Dansey v. Metropolitan Life Insurance Company

Filing 48

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 10/4/12. (jcj)

clEe s OFFI E U. DI COURT
C :. SX

A Ro#j E, A
T FI oK V
LED

IN T H E U N I D STA TE S DISTR IC T C O U R T
TE
FO R TH E W E STER N D ISTR IC T O F V IR G I I
N A
Charl t vil Di si
ot es le vi on

D EBR A D AN SEY ,

0CT 2i 2 1
22
JULI :
A DUDL CL
EY ERK
BY;
CL
ERK

Ci lA ct on N o.3: cvvi
i
11- 00013

Pl nt
ai W
Count cl mm e nda ,
er ai fe nt
M EM OR ANDUM O PI ON
NI

V.

M ETR O PO L I N L I
TA
FE
I SU R AN CE C O M PA N Y ,
N

De nd ntcr s - a m
fe a / o scli
Pl nt countr l mant
ai W
e cai ,
By:Ja e C .Tur
m s
k
Seni Unied St es D i ri Judge
or
t
at
st ct
RA ELY N ERD N ER ,STEPH EN
ER DN ER ,A ND PEAR L ERD N ER

Cr s cai De ndant.
os- l m fe
s

Pe ng bef r t Cour i Pl i if a Co er l m - e e nt D e a D a e s
ndi
o e he
t s a ntf nd unt c ai D f nda
br
ns y'

(t ns y'o d aitf ' Motonf SummayJ dgmen.ECFNo.33.Cr scl m Dee nt
t e ' r s nif) i or
Da
pl
r u
t
os- ai fnda s
Ra ynErne,Stphe Er r a Pe r Erne (olci l û fnda s' rs
el d r e n dne, nd al d r c le tvey,i e nt' e ponde (
De
)
d, ECF
No.38) a Da e r ple ECF No.41 Th Cour he r o a agume so t moi on
, nd ns y e id.
. e
t ad r l r nt n he ton
Se e be 27,201 a i i now rpe f diposton. r t r a ons s tf t he e n,Pl i if s
pt m r
2 nd t s
i or s ii Fo he e s
e or h r i a ntf '

moin f rs mmmy j d me t( No 3 )i DENI Dee d n ' M oin t Srk (
to o u
u g n ECF . 3 s
ED. fn a ts t o tie ECF
o
No. ,t whihPli ifha rs
44) o c antf s e ponde ( No. ,i as DENI
d ECF 45) s lo
ED.
1
.

FA CTU AL BA CK G R O U ND

Thi diput a iesfom a lf i ur nc polc wih pr e ofa oxi ael $ 600
s s e rs r
ie ns a e i y t oce ds ppr m t y 77,

is by M er ian Lie I urnceCompa (d elie' f W ila Er r(d c den
sued
topolt f ns a
ny t tvf' or lim dne d e f),
M
)
De
who di d i 201 D e de ' polc w a pr ded tuoug hi em pl
e n
0. ce nt s i y s ovi
l
h s
oyerand i go r d by t
s ve ne
he

Ea l Reie ntI ome Se urt Ac of 1 ($ SA',29 U. C.j 1 c s q.As
ry trme nc
c iy t
974 $
ER1 '
)
S.
001 / e
di c s d he e n,t pr e ha bee de ied i o t r gi ty oft Cour by M e Li e a
s us e r i he oc eds ve n pos t nt he e s r
he
t
t f , nd

M e Lie ha bee dimis d fom t c s . The r m ani pa tes who a e al r ltve of
t f s n s se r
he a e
e i ng ri ,
r l ea i s
D e ede , s r a
c nt di ag ee boutwho i t pr rbe i i r oft e pr e .
s he ope nefc a y hos oce ds
D e e nt w as t e hus nd of De e n Pe l Er r f t r of D e e
c de
he x- ba
f nda t ar dne , a he
f ndant Ra yn
s el
and St phe Er r a uncl of Pl i if Dans y.Def nt al r s de i N e Y or whe e
e n dne , nd
e
a ntf
e
enda s l e i n w
k, r

De e
c dentlved a w o ke untl 1
i
nd r d i 999,whe he move t Vigi a W hie r sdi i Vigi a,
n
d o r ni . l e i ng n r ni
D e ede s m e i e lve w ih D a ey a a ot rtm es lved i hi ow n a rm e .D e e nt
c nt o tm s i d t
ns nd t he i
i
n s
pa t nt c de
r m a ne i V i gi a untl2008,w he he r t ned t N e Y or a r conc l d wih hi e wi e
e i d n r ni
i
n
e ur
o w
k nd e
ie t s x- f
and c l e
hidr n.

On J nua y 29,2003,De e nt Pe lEr r ob aned a di c fom Dec de .The
a r
f nda
ar dne t i
vor e r
e nt

j g n e trdb t Ne Yo k S p e Co r (ri o c De r e' icu e ap r g a hta
ud me t n ee y he w r u rme u t t v re c e ' n ld d a a rp h t
)
sae :ihePli ifg alEr r wilde i t t pates c lr n asbe iire f one
tts t antf pe r dne j l sgnae he ri ' hid e
t
nefca is or
hal of t pr e of t lf i ur nc polc of t D e e nt ac r d by vi t e of hi
f
he oce ds
he ie ns a e i y
he f nda , qui e
ru
s
e pl e ...a t D e e nt s lr t i t rghtt na e a be i a y f t ot rone
m oym nt
nd he f nda hal e a n he i o m
nefci r or he he

hafoft d t pr e oft sme polc .' ECF No.38,Ex.A.De pie t lnguag
l he eah oc eds he a
iygl'
s t he a
e
lg alEr ne)wildesgnae, t De e nta rnty wa t onl pe s a et efc t t
tpe r d r l i t ' he c de ppae l s he y ron bl o fe t ha
'
desgna i s nc t polcy w as hi .I i undi put d t t D e de , a ound t tm e of t
i ton, i e he i
s ts
s e ha
ce nt r
he i
he

di c i tal c
vor e, nii ly ompled w ih t f r goi pr son by na ng e h ofhi t c l e a
i
t he o e ng ovii
mi ac
s wo hidr n s
pa ta be fc a i , e ilng e c t t e y- i pe c nt of t pr ee of t po i y.l i
ri l ne i i res ntti a h o w nt fve r e
he oc ds
he lc t s
unc e r whe he he m a a s c tc des g t o f t ot r ff y pe ce oft pr ee at
la
t r
de ny pe ii
i na i n or he he i t r nt he oc ds
t tm e.
hat i

