Keitz v. Unnamed Sponsors of Cocaine Research Study et al

Filing 3

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 9/1/2011. (mab)

CLERKS OFF/EU S DI Cotr
SK l

A o <kk v
yR A ,A

jscj1tf
t. 2( i
s?lp
E o.
tz
E

.
.

I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES DI
STRI CO U RT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI O F V I I I
CT
RG N A
CHA RLO TTESV I
LLE D I SI
VI ON

JULI
A
BK

DL c ERK
EM
()
y

M ICH AEL JAM ES K EI
TZ,

Pl i if
a ntf ,

Ci lA c i N o. 11 cvvi ton
3: - 0005
4
M EM O R AN DU M O PI O N
NI

UNNAM ED SPONSORS OF COCAI
NE
RESEAR CH STUD Y ,e a .
t 1,

By: Hon. e E.
Gln Conr
ad
Chi fU nie St t sD i ti tJ
e
t d a e sr c udge

D ef
endant
s.

The pl i tf ,M i ha lJ esKeiz,pr e di pr K ,fl d t sac i n on Augus 26,
a n if c e am
t oc e ng o
ie hi to
t
.

2011 na i a de e nt t Co monwe lhofVigi a va i br nc oft Uni st
, m ng s f nda s he m
at
r ni , rous a hes he veriy
ofVigi a a a lt ny oft
r ni, nd ia
mnmne i vi uase oye by t Uni r iy ofVigi a.The
d ndi d l mpl d he ve st
r ni

c ur grnt t pli ifsc tmpo a ousyfl moi t pr ce dL f mapau rs
o t a ed he antf one r ne l ied ton o o e q or
pei,

purua t 28U. C.j1 ()1 .Afe c
s nt o
S. 915a () tr onduci a i tals re ngoft c ai ,
tng n nii ce ni
he ompl nt
ho ve,hec tc l t timus bedimisdpurua t 28U. C.j1 5()2)B)
we rt our oncudes ha t t s se s nt o
S. 91 e( ( .
Fact B ackzround
ual

Ac or ngt t c
c di o he ompl nt t pl i ifr ponde i l t 2009t r di adve ts m e s
ai , he antf es
d n ae
o a o
rie nt
and a i t pa tc pat i a m e e s udy a t Uni r iy ofVi gi a' Ce e f A ddi ton
ppled o ri i e n
di al t
t he
ve st
r ni s nt r or
ci

Reeac a Ed ai (
s rh nd uc ton UVA Cae .(
r) Compli a 1) UVA Car ac e e t pli ifs
ant t .
e c ptd he antf'
a i a i a i t c ed t pl i ift the woul sa f ni da i U V A Ca e durng t
pplc ton nd ns nl t he a ntf ha
d t y or ne ys n
r
i he

ad nitai oft sudy.(d. Aspa to t sud t pli ifwoul i s tleedos öf
mi srton he t
I)
r f he t y,he antf
d nget lr
es
t dr Topin t a s eque l woul beij cedwihc ai t t tTopia t s
he ug rmae nd, ubs nty, d n e t t oc ne o es
rmae'
efec onadr gus rsdesr frc ane I a 12. Aferi si t frtdos of
ft
u e ' ie o oc i .(d. t - ) t nge tng he is e
Topi am at t pl ntf experenced s e pani and di com f ,and t eaferr us t
r
e, he ai if
i
ever
c
s
ort
her t ef ed he

rmani dos soft dr (d. t2.
e i ng e he ug. I a )

.

punr
E CLERK

(

UVA Ca e dic r t pl i ifni da lt ,f m ihi t pli ifwih wrte
r s ha ged he antf ne ys aer u s ng he antf t it n
i tuci t r por i me ael t t e r nc r m i t e ntt thee re e
nsr tons o e t m di t y o he me ge y oo n he ve ha
xpe inc d

S ni lkes oms' I ) Se r lda a trhi rla e t pli ifs fr das veepa c
t c i ympt .'(d. ve a ys fe s ee s ,he antf ufe e e r ni
ma
a t c a w a t a pored by a bul nc t t e e ge y r
ta k nd s r ns t
m a e o he m r nc oom a t U ni r iy ofV igi a
t he
ve s t
r ni

