I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL, Inc. et al
Filing
788
JURY TRIAL (DAY #15) completed on 11/6/2012 before District Judge Raymond A. Jackson. Attorneys Kenneth Brothers, Frank Ciminio, Jr., W. Ryan Snow, Donald Schultz, and Charles Monterio appeared on behalf of the Plaintiff. Andrew Perlman, Corporate Representative present. Attorneys David Nelson, David Perlson, and Stephen Noona, appeared on behalf of defendants AOL, Inc., Google Inc., IAC Search & Media, Inc., Gannett Company, Inc., and Target Corporation. Petit jurors (9) appeared pursuant to adjournment last evening 11/5/12. Court excused jurors to continue their deliberations at 10:04am. Out of the presence of the jury, court and counsel answered questions of the jury. Court ordered jury sequestered for lunch. Jury later returned with a verdict which was read into the record. Jurors excused. Court directed counsel to file any motions in accordance with the Rules of Civil Procedure. Judgment will issue once the Court makes a ruling on obviousness. Court adjourned. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit List, # 2 Witness List) (Court Reporter Sharon Borden, OCR.)(ptom) (Main Document 788 replaced on 11/7/2012) (ptom, ). Modified on 11/7/2012 to add language re: judgment(ptom, ).
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF VIRGINIA
Norfolk Division
EXHIBIT LIST
I/P Engine, Inc.
PLAINTIFF
V.
Case No: 2:11cv512
AOL Inc., et.al.
DEFENDANTS
PRESIDING JUDGE
COURTROOM DEPUTY
COURT REPORTER
Raymond A. Jackson
P. Thompson
Sharon Borden, OCR
HEARING DATE(S)
PLAINTIFF ATTORNEY(S) K. Brothers, J.
Sherwood, R. Snow, D. Rudenko, D. Schultz,
F. Cimino
DEFENDANT ATTORNEY(S) D. Nelson, D.
Perlson, E. O’Brien, S. Noona, D.
Bilsker, R. Nelson
10/16/12 – 10/30/12
PLF
NO.
DFT
NO.
DATE
Marked
Admitted
Offered
DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBITS
Andrew K Lang
PX
218
10/17/12
X
X
Investor summary of Empirical Media Corporation
12/21/95
PX3
“
“
X
X
5,867,799 Patent
PX1
“
“
X
X
6,314,420 Patent
PX2
“
“
X
X
6,775,664 Patent
PX
123
“
“
X
X
Lang – Lycos Nondisclosure and Developments
Agreement
PX
121
10/17/12
X
X
Patent 6,314,420 Assignment History
PX
416
“
“
X
X
7,647,242 Patent
“
“
X
X
File History for Patent 6,314,420
DX4
Donald M. Kosak
DX
303
10/17/12
X
X
Kosak consulting agreement dated 6/6/11
DX
305
“
X
X
Kosak consulting agreement dated 6/24/11
DX
17
10/17/12
X
X
Stock subscription agreement between Labrador
Search Corp. and Donald Kosak.
“
Jonathan Alferness (video deposition)
PX
228
10/18/12
X
X
Sealed Exhibit
PX
231
“
“
X
X
Product Communications Plan Landing Page Quality
PX
232
“
“
X
X
Google Adwords Help Document
(continued on page 2)
2:11cv512
I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL Inc., et.al.
Exhibits – Page 2 -
Dr. Ophir Frieder
PX
338
10/18/12
X
X
Quality Score – AdWords Help
PX
117
“
“
X
X
Varian Video Clip
PX
229
“
“
X
X
“The Life of a Dollar” A talk for Nooglers about
Google’s Ad System
PX
115
“
“
X
X
Google AdWords Help – Why does AdWords visit my
ad’s landing page?
PX7
“
“
X
X
SmartASS Prediction Model
PX
51
10/18/12
X
X
Understanding Search Ads Quality Presentation
8/26/08
PX
95
“
“
X
X
Extreme Data Mining: The Google Adwords and
Adsense Machine Learning Infrastructure
PX
55
“
“
X
X
Susan’s extended Staff: Ads Quality Presentation
1/20/09
PX
302
“
“
X
X
Marketing and Advertising Using Google – Targeting
Your Advertising to the Right Audience
PX
52
“
“
X
X
6111: How are ads ranked?