The prm a y di agr e e i t c e se s f om a ta a t o pur r i t m a
i r s e m nt n he as t m r
r ns c i n
po tng o ke
D a e t be i i r of one hundr pe c nt of t polc Tha s e nt ta a ton
ns y he nefc a y
ed r e
he
i y.
t ubs que r ns c i
occ r d o J
ur e n une 1 2005, w he a f m w a f l d el c r ni ly w ih M e lie de i tng
0,
n or
s ie e t o ca l
t
t af s gna i

iy.
Pl i ifas t s e be i i r of De e nts M eLie polc l ECF No. 3 Ex.C.Pl n if
antf
he ol nefc a y
c de '
t f
4,
aitf
alege t t s was pr s nt w he D e ede t m a t c ng vi M e Li e s w e ie wih a
l s ha he
ee
n c n
de he ha e a t f '
bst t n
el c r c sgna ur a t t he de ie t c nge.D e e
e t oni i t e nd ha
s r d he ha
f ndan s c l nge t va i t of t
t hale
he ldiy
he
bene i i y c nge,a l gi t ti w a m a wiho t know l dge orc e ofDec de ,a
fc ar ha
le ng ha t s de t ut he
e
ons nt
e nt nd
t tPl ntf had ac es t t i o m a i n nec s a y t m a t c
ha ai if
c s o he nf r to
e s r o ke he hange.They a s a gue t t
lo r
ha

t c ng c r beefe tve a t t tfype c ntoft pr ee t c l enwe e e il t
he ha e amot
f c i s o he i t r e
he oc ds he hidr
r ntted o
r e ve a a r s to t D i ce D e r e.
ec i s e ul f he vor
ce
Folow i t de t of D e ede on J y 3,201 Pl i if a t m pt d t c l c on t
l ng he a h
c nt
ul
0, a ntf te e o ole t
he

polc ast s e bene i ir Afe M e Lie r c ve core ponde e fom De e ntRa l n
iy
he ol
fca y. tr t f e ei d r s
nc r
f nda
ey
Er rr ga di t di ce de r ,i i ta l de e one ha fofPli if scai .ECF No.4,
dne e r ng he vor
c ee t niily nid - l
antf l m
Ex.1 l is co e - a m fl d i t s l w s t M e lie a s s a e i w a û bl t de e m i
. n t unt r cl i ie n hi a ui, t xf l o t t d t s t
una e o t r ne
w he he t 2005 B e f c a y D e i t o was pr r y e c e ' or w he he D e de t ha
t r he
ne i i r
s gna i n
ope l xe ut d'
t r ce n d
s fc en c pac t t m a t c nge I t r us d t pa a po ton of t pr ce ds t
uf i i t a iy o ke he ha . t hus ef e o y ny r i
he o e o

Plitf, u o c n enta i c udb s be t od u l l b ly.
an if o t f o c r h tt o l e u j c t o be i ii
a t
1.
I

PR O CED U R AL H I
STO R Y
Pl i if tl d t s br c of c r t a ton a i t M e Lie i t Cic t Co t o
a ntf i e hi ea h
ontac c i ga ns
t f n he r ui ur f

Fl nnaCount Vigi a.ECFNo.1, A.Purua tt 28U. C.jj1 and1 M elie
uva
y, r ni
Ex.
s n o
S.
441
446, taf
r moved t a ton t t s Cour.ECF N o, 1.M e lie t n tld a ans r a t r pa t
e
he c i o hi
t
tvf he ie n
we , hid- ry
c pl i t a i t Def nda s Ra l a St phe Er ne ,a a co e cl i a i t Pl i if
om a n ga ns
e nt e yn nd e n d r nd
unt r a m ga ns a ntf
1 W ilam E. Da ey and J eph M uchow, Dans s hus nd and br her r pectvel and
li
ns
os
ey'
ba
ot , es i yDecede ' nephews wer na ed ascontngentbenefci i on t s
nts
e m
i
i ares he ame f m .
or

3

a t i er e d de e nt.Thi Cour gr nt M eLie la t de i t f
nd he nt plade f nda s
s
t a ed t f e ve o post he undswih t
t he
Courtand dichar M et f f om t case.ECF N os.23,27.The Cour al o per it Pear
s ged
Lie r he
t s
m ted
l

Er n rt itr e ea dj i he c ide a aco scam d fnd n . No. 9.
d e o ne v n n on r hl rn s r s-li ee a tECF 1
M e Li e a co por to w ih is p i i l pl ce of busne s i N e Yor p o r y
t f,
r a i n t t r nc pa a
i s n
w
k, r pe l

ivo e ti Co r' dv riyj rs ito ,2 U. C.j 1 3 ,i s p r ofrmo l S e ECF
n k d h s u ts ie st u idcin 8 S.
3 2 n up o t e va. e
No. 1 a ! 6.The Cour c ude t t i as ha jziditon ove t c tr am a
t
t oncl s ha t lo s trs ci
r he ounecli nd
itr ea ra ton, s ntt 28U. C.j1
nepl de ci purua o
S.
335.
111
.