Me ia Ce tr (i) Th p an ifc mmu iae t t ee r e c r o safh sp riiain
dc l ne . L
e litf o n c td o h meg n y o m tf i a t p to
c
i teTo ia t su ya dhi r a to t ted u .( . Th e r e c r o sa f h n
n h pr mae td n s e cin o h r g J ) e meg n y o m tf t e
#
die t dt pl i ift lnge i t l bby ç onei apa csa e'whe ehewat d f s ve a
r c e he antf o i r n he o
t
al n
ni t t ,' r
ie or e r l

hour uni awoma s
s tl
n ummone hi t t wi
d m o he ndow.(4. Howe ,at t woma drce
Lz
)
ver fer he
n ie td
t pl nift rt nt hi satt plitf c lps di fon oft wi
he aitf o eur o s e ,he anif ola e n r t he ndow.(d.
I)
Se r lm or hour e a e be or t e r ncyr m sa fes re t pl ntf t C n
ve a
e
s l ps d f e he me ge
oo t f co td he ai if o '
a

ioltdaeaoutofge rle rhotoft ohe paint.'(d. Afe t eedocor a ve t
s ae r
nea as
he t r te s' 1 ) tr hr
t s ni d,he
pli ifr ltdt t hi pa tci toni t dr gsud a hi r a tont t dr (d. t3.
antf eae o hem s ri pai n he u t y nd s e ci o he ug. I a )
The e t r e doc or des td t pl ntf f a t rp ol
s he
t s ere he ai i f or no he r onge pe i be or a nu s e t r t
d rod f e
r e n e ed he

pli ifsr ad nitrdonedo eofvai a C e t hi i ot ni gl'(i) The
antf oom, mi see
s
lum, nd d ngl m nt he ght.' L
s
e ui f orfve days a co di t t pl i i f we e ta lvi he loff ar pa c a
ns ng our i
, c r ng o he a ntf , r i i ng l
e , ni nd

hal i tons' (d. Durngt stmepei t pli ifc tce UVA Caes vealtme ,
lucnai . l ) i hi i
'
rod,he antf ona td
r e r i s
buthi c m uni tonsca ed t U V A Ca e saf t dit nc t m s l f om t pl i tf
s om
ca i
us he
r t f o s a e he e ves r he a n if

e nf t r (I,
ve urhe. Ll)
Thepli ift n boa ded abusa ta le t Fl i at tt e ns hi el of
a ntf he
r
nd r ve ld o ord o dcla e' ms f

û e n .' (d) Ho v r b f r j u ne igt Flrd ,h plitf r c i datlp n c l
d mo s' l . we e , eo e o r yn o o ia te an if e eve ee ho e al
'
fo aû r ner us'
rm d y vo 'UVA Caedocort who t plitf rpore hi desi ton.(d.
ve
r t o m he anif e td s tnai l )
UVA Caema no frhe atmpt t c ac t pli ifdlrnghi tnur i Flrda.(#za
r de u t r te s o ont the antf zi s e e n oi J t
3- ) Onemont ltr t pli ifeece t laveFlrdaa tave t Ne Yor (#=a 4.
4.
h ae ,he antf l td ô e
oi nd r l o w k. J t )
.

Be or exe utng hi pl , he pl i ift l phoned a UV A Ca e doc ort i r whet rt
f e c i
s ans t
a ntf e e
r
t o nqui e
he he

docorwihe t vii wiht pl nif (d. Afe t docorr s
t s d o st t he aitf. I ) tr he t e ponde i t neg tve,he
d n he ai t

plitf ta le t Ne Yok.(d. h l i Ne Yo k,h plitf s fee fo t rv
anif rveld o w r l )W ie n w r te anif u fr d rm t a e
g
i e m it n pa c a t c ' a e r e ed t e ole tonsofodd i e r tonalas c soft
nt r te t ni ta ks' nd xpe i nc d c l c i
r
nt r oga i
pe t
he

g
UVA Ca esud hewa i ' (d. Thepli ifrpore t emedialis st UVA Cae
r t yj
s n. l )
'
antf e td hes
c sue o
r,
whihc t ieds h ra tonsa c
c aegorz uc e ci s ommon a e.(d. Afe s frng fom apa tc al
plc l ) tr ufei r
riulry
s ver pa c at c t pl ntf c
e e ni ta k, he ai if ommit hi eft aNe Yor hos t lse e ge y r ,
ted ms l o
w
k pia ' m r nc oom

wheeher c ve c rai s dai s (d. Thepl ntf algest thek ontnue t t sda t
r e ei d e t n e tve . l )
ai if le ha ù i s o hi y o
c

sr g l wihp n catc t a ween nle itn p irt h sp rii to i t eUVA Ca e
tu g e t a i ta ks h t r o lx se t ro o i a t pain n hr
c
r
sudyq' (d.
t . I)
'
St
andard ofR evi
ew

