/2/2011
IP00071992
IP00071992
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) (Yoav Roth; Ken
Lang); Counsel
Dickstein Shapiro
LLP (Jeffrey
Sherwood; Frank
Cimino; DeAnna
Allen; Charles
Monterio;
Jonathan Falkler)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jeffrey Sherwood, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger) (Yoav Roth; Ken
Lang); Counsel
Dickstein Shapiro
LLP (Jeffrey
Sherwood; Frank
Cimino; DeAnna
Allen; Charles
Monterio;
Jonathan Falkler)
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00071987 from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jeffrey Sherwood, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger) (Yoav Roth; Ken
Lang); Counsel
Dickstein Shapiro
LLP (Jeffrey
Sherwood; Frank
Cimino; DeAnna
Allen; Charles
Monterio;
Jonathan Falkler)
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00071987 from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jeffrey Sherwood, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Page 125 of 149
To:
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
699
11/2/2011
IP00071993
IP00071993
1
700
11/2/2011
IP00071994
IP00071994
701
7/20/2011
IP00072079
702
7/27/2011
IP00072090
Description
Basis
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger) (Yoav Roth; Ken
Lang); Counsel
Dickstein Shapiro
LLP (Jeffrey
Sherwood; Frank
Cimino; DeAnna
Allen; Charles
Monterio;
Jonathan Falkler)
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00071987 from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jeffrey Sherwood, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger) (Yoav Roth; Ken
Lang); Counsel
Dickstein Shapiro
LLP (Jeffrey
Sherwood; Frank
Cimino; DeAnna
Allen; Charles
Monterio;
Jonathan Falkler)
Document communicated as an attachment of
Document IP00071987 from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jeffrey Sherwood, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
IP00072080
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jeffrey Sherwood reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
IP00072090
1
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger; Ken
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
Lang)
(DeAnna Allen) (DeAnna Allen)
Letter communication from Counsel DeAnna
Allen to Alex Berger, et at. Reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Page 126 of 149
To:
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
703
7/18/2011
IP00072091
IP00072094
4
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger; Ken
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
Lang)
(DeAnna Allen) (DeAnna Allen)
Letter communication from Counsel DeAnna
Allen to Alex Berger, et at. Reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
704
7/15/2011
IP00072095
IP00072095
1
Letter communication from Counsel DeAnna
Allen to Alex Berger, et at. Reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
705
7/27/2011
IP00072102
IP00072102
1
706
7/18/2011
IP00072103
IP00072106
4
Counsel
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Dickstein
Dickstein
(Alex Berger; Ken
Shapiro LLP
Shapiro LLP
Lang)
(Charles
(DeAnna Allen)
Monterio)
Hudson Bay
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc.
Hudson Bay
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Capital GP LLC
Shapiro LLP
(Counsel Scott
(DeAnna Allen)
Black)
707
7/27/2011
IP00072107
IP00072107
1
708
8/5/2011
IP00072210
IP00072210
1
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
From:
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
To:
Hudson Bay
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) (Yoav Roth); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Page 127 of 149
Description
Basis
Attorney-Client; Common
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Interest
Counsel Scott Black reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00072102 from Alex Work Product; Common
Berger to Counsel Scott Black reflecting legal
Interest
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00072102 from Alex Work Product; Common
Berger to Counsel Scott Black reflecting legal
Interest
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Charles Monterio, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
709
8/5/2011
IP00072211
IP00072235
25
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
710
8/10/2011
IP00072416
IP00072416
1
711
8/16/2011
IP00072939
IP00072939
1
712
8/21/2011
IP00073706
IP00073706
1
713
8/21/2011
IP00073707
IP00073707
1
714
8/25/2011
IP00074266
IP00074266
1
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
To:
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger) (Yoav Roth); cc:
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Description
Basis
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00072210 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Charles Monterio, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Counsel DeAnna Allen reflecting legal advice
(DeAnna Allen) and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Counsel Charles Monterio, et al. reflecting legal
(Charles
advice and services. This document was
Monterio; DeAnna prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Allen)
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster)
Dr. Oren Fuerst I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00078745 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Page 128 of 149
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
715
8/25/2011
IP00074267
IP00074293
27
Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
716
8/25/2011
IP00074294
IP00074319
26
717
8/29/2011
IP00074880
IP00074880
1
718
8/30/2011
IP00075034
IP00075034
719
9/1/2011
IP00075874
720
9/1/2011
IP00075904
From:
To:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Grossman &
Schole LLP
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00074266 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Charles Monterio reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Charles Monterio reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
IP00075874
1
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
IP00075904
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
Hudson Bay
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Scott Black reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Page 129 of 149
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00074266 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
721
9/6/2011
IP00076044
IP00076044
1
722
9/6/2011
IP00076103
IP00076103
1
723
9/6/2011
IP00076104
IP00076109
6
724
9/7/2011
IP00076729
IP00076729
1
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Ken
Lang)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Falkler;
Frank Cimino); cc:
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Ken
Lang)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Frank Cimino, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Falkler;