AN A LY SIS

M oton t St i
i o r ke

Beo e a d e sng te s mma y j d me tmoin t e Co r frt a d e s s a r ltd
f r d r si h u r u g n to , h u t is d rs e eae
M oto t St i ,f l d by D e e n s ECF N o.44.Spe fc l D e enda s a l ge t tD a e s
i n o r ke ie
f nda t .
cii aly, f
nt le ha ns y'
Su e en a D e l r ton as e t ne f c sr s d f t fr ttm e i Pl i if s Re y a t t
ppl m t l c a a i
s red w a t ai e or he i s i n a ntf
pl nd ha

i s d be src n.I a ! 4.Pli ifs te ame a
t houl
tike d. t
antf ubmitd
morndum i opposton ( No.45)
n
ii ECF
a poi s out t t t a l ge ne f c s as e t by Pl i if a os f om i s s r i e a
nd nt
ha he le d w a t s red
a ntf r e r
s ue a s d nd

a misb ly o j cinsma eb Dee d n si t ero p sto t s mmayj d me t 1 a 3
d siii be to
t
d y fn a t n h i p o iin o u r u g n . d. t 5.
The Cour i pe s ded by Pl i if s o
t s r ua
a ntf ' pposton m e or nd a t ca e c t d t r i The
ii
m a um nd he s s ie he e n.
ne f c sr i ed by Pl i tf ' Re y s cii a l r l t t i s s r i e by t D e e
w a t as
a n i fs pl pe t c ly e a e o s ue a s d
he f ndan s a a e
t nd r
t r or not pr bie a ne e de . Se loz v.Ha pt U ni ,N o.4: 6- 9 2007
he ef e
ohi t d s w vi nce e l or
m on
v.
0 cv- 0,

W L 1 01 a #1 ( D.Va.Ma 3,2007 .iW l r t rpl afda tmeey rs ndst
31 79, t 4 E.
y
) t hee he e y fi vi rl epo o
g
m a t r pl c i i s by t oppos ton brefa doesno s i upon t o
te s a ed n s ue
he
ii
i nd
t prng
he pposng pa t ne
i
ry w

ra onsf t e r ofs mma yj me s'i s dno be src n.1 (ii Ba v.Civ
e s or he nty u r udg nt' t houl t tike d. ctng ugh
t
ofM iwa ,823F.Supp.1 1 -57( D. i.1
l ukee
452, 456 E. W s 993:. c di y,Dee nt'M oi
Ac or ngl fnda s ton

t Sti i D EN I a t Cour w il co i r t ot r s a i s bl a r e s i t
o rke s
ED nd he
t l nsde he he wi e dm s i e ve m nt n he
s em ent decl aton.
uppl
al ar i

B.

M oton f Sum m ary Judgm e
i or
nt

Plitf c n e d s ei e t ld t s mmayj d me tb c u et eei n g n n is e
anif o tn s h s ni e o u r u g n e a s h r s o e uie su
t
of m a e i l f c as t whet r s i t s e be fci r of t polc She c e
t ra a t
o
he he s he ol ne i a y
he i y.
ont nds s i
he s
e il d t one hundr d pe c nt of t pr e ds be a e D ec de was no lm ie by t 200
ntte o
e
re
he oc e
c us
e nt
t i td
he
3
Di c D e r e. D e e nt di a e a post t t D e ede w a pr bied by t D i c
vor e c e
f nda s s gr e nd
i ha
c nt s ohi t
he vor e

Dec e fo desgnai a be fc a y f m or t n ffy pe ce oft polc De e an sa s
re rm
i tng
ne ii r or e ha it r nt he i y. f nd t lo
a gue t t t r i a i s of m at r a f c a t whe he Dec den kno i l c ng d t
r
ha he e s n s ue
eil a t s o
t r
e t
w ng y ha e he
bene i a y t hi polc i 2005.
tci r o s i y n
Standard ofR evi w
e

S mma.j d me ti p o rwheeçh r i n g n ieis ea t a ymae ilfc a d
u l u g n s r pe
y
r i ee s o e un su s o n tra a t n
t

t mo a ti e t ldt j g n a amatro lw. F d R. v P. 6 a. g n ieis eo
he v n s n i e o ud me t s te f a ' e . Ci. 5 () A e un su f
t
'
m ae i lf t e ss whe a r tona tir off c ,c i rng t e de e i t r o d a a
t ra ac xit
n a i l re
a t onsde i he vi nc n he ec r s
w hol coul fnd i f
e,
d i n avor of t non- ovi pa y. Ri v.D est ano, 557 U . 557, 586
he
m ng rt
cci
ef
S.

( 0 9 .E u r j g n i a p o rae o l i tkn t e e ie e a d al ra o a l
2 0 ) s mmay ud me t s p r p it ny f a ig h vd nc n l e s n be
s
i e e esdr w n t ef om i t lghtm os f vo a e t t nonm ovi pa t û m a e i lf t
nf r nc
a her r n he i
t a r bl o he
ng ry, no t r a ac s

aeds u e a d temo i pa t i e tte t j d me ta amatro lw.' He r v. r el
r ip td n h vng ry s nild o u g n s te f a ' n y Pu n l,
'
652 F. 524,531( h Ci.2011 ( n ba )( tng Aus nna v.Ba ofAm .Co p. 352
3d
4t r
) e nc quoi
he n
nk
r,
F. 896,8 ( h Ci.2003).A pa t op i s
3d
99 4t r
)
ry posng ummayj me ,howe r t no r t
r udg nt
ve , k
may t es
upon t m e e alega i or de al ofhi pl a ng, ...m us s tf r h s cii f c ss w i
he r l tons
ni s
s e di but
t e o t pe fc a t ho ng

t tt r i age neis f til'Andes v.Li rvLobbv,l ,477U. 242,248( 986
ha hee s nui sue or ra.
'
ron
be t
nc.
S.
1 )

( tng Fed.R.Ci P.56()a Fis Na' BarkofAz v.CiisSev.Co.391U. 253,288
cii
v.
e nd rt tl t
. te r
,
S.
89(968)
1 ).
2.

