Brickey v. Hall et al
Filing
64
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 3/3/2017. (lml)
CL S OFFI U. DI COURT
ERK'
CE S. SX
ATROANQI ,
V VA
FIED
L
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
A BI GD ON D I SI
N
VI ON
MA2 C3 2 1
27
J
U
BY:
M N DA LL E.BRI EY ,
CK
Pl i if
antf,
. DL JL
0 R ERK
UW CL
ERK
Ci lAc i N o.1 1
vi ton
: 3CV00073
M EM O M N DU M O PI
NION
By:
Hon. e E.Co a
Gln
m d.
Chi fUnie Stt sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge
ROBB H ALL,
De e nt
f nda .
Thi ca e a ies fom pl i if Ra l Brc s t r na i n fom t Sat il Polce
s s rs r
antf nda l ikey' e mi to r
he lvle i
De a t n ($PD' f lo n t p b iain o Brc y' rs o s st q e to spo e t hm
p rme t $ ' o lwig he u lc to f ike s e p n e o u si n s d o i
S )
by l alne pa r dtrng hi Town Counci c m pa g Brc fld t scvi aci n unde 42
oc
ws pe s li
s
l a i n. ikey ie hi i l to
r
U. C.j 1 a ns s ve a me r oft SPD a t SalvleTownCounci,algi t t
S.
983 gai t e r l mbes he
nd he til
l le ng ha
hi t r nai co tt e ar t it y dic r i vi ai oft Fis Ame e . ca ei
s e mi ton nsiut d eala or s ha ge n ol ton he rt
ndm nt The s s
p e e tyb fr t ec u t nt d fn a t bHalsbl o c ss tldp ru n t Ru e5 d ()
rs n l e o e h o r o he ee d n Ro l' i f o t,se u s a t o l 4() 1
l
oft Fe r lRul s of Ci lPr ed e Fort r a ons t tf l t c twila r t
he de a
e
vi oc ur .
he e s
ha olow, he our l wa d he
de e ntcossi t a ot of$1,20.
f nda
t n he m mt
6 90.
ProceduralH i oa
st
On Se e r2,201 t c ur de e i pa ta gr nt d i pa t hedef nda s m oton
pt mbe
4, he o t ni d n r nd a e n r t
e nt ' i
fr s mmmy j d me t As a rs l,ald fnd ns wih t e e c pin o Ro b Hal wee
o u
u g n.
e ut 1 ee a t, t h x e to f b
l, r
dim is d fom t ca e Hal fl aN o ie ofAppea ,s e ng r vi w oft c r ' de a of
s s e r he s . l ied
tc
l e ki e e
he ou ts ni l
s mmayj d me tta wa b s do t d tnniain ta Halwa no s ed dbyq aiid
u r u g n h t s a e n he ee n to h t l s t hil e
ul e
f
i
mmuniy. Unie Stt sCour o Appeasf rt Fourh Cic tr ve s d a r m a d,a
t The t d ae
tf
l o he
t r ui e r e nd e nde nd
hedta Hal se tte t q aiidi nt . Au u t , 01 ,hec tt i alnaj d me t
l h t lwa n ild o u lfe mmu iy On g s 5 2 6 t ou n i lu g n
o d r e tr ds mmayj d me ti fvo o Hal
r e, n ee u r u g n n a r f l.
The ca e i no be or t c ton t def nda ' r ques f a a r ofc t i t
s s w f e he our
he e nts e t or n wa d
oss n he
a o mtof$2, 70.The tme t r s nd t Hal' bilofcossha lps d,a pl ntf ha not
m t
466.
i o e po o ls l
t s a e nd ai if s
i c t d a opposton.Them a tri rpef rr viw .
ndi a e ny
ii
te s i o e e
Sum m aa oft A pplc e Law
he
i abl
G e Rue5 () 1 o t eFe e a Rue o Ci l o e u e c ssGh u db alwe t
l r l 4 d () f h d r l ls f viPr c d r , o t s o l e l d o
und
o
t pr vaii pary'unl saf der lsa t pr de ot r s .' ila sv.M er LieI .Co.
he e lng t
es e a tm e ovi s he wi e'W lim
to f ns
,
6 9F.d 6 2, 3 (t Ci. 1 )( u t Fe . Ci P. 4 d ( ). u ,h l l ç r ae t e
0 3 2 6 6 4 h r 20 0 q oi d R. v. 5 ( )1) Th s te ' e G e ts h
ng
u c
pr s p i n t tc t a et bea de t t pr vaii pa t 'Che r v.Chn pi I ' Cor ,
e um to ha oss r o war d o he e lng ry.' ry
m on ntl p.
