Russell v. Wright et al

Filing 33

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 3/12/12. (jcj)

CLERKS OFFI U.5. ST COURT
CE
DI L
ATROANOKE VA
..

I THE UN I
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN D I I O F VI GI I
STR CT
R NA
CHA RLO TTESV I
LLE DI I O N
V SI

I2
L
j
MA2 FE22 (wkj
13D 1
ç
.

J
BY

DUD

.

AN I RU SSELL,
TA

Pl i if
a ntf ,

P

Ci lA c i N o.3: 1 c 00075
vi ton
1 - v-

M EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI
DEN N EY W RI T,e al,
GH
t .

By:Hon. e E.Conr d
Gln
a
Chi Unied St t Diti J e
ef t
aes srct udg

Dee n s
f nda t .

Thi c s i pr e l bef et c ur on va i m otonsfld by t pli ifa t
s a e s es nty or he o t
rous i ie
he a ntf nd he
de e nt. Fort r s s tf t be ow,t cou twilgr ntt pli tf smoton f la
f nda s
he ea ons e orh l he r l a he a n if
i or e ve
t fl as pe s ng s cond a e d c
o ie u redi e
m nde ompl i a wilde t de e
ant nd l ny he f ndant'motonst
s
i o
t a f rve
r ns e nue.
1
.

Fact and ProceduralBackzround I
ual

Duigt lt e nn h uso Oco e à , 01 , p matxCo nyS rf s
rn he ae ve ig o r f tb r 0 2 0 Ap o to u t heif
Depu i De y W rght Ch it rSa ,a J hn M a
tes nne
i , rsophe ms nd o
ddox we edipa c d t 7724 Re
r s t he o
d

Hous Roa i Appomat Vigi a.( ke No.1 1a 3.
e dn
tox, r ni Doc t
- t )Thede i weedipac di
putes r s the n
r s ns t a 911 c lf om Andr w Rus el, s ofDa e Rus e la A nia Rus el,r pori
e po e o
al r
e
s l a on
ni l s l nd
t
s l e tng

ap tn il nu yt h sltebrt e, etRu sl, iho c re a tra ag me t t ter
oe ta ij r o i i l o h r Rh t selwhc c u rd fe n r u n wi h i
t
h
ft r (d a 4. Folowi t diput,Da elRuselma s et thi s lhetwa o
ahe . L= t ) l ng he s e ni
s l de ur ha s on t t s kay,
a t nl thi home, erdhi ve ce, ndpr ee dt drvea yfo hi hous .( )
nd he ef s
ent e s hil a oc de o i wa r m s e J
#a
H owe ,a t t e de i sne r d t Rus e l 'r i nc ,t s D a e Rus e lsve c e
ver s he hr e pute a e he
s ls esde e hey aw ni l s l ' hi l

pul o oft drve y.(#- Thera trt de ist ne aound,andpr e dt f l
l ut he i wa J s
)
e fe,he pute ur d r
oc ede o olow
Mr Ruselsvehil wiht i lght a srnsa tvae (d.
. s l'
ce t her i s nd ie ci td. l )
'
A Sdic s d beow, t pl ntf s tla i saec t o5l afr tam e d c pl ntand,
s us e l he ai if ough e ve n tt our t e is
nde om ai
t r he ,fldt pr pos dfrtamende c plit Howe ,i i uncea fom t r cor whehe t sae
heea r ie he o e is
d om an .
ver t s l r r he e d
t r he t t
c tg a e t pl ntf ' m otont a e t compl nt Fort sr s t f l ngf c u s mal i
our r ntd he ai ifs i o m nd he
ai .
hi ea on, he olowi a t al um y s
a e fom t ale tonsco ai i t orgi c
doptd r he lga i
nt ned n he i nal ompl nt
ai .

.

LRK
E

Upon bec ng a r oft de is sr , r Rus e lsowe down,a tva e hi
omi wa e he pute ' iens M . s l l d
ci td s

b ik r a dp le o e a t en x s f lc to i a e t paknglt (d. Theewa n
lr e, n uld v r t h e t ae o ain n n mp y r i o . I ) r s o
l
s de ont s tsrthofr dbewee t Rusel' rsde a t paki l .(d.
houl r he hor tec oa t n he s ls e i nce nd he r ng ot l )
Afe soppi hi vehil M r Rus el e td a t ook a o ma el t e se wih hi a m s
tr t ng s
c e, . s l xie nd d
t
ppr xi t y hr e t ps t s r
r s dt de
aie o monsr t t thewa una me a woul c
tae ha
s r d nd
d ompl wih t de i s'i tu tons'
y t he pute nsr c i .
'

(d. Mr Ruselso pe wakn , e ea y r sb fr r a hngt ed puis a drman d
I ) . s l t p d l ig s v r l a d eo e e c i h e te , n e i e
sa ngwihhi amsr s d.(d. Acc di t t c ai , r Ruselma f tdnosg
tndi t s r aie I ) or ng o he ompl ntM . s l niese
ins
ofaggesi a no sgnst thewasatmptngt e dears.(d.
r son nd i ha
te i o va re t l )
Att spoi ,t de i ss e t M r Rus elt ûge on t gr
hi nt he pute hout d o . s l o s t he ound,' f vehi
'but '
ga
m

o l afw sc nd t c mpl wi t er q et' (d. e f t u a yo j diej si ain
ny e e o s o o y t h e u s. I )Th n,s ho t n b e v u tt to
h
'
wi
k
t d s 'defnda W rghttunras bl i ppr rael a unne s aiys ( .Rusel
o o o,' e nt i t e ona y,na op it y, nd
ce s rl hot Mr1 s l
i t c t' t hi Tas ,d usng( 000 volsofelcrct t tow t oug hi body. (d.
n he hes'wih s er d i 50, ) t
ca
e tiiy o l hr h s
' I
'
a 4 )Asadiec r ul oft sd c sr a unpr kedatc 't c antalege ,
t -5.
r t es t hi s esay nd ovo ta k, he ompli l s
unne
'
M r Rus e lwenti o c r a a r s ,be m e t r pons ve s i d i o a c a,a di d sx
. sl
nt a di c r e t ca m es
i , lppe nt om nd e i

mo t sltr o J n 1 2 1 (d. t5)
n h ae , n u e , 01 . l a .
On Oc o r 1 2011 M r .Rus e l a t pe s
t be 9,
, s
s l, s he r onalr pr s nt tve oft esa e ofD a e
e e e ai
he t t
ni l

Rus el,nii td t slws ti t Cic tCo tf Al ma l Count Acc di t t
s l i tae hi a ui n he r ui ur or be re
y.
or ng o he

pa te 'flngs M r. sl rsdesi Al reCount ( ke No.1 a 1;Do ke No.1
ris ii , s Rusel e i n bemal
y. Doc t
0t
c t
4
a 1 6. I t orgi lc ai ,heplitf nn asde e nt Deme W rght
t , ) n he i na ompl ntt anif med
f nda s l y i ,
Appomatx Co y,heCo
to unt t
mmonwe 1hofVigni,a TaerI enatonal I (he
at
ri a nd s ntr i ,nc.t
ma a t e oft Tasrg ,a alge vaiuscamspurua t t Vigi aTo tCli
nufcurr he e un) nd le d ro li
s nto he r ni r ams
Ac;42U. C.j1 3, r ni t tlw;a Vigi abr c ofwarnt lw.M r. s l
t
S.
98 . gi a or a nd r ni ea h
Vi
ra y a
s Rusel
s
ought$1 milon i c pe a o yandpunii da es
5 li n om ns t r
tve mag .