Frank Cimino); cc:
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Ken
Lang)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00076103 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Frank Cimino, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Charles Monterio, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
To:
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Ken Lang);
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Page 130 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
725
12/31/2007
IP00076730
IP00076737
726
9/7/2011
IP00076738
727
9/8/2011
728
729
From:
To:
Description
Basis
8
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Ken Lang);
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00076729 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Charles Monterio, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
IP00076742
5
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Ken Lang);
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00076729 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Charles Monterio, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
IP00076997
IP00076998
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Falkler;
Charles
Monterio); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc. (Ken
Lang)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jonathan Falkler, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
11/2/2011
IP00076999
IP00077003
5
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Falkler;
Charles
Monterio); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc. (Ken
Lang)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00076997 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Jonathan Falkler, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
12/31/2007
IP00077004
IP00077011
8
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jonathan Falkler;
Charles
Monterio); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc. (Ken
Lang)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00076997 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Jonathan Falkler, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
Page 131 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
730
9/8/2011
IP00077047
IP00077048
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio;
Jonathan Falkler);
cc: I/P Engine,
Inc. (Ken Lang)
731
9/8/2011
IP00077125
IP00077125
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
732
9/8/2011
IP00077132
IP00077132
1
733
11/2/2011
IP00077133
IP00077137
5
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Description
Basis
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Charles Monterio, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Counsel SNR Email communication from Alex Berger to
Denton US LLP Counsel Michael Zolandz reflecting legal advice
(Michael Zolandz) and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
legal advice and services. This document was
Schole LLP
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc. (Ken
Lang)
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00077132 from Alex
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Berger to Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al.
Schole LLP
reflecting legal advice and services. This
(Lawrence
document was prepared in anticipation of
Rosenbloom;
litigation.
Christopher
Seamster); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc. (Ken
Lang)
Attorney-Client
Page 132 of 149
To:
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
734
9/9/2011
IP00077138
IP00077145
8
735
9/9/2011
IP00077146
IP00077146
1
736
9/9/2011
IP00077147
IP00077148
2
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc. (Ken
Lang)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc. (Ken
Lang)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Antonelli,
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Terry, Stout, &
Kraus, LLP
(Donald Stout);
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Michael
Zolandz); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Ken
Lang)
Page 133 of 149
Description
Basis
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00077132 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Donald Stout, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
737
11/2/2011
IP00077149
IP00077153
5
738
12/31/2007
IP00077154
IP00077160
7
739
9/9/2011
IP00077161
IP00077162
2
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Antonelli,
(Alex Berger)
Terry, Stout, &
Kraus, LLP
(Donald Stout);
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Michael
Zolandz); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Ken
Lang)
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Antonelli,
(Alex Berger)
Terry, Stout, &
Kraus, LLP
(Donald Stout);
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Michael
Zolandz); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Ken
Lang)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc. (Ken
Lang)
Page 134 of 149
Description
Basis
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Common
attachment of Document IP00077147 from Alex
Interest
Berger to Counsel Donald Stout, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Common
attachment of Document IP00077147 from Alex
Interest
Berger to Counsel Donald Stout, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
740
11/2/2011
IP00077163
IP00077167
5
741
9/9/2011
IP00077168
IP00077176
9
742
9/9/2011
IP00077177
IP00077178
2
743
9/9/2011
IP00077181
IP00077181
1
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc. (Ken
Lang)
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc. (Ken
Lang)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc. (Ken
Lang)
Hudson Bay
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
Page 135 of 149
Description
Basis
Draft document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00077161 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
Draft document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00077161 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client; Common
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
Interest
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Scott Black reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client; Common
Interest
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
744
9/9/2011
IP00077216
IP00077217
2
745
11/2/2011
IP00077218
IP00077222
5
746
9/9/2011
IP00077223
IP00077231
9
747
9/9/2011
IP00077232
IP00077232
1
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc. (Ken
Lang)
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc. (Ken
Lang)
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc. (Ken
Lang)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio;
Jonathan Falkler);
cc: I/P Engine,
Inc. (Ken Lang)
Page 136 of 149
Description
Basis