2003 Di
vorce D ecree

A s not t pa tes di agr a
ed, he r i
s ee boutt e f c of t Di c D e e be w e n D e e nt
he f e t he vor e cr e t e
c de
a Pe r .D e enda s'prm a y c enton c e i t Di r Dec e i t t i pr bie
nd a l f
nt
i r ont i onc m ng he vo ce
r e s ha t ohi t d
D e ed t f om na i Pl n if t s e be tci r of t M e t ie polc t voi ng t
c en r
m ng ai tf he ol nei a y
he t af
i y, hus di he

c
hange i isentr t --ora l a ta t ffy pe c ntoft polcy.ECF No.38 a 3.De e n s
n t ie y
t e s s o it r e
he i
t
f nda t
a g t tt Di r D ec e bi Dec den a t s Cou ta r quiest thi c l e ge a
r ue ha he vo ce
r e nds
e t nd hi
r nd e r ha s hidr n t t
l s ha f oft pr ee oft polcy,or t e y- i pe ce e h.Pl i i fdi ag ee ,a g ng
ea t l
he oc ds he i
w nt fve r nt ac
a ntf s r s r ui
t tbe a e t Di c D e r e doe noti c t a c r a n t r f whi h t des g ton of
ha c us he vor e c e
s
ndi a e ny e t i e m or c he i na i
t c l r n m us be m a nt i d a does no e e sy s a e t tt des gna i i ir voca e,
he hid e
t
i a ne nd
t xpr s l t t ha he i ton s r e
bl
Dec de w a unde no oblga i n t m ai t i hi c l e a f fy- r e be f c a i s f e r
e nt s
r
i to o
n a n s hidr n s i t pe c nt ne i i r e or ve .
ECF N o.41 a 4.I t ad,Pl i if a g s t t De ede comple w ih t pr vi i whe he
t ns e
a ntf r ue ha c nt
i d t he o s on
n

na d Ra l andStphe Er rbe tca isa trt dece wase erd...Pli iff t r
me eyn
e n dne nei ire fe he re
nt e Jl antf urhe
ts
a s r s t t t l c of l ng ge e e sy m a ng t d i ton i r voc bl r
s e t ha he a k
a ua
xpr s l
ki he es gna i r e a e ende s t
r he
D i ce D e e a bi uous a t ta a bi uii s d be c t ue a i tt dr fe ,ie ,
vor
gr e m g
nd ha ny m g tes houl
ons r d ga ns he a t r . .
Pe lEr rand he a t ne .2
ar dne
r tor ys
Pl i tf ' ar e i unpe s s ve,m os not bl bec us i f is t a d by t
a n i fs gum nt s
r ua i
t a y
a e t a l o bi e
he
es a i he r e of cont a t i e pr t ton t t t e c r d S houl be i t r r e a s t g ve
t bls d ul
r c nt r e a i ha h onta '
s d
n e p et d s o o i
ef e t t e c pr s on of t c r t' Am .Rol- Rol- f Ca r e s LLC v.P & O Pors
f c o a h ovi i
he ontac .
'
l on
lo f r i r
t

Batmoe,479F. 288, (t Ci.
li r
3d
293 4h r 2007) i (t ba i prncpl ofc rc i eprtton. .
. A
, d.1 sc i i e onta t ntr eai .
2 Plitf as s gg se f rt etrttmea t es mmayj dg nthe rngt tt eDioreDe r e
an if lo u e td o h i s i t h u r u me ai ha h v c ce
( ra la tt pori a r ng b neist tec lrn,wh we ea ulsa t tmeo t dv c )ma
o t e s he t wa di e ft o h hid e
on
o r d t t he i f he iore y
be i i undera New Yor 1 t t does notalow di ce decr t pr de s
nvald
k aw ha
l
vor
ees o ovi uppor t a taged
t o dul-

c l e lr s e tveo wheh rs halw wo dc n l twihERI A a d b s j c t p e mp in, hs
hi n.re p c i f te uc a ul o fi t
dr
c
S n e ub e t o re to t i
isuewasnotbref d orpr l r s s t Cour doesnotconsi i her
s
i e
opery aied, o he
t
der t e.

6

i t i t r e,t t e entpos i e a 1t t r i a c ta twiho r nderng a oft m
s o n e pr t o he xt
sbl , 1 he e ms n on r c t ut e i ny
he

me ni es ors rl .' ( tng Che k Trdi LLC v.Che x Lt ,393F. 55
a ngl s upe tuous' quoi
)
mbul a nc.
me d.
3d 0,

555 (t Ci.2004).The Di c De r i c t t tPealErne woul na Ra yn a
5h r
)
vore cee ndiaes ha r d r
d me el nd
St phe be i i r e of hal of t pr e ds a t t De de r t i t r g t na e t
e n nefc a i s
f he oc e nd ha ce nt e a ned he i ht o m he
bene i a y f t o he ha f l Pl ntf s a g en w e e c r c ,i woul m ake no s ns f t
tci r or he t r l . f ai i f r um t r or e t t
d
e e or he
e e s r t nton pr s on t be i ude bec us Dec de w oul have i f c r t i d t
xpr s e e i
ovi i o
ncl d, a e
e nt
d
n a t e a ne he
r gh t nam e a be i i r f one hundr d per e of t pr ee , afe t ki t pu e y
i to
nefc a y or
e
c nt
he oc ds t r a ng he r l
t c c l s e of na i hi c l e f s e lm ie pe i of tm e.Pl i if s i e r t ton
e hni a t p
m ng s hidr n or om i t d r od
i
a ntf nt p e a i