OnNovembe 1 2011 M r . s ls ug la i sae c t o fl atr ta nde
r 5,
, s Rus el o ht e ve n t t our t ie i s me d

c
ompl i , n whi h t pli tf as e t t tt Commonwe 1h ofVigi awa no la ef
ant i
c he a n if s red ha he
at
r ni s t i bl or
t a tons ofde e
he c i
f ndan W r ght butw asla e f t ac i nsofLync
t i ,
i bl or he to
hbur Polce O fi e s
g i
fc r
M i ha St l y and Ant
c el a e
hony M a tn, ho a l ge y t a ne m e be soft A ppom a t Count
ri w
le dl r i d m r
he
tox
y
She i f sO f i e i t us ofTas r a s r d asl alTas re rs f a ea l w enf r e e .
rf
fc n he e
e s nd e ve
oc
e xpe t or r a
o c m nt

( c e No. - a 4 - ) Thepanifas s u h t a dan w c u t fa suta db tey
Do k t 1 1 t 4 45.
litf lo o g t o d e o n o sa l n atr
a i tW rght (d. t61- ) Theea tr o Nove r18 2011 t pli ifmove t
gans i . 1 a -62. r fe , n
mbe , ,he antf
do
no uihe cai agans t Commonweat ofVigi a.(#za 75. OnNo mbe 30,3011
ns t r l m i t he
1h
r ni J .t )
ve r
,
t saec te eeda or rofnons ta t t Commo at ofVigi atd. t77)a on
he tt our ntr n de
ui s o he
nwe lh
r ni .=a
k
nd,
t ts m e da W r g r m ove t c s t t Unie St t sD i ti tCour f t W e t r
ha a
y, i ht e
d he a e o he t d a e sr c
t or he s e n

DititofVigi a Cha ltevil Di son.( ke No.1.
src
r ni, ro ts le vii Doc t
)
On De mbe 9,2011 a t rt ca ewasr m ove t t sco t de e n Appomat
ce r
, fe he s
e
d o hi ur, f nda t
tox

Count fldamoi unde Fe r Rul ofCi lPr e e1 b)5)a ( ( t dimist
y ie
ton
r deal e
vi oc dur 2( ( nd b)6) o s s he
co pl ntf i uf i i nts r c ofpr s a f f iu e t s a e a cl i upo w hi h r i f
m ai or ns fc e e vi e
oce s nd or a l r o t t
am
n
c ele

ma begrnt ( ke No.3. W ihr pe tt t Rul 1 b)5)agumentAppomat
y
a ed. Doc t
) t es c o he e 2( ( r
,
tox
Count as e t t tt pl ntf f ie t s r et p o rofi e swih pr s a r uie byt
y s rs ha he ai if al d o e v he r pe fc r t oce s s eq r d he

Fe rlRul ofCi lPr e ea byt Vigi aCode (d.a 1 ) W ih rs c t t
dea es vi oc dur nd he r ni
. I t -2. t epe t o he

Ru e1 ()6 a g me t ted fn a ta srsta teAp o to Co n yS e ifi a
l 2b ( ) r u n ,h ee d n se t h t h p mat x u t h rf s
c tt i ofi runde t Consiuton ofVigi aa f t mor t tt She ifa hi
onsiutonal fce
r he
tt i
r ni nd, urher e, ha he rf nd s

de isaenote oyee ora ncesofc yormunii lgo mme s (d.a 2-3.
pute r
mpl s ge i
ount
cpa ve nt. I t )
Afe co i rngAppom at Co y' motont dimis M r . s l fl on
l r nsde i
tox unt s i o s s , s Rus el ied
Dec m be 22, 1 a m oton f l ve t t l a s co a e d co pl nt i whi h t pl i if
e r 201
i or ea o s e e nd m nde m ai , n
c he a ntf
s kst dr A ppom atox Count as a def
ee o op
t
y
endant and t add asdef ndant t Appom atox
,
o
e
s he
t

Count SheifsOf a Sheif0. is Stpls ( ke No.7a 2. Addii l t
y rf' sce nd rf W lon a e . Doc t
t )
tonaly,he
3

pli tf s e t i udet a op it c pton a t de eer e e t t Comm onweat of
a n if e ks o ncl he ppr rae a i nd o lt ef r nce o he
lh

Vignaa ad fn a t (d)
r ii s ee d n . I .
The e tr on De mbe 23,2011 Ta e l t r tona fld amoton t ta f rve
r afe ,
ce r
, s r n e na i l ie
i o r ns e nue

fo t Cha l ts leDi so t t Ly hb gDi sonoft sc t ( ke No.1 ) The
rm he rotevil viin o he nc ur vii
hi our. Doc t
0.
plitf fldisbre i oppostont t motont ta f ve onJ nuay6,201 ( ke
anif ie t if n
ii o he i o rnser nue a r
2. Doc t

No.1 ) Ta e Itr ain lie isrp yb ifo J n r 1 , 1 .( c e No. 8. Th n
4. sr n en to a tld t e l re n a uay 7 20 2 Do k t l ) e ,
on J r 1 201 de e
anua y 8, 2, f ndant Appom at x Comt a W rghttld am otont ta f rve
s
to
t y nd i ie
i o r nse nue

t t Lync gDi son.( ke No.1 )
o he
hbur vii Doc t
9.
The c t r a g e on t s m otonson J nua y 27,201 Att c l i n of
our hea d r um nt he e i
a r
2.
he onc us o

t he rng, heco ti tuce t pl ntf t fl a s r e ng s co a
he a i t
ur nsr t d he ai if o ie upe s di e nd mende c
d ompli a
ant nd

pemitdted fn a t t i whc t fl a yo j cin .Th c u tn o me t ep rista
r te h ee d n s i n ih o ie n be to s e o r if r d h a t h t
me
e
i woul tkea1oft m otonsunde ad s me pendi t flng oft s pe s di s c
t
d a l he i
r vie nt
ng he ii
he u r e ng e ond

a n e c mpan a da yo j ci n t eeo.OnFe r ay 3 20 2, r. sel ie a
me d d o lit n n be to s h rt
b u r , 1 M s Ru s lfld
moto f l vet fl as r e ngs co nme d c
i n or ea o ie upe s di e nd
nde ompli ,i whih t onl s g tc nt
ant n c he y i nii a
ditnc i f om t orgi ls c am e d c pl i f rw hi s s ugh l ve t fl i t t
s i ton r he i na e ond
nde om a nt o
ch he o t ea o ie s ha
s no l nge s ks t a as d e nt t A ppom a t Count She if s Of i orShe i f0 .
he
o r ee o dd
ef nda s he
tox
y
rf
fce
rf

W is nS a ls ( c e No 2 . Th p ro fro j cinsh sp s e wi u a yo j cins
lo tpe . Do k t . 8) e e id o be to a a s d t t n be to
ho
bei fld by t de e nt .He e, hem o i a erpef diposton.
ng ie
he f nda s nc t
tons r i or s ii
I1
.

Di
scussi
on

1.