Unde 28U. C.j1 5,whihgovensj f mapa rspr e ngs t cou tbe r a
r
S.
91
c
r . or
q
upe i oc edi ,he r as

ma d tr d t t sr e i iiliigs Erln Co v J h s n 4 0F.d65 - 7(t Ci. 0 6 .
n ao y uy o c e n nta tl . iie . . o n o , 4 3 6 5 4h r 2 0 )
n
Spe ii aly,$ dititc tmus dimi sa a tont tt c ti t befi ouso
c fc l t src our
a
t s s n c i ha he our tnds o rvol
r

maii o t tf l t sat acai ' M iha v.Chare t Cnt ,434F. 725,728( hCi.
lcous r ha ais o t e l m. c u
'
lson y.
3d
4t r

2006)(ii 28U. C.j1 5( ( ( )
ctng
S. 91 e)2)B).
The sa r ofr viw f amoto t dimist rFe r lRul ofCi lPr e e
tnda d e e or
in o s s mde de a
e
vi oc dur

1 b)6)as a ist adimis lf fiu et saeacai u rj 1 5()2)B) Ne ome
2( ( lo pple o s s a or alr o tt l m nde 91 e( ( . ws
v.
EEOC,301F. 227,231(t Ci.
3d
5h r 2002)
.Thus i r e ngaco antund t ssaut,
,n eviwi
mpli
er hi tt e
t c r m us ç ce ast u a 1wel- e de a l ga i ' a c t ue t e a l ga i i t
he ou t t t pt r e l
ac
lpl a d le tons' nd onsr hos le tons n he

lg mos fvorbl t t pl ntf Mvl La .l v. aka i7F. 11 11 (t Ci.
iht t a a e o he ai if
an bs.nc, M t r, 3d 30, 34 4h r
1 .A c antne no a s r dealdfcualalgai , mus co ant et n
993) ompli ed t s et tie a t le tons but t nti l
mor ha
l be s a c l i ,a a f m ul c r ia i oft e e en s ofa c us ofa ton wilnot
a l nd onc us ons nd or ai ec t ton he l m t
a e ci
l

do. BelAt.Cop . Two v,550U. 544,555(
' l l
'
v. mbl
S.
2007) Furhemor,e na s ngt
. t r e ve sumi he

f t lal tonsi t c
acua lega i n he ompl i ar t e,he ç tbee
ant e nl t y k
mus
nough t r iearghtt r lefa ve
o as i o ei bo
t s ul tve l ve .' I
he pec a i e l' d.
D i cus on
s si

Thepl i ifsyl hi c us sofaci n asone f m e ca m apr c ie, e ca
antf t es s a e
to
s or di l l a tc m di l
neg i nce a t hni lba tr I pero mi iss r e ngf ton wih r s c t t e
lge , nd ec ca te y. n f r ng t c e ni unci
t e pe t o hes
c am s t c tbiu ca e isa yssandconsde sfr tt m e c lm apr c ie a
l i ,he our f r t s t nal i
i r is he di a l a tc nd
ne i nc c ai s a t t t c ca ba t r cl i .
glge e l m nd hen he e hni l te y a m
M e ca m al a tce a m e c ne i nc
di l pr c i nd di al clge e

I Vigi a,heVigi aM e ca M aprctceAc (I
n r ni t r ni di l l a i t C
VMM A' rquie a pa t al i
' e rs ny ry legng
)
ne i ntm e c c r t o an a e r c rii ai ofm e i prort s r ngpr e supon t
glge
dial a e o bt i n xpe t e tfc ton
rt i o e vi
oc s
he

dee nt Va.CodeAnn.j8. - 1( l1.Thef l et c ywiht scetfc ton
fnda .
0120. 20 )
aiur o ompl t hi riiai
r quie e g ve r s t g ounds f di m i s l l ;Br m br v.U nied St t , o. 1 - v- ,
e r m nt i s i e o r
or s s a . d. e y
t
a es N 7: 0 c 388