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Draft document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00077216 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
Draft document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00077216 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Charles Monterio, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
748
12/31/2007
IP00077233
IP00077233
1
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
749
9/9/2011
IP00077272
IP00077274
3
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio;
Jonathan Falkler);
cc: I/P Engine,
Inc. (Ken Lang)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Charles Monterio, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
750
12/31/2007
IP00077275
IP00077281
7
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio;
Jonathan Falkler);
cc: I/P Engine,
Inc. (Ken Lang)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00077272 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Charles Monterio, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
751
11/2/2011
IP00077282
IP00077287
6
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio;
Jonathan Falkler);
cc: I/P Engine,
Inc. (Ken Lang)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00077272 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Charles Monterio, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
To:
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio;
Jonathan Falkler);
cc: I/P Engine,
Inc. (Ken Lang)
Page 137 of 149
Description
Basis
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00077232 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Charles Monterio, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
752
9/9/2011
IP00077288
IP00077288
1
753
12/31/2007
IP00077289
IP00077295
7
754
11/2/2011
IP00077296
IP00077301
6
755
9/9/2011
IP00077302
IP00077303
2
756
9/9/2011
IP00077314
IP00077314
1
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger) (Yoav Roth); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger) (Yoav Roth); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger) (Yoav Roth); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc. (Ken
Lang)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Antonelli,
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Terry, Stout, &
Kraus, LLP
(Donald Stout)
Page 138 of 149
Description
Basis
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00077288 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00077288 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Donald Stout reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
757
9/10/2011
IP00077315
IP00077341
27
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
758
9/10/2011
IP00077352
IP00077352
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Antonelli,
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Terry, Stout, &
Kraus, LLP
(Donald Stout)
759
11/2/2011
IP00077353
IP00077358
6
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Antonelli,
(Alex Berger)
Terry, Stout, &
Kraus, LLP
(Donald Stout)
760
9/11/2011
IP00077359
IP00077359
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Antonelli,
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Terry, Stout, &
Kraus, LLP
(Donald Stout)
761
11/2/2011
IP00077360
IP00077365
6
762
9/11/2011
IP00077368
IP00077368
1
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
To:
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Antonelli,
(Alex Berger)
Terry, Stout, &
Kraus, LLP
(Donald Stout)
Description
Basis
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00077314 from Alex Work Product; Common
Berger to Counsel Donald Stout reflecting legal
Interest
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Donald Stout reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00077352 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Donald Stout reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Donald Stout reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Antonelli,
(Alex Berger)
Terry, Stout, &
Kraus, LLP
(Donald Stout)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00077359 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Donald Stout reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio; cc:
Jonathan Falkler);
cc: I/P Engine,
Inc. (Ken Lang)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Charles Monterio, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Page 139 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
763
9/12/2011
IP00077369
IP00077395
27
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio; cc:
Jonathan Falkler);
cc: I/P Engine,
Inc. (Ken Lang)
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00077368 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Charles Monterio, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
764
9/12/2011
IP00077396
IP00077425
30
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio; cc:
Jonathan Falkler);
cc: I/P Engine,
Inc. (Ken Lang)
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00077368 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Charles Monterio, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
765
9/12/2011
IP00077428
IP00077428
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio; cc:
Jonathan Falkler);
cc: I/P Engine,
Inc. (Ken Lang)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Charles Monterio, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
766
9/12/2011
IP00077449
IP00077449
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Ken
Lang)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
From:
Page 140 of 149
To:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
767
9/12/2011
IP00077450
IP00077451
2
768
9/12/2011
IP00077985
IP00077985
1
769
11/2/2011
IP00077986
IP00077991
6
770
9/13/2011
IP00078223
IP00078224
2
771
9/13/2011
IP00078431
IP00078432
2
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Ken
Lang)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Shailendra
Maheshwari; cc:
Peter Feldman)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster)
Page 141 of 149
Description
Basis
Draft document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00077449 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00077985 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Shailendra Maheshwari, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
772
9/13/2011
IP00078434
IP00078435
2
773
9/13/2011
IP00078466
IP00078466
1
774
9/13/2011
IP00078467
IP00078493
27
775
9/13/2011
IP00078495
IP00078495
1
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Shapiro LLP
Schole LLP
(Charles
(Lawrence
Monterio)
Rosenbloom)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Description
Basis
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Draft document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00078466 from Alex Work Product; Common
Berger to Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al.