1 6F.d4 2, 4 (t Ci. 9 9 . t ug t c u t a t edsr to t d n a a r o c t,
8 3 4 4 6 4 h r 1 9 )Al h he o r h s h icei n o e y n wad f oss
ho
i mus ç ri ult s m e good r as f rdoi s ' i o de t io r om et pr s
t
t ç tc a e o
a
e on o
ng o, n r r o çve c
'
he e umpton. I
i ' d.
'
( tr a ctto so te ) Th p riu a e pe s sta ma betx da c ssl e Ru e5 ( )1
i en l i in mitd . e a t lr x n e h t y a e s o t md r l 4 d ( )
n
a
c
a estf t i 28U. C.j19 Thatsa epr de ,i pe tne pa tasf l :
r e orh n
S.
20.
tmt ovi s n ri nt r, olows
A j d eo cek o a yc u t f h Uni dS ae ma tx a c sst ef lo n
u g r lr f n o r o t e t tts y a s o t h o lwig:
e
()
1
Fe so t eceka dmas l
e f h lr n rha;
()
2
Fe sf rp itdo ee to ial rc r e ta cit n c sa iy
e o rn e r lcr nc l e o d d rns rp s e e s rl
y
obt i f rus i t ca e;
aned o e n h: s
()
3
Fe sa ds t sme t f rp itn a dwin se ;
e nd ib l e n s o rn ig n t e s s
r
()
4
Fe sf re mpiiaina dt ec sso ma n c p e o a y
e o xe ltc to n h o t f kig o is f n
m ae i l whe 't c e a ene s miy obt i f us i t
t ra s r he opi s r ce s l
e
aned Qr e n he
cas
e;
D oc tf e unde s c i 1 oft stte a
ke e s
r e ton 923 hi il ; nd
()
6
Co e aino c u'a p itde p rs c mp nsto o
mp nsto f o t p on e x e t, o e ain f
t
i epr tr ,a s a i s f es e ns , nd c t ofs i
nt r e e s nd alre , e , xpe es a oss pecal
i e pr tto s r i esunde s c i 18 oftzstte.
nt r e ai n e v c
r e ton 28 li il
28U. C.j19
S.
20.
D i si
scus on
I t i c s ,te d fnd n ' b l o c ssicud s ( )$8 5.0 i fe pad t ap t
n h s a e h ee a ts il f o t n l e : 1 4 8 n e s i o dvae
pr c s s r e a ( )$16 0.0i ta srp f e . r h f l wi r ao ,hec u t e ln st
o e s e v r nd 2 ,2 9 n r n c it e s Fo t e ol ng e s ns t o r d cie o
o
t x t r quese $845. i s r i ef s
a he e t d
80 n e v c ee .
Thef sr quese we e pa d t prva epr s s r er .Suc f esa eno i l d i t
ee e t d r i o i t oce s e v s
h e r t ncude n he
l to txa l c ssst o t i 28U. C. 1 2 .n ta , 1 2 4)o l r fr t t etfe so t e
i fa be o t e f rh n
s
S. j 9 0 I se d j 9 0 1 ny ee s o h t qe f h
g
ce k a m a s l' Ast c tha nb e pr vi l i çi c tane t a y t sa u e a
lr nd r ha .
'
he our s t d e ousy, t ss onsr i d o ppl he t t t s
wrte 'Belftov Re Ro nItr . n .No. 1
itn. l at . d bi n en.I c, 7:4CV0 6 , 3W L 3 6 0 , t* ( .
' o
01 7 201
6 1 43 a 2 W D.
Va J n 1 , 01 ) Th r f r,tb e a et p anln u g o j1 2 4 ) o s te prsl alw
.u e 2 2 5 . ee o e ç lc us he li a g a e f 9 0 1 d e no x e sy lo
g
f rt r ove y ofprva epr e ss r rf e , t c tdeci st t x t e f si t s c s .
o he ec r
i t oc s e ve e s' he our
'
lne o a hos ee n hi a e
M a s v. ah a , 5:9 01 0 2 0W L 3 8 7 3 a * ( . Va S p . 8 201 ) s e
y e M ty s No. 0 CV0 0 , 01
7 3 0 , t 4 W D. . e t 2 , 0 ; e
as Kelvv. tl Ch ri' Au oSae , . 0
lo le Lit a l s t lsNo 4:4CV0 0 3 2 0 W L 2 5 3 5 a * ( . Va
e
e
08,06
4 6 5 , t 3 W D. .