2011W L 1 741 a *7( . Va J n.1 2011;Dea v. a s Ci lAci No.7: c
21 , t W D. . a 3, ) lney M rh, vi ton
08-v00465,201 W L 1 25 ,a * n. ( . Va. a.25,201 ) TheVM M A a ho ie e us l
0
21 69 t 3 6 W D. M r
0.
ut rz s xc a
oft ce tfc ton r quie e tonl whe et pli if 'n good f ih,alege ame c l
he riia i e r m n y
r he antf, ç
i
at l s
di a
m al a tc ac i t tas e t a t r ofla lt wher e r t tm ony i unnec s ar
pr c i e ton ha s r s heo y i biiy
e xpe t esi
s
es y

b c us t ealg da t ne lg n ece ryl swi i t ern eo t j r sc mmo
e a e h le e c of gi e c la l i t n h a g f he u y' o n
e h
knowldgea ex re e. Va.Cod Ann.j8. - 1 Vigi ac t ha obsr e t
e nd peinc '
'
e
0120.. r ni ours ve e v d hat
i t nc e us ng t c r ii aton r quie e wilbe ' ar ' Be l Ent r .v a. Ni hol ,
ns a es xc i he e ttc i e r m nt l û e. verv e s- v. c s
r '

441S. 2d 1,3( .1 .
E.
Va 994)
H e e, he pl ntf scom pl i and t a t c d doc e s a e de d ofa r f e e t
r t
ai i f
a nt
he ta he
um nt r voi
ny e er nc o
t V M M A and t t expertcertfca i r rem ent The courtfnds i pr
he
o he
ii t on equi
.
i
m operi t si t
n hi nsance

t e s loft c tfc tonr ie nt Vigni prc ntcla l e t ihest :û(J
he xcu a he eriiai equrme . r i a e ede e ry sabls hat 1In

mo tisa c s e pete tmo y i r q ie t a ss t ej r Ex r tsi n i o dn rl
s n tn e , x r tsi n s e u rd o sit h u y. pet etmo y s r iai
y

ne e s r t esabls t a opraesa d o ca e ade ato fo t tsa d, ndt t
c s a y o t ih he ppr it tndar f r , vi i n r m ha tndar a ha

s h de ai wa t pr maec us ofda
uc viton s he oxi t a e
mage . L Svigi ac t ha al d
s' i i r ni ours ve lowe
'
pl i tf st pr e wihoute r si m e c ne i e c esonl i s t tonswher a
a n if o oc ed t
xpe t n di al glg nce as
y n iua i
e

lype s woul kno t r quiie sa r ofca ewihoutas itnce. Br mbr 2011W L
a r on
d w he e st tnda d
r t
ssa ' e y,
'

1 7 , t*8(ii Be ryEntr.va.441S. 2da 3) seas e. ,Cosonv. o- e
21 41 a
ctng ve l es- ,
E. t ; e los g. t Bi M d.

Ap lc to so Va. n .6 4 S. 2 5 0 5 2( . 0 8 (eemi igta e pe te t n
piain f .l c, 5 E.d 6 , 6 Va 2 0 ) d tr nn h t x r tsi y
mo
wasunne es a y whe et pl i ifal ge t tt de e n ' e oye t c pl e he i a
c sr
r he antf le d ha he f nda ts mpl es wi e ac d r n

dee tvec r c usnghe t f la srket gr bohtmes;Dikeronv. thi484
fci hai, a i r o al nd ti he ound t i ) c s Fae ,
S. 2d 8 882( .1 (xpli ngt te r t tmo wasunne s aywheet
E. 80, Va 997) e ani ha xpe tesi ny
ce s r
r he
pli ifalge t taphyscinl tanee ei he ne kf lwi s gey) Be rvEntr .
antf le d ha
i a ef
dl n r c olo ng ur r ; ve l e s-

Va.44lS. 2da 3(i nge r t tmonyunn e s yo t is whehe t def nts
,
E. t fndi xpe tesi
ec sar n he sue t r he enda '
e pl e w e e neglge i l a ng a t a off wih a pa i ntw ho w a una e t f ed he s l
m oye s r
i nt n e vi
r y ood t
te
s bl o e
ref

a whoprvi l hadsrousc ngi de s; efro Hos sl v. nLe r 41S. 2
nd
e ousy
e i hoki nci ntl J fes n p. nc. Va a, E.d