Pl ntf ' m ot on f I ave t f l s r e ng s ond am e
ai i f s
i or e
o ie upe s di ec
nded c pl nt
om ai

F d rl eo Ci l o e u e 1 p o i e t a k a pat ma a n ispla igo c
e e a Rul f viPr c d r 5 r v d s h tç q ry y me d t e dn n e
r
a amatrofco s , )...(l alot rc e ,apat ma a
s te
urelbut
in l he ass ry y mendispla ngonl wiht
t e di
y t he
o i pa t swrte c e ort c tslave' Fe R.Ci P.1 a .(lhec ts d
pposng ry' itn ons nt he our' e .' d.
v. 5() i- our houl
-

fe l gv la ewh nj tc s rq r s' I .Th UntdSttsCo r of p asf r h
r ey ie e v e usie o e uie . d e ie ae u t Ap e l o t e
'
4

Fo t Cic i h ssae ta tth lw i wel ete th tla et a n ap e dngs o l b
urh rut a ttd h t t j e a s l stld t a e v o me d la i h ud e
g

d ne o l wh nt ea nd n wo l b p eu iilot eo p sn p ry t eeha b e b d
e id ny e h me me t ud e rj dca t h p o ig at ,h r s e n a
f ih o t pa toft m ovi pa t o t a e e w oul be f ie '' Ed a dsv.Civ of
a t n he r
he
ng r y, r he m ndm nt
d
utl .' w r
t

Gods o,1 F. 231 242( hCi.1 9)(mphai i orgi l ( i J onv.
l bor 78 3d , 4t r 99 e
ss n i na) quotng ohns
Or a FoodsCo.785F. 503,509(t Ci.1 )
owe t
,
2d
4h r 986).
Be rngi mi t sa r s tf t by Rul 1 a t i e pr tng c e lw, he e
a i n nd he tnda d e orh
e 5 nd he nt r e i as a t r
a a st benor a on on t f c soft sca ewhy t c ts ul notal t pl n ift
ppe r o
es
he a t hi s
he our ho d
low he aitf o
fl a s pe s ng s c am e ed c pl i . Furhe m or none oft de e nt ha f l d a
ie u r edi e ond
nd om a nt
t r e,
he f nda s s ie ny
o
pposton t t pl ntf sm o i n t a e Ther f e t c tw ilg a t m o i f
ii o he ai i f
t o o m nd.
e or , he our l r nt he ton or

lavet fl as pes di s onda nde c ant2 ( oc tN o 28.
e o ie u re ng ec me d ompli . D ke
)
.

2.

M ot onst t
i
o ransf venue by def
er
endant T aser lnt
s
ernat onaland W ri 3
i
ght

Assae ab ,Tas I enainala W rghtfldmoi purua t 28U. C.j
ttd ove er ntr to nd i ie tons s nt o
S.

1 4()t ta frvenuefom t Chaltes leDi sont t Lync gDi so 4 Seci
40 a o rnse
r he rot vil vii o he
hbur viin. ton
1 4()ofTil 28pr dest t f t c ninc oft patesandwinesesa wheet
40 a
te
ovi ha,or he onve e e he ri
t s nd r he

itrsso j tc wo l bes r e ad src c u t yta frac s t a o h rd src o
n ee t f usie u d e v d, itit o r ma rnse a e o n t e itit r
di son wihi a diti twhe et c e mi ha bee br ht Be on W ie e sSol i .
vii
t n src
r he as ght ve n oug . ac
rls
utons

l v.Ga nl 'sl ,Ci lAci No.5: 1c 0
nc. nni ntl nc. vi ton
1 -v-0025,2011W L 4737404,a * ( . Va.
t 4 W D.
Oc.5, 1 .I a yi j 1 a ,hede sont ta fraca ersss
t 201 ) n ppl ng 404() t cii o rnse s et oundl wihi t
y t n he
di c e i oft di ti cour . Sq Br k v. r Com put r Ct s,l ,933 F. 1 3,1
s r ton he s rct
t e oc Ent e
e r . nc.
2d 25 257
2

Be aus t cou tw ilgr ntt sm oton,t c r wildimisa moott pl ntf ' o i na moton f
i he ou t l s s s
c e he r l a hi
he ai ifs rgi l i or

la et fl as c n a n e c mplit ( c e No. . Lie s, e a s tes es dn sc n a n e
e v o i e o d me d d o an. Do k t 7) k wie b c u e h up re ig e o d me d d
e
c pli dr Appom at Count asade e t t c tw ildim isa m ootAppomatox Couny' m oi t
om ant ops
tox
y
f ndan, he our l s s s
t
t s ton o

ds s u d rRuel( )5 a d( )6.( c e No 3)
imis n e l 2 b( ) n b( ) Do k t . .
3
Ap matxCo nyj i di Wrg tsmoint ta se v n e bu, ssae a o e Ap mal xCo ny
po to u t one n ih ' to o rnfr e u , ta ttd b v , po to u t
wilbed oppe a a d enda i t sc epu s ntt t s re ng s ond a e
l
r d s ef nt n hi as r ua o he upe sdi ec
m ndedcompl nt Fo t sr s
ai . r hi ea on,
t cou twila yze t m otonst tans e ve onl a t y r l e t W r g a Tas l e natonal
he r l nal he i o r f r nue y s he eat o i ht nd er nt r i .
4
Ta e I e nai lfld ism otont ta frve trt ad ncngs r a gum e si s r ofis
s r ntr tona ie t
i o r nse nue lsy va i eveal r
nt n uppo t t

moin ( c e No 1 ) Wrg tfldhi moint ta se v n a o to emo t ltr W rg ta v n e n
to . Do k t . 0. ih ie s to o rn fr e ue b u n nh ae. ih d a cd o
ag me t i h smo in b tise d r l do t es mer a o ss tf rhi Ta e l t r a in lsmo in.( c e
r u n s n i to , u n ta , e i n h a e s n e o t n s r n en to a ' t Do k t
e
o
No 1 .
. 9)
5

( h Ci.1 ) S.Rv. v.Mad n,235F. 1 201( h Ci.1 ;Si
4t r 991;
Co.
de
2d 98, 4t r 956) mmonsv.J hns
o on,
No.Ci A.7:
v. 05CV00053,2005W L 31
59555,a *1( . Va.
t W D. Nov. 2005) s eas Stwa t
22,
; e lo e r
Or .l v.Rioh. p.487U. 22,29( 988 (ttngt t28U. C.j1 a ti i e d
c. nc. c Cor ,
S.
1 ) sai ha
S.
404() cs ntnde

t plc d sr to i tedsrc c u toa j d c t moinsf rta fra c r igt a
o a e ic ein n h itit o r t du iae t o rnse c o dn o n
o
dndi duaied,c s - c ec i rtonofc nincea f r s ''( i Va Dus nv.
i vi lz a eby-as onsdeai
onve e nd aine s' quotng n e

Barc 3 6U. 61 , 2 ( 9 4 ).
ra k, 7 S. 2 6 2 1 6 ))
The U nie St t s Cour ofAppea s f t Fo t Cic ta U nie St t s Di t i t
td ae
t
l or he ur h r ui nd
t d a e sr c
Cours i V igi a ha el bo a e o t f c o st ta e pr r y c i e i as e s ng whe
t n r ni ve a r t d n he a t r ha r ope l ons der d n s s i
n

ata se wo l sr eb t c n e in ea dteitr sso j sie S. . , 3 F.d a 2 0
rn fr ud ev oh o v ne c n h nee t f u tc . Ry Co.2 5 2 t 0 01. n.Crai LLC v. pfogEnt s.nc. 1 F.Supp. 503,504-05( . Va. )
,
Ge e ton
Lea r
er.l , 92
2d
W D. 2002 ;
Vei n OnlneSe v .I .v.Ras 203F.Supp.2d601 6 -24( D. 200 .Asa
rzo
i r s.nc
lkv,
, 23 E. Va. 2)
ge r m a t r t pl i ifs c ce ofve c m a def r nc Doe v.Connor ,796 F.
ne al te , he a ntf hoi
nue om nds e e e.
s

