Mitchell v. Jenkins et al

Filing 11

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 4/30/2013. (lml)

CLERK S OFFI U. . ST.
CE S DI COURT
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

THE UM TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN D I
STR I O F VI G I I
CT
R N A
A BI G D O N DI I O N
N
V SI
JEA N K .M I
TCH ELL,

APR 32 2 1
23
J A
ULI
BK

DU L , ERK
CL

Ci lA c i N o.1: 3c
vi t on
1 v00003

D ebt A ppelant
orl ,

M EM O M ND U M O PI O N
NI

V.

R O BER T JEN K I e al,
NS t .
A ppelees.
l

By:Sam ue G .W is
l
l on
U nied St es D itri Judge
t
at
s ct

Thi i a a lplrua t 28U. C.j158byt de or J a K. ic l,i a
s s n ppea zs nt o
S.
he bt , e n M thel n
Cha e 1 ba u c c e fo t Ba nz c Cour' ove r lng ofM ic l' sa eof
pt r 3 nkr pt y as , r m he nk pt y
ts r u i
t he ls t mt

l tto so j cint acam a sre b c e io s h rb oh ri lw a d sse-n lw, b r
i ain b e to o li se td y r dt r, e r t e-n-a n itri-a Ro e t
mi
G. n Nik M . e k n .Afe t eBa k p c Co r o er ldt eJ nkn 'o j cinsa d
a d c i J n i s tr h n nlty u t v rue h e is be to n
M ic l a ald,heJ nki decdedno t ptr uet i c am a m o d t dim isi.
thel ppe e t e ns i
t o ls her l i nd ve o s s t
De piet tf c ,M ic l ha fl abrefa nci a ar lm e o t m e is cai ngt t
s t ha a t thel s ied i dva ng n gz nt n he rt , l mi ha
he a a i no m oo ,a a g ng t ts hassa ng. TheCha e 1 t se ha r s nde
r ppe l s t
t nd r ui ha he
t ndi
pt r 3 m t e s e po d
wih abre as e tng M ic l l kssa ngbec us s Ewilpa t s m en ounti t ca e
t
if s ri
t he l ac t ndi
a e he i l y he a
m
n he s
r gar e soft out om eoft a al'butsdi wih M ic l on t que ton ofmoot s
e dls
he c
he ppe ,'
i ng t t he l he si
nes
be us ,hear s unde Fe r Rul ofBa pt y Pr e e3006,ac e t m a not
ca e
gue ,
r de al e
nknz c oc dur
r dior y
w ihdr w a c ai w ihoutco ta oval1
t a
lm t
ur ppr .

'Fede a Rul ofBa pty Pr dur 3006 r ds
rl e
nknz c oce e
ea :
A c e t rma wihdr acai asofrg by flng ano i ofwihd a l e pta pr de i
r dio y t aw l m
iht ii
tce
t r wa, xce s ovi d n

ti r l.l atrace io h sfldap o fo cam a o j cini fldteeoo ac mpliti
hs ue f fe rdtr a ie ro f li n be to s i h rt r o an s
e
tld a an tta ce i ri a a v rayp o e dn ,o tece io h sa cp e o rj ce te
ie g is h t rdt n n d esr r c e ig r h rdtr a c e td r ee td h
o
pln or ot r s haspa tcpa e sgnika l i t ca e,t c e t ma no wihdr w t
a
he wie
rii t d i t nty n he s he r dior y t t a he
cli exc o or roft cour aRe ahea i on notc t t kuse o de ori poses i
am
ept n de
he
t r
rng
ie o he t e r bt n s son,

a d a yce tr' o te ee tdpus a tt j7 5a o a p ne p ru n t j 1 0 o te
n n rdi s c mmite lce ru n o 0 () r p oitd u s a t o l 2 f h
o
Code. The or oft cour s lco an s h tr sa condii ast cou dee spr pe .
der he
t hal nt i uc e m nd
tons he rt m
o r
Unl st co tor r ot r s ,a a ho iedwihdr walofa cam s lconsiu ewihdr wa
es he ur de s he wie n ut rz
t a
li hal
ttt t a l

o a yrltda cpa eo rjcino apln.
f n eae c e tnc r eeto f a

M ic el a t b r e o d mo srtn aj tca l is ef ra p a.S emu ts o
th l h s he u d n f e n taig usiib e su o p e l h s h w
t s hassa ng a t tt r i alvec r ry,o t ti notm oot I t Ba
hat he
t ndi nd ha he e s i ontove s ne ha s
. f he nknmt y
c
Cour g ant t J nki pe ng m oton t w ihdr t i cl m ,i i di fc tt s e how t s
t r s he e ns' ndi
i o t aw he r ai t s f i ul o e
hi

s e i yate t d a a woul havepr e e anyt ng butahypot tc lque to o
e m ngl tnua e ppe l
d
es nt d
hi
hei a
si n r

o tie a yt n b ta a v s r o nin Un rtecru tn e , o pupo e o j dca
b an d n hig u n d io y pi o . de h ic msa c s fr r s s f u iil
ec
onomy, fc e y,a t pr ntt unne s ar us ofr s
efi i nc nd o eve he
ce s y e e omves t co twilr ma t s
, he ur l e nd hi
ca e t t Ba u c Cour t r e o t J nki 'm o i n t wihdr w t i cli .
s o he nkr pt y
t o ul n he e ns to o t a her am
EN TER : prl30,201
A i
3.

Z
UN I
TED STA TES D I
STR I J GE
CT UD