441, 43( 1 47)( tr ni t te r tsi
442- Va. 9 deemi ng ha xpe tetmonywasunnec s r wheet plitf
esay r he anif
a l d t tnur e de a d t ry m i esi r pondi t a ca lf om a el ry, d- i n
lege ha
s s l ye hi t nut n es
ng o
l r
n de l be rdde

paintwhoprviusyha de e tdhi be wihou a ssa e .
te
e o l d s re s d t t s itnc )

l t ec s a b r ii n wi i t ec mmo k o e g a de p re c o aj r t
n h a e t a ,t s ot t n h o n n wld e n x e in e f u y o
h
de e m i whe he t va i def nda ss ts i t s a r ofc r i t i r pons s bo h t
t r ne
t r he r ous e nt a i fed he t nda d
a e n he r es
e t o
t pl i if sr c i t Topia a e a t t pl i i f svi ist t U ni st ofVi gi a
he a ntf ea ton o
r m t nd o he a ntf ' st o he ver iy
r ni
e e ge y r . l
m r nc oom ndee as e t i ng t exa tsa r ofc r i t va i st tonsaleg
d, c r a ni he c t nda d
a e n he r ous iua i
l ed

b tepanifi a e e cs o ti eo ajly' o dn r c mp e n in Th ,h c ur fn s
y h litf s n x r ie u sd f t s r i ay o rhe so . us te o t id
r
t tt sc e f is t qualf a one oft r r i t nce i whi t di pens w ih t VM M A '
ha hi as a l o
iy s
he a e nsa s n ch o s e t he
S
expertcertfcaton r r ent A ccor ngl because t pl ntf f l t obt n s a
i i i equiem .
di y,
he ai if aied o ai uch

c r ii ton, he c t
e tfca i t our conc ude t tt pl i ifha f ie t s a e a cl i on w hi h r i fm a
l s ha he a ntf s a l d o t t
am
c ele
y

begr nt d. Thepl i ifsc am sf me c lne i e e a me c ma pr c iet r o e
a e
antf l i or di a glg nc nd di al l a tc he ef r

mus bedimis puruan t 28U. C.j1915e( ( .
t s sed s t o
S.
()2)B)
Tec c ba t r
hni al te v

Thepl ntf as s st rat r oft cmi lba tr aleg ng t theag ee t
ai if lo ue mde heo y e l ca te y, l i ha
r do
pa tcpa ei UVA Cae' dr a c i e rme , d d no c e t l in e r a i
rii t n
r s ug dditon xpei nt but i t ons nt o t it r og ton'
any

ts ee n g i o e u n hm whl u e tei l e c o k o o u k o d u s'
e t lme t) mp s d po i ie nd r h nfu n e f n wn r n n wn r g .
'
(
Compl nta 5. Unde Vigi alw,çhet tofbat yi tn u
ai t )
r r ni a û or
t
ter s a nwantdt hi whih i
e ouc ng c s

n ih rc n e tdt , x us d n r u tfe .'Mo vlov. h n n o hM e l s , 4 F.
et e o s ne o e c e , o j siid' r il S e a d a m' Ho p.5 7
'
Supp.2 5 531( . Va.
d 28, W D. 2008)(uoi Kofma v.Ganet 265S. 2d258,261(
q tng f n
r t
E.
Va.
2003:.TheSu e Cou tofVigi ahasr ognie t c e ua naur oft rltons p
pr me r
r ni
ec z d he ons ns l t e he eai hi

bewe naphyscinandapaint L. ( tngW a hb v. aa,5 S. 2d682,685(
t e
ia
te . dscii
u
s um Klr 61 E.
Va.
2002) He ,çt es a e r nc oruna i pae pr e a ie ,aphysca orslgeo
). nce çunl s n me ge y
ntci td oblm rs s
iin tr n
mus frtobt nt c e tofapai tbeor teai oropeai ont tpaint''J.(ii
t is ai he ons n
ten f e r tng
rtng ha te .' .S ctng
/
W as
hbum,561S. 2da 685 .Onewa i whihat l ca batr occ si t namedial
E. t )
y n c ecmi l tey ur s t
whe
c
pr e ei pef me t exc e t sopeo apaintsco e . I ( tngW a hbur 5 1
oc dur s ror d hat e ds he c
f te ' nsnt' d.cii
'
s n, 6
S. 2da 686)
E. t .
The pl i if c a m s t the s f r d
a ntf l i ha
uf e e

r ole tonsofodd i e r a i la pecs oft tsu 'he wa i He r a l
ec l ci
ntrog tona s t
he tt dy'
s n.
ec ls
bei as d t name r ndom wor sa tng wih t s me l te a t y s w
ng ke o
a
ds t ri
t he n
et r nd he pe