as rn e step o s ( rteb n ftt P a l n tec id e )me nige so s p rl o s I
lo e d r h r mie o h e e i o e r a d h hl rn a n ls r u efu u ,t
woul r quie onl t tt De e ntna hi c l e f s e uns c fe l t of tm e
d e r
y ha he c de
me s hidr n or om
pe ii d eng h
i ,
e n l s t n a da and t n he w oul be e il d t c nge t de i ton a w il Thi woul
ve e s ha
y,
he
d
ntte o ha
he s gna i t l . s
d
con r ve t pl i m ea ng oft de e
t a ne he a n
ni
he cr e.
I s t t Cour fnds no a bi t i t t r s of t Di c D e r a i t d
n hor , he
ti
m guiy n he e m
he vor e c ee nd nsea
tndst ti pl i y r r D e e
i
ha t a nl equied c dentt gi up hi r g t nam e a be f c ar f ff y pe c nt
o ve
s i ht o
ne i i y or i t r e
of t polc s pr ce ds and ga t t be i t Pea l Er r w ho el c e t de i t her
he i y' o e
ve ha neft o
r dne ,
e t d o s gna e
chidr n ast be i i res
l e
he nefc a i .
I t r tngl t pa tes ha no a e s d i de ai one of t pr m a y l ga i s s
n e es i y, he r i
ve t ddr s e n t l
he i r e l s ue

r s dbyM eLiei ispla ngs whehe t Di r De rec tt esaQuaii dDome tc
aie
t f n t e di : t r he voce ce onsiut
lte
si

ReltonsOr r (ç
ai
de iQDRO' unde ERI ECF No.4 a ! 23.ERI e iil pr mpt a1
'
)
r SA.
t
SA xplcty ee s l
sae1w i ofra i ûeaest 'a ERI pl 29U. C.j 11 a .M ehe t dece i a
tt a ns a s t t lt o' n SA an.
r
S.
44()
t r he re s
QDRO i sgnii ntbe us QDROSaesaut iy e l fom t br dr a h ofERI S
s i fca ca e
r tt orl xcuded r he oa e c
SA'

pre ton pr so See29 U. C.j11 b)7 (i-hepr e i clus )s l nota y t
e mpi oviin.
S.
44( () Gg- e mpton a e hal
l
ppl o
qualfe do si r ai or r ( t nt me ni ofs ci 1 d)3( ()oft stte .
iid me tc eltons des wihi he a ng e ton 056( ()B)i hi il)

7

' .Th ,i t Di ceDe r heei a QDRO,i woul notbe pre ed byERI a
' us f he vor
)
cee r s
t d
e mpt
SA nd

. . .

coul begi n f lf c a efc .l i i notaQDRO,t ni woul bepr e e by ERI
d
ve ul ore nd fe t f t s
he t
d
e mptd
SA.

Se M er Liel .Co.v.Pett 1 4 F. at863 ( prpet s tlme a e me e e e
e to. f ns
ti, 6 3d
-64 a o ry ete nt gre nt ntr d
i o by t di r i pate di notquaiy a aQDRO a t waspre td be a et
nt
wo vo cng ris d
lf s
nd hus
e mpe c us he

a e men pr ded k n alenae me hanim t obt n pln be is';i a n. (C SA'
gr e t ovi d tr t c s o ai a neft' d. t 7 I
a
l
ERI S
pr mp i n clus wo d ba a sae 1 w domesi r ltonsor rfom at c ng ERI pl n
ee to a e ul r ny t t a
tc ea i
de r
ta hi
SA a

be is pe i orwelae,i i di notqualf asaQDRO'a fdealc
neft, nson
fr f t d
iy
' nd e r ommon 1w c dnot
a oul
ovec ERI Spli ma t)
rome SA' an ndae.
AlhoughDeenda ssaet tt Di c Dece i aQDRO,t y donots cf how
t
f nt tt ha he vore re s
he
pe iy

i me t t r uie t of29U. C.j 1 ( ( ( -( .l t d,t y smpl c e t ti
t es he eq rmens
S.
056d)3)B)-D) nsea he i y ontnd ha t
i aQDRO i rNew Yor lw'( No.38a 9)be a eisopeai lng gei smia t
s
l
unde
k a 'ECF
t c us t rtve a ua s i lr o
t l gua oft di c de r f
he mz ge he vore cee oundt bea QDRO i M er poltn LieI urnc Co.v.
o
n to ia f ns a e

Bi o 283F. 436,4 ( Ci.2002) Pl nifdo notofe a a g ntast whyt
celw,
3d
41 2d r
. aitf es
fr ny r ume
o
he
Di r eDe r ehe ei notaQDRO.l a e nt Def nt di nottmeymovef s mmay
vo c c e r s
n ny ve , enda s d
i l
or u r

j d me to t i is e o a y is e3I lg to t i fiu ea d te Co r' r ig i te n x
u g n n hs su r n su . n ih f hs al r n h u ts ul n h e t
n
s ci n t tt r i a diput off c t tplce Pli ifsrghtt a pr ee oft polc i
e to ha he e s s e a t ha a s antf i o ny oc ds he iy n

queton,heCo tne no deemi a t stmewhehe t Di c Deceei aQDRO.
si t
ur ed t tr ne thi i
t r he vore r s
June 2005 C hange ofBenef ci es
i ari