PX
357
10/18/12
X
X
An AdWords Help Page
PX
112
“
“
X
X
Google Learning Center – AdWords Help (2)
PX
21
“
“
X
X
About Quality Score
PX
22
“
“
X
X
Ad Rank Formulas
PX
40
“
“
X
X
12/5/07 email from C. Bavor to K. Hansen
PX
46
“
“
X
X
12/14/07 email from K. Hansen to M. O’connor re:
Change to Quality Score FAQ
PX
180
10/18/12
X
X
6,269,361 Patent
(continued on page 3)
2:11cv512
I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL Inc., et.al.
Exhibits – Page 3 -
Dr. Ophir Frieder cont’d
PX
330
10/19/12
X
X
Sealed Exhibit
PX
227
“
“
X
X
Sealed Exhibit
PX
333
“
“
X
X
Sealed Exhibit
PX
332
“
“
X
X
Sealed Exhibit
PX
331
10/19/12
X
X
Sealed Exhibit
PX
111
10/22/12
X
X
Google Learning Center-AdWords Help
PX
249
10/22/12
X
X
2008 Google Ads Narratives
Jonathan Alferness(Video Deposition)
PX
251
10/23/12
X
X
Building Our Partnership Presentation
Derek Leslie-Cook (Video Deposition)
PX
349
10/23/12
X
X
Google Ads Quality Explained, SES
PX
255
10/23/12
X
X
Google 10/3/11 Document by Derek Cook & David
Arthur
Kevin Cotter (Video Deposition)
PX
242
10/23/12
X
X
IAC Google Services Agreement
James Christopherson (Video Deposition)
PX
260
10/23/12
X
X
Google Services Agreement
PX
261
10/23/12
X
X
Google Services Agreement Order Form
(continued on page 4)
2:11cv512
I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL Inc., et.al.
Exhibits – Page 4 -
Dr. Stephen L. Becker
PX
64
10/23/12
X
X
Page 38 of the presentation
PX
34
“
“
X
X
Video
PX
32
“
“
X
X
Video
PX
337
“
“
X
X
SmartAds PCTR Model Reliability Design
Jonathan Alferness
PX
176
10/24/12
X
X
Google Inside AdWords – Answers to your keyword
state questions 7/18/05
Dr. Lyle Ungar
DX
91
X
X
U.S. Patent No. 7,130,808
DX
92
“
“
X
X
U.S. Patent No. 7,415,423
DX
50
“
“
X
x
“Content-Based, Collaborative Recommendation,” by
M. Balabanovic & Y. Shoham
DX
49
“
“
X
X
“Feature Guided Automated Collaborative
Filtering,” by Y. Z. Lashkari Master’s Thesis
DX
34
“
“
X
X
U.S. Patent No. 6,202,058
DX
59
10/25/12
X
X
U.S. Patent No. 6,185,558
DX
58
PX
5
10/25/12
10/25/12
X
X
U.S. Patent No. 6,006,222
10/26/12
X
X
6,775,664 File History
(continued on page 5)
2:11cv512
I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL Inc., et.al.
Exhibits – Page 5 -
Dr. Keith Ugone
DX
19
10/26/12
X
X
Patent Purchase and License Agreement between
Smart Search Labs and Lycos
DX
90
10/26/12
X
X
Patent License Agreement between Google and Carl
Meyer
10/31/12
X
X
Excerpt of Google Inc., Securities and Exchange
Commission Form S-1 Registration Statement
PX
447
Dr. Jaime Carbonell
PX
434
10/31/12
X
X
The TREC-4 Filtering Track
DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBITS
PDX
149
10/16/12
DDX
1.1
.65
X
Slides used with Plaintiff’s opening statement
10/16/12
X
Slides used with Defendant’s opening statement
Andrew Perlman
PDX
51
10/17/12
DDX
10.
1 .2
X
Vringo, Inc. company chart
10/17/12
X
Slides used with testimony of Mr. Perlman
(continued on page 6)
2:11cv512
I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL Inc., et.al.
Exhibits – Page 6 -
Donald M. Kosak
DDX
1.1
8
X
Slide used with testimony of Mr. Kosak
Dr. Ophir Frieder
PDX
5284
10/18/12
X
Slides used with testimony of Dr. Frieder
PDX
8797
“
X
Slides used with testimony of Dr. Frieder
PDX
107
10/19/12
X
Slides used with testimony of Dr. Frieder
PDX
123
129
10/22/12
X
Slides used with testimony of Dr. Frieder
PDX
98
99
10/22/12
X
Slides used with testimony of Dr. Frieder
PDX
101
105
“
“
X
Slides used with testimony of Dr. Frieder
PDX
108
117
“
“
X
Slides used with testimony of Dr. Frieder
PDX
119
–
122
“
“
X
Slides used with testimony of Dr. Frieder
PDX
130
–
148
“
“
X
Slides used with testimony of Dr. Frieder
“
“
X
Grill Google Search Page
DDX
4.12
“
(continued on page 7)
2:11cv512
I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL Inc., et.al.