Sup 21 221( . Va.1 ;seas Aker v. rol & W . Co.378F. 78,80( h
p. 4, W D. 992) e lo
s No f k
Ry. ,
2d
4t
Ci.1 ( rc im)(û coure, r c zet prmayrghtoft pli ift c ehi
r 967) pe ura tOf s we e ogni he i r i
he antf o hoos s
f um,as l to no e iyt beove tr '.Howe r t pli ifsc c ofve
or
eecin t asl o
rl own.l
l
'
ve,he antf hoie
nue
de a l s de e e e w hen t s ti nottl i t di ti ta di s on i w hi h he r s de ,
m nds es f r nc
he ui s
ied n he s rc nd vi i n
c
ei s

Glmor nCoa Cop.v.RanesGr PLC,85 F.
a ga
l
t r oup.
4 Supp. 437( . Va.1 93 , whe
436, W D.
9 ) or n
ltl e s st c m ec t c e f um w ih t c us ofa ton. Se. xtl M a h. I v, .
ite xit o ol t he hos n or
t he a e c i
Te ie c . nc. H

W as & Sons l .No.4: CV00066,2006W L21 723, t*2( . Va. a 27,2006)
rhow
, nc,
05
3 a W D. J n.
.
Alhoug t de e ofdefr nc duet t pli ifma va y,hede enda nonehels sil
t h he gr e
ee e
o he antf y r t
f nt
t e s tl

s o le steb r e 'os o ta ç ebaa c o e ui e i i gt)fv rgn jta j dca
h ud r h u d n û h w h t t ln e f q t s s n is a o a d h t u iil
t
h
i
econom y and conveni
ence t a1 pari f
o l tes avor s ti anot f
ui n
her orum .' D oe,796 F.Supp.at221
''

( i El i ev.Bouc r 620F. p.678, 4( . Va.1985).Fe rlc rt i
quotng drdc
had,
Sup
68 W D.
) dea ou s n
V igi a ofen as st f l i f or i det i ng whet t bal
r ni t
ses he olow ng act s n erm ni
her he ance ofequii f s
tes avor
6

ta fri ac s t ad fee tv n e ( )tec n e in eo t ewin se ; 2 te
rnserng a e o ifrn e u : 1 h o v ne c f h t e s s ( ) h
c ninc oft pa tes ( s t tci e iy;()fine s ( t avalbiiyof
onve e e he ri ; 3) ysemai ntgrt 4 ar s ' 5) he ia lt
,
c
ompulor pr es ;( t cos ofo ani t atnda eofwine s s ( e eofac es t
s y oc s 6) he t bti ng he te nc
t s e ; 7) as
c so
s r e ofpr ;a ( )t i eessi ha ngl a c rvese de de a home Be c
ou c s oof nd 8 he ntr t n vi oc l onto ris ci d t
. a on
W ie es Sol tons l ,2O11 W L 4737404,a * Optc Ca e Cop .v.M a s El c.
r l s u i . nc.
t 4; i al bl
s . e Consr
t.

Co, F. u p 2 5 2 5 2( . Va 1 9 ) Th weg ta c r e t t e ef co ss o d
.21 S p . d 8 , 9 W D. . 9 8 . e ih c o d d o h s a tr h ul
c r pondwiht de eet te chi t t polc be nd j1 a- t ma t til
ores
t he gr ha a mpacs he iy hi
404() o ke he ra
E s e
s y, xpediiusa i xpe i ' Glmor nCoa Coo .854F.Supp. t437(ntr l
ea
to nd ne nsve. a ga
'
l
,
a
i e na
quottonmaksomitd)
ai
r
te .
l t rm o i t t a f rve
n hei tons o r ns e nue, he de e nt c r ty a s r t tt sca e c d
t
f nda s or ec l s e t ha hi s oul

ha bee fl i t Lync g Di so , t po e i ltans e e f u . Se Fi e c ni a
ve n ied n he
hbur vii n he t nta r f r e or m S e nm c a c

S. A. Ge M ot sCom .No.1: c 794,2007W L 41
P. v. n. or
,
07-v43074,a * ( D.Va.
t 2 E.
Nov.1
9,
2007 (tn a pl ngSe in 1 4( ,adititc t tfrtde iewhehert cli mi t
) (I p yi cto 40 a) src our mus is cd
t he ams gh

ha be nbr ug i t ta fr ef um. Howe rt f tt tt sa tonc dha be n
ve e o ht n he rnse e or '
).
ve,he ac ha hi ci oul ve e
br ug i t Ly hbur Di son do noti via y r s ti t concusont tt
o ht n he nc g vii
es
ne t bl e ul n he
l i ha he
de e nt 'm otons s d be g a e Ra he ,a a tc a ed a
f nda s
i
houl
r nt d. t r s ri ul t bove t de enda s s ul rt
, he f
nt ho de he
bur n t de ons r t t tt bal nc o eq te f vor ta f rt t pr pos t a f r e
de o m ta e ha he a e f uii s a s r ns e o he o ed r ns e e

f t Thefcor r lva t t sj1 a a yssaee mi dbeow.
orz
m.
a t s ee nt o hi 404() nal i r xn ne l
5

ThePli ifconc
antf
edesi he r s i bre t tt sa tonpr rycoul ha be n br
n r e ponsve if ha hi ci ope l
d ve e oughti t
n he

Ly c bugDiiin.( c e No. 4a 5)Th c u t g eswi tep rista t i ato c udh v b e
n h r vso Do k t 1 t . e o r a re t h at h t hs cin o l a e e n
h
e
b o g ti teLy c b r Di iin.P rua t oLoc l l 2( , ii a t n f rwh c v n ei p o e i t i
r u h n h n h u g v so u s n t a Ru e b) cv l c i s o ih e u s r p r n h s
o
ditit s b bo g ti t prp r vso a wel W . Va Ge . 2b) I a i iga ti diiin l e u
src mut e ru h n he o e diiin s l. D. . n R. ( . n n vn ths vso a v n e
d tr n to , c lRue2b frhe po ie ta teve u r lsfrfd rldsrc c u t i t UntdStts
eemiain Lo a l () ut r rvd sh th n e ue o e ea itit o rs n he i ae
e
Co eso l b a o td s b tui tewodS iiin'o tetr tu iil itit' n t itit'l.Th
d h ud e d pe , u si t h r t vso 'fr h emsj dca dsrc'a d ç src. d e
t ng
d
d
'
r lv n v n er l f rfd r l ititc u t i c nan d i 2 U. . j 1 9lb , c p o ie ,n p rie t r
e e a t e u u e o e e a d src o rs s o tie n 8 S C. 3 ( ) whih r vd s i e t n paq
n
t t na to cnb bou h o l i tl aj dca dititnwhiha yd fn a trsd s ial ee d nsae
ha a cin a e r g t ny n ç ) u iil src i c n ee d n e ie ,f ld fn a t r
(
rsd nso teSaei whc tedsrc i lctd gr () u iil ititi whc as btnt l a4o te
e ie t fh tt n ih h itits o ae 'o l 2 aj dca dsrc n ih u sa i p l fh
,
a
e e t o o sin gvn rs t tecam o c re . 28U. C. l 91b ( 0 ) Clal t sato c udh v
v ns r miso s iig ie o h li cu rd'
'
S. j 3 () 20 6 . ery,hi cin o l a e
be i taedi t Lynch g di so be us aloft deend sr i i Vigi aand be us Ta e
en niit n he
bur viin ca e l he f ant esde n r ni
ca e s r

ltrain lsd e dt rsd i teLy h ugDiiinb s do tefc ta ii s be top ro a
nen t a i e me o e ie n h nc b r vso ae n h a th tt s u jc t es n l
o
j idcini ta dvso l j1 91b () F rh r r, e u i as po e i teLy c b r Diiinb c ue
urs ito n h t iiin. d. 3 ()1. u temo e v n e s lo rp r n h n h ug vso e a s
atu sa t l at ftee e t . . iigrs t t cam o c re 'nta dvso .l jl 91b( )
ç btni p r o h v n s . gvn ie o he li c urd'i h t iiin d. 3 ()2.
s
a
7

a.