A s pr vi l no e t pa te a s di a e ove w het t 2005 change t t
e ous y t d, he ri s l o s gr e
r
her he
o he
bene i a y f m des g tng D a e as t s e be t c a y w hi h w as m a onlne w as
fci r or
i na i
ns y
he ol ne i i r c
de i At t hearng,De endant counselac
he
i
f
s'
knowl
edged t he had not fl a wrte m oton,but
hat
ied
il n
i

s g se t tp rils
u ge td ha a ta umma' j gme ti hi cins fvo woud b pr e pu s ntt Rul 5 4
l ud n n s le t' a r l e op r rua o e 6 9.
y
Rul 56 9 al tec r t g a ts
e ( lows h ou t o r n umma yj dg nto pata s
r u me r ril ummayj gme tide e e to t e
r ud n n p nd n f h
mo i ,6a fe gi ngn iea dar a o bl tmet r s n ...'Th Cour de ln st is apata
ton ç ltr vi otc n e s na e i o e po d . e
l
'
t cie o sue ril
s mmayj g ntr ig wiho talwig Plitf ap o e o oruni t r p d. c dn y,t t e
u r ud me uln t u lo n an if r p r pp t t o es on Ac or igl o h
y
e tntt tDe e nt ha mad a o a mo i f pata s mma yj dg nt t tmo in i d nid
x e ha fnda s ve e n r l ton or ril u r u me , ha to s e e
wiho tprj die.
t u eu c
8

va i y a know i y m a by Dec de .The pa te f t r cont tt a i s biiy o ea h
ldl nd
ngl
de
e nt
r i s urhe
es he dm s i lt f c
o he ' e i enc of e e t pr ordi pr t rve s ons oft f c s4 The Cour hasca e uly
t r s v d e f r d o ove
s ove hei r i
he a t .
t
rf l
c i r d t a i s bl e de of e ed by e c pa t a de e nes t tt r a e di pu e
ons de e he dm s i e vi nce f r
a h ry nd t nni ha he e r s t d
i s ofm a e i f c a t w he he D e e thi s l know i y c nge t be i i r
s ues
t ral a t s o
t r c den m e f
ngl ha d he netc a y.
The Co tno es t t Pl i if ha of e ed s gnii nta s t ntale de t s
ur t ha a ntf s f r i tca nd ubs a i vi nce o uppor
t
he c a m t tD e de know i y c nge t nn e be fci r on hi M e Li e polc i J
r l i ha ce nt
ngl ha d he m d ne i a y
s t f
i y n une
2005. Fis , Pl i if s it t de l z to of St ve Sha ef w ih he m e o a
r t a ntf ubm ted he c a a i n
e n
r f t
r m r ndum i
n

s p o to s mmayj d me t ECF No. 4,S aefDe l Mr S rf i a atr e wh a es
u p r f u r u g n.
3 h rf c. . hae f s n to n y o v r
t a h me wihDe e e to J n 8 2 0 t p e aeawilfrDe e e t S ae fDe l a !3
h t e t t c d n n u e , 0 5 o rp r
l o c d n . h r f c. t .
M r Sha e f s a es t tD ec de diec e t tPl i if be m a t s e be tci r of t w il
. r f t t ha
e nt r t d ha a ntf
de he ol ne i a y
he l
a t thi chidr n- Def nda s Ra l n a St phe Er r be di i ied.Sha e f De .a
nd ha s l e
e nt e y nd e n dne s nhert
r f cl t

!4.Mr Shaefalosae t thi fl not rfec De ede te esedadesr t ma Da e
. rf s tts ha s ie es el t c n xpr s
ie o ke ns y
t s ebe fcay oft M eLiei urnc polc ShaefDec.a ! 6.M r Shaef notd t t
he ol neiir he t f ns a e iy. rf l t
. r f e ha
he a s d D e ede t t t wilw oul not a f c t lf i ur nc polc a t the woul
dvi e
c nt ha he l
d
f e t he ie ns a e i y nd ha
d
ne t m ake t t c
ed o
ha hange unde t polc 1 W hie Def nda s cha l nge m uc of M r
r he i y. d.
l
e nt
le
h
.
Sha e f s de a a i on hea s gr
r f ' cl r ton
r ay ounds t Cour c ude t tm os ,i nota l oft he r ay
, he
t oncl s ha
t f
l, he a s

c ane t ri flswihi t he ra e e in ofRul 8034 ,whih al a c tt
onti d heen al t n he a sy xc pto
e
3) c lows our o
a tr a dls ofadeca a ' a l lt tg)sae ntoft de l a ' t n-xitngsae
dmi,eg r e s
lr nts vaiabiiy,sa ttme
he carnts he e si tt
ofmi (uc a motve,i e orpln).... Fe R.Evi 8034 ,s as Unie Sttsv.
nd s h s i ntnt
a
' d.
'
d. 3) ee lo td ae
.
Srvatva,411F.App' 671 684 ( h Ci.Feb.18 2011 (npubls d)( l tng a t iy
i sa
x. ,
4t r
, )u
ihe coleci uhort
4 Asnot , t e lf i ance polcy atis i t scas i gover ERI ,whi pr
ed h ie nsur
i
s ue n hi e s
ned
SA
ch eempt al sa e
s l tt

lwst tr aet a y e o ebe ei pa 29 U. C.j 1 44 a . c us f d r llw s ple ter e
a ha elt o n mplye n tt ln.
S.
1 ( ) Be a e e e a a up is h ul
ofdecii t f r r es ofevi
son, he ede al ul
dence appl Phoeni M ut Lie I Co.v.Adams,30 F. 554,566
y.
x
. f ns,
3d

( h Ci.1 4) Addiinal f d r lp oc du a sa a d- icl i fdea lw a t t a misbl y
4t r 99 . to l e e a r e r l tnd r s n udng e r l a s o he d s iii
y,
t

o e ie c- g v r smma j d me tna ycs . it Co to Co p v P ic Wil m Co srCo.
f vd n e o en u q u g n i n a e Uti nr l r . . rn e la n t. .
ly
i
I .5 F.d 71 ,7 0 (t Cl.1 7) Ac or ngy t t e tn t tt ep ris ag nt r l o sae
nc, 58 2 6 2 4 h r 97 . c di l, o he xe t ha h a te ' r ume s ey n tt
evi ntar r es t Cour doesnotconsi t e ar
de i y ul , he
t
der hos gument .
s

