Leonard v. Electro-Mechanical Corporation
Filing
25
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 6/17/2014. (lab)
G ERKS OFFI t..DI COURT
CE 1S SK
AT > 0G ,
>
F1
I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
FO R THE W ESTERN D I
STRI OF V I GW I
CT
R
A
A BI G D ON D I I ON
N
V SI
21
26
J
%
BK
C DU tc CLER
u
.
K
HA RO LD L LEON ARD ,
Ci lActon N o.1: 3CV 00029
vi
i
1
Pl ntf s
ai if
M EM O M ND U M O PIN IO N
ELECTRO - ECH AN I
M
CAL CO RPOR ATI ,
ON
H o Gl n E.Conr d
n. e
a
Chi fU nie St t D i ti tJ
e
t d a es sr c udge
Def nt
enda .
OnAp i 5 2 1 ,h c u t r ne s mmayj d me ti fv ro t d fnd n o te
rl , 0 4 t e o r g a td u r u g n n a o f he ee a t n h
pli ifscamst rt Ame ia wihDia lte Ac (
antf li mde he rc ns t s biiis t ADA) 42U. C.jj1 01 1 1
,
S.
21 - 21 7,
a t Fa l a M e ca Lea Ac (
nd he miy nd di l ve t FMLA) 29U. C.jj2601265 Thepli ifha now
,
S.
- 4.
antf s
move t ale ora ndt j me unde Rul 5 e oft FedealRul ofCi lPr e e.
d o tr me he udg nt r e 9() he
r
es
vi oc dur
Fort f l ng r a ons t m o i w ilbe de ed.
he olowi e s , he ton l
ni
d Rul 5 e)motonma begrntdonl i t eest tons i1 t a co
&
A e 9(
i
y
a e y n hr iuai : () o c mmodaea
t n
i ewe ngc ngei contoli lw;( t ac ountfrne e de notavalbl g evi l ;
ntl ni ha n r lng a 2) o c
o w vi nce
ia e pr ousyl
o ()t c re tace rer ro 1w o p e n ma ie tnusie' M a fedv. tl sn fr
r 3 o o r c la ro f a r rve t n fs ij tc .' y il Na' As ' o
'
St kCa AuoRa na,l ,67 F. 369,378( h Ci.201 ( tngZi ndv. own,478
oc r t ci nc. 4 3d
4t r 2) quoi nka
Br
F. 634,637( h Ci.2007). il i a e ror nayrme t ts ul bea i s rngl '
3d
4t r
) st s n xta di r e dy ha ho d ppled pai y,'
a onl i i xc ptona cic s a e .' I Ther eC a no beus t r ltga e o1 m a t r ,
nd y n t e i l r um t nc s ' d.
e
ul k y t
m
ed o e ii t d te s
ort r s a g e sorpr e e de t tc d ha be n r s d prort t en r of
o ai e r um nt
es nt vi nce ha oul ve e ai e i o he t y
j me . ExxonShi n:Co. Ba r 5 U. 471 48 n. ( )(ntr lctto a
udg nt'
'
ppi
v. ke , 54 S. , 6 5 2008 i ena iain nd
quotto maksomitd .
ain r
te )
Appl ngt eprncpls t co tc l
yi hes i i e , he ur oncudest tt pl ntf i note il t r le
ha he ai if s
ntted o e if
unde Rul 59( . I hi moi t plitf as t c torc i risr lngt ta
r e e) n s ton,he anif ks he our t e onsde t ui ha n
i d p n e tme ia e a n to rq ie b t ed fnd n wa l b r ltda dc nsse t t
n e e d n d c l x miain e u rd y h ee a t s jo -eae n o itn wi
h
busnes ne esiy.' See42U. C.j1 1 d)4)A) Howe r t pli ifdoesnotpoitt
i s c st '
S.
21 2( ( ( .
ve ,he antf
n o
a r e c nge i t c r lng l ,
ny ec nt ha
n he ontoli aw newl d s
y i cove e e de e,o cl re r w hi h w oul
r d vi nc r ea r or c
d
m e i an ale a i ora e en t t c tso ni n a or r l t a he m e e y a t m pt t
rt
t r ton m ndm t o he our ' pi o nd de . ns e d,
r l te s o
ditnguih hi c efom s m eoft ect d by t c t W hiet pt i ifma di a e wih
si s s as r
o
hos ie
he our.
l he antf y s gr e t
t c tsde sonont sis t r diag e me doe nots ppo taRul 59()moton.
he our' cii
hi sue,s e s r e nt s
me
u r
e e
i '
'
Huthi onv. aon, 4F. 1 1 2( hCi.1 4s ealoPrthadv.W a- r St e ,
c ns Stt 99 2d 076, 08 4t r 993) e s ic r
lMa t ors
l c, F. p' 5 , 3( t Ci. 01 (k h ntemoi n(o rc n i eain . . r l rq ss
n .3 Ap x 2 5 4h r20 ) k e h to f r e o sd rto ) . meey e ue t
W
t dititc torc i ral lis ort iha ismi 'rle i nota t i d.'
he src our t e onsde ega sue o c nge t nd, eif s uhorze '
)
( i Unie Sttsv.W ila ,67 F. 31 31 (t Ci.1 ) Acc di y,he
quotng td ae
lims 4 2d 0, 2 4h r 982). or ngl t
pl ntf smoi t atrora ndt s
ai if ton o le me he ummayj me r i wilbede e
r udg nt ulng l
nid.
The Cl r i di e t t s nd c r ii c e oft sm em or ndum o ni a t
e k s r c ed o e e tfed opi s hi
a
pi on nd he
a co pa ng or rt a1 couns ofr c d.
c m nyi
de o l
el e or
ENTER:Thi i' da ofJ ,201
s '
1
y une
4.
Chi fU nie St t sD i t i tJ e
e
t d a e s rc udg
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?