C onve ence o t w ine s s
ni
f he t s e

l s
n uppor oft rm o i t t a f rve ue t def nt as e t ha a lo t i pa t
t hei tons o r ns e n , he enda s s r t t l f he r r y

wine s r i wihi t Lync gDi son.( ke No.1 a 5.
t ses esde t n he
hbur vii Doc t
0 t )Thepl ntf ur est
ai if g he
c tt de t m o i t ta f rve ba e on t f c t ts r s de w ihi t
our o ny he ton o r ns e nue s d
he a t ha he e i s t n he

Chal ts leDi son.( ke No.1 a 6 ) Howeve,d oursha r ae yempha ie
rote vil vii Doc t
4 t -7.
r t t ve epe tdl
c
sz d

t a i c n ieigwh t e t ta se ac s u e 2 U. C. 1 0 () teic n e e c t
h t n o sd rn eh r o rn fr ae nd r 8 S. j 4 4 a,h n o v nin e o
pa t wines e i no a f r t s m eweghtast i onve e et non- ry wine s .
ry t s s s t f o ded he a
i
he nc
ni nc o
pa t t s es'
'

Bea onW iees Sol i .l ,2011W L 4737404,a * (ntr lq ttonmaksomitd)
c
rl s utons nc.
t 5 i ena uoai
r
te

( u tn US La .l c v. o En i e rdSu plme t & Nurto .nc, .10 c 4 , 0 9
q oig A bs. n . Bi- g n ee p e ns
ti n l .No :9 v 7 2 0
i
W L 1 2 8 7 a * ( D. . y4, 0 9 ) Bohp rish v i e tfe n n-a t wi e s si
2 7 6 , t 4 E. Va Ma 2 0 ). t a t a e d niid o p ry t se n
e
n
t s c e. Spe ii aly, he pl ntf i ntteshe t o s a t m e c lpe s
hi as
c tc l t
ai if de i
i
r w ons nd he di a r onne w ho
l

te tdDanilRusels a trhewa s .( ke No.1 a 8 ) The enon- ry
rae
e sl oon fe
s hot Doc t
4 t -9. s
pa t
w ine s r i i A l m a l Coun y. The def nda t i ntf Appom a t Cot t She if s
t s es esde n be r e
t
e n s de i y
tox m y
rf '

De isSa sa M a
pute m nd ddox,
who wer pr s ntwhe W rghtal dl utlz t Ta e a i t
e ee
n i lege y iied he s r gans

M r Rusel.( ke No.18a 11 2. Thes non- rywinesesrsdei Appomat
. s l Doc t
t -1 )
e pa t t s e i n
tox
Count H e ,i nve enc i via y w ila c ue t s e no pa t w ine s si t sc e
y. nce nco ni e ne t bl l c r o om
n- ry t s e n hi as
w he he t ca e i t a f r e t t Lync
t r he s s r ns e r d o he
hbur D i s on ori r t ne i t Cha l t s le
g vi i
s e ai d n he
rote vil
Di s on. The de e nt m a no s c le a ta f rofve t tw o d m er l s f
vii
f nda s y t e tr r ns e
nue ha ul
e y hi t
i onve e e f om one s de t t ot r See Roc ng m Pr c t l v. m . nfasr t enc
ni nc r
i o he he .
ki ha
e as s nc. A I r t uc ur

M d.nc, v l to No. : 1 v 0 2 , 01 W L 5 26 9 , t+ ( . Va No .1 , 0 1
.l .Cii Acin 5 1 c 0 0 4 2 1
5 0 2 a 6 W D. . v 4 2 1 )
(û-lrnser ofve aenota lbl merl t s f i onve enc fom onesdet a he .
ig a f s nue r
f
vaia e ey o hitnc ni e r
i o not r'
'
(ntr lquotto maksomitd)(uoi AA1Cor v.Apple Ge Te hsaI , viNo.
i ena
ain r
te q tng
p.
id o c . nc.Ci l
J I1608,2011W L 3678903,a * ( M d.
KB- t 4 D. Aug. 2011).l ot wor , a et
22, )) n her ds bec us he
a ys soft c
nal i
he onve e oft w ine s f t de onsr t st tone s de' non- r y
ni nce he t s es ac or m ta e ha
i s
pa t
8

wines e wili via y s f ri onve e ,t dee nt ha f ie t ca r t rbur n of
t s s l ne tbl ufe nc
nince he fnda s ve al d o ry hei de
s wi t taconsde a i oft sf corf vor atanse .Doe 796 F.Supp.a 221.
ho ng ha
i r ton hi a t a s r f r
,
t
b.

Conveni
ence oft partes and eas ofaccess t sourees ofproof
he
i
e
o

The de enda sc a m t tt y w oul be i nve e ed by t a lng f om A ppom a t
f
nt l i ha he
d nco ni nc
r veli r
tox

Cou yt t fdea c t ei Chal ts le,( ke No.1 a 5 ) W hiet smihtbe
nt o he e rl ourhous n rote vil Doc t
0 t -6.
l hi g
tue, sur ngt pl ntf sc ceoff u a t r by r rng hert ta lfom
r dit bi he ai if hoi
or m nd he e equii
o r ve r
Al m a l Coun y t t f r lc t e i Lync
be r e
t o he ede a ourhous n
hbur w o d lke i e i onve e e he .
g ul i w s nc
ni nc r

SeeRoc naha Pr c t I .2011W L 55
ki m e as.nc,
26092,a *6(t-la f sofve a eno a lbl
t tg-rnser
l
nue r t vaia e

meeyt s f ic n n e c fo o esd t a t e. (ne n l u tto ma k o te )
r l o hitn o ve in e r m n ie o noh r' itr a q o ain r s mitd
'
( tngAA1Cor ,2011W L 3678903,a * s ealo 1 Cha lsAlnW rght ArhurR.
quoi
p.
t 4:; e s 5 re a i , t

Milr& Edwar H.
le
d Coope,Fe r Pr tc a Pr e ej3849,a 1 -65( e 2007)
r deal acie nd oc dur
t 64 3d d.
C$ def ntmovngf ta f mus s bot t tt Orgi lf m i i nv e f i
A enda
i or rnser t how h ha he i na onl s nco enint or t
a t tt pl ntf woul notbes tntal i onve e dbyata fr' .Ast pli if
nd ha he ai if d
ubsa ily nc nince
r nse .)
'
he antf
poi s o ,a i onve e e t t def nda s i ta lng f o Appom a t Count t
nt ut ny nc
ni nc o he e nt n r veli r m
tox
yo