9

a dic sngt r uie nt fra si lt unde Rul 8 3). anyoft sae nt of
nd susi he eq rme s o dmisbiiy
r e 03( ) M
he ttme s
D e e nt r f r ed i M r Sha e f s de a a i a e a is bl unde t s e e i a t
c de e e enc n . r f ' cl r ton r dm s i e
r hi xc pton nd hus
s
uppor D a e s ve s on oft f c s
t ns y' r i
he a t .
Pl ntf al o s it d he o n de l r ton,i whi h s s a e t t s w as pr s n
ai if s ubm te
r w
c a ai
n
c he t t s ha he
eet

whe De de ma t c ngeo J 1 2005. ns yDe l a !4. ai ifatc d ac
n ce nt de he ha n une 0,
Da e c. t Pl ntf ta he opy
of t Be i i r Des gna i prn e by De de a gi n t Pl ntf on J
he nefc a y
i ton, i t d
ce nt nd ve o ai i f
une 1 2005.
0,
ECF N o. 34, C; ns De l a !4. Pl i i fsde a a i a s s a est tD e de t d he
cl r ton l o t t ha ce nt ol r
Ex. Da ey c. t 5 antf
he was m aki hert pr m a y be i i r û of g a iude f hel ng hi a a tm e i hi lf
ng
he i r nefc a y t
out r tt
or pi
m t i n s ie

whe hewa s frng s roushe t p o e .'Da e De l a !7.Pli iffrhe sae t t
n
s ufei ei
alh r blms' ns y c. t
antf u t r tts ha
s w a pr e w he D ec de c l hi ne w , J e M uchow , on t t da t get t
he s es nt
n
e nt aled s phe
os ph
ha y o
he

ne sa yi or to t ma hi ac tnge be ii y.Da e De .a !5;s eas ECF
ce sr nf main o ke m oni nt nefcar ns y cl t
e lo
No.3 Ex.J The esae t,oo,aead si eunde Fe R.Evi 803()
4, . s ttmens t r misbl
r d.
d. 3 .
Def nt con e tt valdiy of t c nge i be tci r e ,a a l ge t t De de
enda s t s he i t
he ha
n ne i a i s nd le ha ce nt
di notha know l
d
ve
edge oft cha .The s
he nge
y ugges i t a t tPl ntf m ade t c nge usng
t ns e d ha ai i f
he ha
i
i or a i a ia e t he .ECF N o.38 a 1 The ar ue t t f t s r a on,t y a e t
nf m ton va l bl o r
t -2. y g ha or hi e s
he r he
be fci r e of o hundr d pe ce of t M e Lie polc I s
ne i a i s
ne
e
r nt he t f
i y. n uppor of t i ve s on of t
t he r r i
he
f c s De e nt of e cic s a i la t s i oni le de e t tD e de had no know l ge
a t , f nda s f r r um t nta nd e tm a vi nc ha ce nt
ed

oft c nge ofbe i a y m a o J 1 2005.Def nda spoi t t Di c Dec e
he ha
nefcir
de n une 0,
e nt
nt o he vor e
r e,
whi h or r d D e e ntt na e hi t o c l e a t be t c a i of ha f of t pr e ds
c de e
c de o m
s w hidr n s he ne i i res
l
he oc e ,
and Decedent s subs
'
equentcom plance w ih t s or ECF N o.38 at 7,Ex.A .Bas on t s
i
t hi der.
ed
hi ,

5 W hie Def ndant chale t documentas i
l
e
s
lnge he
nadm isbl, Dans hasave r t i was gi t
si e
ey
r ed hat t
ven o
herby De ntaRe he prnt i.A sm iardocumentwasalo atached t one ofM etaf s pl ngs.
cede
r
i ed t i l
s t
o
tie' eadi

Al ug t sd u ntma no be p o e l a t e tc td frp p e o s mma yj me t t r i
t h hi oc me
ho
y t r p ry u h niae o ur os s f u r udg n , hee s
enough evi
dence, e wihout i,t s
ven t
t o upporta tndi t Dec nt made t change,as dicus d
i ng hat ede
he
s se
her n.
ei

10

t y co e t t Dec nt woul notha tid t na s one as one h r d pe ce
he nt nd ha
ede
d
ve re o me ome
und e r nt
bene i i r s nc he kne he had no r gh t do s
fc a y, i e
w
i to
o.
D e e nt alo s
f nda s s ugges t t Da e ha t m e ns a o
t ha ns y d he a nd pporuniy t m a t c ng
t t o ke he ha e
he s f I s ppo toft saleg i n, he not t tM e tie s ntt D e de ' pos ofi e bo i
r el. n u r
hi l ato t y e ha
t af e o ce nt s t fc x n
Tr V igi a a l tert t i l d hi em pl e i n ii ton num be a enc a d hi t
oy, r ni e t ha nc ude s
oye de ttca i
r nd our ge m o
us a onlne f t r s a e orc nge hi be f c a y desgna i ECF N o. a 7,Er rD e .
e n i onu o e t t
ha
s ne i i r
i ton
38 t ' dne cl

a !9,Ex.B.M orove ,i he afda t Dee ntPe r Er rsae t tDec de waslvi
t
e r n r fi vi, fnda al dne tts ha
e nt
i ng
i Cha l t s le a t tm e t lte was mal d a t t Pl i if ha a c s t r tive
n
rote vil t he i he et r
ie nd ha antf d c es o e re

