Howard v. Abingdon Virginia

Filing 13

MEMORANDUM OPINION dismissing complaint without prejudice. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 9/19/12. (ejs)

rlppœs OFFI U. DI rnlr
CE S. ST. - I
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FIBB
L

I TH E U N I
N
TED STA TE S D I
STR I C O U R T
CT
FO R TH E W ESTER N DI
STR I T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
A BI G D O N D I I O N
N
V SI
A ND R E J.H O W A RD e al ,
t .

SEF 19 2 1
22
JULI C. UD P(CLERK
A
BY:
r GRK
d

C i lA c i N o.1: 2c
vi t on
1 v00035

Pl nt f s
ai i f ,
M EM O R AND UM O PI IO N
N

A BI G D O N V I G I I I
N
R N A N
W A SH I G TO N C O U N TY ,
N
D ef
endant
.

By:Sam ue G . is
l W l on
U nie St t sD i t c Judge
t d a e s ri t

Thi i a a ton bypr s pl n ifA nd e J H owa d1a d a i e e m i t num be of
s s n ci
o e ai tf
r .
r
r n n nd t r na e

Howad' fm iyme r a ns t t ofAbi on, r ni, alegi (mongot
r s a l mbes gai t he own
ngd Vigi az l ng n
her
t ngsno i ditl cea)t tt dee nt ha tke a ntgeofmi ii a t i
hi
t mme aey l r ha he fnda s ve a n dva a
nortes nd her

p o e t sf rp o i.Ho r s e s$ ,0 ,0 frp i a ds f rn a a ij cin
r p ri o r ft wad e k 35 00 0 o an n ufeig, nd n nun to
e
or e i t t w n t S om pl t a co i .. m ai e nc ofTa orH il sr e l e .'
d r ng he o o l
c
e e nd ntnue . nt na e
yl
l' ed ve opm nt'

Abi
ngdonha move t dim isHowa d' c
s
d o s s
r s ompl i f f iur t sae acai .Howa d' tme
ant or al e o t t l m
r si

1Howa dhasa e e i tac rcor i t fde a co t. SeeHowa dv. ehoditHos Sys,Ci l
r
n xtnsve r k e d n he e r l urs
r M t s p. . vi

Acin1-521 2, t*-6( D. x De .1 , 0 5 ($ tels d cd , deJ e Ho r h sfldtnlws t
t 40 - 4 a 1 S. Te . c 3 2 0 ) $n h at e a e An r o l wad a i e a ui
o
l
e
s
i t sco t ...Openco t havelm is, Howa dha r c t m ....H owa dwilbepr cl
n hi ur.
urs
i t and
r s ea hed he
r l
e udedfom flng
r ii

a ohe lws ii ti c u t ndisajmcsu tl eh sa v n ewrt np r sino tij d ea du tl eh s
n t ra utn hs o r a t dt t nih a d a c ie emiso f hs u g n nih a
t
ma eg o -at p y nso hi c s a dsncin o iain h r a di tec u t fa pe l.)
d o dfi a me t n s o t n a t s bl to s ee n n h o r o p ash.
h
o
g
'
2I i notw holy ce whehe H owa di ende t na eW a hi t n Couny,V igi a i t ss t The
ts
l lar t r
r nt d o m
s ng o
t r ni n hi ui.
ca in ofHowa d' compl ntlssû ngdonV igi ai W as ngt Couny'ast s epa t a Howa dhas
pto
r s
ai it t
Abi
r ni n
hi on
t ' he ol ry, nd
r
nota e dhi compli .H o e ,i a r t Howa date ptd t s r W as ngt Count byha
m nde s
ant w ver t ppea s hat
r tm e o e ve
hi on
y
nddelve i as
i rng umm onst t W as ngt Coun yCo m isone ofReve
o he
hi on
t m si r
nue.Co e f rW as ngt Co t ha
uns l o
hi on uny s
m a as cila a a et i or Howa dandt c tha i Howa d i fcti e
de pe a ppe r nc o nf m
r
he our t t f
r n a ntndedt s t c y,s vc
o ue he ount er ie

o po eswa n n o la twi F d rl l o CiiPo e ue4j( )a dVigni Co ej8013 02.S eF d.
f rc s s o c mpin t e ea Rue f vl rc d r ()2 n r i a d . -0 . e e
h
R. v P. j()A)( Ct sae amu cp l op rto , r n oh rsaece tdg v r me tl r a iain
Ci. 4()2 ( -B) A tt, niia c r oain o a y te tt-rae o en na o g nz to
ta i sbe tos imu t esr e b :A) eieigac p o tes mmo sa do tec mpan t i c if
h ts u jc t ut s b ev d y ( d l rn o y fh u n n f h o lito t he
v
s
e e uieo scr o ( sr igac p o e c i tema n rpe cie b ta sae' 1w frsrigas mmo s
x c tv f e; r B) evn o y f a h n h n e rsrb d y h t tt s a o evn u n
o I epo eso sc ad fn a t'; r i aCo ej80 -0 2(e urn sr ieo pocs o teCo ny
r i rc s n u h ee d n.lVigni d .13 0. rq iig e vc f r es n h u t
k
'
Aton yo Co n at sAton y.Wh me e Ho r itn e t s e hic mpan sae nocam a ant
tr e r mmo we l
h' tre ) o v r wad ne d d o u , s o lit tts li g is
a pa t
ny ry.