Cha l ts lei be id by t i ons uen i c
rote vil s le
he nc eq tal onve e et twoul a r t t m i t
ninc ha
d cc ue o he f he
t m e as he a ntf m
i e , he
a ton w e e t a f n'd t t Lync
ci
r r ns e e o he
hbur D i s on. Furher or , t pl i ife phas z s t
g vi i 6
de e nt do notcl i t t s ur s ofpr upon whi h t y w ilr y a e nota e bl t
f nda s
a m hat he o ce
oof
c he l el r
m na e o

ea y tans rai He e, hedef nt ha f ld t ca r t rbur n ofs
s r po tton. nc t
enda s ve aie o ry hei de
howi t ta
ng ha
co i a i oft s f c orf vor a t a f rofve
nsder ton hi a t a s r ns e
nue.
Sys em ate i egriy and f rness
t
i nt t
ai

An a l i oft sf t r r st c tt c i ra a gu e by t de e nt
na ys s hi ac or equie he our o ons de n r m nt he f nda
r l tng t unde l ng s a e a f de alve r l s
e ai o
ryi t t nd e r
nue u e .The d e nt eon e t t butf t
ef nda s t nd ha ,
or he
6
Thepl ntf e ai , a t defndan sdonotdipue,t t ditnc fom Appom at Vigi at
ai if xpl ns nd he e t
s t hat he sa e r
tox, r ni o
t f de a courhous i Cha l t vil i 6 11m ie ,whe e t dit efom Appom atx,Vigi at t
he e r l t e n
rotes le s 4.
ls
r as he sanc r
to
r ni o he

fdea c u to s i Ly h u gi 2 .4mi s adifrn eo a o t3 - 0miue o ta e t .( c e No.
e rl o rh u e n nc b r s 27 l - fee c f b u 0 4 n ts frv li Do k t
e
me
1 a 9.
4t)
9

ca m purua t t Vigi aTo tCli Ac , hi a ton c d ha be orgi l br ti
li
s nt o he r ni r a ms t t s c i oul ve en i naly ough n
saecou tonl i t Appoma t Count Cicui Cour. I t ts t t o , t def nda s
tt
r y n he
tox
y r t
t7 n ha iua i n he e nt
a g t ca e w o d ha be n r ove t t Lync
r ue, he s
ul ve e em d o he
hbur Di s on oft s c t Furhe
g vi i
hi our . t nnor
e,
t de e
he f ndan s s m t a gue t ti i notf i t r t i ve i t Cha l t s le D i s on
t ee o r
ha t s
a r o e a n nue n he
r ote vil vi i

be a et c s i i t sdi son ba e onl upon d e ntW rghtsde son t r movei
c us he a e s n hi vi i
sd y
ef nda
i ' cii o e
t

fo saec u tof d r l o r.Be a eteo l cam ta pemitdve u i saec u t a
r m tt o r t e ea c u t c us h ny li h t r te n e n tt o r (
cam unde t Vigi aTor Cli Ac)hassnc bee nons t - a f t r e wa
li
r he r ni t ams t
ie n
uied nd, urhemor, s
no uie be or t de e nt r m ove t ca et f de a c t t de enda sa
ns t d f e he f nda s e
d he s o e r l our- he f nt ppea t
ro
a g t tt s e ntr mova t f der lc ti t Cha lte vil Di son i s ho
r ue ha he ubs que e
l o e a our n he ro t s le vii s ome w
t i ed by t f c t tt r as f t c s orgi l be ng i s a e c ti no m oo .
a nt
he a t ha he e on or he a e i naly i n t t our s w
t

( ke No.1 a 3,5.
Doc t
0 t )Thedee nt f t aguet tt sc ecoul notpr pel ha bee
fnda s urher r ha hi as
d
o ry ve n
br torgi l i t Chal t vil Di so oft sc t r28U. C.j1 ( be a e
ough i naly n he rotes le viin hi our unde
S. 391b) c us
a loft r e nte nt oc ur ed i t Ly hb g Di son. The a s r t tt onl
l he el va ve s c r n he nc ur vi i
y s e t ha he y
c
onnec i t tt s c e bea st t Cha l t s le Di s on i t tt pl i ifr i w ihi
ton ha hi as
r o he
rote vil vi i s ha he a ntf esdes t n

t di son,whih, c di t t de e nt , ul bei ufi e t s
he vii
c ac or ng o he f nda s wo d ns fcint o uppo tafndi of
r i ng
ven i t ca e or g na l ha be n fl d i t sdi s on.
ue f he s i i ly d e ie n hi vi i
To t e e t tt de e nt 'ar um e c d be c t ue asonet ta ta f rof
he xt nt ha he f nda s g nt oul
ons r d
ha r ns e

ve s d beefe t d bec us ve i t Cha ltes leDi son i i o ,t s
nue houl
fce
a e nue n he ro t vil vii s mpr per hi
a gum e f isbas on t f c t tt l alve r esf t sdi t i tw oul a l f ve
r
nt a l
ed
he a t ha he oc
nue ul or hi sr c
d low or nue

i teChalte vleDiii nbe a s , steplitf p it o tTa e lt r to l ss be t
nh
rots i v so c u e a h an if on s u , s r nenaina i u j c
l

1

Pu s ntt Vigi a' pr e r ve esaut, a a i u
r ua o r ni s efred nu tt e n cton ndert Vigi aTor Cli Ac maybe
he r ni
t ams t

b o g ti tec u t o ct wheetecama te ie .Va Co ej8012 ( 8() Wet 1 ) Ho v rite
r u h n h o ny r i
y r h li n rsd s . d . -611 )a ( s20 2 . we e,fh
aci ha notorgi ly contm pltd acl m undert V igi aTo tCl msAc,t a tonco d ha be n
ton d
i nal
e ae
ai
he r ni r ai
t he c i
ul ve e

b o g to y i t eAp o to Co n y Cic i Co r, h d fn a t cam. l . 8012 2.
r u h nl n h p mat x u t r ut u tt e ee d n s l i d j . - 6
10

t p ro a j rs ito i t i dv so 8 W . va Ge . . ( ) I a e e t s ha ag me t
o es n l u idcin n h s iiin. D. . n R 2 b . n ny v n , uc n r u n
i pr ryma puruantt amotonunde 28U. C.j 1 a) Howe r t d e nt'
s ope l de s
o
i
r
S.
406( .
ve,he efnda s
moto weenotfl unde j1 a,buti ta we efl underj1 a .Se Va Dus n,
ins r
ied
r 406()
nse d, r ied
404() e n e
376U. a 634Ct t
S. t
Alhoughbot sci weebr dl de i dt al ta fri t dof
h e tons r oa y sgne o low rnse nsea

dimis l j1 a pr de f ta frfom f umsi whihve i wr yori ope l
s sa, 406() ovi s or rnse r or n c nue s ongl mpr ry

li , ee s i c nr s, 1 0 ()o eae o t ep e s sta t plitf ha p o e l
ad wh ra ,n o ta t j 4 4 a p rts n h rmie h t he an if s r p ry
e rie hi ve p i lge.) c di l t c t l e mi t def nt'agume
xecsd s nue rvie ' .Ac or ngy,he our wil xa ne he enda s r nt
'
a ibe r ont o yrlva i r i t sj 1 4()a l i- whehe c ni ea t
s t a s he nl ee nt nquiy n hi 40 a nayss
t r onve enc nd he

itr sso j siefv rta se t t eLy c b r Diiin
nee t f u tc a o rn fr o h n h u g vso .
The de e nt c t pr do i nty t t o c s s a s
f nda s ie e m na l o w a e s uppor f t i a gum en t t
t or he r r
t ha

c n e inc a dt itr sso j tc a d, r s e iial t s se tcitg i a d
o v ne e n he n ee t f usie n moe p cfc l he y tmai n e rt n
y,
y
f r s f t sa
aine s acor , dvocaef a ta f rofve
t or r nse
nue. Thede e nt r l on M uli v.Eguia
f nda s ey
lns
fx