Exhibits – Page 7 -
Dr. Ophir Frieder cont’d
DDX
4.2
–
4.4
“
DDX
4.6
10/22/12
“
X
Slides used with testimony of Dr. Frieder
X
Slide used with testimony of Dr. Frieder
Dr. Stephen L. Becker
PDX
53
–
55
10/23/12
X
Slides used with testimony of Dr. Becker
PDX
58
83
“
X
Slides used with testimony of Dr. Becker
X
Slides used with testimony of Dr. Becker
DDX
5.2
–
5.7
“
10/24/12
Jonathan Alferness
DDX
7.1
10/24/12
X
Slide used with testimony of Mr. Alferness
DDX
7.4
–
7.7
“
X
Slides used with testimony of Mr. Alferness
DDX
7.9
10/24/12
X
Slide used with testimony of Mr. Alferness
“
Bartholomew Furrow
DDX
12.1
10/24/12
X
Slide used with testimony of Mr. Furrow
(continued on page 8)
2:11cv512
I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL Inc., et.al.
Exhibits – Page 8 -
Dr. Lyle Ungar
DDX
2.2
–
2.9
10/24/12
X
Slides used with infringement testimony of
Dr. Ungar
DDX
2.11
–
2.21
“
X
Slides used with infringement testimony of
Dr. Ungar
DDX
2.25
–
2.36
10/24/12
X
Slides used with infringement testimony of
Dr. Ungar
DDX
2.42
–
2.49
10/25/12
X
Slides used with proprietary testimony of
Dr. Ungar (SEALED)
DDX
2.35
–
2.40
“
“
X
Slides used with infringement testimony of
Dr. Ungar
DDX
2.50
–
2.57
“
“
X
Slides used with infringement testimony of
Dr. Ungar
DDX
2.59
–
2.62
“
“
X
Slides used with infringement testimony of
Dr. Ungar
DDX
2.64
–
2.81
10/25/12
X
Slides used with infringement testimony of
Dr. Ungar
DDX
3.2
–
3.32
10/25/12
X
Slides used with validity testimony of Dr. Ungar
DDX
3.37
–
3.40
10/25/12
X
Slides used with validity testimony of Dr. Ungar
DDX
3.42
–
3.57
10/25/12
X
Slides used with validity testimony of Dr. Ungar
DDX
3.59
–
3.60
10/25/12
X
Slides used with validity testimony of Dr. Ungar
“
(continued on page 9)
2:11cv512
I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL Inc., et.al.
Exhibits – Page 9 -
Dr. Lyle Ungar cont’d
DDX
3.62
– 3.
129
X
Slides used with validity testimony of Dr. Ungar
10/25/12
PDX
252
10/25/12
X
Slides used with validity testimony of Dr. Ungar
Dr. Keith Ugone
DDX
15.1
–
15.1
4
10/26/12
X
Slides used with testimony of Dr. Ugone
DDX
15.
19 –
15.
23
10/26/12
X
Slides used with testimony of Dr. Ugone
DDX
15.
24
10/30/12
X
Slides used with testimony of Dr. Ugone
DDX
15.
27
“
X
Slides used with testimony of Dr. Ugone
DDX
15.
29
10/30/12
X
Slides used with testimony of Dr. Ugone
“
Dr. Jaime Carbonell
PDX
253
–
298
10/31/12
X
Slides used with testimony of Dr. Carbonell
(continued on page 10)
2:11cv512
I/P Engine, Inc. v. AOL Inc., et.al.
Exhibits – Page 9 -
PDX
401
–
441
11/1/12
X
Slides used with Plaintiff’s closing argument
PDX
443
–
444
“
X
Slides used with Plaintiff’s closing argument
PDX
447
455
“
“
X
Slides used with Plaintiff’s closing argument
DDX
17.1
–
17.1
9
“
“
X
Slides used with Defendant’s closing argument
DDX
17.2
1 –
17.2
6
“
“
X
Slides used with Defendant’s closing argument
DDX
17.2
8 –
17.3
4
“
“
X
Slides used with Defendant’s closing argument
DDX
17.3
6 –
17.3
8
11/1/12
X
Slides used with Defendant’s closing argument
“
Black Binder containing Sealed Material
Black Binder containing Plaintiffs’ Video
Deposition Transcripts
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?