Interest
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. Email communication from Counsel Charles
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger;
Monterio to Alex Berger, et al. reflecting legal
Yoav Roth; Ken advice and services. This document was
Lang); Counsel prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Dickstein Shapiro
LLP (Jeffrey
Sherwood; Frank
Cimino; DeAnna
Allen; Jonathan
Falkler)
Page 142 of 149
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
776
9/13/2011
IP00078496
IP00078522
27
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio); I/P
Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth; Ken
Lang); Counsel
Dickstein Shapiro
LLP (Jeffrey
Sherwood; Frank
Cimino; DeAnna
Allen; Jonathan
Falkler)
Legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00078495 from
Counsel Charles Monterio to Alex Berger, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Work Product
777
9/13/2011
IP00078523
IP00078523
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Charles Monterio reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
778
9/13/2011
IP00078552
IP00078552
1
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
779
9/13/2011
IP00078553
IP00078579
27
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Shapiro LLP
Schole LLP
(Charles
(Lawrence
Monterio)
Rosenbloom)
780
9/13/2011
IP00078610
IP00078614
5
781
12/31/2007
IP00078615
IP00078641
27
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Draft legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00078552 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
Counsel SNR Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Denton US LLP Counsel Michael Zolandz, et al. reflecting legal
(Michael Zolandz; advice and services. This document was
cc: Shailendra prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Maheshwari)
Counsel
Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
Counsel SNR
Denton US LLP
(Michael Zolandz;
cc: Shailendra
Maheshwari)
Page 143 of 149
Legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
attachment of Document IP00078610 from Alex
Work Product
Berger to Counsel Michael Zolandz, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
782
9/13/2011
IP00078738
IP00078738
1
783
9/14/2011
IP00078739
IP00078744
784
9/13/2011
IP00078745
785
9/14/2011
IP00078746
Description
Basis
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood; cc:
DeAnna Allen;
Charles Monterio)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jeffrey Sherwood, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
6
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood; cc:
DeAnna Allen;
Charles Monterio)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00078738 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Jeffrey Sherwood, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
IP00078745
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood; cc:
DeAnna Allen;
Charles Monterio)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jeffrey Sherwood, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
IP00078751
6
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood; cc:
DeAnna Allen;
Charles Monterio)
Draft legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00078745 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Jeffrey Sherwood, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Page 144 of 149
To:
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
786
9/14/2011
IP00078885
IP00078885
1
787
9/14/2011
IP00078886
IP00078886
788
9/14/2011
IP00078890
789
9/14/2011
IP00078915
Description
Basis
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc. (Ken
Lang)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Charles Monterio, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Jeffrey
Sherwood; cc:
DeAnna Allen;
Charles Monterio)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Jeffrey Sherwood, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
IP00078891
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio); cc: I/P
Engine, Inc. (Ken
Lang)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Charles Monterio, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
IP00078916
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio); I/P
Engine, Inc. (Ken
Lang); Counsel
Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Attorney-Client; Common
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Interest
Counsel Charles Monterio, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Page 145 of 149
To:
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
790
9/14/2011
IP00078917
IP00078918
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
791
9/14/2011
IP00078919
IP00078920
2
792
9/14/2011
IP00078927
IP00078929
3
793
9/14/2011
IP00079614
IP00079614
1
794
12/31/2007
IP00079615
IP00079641
27
795
9/14/2011
IP00080288
IP00080288
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Counsel DeAnna Allen reflecting legal advice
(DeAnna Allen) and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Counsel Christopher Seamster reflecting legal
Schole LLP
advice and services. This document was
(Christopher
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
Schole LLP
legal advice and services. This document was
(Lawrence
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster)
Counsel
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff Legal document communicated as an
Attorney-Client; Attorney
Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
attachment of Document IP00079614 from Alex
Work Product
Shapiro LLP
Schole LLP
Berger to Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al.