I onnai Se vc s LLC, Ci A. 05CV888,
nf ton r ie ,
No. v. 3:
2006W L 1 402 ( D.Va.Apr 28,
21 4 E.
.
200 ,a onSout senTe ieM a hi r l .v.H. a s & Sons l ,
6) nd
heatr xtl c ney.nc
W rhow
,nc.No.
4:
05CV00066,2006W L 21
3723( . Va. a 27,2006)f t pr ii t tt sc t
W D. J n.
,or he oposton ha hi our
m us cons ts a e a l a f de a ve r l sw he de di a m o i t ta f rve unde
t
ul t t nd oc l e r l nue u e
n ci ng
ton o r ns e nue
r

j1 a .W hiet de e nt mihtbecor tt ta a yssund t s tmai i e iy
404()
l he f nda s g
rec ha n nal i er he yse tc ntgrt
a f r s f c or r qui e t c tt cons de s h ve r e ,t c esc t d by t
nd aine s a t s e r he our o
i r uc nue ul s he as ie
he

de e
f ndan sa editnguiha eon t i f c s
t r si s bl
he r a t .
Fis ,i M uli , he co tc uled t l alf de alve r e onl w ihi t co e
rt n
lns t
ur ons t he oc e r
nue ul s y t n he nt xt

ofa a l i underj 1 a t deemi whehe ve wa i o ri t s lce di son.
n nayss
406() o tr ne t r nue s mprpe n he ee td vii
8
Al o g ted fn a t d n tc neth fc ta Tae Itrain li sb ett p ro aj rs it ni
t u h h ee d ns o o o tste a th t sr nen to a s u jc o es n lu idci n
h
o
t sdiiin( c e No 1 a 9 0 ,h d fn a t ag eta itrrtn 2 U.. j1 91b a alwi v n e
hi vso Do k t . 8 t -1)te ee d ns ru h tnepeig 8 SC. 3 () s l ng e u
o
i t sdi so efeci l elm i t sta nee f ac ctonbewe n t o r tvefct ofac eandt ve
n hi viin f tvey i na e <ny d or onne i
t e he pe ai a s
as
he nue

slce frtec s whe e e teei ac r rt d fnd n. (d a l . Ho v r t sag me tst tyd fae
eetd o h ae n v r h r s opoae ee a t' 1. t 0) we e,hi r u n i l l ee td
'
a
b t fca ln u g o jl 91b , ihalwsfrv n ei < u iildvso !i whiha yd fn a trsd s
y he a ila g a e f 3 () whc l o e u n t dca (iiin n c n ee d n e ie,
o
aj
i al fn a t a er sd n so t e Sa ei wh c t dititi lc td ' 2 U. . j 1 91b ( )
f 1dee d n s r e i e t f h tt n ih he src s o ae . 8 SC. 3 ( ) l .
'
#
'

M uli ,2006 W L 1 4024, *3- Furhe mor ,t cou tc i r d t l alf de a ve
lns
21
at 4. t r e he r onsde e he oc e r l nue

r e be a e,mlket a to i t i tntcae( c wa rmo fom saeco t,he
uls c us l i he cin n he nsa s whih s e ved r tt ur)t
a ton i M uli had be n i ta ed i f de alc t l a * H e ,t scour i oft opi on
ci n
lns
e nii t n e r our . d. t 4. nce hi
t s he ni
t tM uli doe notl nd s
ha
lns s
e uppor t t def nt 'poston.
t o he enda s
ii
Se nd,i Sou he t r Te ie M a hi r l ,t c t ns t d t V igi a ve
co
n
t as e n xtl
c ne y, nc. he our co ule he r ni nue

sauei a ayzn aj 1 0 ()moint ta se v n i ac s t a ha b e rmo dfo
ttt n n l ig
4 4 a to o r n fr e ue n a e h t d e n e ve r m
sat co t Se.Te ie M ac . nc. 2006 W L 21 23, t* H ow e r t c tc r cty
t e ur .
xtl
h. l ,
37 a 4.
ve , he our or e l

r ogni dt tiwasnotbo by saeve lw.L- Furhemor,i t tca e ve wa
ec ze ha t
und tt nue a 4. t r e n ha s , nue s
i pr ry l i i t pari a sat co ti whi h t ac i w asc m e e a f om w hi h
m ope l a d n he tcul r t e ur n
c he ton
om nc d nd r
c

t c ewasrmove t f r c t Jl a *4 l c r t t aci i t i tntc ewa
he as
e
d o edeal our. -. t -5. n ontas,he ton n he nsa as s
ts
pr ry b oughti t A l m a l Co y Ci c tCour- t f c t tt V i gi a Tor Cl i s
ope l r
n he be re unt r ui
t he a t ha he r ni
t am
A c cl i , he onl r as t tven a l ge y w a p o ry l d i A l a l Count w a l t r
t am t
y e on ha
ue le dl s r pe l ai n bem r e
y, s a e
nons t d doe nots e
uie
s
om how vii t t c tnui pr i t ofve i t tc t H e e,
ta e he on i ng opre y
nue n ha our . nc
Sout as e n Te ie M a hi r l doesnotl nd g ea s
he t r xtl
c ne vs nc.
e r t uppor t t def nt 'c us eihe .
t o he enda s a e, t r
I a e ,ast c ti Sou he t Te t l M a hi r l pr r y r c ze
n ny vent he our n
t asem x ie c ne ys nc. ope l e ogni d,
t sw rnkl i t f de a venue ta f rana ys s c us d by t c i r ton ofs a e ve
hi i e n he e r l
r ns e
l i, a e
he ons de a i
t t nue

r e ,rggest s tmai itgrt a fi sfco s Se i a * (t heeae... a tca
uls ti r he yse tc ne iy nd anws a tr . e d. t 4 t- r r prci l
f
co i r tonsoftm i a lm ia i ofr le a l bl t a def nda w ho i s d i a
ns de a i
i ng nd i t tons e i f vaia e o
e nt
s ue n n

i ope saec t
mpr r tt our venuea wihest rmovet c et fde a c t' 'ts(ffad e nt
nd s o e
he as o e r l our.', . ç efnda
) tl l
z
opt t c l nge s a e c tve i s a e c r ,he willke y notha tm e t r m ove t c s
s o hale
t t our nue n t t ou t
l i l
ve i o e
he a e

t fde a c ti hi c le f l.'.Ba e ont f eg nga l i,t c tbeive t t
o e r l our f s halnge ais'
) s d he or oi nayss he our le s ha
t s t m atc i egrt a f i ne sf c or ,a m os,c ea e a te w ih r s tt t pa te '
he ys e i nt iy nd a r s a t s t
t r t i t e pec o he r i s
r
espectve i er t Even i t
i nt ess.
f hese f or f
act s avort def
he endant ,t st i woul not
s hat iuaton
d
neces iy m ean t a t
sar l
hat ransf ofvenue w oul be i or
er
d n der. Rat ,t
her hese f t sm us be
ac or
t
12

c i r d al wih a1 oft ot rf c o si de e mi ngwha t û l nc ofe te '
onsde e ong t 1 he he a t r n t r ni
t he t a e quii s'
ba

ditt .Doe 796F.Supp. t221(ntr lquotto maksomitd)(mpha i a d)
caes
,
a
i ena
ain r
te e
ss dde .
d.