t r pond ha e a e a t ma tri rpef rde ii Viwi Ho a d' compl nti t
o es
s lps d, nd he te s i o cson. e ng w r s
ai n he
lghtm os f vor e t hi , he co ti wholy una e t di c n a pl i e cl i t r le a
i
t a abl o m t
ur s
l
bl o s er
aus bl a m o e i f nd
3

wilh r fr ds s t i ma trwih u p eu ie
l teeo e imis h s t t o t rj dc .
e
Fe rlRul ofCi lPr ed e8()2)rquiesats t ndpli sae ntoft cai
dea e
vi oc ur a( e r çhor a an ttme
he l m
s ngt tt pl de i e ildt rlef' Fed. Ci P.8a( .Thi fmiirr l i
howi ha he ea r s ntte o ei .
'
R. v. ()2) s a la ue s
gr a l r l xe f pr sepl ntfs a ltga t wih me iorouscl m ss d notbe sym id
e ty e a d oç o
ai if, nd ii n s t rt i
ai houl
t e

bytcmia r e ofpl di Se Be udetv. t ofHn on,775F. 1 1
e l c l uls ea ng. e a t Civ
mpt
2d 274, 277-78(t
4h
Ci.1 5) Ther a tonofRul 8()2)i nothowe , t tlmis.A co tmus bea e
r 98 .
elxai
e a( s , verwihou i t
ur t bl
t di c r f om t com pl ntt pa te be ng s d a t a l ed c
o s e n r he
ai he r i s i ue nd he leg onduc on whi h e h c ai
t
c ac l m
r s s Tho h r l xed,t s a r s ilde a ge r c r nc and i do no r quie
et.
ug e a
he t nda d tl m nds ne al ohe e e,
t es t e r

c u t Eoc n u eu q e to sn v rs u rl p e e tdt te ' l a 1 7
o rs d o j r p u sin e e q aey r sn e o h m. d. t 2 8.
t
'
I hi c pl i ,H ow a d ha a t m pt t de c i Abi
n s om a nt
r s te ed o s r be ngdon' a l ge w r
s le d ongsaga ns a
i t

n l rofAbi n r sde s Among ot t ngs hem e i Abi
lmbe
ngdo e i nt .
her hi ,
ntons ngdon' r t lai f a
s e ai ton or n
ol un i wae bil aneghbor
d, pad tr l; i
hood E ra n byt Ciy a Count t e ur t t
s tke
ove
he t nd
y o ns e ha
m i ii s no l ra e t prm a y ow ne s ofs d pr pe tes' a l c ofr m a n e nc
norte
onge r he i r
r
ai o r i '; a k oad i t na e;
w r ulc l c i ofpr r y t xe ;z ng;s i lc tons s op a f i ks na i
ongf ole ton
ope t a s oni oc a ondii ' t nd r s ; tonhood;
,
e lpr e i a ag di c i i ton. Atno poi ,
qua ot cton; nd e s r m na i
nt howe r doe H o ar a s m bl a
ve , s w d s e e

c he e cli t r le .Notonl i i difc tt a c rai t lgalt ore on whih Howa d
o r nt am o e if
y s t fi ul o s e t n he e he i s
c
r
r les i i i
ei ,t s mpos i et gl n f c ua s
sbl o ea a t l uppor f a s h lga t ore . W hiet plad ng
t or ny uc e l he i s
l he e i
r l sd noti
ue o
mpos a exa tng sa r on Howa d, m us ofe s m ef hol on whi h
e n c i tnda d
r he
t f r o oot d
c

3 s rieaRue1 ( ()moin tepedigmutc nançn u hfcst saeacam t rl fh t
To u vv
l 2b)6 t ,h la n s o ti ç o g a t o tt li o ei ta
o
e
e
i pa sbl o i fc . Bel lCop. Two l 5 0U. 5 4 5 0( 0 ) ctto o t d.Co t mu t
s lu i e n t a e' lAt. l v. mbv, 5 S. 4 , 7 20 7 (iain mit ) m' s
s
'
e
s
l eal c nsrerr s c mpans Erc s nv. r u , 51U. 8 , 4(0 7, nda c p tecama tsfcu l
i r l o tu o e o lit, ik o Pad e 5 S. 9 9 2 0 )a ce th li n ' ata
b y
alg to sa tu .He Gru . v. t o N. ,l 0S Ct9 3 9 6 8 ( 0.Ho v rti tn ti
le ain s r e mi o p LLC Civ f Y. 3 . . 8 , 8 - 7 201 ) we e,hs e e s
tna ia et lgalc usons Thr dba er ial oft elme sofaca eofa ton,s
< pplc bl o e oncl i . ea r ect s he e nt
i
us
ci upporedbyme e
t
r

c n ls r sae ns d n tsfke' As cot .q a,5 6U. 6 2, 7 (0 9 .
o cu oy ttme t, o o u f . h rf v Ib l 5 S. 6 6 8 2 0 )
'
2

Abn d n c nb s a a s ro o wh c tec u t a b s aj g n .Ac o dn l ,h c u t
ig o a a e n n we r n ih h o r c n a e ud me t c r ig y t e o r
wilds s Howad' comp1i wihoutprj c f fiur t saeac1i 4
l imis
rs
ant t
eudie or al e o tt am.
EN TER :Se e be 1 201
pt m r 9, 2.

/ <
UN I
TED STA TES DISTR I J DG E
CT U

4Thecour dipe esw ih o alagum e be aus t fct a lgalc e i ar ade t yprs ntd
t s ns
t r r
nt c e he a s nd e ontntons e quael e e e

i temaeil b fr t c u ta ag me t udn tadted cso a po es S eLo a Rul 1 ()Ct
n h tras eo e he o r, nd ru n wo l o i h e iin l rc s. e c l e lb l
n
a c r a c wihFe e a Rul o Ci iPr c d r 7 ( ) t Co r ma d tr n amo in wih u a o a
c o d n e t d r l e f vl o e u e 8 b ,he u t y ee mi e
t
o to t n rl
h aig'.
e rn .)
'