(Charles
(Lawrence
reflecting legal advice and services. This
Monterio)
Rosenbloom;
document was prepared in anticipation of
Christopher
litigation.
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
Counsel Charles Monterio, et al. reflecting legal
(Charles
advice and services. This document was
Monterio; cc:
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Jeffrey Sherwood)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Page 146 of 149
To:
Description
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Charles Monterio reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Basis
Attorney-Client
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
796
9/14/2011
IP00080350
IP00080351
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
797
9/14/2011
IP00080352
IP00080353
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
798
9/14/2011
IP00080354
IP00080354
1
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
799
9/14/2011
IP00080355
IP00080356
2
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
800
9/15/2011
IP00080357
IP00080358
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
To:
Description
Basis
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth);
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth);
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth);
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
I/P Engine, Inc.
(Yoav Roth);
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom)
Counsel Dickstein
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Draft document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00080352 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
Draft document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00080352 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
Page 147 of 149
Attorney-Client; Common
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Interest
Counsel Charles Monterio, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
801
9/14/2011
IP00080359
IP00080360
2
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio); cc:
Counsel Ellenoff
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Christopher
Seamster)
802
9/15/2011
IP00080825
IP00080826
2
803
12/31/2007
IP00080827
IP00080853
27
804
9/15/2011
IP00081031
IP00081031
1
805
9/15/2011
IP00081243
IP00081243
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc.
Hudson Bay
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Capital GP LLC
(Counsel Scott
Black)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Page 148 of 149
To:
Description
Basis
Attorney-Client; Common
Legal document communicated as an
Interest
attachment of Document IP00080357 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Charles Monterio, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
Legal document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00080825 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Lawrence Rosenbloom, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
Attorney-Client; Common
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Interest
Counsel Scott Black reflecting legal advice and
services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Attorney-Client
Counsel Charles Monterio, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
I/P Engine Privilege Log - I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al., – CIVIL NO. 2:11-CV-00512 (E.D Va.)
Date Created
Doc ID Beg No
Doc ID End No
Pages
806
9/15/2011
IP00081290
IP00081290
1
807
9/15/2011
IP00081332
IP00081332
808
9/15/2011
IP00081333
809
9/16/2011
810
811
Description
Basis
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio; Jeffrey
Sherwood)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Charles Monterio, et al. reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Charles Monterio reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
IP00081334
2
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Charles
Monterio)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Charles Monterio reflecting legal
advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
IP00081481
IP00081481
1
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Christopher Seamster, et al. reflecting
legal advice and services. This document was
prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
11/2/2011
IP00081482
IP00081482
1
Draft document communicated as an
attachment of Document IP00081481 from Alex
Berger to Counsel Christopher Seamster, et al.
reflecting legal advice and services. This
document was prepared in anticipation of
litigation.
Attorney-Client
9/17/2011
IP00081542
IP00081542
1
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Ellenoff
(Alex Berger)
Grossman &
Schole LLP
(Lawrence
Rosenbloom;
Christopher
Seamster)
I/P Engine, Inc. I/P Engine, Inc. Counsel Dickstein
(Alex Berger)
(Alex Berger)
Shapiro LLP
(Bradley Wine)
Email communication from Alex Berger to
Counsel Bradley Wine reflecting legal advice
and services. This document was prepared in
anticipation of litigation.
Attorney-Client
CONFIDENTIAL OUTSIDE COUNSEL ONLY
Author:
From:
Page 149 of 149
To:
]]>
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