fom hi mi s e ngl de d ofhi ef t The E
r
s nd e mi y voi
s for.
UVA Cae e oye '
r mpl ejs
co m e t ha ' c m on' whe he r por st t m :M y m i s m st ope a
m nt i ts om
t
' n
e t o he 1
nd ee o n nd

a1ki ofwor c ou .ldo tknow wheet y clmefom;Tl enlkea
1 nds
ds ome t
n'
r he ga r
hl i
d o s utn ,lc nrl e e t ik o te wod c t.... Thep an ifc n o
o r h tig a 't v n hr f h r a
t
'
'
litf a n t
a ve a a l c lr as n s h que tons wo d pe ti t a sudy ose i y t
ni t ogi a e o uc
si
ul ran o t
t nsbl o

Ssei t r at r e ca ngsf c ane.'
çe f opiamgje educ s rvi or oc i '
(
Compli a 4.
ant t )

Asme to da o e 28U. C. 1 5e ()B)a t rz sad src c u tods s a
nine b v ,
S. j 91 ()2 ( uhoie itit o r t imis n
a to t a i fi l u .28U. C. 1 5 e()B) Th S p e Co r h ssae t t:
ci n h t s rvoo s
S. j 91 ()2 ( . e u rme u t a ttd ha 4
a
c pl n , ont ni a i doesbot f ct la l tonsa l lc us ons i f i ouswhe e
om ai t c ai ng s t
h a ua lega i
nd ega oncl i , s rvol
r

i l c a a gua e ba i et ri l w o i f c . Ne tkev.W ila s 490 U . 31 325
t a ks n r bl ss ihe n a r n a t' iz
'
lim ,
S. 9,

( 98 .t st CoursofAppe l haverc z j 1 5d)str 'rvol ywhe a i
1 9) W he
t
as
e ognied, 91 ( ' e m fi ous' n ppled
t ac
o ompl nt embr ce no onl t i r bl l alc l i n, a s t f nc f f c ua
ai ,
a s t y he na gua e eg oncuso but lo he a iul a t l

alg to ' I (o t t o te ) i mp e o fioo scamsicu et s wh s fcu l
l ain. d.f onoe mi d . t
e
'
t
Exa ls f rv lu li n ld ho e o e a t a
ale tonsa e ço nuty, t l i , orû l fnciul ast be sm pl û
lgai
r s
t ' deusonal' wholy a f ' o
i y unbele bl ''
iva e.'

M c a nv. tdStts 566F.d 3 400(t Ci.
tea Unie ae ,
3 91, 4h r 2009)(ii De onv.He a z,
ctng nt
m nde 504
U. 25, ( 992) Gldne v.Pe eo Cor Fa iiv, F. 773,774(t Ci.
S. 29 1 ; a y
ndltn r. clt 302 3d
7h r 2002).
)
Thec tfndsf nciula unbele bl t f c ua al tonsi t c
our i a f nd
iva e he a t l legai n he ompl i
ant
r ga di t pl ntf alege me ore ofi e r tona t c que e oye ag ns hi
e r ng he ai irs l d m is ntroga i l e hni s mpl d ai t m
durngt dr sudy a hi c am sr a di t s e nto ni a s tng o hi mi
i he ug t
nd s l i eg r ng he ubs que pe ng nd huti f s nd.
Th ,be a e t c tfndst tt pl i if st c c ba t r c a m l c an a gua e ba i i
us c us he our i ha he a ntf e hni al te y l i a ks
r bl s s n

f c ,t co tc l st tt pl i ifscli i fi o .Thepl n ifst c c lba tr
a t he ur onc ude ha he antf ' am s rvolus
aitf e hni a te y

cli t rf emus bedimis purua t 28U. C.j1 1 e( ( .
am heeor
t s sed s nt o
S. 9 5()2)B)
C o uson
ncl i
Fort f r ng r s , he c tc l st tt pl ntf scl i sm us be
he o egoi ea ons t our onc ude ha he ai if' a m
t

dimis dpurua t 28U. C.j1 5()2)B) TheClr i die tdt s ndac tfe c
s s e s nt o
S.
91 e( ( .
ek s rce o e
eriid opy
oft sm e o a
hi m r ndum opi on a t a co pa ng or rt t pl i if
ni nd he c m nyi
de o he a ntf .

ENTER:Ths t da o G i e yf

6c%. , 01 .
2 1

Chi U nied St esD i t i J
ef t
at
s rct udge