De e n ' malfom t pos ofie box.Er ne Dec.a ! 1 6Deenda Pe r Er ras
c de ts i r he t fc
d r l t 0. f nt al dne lo
f
ound a ong Dec den ' per ona pa r a doc e ti Pl i if s ha rtng t tr a d s r
m
e t s s l pe s
um n n a ntf ' ndw ii ha e d: ' e
U

Na Uncl 999 Paswor 99999W . Er r Dec.a ! 1 Pe r Er r sae t ts i
me
e
s d
5 dne
'
l t 5. a l dne tts ha he s
i onned a oft bei ft tt swa t a coun i o ma i us t c ng t be i ir
nf
nd he le ha hi s he c
t nf r ton ed o ha e he nefca y
de i ton on t M et f polc l La ty, Pea lEr r not s t t D ec de û erook t
s gna i
he
Lie i y. d. s l
r dne
e ha
e nt t
und t
o
r ove Pl ntf as a benefci y t any ofhi es at orasset i udi hi wil' s l aferhe
em
ai i f
i ar o
s te
s, ncl ng s l,' horty t

rtmwd t New Yok a rc l wih Dee nt.l a !! 1 -20.I lght of t s
et
o
r nd e oncied t fnda s d. t
9
n i
hi,
D e e nt c e t t Dec de ' f l e t c
f nda s ont nd ha
e nt s aiur o hange t Polc s be f c a y desgna i ba k
he i y' ne i i r
i ton c
t hi c l e s
o s hidr n uppor s a i e e t the di no know i had be n c nge t s e ot r
t n nf r nce ha
d t
t
e ha d o om one he
t n hi c l e
ha s hidr n.
W hie t e de e i s
l he vi nc n uppor of De e nt 'co e i nsi s e tw e k ba e on t
t
f nda s nt nto s om wha a s d
he
c r ntr co d,t Cour c ude t tt e de e i s fci ntt cr a e a ge ne di pu e of
ur e e r he
t oncl s ha he vi nc s uf i e o e t
nui
s t
m a e i lf tas t whet r o no D e e nt knowi l cha d t be fci r des g ton f
t r a ac
o
he r t c de
ng y nge he ne i a y i na i or

6 Pl ntf o j cst t s sae n sf lc ofpes a k wld .Pe r' afda tsae t a
ai if b e t o he e ttme t or a k
ron l no e ge als fi vi tts h t
s has per onalknow l
he
s
edge,but of er no ot evi nce t s
f s
her de
o uppor t s On t bass oft cur ent
t hi.
he i
he r
r d,t Cour cannots y defnii y wheherPear Er
ecor he
t
a
i tvel
t
l dnerdoes ordoesnothave per onalknow l
s
edge
oft e f ct Regar ess even i t e sat
hes a s.
dl ,
f hes t ement wer i
s e nadm isi e,Def
s bl
endant ha pr ded ot
s ve ovi
her
admi i e evi nce s fci f t Cour t r e on t smoton.
ssbl de
uf i ent or he
t o ul
hi
i

hi M e Lie polc The t tm ony of De de ' a t ne ce t i y pr de s gnii a e de
s t f
i y.
es i
ce nt s tor y ra nl ovi s i f c nt vi nce
t t i w a D e ede ' de i e t nn e D a ey a hi be t c a y i 2005. Pl i if s o n
ha t s c nt s s r o m
ns
s s ne i i r n
a ntf ' w

t si
e tmony,a we l woul s
s l,
d uppor s h a fndi Thi Co t howe r mus c i whe he a
t uc i ng. s ur,
ve , t onsder t r
r s bl f c -i r c d fnd f D e e nt ,a m us dr w al r as bl i er nc s i t
ea ona e a t tnde oul i or f nda s nd
t a 1 e ona e nf e e n he
lgh m os f vor bl t t m .l doi s t Co tc ude t t Def nda s ha pr vi ed
i t
t a a e o he n ng o, he ur oncl s ha
e nt ve o d
s fci nt a i sbl c r um sa i l e de
uf i e dm s i e i c t nta vi nce t s
o uppor t e s e e of a ge ne i s of
t he xi t nc
nui s ue
m a e i lf c ast w he he D e ed t e c e t c
tra a t o
t r c en xe ut d he hange i be i i r f
n nefc a y onn.Att ve y l as ,
he r e t

t fcs a i ee s s
he a t nd nf rnce unoundi ( ) t lte snt by M elie i M a 2005,( t
ng 1 he etr e
tvf n y
2) he
s eq n us of a onlne be tca y de i ton f m, an () De de ' a rnt
ubs ue t e
n i
nei ir sgnai or
d 3 ce nts ppae
s e nt e f t t r m ove Pl i if as a be i i r t hi e t t a a s t ,a e s fc e t t
ubs que f or s o e
a ntf
nefc a y o s s a e nd s e s r uf i i n o
ove c e Pl i if s a s ri t t no g ne i s of m a e i f c s e s . A c r ng y,
r om
a ntf
s e ton ha
enui s ue
t ral a t xi t
co di l

Plitf smoin frs mmayj dg n i DENI
an if to o u r u me t s
ED.
l .
V

C ON C LU SI N
O

Fort ra onss tf t heei Dee nt'Motont Sti ( No. )i DENI
he e s e orh r n, fnda s i o rke ECF 44 s
ED
a Plitf M oto f SummayJ
nd anips in or
r udgme ( No.33)i DENI An a opraeode
nt ECF
s
ED. ppr it r r
s lis t sda
hal s ue hi y.

ENTER:Thi /m Qu y ofOct r 2012.
s t da
obe ,

p
'

p
.

t zZ/pu <
,- uu
'
,
Jmues C . ; ur
a
j k

Se orU nie St t D i t i tJ
ni
t d a es sr c udge