Aug 2 ,2 0 )(g h panln u g o j 1 2 ()o l a le t fe padt t cek a d
. 2 0 6 çT)e li a g a e f 9 0 1 ny ppis o es i o he lr n
ç
mas l Be a et ln u g o j 1 2 ( )i ce ra dt mb g uso isfc ,In lah t
rha. c us he a g a e f 9 0 1 s la n ma iuo n t.a e m o t o
ra a yhn a dto lit te sau e'.Ac o dngy t e d f n a tsb l o c ss wi b
e d n tig d i na n o h tt t.) c r i l , h e e d n ' il f o t l e
i
'
l
r duce by $845.
e d
80.
The ne c t gor of e ns s i l $1,20. i f spad f r obt ni de ii n
xt a e y
xpe e ncudes 6 90 n ee i o ai ng posto
ta cit a d ata c ito t e Au u t2 ,20 4 sl yj d me th ai g S ci n 1 2
rnsrp s n rnsrp f h g s 2 1 l
mmm' u g n e rn . e to 9 0
al a c tt t x a c t t ee f prnt d ore e to c l r or d tans rpt nec s arl
lows our o a s oss ç s or i e
f
l c r nialy ec de r c i s e s iy
obti dfrus i t ca e'28U. C.j1 2) Thec tofata ci i ge r lyr ovea e
ane o e n he s .'
S. 9204 .
os
r ns rpt s ne al ec rbl
i i i ç e s na y nçc s r a t tm e ofist l ' La a Cor v.Dom i o Fe r lSa &
f t s s a o bl
r
es a y t he i
t adng.' v v
n.
ni n de a v.
Loa As ' 830F. 522, ( hCi.1 .nt sc e,hec t r e t tt tt de ii
n sn,
2d
528 4t r 987)I hi as t our ag e s ha ha he poston
ofpl ntf wasr a ona y ne s a y t t ltg t o a t tm e i w a t ke The co tlke i e
ai i f
e s bl ce s r o he ii a i n t he i t s a n.
ur i w s
a r e t tt e ta ci tf rt sl r j d me th aig wa r a o a l n c say t t
g e s ha h rnsrp o he l
mmay u g n e rn s e s n by e e s r o he
ltg to S e ec,Bd.o DissW ae ' Ed ev.And n Gp . 1 5 F. D.$ 9 1 6 ( D.Va
iiain. e . ..
f r. trs g
e
, 3 R. 2 , 3 E. .
1 91 (ee nn ta he rngta srp sc udb p o rytxe wh nGhep era pr c e ig
9 ) d tnniig h t ai r n c it o l e r pel a d e E rtil o e dn s
t
weeo s bsa ta i o tn et bohp ris. .' Itle t a Ve tr sILLC v. pia On
r f u tnil mp ra c o t a t . '; n elcu l nu e
e
)
Ca tl e
Fi. p .No 1 1 CV0 40 2 5W L 7 8 0 , t* (lo n f rtx t n o ta srp sfo
n Co , . :3 7 , 01
2 31 8 a 7 alwig o a ai f r n cit r m
o
te sl l j dg n he rng .As s h,t e c u twila r d fnd n t c ss o te
h l ' u me t ai )
mmay
uc h o r l wa d ee a t he o t f h
ta c i s
r ns rpt.
C oncl i
us on
I a o da wih t nzi s tf t a
n cc r nce t he lngs e orh bove t co twila r t def nda c t i
, he ur l wa d he e nt os s n
t amot of $1620. The Clr i diece t s nd c ri d c e oft s me or ndum
he
mt
, 90.
e k s r td o e e tse opi s hi m a
o ni n andt ac ompa ng or rt a 1c ms lo r or
pi o
he c
nyi
de o 1 ot e f ec d.
ENTER: iZ Y d yo Mac 20 7.
Ths
a f rh, 1
Clif nied St t sDititJ
le
t
a e src udge
4
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?