lnt
erest i havi I çont
sn
ng ocal
roversi deci athom e
es
ded

Alho h t c e e t t tga r s t t s l w s tunde abl occ r d w ihi t
t ug he or ven s ha ve i e o hi a ui
ni y ur e t n he
Lync
hbur Di s on,t pl ntf c e t tCha l tes le nonet e s pos es e a s r ng
g vi i he ai i f ont nds ha
r o t vil
hel s
s s s to

i er s i t r s u i n oft sc e:
nt e t n he e ol to
hi as
Thi c e w ilhe p de i t lm is as t t ac e abl a oun of f c t t a
s as l l fne he i t
o he c pt e m
t
or e ha
l w e or m e of i e m a us on a c tz
a nf ce nt fc r y e
ii en. TA SERS a e r a l de oye
r egul r y pl d
a i t Charote vil a A l m a l Count c tz ns Shoul Pl i if be
ga ns
l t s le nd be re
y ii e .
d a ntf
s c s ul t n t l w s t wil ca e l l l w e or e e of i e s t r f ai
uc es f he he a ui l us oca a nf c m nt f c r o e r n
fom t i ppr i t us of TA SERS a w ilt pr e tt r i n s oft s
r
he na opra e e
nd l hus ot c he es de t
hi

ae fo u n c sayij r .
ra r m n e e s r nu y
( ke No.1 a 11)Eveni t sf t weg mor he viyi fvoroft dee nt wihi
Doc t
4t .
f hi acor ihs e a l n a
he fnda s t n
t c e toft sj 1 4()a yss t be ofas iayfco ,a sae a
he ontx hi 40 a nal i,he nt
oltr a tr s ttd bove,doe not
s
ne e s iy di t t a c r a n out om e o t s m oton t t a f rvenue.
c s arl c a e e t i
c
n hi
i o r ns e
Bal
ance off ors
act

Thec tdeemi st tbas ont pr e ngexa nai oft r e tfcos aj
our tr ne ha, ed he ec di
mi ton he elvan a tr,
1 4()a lssa s si fvorofrti ngve i t Cha l ts leDi so The
40 a nay i dvie n a
eani nue n he rotevil viin.
pl i if sa i a i tTas r l e na i l w hi h i nothea ua t e i Vi g ni i one f
a ntf ' cton ga ns
e nt r tona , c s
dq rer d n r i a, s
or
pr
oduc sla lt a a s h,i m a t r ltl w he e t a ton i br
t i biiy nd, s uc t te s ite
r he c i s ought He ,i co i r ng
. nce n nsde i

t de e nt 'moton t tanse ve ,t c tobs r est tt sa ton ditlsi t one
he f nda s
i o r fr nue he our e v ha hi c i
sil n o
be wee a w i
t n
dow a t de y w ho a l ge y s he hus nd w ih a Tas r l s h
nd he put
le dl hot r ba
t
e . n uc
cic s a e ,a f t r as de aie a ve t ba a e ofe te w e ghs i f vo of
r um t nc s nd or he e ons t l d bo , he l nc
quii s i n a r
alow i t pl i ift c
l ng he a ntf o hoos he own f r . l ed, he c t us afor de e e e t t
e r
o um nde t our m t f d f r nc o he
pl ntf ' c c ofvenue. The de e nt co e t tt pl i if s c ce ofve s d be
ai i f s hoi e
f nda s nt nd ha he a ntf hoi
nue houl
accor no def ence becaus t ac i w as orgi l fl i s at courtand becauset f t
ded
er
e he ton
i naly ied n t e
he ac s

13

aleg i t com pl ntbe rltl r a i hi t t Cha l t vil D i s on. How e r t
l ed n he
ai
a ite el tons p o he
rotes le vi i
ve , he

defnda t dir ga d t f c t tapl i ifsc c ofve ge r l co m a dee e e,
e n s s e r he a t ha
antf hoie
nue ne aly m nds fr nc
D oe 796 F.Supp. t221 a f t r or de a e n m or def r nce w he t s ti fl d
,
a
, nd, urhe m e, m nds ve
e ee
n he ui s ie

i t pl ntf shomef um.Se Ro ki m Prc tl ,2011W L 55 2, t* (çA)
n he ai if
or
e c ngha e as.nc.
2609 a 3 :g
pl i if sc c ofis hom e f um i gi n m or w e g t n ischoi ofa f ei f um .
a ntf hoi e t
or s ve
e i ht ha t
ce
or gn or '
'

(n en l u tto makso te )( u tn GTE W iee s I . . lo
itr a q o ai n r mi d q oig
t
rls.nc v Ouac mm.n .71F. p
Ic,
Su p.
2:51 51 ( D.Va.1 );Al r .l v.Pur PhamaL. ,634F.Supp. 626,633
1 7, 9 E.
999)) phama nc.
due r
P.
2d
( . Va 2009)(ttngt tadee ntmus s ovewhemi i
W D. .
sai ha fnda
t how r l ng nconve e et prvalon
ninc o e i
amoi t ta frve whent pli ifi tae t s ti hi homef m) Furhe mo e
ton o rnse nue
he antf niitd he ui n s
onl . t r r ,
t c tnot t tt de enda s s ils de t bur n i o s
he our es ha he f
nt t l houl r he de ç how t tShe ba a e o eq tes
t
ha t
l nc f uii

i i t erfv r(nd t a j d ca e o o a dc n e e c t a1 a t sfvo s i i a ohe
s n h i a o a q h t u iil c n my n o v nin e o l p ri a r ut n n t r
e
f um.' Doe, F.
or ''
796 Supp. t221(uoi El i e, F.Supp.a 68 .Ast f eg ng
a
q tng drdc 620
t 4)
he or oi
a l i de
nayss monsr t s t de e nt ha f ie t s tsy t sbur n- t y ha f ie t
ta e , he f nda s ve al d o aif hi de he ve a ld o

s o t th b ln eo e ute tlsi terfv ra dt a j dca e o o a dc n e in et
h w ha te aa c f q iis i n h i a o n h t u iil c n my n o v n e c o
t
a lpa te f vors ti t Ly hbur D i s on,a o
1 ri s a
ui n he nc
g vi i s ppos d t t Cha l t s le D i s on.
e o he
r ote vil vi i
11
1.

Concl on
usi

Fort r a ons de a l d a
he e s
t ie bove, he c t ilg a tt pl i if sm o i f l ve t fl
t our w l r n he a ntf
ton or ea o ie
a s r edi s c n e d c pl i . A c di y, he c twildi m i sasm ootbot t
upe s ng e ond m nde om a nt cor ngl t our l s s
h he
pl i t f s o i na m oton f l a t fl a s ond a e d com pl i and Appom a t
a n if r gi l i or e ve o ie ec
m nde
a nt
tox

Cot y' Rul 1 b)5)a ( ()moi Furhe e,hec t l de t defnda s
mt s e 2( ( nd b)6 ton. t nnor t our wil ny he e nt'

14

m otonst t a f rve
i o r ns e nue.
The Cl r i die t d t s nd c ri i d co e oft sm e o andum opi on a t
e k s r c e o e e tfe pi s hi m r
ni nd he
ac om pa ng or rt a 1c
c
nyi
de o 1 ouns lofr or
e
ec d.

ENTER:Thi 1
s $

d yo Mac , 01
a f rh 2 2.

Chi Unie St t DititJ ge
ef t d aes src ud

15